UC Hastings Scholarship Repository
Hastings Alumni Publications
4-1-2001 Hastings Community (Spring 20001) Hastings College of the Law Alumni Association
Follow this and additional works at: http://repository.uchastings.edu/alumni_mag
Recommended Citation Hastings College of the Law Alumni Association, "Hastings Community (Spring 20001)" (2001). Hastings Alumni Publications. 109. http://repository.uchastings.edu/alumni_mag/109
This is brought to you for free and open access by UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Hastings Alumni Publications by an authorized administrator of UC Hastings Scholarship Repository.
. ' HASTING ~ HASTINGS
LETTER TO ALUMNI FACULTY NOTES Dean Mary Kay Kane Write on Legal Education; Its Past and FlHure
AALS PRESIDENTIAL CELEBRATION
CAMPUS NOTES • Dean Kane Elected AALS President • Debra Holcomb Named Alumni Director m ON THE COVER : • Election 2000 at Hastings FOR THE BENEFIT Alumnus of the Year PhiliP M. Knox, Jr. (49); • Hon. William Channell Steps Down From 2000-2001 Hasl i ngs Alum ni Associa tion President OF THE COLLEGE Hastings Board Wain M. FishblHn ('81); and Nicholas G. Moore ('67), • Fishburn, Freitas Assume Alumni, 1066 Chairman, Pricewaterhol THE 17TH MATHEW O. Alumni Events TOBRINER MEMORIAL • Orange County Chapter Holiday LECTURE Boat Parade Presented by Gabrielle Kirk McDonald, • Board of Governors Faculty Luncheon Retired President of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia CLASS NOTES FOUNDER' S DAY • Eric Schneider ('62) Leads Baltimore Alumnus of the Year; Philip M. Knox, Jr. (49) Law School Speaker; icholas G. Moore ('67), Chairman, • Bush Names Ann Veneman ('76) Priceu'aterhouseCoopers Agriculture Secretary • Jeff Lau ('77) Is Hawaii's Honorary Consul General to Belgium II AS TIN G S LETTE R TO ALUMN I SPRING 2001 [Ed. Note. In January, Dean Kane was in 1924 the AALS adopted standards inducted as the President of the Association providi ng that a school must ha ve at lea t of American Law Schoo ls (AALS), the one full- time teacher per 100 studen ts! national law school organization. What (6) Perhap not unrelated to cla s size, follows are excerpts fro m her inaugural at the turn of the last century, law faculty, address .} even in univer ities, typically were paid not by sa lary but by student fees. Indeed, it has his year marks the first of the new been reported that the coll ections in law II century. It thus seems an li brarie of many schools often consisted of appropriate time to stop and to the books owned by the fac ulty members. take stock of just how far legal education and (7) Finally, the la w professori ate in those law schools have come in the past 100 yea rs, ea rl y years was drawn almost excl usively as well as to reflect on the question of what from the practicing ba r, and legal legacy we want to leave for those in legal scholar hip was not a job requirement for education when the 22nd Century unfolds. law professors. The predominant form of We live in a fast-paced world, with scholarship that did exist was found in almost daily changes and challenges raised the typewriter (the ea rl y 20th Century's treatises, often written by judges. by technology and globalization. The task technological innovation), which allowed of determining how to adapt or shape our the substitution of a stenographer fo r the It i aga inst that background that the teaching and scholarly missions in this longhand copyist in most law offices, AAL was formed in 1900 with 30 charter changing world will not be an easy one. destroying the demand for apprentices. member law schools (of which Has tings Inspiration for how much can be Studen ts generall y could attend la w was one). They came together with the accomplished, however, can be taken from school with only a high chool educati on; object of improving legal education in a brief look at the state of legal education no undergraduate degree was required. America. And what improvements have at the turn of and in the early years of the And, of course, there wa no ge neral occurred through the years! 20th Century in contrast to where we are entrance examination; an open admissions Formal legal education and the today. Consider the following. system prevailed. graduate school model as a predicate for (4) Although a 1907 report notes that entry to the profession is the sine qua non (1) In 1901, law-school training as a 93 of the then-existing law schools we re of the modern American legal profession. prerequisite for entry to the profession was affiliated with a unive rsity, the connecti on Indeed, it is now being looked to by other not required by any state; applicants for wa only nominal. University law schools countries, which are in the proce s of the bar could obtain their education either generall y operated independently; indeed, examining their own legal training systems. in school or in a law office. they typicall y we re required to be totally Further, although the law school (2) In 1900, there were 102 law schools self-su pporti ng. population has grown from the 19,567 dispersed across 33 of our then 46 states, (5) As to the clas room, in the early studen t in 1910 to the more than 125,184 with a total student population of 12,516, 1900 there we re ongoing debates about the in 1999-2000, the number of law school and with part-time law schools dominating content of legal education, with lectures applicants still far exceeds the n umber of by a three-to-one margin. Indeed, from 1890 and recitations vying with the case method places avail able in law schools. Thus, law to 1910 there was an explosion of new law as the preferred method of instruction. school admissions remain very competitive, schools, from 61 to 124, with the greatest There was no ag reement on the place in with high academic achievement in growth found in night-division schools, the curriculum for courses focused on undergraduate schools, as well a which expanded by 350%, from 10 to 45. teaching skills, such as drafting pleadings performance on the LSAT, serving as (3) The law student population grew and interviewing clients. Further, the then important guideposts to law school entry. ove r 300% during the sa me period, from growing prevalence of the Langdellian The professoriate and the relationship 4,518 in 1890 to an astonishing 19,567 in case-method of instruction allowed for of law schools to the universities of which 1910, revealing a clear move away from the large classes and large student/ faculty they are a part also have changed apprenticeship model to more formal ratios. As a point of interest, in 1895 dramatically over the course of the last trai ning. This move to law-school training Harvard had a student/ facu lty ratio of century. All law schools now benefit from was spurred in part by the development of 40/ 1, which by 1925 had grown to 78/ 1, and the ongoing efforts of a fu ll- time facul ty, . 1 · . HASTING ompl mented by part-time faculty better meet the demand of the greate t trength . But the fact that we offering \'ariou . pecialized or advanced marketplace - both the marketplace for embrace in th cla room and in the lega l la ses. }.. (an ' chools share joint faculty tudents and the marketplace for lawyers. literature so many tyles and intere t ,\\'lth appOll1tmen t with other department in For example, it has been suggested that more competing for our attention in the their uni\'er itie . Today's full-time law over the course of the next century we future, sugge t that now w uld be an faculty are expected to engage in opportune time to take tock and to may see the development of orne two cholarship, and their credentials and evaluate what i at the core of tho e two year degree programs, and, moving to the training are such that interactions within functions and is likely to remain so and oppo ite end of the spectrum, there may their uni\'er ities now are common. Indeed, what may be u ceptible to change or faculty tenure i granted by the university, be an increased focus on developing more development as we adapt to the usi ng tandards generally applicable specialized training within existing three challenges ahead. throughout the university. year JD programs. Although participants The serious examination of our The curriculum and teaching in the 21st necessarily offered different visions on teaching and scholarl y missions is a Century law school also are dramatically the vari ous aspects of legal training that daunting task. But we all chose legal different. Although the case method still may evolve, everyone ultimately eemed to education as our professional path. We occupies a place of prominence, the agree that two things were driving much have the lu xury of academic freedom and development of clinical legal education in of the pressure for change: (1) the the joy of the classroom. We are blessed the pa t 30 years has added an entirely new technological revolution we are with the ability to pursue our ideas and and ubstantial dimension to the upper research as we wi h. The chance to spend witnessing, and (2) the increasing class curriculum. Similarly, there has been a some time thinking about what we do, why interconnectedness of the world fl ow ing trend away from large lecture classes to we do it, and how we can do it more from globali za ti on. Technological small speciali zed courses. The result has effectively is an opportunity not to be been an explosion of seminar offerings, revolution and globalization are here to missed. Thus, I hope that this year will spur all owing the students to develop their stay, and it is our obligation to carefully a robust dialogue and encourage the kind writing skills and to explore topics in depth and analyticall y evaluate how these two of collegial debate and sharing of ideas under the supervision of individual faculty forces ca n and should affect our teaching among faculty that is the ideal of our members. Curricular expansion ha and our scholarship. In this way, we will be learned profession. extended to courses focusing on the in a position to control how our legal intersection of law with the variou social education system ultimately evolves, science and the di tinct movement to rather than simply reacting to the forces apply the approaches of other disciplines, about us. such as economics and anthropology and It is not enough simply to say that we psychology, to the examination of legal can use technology to perform our teaching problems. In numerous schools, and research tasks more efficiently or for concentrations in specialized fields are Mary Kay Kane wider audiences. Those possibilities offered for those students who elect to Dean certainly are real and exciting. The follow them. In short, the curriculum of question, however, is how can these today is far richer in both content and style developments enhance what we do than that of the ea rl y 1900s. qualiratively? Globalization trends require We have come far, but what doe the similar thoughtful analys is, both to future hold? What do we want legal determine how they mayor should impact education of the 21st Century to be each of us internally in the way in which remembered for? we develop our courses and train our As we celebrated our entry into the students, as we ll as to consider how they new millennium this past year, the future may open up entirely new opportunities for of legal education was a topic addressed in scholarly exchange and shared knowledge. everal high profile events, from circuit I am not suggesting that there should judicial conference to the ABAS meeting be a single vision adopted with regard to in London this past July. Leading members either law school teaching or legal of the bench, bar, and academy offered scholarship. The gains of the last century intere ting vision of what the next on both fronts reflect a healthy broadening century might hold. Among the general of what i entailed in obtaining a legal education and what it means to be a legal ob ervations made was that there will be cholar. The fact that the legal academic increa ed diversification in the delivery of profes ion is not monolithic is one of its legal education by individual school to 2 II AST I NGS CAMPUS NOTES Dean Kane Installed As AALS President ean Mary Kay Kane bega n her yea r's term as III President of the A sociation of American Law Schools in January 2001 at the AALS annual meeting in San Francisco. She is the Association's 99th President. Dean Kane delivered her in augural address at the Association's House of Represe ntatives on Jan uary 6, speaking on the topic of progress in legal education. (See the Dean's Letter, page 1, for more from her talk.) The conference was attended by some 3,500 law faculty from across the nation and fe atured more than 90 programs on a va riety of iss ues applicable to law faculty in their roles a teachers, scholar, and citizens. Photos from At the AA LS HOtL se of Representatives meeting where Dean Kane assumed the presidency, she the celebration appear on pages 22 and 23. appears at the podilLm with Elliott MiLstein of America n University, the 2000 AA LS President Debra Holcomb Named Alumni Director astings' new Director of Alumni Relations is Debra mHolcomb, who started at her post in October 2000. She previously served as Director of Law Alumni Relations at Golden Gate University, where she developed that school's first Alumni Relations program and worked extensively with alumni volunteers. She received a BA degree in English from the University of Connecticut in 1990 and later earned a master's degree in education in 1992 from Plymouth State College in New Hampshire, where her studies focused on higher education administration. She replaces Judy Lane, who assumed a new position as Director of Special Events and Protocol at UC San Diego in the summer of 2000. A ilLmni Director Debra HoLcomb · 3 HASTINGS ELECTION 2000 ndecision 2000," a panel ponsored by the Office of the political and election law, and Joseph Remcho of Remcho, Johan en Academic Dean and Hastings Constitutional Law & Purcell of San Franci co and Sacramento, a firm specializing in Quarterly, played to a full house in the Louis B. Mayer public policy and election law. The event brought c verage on Lounge on O\'ember 16. Professors Ashutosh Bhagwat, David KGO-TV and intensified an already steady stream of local and Faigman, Reuel chiller, and Vik Amar, who erved as moderator, national media inquiries on the intricacies of constitutional law were joined by Adjunct Profe sor James utton of Nielsen, and election-related issues. Merksamer, Parrinello, Mueller & Naylo r, a firm focusing on A Channel 7 TV camera records the panel. "Indecision 2000" panelists Faigman, chiller, Bhagwat, Amar, Remcho, and Sutton. On November 14, Professor Vik Amar prepares for an inter view with Phil Matier, center, of the Chronicie/Channel4. Left: Professor Joel Paul was among faculty inter viewed following the Presiden tial election. Here he talks with linda Yee of KRON-TV on December 8 about the Fl orida upreme Court' decision calling for a ma n ual recou n t of votes. Righ t: Professor Vik Amar speaks with Grace Provenzano of Bay TV on ovember 9. 