Disintermediation in Question: New Economy, New Networks, New Middlemen
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Disintermediation in Question: New Economy, New Networks, New Middlemen Fr&l&ic Jallat and Michael J. Capek raditionally, disintermediation has been sales transactions, we defined as a development that enables intend to demonstrate T households to bypass banks and place that current Internet their savings directly with other types of financial trends go beyond Far from sidelining institutions. In the context of the Web, it has disintermediation. distributors and other come to signify the disappearance of a wide vari- Emerging new Internet ety of “middlemen,” or intermediaries, and the players are being intermediaries, e- creation of an enhanced sales network in which joined by entirely new customers deal directly with service providers. types of intermediar- business is replacing The result is supposed to be a “frictionless capi- ies, leading to the them with new ones, talism” that reduces both inefficiencies and costs. radical restructuring of The first studies on e-commerce provided industrial and com- sometimes even contradictory predictions about the impact it mercial networks. would have on intermediaries. Some suggested bolstering the number that the Internet would kill them off, while others THE INFORMATION of network players. concluded that their role would become more ECONOMY: IMPACT important than ever. Evans and Wurster (1997) ON CORPORATE pointed to a critical aspect of the e-business revo- STRATEGY lution: that the possibility of dissociating the physical flow of products and related information ew forms of commerce provided by the offers a wealth of new opportunities for reshuf- Internet represented less than 1 percent fling and reconfiguring the relationships among N of overall retail sales in the United all the participants in the value chain-suppliers, States in 1999. Nevertheless, millions are buying distributors, retailers, customers. We contend that goods and services online from work or home predictions of the imminent demise of intermedi- daily, and millions more are communicating by aries are premature, reflecting both a failure to means of these same open, universal electronic analyze the variety and importance of intermedi- systems. This rise in electronic connectivity is ary functions and, more important, the lack of an arguably the most important driver of the Infor- overall strategic view assessing the costs of ser- mation Revolution. vices intermediaries provide in the context of Over the past few years, most companies their perceived value to clients and customers. have focused on adapting their operations in Understanding the impact of e-commerce on response to the new information technology (IT). intermediaries requires an analysis of how the But even though such changes have been wide- tasks and functions of traditional economic actors spread, corporate managers-and not just those are being reformulated and rebuilt. Electronic in high-tech industries or telecommunication retailing, or e-tailing, has been a frontier for the firms-must continue to redefine their strategies development of e-commerce. By examining tradi- as the impact of e-commerce widens. For compa- tional functions provided by intermediaries in nies in virtually every industry, this means con- Disintermediation in Question: New Economy, New Networks, New Middlemen 55 ducting an ongoing reevaluation of their position extensive store ownership or traditional franchise in the value chain. arrangements. Optical scanners in each store and a centralized IS at headquarters monitor young The Strategic Importance customers’ buying trends. By collecting real-time of the Information Value Chain data at the source, Benetton can retain the ben- efits of decentralization while patrolling the rap- Information has become an ever more important idly changing preferences of its famously fickle component of a firm’s value chain. The tremen- teenage customer base. dous increase in information resources and con- 3. Firms can create special long-term nectivity available to businesses can provide ma- relationships with customers and establish jor strategic advantages, which in turn contribute more efficient retention programs. The al- to the emergence of the novel intermediary func- most one-on-one perspective enabled by Net- tions illustrated later. These advantages include: based commerce offers many ways to strengthen 1.Firms can better organize and control customer retention. Amazon.com, the Internet logistics while enhancing customer service. bookseller, illustrates how firms can use informa- In a highly competitive market, Federal Express tion about customer preferences to develop a has created a first-mover advantage, drawing on variety of programs that encourage customer the value of information its market provides by loyalty and retention, thereby creating a new and adding a tracking system for clients. The com- potentially powerful form of connection between pany created a huge database, integrating some the retailer and customer. two million packages shipped daily. It also tracks 4. Firms can use the Net to obtain better clients, trucks, and planes and provides interac- control over their retail networks and more tive features for clients. This integrated informa- contact with end users. General Motors is using tion and logistics system provides an important the Net to increase its control over the semiauto- added value for the client and a key competitive nomous dealer networks that have traditionally differentiating element for FedEx. At the same wielded considerable power at the retail level. By time, the database allows for better control of using its Web site to implement a more central- services at each step of the process. ized strategy, GM is forging direct links to cus- 2. Direct access to customers enables tomers at the expense of the dealer’s power. GM fh-ms to adapt products and services more can choose the dealer closest in physical proxim- rapidly to demand. Benetton, the global pur- ity to the Internet customer and have that dealer veyor of fashionable knit clothing for teens and contact the customer via email or by telephone to young adults, has built a top-rate real-time infor- consummate the sale. This system enables the mation system (IS) to handle physical and logisti- company to: cal relationships. The system has enabled the l begin to optimize the “relationship” func- firm to maintain strong controls while forgoing tion with customers and create a database that helps develop other direct contacts with them, thereby building relationships and loyalty; and Figure 1 l shift power from dealers to strengthen the Cybermediariesand Their Related Functions overall retail network, directing business among dealerships to optimize network functioning. From Intermediaries to Cybermediaries Aggregating demand and wholesale price for house- The move from traditional intermediaries to the * Aggregating suiply and traditional online suppliers new “cybermediaries” initially requires an ap- proach that breaks down the sales transaction Trust l Institutionally backed brand or guarantee-based confi- into its constituent elements and functions. When dence (eTrust: “Building a Web you can believe in” carried out either directly or via a third-party refers to the companies that have subscribed to deon- intermediary, four key functions make exchanges tology respecting a person’s private life) easier, cut the costs of carrying out the sales l Guaranteeing purchases (Amazon: “Hello! Shopping at transaction, and improve responsiveness to cus- Amazon.com is 100 percent secure--guaranteed!“) tomer needs. These four functions are: 1. Aggregation. The aggregated demand of Facilitation l Easy payment and logistics (Auto-by-Tel, E’Trade) buyers by a single intermediary, or the aggrega- l Clients fix price “levels” and unsold inventories (Priceline, Webhouse) tion of several suppliers by a distributor, are alter- I I natives to the situation in which each buyer must 1 &chiG [ l Web portals and on-site selections (AOL, Yahoo!) find a direct source of goods and each producer l Auctions (e-bay, iBazar, S/R auction) I must sell products directly to individual custom- ers. This aggregate function cuts transaction costs 56 BusinessHorizons / March-April2001 and favors economies of scale, thereby reducing e-tailing. The following three examples illustrate the asymmetry of negotiating clout between buy- a number of trends in the “new” intermediation: ers and sellers. 1. reorganizing networks by substitution; 2. Trust.Intermediaries can also provide a 2. disintermediation as the vector for creating guarantee and protect buyers (or sellers) against new types of business; and oppo~nistic and/or manipulative actions. This 3. replacing the existing supply chain with function further lowers transaction costs-particu- novel forms of reintermediation. larly important in the anonymous world of e- commerce, where mechanisms assuring confi- Reorganizing try Substitution: Amazon.com dence in the retailer, co~dentiali~, and security are not yet fully established. A related develop- Since mid-1995, the cyber bookstore Amazon.com ment is the growth of “reputation managers”- has been selling books directly via the Internet, programs that can be external (a Web site dedi- substituting direct customer contact for transac- cated to offering customer and expert opinion on tions that previously involved, perhaps, “the sites, products, and services) or internal (book bookstore around the corner.” It has gained a reviews and readers’ ratings on Amazon.com). respectable percentage