In Search of Lost Universalism 5th International Forum

Berlin, 27-28 November, 2

Association of Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Europe

0 19

Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung Academy Tiergartenstraße 35, 10785 with support from Konrad Adenauer Stiftung Learning to understand, learning to trust

2 / 3 Wednesday 27 November

Global RESPONSIBILITY

10.00–11.00 opening session: 13.00–14.00 Lunch Lena Nemirovskaya Founder, School of Civic Education 14.00–16.00 Panel I: International Organizations Address by Nils Muižnieks Moderator: Mikhail Fishman Political Scientist, Commissioner for Human Rights at the Panelists: Konstantin von Eggert, Ambassador Löjdquist, Council of Europe (2012–2018); President, Association of Elena Panfilova the Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Europe Address by Catherine Lalumièrre 16.00–16.30 Coffee break Secretary General, Council of Europe (1989-1994) Address by John Lloyd 16.30–18.30 Panel II: Media and Politics Contributing Editor, The Financial Times, Author Moderator: Bobo Lo Panelists: Riina Kaljurand, Sylvie Kauffmann, Kadri 11.00–11.30 Address by Dr. Gerhard Wahlers Liik, Natalie Nougayrède, Pilar Bonet Deputy Secretary-General and Head of the European and International Cooperation Department of the Konrad 18.30 Buffet Adenauer Foundation

11.30–12.00 Coffee-break

12.00–13.00 Address by Thomas Bagger Diplomatic Adviser at the Office of the Federal President of

4 / 5 Thursday 28 November

Global RESPONSIBILITY

10.00–10.30 Message of the forum Yury Senokosov 16.30–17.00 Coffee break

10.30–11.00 Address by Marco Politi, Author, Vatican Analyst 17.00–19.00 Advanced School Projects Launch Citizens as actors of change 11.00–11.30 Coffee break Moderator: Marina Gurieva

11.30–13.30 Panel III: Economy and Global Space 19.00–19.30 Coffee break Moderator: Mikhail Fishman Panelists: Torbjörn Becker, Fredrik Erixon, 19.30–20.00 Address by Michael Mertes Yuri Romanenkov Author, Political advisor to Chancellor (1987–1998) 13.30–14.30 Lunch 20.00–20.30 Closing remarks 14.30–16.30 Panel IV: Jack Hanning Why Do We Need Global European Space Lena Nemirovskaya Moderator: Mikhail Fishman Panelists: Bobo Lo, Mikhail Minakov, Vytis Jurkonis, 21.00 Dinner Michael Sohlman, Pernille Rieker

6 / 7 Kadri Liik Senior Policy Fellow, European Council KEY SPEAKERS (Estonia) on Foreign Relations John Lloyd Thomas Bagger Contributing Editor, The Financial Times Diplomatic Adviser at the Office of the (United Kingdom) (Germany) Federal President of Germany Bobo Lo Independent analyst, Associate Fellow Torbjörn Becker Director, Stockholm Institute of (United Kingdom) with IFRI, Non-Resident Fellow with () Transition Economics the Lowy Institute Pilar Bonet Correspondent, El Paнs Ambassador Fredrik (Spain) Department for European Löjdquist Security Policy, Ministry for Foreign for Konstantin von Eggert Columnist, Deutsche Welle (Sweden) Foreign Affairs () Michael Mertes Author, Political advisor to Chancellor Fredrik Erixon Economist, Author; Director, European (Germany) Helmut Kohl (1987–1998) (Sweden) Centre for International Political Mikhail Minakov Visiting Professor, Basel University; Economy (ECIPE) () Senior Fellow, Kennan Institute; Mikhail Fishman Journalist, Author, Producer of the film Editor-in-Chief, Kennan Focus Ukraine; (Russia) The Man Who Was Too Free (2016) Editor-in-Chief, Ideology and Politics Journal Marina Gurieva Co-founder and CEO, Cyber Fund (Russia) Nils Muižnieks Human Rights Activist, Political (Council of Europe) Scientist, Commissioner for Human Jack Hanning Secretary General, Association of Schools Rights at the Council of Europe (2012– (Council of Europe) of Political Studies, Council of Europe 2018); President, Association of the Vytis Jurkonis Lecturer, Institute of International Schools of Political Studies of the (Lithuania) Relations and Political Science, Vilnius Council of Europe. University Lena Nemirovskaya Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education Riina Kaljurand Policy Adviser, Ministry of Foreign (Russia) (Estonia) Affairs of Estonia Natalie Nougayrède Editorial Board Member and Sylvie Kauffmann Journalist, Editorial Director, Le Monde (France) Columnist, The Guardian (France) Elena Panfilova Chairperson of the Centre for Anti- Catherine Lalumière Secretary General, Council of Europe (Russia) Corruption Research and Initiative (Council of Europe) (1989–1994); Member, European Transparency International, the Russian Parliament (1994–2004); President, chapter of Transparency International; Association of the Schools of Political Director, Transparency International Studies of the Council of Europe 8 / 9 Marco Politi Author, Vatican Analyst (Italy) Participants

