The Evolving Law Firm Office Market: Key Trends in 10 Major U.S

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Evolving Law Firm Office Market: Key Trends in 10 Major U.S THOUGHT LEADERSHIP SERIES THE EVOLVING LAW FIRM OFFICE MARKET: KEY TRENDS IN 10 MAJOR U.S. CITIES NOVEMBER 2019 KEY FINDINGS » As space efficiency has become a primary real estate strategy for most major law firms, the amount of square TABLE OF CONTENTS feet leased per attorney has generally decreased over the past 10–15 years across the ten markets studied. I. Recent Trends in the U.S. Law 04 However, factors such as fluctuating attorney counts, Firm Office Market subleasing of space, and variances in space design » Feature: Trends in Law Firm versus space utilization make it difficult to draw direct Workplace Strategy 06 conclusions from the amount of leased space per attorney. In short, the intent behind how law firms lease II. Key Law Firm Real Estate and use office space does not always match the reality Trends for 10 Major U.S. Cities of how much space they occupy. Nonetheless, these figures have generally trended downward even as many a. Atlanta 08 firms have dedicated more space to shared amenity b. Boston 10 and meeting areas. » Legal services employment in the 10 markets studied c. Chicago 12 has remained relatively flat over the past five years, d. Dallas 14 averaging only 0.5% annual growth. However, this was a considerable change from the layoffs many firms e. Los Angeles 16 endured during and after the Great Recession. Sluggish growth in legal services employment is expected to f. Miami 18 continue with forecasted annual growth for these markets averaging only 0.2% over the next five years. g. New York 20 Recruitment and retention is a priority. h. Philadelphia 22 » Rental rates for law firm leases have increased over the past 15 years, with most cities seeing a marked i. San Francisco 24 rise in rents over the past five years; the 10 markets j. Washington 26 studied saw a 21% average increase in law firm rental rates during the 2015–2019 period compared with III. Market Summary and Action Steps 28 the 2010–2014 timeframe. This significant increase is mostly attributed to a flight-to-quality trend among law firms, as the increase in efficiency allowed many firms to upgrade their space while maintaining or reducing overall occupancy costs. 2 | © NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK | RESEARCH | NOVEMBER 2019 THOUGHT LEADERSHIP SERIES | 3 Factors such as fluctuating attorney counts, subleasing of space, and variances in space design versus space utilization make it difficult to draw direct conclusions from the amount of leased space per attorney. In short, the intent behind how law firms lease and use office space does not always match the reality of how much space they occupy. I. RECENT TRENDS IN THE U.S. LAW FIRM OFFICE MARKET Legal Services Employment has a significant impact on the as the size of firms’ operations, the requirements surrounding Whether firms have renegotiated or relocated has a large impact services employment is expected to continue with forecasted commercial real estate market nationwide. As one of the largest confidentiality and branding, and the need for practice groups to on their space utilization. In short, the intent behind how law annual growth for these markets averaging only 0.2% over the office tenant types, trends within the law firm sector have a major work in the same office. firms lease and use office space does not always match the next five years. Law firms are improving the efficiency of how effect on overall office space demand. In the markets with the reality of how much space they occupy. Nonetheless, these they work, as new technology does some of the tasks that junior The markets chosen for this study represent the 10 largest largest concentrations of top-tier law firms, these trends can bring figures have generally trended downward even as many firms attorneys used to handle. national markets by legal services employment. They are about significant change to regional market fundamentals and have dedicated more space to shared amenity and meeting geographically diverse and represent a full spectrum of law Rental rates for law firm leases have increased over the past 15 economic indicators. Since there is regional variance among top areas. For the purposes of this study, square feet leased per specialties. The purpose of the study is to provide a snapshot years, with most cities seeing a marked rise in rents over the past employment sectors—for example, financial services and banking attorney is presented as a range and a median to account for the of the law firm real estate market in each major city and to five years; the 10 markets studied saw a 21% average increase in in New York, the federal government in Washington, DC and the variables that have affected occupancy over the course of the see how recent trends have influenced rental rates and the law firm rental rates during the 2015–2019 period compared with