4 HA S TING S HA I G BOA D LE D R HON. WILLIAM CHANNELL RETIRES ustice William Channell retired from the Has ting when the Coll ege was located in the California Building at J Board of Directors upon the expiration of his 12-yea r 515 Van Ness Avenue. term this last O ctober. His leadership kill deftly guided He wa named to the tate' appell ate bench by Governor the College's direction in the pas t, and his influence wi ll remai n George Deukmejian in 1984. Before Governor Ronald Reaga n clearly in evidence a Hastings pursues its future age nda, sa id appointed him to the Contra Costa Superior Court in 1970, he Dean Mary Kay Kane. practiced law in Alameda and Contra Co ta Countie . He wa Appointed to the Boa rd in 1989 for a I2-year term by named "Trial Judge of the Year" in 1977 by the Alameda-Contra Governor George Deukmejian, Justice Channell was elected to Costa Lawyer Association. three terms as Vice C hair of the Board (1995-1997) and also se rved as a member of the Board's Finance Committee. He made an enduring contribution when he se rved as Chair of the Board's Educational Policy Committee in 1994. In that capacity he oversa w the formulation of Ha ting , successfull y completed 2000 Long-Range Plan, culminating in the upgrad ing of College facilities and the augmentation of endowments for Distinguished Professorsh ips. Additionally, Justice Channell chaired the Educa ti onal Poli cy Committee in 1999, overseeing the development of the next planning phase, Has tings' 2007 Long-Range Plan. "He always has brought an admirable combination of sound judgment, steady leadership, wit, and civility to bea r on the Board' deliberations, and hi pre ence wi ll be greatl y missed," said Dean Kane, who added that "hi contributions are manifest in the College's 2000 Long-Range Pl an and will endure as the 2007 Long-Range Plan is implemented during the course of this decade." Justice C han nell, a retired Judge of the state's First District Court of Appeal, graduated from Hastings in 1949, jjHe always has brought an admirable combination of sound judgment, steady leadership, wit, and civility to bear on the Board's deliberations ••• " 5 . HAT I G Alumni Volunteers Assume Leadership Posts: Wain Fishburn Heads Alumni Association - Robert Freitas Is 1066 Foundation President n June, Wain Fishburn of an corporate governance iss ue and is a law school, he clerked with O regon I Diego began a one-yea r term a founder of the International Forum for Supreme Court Ju ti ce Ralph Holman. the 6th President of the Has tings Corporate Director . He also has been At Has tings, Freitas se rved as a Note Alumni A ociation. A 1981 graduate of active with the UCSD CONNEC T and Comment Edi tor ~ r the Hast ings Law the law chool, Fishburn over the yea rs has program in entrepreneurship, having Journal and also ea rned membership in made contribution to Has tings on many served as the President of the CO N EC T O rder of the Coif. ince graduating, he fronts, including hi ervice since 1985 as a San Diego Tech nology Fi nancial Forum. often has voluntee red his time to help member of the Alumni Association's Board Additionall y, he has served as a Director of benefit his alma mater. In addition to hi of Governors, his se rvice ince 1991 as a involve ment in va rious member of the Ha ting activities of the an 1066 Foundation's Boa rd Diego Alu m ni of Trustees, he ha been C hapter, as a longtime a longtime cl ass age nt Has tings 1066 for his C lass of 1977 and, Foundation member, more recently, he helped and as a representative co-chai r that cl a s's ve ry for the College's successful major gift firm wide soli citation campaign to help program. In addition, refu rbish and name a he has served on new classroom in everal committees for nodgrass Hall in honor both the Association of the C lass of 1977. He and College, including also has served a Has tings' Has ting' repre entati ve Commencement at Orrick's Silicon Speaker election Valley office in Committee and on a Wain Fishburn Bob Freitas conjuncti on with the th ree-member panel law school's firm wide that recently selected soli ci tati on prog ram. Has tings' new Director of Alu mni the Burnham Institute and is active in Not withstanding hi demanding Relation s, Debra Holcomb. numerous other community orga ni za tions. schedule as both an Orrick partner and a Fi hburn practices wi th Cooley He i admitted to prac tice before both the very acti ve Hastings volunteer, Freitas also Godward's San Diego office, which he A rizo na and Califo rnia bars. has taken time to participate in a va riety of joined as a fo undi ng pa rtner in 1992. His In October, Bob Freitas, a 1977 graduate other civic and bar-related activities. These practice emphasizes general re presentation of Has tings, took ove r as the new President include his memberships on important of high-growth tech nology and other of the Has tings 1066 Foundation. He is an Ameri ca n Bar Associati on sections and operating companies, which range f rom in tell ectual property and litiga tion partne r committee - the ection of Intell ectual tartups to publicly held corporations. H is with Orrick, Herrington & Sutcl iffe's Property Law, the Section of Litiga ti on's practice more specificall y focuses on il icon Va ll ey office. H is practice more Insurance Coverage Committee, and the corporate gover nance matter, a we ll a specificall y foc uses on antitrust law, Section of Antitru t Law' Sports, Labor, meraers, acqui ition ,st rategic alliances, insu rance coverage Ii tiga tion, trademark and Entertainment Industry Committee. and intellectual property licensing and law, and complex litigation. From 1991 to Additionall y, he has held directorsh ips with management. He also assi ts his client 1994, he served as the National both the Lo A ngeles Bu iness Council and companie in financing matters, often Coordinating Counsel fo r the the Public Coun el orga niza tion. in \'01 vi ng the place men t of debt and International Insurance Com pa n y's H is term as the 16th Presiden t of the equity securitie . environmental impairment liab il ity Ha ting 1066 Foundatio n will run through Fi hburn lecture frequently on in urance coverage litigation. Right after October 2002. 6 HA S TING S PRC Visitors n November 2, 2000, Dean Kane talked with judges from a civil trial procedure delegation from Shanghai and Jinan, People's Republic of China. The judges heard a presentation from Professor William Dodge entitled "China's Accession to the WTO: Implication for the Judiciary." Their visit was arranged by the National Committee on United States-China Relations. Translator Wendy Locks, at left, is a member of Hastings' Class of 1994. CON FER ENe E S On the Napster Controversy apster, Copyright, and the Barton Bassett (,96), a tax specialist in II Internet" was the topic of a Fenwick & West's Palo Alto office; the conference on November 6 speaker, Fenwick & We t partner and focused on a copyright case against the Napster counsel Laurence F. Pulgram; peer-to-peer software innovator. and Chelsea Doerrie (,01), Editor-in Pictured are Holly Pranger (,01), Chief of the Hastings Communications President of the Internet Technology and Entertainment Law Journal, the Venture Group, co-sponsor of the event; event's co- ponsor. Labor Law in the Public Sector he Public Law Resea rch Institute's fourth annual "Cities on the T Cutting Edge" sy mposium on October 20 addressed public sector labor law. Topics included reconciling coll ective bargaining with unionized public employees with public policies li ke those governing the authority of elected officials to all ocate governmental resource, and the tensions between con titutional and statutory ri ghts and those secured by collecti ve bargaining. Among participants were the speaker, Hon. Mar ha Berzon of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals; Kathleen Bales-Lange, Tulare County Counsel; and Joseph Grodin, John F. Digardi Distinguished Professor of Law and an expert in labor law. The symposia are co-spon ored with the Municipal Law Institute of the League of California Cities. 7 HA TI GS Four Hastings Faculty Gain Tenure Status our facu lty member were granted tenure and the status of full profes orship effective July 1,2000. They are Professor Ashutosh Bhagwat, who teaches ad ministrative law, antitrust, constitutional law, contract, ___ economic regulation, and telecommunicationsj Professor Rory Little, who teaches various topics in criminal law and procedure, and legal ethicsj Professor Shauna Marshall , who teaches in the Civil Justice C linic in the areas of employment, education, and housingj and Professor Radhika Rao, who teaches constitutional law, family law, and property. 65 Club Member Joseph Sweeney 1920 .. 2000 oseph Modeste Sweeney died France v. United Scares, involving ri ghts of he directed the Institutes of Comparati ve O Dec. 11 in Denver. From 1987 to American nationals in Morocco, before Law and Inter-Ameri ca n Law and, in 1997, he was a member of the International Court of Ju tice at The 1966, headed the U.S. delegati on to the Hastings' "65 Club" of eminent scholars Hague. fifth meeting of the Inter-America n and jurists of retirement age who opted to For 11 years, he served as a law Council of Jurist, OAS, in El Salvador. continue practicing their craft. A professor at New York University, where From 1968 to 1977, he was the Dea n of pecialist in torts, conflict of Tulane Law School in New laws, and international law, he O rleans and, in 1975, led the U.S. was the co-author of The delegation to the first Inter Inrernarional Legal Sysrem, one American Conference on of the definitive texts on the Pri va te International Law in subject. Panama. He continued on the Born in Philadelphia, as a Tul ane faculty until 1987. A ch il d he moved to France, where member of the American Law he earned undergraduate and law Institute and the American degree from the University of Societ y of Internati onal Law, he Grenoble. Returning to the was the recipient of an honorary United States in 1942, he joined doctorate from the University the Army and, despite an attack of Lyo n, France. of polio a a youth, served in the He is survived by his wife, 7th Mountain Infantry and later Barbaraj four daughters, Marl y with the Office of trategic Thompson, New Orleans, Anne ervices. After receiving a Marie Barnes, Annapolis, second law degree from Harvard Maryland, Pamela Thompson, in 194 ,he practiced in Burlingame, and Jackie Sa rl o, Washington, D.C. As a legal Denverj a son, Patrick, Palo Altoj advi er to the U. . tate and two grandsons. Department, in 1952 he argued 8 From the Class of 1950 to the Class of 1990, some 350 Has tings alumni and guest attended Reunions 2000 on Se ptember 23 at the College and the St. Francis Hotel on U ni on quare. Campus tours and a recepti on were held aturday afternoon at the College. That evening the C lasses of 1950, 1955, 1960, 1965, 1970, 1975,1980,1985, and 1990 enjoyed a reception, priva te class dinners, and dancing at the t. Francis. 1950 1955 II A) T I G 1960 1965 1970 10 H AST I NGS 1975 1980 -...ol.~ 1985 . 11 · . HA TI GS 1990 1970 classmates Alan Crafts, Mike Ferguson, and Richard Crossman were among those touring the campus on September 23 d/(ring Reunions 2000. 1960 classmates at the reception: Richard Johnson, Gordon Treharne, David Pierson, Paul Hong, Douglas Liechty, and Michael Clepper. 