Can Ecosystem-Based Deep-Sea Fishing Be Sustained? Les Watling University of Hawaii at Manoa, [email protected]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The University of Maine DigitalCommons@UMaine Marine Sciences Faculty Scholarship School of Marine Sciences 2011 Can ecosystem-based deep-sea fishing be sustained? Les Watling University of Hawaii at Manoa, [email protected] R L. Haedrich Memorial University of Newfoundland J Devine Institute of Marine Research, Bergen, Norway J Drazen University of Hawaii at Manoa M R. Dunn National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research, Wellington, New Zealand See next page for additional authors Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/sms_facpub Part of the Marine Biology Commons Repository Citation Watling, L., Haedrich, R.L., Devine, J., Drazen, J., Dunn, M.R., Gianni, M., Baker, K., Cailliet, G., Figueiredo, I., Kyne, P.M., Menezes, G., Neat, F., Orlov, A., Duran, P., Perez, J.A., Ardron, J.A., Bezaury, J., Revenga, C., and Nouvian, C. 2011. Can ecosystem-based deep- sea fishing be sustained? Report of a workshop held 31 August-3 September 2010. Walpole, ME: University of Maine, Darling Marine Center. Darling Marine Center Special Publication 11-1. 84p This Conference Proceeding is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UMaine. It has been accepted for inclusion in Marine Sciences Faculty Scholarship by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@UMaine. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Authors Les Watling, R L. Haedrich, J Devine, J Drazen, M R. Dunn, M Gianni, K Baker, G Cailliet, I Figueiredo, P M. Kyne, G Menezes, F Neat, A Orlov, P Duran, J A. Perez, J A. Ardon, J Bezaury, C Revenga, and C Nouvian This conference proceeding is available at DigitalCommons@UMaine: https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/sms_facpub/145 CanCan Ecosystem-Based Deep-SeaDeep-Sea Fishing BeBe Sustained?Sustained? ReportReport ofof aa WorkshopWorkshop heldHeld 3131 August-3August-3 SeptemberSeptember 2010 Neuville-Bosc, France Grenadier (Nezumia sp.) Executive Summary Authors Contents Can Ecosystem-Based Deep-Sea Fishing Be Sustained? Watling, L.1 Executive Summary International scientific workshop fishery- are imprecise because they are based on information Haedrich, R.L.2 Can Ecosystem-Based Deep-Sea Fishing Be Sustained? 1 Held 31 August - 3 September 2010 that is not necessarily available, while others such as whether Devine, J.3 a management plan is currently in place, does not account Drazen, J.1 Key Findings 2 Can there ever be a truly sustainable deep-sea fishery and if for the history of the fishery. As a result, some deep-sea Dunn, M.R.4 so, where and under what conditions? Ecosystembased species such as black scabbardfish and roundnose grenadiers Gianni, M.5 Can ecosystem-based deep-sea fishing be sustained? fisheries management requires that this question be were rated as not very susceptible to overfishing even Baker, K.2 Report of a Workshop held 31 August - 3 Sept. 2010, addressed such that habitat, bycatch species, and targeted though their populations over the past decade have severely Cailliet, G.6 Neuville-Bosc, France 5 fish populations are considered together within an ecosystem declined. These results create a misleading impression of the Figueiredo, I.7 context. vulnerability of deep-sea species in some cases. Kyne, P.M.8 Objectives 6 9 Menezes, G. Background Papers 6 To this end, we convened the first workshop to develop an The PSA vulnerability plot is essentially a risk analysis, but Neat, F.10 ecosystem approach to deep-sea fisheries and to ask whether it does not address the question of sustainability directly. Orlov, A.11 Fishery Case Studies 7 deep-sea species could be fished sustainably. The workshop However, with further refinement of the susceptibility criteria, Duran, P.12 participants were able to integrate bycatch information into and with the addition of habitat criteria, it could be used to Perez, J. A.13 Considerations on the Use of Models 12 their framework but found it more difficult to integrate other identify particularly vulnerable species within an ecosystem 14 Ardron, J.A. Reports on Deep-Sea Fisheries 13 ecosystem indicators such as habitat characteristics. context and suggest possible management strategies. Bezaury, J.15 16 Revenga, C. What is a Deep-Sea Fish? For this workshop, “deep-sea” was acknowledged to include Long-term and broadly based scientific study of the deep-sea 17 Nouvian, C. A Phylogenetic and Life History Approach 13 ocean depths greater than 200 m, but the fish species of presents a picture of a realm where life proceeds at a slow concern were those with adult distributions at depths greater pace. Species are slow growing, long-lived, late to mature Sustainability of deep-sea fisheries: Orange Roughy 24 than 400 m. It was understood that the juveniles of some and of low fecundity, but diversity is very high, especially at species might occur in the shallower waters off the edge of upper bathyal depths (200 – 2000 m). Since all deep-sea Orange roughy fisheries in the Northeast Atlantic 26 the continental shelf. Also, the concept that all