technology sector in San Francisco—the level of legal services years studied. the 2010–2014 timeframe. This significant increase is mostly amount of space leased by law firms. In order to keep the scope employment as well as the most prevalent types of law practiced In most cities studied, law firms currently lease less office attributed to a flight-to-quality trend among law firms, as the manageable, this study focuses primarily on Am Law 100 firms vary widely across U.S. cities. space collectively than they did 10–15 years ago. This is due increase in efficiency allowed many firms to upgrade their space (a ranking of the 100 largest U.S. law firms by gross revenue as Recently, legal services—a sector that is heavily office-using—has to both the densification trends noted previously and the fact while maintaining or reducing overall occupancy costs. reported by law publication The American Lawyer). followed some national office trends, while staying away from that the law firm sector has seen slow employment growth over Overall, real estate trends have been fairly consistent across As space efficiency has become a primary real estate strategy others. For example, like many other industries, law firms have the past several years. Legal services employment in the 10 these 10 markets, as many Am Law 100 firms have a national for most major law firms, the amount of square feet leased sought to make more efficient use of their space. In many cities, markets studied has remained relatively flat over the past five presence, and thus their real estate strategies are implemented per attorney has generally decreased over the past 10–15 densification has been widespread, especially when firms have years, averaging only 0.5% annual growth. In addition, enrollment simultaneously across multiple cities. Please see the table at relocated to newer office space in recent years. On the other years across the 10 markets studied. However, factors such as in law schools has declined since the Great Recession. Law the back of this report for a statistical summary of the 10 hand, the legal sector has not been an early adopter of coworking fluctuating attorney counts, subleasing of space, and variances school enrollment grew at a steady rate between 1985 and 2010, markets studied. formats and shared-space layouts, as has been the case in in space design versus space utilization make it difficult to draw followed by a decline of nearly 30% by 2015, with law school other sectors. This is attributable to a variety of factors, such direct conclusions from the amount of leased space per attorney. graduations following a similar trend. Sluggish growth in legal 4 | © NEWMARK KNIGHT FRANK | RESEARCH | NOVEMBER 2019 THOUGHT LEADERSHIP SERIES | 5 As law firms endeavor to keep operating margins and expenses TRENDS IN LAW FIRM in line with revenue growth, managing partners and firm WORKPLACE STRATEGY administrators are consistently evaluating the feasibility and financial impact of implementing various organizational By Madeline Dunsmore practice- and client-driven changes. Increasingly, law firm Regional Workplace Manager, leadership is incorporating new strategies to help support Washington, DC performance from a firm’s people, place, and practice. FEATURE Thinking Through Recruitment and The Changing Old Law vs. Space as a Tool Retention Workplace Landscape New Law Today, a successful people-strategy includes Many of today’s firms struggle in creating a In general, the total headcount of law firm Some smaller boutique firms are adopting developing a dynamic work environment sustainable pipeline of talent, particularly for employees is decreasing. With the reduction technology at a much faster rate than large flexible enough to meet the demands of a legal associates. The work assigned to associates in number of paralegals, secretaries, and legacy firms. Especially on the West Coast, we culture that engages partners, associates, is changing and many firms no longer focus on administrative personnel, there are fewer people are beginning to see the adoption of virtual legal support and clients. Less square footage mentorship and growing associates into future who need office space. This, coupled with the teams and virtual court rooms. This can allow per attorney is balanced by more collaborative partners. There is an accelerating trend of five- or move to single-size offices for partners and the some attorneys more flexibility, and more spaces, connectivity, mentorship, amenities, six-year associates as partners stay on longer, broader focus on space efficiency, is driving down work-from-home time decreases the need for and efficiencies that address client demands. and many associates are frustrated by the lack demand for law firm office space. However, firms space. Additional flexibility also serves the goal A smaller real estate footprint is balanced by of upward mobility. In some cases this has led to that invest in more collaboration and community of improving retention of high-quality talent.