12 HASTINGS "Reflections on the Contributions of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugosla'via" The 17th Mathew o. Tobriner Memorial Lecture Gabrie lle Kirk McDona ~ d, retired President of the Internationa~ Crimina~ Tribuna~ for the Former Yugos~avia, delivered the I7t h Mathew 0. Tobriner Memoria ~ Lecture on SejJtember rB, 2000. Judge McDona~d began her career as a civi~ rights ~ awyer, and it was a commitment to human rights as an internationa~ extension of civil rights that eventually took her to The Hague. As a for mer professor, Judge McDona ~ d relished exp ~ oring new areas of the ~aw and, as a former judge in the United States, she saw the chance to conduct tria ~ s in this new internationa~ forum as a once in a lifetime oP1Jortunity. Her ~ ec t ure recoun ti ng her experiences at the Tri buna ~ took her audience on a journey to witness the birth of the court and exp ~ ore its workings. he Internat io nal C riminal and submitting the indictment to a judge be imposed is Ufe imprisonment. Sentences II Tri bunal fo r the former Yugoslavia who determines whether a prima fac ie case are served in a Scate that has agreed to or ICT Y and its sister institut ion, has been escablished. accept convicted persons. Scates are required the International Criminal Tribunal for to cooperate with the Tribunal, including in Rwanda or IC T R, addressed what Judge THE REGISTRY services both the arrests or detentions. If a State fails to McDonald described as the greatest gap in Chambers and the Prosecutor, similar to a cooperate, the President may report non International Humanita ri an Law: the Clerk of the Court, but with more compliance to the Security Council for fa il ure to enforce the comprehensive legal responsibilities. appropriate action. reg ime enhanced after World War II and designed to protect ba ic human rights National courts have concurrent ''A ll of this was on paper; but in 1993, in during armed conflict. jurisdiction, but the Tribunal, established by reality, the judges were the Tr ibunal. T he Yet when the judges first met in the Chapter Seven powers of the Security court had no premises, no rul es, and no November 1993, the Trib unal ex isted only Council, has primacy, giving it the one in custody," Judge McDonald said. In as UN Security Council Resolu tion 827 authority to request national courts to defer loaned space, over four months, they setting forth its framewo rk. Judge to the competence of the TribunaL The merged elements of common and civil law McD nald fi rst outl ined its three orga ns accused is guaranteed internationally into 129 ru les, producing the first the C hambers, the Prosecutor, and the recognized rights, including the presumption comprehen ive international code of Registry - and thei r workings. of innocence and the right to be present at criminal procedure. They also developed his trial. The maximum penalty that may measures to protect the identity of THE CHAMBERS has three trial witnesses without infringing on the rights chambers of three judges each and an of the accused to a fair trial. "This appeals chamber of five judges. The balancing of the ri ghts of victims and the Yugos lavia Tribuna l, escablished so lely for accused wa an extraordinary chall enge the conflict in the former Yugoslavia, is and a signal accomplishment for a criminal given competence to try persons for serious judicial institution," Judge McDonald violations of the laws or customs of war, explained. genocide, and crimes against humanity. By late 1994, the Pro ecutor had a Trials are conducted by judges without a skeletal staff and had received ufficient jury. The statute directs the judges to adopt supplementary information to present the ru les of procedure and evidence for the first indictment. However, it was not until conduct of the proceedings and the two years after its creation that the protection of victims and witnesses. Tribunal secured custody of an accused. As the case proceeded to the courtroom, it THE PROSECUTOR is independent and triggered the further development of an responsible for initiating the investigation institutional structure: a detention unit 13 II\\TI c,) mllniror d hy the International coherent policy to respond to the carnage only in the former YLlgo~lavi'l, bu t In the CllmmItree of the Red Cross, d tention inflicted in the former Yugoslavia. In n,id- nited tate' as \\'ell , where Judge regulatiom, and an international legal aid 1997, he explained, the Tribunal received McDonald aid ,he (ou nd "so many \\' ho ~\'~tem. en forcemen t su pport when a -mall bu t neithe r understood, nor pe rhap ca red As Presiding Judge for the first fu ll influential group of tates pu hed fo r the about the Tr ibu nal. " tria!, which hega n on Ma y 7, 1996, Judge arre t of indictees. By 1998, a n umber of Judge McDonald desc ribe I the ec urity t-. lcDonald fo u nd the atmosphere almost government we re compleme nting their Council' choice of a court of law to help circu '-like. Opening day brought more newly proactive stance with additional to b ring about and maintain peace a a than 300 members of the media, and the staff and funding. As the n u mber of trials victory fo r the rule of law, the ancho r o( public ga ll ery, epa ra ted from the cl imbed, everal tates ag reed to provide civ il societ y. "In the Tribunal's ea rl y day, COu rtroom by a bull et proof floor-to-ceiling wi tne protect io n and enfo rcemen t of some thought that prosecution of all eged gla s, was fi ll ed to its ISO-sea t capacity. Most sentences. wa r criminal was in con istent with effort reporters, expecting h igh drama, departed Another obliga tion of State to bring peace to the region. Now, the goals when the Prosec utor's case began with a cooperation, the execut ion of arrest of peace and inte rnati onal criminal ju tice are no lo nge r seen as mutuall y ex clu ive; rathe r, they are interdependent and complementary." The Tribunal, now fu ll y functi ning, hold trial and appell ate proceeding on a regular basis. Mo re than 1,000 peopl e from 65 countries are in volved in prosecuting and trying case. International lawyer locate and interview witnesses, and poli ce and fore nsics ex pert exhume grave ite . A coaliti on of N ATO force identifie, trac k , and detains pe rsons indicted and tran fers them to the cou rt. The c ritical contribution of the l\'ibunal has been to foste r a recognition of the need to enforce norms of internati onal law prohibiting massive violati ons of human ri ghts, Judge McDonald sa id. "The Tribunal's judgments do more than dete rmine guilt o r innocence, establish an jad!(e The/ron Henderson of rhe u.s. DiStncr COllrt, Northern District of California, Tobnner Lecturer jltdge Gabnelle Kirk !eDona/d, Mrs. Rosabelle Tobnner, Tobnner Executlt'e Committee Chair GeraLd D. Marcus, hist rical record, and interpret and Dean Mary Kay Kane. international humanitarian law. T hey are evidence of the actual enforcement of professor's da ys -I ong testi mon y - a h istory warrants, "has been honored onl y in its norms. This is the best proof that the lesson o n the Balkan . D uri ng that t rial, the breach by man y State in the former numerous con ve ntions, protocols, and Tribunal hea rd f rom mo re than 125 Yugoslavia," Judge McDonald sa id. resolutio ns affirming human dignity are witne ses and ad m itted ome 300 exhibits. onetheless, she sa id, the Tribunal now is mo re than promises." Many iss ues were decided, including making progress in fulfilli ng its mandate. hearsay (ad missible in the proceedings), Judge McDonald believes that the Tribunal conflicting interest of protecting victims has made a contribution that goes beyond and witne e while pre erving an accused's expanding the juri prudence of right to fair trial, and disclosu re of internati onal humanitarian law, document between the parties. demonstrating that the rule of law is an "From a broader perspective, what is of in tegral pa rt of the peace process, and signal importance i that the trial gave the proving that in ternational criminal justice Tribunal the fir t opportunity to ... is possible. She ees the Tribunal's O utreach demonstrate that international crim inal Program as helping reconciliati on through ju tice \\'a pos ible," Judge McDonald said. weekl y televised u pdates on Tribunal he characteri: ed the Tr ibunal's acti vi ties, broadcasts of proceedings, and creation as imultaneously an act of hope, information exchange bet ween The judge McDonald calked WIth stl!denLI followm g her de~pera[\on, and cynicism by an Hague and the region. The O utreach address. international community lacking a Program also combats m isinformation, not 14 · H AS r l NGS FOUN DER'S DAY HASTINGS' 2001 ALUMNUS OF THE YEAR Philip M. Knox, Jr. Class of 1949 hilip M. Knox , Jr. is the recipient of Directors of the Family Se rvice Agency of the National C hair for the Hastings Annual P the Hastings Alumni Association's G reater Sacramento and President of the Campaign in 1995-96. 2001 Alumnus-of-th e-Yea r Award. Rotary Club of Sacramento. Previously, he Knox has be n acti ve on other fronts at The award is prese nted in recognition of his was the State President of the California the College, a well. His Sacramento Alumni exemplary legal ca reer, as well as his lifetime of Junior C hamber of Commerce and also C hapter named him the C hapters Alumnu se rvice to the profession, to his community, earli er erved as the General Coun el for the of the Yea r in 1997. An ori ginal supporter of and to the law school. Knox currently is of United States Junior C hamber of Commerce. the Attorneys General Forum, he reg ul arl y counsel to the Sacramento law firm of Knox , A member of the Navy Leaaue of the United attends that and other alumni events, such as Lemmon & Anapolsky, having earlier held States, he wa in the U.S. Naval Re erve and the annual Founders Day program. Whats several major po ts with Sears, Roebuck and on ac ti ve duty from [943 to [946. more, he also has been a longtime leader in Company. The e included service from [973 Knox has been a dedica ted alu mnus to promoting class reunion ac tivities and ha to 1980 a Sea rs' Vice President for both of his alma maters. A Director of the been class age nt for his Class of 1949 since the Governmental Affairs in Washington, D.C., California Alumni Association from [997 to class age nt prog ram was initiated in 199 1. In and from 1981 to 1986 as Vice President and 2000, he has remain ed acti ve a a Ha tings sum, Phil Knox has had a ve ry distinguished Corporate General Counsel at Sea rs' nati onal alumni voluntee r. For example, he has been a legal ca reer and has been a most loyal headquarters in C hicago. longtime member of the Hasting [066 supporter of hi alma mater, both at the Knox received his BS in Business Foundation Board of li'ustee and served as chapter level and for the overall benefit of Admini tration from U Berkeley in 1943 the Foundation' President from 1992 to the school. He truly is deserving of this yea rs and earned his JD from Hastings in 1949. In 1994. He also took on the additional role of Hastings Alumnus-of-th e-Yea r Award. addition to his demanding legal career, he has been involved over the yea rs in a va riety of bar-related activities, including se rving on the Conference on Consumer Finance Law and as a founding Director of the American Corporate Counsel Associati on. A life Fell ow of the American Bar Foundation, he also has taken time to share his ex pertise with others by teaching banking and con umer finance law from [987 to the present as an Adjunct Professor of Law at McGeorge School of Law. Knox' civic contributions have been Classes of 1949 and 1937 hel ped celebrate Phili p Knoxs Allimnus-ofthe- Year Award. Left to right are Hon. William numerous. He is Counsel to the Boa rd of H. Phel/)s, Hon. William R. Channel l, Bruce T Cogg ms, Ca rl Howard, Kn ox, Hon. Thomas M. jenkms, Henry C. Todd '37, and Robert V Wink ler. I 5 Addressing Multidisciplinary Practices NICHOLAS G . MOORE '67 As markets become more efficient, pricing performing great s rvice for their client. lobal Chairman, PricewaterhouseCoopers becomes more competitive, and clients They have a re ponsibility to other expect a lot more for a lot Ie s. takeholders - investors, creditor, Thc founder'l DelY fcuund spcuker llt!5 In today's complex marketplace, many regu lato rs - with respect to their audit of . lellOla, C. ?\(oon:. !;Iohal C/Wlrman of projects or tran action requi re the a company' financial tatements. They Prlccwu[erhou.\cCoopers. PHC muinruins a combined kills of tax, accounting, and legal must be independent of their client both prcsencc l11 some 1';0 COIl11rrlC.\ (lnd rerrlWYleS, service. In most cases, clients engage in fact and in appearance, making no 1l'l1h 9.000 IkllTncT5 (l11d (( \wjf of 150.000. eparate professionals and must coordinate inve tments in the clients and making no '\(oorc ycceitcti tl B~ l11 Accounring from their activities, which can be daunting. But management decisions for the clients. \r .\Imy:\ College in \1om,-;u in 1963 (Inti (( we are starting to see that, in many case, Lawyers, on the other hand, must be Jf) trom Hmtings in /(,)67· Hc /ws been a our clients want comprehensive service advocates for their clients. But lawyer do longtlmc 1066 FOlmdution member und ll(ll from a single source: a team approach, with need to be independent of outside influence an curly hucker of (( recend'l complered consultants working together. They are o they can be free to make decisions and cumthllgn W refurbish uncI name a \nodgrall looking for a eamle delivery of services recommendations that are in clients' best Hull .Icmznar room fi))' his c/(L\I. what we believe a multidisciplinary interests. The sole beneficiaries are the clients, practice, as one alternative, can help deliver. Can both types of independence ex ist In an MOp, lawyers work together with in a single bu iness model? Many THE WORLD Is CHANGING non-lawyer profes ionals to provide profe ional services providers, including I'm tating the obvious when I say the worlds service to joint clients, whether in a single my firm, believe they can and support the marketplace is changing, How we do bu iness firm or in a 100 er form of business pu h for multidisciplinary practice that - and what client expect - are far different arrangement. No one i suggesting it' the cross national and profeSSional boundaries. from just a few years ago. More business only solution. But there are many That's the accounting profession' enterprises are building a global presence. In circumstances in which it makes sen e, perspective on independence. addition, technology and the Internet are particularly for a client organization that From the legal perspective, in the nited h lping to remove obstacles presented by has limited project management kills or is States, lawyers presently cannot practice law focused on other priorities, national boundaries. 