DOCSLIB.ORG

The History of the Fourth Dimension: a Way of Engaging Pupils in Secondary Classrooms Snezana Lawrence

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The History of the Fourth Dimension: a Way of Engaging Pupils in Secondary Classrooms Snezana Lawrence The history of the fourth dimension: A way of engaging pupils in secondary classrooms Snezana Lawrence To cite this version: Snezana Lawrence. The history of the fourth dimension: A way of engaging pupils in secondary classrooms. CERME 9 - Ninth Congress of the European Society for Research in Mathematics Educa- tion, Charles University in Prague, Faculty of Education; ERME, Feb 2015, Prague, Czech Republic. pp.1846-1852. hal-01288395 HAL Id: hal-01288395 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01288395 Submitted on 15 Mar 2016 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. The history of the fourth dimension: A way of engaging pupils in secondary classrooms Snezana Lawrence Bath Spa University, Faculty of Education, Bath, UK, [email protected] The National Curriculum in England has, over basis of the problem.3 The organizations such as the past decade, been revised a multitude of times. National Strategies (discontinued 2010) previously Disengagement of pupils was one of the reasons for revi- tried to help teachers devise teaching episodes and sions. In September of 2014, a new curriculum in math- gave suggestions on pedagogy. The new curriculum ematics was introduced, aiming to give greater freedom instead offers an element of autonomy, meaning that to teachers and schools to construct a curriculum and schools and teachers are given freedom to choose and teaching episodes that are engaging and appropriate design the topics and teaching episodes appropriate for their students. This paper investigates how such ep- to their environments. Likewise, the curriculum it- isodes can be constructed through the investigations self lists the skills and knowledge to develop in pupils, based on historical development of mathematical con- but gives no (or minimal) guidance as to the choice cepts and how they could easily link to the new curricu- of topics. lum, offering at the same time greater opportunities for pupils’ engagement. The history of the fourth dimension The choice of topic described in this paper – the his- is one such possible topic, and the paper suggests a way tory of the fourth dimension – arose from two expe- of using it in a secondary classroom. riences: of working with gifted and talented pupils some years ago on the representations of the fourth Keywords: Fourth dimension, engagement, Schläfli, dimension in mathematics (Lawrence, 2012) and the Stringham, Flatland. engagement reported in alternative curricula, such as, for example, Steiner system, which introduces projective geometry and the study of the fourth di- INTRODUCTION mension in the final years of secondary school (Woods et al., 2013). In the decade between 2004 and 2014, mathematics curriculum changed twice, about fifty reports on The paper thus first gives a historical overview of the mathematics education in the country have been topic, and then investigates the possible pedagogi- published, and seven different Secretaries of State cal approaches to develop material based on certain for Education passed through the British Parliament. principles listed. It concludes by showing how an Each of the changes and reports suggested that the unorthodox topic such as this, can nevertheless be state of mathematics education in Britain is trouble- easily linked to the new curriculum and the skills and some; the causes were identified, the evidence was giv- knowledge it aims to develop in pupils. The engage- en (in either a narrative or analytical format), and of ment is expected but not yet empirically proven; this course the suggestions to improve the situation were is proposed as a possible future study, and some ini- recommended.1 The most troublesome of all troubles tial experiments from schools in which the teaching listed was the perceived irrelevance of mathematics pedagogy is trialed are described. and the lack of desire to