Recommended publications
  • THE ASIA-PACIFIC 02 | Renewable Energy in the Asia-Pacific CONTENTS
    Edition 4 | 2017 DLA Piper RENEWABLE ENERGY IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC 02 | Renewable energy in the Asia-Pacific CONTENTS Introduction ...................................................................................04 Australia ..........................................................................................08 People’s Republic of China ..........................................................17 Hong Kong SAR ............................................................................25 India ..................................................................................................31 Indonesia .........................................................................................39 Japan .................................................................................................47 Malaysia ...........................................................................................53 The Maldives ..................................................................................59 Mongolia ..........................................................................................65 Myanmar .........................................................................................72 New Zealand..................................................................................77 Pakistan ...........................................................................................84 Papua New Guinea .......................................................................90 The Philippines ...............................................................................96
    [Show full text]
  • Turning Distance Into an Advantage
    Capital Thursday, May 19, 2016 Section D Markets NZ stock market in tip-top shape sthe benchmark S&P/ “In the next year or two, we expect NZX50 share index heads NZX boss Tim Bennett doesn't believe the sharemarket is over- to see agood mix of New Zealand towards yet another record businesses come to the market in the A high, NZX chief executive valued; he says it is poised for further growth, as Jamie Gray reports mid-sized businesses —inthe range Tim Bennett says the market is in of $300 million to $700 million,” great shape. Bennett says. The index built on an already As the sharemarket enters another strong 2014 to end last year with a year of very strong gains, analysts 13 per cent gain. fear it is looking overvalued from a Concerns about an economic price-earnings perspective but slowdown in China led to convul- Bennett is dismissive. sions in domestic and world markets “It’s all relative,” Bennett says. “New in February, but investors seem to Zealand is an attractive market. We have put their worries behind them have got avery strong economy. We for now. have got businesses that are paying “The sharemarket is in great relatively high yields and with agood shape,” Bennett says. ``We have seen, mix of companies to invest in.'' over anumber of years, avery strong The common complaint from fund performance in the index. We are also managers is that not enough IPOs seeing alot more interest in the initial have come to the market to meet public offer (IPO) pipeline this year investor demand.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report
    Top Ranking Report Annual Report Architectural Record ENR VMSD Top 300 Architecture Top 150 Global Top Retail Design Firms: Design Firms: Firms of 2014: # #1 Firm Overall #1 Architecture Firm #1 Firm Overall Building Design ENR Interior Design Message from the Board of Directors 2014 World Top 500 Design Firms: Top 100 Giants: Architecture 100 Most #1 Architecture Firm #1 Architecture Firm Admired Firms: Gensler is1 a leader among the #1 in Corporate Office As we celebrate our 50th anniversary, we world’s architecture and design #1 US Firm #1 in Retail #4 Global Firm #1 in Transportation firms. Here’s how we ranked in #1 in Government look forward to more record-setting years, our industry in 2014. #1 in Cultural thanks to our great client relationships and extraordinary people around the world. Financial Report Our financial performance and recognition throughout the We’re entering our 50th year stronger than ever. Financially strong and debt-free, we contributed industry are indications of the breadth of our practice, our global In 2014, our global growth continued apace $38.5 million in deferred compensation to our reach, and the long-standing trust of our clients. with our clients as they entrusted us with new employees through our ESOP, profit-sharing, and challenges and led us to new locations. Our international retirement plans. We made strategic expanded Gensler team of 4,700+ professionals investments in our research and professional We’ve broadened our services to 27 now work from 46 different offices. With their development programs, along with upgrades to practice areas, with total revenues help, we completed projects in 72 countries and our design-and-delivery platform and the tools for the year setting a new record $ increased our revenues to $915 million—a record and technology to support it.
    [Show full text]
  • Wayne A. Budd
    PRESENTSPRESENTS in the law IN PARTPARTNERSHIPNERSHIP WITH GOLD SPONSORS SPO SROSN SILVERSILVER SPONSORS SPONSO SR BESPOKE BANKING 2012 Annual Dinner Featuring Keynote Speaker VICTORIA REGGIE KENNEDY, ESQ. Thursday, May 31 ◆ Westin Boston Waterfront 5:30 p.m. Reception ◆ 7 p.m. Dinner Honoring Also honoring MBA LEGISLATOR OF THE YEAR 2012 ACCESS TO JUSTICE AWARDS RECIPIENTS Legal Services Award Thomas Mela Massachusetts Advocates for Children Pro Bono Law Firm Award Brody, Hardoon, Perkins & Kesten LLP Boston Pro Bono Publico Award Linda Hickman SPEAKER ROBERT A. DELEO Neighborhood Legal Services Inc. (D-Winthrop) Defender Award Dulcinea (Duci) Goncalves Sponsorship and registration CPCS Youth Advocacy Department information at Prosecutor Award Michael Fabbri www.MassBar.org/AD12 or (617) 338-0530. Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly • May 2012 • B3 in the law TABLE OF CONTENTS Up & Coming Lawyers Excellence in Diversity Excellence in Firm Alison R. Bancroft . 5 Wayne A. Budd . 19 Administration Jason G. Benzaken . 5 Angela McConney Scheepers . 19 Fangli Chen . 6 Catherine E. Reuben . 20 Lorraine Curry . 23 Zachary N. Coseglia . 6 Minita Shah-Mara . 20 Sherley E. Cruz . 8 Excellence in Operations Vikas S. Dhar . 8 Excellence in Pro Bono Steven E. Gagne . 9 Julie C. Pease . 23 Daniel K. Gelb . 9 Hanishi T. Ali . 21 Cynthia M. Gilbert . 10 Susan M. Finegan . 21 Rebecca A. Jacobstein . 10 William E. Kelly . 21 Excellence in Legal Joseph P. Kennedy III . 11 William O’Brien . 22 Journalism Adam J. Kessel . 12 William L. Patton . 22 John B. Koss . 12 Michael N. Sheetz . 22 Kevin Cullen . 24 Stephen M. LaRose . 13 Brown Rudnick . 22 Katharine L.