0 longer is size alone in partnerships or share fees with non important. peed and agility drive todays lawyers. The ABA and most state and city bar succes ful businesses. Many of the giants of MDPs - THE ISSUES associations prohibit such arrangements. At the past are being out-paced by smaller and In many parts of the world, multi the July 2000 ABA meeting, the Commis ion nimbler competitors, particularly those with disciplinary practices have led to a new, on Multidisciplinary Practice - after much di ruptive technologie . Our clients are efficient business model. But in the United study - made a proposal backing MOPs. (l looking for ways to simplify doing busines States, the idea of MOPs evokes strong mention this so that you understand MOP worldwide without increasing risk. As always, negative reactions. What some might are not a wild idea "cooked up" by the Big they demand efficient, competent, and cost de cribe as a heated debate is ongoing Five accounting firms. They are being effective service from all their profes ional between the professional services providers propo ed from within the legal profession.) service providers. and the legal profession over this i sue. But the ABA delegates overwhelmingly The debate seems to be focused on two rejected the proposal, which would have A WORD ON COST-EFFECTIVENESS area: independence and business models. permitted lawyers to form partner hips or All of u -lawyer and profes ional service In the United tates, both regulators and share legal fees with non-lawyers. ome eem providers - have made a very good living our markets worry about the independence convinced that a lawyer' independence over the year, because we had the luxury of of CPA and lawyers. They want assurance cannot be guaranteed with MOP, and operating in a grossly inefficient market. that both will be able to carry out their therefore the public interest would be at risk. But our client are now comparing what' respective obligations. We respect that principle, but [we are also a\'allable, and they have access to more data CPAs who are auditors need to be mindful of that old adage:] "When they say eyer\, day. What was once a \'ery pro perou independent of their client' influences. it's not about money, it always i ." IneffiCIent market i starting to di appear. Their responsibility extends beyond Keep in mind that the bar already has 16 recognized and appr ved situations in which o n the basis that such bans are • Mo re recently, o n-line service also have lawye rs may wo rk for and even be supervised discriminato ry, anti-competitive, and against been attacked by ma n y bars as a dangero us and compensa ted entirely by non-lawye rs European law. I want to em phasize that the threat ro the public. without compromi ing the ir profe sio nal PwC model does not provide all fo rm of integrity. Examples are in-house coun el, legal se rvices. We will provide ervices Virtually every innovatio n in the practi ce g vernme nt lawye r, legal aid atto rney , and whe re our cli ents de mand them, where we of law ver the past 100 yea r, at least initiall y, insurance company lawye rs who repre ent have a core competence, and where we can ha been criticized and ofte n roundly insureds and benefi ciari es. So both suppo rt the highe t level of ervice. We will condemned by the o rganized ba r. And all profession have a big stake in independence concentrate in o ur strategic areas: complex were driven by client demands fo r effi ciency. and erving the public inte rest. The reality is cross-bo rder tran acti o ns, including me rgers MOPs represent the latest in a se ri es of that eve rything ride o n the integrity of the and acquisitions, corpo rate transfo rmation, developme nts going back mo re tha n 100 individual lawyer o r C PA. e-business, and employment law. yea rs that were all essen t iall y market driven We believe that permitting MOPs to and all designed ro m ake legal se rvices mo re operate in the United States can be a win-win THE LEGAL PROFESSION ' S accessible, mo re effi cient, a nd mo re co t situation fo r the legal profe sion and fo r the RESPONSE effective. The ma rket is speaking lo ud and professional service industry. And we believe N o twithstanding the lo ng histo ry of the clea r. It's time fo r the legal professio n to independence can and would be preserved. in volveme nt of lawyers in related and change alo ng wi t h the wo rld marketplace Now to business model s. There is a sense unrelated business activities, the Ame ri can and not end up o n the o ut ide looking in. among some lawyers that fo reign business legal professio n - at least a re presented by Dot.coms may be out of favor, but there models, particularly European m odels, the ba rs and ba r associatio ns - has are companies out there that are ab olutely which approve of and include MOPs, are gene rall y been resistant to change in the sca ry. G o to the m yCFo.com web site. Look not appropriate fo r the U.s. marketplace. Its practice of law. Thi ha been especiall y at the ve nture ca pital financing, the power true that the histories of the two professio ns true when a change threatened to reorder of the board, the depth of management, and in Euro pe and the United State are economic interests within the professio n . the credentials of the service providers. We different. A need existed in Europe in our Nume ro us examples may be cited. trained them all in the legal and accounting "power alleys": taxation, transactio ns, and professio ns. And if you reall y want to be employee benefits. The legal professio n, • At the end of the last century, the frightened, look at their technology particularly in continental Europe, had not eme rgence of the mode rn law firm was backbo ne. They are relentlessly invading developed ufficiently to meet global client condemned by man y in the ba r as the o ur turf (yo urs a nd o ur ). I do n't think they demand. Acco unting firms jumped into a selling o ut of the profe sio n to c rass care whethe r they are percei ved as vacuum. Providing services to o ur clients in comme rcial inte re ts. practi cing law o r accounting, o r as li censed these areas was a natural act fo r us, • So me years late r, the development of in in vestment professio nals, and I don't think particularly in Europe, but clie nt house law de pa rtments by Ame rica n the market cares. everywhere are increasingly demanding corporati ons was ro undly criticized by The ma rket wants speed, quality, and efficient and cost effective services from all m an y prominent bar leade rs as threate ning cost effecti veness. Eithe r we delive r it o r of their professio nal service providers, the professio nal indepe ndence of lawye rs. othe rs will. It's a survival iss ue, and we're in including legal services providers. the boat together. All of the Bi g Five firms have had • In the 1930s, the introduction of group success offering MOP and MOP-like se rvices legal services pl ans also was vigorously attacked by the bar and ultimately o nly in countrie aro und the wo rld. MOPs we re Although ellentially pro/Hinted from approved in Australia in 1994, and the resolved in a se ries of Suprem e Court /)T(n itling legal sen lce.1 In the 1 initcd \t(ltC\ Canadian Bar Association approved them in decisio ns that the bar lost. ruc lS in the MDP Inmnesl thrrmghOlfl 1999. In the UK, co mpetitio n authorities are • In the 1970s, the introduction of paralegals, much of the rClt of thc Horltl, 111 /)elrt expected to recommend lifting the ban on in-house investigators, and other paraprofe - til rOl/gil a nctwork of corrLs/JOndcnt 1m! MOPs an y day now. Surviving prohibitio ns sionals was challenged by many as amounting flrms. The len Ile, Inantled "L({ndHdl " hUI in continental Europe are being challenged to the unautho rized practice of law. more thun ~,()()() latl'ycn 111 40 lOlfntrlCI . . . . 1 7· ... HAT I G FACULTY NOTES PROFESSOR VIKRAM AMAR had PROFESSOR MARGRETH PROFESSOR Jo CARRILLO was publi shed fo ur editori als: 0 "Why We'd BARRETT was selected to se rve on the elected to the Boa rd of lj'ustees of the Law Rather Not Be in Court," San Jose Mercury Editorial Board of the A IPL A Quarterly and Society Association fo r a two-year ews, Nov. 19,2000.0 "Don't Change the Journal, a scholarl y journal published by the te rm, 2001 -2003. Rules of the Game," Los Angeles Times, American Intell ectual Property Law Nov. 26, 2000. "What Are the upremes A sociati on. O In February, she moderated a PROFESSOR DAVID FAIGMAN Up To?" The Daily Journal; American panel entitled "Ethical Obli gations of had published the foll owing: Modern Lawyer, Inc., Nov. 29, 2000. 0 "The Intellectual Property Owners" at a Scie ntific Evidence: The Law and Science of Supreme Court's Equal Protection Ruling conference, Holding Multinati onal Expert Te stimony (2nd ed. 200t) (with Kaye, Does Disservice," San Jose Mercur y News, Corpo rations Responsible U nder aks & Sander). "The Law's Scientific Dec. 17,2000 (with Park). 0 "Judgment International Law, held at the li ege in Revoluti n: Reflections and Ruminati ons Under Pre ure: Bush v. Gore and the as ociation with the American Society of on the Law's Use of Experts in Year Seven upreme Court's Misreading of Article 11 " International Law and the Hastings of the Revolution," 57 Was h. & Lee L. Rev. was the title of an article in the May 2001 International and Comparative Law Review. 661 (2000). i sue of Federa l Lawye r. In October 2000, Professor Faigman In ovember, he was one of four PROFESSOR ASHUTOSH gave a speech entitled "Current Trends in participants in Stanford's Town Hall Meeting BHAGWAT had publ ished the foll owing Expert Testim on y" at the ympo ium on on the Presidential El ection Controversy articl es: 0 "Parking at BART, o r Economic cientific Evidence at Seton Hall held at tanford Law choo!. 0 In and Its Discontents," 4 Green Bag 2d 7 University School of Law in Newark, New connection with the 2000 Presidential (2000).0 " eparate But Equal? The Jersey. 0 In December 2000, he spoke on election, Professor Amar appeared more Supreme Court, the Lower Federal Court, the topic of standards of ad missi bility fo r than 75 times on local or national TV and the ature of the 'Judicial Power,'" 80 sc ientific evidence at a Congressi nal (including M BC and Bay TV, and BC, B. U. L. Rev. 967 (2000). briefing sponsored by the American A B , and CB local affili ates), did cores of Chemical ociety in Wa hington, D.C. 0 interview segments for local and national PROFESSOR GEORGE Also in December, Profes o r Faigman was radio, including multiple NPR program, BISHARAT was an invited speaker on a appointed to a panel of the National and was quoted in some 15 major newspapers panel, "The Ruse of Law: Justice and Academyof ciences to evaluate the and magazine, including the Los Angeles Human Ri ght Under the Palestinian reliability of polygraphs. 0 In January 2001, Times, the San Jose Mercury lews, the San Authority," at the Middle Ea t tudies he wa appointed to the Editorial Boa rd of Francisco Chronicle, the Dallas Morning A sociation annual meeting in O rlando, the Journal of Legal Education. In J 'eus, the Philadelphia Inquirer, the Miami Florida, in ovember. March, at a symposium on DNA profilin g, Herald, and the Seatele Times. he gave a pre entation entitled "The 18 H AS TI NGS Le sons of DNA fo r the Courts" at disc us ion on Bush v. Gore. 0 In May 2001, PROFESSOR EVAN LEE had Brooklyn Law School in New York ity. O he poke to the Na ti onal Academy of published a book review of Rights and At an ABA To rts and Insurance Practi ce Arbitrato rs at its meeting in A tl anta on the Res/)onsibilities by Leon Trakman and Sean Sess ion in San Francisco in March, he gave subject of arbitrati on decision of the U.s. Gati en in 17 Const. Commentary 41 7 (2000). a speech, "Overview o f Recent ase Law Supr me Court in 2000-2001. The talk is to o In November and December 2000, on the (Expert Testimon y)." 0 In April, he gave be published in the Labor Law Journal. ubject of the Presidential electi on, he was the key note address, "The U e and Misu e interviewed numerous time by the medi a, of Science in the La w," at a 1( xics DEAN MARY KAY KANE , including KCBS and KGO radi o, KQ ED Causa tion eminar in Boston sponsored by DISTINGUISHED PROFESSOR radio's "Fo rum With Mi chael Kras n y," Meale y's Publishers. 