engage with it.2 HISTORY OF THE FOURTH DIMENSION When exploring the issue of disengagement, teach- ers reported that it was the curriculum that narrows Whilst the concept of the fourth dimension was de- down the topics and the lack of choice to engage with veloped in the nineteenth century, the origins of it different topics from the curriculum that was at the could be traced as far back as the antiquity in the CERME9 (2015) – TWG12 1846 The history of the fourth dimension: A way of engaging pupils in secondary classrooms (Snezana Lawrence) most possibly wide sense of conceptual development. Friedrich, 1834–1882) further simplified this. If one Aristotle for example, discussed it in De Caelo,4 and has a circle and a point outside of it, how can one get Ptolemy denied and disproved it but nevertheless the point into the circle without cutting or crossing mentioned and contemplated upon it (Cajori, 1926, over the circumference? p. 397; Heiberg, 1893, p. 7a, 33). John Wallis, although writing this whilst considering geometric interpre- In 1852, Ludwig Schläfli (1814–1895), a Swiss math- tations of quantities he was developing in the context ematician published a book Theorie der vielfachen of algebra, wrote (Wallis 1685, p. 126): Kontinuität, (Theory of Continuous Manifolds), in which he wrote about the four dimensions. Schläfli A Line drawn into a Line shall make a Plane or looked at Elementa doctrinae solidorum published in Surface; this drawn into a Line, shall make a Solid: 1758, in which Euler described for the first time what But if this Solid be drawn into a Line, or this Plane was to become known as Euler’s characteristic, the into a Plane, what shall it make? A Plano-Plane? expression which conveys the information that in all That is a Monster in Nature, and less possible convex solid bodies the sum of the solid angles and the than a Chimaera or Centaure. For Length, Breadth number of faces is equal to the number of edges add 2. and Thickness, take up the whole of Space. Nor can our Fansie imagine how there should be a Fourth Local Dimension beyond these Three. With the French Revolution, some revolutionary mathematical thinking happened, and Lagrange in particular, spoke of three coordinates to describe the space of three dimensions, introducing time as the Figure 2: Euler’s characteristic first described in Elementa fourth, and denoting it t (Lagrange, 1797, p. 223). doctrinae solidorum, 119 The reader is reminded that this can by no means be We now usually denote Euler’s characteristic by an exhaustive study, but is a sketch of the history of Greek letter chi and describe it for convex polyhedra the fourth dimension and the narrative given is but χ = V − E + F = 2, where V is the number of vertices, E a thread that will later be examined in possible edu- is the number of edges, and F is the number of faces cational setting and application to teaching. in a polyhedron. If we further analyze the formula we notice that we begin from the first variable which Let us then trace further historical development. The counts points (point we earlier took to represent 0th first such opportunity was the example of Möbius dimension); the second variable which numbers the and Zöllner. Möbius (1827) first spoke about an ob- edges in a solid, (representing line, 1st dimension) and ject getting out of a dimension it belonged to in order the third variable, numbering the faces of a solid, (pol- to perform a spatial operation. If one had a crystal, ygon is bound part of a plane, representing the 2nd structured like a left-handed staircase, how would one dimension). get its three-dimensional reflection? Zöllner (Johann Schläfli (1852) showed that this formula is also valid in four dimensions or indeed any higher dimension. We will get there – but let us first look at how he first defined a system which would describe any regular P polytope in any dimension. There is only one polytope in 1st dimension, a line segment, and the Schläfli symbol denoting this is {}. Regular polygons in two dimensions are, for example, triangle {3}, square {4}, pentagon {5}, etc. Figure 1: Zöllner illustrates that in