Pernille Rieker Research Professor, Norwegian Institute (Norway) of International Affairs ARMENIA Yuri Romanenkov Executive Vice President of Kamo Mayilyan Resident Representative of Canadian () Development and Business Commodities Trading Company in Administration; Faculty Member at the Armenia Stockholm School of Economics in Elina Mkrtumyan Project Coordinator, Yerevan School of Yury Senokosov Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education (Russia) Political Studies Armen Zakaryan Director, Yerevan School of Political Michael Sohlman Chairman, Swedish Institute of Studies (Sweden) International Affairs; Member, Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences; Executive director, Nobel Foundation AZERBAIJAN (1992– 2011) Ilgar Mammadov Dr. Gerhard Wahlers Deputy Secretary-General and Head of Director, Baku Political Studies (Germany) the European and International Programme, Association of the Schools Cooperation Department of the Konrad of Political Studies of the Council of Adenauer Foundation Europe

BELARUS

Dzmitry Lukashuk Broadcast Editor, special correspondent, European Radio for Belarus Alaksiej Michalevic Lawyer, Belarusian Centre for Refugee Support Mihail Novoselov Senior Lecturer, School of Business of Belarusian State University Ivan Sadouski Director, Independent Pro-Market Think Tank Mises Center

10 / 11 Barbare Okropiridze BELGIUM EU Project Coordinator, Konrad Adenauer Foundation, Tbilisi office Philippe Van Asten Political and civic activist Tamta Tskhovrebadze Associate Professor, International Black Sea University BOSNIA and HERZEGOVINA

Esad Mavric Director, School of Political Studies GERMANY Miriam Kosmehl Senior Expert for the Eastern Neighbourhood and East Europe, BULGARIA Bertelsmann Stiftung, Gütersloh-Berlin Aleksandar Ilchev Project Manager, Bulgarian School of Alexey Kozlov Executive Director, Solidarität mit der Politics Dimitry Panitza Bürgerbewegung in Russland e.V. Stanimir Kaytazki Attorney, Sofia Bar Association Olga Romanova Director, Meine Russischen Rechte (MRR); Director, Rus’ Sidashaya

CROATIA GREECE Suljicic Darko Program coordinator, Academy for Political Development Elli Papastergiou Programme Officer, Symbiosis Dragan Nikolić Senior international correspondent, News Media Service ITALY Iva Petković Executive Director, Academy for Political Development Gianpietro Borghini City mayor of Milan (2006 - 2009)