    [Show full text]
  • Financial Services Update
    MAY 2016 FINANCIAL SERVICES UPDATE Some welcome relief for managers of real property schemes. The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) CUSTODY OF REAL PROPERTY The first exemption removes the need for real property has announced a new class exemption assets of existing closed property investment schemes to for managers of property schemes. The be held by the scheme’s supervisor or an independent custodian. This will be conditional on the supervisor exemption announced yesterday relieves holding a first ranking security that is registered against the managers and their custodians from the property. If a manager holds real property under this exemption then it will also be exempt from the need to some of the licensing and governance obtain an annual assurance engagement - this would requirements that would usually apply otherwise require the manager to engage an auditor to provide an annual assurance report on the custodial under the Financial Markets Conduct Act processes, procedures and controls. (FMCA), and that may cause unnecessary All other assets will need to be held by the supervisor or custodian and will be subject to an annual assurance costs for property schemes because of the engagement. special nature of their assets and operations. CASH RECONCILIATIONS Custodians of all schemes (new and existing) will be exempt from the requirement to undertake daily cash reconciliation. This will be conditional on reconciliations taking place at a frequency that is appropriate for the volume and frequency of transactions. Financial Services Update | 1 QUALIFYING PROPERTY INVESTMENT KEY CONTACTS SCHEMES IN ACTIVE WIND-UP Daniel Arapere The FMA has recognised that, for a scheme that is in Partner active wind-up, the cost of compliance with the new +64 4 474 3210 licensing and governance requirements will outweigh the [email protected] benefit for investors.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Brochure
    NEW ZEALAND Share Our Vision Shape Your Future www.dlapiper.com/nzgrads SHAPE OUR VISION SHAPE YOUR FUTURE DLA Piper New Zealand’s flagship office in Commercial Bay, Auckland. 2 WWW.DLAPIPER.COM/NZGRADS Contents Introduction to DLA Piper ................................................4 What makes us different ..................................................6 Values, awards and vital statistics ..................................8 Our practice groups ....................................................... 10 Responsible business ..................................................... 12 Why DLA Piper? ............................................................... 14 An interview with Sara Battersby ................................. 15 What we look for ............................................................. 16 Opportunities ................................................................... 17 Your development ........................................................... 18 Law clerk application process and timeline .............. 19 3 SHAPE OUR VISION SHAPE YOUR FUTURE If you want to become a global lawyer you’ve come to the right place DLA Piper is a global business law firm located in more than 40 countries throughout the Americas, Europe, the Middle East, Africa and Asia Pacific, positioning us to help clients with their legal needs around the world. We strive to be the leading global business law firm by delivering quality and value to our clients and contributing to the communities we operate in. DLA Piper is a firm that’s challenging
    [Show full text]
  • Australia and New Zealand Property Journal: April 2012
    RESIDENTIAL VALUATION HOTEL INVESTMENT BUMPER EDITION What’s the value of a view? Dispelling the myths AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND PROPERTY JOURNAL December 2012 Vol 3/No. 8 $12.95 (incl GST) GREEN REAL ESTATE DOES IT GIVE A COMPETITIVE EDGE? Print Post Approved PP246764/00006 Print Post Approved A.R.B.N. 007 505 866 ABN 49007 ISSN 1836-6635 PINZ ISN 100 1330 THE OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF THE AUSTRALIAN PROPERTY INSTITUTE AND THE PROPERTY INSTITUTE OF NEW ZEALAND OFC_Artwork.indd 1 12/7/2012 5:22:20 PM Smarter Solutions for Places That Matter Yardi Voyager for Office, Retail and Industrial SMARTER YARDI Commercial SuiteTM delivers a smarter approach to property management – a single platform for the