Refining a Woman's College: Toward a History of Brenau
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REFINING A WOMAN’S COLLEGE: TOWARD A HISTORY OF BRENAU UNIVERSITY, 1878 – 2008 by CHARLES HOOPER WILSON III (Under the Direction of Ronald E. Butchart) ABSTRACT Brenau University is a private, selective, non-denominational, comprehensive university of about 2000 students. Its main campus sits on 57 acres located in Gainesville, Georgia, approximately fifty miles northeast of Atlanta. At the heart of Brenau is its liberal arts Women’s College, which was founded in 1878 as the Georgia Baptist Female Seminary and became Brenau College in 1900. This dissertation examines the history of Brenau’s academics, policies toward integration, disciplinary rules and regulations, physical culture and athletics, and Greek life and student organizations. These topics are considered within a thematic framework that contemplates college as a “negotiated space” in which the overall experience of any college is refined over time in an on-going, often unspoken, give-and-take process of negotiation between two key groups, the college’s students and its faculty and administration, a dynamic that is lost in many institutional biographies. Throughout the institution’s history, Brenau’s students and faculty each jockeyed to refine “their Brenau,” their ideal version of what the Brenau College experience should be. Often, Brenau’s faculty and administration gained the upper hand in negotiations with students. This was particularly evident in fashioning the college curriculum and in setting institutional policies about such things as integration. However, in many instances, this was not the case. At times, Brenau’s students won the negotiations and exhibited a remarkable degree of autonomy in conducting affairs in some arenas. Brenau women had a prominent voice in effecting college rules and discipline, in bringing athletics to campus, and in running student organizations. INDEX WORDS: Brenau University, College History, History of Higher Education, Women’s Higher Education, Women’s Colleges REFINING A WOMAN’S COLLEGE: TOWARD A HISTORY OF BRENAU UNIVERSITY, 1878 – 2008 by CHARLES HOOPER WILSON III B.S., The University of Georgia, 1993 J.D., The University of Toledo College of Law, 1996 M.S., The Georgia Institute of Technology, 1999 M.P.A., North Georgia College and State University, 2005 M.A., The University of Georgia, 2006 A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY ATHENS, GEORGIA 2008 © 2008 Charles Hooper Wilson III All Rights Reserved REFINING A WOMAN’S COLLEGE: TOWARD A HISTORY OF BRENAU UNIVERSITY, 1878 – 2008 by CHARLES HOOPER WILSON III Major Professor: Ronald E. Butchart Committee: Derrick P. Alridge Todd D. Dinkelman Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia August 2008 DEDICATION To Ana and Celia, with all my love. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work owes its completion to a great many people. I am indebted to my colleagues at North Georgia College and State University, and particularly to my supervisor, Dr. Leo Downing, for much support. No one ever had better coworkers and friends. I also appreciate the many students I have taught over the years who have said that I enriched their lives. Their sentiments encouraged me to seek my degree and to continue teaching. I am grateful to many fine people at Brenau University for their help and encouragement, including Drs. John S. and Patricia A. Burd, Dr. James Southerland, and archivist Debbie Thompson and the staff of the Brenau Trustee Library. My doctoral committee members, Dr. Derrick P. Alridge and Dr. Todd D. Dinkelman, were simply outstanding. I learned much from their tutelage and they always provided me with invaluable feedback and support. To my advisor, Dr. Ronald E. Butchart, I owe a very great deal indeed. I have been the beneficiary of his insight, his wisdom, his intellect, and his unfailing support more times than I could count. No student ever had a better advisor and friend. Finally, I owe the most of all to my friends and family (in both America and Spain) who have been there for me over the years. Two are first in my heart: my daughter, Celia, who amazes and inspires me beyond words and my wife, Ana, who means more to me than I could ever express. Os quiero mucho. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................................ v LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................................vii LIST OF FIGURES......................................................................................................................viii INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER I PARTIES TO NEGOTIATION: BRENAU’S STUDENTS AND FACULTY ......... 30 II ACADEMICS AT BRENAU ..................................................................................... 61 III SEGREGATION AT BRENAU................................................................................. 97 IV RULES AND DISCIPLINE AT BRENAU.............................................................. 128 V PHYSICAL CULTURE AT BRENAU.................................................................... 182 VI “ATHLETICS” AT BRENAU.................................................................................. 198 VII STUDENT SPACE AND SECRET SOCIETIES AT BRENAU............................. 231 CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................................... 267 ABBREVIATIONS..................................................................................................................... 273 BIBLIOGRAPHY ....................................................................................................................... 274 APPENDIX ................................................................................................................................. 290 vi LIST OF TABLES Page Table 1.1: Number of Males and Females on Brenau Faculty by Year........................................ 57 Table A.1: Undergraduate Degrees Offered by Brenau from 1900 - 1930........................290 - 292 Table A.2: Undergraduate Degrees Offered by Brenau from 1940 - 2000........................293 - 294 vii LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 1.1: The Reverend W. C. Wilkes....................................................................................... 44 Figure 1.2: Dr. Azor Van Hoose ................................................................................................... 46 Figure 1.3: Dr. Heywood Jefferson Pearce ................................................................................... 48 Figure 3.1: The Tri-Kappa Society of Brenau College circa 1912 ............................................. 108 Figure 7.1: The Stabs as Depicted in the Bubbles ....................................................................... 233 Figure 7.2: Initiation into the H.G.H. Society............................................................................. 236 viii INTRODUCTION “A university should be a place of light, of liberty, and of learning.” Benjamin Disraeli Speech given 8 March 1873 British House of Commons College histories tend to be celebratory works that trumpet an institution’s triumphs and gloss over its tragedies. No doubt this is because the authors of these institutional biographies, who are often teachers at or graduates of the place being written about, frequently have close ties to the college itself. How likely would a faculty member writing about his employer be to air dirty laundry, even if it needed airing? How likely would an alumnus of an institution be to depict an alma mater , the place where he or she invested much time, effort, and money, as anything but a fine place to earn a degree? Such personal connections increase the chance that history might be intentionally misrepresented. However, even where this does not occur, authors with close ties to an institution might subconsciously paint a rosier picture of the college or university without even realizing it. While no author can claim true historical objectivity, I believe my slight ties to Brenau University make this a relatively unburdened institutional history. Other than having taught two history courses there as an adjunct faculty member, attending an occasional music recital or theatrical performance, and rarely making use of its library, I have no ties to Brenau. Yet, even as I am perhaps able to avoid writing a celebratory account of Brenau’s history, I found that there are, in fact, things to celebrate about the institution. In many ways, Brenau is something of the university Disraeli contemplates. The name “Brenau” is derived from German ( brennan , which means “to burn”) and Latin (aurum , which means “gold”) and means “gold as refined by fire.” The motto reflects Brenau’s desire to forge its students into remarkable beings. The main campus of the university is located about fifty miles northeast of Atlanta, Georgia, in the city of Gainesville, near the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains. Over two-dozen buildings, some of which are on the National Register of Historic Places, occupy this verdant fifty acre site. Brenau is accredited by the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools and is a self-described private, selective, non- denominational,