0 "Expert Sc ientific OF LAW, in March 2001, had published KRON and KPI X television, Bay TV' Testimon y Trends in Federal Prac ti ce" was the 3rd edition of volume 7 of Federal "Take Iss ue" program, and the San Fra ncisco the title of hi speech to the AU-ABA Practice and Procedure (with Wright & Chronicle and Contra Costa Times. Advanced Cour e of tudy in April 2001 at Miller), dealing with indispensa bl e parties, a an Franci co meeting sponsored by A U permissive party joinde r, and interpleade r. PROFESSOR DAVID LEVINE is ABA and the Federal Judicial Cente r. In October 2000, she was appointed by the co-author, with arel tolker, of two C hief Justice William Rehnquist to a articles, "Rampen: Persoonlijke JOSEPH R . GRODIN , JOHN F. three-yea r term as a member of the Aansprakelijkheid en Preventie" and DIGARDI DISTINGUISHED Standing Committee on Practice and "Compensa ting fo r Psychi atric Damage - PROFESSOR OF LAW, had Procedure fo r the United tates Judicial A Pl ea for a Multifacto r Approach," to be published in the N ovembe r 23, 2000, Los Confe re nce. The Committee is published in a book, Ramp en Recht, A nge les Times an op-ed pi ece o n the respo nsible for reviewing and roughly translated as Disas ters and the Law, Florida u preme Cou rt's deci ion in the recommending to the Supreme Court published by Boom Juridische Uitgeve rs, Bush/ Gore electio n entitled "The Court pos ible fede ral rul e amendments Den Haag, and forthcoming in spring 2001. Sifted Through the Iss ue WelL" 0 Hi proposed by the Adviso ry Committee on article, "Wrongful Te rminatio n Law in the Appell ate Rule, Bankruptcy, C ivil Rules, PROFESSOR RORY LITTLE had California Supreme Court: 2000," C riminal Rule, and Evidence. publi hed an article, "The Future of the appeared in 15 Ca l. St. B. Lab. & Federal Death Penalty," 26 Ohio N.U. L. Em plo yment L.Q. 1 (2001). PROFESSOR DANIEL Rev. 529 (2000). Foll owing the Presidential election, he LATHROPE had the foll owing In eptembe r 2000, he presented a talk was a discu sa nt in two NPR "Forum" publications: 0 "Reduce the Impac t of the entitled "Why Not Abolish All Federal programs with Michael Kras n y o n that Alternati ve Minimum Tax," Tax Ideas CjJIl 6 C rime ?" to the annual meeting of the topi c. 0 In February, he gave a talk at the (M ay 2000).0 The A lternative Min imum Federal Bar Associati on in Cleveland, monthly luncheon of the U.s. District Tax: Compli ance and Planning With O hi o. 0 "Law Pr fesso rs a Lawyers: Court in San Francisco on the subject of Analys is (2000-2 and 2001 -1 upplement). Consultants, O f Counsel, and the Ethics of the u .s. Supreme Court's decision in Bush o Selec ted Federa l Taxation Sta tutes and Self-Flagell ati on" was the title of a talk he v. Gore. 0 Also in February, he participated Regu latio ns (2001) .. gave in October to the Legal Ethics as a panelist in a program sponsored by the In O ctober, he gave a peech entitled Sym posium at the South Texa Coll ege of Be nch-Bar-Medi a Committee of the Sa n "Income Tax Developments - Year 2000 Law in Houston. 0 In November, he wa a Francisco Bar Associati on on the subject of and Beyond" at the 2000 Ann ual Meeting presenter at MC LE Legal Ethics the role of the courts and th media in the of the California Tax Bars in San Francisco. Conferences in an Francisco and 2000 Presidential election. 0 In a televised o Professor Lath rope recently wa Oakl and, where he spoke o n criminal interview on ABC affiliate KGO TV on appointed to a three-yea r term as a litiga tion ethic . "Prosecutors a ' hadow February 2, he addressed the topic of member of the Associati on of A merican Agents': ew R ule for Prosecutor employ ment law. 0 At the pring meeting Law chools' Committee on Aud it and Deali ng With C riminal Informan t ," was of the Academ y of Appell ate Lawyers in Associati on Inve tment Policy. the t itle of a December speech to the February in San Francisco, he moderated a C ri m inal Ju tice and Info rmants 19 111\\TI I GS '::\mpn~ium at 'ardo:n La\\' chool in e\\' Federal Practice Program, U .. District PROFESSOR MELISSA It)r\.: It\'. ourt Federal Practice Committee. Q In NELKEN was the author of an arrtcle, In ~ ptemher 2000, Profe sor Little was eptember, he spoke at the ., Magi trate "The Limits of Privilege: The Developing appointed to the American Bar Judges' Workshop (II) at the Federal cope of Federal Psychotherapi t-Patient A sociation' tanding ommittee on Judicial Center in Albuquerque, ew Privileg Law," which appeared in I Ret '. riminal Ju tice tandards for a three-year Mexico, delivering a talk entitl ed "The Litig. 20 (2000). tenT\. 0 He \\'as an invit d participant at 2000 Amendments to the Federal th .. entencing Commission' Discovery Rules." 0" ew Amendment to ROGER C . PARK , JAMES ympo ium on Economic and High-tech the Federal Rules of C ivil Procedure" was EDGAR HERVEY CHAIR IN rime in Wa hington, D.C., in October. the title of his December speech to the LITIGATION , had publi hed his Th roughou t the fall, Profe sor Li ttle American Inns of Court, ouncil Oaks Teachers Manual to ases and Materials provided media commentary on issues of Chapter, in Tulsa, Oklahoma. on Evidence (9th ed. 2000) (with Waltz). constitutional and criminal law and legal He was the c -author, with Professor ethic, including appearances on various ACADEMIC DEAN LEO P. Vikram Amar, of an edito rial , "The radio and network TV news hows, and MARTINEZ conducted a site visit in Supreme ourt'S Equal Prot cti on Ruling was quoted in various newspaper and October for the American Bar Doe Disservice," which appea red in the magazines, including A merican Lawyer, A sociati on at the Wa hington Univer ity an Jose Mercury News on December 17, The ational Law Journal, The Recorder, chool of Law in t. Loui regarding the 2000. 0 He al 0 publi shed the second and the Sacramento Bee. 0 Al o in the fall, establi shment of an LL.M. program in editi on of hi Trial Objections Handbook he was a regular commentator for KCBS Intell ectual Property. 0 In November, he (2001), a 600-page text on obj ctions to radio on legal issues in the Florida electi on was invited to join the Board of Directors evidence and cl osing arguments. 0 controversy. 0 In November, he appeared of newly formed Public Radio Capital, a Professor Pa rk ha forthcoming a parody of as sole guest on Bay TV's "Take Iss ue" show, nonprofit o rga nization establi shed with a Bush v. Gore in Const. Commentary. add res ing the Pre idential election and it half-million dollar grant from the In Februa ry 2001, he was a impact on the federal death penalty. Corporation for Public Broadcasting to commentator on expert testimony at a rai e capital to acquire radio broadcast symposium, "New Per pective in PROFESSOR RICHARD frequencies for public radio station. 0 In Evidence, Experts, Empirical tudy, and MARCUS, HORACE O . COIL January 2001, in an Francisco, he Economic Analysis," sponsored by the ('57) CHAIR IN LITIGATION , had presented a paper at the Association of University of Virginia in C harlottesvill e. publish d an article, "Benign Neglect American Law Schools' annual meeting Reconsidered," 148 U. Pa. L. Rev. 2009 (2000). entitled "The Infringement of Intellectual PROFESSOR JOEL PAUL had In July 2000, Professor Marcu Property Rights and the Intentional published: 0 "Executive Agreements" in delivered three speeches in Toky : Injury Conundrum." The paper wil l be Encyclopedia of the American Constitution "Developments in U . . Discovery Practice" published by the Connecticut In surance 941 (Levy & Karst, ed .,2000). 0 "Political at Keio niversity; "Development in U. . Law Journal. 0 Also in January, he was Corruption a an International Offense," CIa Action Practice" at Chuo University' elected Chair of the A sociation of 2000 Proceedings of the 94th Annual Downtown Campus; and "Myths and American Law Schools' Section on Meeting of the American Society of Realitie of U .. Litigation" at Chuo Insurance Law. 0 That same month, in International Law, 57. 0 "Cultural Univer ity, Tama City. 0 "The 2000 San Franci co, he was a focus group Resistance to Global Governance," 22 Amendments to the Federal Di covery facilitator for the Association of Mich. J. In t'l L. 1 (2001).0 "Is G lobal Rule " was the title of a talk he presented American Law chools' elf Study on Governance afe for Democracy?" 1 U. Chi. at the .. Magi trate Judges' Workshop (1) Professional Develo pment Programs. In J. Int'l L. 263 (2000). "E ays on the at the Federal Judicial Center in Portland, February, he participated in an ABA site ature of International Trade Law," 94 Oregon, in July. :lIn Omaha, ebra ka, in vi it for the reaccreditation of the Am. J. Int'l L. 206 (2000) (book review). July, he pre enteJ a peech, "Di covery Fordham University Law choo! in New In November 2000, Profes or Paul wa Practice in the e\\' Millennium," to the York Cit y. appointed to the Editorial Board of Global 20 HA S TIN GS Juri st, an online publication of Berkeley combating impunity at the Amnesty December, he made a presentation Electronics Press. 0 In January 2001, he Inte rnational Lawyers' Meeting in San entitled "The Year in Review and the gave a talk entitled "Cultural Resistance to Francisco. 0 In November, in Boston, she Bush/ Gore Legislative Agenda: Recent Global Governance" at the Coll oquium on presented a talk entitled "The Pinochet (and Future) Developments Affecting Internati onal Law and Politics at Boalt Case and Universal Jurisd iction" at the Nonprofit Organizations and Thei r Hall, University of Califo rnia, Berkeley. 0 Universal Jurisdiction: M yths and Realities Donor" to the San Francisco Jewish "Globali za tion and Race" was the title of Conference at New England Law School. 0 Community Endowment Fund his talk to the International Law "Corporate Accountability in an Era of Professional Subcomm i ttee. Association Meeting at Pepperdine G lobalizati on" was the title of her talk at University ch 01o f Law in Malibu in the National Lawyers G ui ld Convention in WILLIAM SCHWARZER , January. 0 Profes o r Paul co-chaired a Boston in November. In January, in San THOMAS E. MILLER conference, "Holding Multinational Francisco, she presented a speech to the DISTINGUISHED PROFESSOR Corporatio ns Responsible Under AALS Section on Internati onal Law OF LAW, presented the foll ow ing International Law," held at Has tings in entitled "The Massachusetts-Burma Case speeches: 0 "New Developments in C lass association with the American Society of and the Turn to Corporate Accountability." Actions" to an AU-ABA course in San Internati onal Law and the Hastings o Also in January, she attended the Franci co in August 2000.0 "Management International and Compara ti ve Law Internati onal Law Association West of Expert Evidence" to a Federal Judicial Review in February, at which he spoke on meeting in Malibu, delivering a speech Center Video Panel in Washington, D.C, this subject as well. 0 In March, Professor entitled "Ethnic Cleansing and Genocide: in October. 0 "Federal Jurisdiction" to a Paul spoke on the current state of Lessons From the Latin-American Cases." Law Clerks' Institute Lecture at scholarship in international economic law o In March, she spoke on lessons of the Pepperdine Law School in Malibu in at the Annual Meeting of the American Pinochet case at an American University January 2001. 0 "Reforming Class Actions Society of International Law in conference on the Pinochet case in in Antitrust Litigation" to an ABA Washington, D.C Washington,D.C Antitrust Section Meeting Panel in Maui, In 2000, Profe ssor Roht-Arriaza Hawaii, in January. 0 "Recent Supreme PROFESSOR NAOMI ROHT received a resea rch and writing grant from Court Decisions" to the American ARRIAZA had published the foll owing: 0 the MacArthur Foundation Program on As ociation of University Women in San '''Soft Law' in a 'Hybrid' Organization: The Global Security and Sustainability and a Francisco in February. 0 "Managing Expert International Organization for resea rch grant from the United tates Evidence" to an AU-ABA course in San tandardization" in Co mmitment and Institute of Peace. 0 In 2001, she was Francisco in April. Co mpliance: The Role of Non- Binding appointed to the National Advisory Norms in the International Legal Sys tem (D . Committee to the U.S. Represe ntative to PROFESSOR WILLIAM K.S. Shelton ed., 2000). 0 ' ~mnesty and the the Commission for Environmental WANG had published Insider Trading ICC " in International Crimes, Peace, and Cooperation under the Environmental (2001 Supplement). 0 During fall 2000, he Human Rights: The Role of the Supplemental Agreement to the North was a Visiting Professor at Brooklyn Law International Criminal Court (D. Shelton American Free Trade Agreement. School in New York C ity. ed., 2000). 0 "The Pinochet Precedent," 35 New Eng. L. Rev. 311 (March 200t). PROFESSOR STEPHEN Professor Roht-Arriaza made the SCHWARZ in November prese nted a following speeches: 0 In Ju ly 2000, in paper, "Federal Taxation of Investments Guatemala C ity, Guatemala, she presented by Nonprofit Organizations: Beyo nd a a talk entitled "The Pinochet Case: Lessons Primer," at an invitational conference for Guatemala," sponsored by the Center entitled Taxing C haritable Investments for Legal Action on Human Rights and hosted by the National Cente r of American University. 0 In September, she Philanthropy and the Law at New York made introducto ry remarks on the topic of University School of Law. 0 In 2 1 Ii\ 11 G S Additional Gift and Tax Savings Opportunities Available to Benefit Both Donors and Hastings II- YOLR ESTATF- A D TA X-PLANNI G objectives include making a charitable gift, receiving an income for li f ,and btaining tax benefit, then you may want to consider one of the gift vehicles described below, all of which are now ava il able through Hastings and admin istered by Uc. The e gift vehicle are part of a family of gifts sometimes called "life-income gifts" or "planned gifts." Thi terminology is u ed because these gifts require advance planning - with the assistance of tax and legal counsel- before they are incorporated as a part of y ur estate plan. uch planned gifts made to Hasting will provide continuing upport that will help enable the law school to maintain it tradi tion of excell ence. The following planned gifts are available. 1. Charitable Remainder Unitrust plans. The donor is thus able to make a gift now and u e the in come tax charitable deduction when he or she is in a hi gher tax This is a trust that pays the income beneficiary a se t percentage bracket, deferring annuity pay ments until those years when the of its net a set value each year. The trust is revalued annuall y. beneficiary may need the income more. The amount of each An income tax deduction is all owed for the value of the remain payment that wi ll be tax-free depends on the donor's life ex der interest of the trust that is designated for a charity. pectancy and the appreciati on in the gift assets. The charitabl e A variation of this trust is the "net income" unitrust, which dis contribution is the face value of the gift less the actuarial value tributes the trust's net income, up to a set percentage of the an of the deferred annuity. The minimum donation is $10,000. nual market value of the trust assets. This protects the tru t cor pus from ero ion due to high income payments. The e separately inve ted trusts may be established with a mini 5. Pooled Income Funds mum gift of $100,000; additional contributions ca n be made to a These funds are made up of the donati ons of many donors, unitru t at any time. which are combined for investment purposes. There are two pooled income funds that are operated by the Rege nts of the Uni ve rsity of California for this purpose. These funds pay the 2. Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust donor or his/her designated beneficiary a pro rata share of the Thi plan pays a fixed dollar amount to the donor or his/ her particular pooled income fund ea rnings each year for life. designated beneficiary for life. A charitable contribution deduc Income is taxed as ordinary income, and a charitable deduction tion is all owed for the value of the trust's remainder interest. is all owed for the value of the remainder interest. Pooled income Like the unitrust, an annuity trust may be established with a funds may be started with as little as $5,000, and additional con minimum gift of $100,000. Annuity trusts cannot accept addi tributions of $1,000 or more may be made at any time. tional con tribu tions. Donors to charitable remainder trusts and pooled income funds 3. Charitable Gift Annuity may make a gift using appreciated property without having to in cur capital ga ins taxes. The trust can sell those assets and purchase This pays a fixed annuity for the life of the income beneficiary. other higher-yielding assets, also without capital ga ins taxes. Capital The rate is based on the age of the income beneficiary on the gai ns on donations to gift annuities are usuall y distributed over the date of gift, and part of each payment is usually tax-exempt. The annuitant's life expectancy. amount of the cha ri table contribution deduction is basically the difference between the va lu e of the gift (cash or the value of se Calculation that illustrate some of the benefits of various li fe-in curities or real estate) and the valu e of the annuity. Gift annu come arrangements and more detail ed information about all of ities may be established with 10,000 or more. these life-income plans are available on request. 4. Deferred Payment Gift Annuity Univer ity of California Hastings College of the Law Like the gift annuity, this plan al 0 pay a fixed amount, but the 200 McAllister St. first payment is deferred for a year or more from the date of the San Francisco, CA 94102 aift and i u ually timed to coincide with retirement or other Office of College Relati ons (415) 565-4615 24 ···· II AS TI NGS 25 II AS T I G Alumni/ Student Picture Gallery NEW BAR AOMITTEES RECEPTIONS A F RA CISCO CHAPTER / 9TH CIRCUIT C OURT OF ApPEALS D ECEMBER 2000 Dea n Mary Kay Ka ne, Hon. William Fletcher, a nd LeRoy Humpa l ('67). Matthew Ball ('97), Dis ti ng ll is hed Professor Stephen Lind, and Alumni Associa rion Presldenr-Elecr Ste1!e El.ie ('87 ). A lllmni AssociatIOn Secretary and the Hon. Brad Hil l (' 3), Spencer Martinez Paml Dos hl -O ' elll ('00), Da mon McClain ('00), Florence McClain, and ('99), Adrienne Nelson ('00), a nd joan Podo lsky ('00). A nne Pollack ('00). Alllm11l A "O':I ... 26 - HASTINGS SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER / 9TH CIRCUIT COURT OF ApPEALS DECEMBER 2000 CONTINUED Alumni Association Board member Dennis Hightower ('92) and Kathy Principi. Professor john Malone, Douglas Oh-Keith ('99), and jay C. Kim ('98). Tawni Olson ('00) and Professor David jung. Dr. Harry Weber and jean Margaret Wall ('70). Clyde Rockwell ('49) and CeUa Rockwell. Thomas Wallace ('00), Randel Campbell ('00), C hristian RefseU ('00), Brandi Chavin ('00), and Dean Leo Martinez ('78 ). 27 . II ,\ \ T I lJ \ H I. ~ II rn'R ] Rl 2101 John Komel}l ('79), Al \\vng ('64), Dean Mary Kay Ryan All ('97), U.S. Senator Dan Inollye, Todd Hirai Coralie Marayoshi (,81), aral Mon Lee ('7-1), U.S. Kane, and HawaII U.S. Senacor Dan Inouye. ('00), Tom Yee ('99), and Naralie Au ('00). Senator Dan Inollye, and Crystal Rose ('82). Harvey Henderson ('6 ), Hawaii Supreme Court Richard Hirai ('67) and Elsie Hirai wieh reception hOSI Ben Dean Mary Kay Kane and Hawaii Alumni Chapler Jlmice Pallia Nakayama ('7 ), and Jeff Lau ('77). Kobayashi ('65) President Harvey Lung ('81) with new bar admiltee Todd Hirai ('00). Los A GELES CHAPTER HILL, FARRER & BURRILL FEBRUARY 2001 Elene ho e Kelin Broga n ('79), Dean .\!ary Pamcla Cohen, Victor Cohen ('97), and Tom 1999 classmates Azniv Ksachikyan and Michael Amir, Ka) Kane, and Los Angeles Chapeer Mesereau ('79). Celeste Pace ('00), Paul Supnick ('71), and Gina Presldene Dana Cole ('79). Sam ore ('00). 2 8 IIAST I NGS ORANGE COUNTY CHAPTER SNELL & WILMER FEBR UARY 2001 Erik Friess ('90) and Roberto Lara ('97). Dennis Chan ('77) and Orange County Chapter Dean Mar y Ka y Kane and reception host Christy President Brian Day ('88). joseph ('88). SA DIEGO CHAPTER COOLEY GODWARD FEBRUARY 2001 Dean Mary Kay Kane and ChandLer Rand \'(/iLLiams ('89). Michael Reedy, KeLLy LindLar ('00), and Aidee Acero. Hastings ALumni Association President and reception host Wain Fishbu rn (,81) and Ai 1977cLassmates Todd Stone and joh n Crauford wit h 'Ian Diego Chap ter Pres ident Mori ('00). jeff johnson ('83). 29 HASTI GS ALUMNI EVENTS ORA"lGE COUNTY CHAPTER / HOLIDAY BOAT PARADE DECEMBER 2000 Lenda Camp, Kimberly Smith, and Bailey Smith ('68). Jeff Hoelsken ('99), Matt MiUer ('00), Tom Miller ('73), and Liz: Lindh ('92) at the Holiday Boat Parade held in December at the home of Tom and Kiki MiUer. Nora Sheriff ('00) and Julie Feldman. Jodie Goldstein and Marc Goldstein ('79). John Price and Ronda Jamgotchian ('98). 1999 classmates Amy Anderson and SCOll Borthwick ('99) with Peter Rundle ('85). 30 HASTINGS BOARD OF GOVERNORS FACULTY L UNCH DECEMBER 2000 Professor Kevin Tierney and Alumni Association Alumni Association Board member Mercedes Moreno Distinguished Professor Stephen Lind, former Alumni Presiden t-Elect Steve EUe ('87). ('80) with joseph Grodin, the john F Digardi Association President jamoa Moberly ('76), and Distinguished Professor of Law. Professor Richard Boswell. Al!! mni Association Board member Dennis Hightower Professor Richard Cunningham, Alumni Association Alumni Association Board member Ste phen Van Liere ('92) and Professor jo Carri Uo. President Wain Fishburn ('81), and Profe~sor ('91) with Charles KnaJJJJ, the joseph W Cotchett Margreth Barrett. Distinguished Professor of Law. Professor Daniel Lathrope and Alumni Association 1Teasurer Gregg Hovey (,83). 3 1 IIASTI G ALUMNI ASSOCIATION CLASS NOTES BOARD OF GOVERNORS EXECUTIVE BOARD FOR 2000-01 President M. Wainwright Fishburn '81 (San Diego) CLASS OF 1939 CLASS OF 1952 President-Elect JEROME SAPIRO writes, "In JOHN KNOX write, ''I'm pretty much Steven J. Elie '87 (Los Angeles) retirement, I am doing the foll owing: (1) retired [from Nos aman, Gurl-mer, Kn ox & Tutoring and coun eling students in seventh Elliott in San Francisco], but I' m still around." Vice-President Frederick D. Butler '86 and eighth grade social tudies, including (San Francisco) U.s. History and World History at A.P. CLASS OF 1957 Giannini Middle School in an Franci co. Secretary HON . EARL B . GILLIAM died on This tends to keep me thinking young. (2) Han. Brad R. Hill '83 January 28 in an Diego after a heart (Fresno) Continuing as National Chaplain of the related illness. On October 30, 2000, he was ociety of the Third Infantry Divi ion, U.S. Treasurer named to the California Law Business' "Top Army (we ran out of men of the cl oth), Gregg B. Hovey '83 100" li st of influential lawyers in California (San Diego) which includes writing a Chaplain's Corner that was publi hed in the October 30,2000, and leading prayer and rituals. (3) Writing Immediate Past President Daily Journal. He was a senior judge of the Han. Jamoa Moberly '76 an Infantry Company newsletter that U.S. Di trict Cou rt for the Southern (Newport Beach) comes out every three or four months. (4) District and was San Diego's first African Enj ying gardening. Currently, 1 continue a American municipal court, uperior court, class age nt for the Hastings Annual Fund. and federal di trict court judge. Our active ro ter include six grads THE 1066 ROBERT H. ANDRESEN , FOUNDATION ELECTED CLASS OF 1958 THE FOLLOWING NEW ARTHUR C. ATTERIDGE, OFFICERS TO SERVE ROBERT BALL, SAMUEL H . HON . WILLIE L. BROWN , an TWO-YEAR TERMS RINDGE, and HON. REGINALD Francisco mayor, wa named to the "Top BEGINNING IN M. WATT - a great group - plu me. We 100" list of influential lawyer in California OCTOBER 2000. always proudly say that the C lass of 1939 in the Cali fornia Law Business supplement President broke tradition and beat Boalt Hall in the to the Daily Journal on October 30, 2000. Robert E. Freitas '77 State Bar exam pas ing. Regret to advise (Menlo Park) that my mail-out produced a response from CLASS OF 1959 First Vice President Muriel Busch tating that our JUDGE Rebecca A. Hull '81 GERALD STERNS was named a (San Francisco) HENRY M. BUSCH died four year "Lawyer of the Year" by California Lawyer ago after a long bout with Alzheimer's - Second Vice President in December fo r winning a record-setting Alfred M.K. Wong '64 God bless and protect him." award for the family of a doctor who died (Honolulu) after inhaling econd-hand smoke on an CLASS OF 1951 Secretary O lympic Airways ai rplane. Elaine R. Bayus '77 Leland Edman, retired pilot, lawyer, and (Piedmont) teacher, was featured in the ovember 26, CLASS OF 1960 Treasurer 2000, Fresno Bee for his artistic talent. He ROBERT FIELD became of coun el Aletha R. Werson '62 began painting at age 61. His oils feature (Orinda) to Field, Richardson & Wilhelmy to be a land capes, seascapes, cloudscapes, and full-time neutral for the American mountain of the West. Arbitration As ociation. 32 H AST I NGS HON . THOMAS W . STOEVER Vegas, and join a law firm. H ON. was fea tured in the Octobe r 16,2000, is ue RICHARD FREEBORN retired of the Da ity News of Los Angeles. He was from the bench of the Lake o unt y named the Pasadena Bar A sociati o n 's Supe ri o r Court on January 8. He w ri tes, Judge of the Year in October 2000 and "Li fe ha been kind. Ma rried to Kath y 37 became the county' supervi ing Probate yea rs, and we have three health y sons who Ju dge in February 2001. a re doing wel \. " RAYMON D V . SWEENEY w rit s, "Sin ce 1965, after CLASS OF 1962 the bar exam and the U .. A rm y, 1 have been in ge neral prac t ice - civil , criminal, ROBERT L. BLETCHER was and some mu ic work/ product i n. I elected Pre id ent of the Sa nta Barbara worked with atto rney Roger Corbett County Ba r As ociatio n fo r 2001. from 1965 to 1972 and since the n have HON . FREDERICK BYSSHE was remain ed in Northern Cali fo rnia. 1 dealt appointed to the Ventura County upe rior in country music fo r man y yea rs, Court by Governo r G ray Davis in publi hed Western News from 1968 to Decembe r. ROBERT LIST, former 1975, and managed artists as Nevada Governo r, wa profil ed in the entertainment counsel, including Capitol Sunday, December 24, 2000, edition of the artist Stoney Edwa rds. 1 currently have a Las Vegas Review-Journal. C urrently C EO small Blues recording label, Swewebb of the Robert List Com pan y, he consul ts Record , with Bobbie Webb, and record with casinos, developers, utilities, and R&B/ Blue . At this time, 1 provide a individual clients on working with federal, 'mobil e service' la w practice that offers to tate, and local governments. 'visit yo u,' so 1 am in courts all over Northe rn Califo rnia." RONALD E . CLAS S OF 1963 VERNON retired from law practice. He BRUCE BELDING , a full-time writes, "I had a heart attack in fall 1999. neutral arbitrator, has been appointed to Now is the time to hang up the shingle. It the American Arbitratio n Association 's was a great ride." Internatio nal Panel of Arbitrato rs and was an in vited speake r/ panelist at The C LASS OF 1 964 Mas ter Fo rum, a special conference o n JOSEPH W. COTCH ETT was dispute resolutio n presented by named to the Califo rnia Law Business' Pepperdine U nive rsity Law School's "Top 100" li st of influential lawye rs in the Institute fo r Dispute Resolutio n. HON . Dai ly Journal supplement on October 30, RICHARD BRYAN retired as 2000. He al so was named as a "Lawye r of Nevada's U.S. Se nato r after 36 yea rs in the Yea r" by Ca lifornia Lawyer in public life. H e was profil ed in the Sunday December for successfully defending edit ion of the Las Vegas Review-Journal Consumers Union, publishers of Consumer on January 7, 2001, fo r his career a a Reports, in a First A mendment case filed by Public Defender, an Ass istant District IsuZLI Moto rs. He is a partner with Attorney, State Legislator, Attorney Majeski, Kohn & Bentley in San Jose, Burlinga me's Cotchett Pitre & Simon. General, Governo r, and U . . Senato r. where he focuses on heal th care, products ROBERT S . LUFT joined Mediation Follow ing his retire ment, he and his wife liability, and professional liability. He is also Works, an alternative dispute resolution vacationed in Australia and New Zealand an avid golfer and Pre iden t of the Board firm, as a neutral speciali zing in medical - their first vacatio n in 22 yea rs. He plans of D irecto rs of the Sharon Height Golf malprac tice. He is a pa rtner wi th Roper, to teach at the U ni ve rsity of Nevada, Las and Country C lub in Menlo Park. 33 II \ \ T I l.J \ c::.c::. ,..... Presldlllg Judge of the anta lara ounty President or hair (or !aul c.conomic ROBERT K . BOOTH , Jr. dIed on ~ uperior Court in OctOber. utgoing Opportunity, the HawaiI H Oll~ing ('wi->er 4, 2000, In Lo~ Gato~ after a brief Presiding Judge and Ha tings