entire real estate lifecycle that enables managers to maximise NOI, drive asset value for the owner and provide the best customer service to tenants and their employees. Yardi Systems Pty Ltd - Investment, Asset & Property Management Software Suite 3, Level 23 | 25 Bligh Street | Sydney, NSW 2000 | Tel: +61 (2) 8227 2200 | Fax: +61 (2) 8227 2222 SMART Yardi Voyager plus Yardi Orion and the Yardi Commercial Suite YARDI VoyagerTM YARDI Commercial CRMTM End-to-end software enables smart, highly efficient Shorten leasing lifecycles and deliver increased operational management of the entire real estate lifecycle efficiency in work practices to drive revenue enhancement YARDI OrionTM for SharePoint® YARDI PAYscanTM Out-of-the-box business intelligence dashboards, document management Improve efficiency and save costs with automated and portals—built for
    [Show full text]
  • Self- Represented Litigants – Continuing the Dialogue
    THIS ISSUE: A friend in need? Looking at options for self-represented litigants The ins and outs of making donations ADLSI honours Justice Simon Moore LAWNEWS ISSUE 6 13 MARCH 2015 www.adls.org.nz + Courts, litigation, self-representation SELF- REPRESENTED LITIGANTS – CONTINUING THE DIALOGUE By Anthony Jackson, Barrister Self-represented litigants are a phenomenon that the courts and practitioners increasingly have to address and contend with at all levels. This article is intended to be thought-provoking and (hopefully) to continue the discussion on ADLSI hosted a dinner on Friday 6 March 2015 in honour of the Honourable Justice Simon Moore, this matter. It is not intended to provide answers, former Crown Solicitor and long-time ADLSI member and supporter. His Honour (in the centre) is pictured but readers’ feedback would be welcome! here with Andrea Manuel, his Honour Judge Gary Harrison, his Honour Judge Kevin Glubb and Chief Coroner Deborah Marshall. For more pictures from this event please turn to pages 4 and 5. Changes to representation in court Changes to legal aid, particularly for Family Court cases, and changes to the rules allowing lawyers to be present for clients have meant as it affects the rule of law. England and Wales) made it clear that he was (for example) that in many cases parents are not prepared to countenance the parents facing no longer able to have a lawyer represent them Looking further afield (to the United Kingdom), the application by the local authority without in what can be difficult cases. This means another example of a judicial viewpoint on these proper legal representation.
    [Show full text]
  • INDUSTRY ADVISORY GROUP Annual Meeting April 5, 2017 SOM | U.S
    INDUSTRY ADVISORY GROUP ANNUAL MEETING April 5, 2017 SOM | U.S. Consulate General Guangzhou AGENDA AGENDA AGENDA AFTERNOON SESSION Public LOY HENDERSON 2:00 OPENING REMARKS Ambassador William Moser 2:15 INDUSTRY PARTICIPATION Ann Beha INDUSTRY ADVISOR 2:30 SUPPORTING THE U.S CONSULAR PROGRAM WORLDWIDE BUREAU OF CONSULAR AFFAIRS John Brennan DEPUTY ASSISTANT SECRETARY John Brennan is a Senior Foreign Service Officer who has served with the Department of State since 1985. In November 2015, he was named Deputy Assistant Secretary (DAS) for Resources in CA, a position in which he is responsible for budgets, strategic planning, human resources, and IT. He has extensive experience domestically and abroad, having most recently served as Senior Advisor in charge of the Electronic Visa Project. Prior to that, Mr. Brennan was the Minister Counselor for Consular Affairs in Mexico, with responsibility for consular operations at the Embassy and nine U.S. Consulates General in Mexico. Scott Feeken MANAGEMENT ANALYST Scott Feeken joined the Foreign Service in 2002 and is a consular officer in the Bureau of consular affairs. He previously served in consular assignments in Kyiv, Manila, Monterrey, and Toronto. He has also served in the Bureau of Legislative Affairs. Before joining the State Department he worked as a Congressional staffer for members of the Kansas Congressional delegation. SOM | SKIDMORE, OWINGS & MERRILL David Diamond ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR AND TECHNICAL DESIGNER David Diamond, FAIA, is an Associate Director and Technical Designer in Skidmore, Owings & Merrill llP’s San Francisco office. He has over 25 years of experience in the design, documentation, and construction of commercial, civic, and institutional projects.