order to perform certain Remembering that he only used these symbols to de- operations in space, objects must exit their current dimension note regular polytopes, we continue. In three dimen- (Zöllner, 1878) sions the five regular polyhedra, Platonic solids, can 1847 The history of the fourth dimension: A way of engaging pupils in secondary classrooms (Snezana Lawrence) be described as {3, 3} – tetrahedron has three-sided The mathematical description of generating the polygons that meet three at each vertex; {4, 3} – cube fourth (and higher dimensions) was first given in an has four-sided polygons three of which meet at each elegant way by William Stringham (Stringham, 1880, vertex; {3, 4} – octahedron has three-sided polygons p. 1): four of which meet at each vertex; {3, 5} – icosahedron has three-sided polygons five of which meet at each A pencil of lines, diverging from a common ver- vertex; {5, 3} – dodecahedron has five-sided polygons, tex in n-dimensional space, forms the edges of three of which meet at each vertex (Schläfli, 1852). an n-fold (short for n-dimensional) angle. There must be at least n of them, for otherwise they would lie in a space of less than n dimensions. If there be just n of them, combined two and two they form 2-fold face boundaries; three and three, they form 3-fold trihedral boundaries, and so on.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Flatterland: the Play Based on Flatterland: Like Flatland Only More So
    Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont HMC Senior Theses HMC Student Scholarship 2012 Flatterland: The lP ay Kym Louie Harvey Mudd College Recommended Citation Louie, Kym, "Flatterland: The lP ay" (2012). HMC Senior Theses. 27. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/hmc_theses/27 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the HMC Student Scholarship at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in HMC Senior Theses by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Flatterland: The Play based on Flatterland: Like Flatland Only More So by Ian Stewart Kym Louie Arthur Benjamin, Advisor Art Horowitz, Advisor Thomas Leabhart, Reader May, 2012 Department of Mathematics Copyright c 2012 Kym Louie. The author grants Harvey Mudd College and the Claremont Colleges Library the nonexclusive right to make this work available for noncommercial, educational purposes, provided that this copyright statement appears on the reproduced ma- terials and notice is given that the copying is by permission of the author. To dis- seminate otherwise or to republish requires written permission from the author. Abstract This script is an adaptation of the popular science novel Flatterland: Like Flatland, Only More So by Ian Stewart. It breathes new life into mathemat- ical ideas and topics. By bringing math to the stage, this script presents concepts in a more friendly and accessible manner. This play is intended to generate new interest in and expose new topics to an audience of non- mathematicians. Preface I was first introduced to Flatterland by Sue Buckwalter while I was at Phillips Academy.
    [Show full text]
  • Geometry Course Outline
    GEOMETRY COURSE OUTLINE Content Area Formative Assessment # of Lessons Days G0 INTRO AND CONSTRUCTION 12 G-CO Congruence 12, 13 G1 BASIC DEFINITIONS AND RIGID MOTION Representing and 20 G-CO Congruence 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 Combining Transformations Analyzing Congruency Proofs G2 GEOMETRIC RELATIONSHIPS AND PROPERTIES Evaluating Statements 15 G-CO Congruence 9, 10, 11 About Length and Area G-C Circles 3 Inscribing and Circumscribing Right Triangles G3 SIMILARITY Geometry Problems: 20 G-SRT Similarity, Right Triangles, and Trigonometry 1, 2, 3, Circles and Triangles 4, 5 Proofs of the Pythagorean Theorem M1 GEOMETRIC MODELING 1 Solving Geometry 7 G-MG Modeling with Geometry 1, 2, 3 Problems: Floodlights G4 COORDINATE GEOMETRY Finding Equations of 15 G-GPE Expressing Geometric Properties with Equations 4, 5, Parallel and 6, 7 Perpendicular Lines G5 CIRCLES AND CONICS Equations of Circles 1 15 G-C Circles 1, 2, 5 Equations of Circles 2 G-GPE Expressing Geometric Properties with Equations 1, 2 Sectors of Circles G6 GEOMETRIC MEASUREMENTS AND DIMENSIONS Evaluating Statements 15 G-GMD 1, 3, 4 About Enlargements (2D & 3D) 2D Representations of 3D Objects G7 TRIONOMETRIC RATIOS Calculating Volumes of 15 G-SRT Similarity, Right Triangles, and Trigonometry 6, 7, 8 Compound Objects M2 GEOMETRIC MODELING 2 Modeling: Rolling Cups 10 G-MG Modeling with Geometry 1, 2, 3 TOTAL: 144 HIGH SCHOOL OVERVIEW Algebra 1 Geometry Algebra 2 A0 Introduction G0 Introduction and A0 Introduction Construction A1 Modeling With Functions G1 Basic Definitions and Rigid