classmate Authority, Maui Family YM ~ ,and the Illness. He was a longtime municipalla\\' HON . JACK KOMAR sa id, upon Maui Jaycees, urrently, he work , to ass ist practitIoner in the outh Bay and most Turrone's appointment, "He is a very local AID programs and i Vice President r cently a partner with Atkin & Farasyn intell igent, hardworking judge \\'ho will of the J. Walter Cameron enter, which of !ountain View. He e rved a the City bring a ve ry strong commitment to maintain an apa rtment huilding for ttorn y for Palo Alto and Los Altos and maintain the unity of the court and the hattered wo men. GUY O . argued the Stanford Daily ca e in the U. . ervices we provide to the public." KORNBLUM received his certification upreme Court on behalf of Palo Alto. He GEROLD G . WILLIAMS, a priva te as a C ivil Tri al Advocate from the ational i urvived by hi wife, father, on, practitioner in Newport Beach, began hi Boa rd of Tri al Advocacy, the only nati onal daughter, and brother, STEPHEN U . two-year term a a new Has tings 1066 certifying ntity for trial lawyers. BOOTH ('68). W . STUART Foundation Trustee in October 2000. He Certifica ti on is ba ed on meeting a HOME writes, "I had a bad vehicle also is committed to other volunteer ri gorous s t of requirements accident in May 1999. I had no broken ac ti vities, having been President of his demonstrating ubstantial experience in bo nes, but uff red a brain injury. I was out homeowner' a ociati o n, Treasurer of the the trial courts, pa ing a full -day written cold for five wk. The Veterans Laguna Beach Educational Foundation, a examination, and receiving Administration took wonderful care of member of the Board of Di rector of the recommendatio ns and reference from ITle. I am told that the injury will probably Orange County Bar Association, and sitting trial judges and lawyers who have heal around 2002. As m y memo ry comes Chairman of the Judicial election observed th candidate in cou rt. bac k and I continue to heal, I am now in Committee. His son, Rod, i a Hastings CONGRESSMAN ROBERT T. the office two days a week and enjoy ing student in the C lass of 2002. MATSU I was amo ng participants and everything a lot more. The accident was peakers at the Regio n 2000 Reunion for wonderful, for it gave me a fre h tart." CLASS OF 1966 Japanese-American moved to internment HON . EDWARD KAKITA was the FREDERICK ALLEN was awarded ca mps during Wo rld War II held in Loomi s cover feature fo r the Daily Journal's pecial the Boy cout of America title in September. Matsui bega n se rving in the edition "Verdicts & ettlements" on "Champion of couting" at an event in Los .S. Hou e of Repre entatives in 1978 and November 3, 2000. On May ,he Angeles on October 25, 2000. was re-e1ected in November. He serves as a celebrated his 60th birthday and retired HON . WILLIAM ( BILL) C . member of the Ways and Means from the Los Angeles Superior Court. HARRISON was elected to his econd Committee. He also was the featured hortly thereafter, he began mediating term as Presiding Judge of the olano luncheon speaker at last May' 1066 Boa rd ca es through We t Los Angele ' County Superior Court for 2000 and 2001. of Trustee meeting in Washington, D. Alternative Resolutio n Center. He currently i President of the California HON . RICHARD TURRONE was Judges Association, which, with 2,500 CLASS OF 1967 elected to serve a two-yea r term as member, is the larges,t orga niza tion of RON HARRINGTON bega n a year judges and commissioners in the country. long term as President of the Ventura He also is a member of the Califo rnia County Bar A sociatio n in Jan uary. CLASS NOTES Judicial Council for 2000-2001. He recently DEADLINES became a grandfather to Jordan and CLASS OF 1968 McKenzie and has two more grandchildren RICHARD LANDES retired after For the Autumn Issue: May 15 on the way. LARRY I NG received the more than 20 yea rs with the C ity of Long Maui Chamber of Commerce and Island Beach as principal City Atto rney, erving For the Winter Issue: Business Magazine's Valley Isle Award of I as legal counsel in the Harbor Department September "Humanitarian of the Year." In addition to for the Port of Lo ng Beach. His career volunteering with a long Ii t of Maui For the Spring Issue: January 15 spanned the transition of the port from a community groups, he ha erved as either regional facility to an international 3 4 H AST I NGS economic fo rce that eIT1ploys some 18,000 Supe ri or Court Judge in Fremo nt at the in the region. He also represe nted the city start of the new yea r by Governor Gray in the development o f the Alameda Davis. STEVEN MEYERS, founder Corrido r Project, a rail ex pres way that will and manag in g pa rtner of Meye rs Nave speed ca rgo from the port to Riback il ve r & Wilson, wa elected transc ntinental rail ya rds. C hairman of the Bay Pl anni ng Coaliti on in Dec mbe r. He will lea d the coali tion in CLASS OF 1969 addre sin g ongoin g enviro nmental pe rm it PETER DAVIS wa named Pres ident and pl anning iss ues in the Bay Area. At his of the American Academy of Appell ate law fi rm, he focuses on land use and Lawyers. He founded and chair the environmental law, redevelopment, and appell ate department of the an Francisco writs and appeal . office of C rosby, Heafey, Roach & May and GATES is founder a nd Preside nt of the ha practiced exclusively in the appellate CLASS OF 1974 Gates Group, an inte rnati o nal field for more than 25 yea rs. JUDITH M. COPELAND wa consultancy located in Atlanta, and elected to the Cali fornia State Bar Board of Pre id ent of the nonprofit hared CLASS OF 1971 Governors. JUDITH A . MAZIA has Capitalism Institute, with office in ROGER HEDGECOCK , a southern been appointed to the Califo rnia Court of A tlanta and Cambridge, Massachusetts. California radio talk how ho t, was the Appeal, First Appell ate District Mediation STUART HANLON was named a subject of a September 25, 2000, San Panel. BARBARA E . ORNITZ "Lawyer of the Year" by Ca lifornia Lawyer Francisco Recorder "Bar Talk" feature. A married Dwight Shell man, Jr. on in December for hi $4.5 mill io n ve rdict former attorney and Sa n Diego mayor, he September 23, 2000, in Aspen, Colo rado, fo r Gero nimo Pratt in his civil action is the outspoken host of KOGO's "Roger after a 23-yea r engagement. The couple aga inst the city of Los Angeles a nd the Hedgecock Community Fo rum" by day continues to res ide in their home in FBI. HON . JAMES LAMBDEN , and ow ner of Roger 's on Fifth, a Woody reek. DOUGLAS WAH jOined Associate Justi ce of the Fi rst District restaurant in Sa n Diego's Gaslamp Bi shop, Barry, Howe, Haney & Ryder in Court of Appeal, was the subject of a Quarter, by night. PAUL D. Emeryv ill e as a partner, specializing in September 15, 2000, San Fran cisco SU PN I K , a solo prac titione r in Beverl y products li abil ity, tox ic to rts, and Examiner article on the ethical question Hills, is President-Elect of the Los A ngeles environmental defense. of judges se rving with the Boy Scouts Copyright Society. after the Dale deci ion. Judge Lambden CLASS OF 1975 fo rmerl y se rved as a scout maste r. HON. CLASS OF 1972 MANUELA ALBUQUERQUE , GEORGE V . SPANOS was Be rkeley's C i ty A ttorney for the past 15 JEROME L. LEMBERGER, appointed to the Contra Costa Superio r yea rs, wa profiled in the November 17, Director of Administrati on and Access for Court in November by Governo r Gray 2000, iss ue of the Sa n Fran cisco Recorder. the Colorado Legal Service program, Davis. CHRISTINE V. TEJADA , DANIEL DONOVAN resigned as received the Bruce T Buell Award from Director of Real E tate fo r Charles senior li tigator with the Federal the Colorado Lawye r Trust Account Sch wab & Co., wa elected chai r of the Defende rs of Montana to re-establish his Foundation in Denve r in November 2000. San Francisco/Sili con Va ll ey C hapte r of private practice in Great Falls, Montan a. The award is given periodicall y to the Inte rnational Developmen t Research His law offi ce emphasizes criminal individuals, o rga ni za ti ons, or businesses Council. She continues as a board defense work, particularly federal court that help fund o rga nizations prov iding member of the San Francisco Plannin g cases. Do novan ga ined national lega l se rvices to the disad va ntaged. and Urban Research Association. recognitio n for briefing, arguing, and winning a case before the United States CLASS OF 1973 CLASS OF 1976 Supreme Court, Old Chief v. United HON . DAN C. GRIMMER was HON. STEPHEN D . BRADBURY States, 519 U .. 172 (1 997). JEFF elevated from traffi c commissioner to continues as the Presiding Judge of the 35 ' 11t\~T I GS ' u perior Court of La"en Cou nty ,\nd ha, h gu n his second year ,I, an E:-.ec u t! \'e Board Member of the ali(ornia Ju dge~ Associati on. Thi u m mer, he wi ll begin hl~ eventh yea r a, a member o( the (ac ui ty at the alifornia Judges oll ege at Be rkeley and i currentl y s rv ing a~ a faculty member fo r the Q ualifying Tri al Ethics Program being p resented to ve ry state judge in Califo rnia. A highlight of hi yea r was joini ng with 12 Ha tings cl assmates (the "A meekables") in spring 2000 fo r their annual G iants ga me and dinne r. HON . KARLA M . GRAY was elected hief Ju tice of the Montana Su preme Cou rt a nd took office Ja n ua ry 2, 2001. he is the first woman C hief Ju ti ce of Mo ntana' highest court, having bee n the first woman elected as A sociate Justi ce to the Court in 1991. STEVEN MCCORMICK in December was named President and hief Executive Office r of the Arlingto n, Virginia-based Nature CO il e rva ncy. The nati on' 12th-large t non profit orga nizati on owns mo re than 1,300 preserv s and has protected more than 12 mill io n acres in the United tates to prese rve plant and an imal di versity. THE PAST PRESIDENT' S AWARD OUTIng Founder's Day ceremOnies, Alumni Alsoctanon President Wain Fishburn ('81) presented Hon. jamoa Moberly ('76) wah an honorary plaque In recognlllOn of her sen Ice as President of the AlumnI Assoctal1on eluTing 1999'2000. 36 HA S T I N GS CLASS OF 1977 a d ive r e state, and it's inevitable we will attorney, was fea tured on the front page of THOMAS C . GEISER , Executive become a more di verse state." HON. the Los Angeles Daily Journal on Jan uary 3, Vice President and General Counsel of ROBERT M . HERTZBERG , 2001, fo r h is pro bono contributio ns. He is WellPoint Health Networks, is chief Spea ker of the California Assembly, was of counsel with the Century C ity firm of attorney fo r WellPoint and its subsidiaries, named to the "Top 100" list of influential Donahue, Mesereau & Leid s. which include Blue C ross of California. He lawye rs in California in the Califo rnia Law was named to the California Law Business' Business supplement to the Daily Journal CLASS OF 1980 "Top 100" list of influential lawye r in the on October 30, 2000. JEFFREY KATHLEEN BALES-LANGE was Dai ly Journal supplement on October 30, KIMMEL, founder and President of appointed to her second fo ur-yea r term as 2000. CHRISTOPHER R . INAMA i Liaise Corp. in Danville, was profil ed in the the County Counsel fo r Tul are County. the Academic Director of the executive Hayward Daily Review on December 3, She started with the office in 1981 as a MBA program and a Professor of 2000, for his pl an to crea te a pri vately deputy and was first appointed County Economics at the Silicon Valley campus of funded public transit monorail system on Counsel in 1996. LEE F. Golden Gate U nive rsity. the Las Vegas strip. THOMAS A . GOTSHALL-MAXON moved to the MESEREAU , a criminal defense San Francisco office of Allen, Matkins, CLASS OF 1978 JENNIFER L. KELLER has been named C riminal Defense Attorney of the Yea r by the Orange County Trial Lawye rs Association. Keller, who is in priva te practice, was the 1996 President of the Orange County Bar Association. CLASS OF 1979 MARC ABRAMSON is a se nior trial attorney with O 'Donnell, Murtaugh & Coghlan in Chicago, practicing commercial liability and dental malpractice defen se. He enjoys working in the C hicago Loop, practicing in Cook County, and li vin g near the north shore of Lake Michiga n with his wife and son. LES BOCK is the new Executive Director of the Idaho Human Rights Education Center and will head its efforts to erase prejudice and bigotry in the state. The Center is building the Idaho Anne Frank Human Rights Memorial, scheduled to open in June. After 15 years volunteering for nonprofit groups, he left his partnership with Dillion, Bosch, Daw & Bock in Boise to pursue this opportunity. Idaho experiences tensions between Anglos and Hispanics and between Indian tribes and Caucasians that need to be dealt with in a constructive way, he says. "We are . 