    [Show full text]
  • Chc-2020-1883-Hcm Env-2020-1884-Ce
    Los Angeles Department of City Planning RECOMMENDATION REPORT CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION CASE NO.: CHC-2020-1883-HCM ENV-2020-1884-CE HEARING DATE: May 7, 2020 Location: 420-430 South Bundy Drive TIME: 10:00 AM Council District: 11 – Bonin PLACE : Teleconference (see Community Plan Area: Brentwood – Pacific Palisades agenda for login Area Planning Commission: West Los Angeles information) Neighborhood Council: None Legal Description: Westgate Acres, Lot PT 72 EXPIRATION DATE: The original expiration date of April 17, 2020 is tolled, and a revised date will be determined pursuant to the Mayor’s March 21, 2020 Public Order Under City of Los Angeles Emergency Authority re: Tolling of Deadlines Prescribed in the Municipal Code and April 17, 2020 Public Order Under City of Los Angeles Emergency Authority re: Tolling HCIDLA Deadlines and Revising Expiration of Emergency Orders PROJECT: Historic-Cultural Monument Application for WOODMERE REQUEST: Declare the property an Historic-Cultural Monument OWNERS: Cynthia Jopanda, Trustee Kato Pomer, Trustee Pomer Dec’d Trust Pomer Family Trust PO Box 889 430 South Bundy Drive Monterey Park, CA 91754 Los Angeles, CA 90049 APPLICANT: Hollywood Heritage, Inc. PO Box 2586 Hollywood, CA 90078 PREPARERS: Mary Mallory Laura Meyers 11161¼ Acama Street 1818 South Gramercy Place Studio City, CA 91602 Los Angeles, CA 90019 RECOMMENDATION That the Cultural Heritage Commission: 1. Take the property under consideration as an Historic-Cultural Monument per Los Angeles Administrative Code Chapter 9, Division 22, Article 1, Section 22.171.10 because the application and accompanying photo documentation suggest the submittal warrants further investigation. 2. Adopt the report findings.
    [Show full text]
  • GUIDE to GOING GLOBAL IPT Full Handbook
    GUIDE TO GOING GLOBAL IPT Full Handbook Downloaded: 24 Sep 2021 TABLE OF CONTENTS GUIDE TO GOING GLOBAL | IPT TABLE OF CONTENTS About Guide to Going Global . 2 Angola . 4 Argentina . 14 Australia . 25 Austria . 39 Belgium . 51 Brazil . 67 Canada . 78 Chile . 88 China . 99 Colombia . 110 Czech Republic . 127 Denmark . 135 Finland . 145 France . 154 Germany . 170 Hong Kong, SAR . 182 Hungary . 192 India . 204 Indonesia . 215 Ireland . 227 Israel . 240 Italy . 252 Japan . 266 Luxembourg . 276 Mexico . 291 Netherlands . 300 New Zealand . 315 Nigeria . 325 Norway . 340 Philippines . 350 Poland . 362 Portugal . 378 Romania . 390 Russia . 400 Saudi Arabia . 409 Singapore . 419 Slovak Republic . 429 South Korea . 442 Spain . 454 Sweden . 467 Switzerland . 478 Taiwan, China . ..
    [Show full text]
  • Insurance Update
    OCTOBER 2016 INSURANCE UPDATE Property policies - The effect of reinstatement provisions On 10 October 2016, the English Court rebuild the premises, although no reinstatement work had of Appeal (Court) handed down an important at that stage been carried out. The judge dismissed the insurers’ defences and granted the declaration. The Court, decision on the measure of indemnity under a making a minor variation to the judge’s ruling, upheld his property policy and, in particular, the effect of general conclusions. reinstatement provisions. The Court laid down the following general principles: In Great Lakes Reinsurance v Western Trading,1 1. Where real property was destroyed, the measure of the insured company was the occupier and manager of indemnity to which the insured was entitled depended premises belonging to the company’s controller, Mr Singh. on: The insured was under an obligation to insure the premises i. the terms of the policy; and to reinstate them in the event of loss or damage. The premises, for which planning permission to convert into ii. the interest of the insured in, or its obligations in apartments had earlier been obtained, were unoccupied respect of, the property insured; and and used for storage. They were insured under a policy iii. the facts of the case, including, in particular, the for the sum of £2,121,800, representing the rebuilding intention of the insured at the time of the loss. If cost of the property. The market value was only £75,000. the insured had a limited interest in the property, it The policy provided that the insurers would indemnify the would be material to consider whether the subject insured against loss or damage, but reinstatement costs matter of the insurance was the whole interest in were payable only if the reinstatement work had been the property insured and not solely that of the commenced and carried out with reasonable despatch.
    [Show full text]