    [Show full text]
  • Dimension Guide
    UNDERCOUNTER REFRIGERATOR Solid door KURR114KSB, KURL114KSB, KURR114KPA, KURL114KPA Glass door KURR314KSS, KURL314KSS, KURR314KBS, KURL314KBS, KURR214KSB Detailed Planning Dimensions Guide Product Dimensions 237/8” Depth (60.72 cm) (no handle) * Add 5/8” (1.6 cm) to the height dimension when leveling legs are fully extended. ** For custom panel models, this will vary. † Add 1/4” (6.4 mm) to the height dimension 343/8” (87.32 cm)*† for height with hinge covers. 305/8” (77.75 cm)** 39/16” (9 cm)* Variant Depth (no handle) Panel ready models 2313/16” (60.7 cm) (with 3/4” panel) Stainless and 235/8” (60.2 cm) black stainless Because Whirlpool Corporation policy includes a continuous commitment to improve our products, we reserve the right to change materials and specifications without notice. Dimensions are for planning purposes only. For complete details, see Installation Instructions packed with product. Specifications subject to change without notice. W11530525 1 Panel ready models Stainless and black Dimension Description (with 3/4” panel) stainless models A Width of door 233/4” (60.3 cm) 233/4” (60.3 cm) B Width of the grille 2313/16” (60.5 cm) 2313/16” (60.5 cm) C Height to top of handle ** 311/8” (78.85 cm) Width from side of refrigerator to 1 D handle – door open 90° ** 2 /3” (5.95 cm) E Depth without door 2111/16” (55.1 cm) 2111/16” (55.1 cm) F Depth with door 2313/16” (60.7 cm) 235/8” (60.2 cm) 7 G Depth with handle ** 26 /16” (67.15 cm) H Depth with door open 90° 4715/16” (121.8 cm) 4715/16” (121.8 cm) **For custom panel models, this will vary.
    [Show full text]
  • Spectral Dimensions and Dimension Spectra of Quantum Spacetimes
    PHYSICAL REVIEW D 102, 086003 (2020) Spectral dimensions and dimension spectra of quantum spacetimes † Michał Eckstein 1,2,* and Tomasz Trześniewski 3,2, 1Institute of Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics, National Quantum Information Centre, Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, University of Gdańsk, ulica Wita Stwosza 57, 80-308 Gdańsk, Poland 2Copernicus Center for Interdisciplinary Studies, ulica Szczepańska 1/5, 31-011 Kraków, Poland 3Institute of Theoretical Physics, Jagiellonian University, ulica S. Łojasiewicza 11, 30-348 Kraków, Poland (Received 11 June 2020; accepted 3 September 2020; published 5 October 2020) Different approaches to quantum gravity generally predict that the dimension of spacetime at the fundamental level is not 4. The principal tool to measure how the dimension changes between the IR and UV scales of the theory is the spectral dimension. On the other hand, the noncommutative-geometric perspective suggests that quantum spacetimes ought to be characterized by a discrete complex set—the dimension spectrum. We show that these two notions complement each other and the dimension spectrum is very useful in unraveling the UV behavior of the spectral dimension. We perform an extended analysis highlighting the trouble spots and illustrate the general results with two concrete examples: the quantum sphere and the κ-Minkowski spacetime, for a few different Laplacians. In particular, we find that the spectral dimensions of the former exhibit log-periodic oscillations, the amplitude of which decays rapidly as the deformation parameter tends to the classical value. In contrast, no such oscillations occur for either of the three considered Laplacians on the κ-Minkowski spacetime. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevD.102.086003 I.