deep-sea fish fisheries also occur at these depths, the characteristics of the Applying a basic productivity-susceptibility are alike was considered and rejected. In fact, a deep-sea deep-sea fauna have led scientists, governments and NGOs 1 University of Hawaii at Minoa, analysis to a complex deepwater mixed fish could be one that has a long evolutionary history in the to become concerned about the sustainability of deepsea Honolulu, Hawaii, USA/University deep-sea or one that evolved recently from a shelf-dwelling fisheries and their impact on biodiversity and habitat. of Maine, Darling Marine Center, trawl fishery in the Northeast Atlantic 35 ancestor. A small group of workshop participants evaluated Governments have been responding to this growing concern, Walpole, Maine, USA Sustainable Deep-Sea Fisheries for Grenadiers 52 the biological characteristics of a large number of deep-sea and in 2002 the United Nations General Assembly entered 2 Memorial University of species and found that their depth of occurrence correlated a process of negotiation that culminated in the adoption of Newfoundland, Canada Productivity – Susceptibility Analysis of most strongly with their life history parameters. UNGA resolutions 61/105 in 2006 and additional provisions 3 Institute of Marine Research, Deep-Sea Fish Species in a Global Context 64 in 64/72 in 2009 to ensure the long-term sustainability of Bergen, Norway In order to evaluate the potential of deep-sea fisheries for deep-sea fish populations and the preservation of vulnerable 4 National Institute of Water and Deep-water fishing in tropical latitudes: ecosystem-based sustainability, it was originally thought that marine ecosystems. Recognizing that deep-sea fish species Atmospheric Research, the Brazilian experience 67 the relatively simple Lotka-Volterra class of models could be are vulnerable to overexploitation, and that particular Wellington, New Zealand applied, but we soon realized that deep-sea fisheries suffered fisheries result in habitat damage, the European Commission 5 Amsterdam, The Netherlands Habitat Impact of Deep-Sea Fisheries 69 critical data limitations (i.e. needed information such as has also set fishing quotas which have been regularly reduced 6 Moss Landing Marine Laboratories, Summary and Conclusions 74 life history characteristics, bycatch, or discard rates did not since 2003, and imposed some area closures within which Moss Landing, California, USA exist) that made the use of quantitative models difficult. An no bottom tending gear can be used. However, deep-sea 7 IPIMAR, Lisbon, Portugal Literature cited 78 alternative approach, one that allowed the combination of fisheries are still harvested outside safe biological limits and 8 Charles Darwin University, Darwin, both fish life history data and ecosystem criteria, was to apply cannot be said to be conducted sustainably. Northern Territory, Australia Acknowledgements 84 a semi-quantitative model (the Productivity – Susceptibility 9 University of the Azores, Analysis, PSA) to species routinely caught in deep-sea States have an obligation to ensure the long-term Horta, Portugal fisheries. This model subjectively scores species on a scale sustainability of targeted fish stocks as well as bycatch 10 Marine Scotland – Science, of 1-3 in terms of their potential productivity (derived from species, prevent significant adverse impacts on deep-sea Aberdeen, United Kingdom life history data) and susceptibility to overfishing (based ecosystems through the conduct of environmental impact 11 VNIRO, Moscow, Russia on species distribution and behavior, and management assessments prior to fishing, and close areas to bottom 12 Spanish Institute of Oceanography, practices). The model output is a plot displaying the fishing where vulnerable ecosystems occur. Vigo, Spain vulnerability of each species relative to the others analyzed. 13 Centro de Ciencias Tecnologicas da This workshop examined three deep-sea fisheries using the Terra e do Mar, Brazil In the short time of the workshop, we were unable to fully semi-quantitative PSA model and considered environmental 14 Marine Conservation Biology Institute, evaluate all the criteria used in the PSA model by Patrick et al. consequences of using trawl vs. long-line gear in some. Washington, DC, USA (2010), but the workshop participants were able to agree on Following the workshop, further analysis and writing 15 The Nature Conservancy, a list of objective productivity criteria (maximum size and age, proceeded for two months, during which general patterns Mexico City, Mexico estimated natural mortality, measured fecundity, breeding and rules came to light, enabling us to draw what we have 16 The Nature Conservancy, strategy, age at maturity, and mean trophic level). On the named “lessons” that should be understood by managers Arlington, VA, other hand, identifying criteria that reflected the susceptibility as golden rules whose implementation is essential to ensure 17 Association Bloom, Paris, France of species to overfishing was more problematical. Some of long-term ecosystem-based sustainability of deep-sea these criteria -for example area and vertical overlap with the fisheries.