GEORGIA KAZAKHSTAN Armaz Akhvlediani Director, Tbilisi School of Political Assel Ayaganova Project Supervisor, DigitalMedia Studies Consultant Agency Nodar Daraselia Press Relations Advisor of Public Alexandr Danilov Manager Partner, B2C Consulting Group, Relations and Mass Media, Center for Political Management and Public Public Relations Consulting Lasha Kiladze General Director, Center for Mental health and Prevention of Addiction 12 / 13 Artur Nigmetov Director, Media Technology Center MONTENEGRO Private Foundation Jelena Ristović Coordinator, Montenegro School of KOSOVO Political Studies Leonora Kryeziu Executive Director, Prishtina Institute MOROCCO for Political Studies Chakib Moussafir Municipal Councillor, Alumni, Citizenship School of Political Studies KYRGYZSTAN POLAND Elmira Nogoibaeva Founder and Director, Academy of Civic Education Olena Babakova Project Coordinator, WOT Foundation; Freelance Journalist Igor Isajew Editor-in-chief, PROstir.pl, Ukrainians’ LATVIA portal in Poland Māris Jonovs Organizer, City People Community Agnieszka Chairman, Center for Support of Smolczynska-Wiechetek International Initiatives; Adjunct (PhD), Eastern Institute of the University A. LITHUANIA Mickiewicz, Poznan Joanna Sozańska Program Coordinator, European Vsevolod Chernozub Director, Alexander Herzen Foundation Academy of Diplomacy

MACEDONIA RUSSIA Zhidas Daskalovski Director, Mother Teresa School of Mariia Anikina Correspondent, Belsat TV channel; Public Policy (Novosibirsk region) Producer of visual content, Novosibirsk Information Agency Olga Arifulina MOLDOVA Project manager, Paragon Software Group (St. Petersburg) Viorel Cibotaru Executive Director, European Institute Kurban Askandarov Journalist, Public figure for Political Studies in Moldova (Republic of Dagestan)

14 / 15 Alexey Baraev Entrepreneur; Member, Public Council Solomon Ginzburg President, Regional Strategy (Yaroslavl region) at the Tourism Department of the (Kaliningrad region) Foundation; Member of the Public Yaroslavl Region Chamber of the Kaliningrad region Anton Barbashin Editorial Director, Riddle Project Dmitrii Gorin Head of Laboratory, Plekhanov Russian (Novosibirsk region) (Bryansk region) University of Economics Yakhya Buchaev Rector, Dagestan State University of Maksim Goriunov Presenter, Euroradio.fm Radio Station; (Republic of Dagestan) National Economy (Novgorod region) philosopher, blogger Akhmed Buzurtanov Founder, Editor-in-chief, Fortanga ORG Denis Grekov Teacher, Department of Humanitarian (Republic of ) News Portal (Altay krai) Sciences, Liberal Arts College (RANEPA) Andrey Bystrov Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law, Dmitrii Grushevskii Founder, Supervisor, Institute of (Moscow) National Research University Higher ( region) Regional Economics and Social Design School of Economics Alexey Gusev Deputy, Council of Deputies, Tsyrendorzhi Damdinov Head, Regional Branch of the (Moscow) Cheremushki Municipal District of (Transbaikal region) Spravedlivaya Rossiya (Fair Russia) Party Moscow; History Teacher Ilya Dovgiy Deputy, Duma of Novgorod; English Denis Iagodin Manager, TFOMS of Saint-Petersburg (Novgorod region) teacher, secondary school #20 named (St. Petersburg) after Cyril and Methodius Aleksandra Iasharkina Civic activist Evgenii Drogov Director, O-Kratkoe publishing house (Yaroslavl region) (Kirov region) Olga Irisova Senior editor, Riddle Project Denis Dzhenzhera Director, FORME company; publisher, (Udmurt Republic) (Primorsky Krai) local historian Evgenii Ishigenov Individual Entrepreneur Artem Filatov Journalist (Pepublic of Buriatia) (St. Petersburg) Viacheslav Ivanetc Lawyer, Bar Association Lora Fish Journalist, OVD-Info project (Irkutsk region) (Moscow) Kirill Ivanov Human Rights Activist, Lawyer Aleksandr Fuks Journalist, Karelskaya Guberniya (Kaliningrad region) (Republic of Karelia) Newspaper Evgenii Kalinin Individual Entrepreneur Elena Galkina Political scientist (Nizhny Novgorod Region) (Moscow) Larisa Kazakova Member of the Federal Council, Yabloko (St. Petersburg) political party