    [Show full text]
  • ___Booknotes for Flatland Authorial Background: Edwin
    ____________ Booknotes for Flatland Authorial Background: Edwin Abbott Abbott was born in 1838, in a time when the nineteenth-century middle class had begun to rise up from social oppression in Britain. A highly distinguished head schoolmaster, English clergyman, and Shakespearean scholar, he was more interested in the fields of theology and classic literature than in mathematics. Because he sought to express concern over the social problems of the period, he recognized his motivation for writing Flatland; the book was published in 1884 under the pseudonym A. Square to protect himself from attack by those he satirizes in the book. However, although he held his interests in theology and classic literature, his presentation of geometrical concepts earned him acclaim for his intricate barbed satire of the hierarchical Victorian age. For eighty-eight years he lived; in 1926 he died, renowned and remembered for his treatise on mathematical fiction and the power of knowledge. Literary Period/Country: Victorian Period, Great Britain. Setting: The social context of the satire was during the 1800s, when socioeconomic and political changes began to create a flux of new ideas, rebellion, and tense order. The satire takes place in the two-dimensional space Flatland, where lines and shapes move “freely about, on or in the surface” (1). A hierarchical dominion exists in Flatland: Circles are priests, figures having the greater number of sides comprising the higher class, isosceles and irregular triangles are shunned from society, and women--only pinlike lines--are considered the lowliest class of all. This hierarchy emulates exactly the social order of Britain at the time.
    [Show full text]
  • Zero-Dimensional Symmetry
    Snapshots of modern mathematics № 3/2015 from Oberwolfach Zero-dimensional symmetry George Willis This snapshot is about zero-dimensional symmetry. Thanks to recent discoveries we now understand such symmetry better than previously imagined possible. While still far from complete, a picture of zero-dimen- sional symmetry is beginning to emerge. 1 An introduction to symmetry: spinning globes and infinite wallpapers Let’s begin with an example. Think of a sphere, for example a globe’s surface. Every point on it is specified by two parameters, longitude and latitude. This makes the sphere a two-dimensional surface. You can rotate the globe along an axis through the center; the object you obtain after the rotation still looks like the original globe (although now maybe New York is where the Mount Everest used to be), meaning that the sphere has rotational symmetry. Each rotation is prescribed by the latitude and longitude where the axis cuts the southern hemisphere, and by an angle through which it rotates the sphere. 1 These three parameters specify all rotations of the sphere, which thus has three-dimensional rotational symmetry. In general, a symmetry may be viewed as being a transformation (such as a rotation) that leaves an object looking unchanged. When one transformation is followed by a second, the result is a third transformation that is called the product of the other two. The collection of symmetries and their product 1 Note that we include the rotation through the angle 0, that is, the case where the globe actually does not rotate at all. 1 operation forms an algebraic structure called a group 2 .
    [Show full text]
  • In Between Psychology Table Topic for Scientific Investigation, and the Re-Discovery of the Role of Unconscious P.N
    _NA_ru__ ~_v_o_L_n __ ~_~ __ R,_L_•~-----------------------S~NGBQQKS·--------------------------------------- 7~ related, revolutions in American psycho­ logy: the recovery of the mind as a respec­ In between psychology table topic for scientific investigation, and the re-discovery of the role of unconscious P.N. Johnson-Laird mental processes. Bruner began by setting a new fashion in In Search of Mind: Essays in Autobiography. By Jerome Bruner. the study of perception, the so-called Harper & Row: 1984. Pp.306. $19.25, £14. "New Look". He and his colleagues carried out a series of experiments showing THE imaginary line that divides the two less trust in the testimony of his father. that people's desires, attitudes and expec­ cultures runs through the middle of Bruner with hindsight also offers a tations can affect the way they see the psychology. On one side lies a science that Freudian interpretation of his experiment, world. For example, children over­ aims to explain the mechanisms underlying though it may be significant that he later estimate the size of coins, and children behaviour and the mind. Its practitioners ran into trouble at college for refusing to from poor homes make a greater error than propose explicit theories, often modelled in attend compulsory chapel. those from affluent ones. Other studies the form of computer programs or axiom­ Few people of Bruner's generation showed that an emotionally charged word atized within a formal calculus, sometimes takes very much and attempt to test them in longer to recognize than a more controlled experiments on neutral word - as though the human beings or animals.