16 / 17 Kseniia Kharina Journalist, 7X7 Online Journal Aslan Mazukabzov Entrepreneur; Assistant Head of the (Kirov region) (Kabardino-Balkarian Delegation in the North Caucasus, Republic) International Committee of the Red Cross Igor Knyazev Bishop, Head of the boarding house for (Kaluga region) the care of the sick and the elderly David Meladze Deputy, City Council of Zubov ( region) Nina Kolipova Programme Manager Assistant, (Komi Republic) Memorial Human Rights Center Igor Mintusov Founder, Head of the Board of Director, (Moscow) Agency for Strategic Communications Natalia Korchenkova Editor, Team 29 Media project (Moscow) Nikkolo M Viktor Muchnik Georgy Kozlov CEO, News agency TV2 Individual Entrepreneur ( region) (Moscow) Viktoriia Muchnik Mikhail Krasulin Journalist, News agency TV2 Leading Expert, Center for (Tomsk region) (Yaroslavl region) Contemporary Politics, Demidov Yaroslavl State University Aryuna Namsaraeva Director, Business Time Consulting (Transbaikal region) Agency Elena Kriven Student, Faculty of Philosophy, (Moscow) Research University Higher School of Sergei Ponomarev Director, International Impact Investing Economics; Activist of the youth (Perm region) Center Galileo movement, Yabloko party Marina Potekhina Freelance journalist Nikita Kuzmin Editor, RUGRAD.EU Internet Project (St. Petersburg) (Kaliningrad region) Anton Rubin Director, Domik Detstva Regional Anna Lapshina Editor-in-chief, Information and ( region) Public Organization (Kirov region) Analytical Broadcasting Department, Dmitry Rudenkin Sociologist, Associate Professor, Ural Radio Station Echo of Moscow in Kirov (Sverdlovsk region) Federal University Dmitrii Loboiko General Manager, Zasekin LLC Aleksei Rykov (Samara region) Master Programme assistant, (St. Petersburg) Department of Liberal Arts and Iurii Lobunov Chief Editor, City 32 information Sciences, St. Petersburg State University (Bryansk region) agency; Analyst, GSA consulting company Roman Sacharov Coordinator, Glasnost Defense Foundation Fedor Lukovtsev Senior Lecturer, New Media Chair, (St. Petersburg) (Republic of Sakhа-Yakutia) Faculty of Journalism, Moscow State Liudmila Savochkina Head, Regional College of Arts, University (Saratov region) Branch in Balakovo Semen Matkheev Chairman of the Regional Office, Public (Pepublic of Buriatia) organization Business Russia 18 / 19 Evgeniya Sayko Founder, DemoSlam Youth Project Elizaveta Strokova Student, Dutch Language Integration (Tomsk region) (Republic of Tatarstan) and Study Programme Supported by the Flemish Language Community Iuliia Schastlivtseva Director, Leonid Nikitinsky Center for ( region) Legal and Media Programs non-profit Iuliia Tarkovskaia Radio Anchor, Echo of Moscow Radio partnership (Yaroslavl region) Station, Author and Anchor, Probel (Gap) Radio Talk Show Natalia Sevetc-Ermolina Head, Agriculture-club Independent (Republic of Karelia) Urban Community Aleksandr Tikhonov Deputy Editor-in-Chief, Web Paper (Yaroslavl region) Side-view - Yaroslavl Dmitrii Shevkunov Senior Lecturer, Institute of Social (Udmurt Republic) Communications, Udmurt State Artem Torchinskiy Project Manager, Anti-Corruption University; Head, Bricolage Intellectual (Moscow) Foundation and Debating Club Timur Uzhakhov Associate Professor, International Alisa Shishkina Research Fellow, National Research (Republic of Ingushetia) Innovation University (Moscow) University Higher School of Economics Iuliia Vashchilina Key advisor of the Department of Alexander Shmelev Political Analyst (Bryansk region) Internal Policy, Government of the (Moscow) Bryansk Region Vladimir Shmelev Deputy Principal for Student Anton Veselov Deputy Director of Public Relations, (Moscow) Development, LETOVO School (Novosibirsk region) State Public Scientific and Technical Library; Columnist, Continent Siberia Svetlana Shmeleva Tutor, I-Forum Distance Education Business Weekly (Moscow) Programme, School of Civic Education Idris Yusupov Correspondent, Novoe Delo (New Business), Daria Skibo Research Fellow, Centre for (Republic of Dagestan) Dagestan Socio-political Weekly (St. Petersburg) Independent Social Research Ilyas Yusupov Coordinator, Peace to Your Home Konstantin Smirnov Deputy, Municipality of Dubrovic Rural (Republic of Dagestan) Ecological project (Ryazan region) Settlement; Editor-in-Chief, Side View (vidsboku.com) Internet Newspaper Svetlana Zanko Editor-in-Chief, Echo of Moscow Radio (Kirov region) Station, Kirov; Member of Regional Alexey Sokin Deputy, City Council of Deputies (Omsk region) Public Chamber Kirill Zarifulin Coordinator, Public Diplomacy. EU and Mariia Solenova Member, Council of Deputies of the (Moscow) Russia Project (Moscow) Sokol District, Moscow Mikhail Zhukov Coordinator, Solidarität mit der Alexander Solovyev Ex-chairman, Open Russia Russian (Yaroslavl region) Bürgerbewegung in Russland e.V. (Moscow) Public Net Movement International Youth Projects