    [Show full text]
  • A Non-Linear Take on the Flatland and Sphereland Films
    MEDIA COLUMN Over-Sphere in the fourth dimension is voiced by Kate Mulgrew, who played Captain Janeway on Star Trek: Voyager, In addition to longer reviews for the Media Column, we invite and the minor character Captain Aero is voiced by Danica you to watch for and submit short snippets of instances of women McKellar, who studied mathematics at UCLA and is a force in mathematics in the media (WIMM Watch). Please submit to for encouraging girls to like and do math. In this day and the Media Column Editors: Sarah J. Greenwald, Appalachian age of excessive narcissism, I especially appreciated Tony State University, [email protected] and Alice Silverberg, Hale’s rendition of the King of Pointland; in a bonus inter- University of California, Irvine, [email protected]. view, Hale refers to this character as “just a sad emasculated point.” It’s great that such prominent celebrities were A Non-Linear Take on the enthusiastic about giving their all for some short animated educational math films. Flatland and Sphereland Class stratification was a major theme of Flatland. Films York reminds us in an actor interview that Abbott anticipated a number of political and sociological trends. Circles were Alice Silverberg superior. As stated in the Flatland film, “The more sides you have, the greater your angles, so the smarter you are.” Irregular I enjoyed the delightful 35 minute animated film polygons were viewed as monsters who could be “cured” by versions of the classic Flatland and its lesser known quasi- surgery, or executed. sequel Sphereland. They were released directly to DVD in Abbott’s Flatland society was blatantly sexist, though 2007 and 2012, respectively.
    [Show full text]
  • Contemporary Reviews of Flatland We Have Made a Few Very Minor
    æ Contemporary reviews of Flatland We have made a few very minor editorial changes in these reviews including making (mathematical) word usage current and correcting obvious typos and misspellings. The footnotes are from the original articles; the endnotes contain our commentary. 1. The Academy (November 8, 1884), p. 302. 2. The Athenaeum No. 2977 (November 15, 1884), p. 622. 3. The Athenaeum No. 2978 (November 22, 1884), p. 660. (Abbott unmasked.) 4. The Athenaeum No. 2980 (December 6, 1884), p. 733. (Abbott’s reply to No. 2977.) 5. Nature (November 27, 1884), pp. 76–77. 6. The Spectator (November 29, 1884), pp. 1583–1584. 7. New York Times (February 23, 1885), p. 3. 8. The Literary News (March 1885), p. 85. 9. The Literary News(April 1885), p. 123. (Abbott identified by name.) 10. Science (February 27, 1885), p. 184. 11. Science (April 3, 1885), pp. 265–266. 12. The Literary World (March 21, 1885), p. 93. 13. Lippincott’s Magazine (May 1885), p. 528. 14. City of London School Magazine 8(December 1885), 217–221. 15. Nature(February 12, 1920), p. 629. (Excerpt of Garnett’s letter.) 16. Saturday Review of Literature (October 30, 1926), p. 254. 17. Reviews we’d like to have. 1. The Academy (November 8, 1884), p. 302. Flatland is a world inhabited by beings whose experience of space is limited to two dimensions. In this book a native of this strange region has undertaken to describe its peculiarities to us dwellers in ‘Spaceland.’ It seems the male Flatlanders are plane rectilineal figures, varying in shape according to their position in the social scale, or, what in Flatland is the same thing, to their degree of intellectual development; the lowest class being isosceles triangles, and the highest class, or priesthood, being polygons which have so many sides that they are accounted circles.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating a Revolve
    Always begin your creo session by selecting your working directory If you select working directory at the beginning, that folder will be the default location when you try to open files, as well as when you save files. It makes everything a lot easier if you select your working directory first. For help opening/saving/downloading files see basics, for help creating an extrude see basic solids. Creating a Revolve Open a new part file, name it something unique. Choose a plane to sketch on Go to sketch view (if you don’t know where that is see Basic Solids) Move your cursor so the centerline snaps to the horizontal line as shown above You may now begin your sketch I have just sketched a random shape Sketch Tips: ● Your shape MUST be closed ● If you didn’t put a centerline in, you will get radial instead of diameter dimensions (in general this is bad) ● Remember this is being revolved so you are only sketching the profile on one side of the center line. If you need to put in diameter dimensions: Click normal, click the line or point you want the dimension for, click the centerline, and click the same line/point that you clicked the first time AGAIN, and then middle mouse button where you want the dimension to be placed. After your sketch is done, click the checkmark to get out of sketch, then click the checkmark again to complete the revolve The part in the sketch will look like this: .
    [Show full text]
  • FLATLAND: a Romance of Many Dimensions - E
    FLATLAND: A Romance of Many Dimensions - E. Abbott Published in 1884 FLATLAND: A Romance of Many Dimensions Edwin A. Abbott Table of Contents Preface to the Second and Revised Edition, 1884. By the editor PART 1: THIS WORLD Of the Nature of Flatland Of the Climate and Houses in Flatland Concerning the Inhabitants of Flatland Concerning the Women Of our Methods in Recognizing one another Of Recognition by Sight Concerning Irregular Figures Of the Ancient Practice of Painting Of the Universal Colour Bill Of the Suppression of Chromatic Sedition Concerning our Priests Of the Doctrine of our Priests PART 2: OTHER WORLDS How I had a Vision of Lineland How I vainly tried to explain the nature of Flatland Concerning a Stranger from Spaceland How the Stranger vainly endeavoured to reveal to me in words the mysteries of Spaceland How the Sphere, having in vain tried words, resorted to deeds file:///E|/moe/HTML/Abbott/Abbott_contents.html (1 of 2) [10/27/2003 5:15:19 PM] FLATLAND: A Romance of Many Dimensions - E. Abbott How I came to Spaceland, and what I saw there How, though the Sphere shewed me other mysteries of Spaceland, I still desired more; and what came of it How the Sphere encouraged me in a Vision How I tried to teach the Theory of Three Dimensions to my Grandson, and with what success How I then tried to diffuse the Theory of Three Dimensions by other means, and of the result file:///E|/moe/HTML/Abbott/Abbott_contents.html (2 of 2) [10/27/2003 5:15:19 PM] FLATLAND: A Romance of Many Dimensions - E.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Observable Space Is Three Dimensional
    Adv. Studies Theor. Phys., Vol. 8, 2014, no. 17, 689 – 700 HIKARI Ltd, www.m-hikari.com http://dx.doi.org/10.12988/astp.2014.4675 Why Observable Space Is Solely Three Dimensional Mario Rabinowitz Armor Research, 715 Lakemead Way Redwood City, CA 94062-3922, USA Copyright © 2014 Mario Rabinowitz. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Abstract Quantum (and classical) binding energy considerations in n-dimensional space indicate that atoms (and planets) can only exist in three-dimensional space. This is why observable space is solely 3-dimensional. Both a novel Virial theorem analysis, and detailed classical and quantum energy calculations for 3-space circular and elliptical orbits indicate that they have no orbital binding energy in greater than 3-space. The same energy equation also excludes the possibility of atom-like bodies in strictly 1 and 2-dimensions. A prediction is made that in the search for deviations from r2 of the gravitational force at sub-millimeter distances such a deviation must occur at < ~ 1010m (or < ~1012 m considering muoniom), since atoms would disintegrate if the curled up dimensions of string theory were larger than this. Callender asserts that the often-repeated claim in previous work that stable orbits are possible in only three dimensions is not even remotely established. The binding energy analysis herein avoids the pitfalls that Callender points out, as it circumvents stability issues. An uncanny quantum surprise is present in very high dimensions.
    [Show full text]