20 / 21 Natalia Zviagina Director, Amnesty International Russia UKRAINE (Voronezh region) Iuliia Arkhipova Volunteer, Kreisau-Initiative Project Hanna Bazhenova Senior Analyst, Institute of Central SERBIA Europe Ivanka Mihailovic Program Coordinator, Belgrade Fund Georgy Chizhov Program Director, Reforms Assistance for Political Excellence Centre Public Organisation Olexiy Girenko Head, Ukraine+ all-Ukrainian Public SLOVAKIA Organization Sergiy Koshman Strategy Director, TV Public Andrea Tittelová Founder, CEO, Global Academy Broadcasting Corporation of Ukraine of Conscious Politics and Future Constellation Leader in Global Institute Andrii Kruglashov PhD in Political Science, Strategist, for Evolving Women Consultant & Trainer; Associate Professor, National Academy of Public Administration SPAIN Polina Lavrova Director, Laurus Publishing House Miguel Beltrán de Felipe Professor of Administrative Law, Oleksandr Shcherba Member of the Political Council, University of Castilla-La Mancha Republic Political Party Oleh Slyzko Chairman, Poltava regional branch, Students’ Republic Youth Public TUNISIA Organisation Ahmed Driss Director, Tunisian School of Politics Pavlo Viknyanskyy Head, Students’ Republic Youth Public Organisation

TURKEY

Sinan Fındık Genetics-Bioinformatics Scientist, Medipol University

22 / 23 Enlightenment is man’s emergence from his self-imposed nonage. “ Nonage is the inability to use one’s own understanding without another’s guidance. This nonage is self-imposed if its cause lies not in lack of understanding but in indecision and lack of courage to use one’s own mind without another’s guidance. Sapere aude! “Have the courage to use your own understanding”, is therefore the motto of the enlightenment. Immanuel Kant “Answering the Question:” What Is Enlightenment?”