37 Professor of Law at New York Law choo! (,81 ), live in Berkeley with their two in Manhattan' fashionable Tribeca. He daughters. DAVID M . WILF w a~ taught first-year torts and an advanced appointed hief perating fficer at the tort course. With tuart Madden and Swit:erland-ba ed Fantastic o rpo rati o n Ha ting Professor John Diamond, he is a in Zug. He \\'ill head a cu tomer-solutions co-author of the second edition of the torts focused operati o nal unit within the treatise, Understanding Torrs, published by company to deliver data broadca t Lexi / Matthew Bender. JEFFREY D . solu tion to cu to mers wo rl dwide. MANOS, formerly a partner with orey, Lu:aich, Manos & Pliska, joined ICon CLASS OF 1983 Profe s ional ervices as General Coun el in BRENDA BIREN specializes in August 2000. A national web-based employ ment law at ayad & Biren in an company specializing in independent Francisco. NAN CASTLE retired from Leck, Gamble & Mall o ry in October. He contractor compliance enTices, ICon wa the practice of law and now concentrat pecializes in representing developers and named the sixth fastest growing c mpany her effo rt on ra ising mo ney for the investors in land acquisition, landlo rds and in ilicon Valley in November 2000. educatio n f u nd for Casa Hoga r Don tenants in commercial realty, and DAVI D N ELSON opened hi own Bosco, a girls' o rpha nage in San M iguel de development and dispo itions. firm, the Nelson Law Firm, in Lo ngview, A ll ende, Mexico. JEFFERY FADEFF LAVONNE REIMER joined Washington, in October. He pecializes in is a partner w ith Bishop, Barry, Howe, Cenquest, Inc., in Po rtland, Oregon. real e tate, personal injury, employment, Haney & Ryder in Emeryvill e, where he STEVEN ROYCRAFT joined Walnut and municipal law. continues his practice in insurance Creek's Archer Norris a a partner. defense litigation. HaN. SERGIO FO[!T1erly manager of the claim counsel CLASS OF 1982 GUTIERREZ, the first and o nl y department for C ru m & Forster, a KARL OLSON is a partner with Levy, Hispan ic judge in Idaho, received the national property and casualty in urance Ram, O lson & Rossi, a six-lawyer firm he Voices of Fa ith Hu man Rights Awa rd in company, he pecializes in complex started in an Francisco with two December. He was p rofil ed in the insurance coverage and bad faith litigation, colleagues in 1997. SUZAN N E December 14,2000, Boise Weekly. MARK including advertising injury, personal SOLOMON ('93) and JONI PETERSEN wa elected to chair injury, con truction defects, and JACOBS ('95) are associates at the Farell a Braun & Martel's litigation and professi onal Iiabi l i ty. firm. 0 1 on specialize in media law, busi ness departmen ts. intell ectual property, and clas action CLASS OF 1981 litigation and has been a Co-Chair of the CLASS OF 1984 JOE COLE is publi her of the Sa nta Bench/ Bar Media Committee of the Bar JEANNE "JONNIE" Ba rbara lews- Press, a 45,000 daily A ociation of San Franci co since 1991. (ETCHEMENDY) DAVILA writes, "I circulation newspaper. He remains RANDY SHAW was ptofiled in the Los left the practice of law in 1989 and have Executive ice President of Ampersand Anaele edition of the DaiLy Journal on been a fundrai er ever since. My marriage Publi hina and of counsel at eed, Mackall o ovember 27, 2000, for his work a in 1999 to Angel Davila brought me to and Cole, a anra Barbara firm that Director of San Francisco's Tenderloin Dall as, where I wo rk for Southern peciali:es in bu ines ,tax, ecurities, and Housi ng Clinic. He also founded Housing Methodist University. My legal education real estate issues. HON . RUTH America, a national coalition that lobbies comes in handy in my plan ned-giving KWAN wa profiled in the San Francisco for affordable housing, and publi hed two work." DIANE GIBSON became a Daily Journal on December 12,2000, for how-to books on gras root acti on: The partner in the an Francisco office of her role a Pre iding Judge of the Eastlake and Activists Handbook Reclaiming quire, ander & Dempsey as a result of JU\'enile Court, Lo Angele uperior America: ike, Clear Air, and the lew the combination of quire anders and Court. LAWRENCE C . LEVINE rational Acti'vism. He and hi wife, civil Graham & James' West oast and Asia pent the fall semester a a isiting right lawyer ELAINE FEINGOLD offices. he continues to head the litigation 38 IIA T I N GS department a the ad vocacy team leader CLASS OF 1986 was profil ed in the Lo Angeles edition of and peciali ze in complex commercial HaN. CYNTHIA A . BASHANT the Daily Journal on November 6, 2000, for litiga ti on with an emphasis on real estate was appointed a judge f the Sa n D iego hi leader hip of the political pract ice disputes. SHARON E . JAFFE was County upe ri o r Court in November group at his law firm, Smith Kaufma n. awarded the Department f Ju ti ce's 2000 by Governo r G ray Davis. She had Certificate of Commendati on for been an Assistant U .. A tto rney since CLASS OF 1988 O utstanding Performance and Invaluable 1989 and wo rked as Deputy C hief of the MARTI N KASSMAN , a solo Assi tance in Support f the Activities f majo r na rcotics ection of the offi ce, practitio ner in San Francisco, is a the En vironment and Natural Resources pro ecuting case aga in t Mex ican drug specialist in appell ate law certified by the Di vision. She prosecu ted en vi ron men tal traffi cking o rga niza tio ns and local State Ba r of Cali fo rnia Board of Legal crimes and enforcement actions for seven methamphetamine labs. From 1997 to Speciali za tion. He represents clien ts in yea rs in the U . . Attorney's Office for the 1999, she also se rved as C hief of the criminal and civ il appeals and appell ate District of Connecticut before joining the Bo rder C rimes ecti on. BETTY w rit proceedings in state and fede ral ew York C ity firm of Levin & Glasse r. ORVELL chair the State Bar of court . He is acti ve in the Califo rnia She represe nts individual and corporations Califo rnia's executive committee of the Appell ate Defe nse Counsel, an associatio n in environmental and other governmental estate pl anning, trust, and probate law of lawye rs who accept appointments from matters and in vestiga tions in New York and section. A partne r with C rosby, Hea fey, the Califo rnia Supre me Court and the Connecticut. RAYMOND LYNCH Roach & May in Oakl and, she speciali zes Califo rnia Courts of Appeal to represent joined the Sa n Francisco office of Hanson in planning complex estates and employee indigent c riminal defendants. He also Bridgett Marcus V lahos & Rudy, working benefits distributions. GEORGE assists clie nts with First Amendme nt and in the firm 's labor and employ ment group. TREVOR writes, ''Afte r 11 yea rs with media law matters. EDWARD D . HON . DA VI D MINTZ was elected a G old Bennett Cera & Sidener in Sa n MARKS is a pa rtner with Thoits Love judge of the Los Angeles Superior Court. Francisco, I opened my own prac ti ce in Hershberger & McLea n, a full-se rvice For the past 16 years, he was a Deputy Corte Madera in August 2000. I continue business firm specializing in co nstructi on District Attorney with the Los Angeles to practi ce business litiga tion in securities and real estate dispute resolution and County District Attorney's Office, where, and antitrust. The reductio n in commute litiga tio n. Two 1966 cl assmates, BRUCE among other assignments, he headed the time leaves lots mo re time fo r mountain MUNRO and BILL McLEAN , are real estate fraud unit. He al 0 has been an biking o n Mt. Tam." also Thoits, Love partners. LAUREN Adjunct Professor at Pepperdine University TERK left Carroll , Burdick & School of Law since 1993 and is a co-author CLASS OF 1987 McDonough to become of coun el at of the sea rch and seizure chapter in the JENNIFER HAGLE, a partner with Holland & Knight in Sa n Francisco. fifth edition of C EB's California Criminal the Los Angeles offi ce of Sidley & Austin, Law Procedu re and Prac ti ce. joined the Boa rd of Directors of the CLASS OF 1989 Aquarium of the Pacific, located on DANIEL BLAKEY was named of CLASS OF 1985 Rainbow Harbor in Long Beach. counsel at Steptoe & Johnson in Lo DAVID FRANK left the U.s. DENISE HAMER and Mirkarim Angeles in December 2000. His practice Department of Justice C riminal Divi ion Yakubov of Barcelona, Spain, announce the focuse on tox ic torts, defending in Wa hington, D.C., and now is working birth of their daughter, Alexandra Rachel petroleum and chemical manufac turers for the U.S. Attorney's Office in Miami, Yakubov, on December 19, 2000. PHILIP against pe rsonal injury and w rongful Florida. LEE D . JACOB, formerl y a HAYES is the lead guitarist, singer, and death claims. C urrently, he is coordinating pa rtner with the Beverl y Hills firm of creative director of the an Franci co band the natio n wide defense of personal injury Ervin , Cohen & Jess up, is now the Chief "I Seen Elvis." The band plays music ftom cl aim against a manufacturer of Administrative Officer and General the '70s, '80s, and '90s once a month at herbicides and pe ti cides. DEBORAH Counsel of Covina-based HYI, an importer va ri ous venues in the city. By day, Hayes is DANILOFF is of cou n el in the of footwear and spo rting good . an estate pl anning lawye r with Goldman Oakland offi ce of Crosby, H eafey, Roach & Associates. STEPHEN KAUFMAN & May and practices in the firm' 39 . II \ \ T I'e \ rroduct~ It 'l htlit\' group. GEORGE W . tate starting and ending in an Ener en' an Franci ' ooffi e. He practi es KUN E Y. tormerlv a partner In the an Francisco. he writes, "It wa an organized litigation and a pellat law. lliego office of Allen htkin' Leck group ride, and, with six other rider, I Gamhle 1allor)" Joined the faculty of rode 9,000 miles. We left an Franci co on CLASS OF 1991 the Univer ity of Tenne ee College of March 29,2000, rode to an Diego, across STUART EINBINDER has been Law. He hold the position of Associate the southern part of the country to named of counsel at rowell & Moring in Profes or and Director of the James L. Brunswick, Georgia, up the ea tern Irvi ne. VALERIE KARNE is an layton enter for Entrepreneurial Law seaboard to New York, acro the northern Assi tant Profe or of English at the and continues to head the California portion of the country to Seattle (via Univer ity of Rhode Island. She teaches Bankruptcy Journal a Editor-in-Chief. Hi Niagara Fall and Ontario), and arrived course in law and literature and academic focu i on busines law, back in San Francisco on eptember 1, contemporary literature and culture. Her pecifically commercial law and the 2000. We averaged 70 mile per day and most recent article, "Legal Hunge r: Law, reorganization of busine s enterpri es. had one day off each week to rest. We rode Narrative, and Orality in Le lie Marmon TYLER OLPIN is of counsel with through the desert and over mountain Silko's Storyte ll er and Almanac of the Oakland's Morton, Lul ofs & Wood, after passes, rain or shine. It was a wonderful Dead," is forthcoming in the jou rnal serving the firm a an associate for eigh t adventure." he has been with the Co llege Literature. JOH N L. SM ITH year. His practice focuses on insurance California Office of Legislative oun el for was named manag in g partner with coverage, appellate work, and complex 10 years and took a leave of absence to do C rosby, Heafey, Roach & May's Oakland commercial litigation. VALERIE the bike ride. MARY J . DECKER , an office in January. He has been with the PURNELL, A ociate Director of the environmental litigation and compli ance firm his entire legal ca ree r. He is a former Univer ity of California' Office of State attorney in McCutchen, Doyle, Brown & Co-C hair of the Bench/ Bar Media Government Relation, received the 2000 Enersen' Los Angele office, was elevated Committee of the Alameda County Bar Marvin D. 'Swede' John on Awa rd for from a ociate to Counsel. ERIC Association and live in Oakland with his outstanding leadership in state DEJONG joined the Seattle offi ce of wife, son, and daughter. TRACY government relation on behalf of higher Perkin Coie as a partner in the corporate THOMAS joined the firm of Haliw, education. The annual award is jointly finance group in October. His practice Siciliano & M yc halowych in Farmington sponsored by the American Association of focuses on emerging companies, corporate Hill s, Michigan, in Januar y. tate Coll eges and Univer ities, the finance, securities regulation, and mergers Council for Advancement and Support of and acquisitions, as well as general CLASS OF 1992 Education, and the National Association corporate law. Prior to joining Perkins MATTHEW BERGER , a technology of State Universitie and Land-Grant Coie, he was a partner wi th Davis Wright transacti ons attorney, was elevated to Coll ege. JOHN STEVENS has Tremaine in Seattle. MILLIE JEW partner with Morrison & Foerster in the worked for the U.S. State Department's writes, "After working various part-time firm's Los Angeles office. PAUL JAHN , ear East Bureau for the past 10 years, contract positions during the past few a technology transactions attorney, was serving in Washington, D.C., and in years in order to stay home with my three elevated to partner with Morriso n & embas ie in Riyadh, Cairo, and Tunis. He children, Larry, 7, Ryan, 5, and Tamlyn, 2, I Foerster in the firm's San Francisco office. will be in Damascu for a year starting in am back fu ll- time as corporate counsel KATHRYN ELLIOTT LOVE was July 2001 and would be glad to hear from with Oracle Corporation. My hu band, elected to partnership in the St. Loui s, Hastings alumni who happen to be in the Larry Chew, also an attorney, recently left Missouri, office of the international law area or who are interested in careers in the private practice to join Franklin Templeton firm of Bryan Cave. She is a member of the Foreign ervice. He can be reached at Inve tments' legal department. We are both firm's entrepreneurial, technology, and teven jx@ tate.gov. reveling in the fact that our commute are commercial practice and transactions and now only 10 and five minutes re pectively corporate governance client se rvice groups. CLASS OF 1990 from our Foster City home." FRANK B . WAUKEEN Q . MCCOY, a solo KENNAMER was promoted to partner LARA K . B IERMAN completed a practitioner in an Francisco, was profiled with McCutchen, Doyle, Brown & fi\'e-month bicycle ride around the nited in the San Francisco Daily Journal on 40 H AST I NGS December 8, 2000, for his represe ntation of JOHN HOLTRI CHTER practices labor unions, joined two other Hastings client on claims of ra cial discrimination international securities transactions, alumni, KARL OLSON (,82) and and bias ba ed on sexual orientation and merge rs and acquisitions, and general SUZANNE SOLOMON (,93) , at HIV statu , including the former corporate law with Freshfields Bruckhaus the San Francisco litigation firm of Levy, employees who ued the makers of Wonde r Deringe r in London. KRI S TI N J ENNY Ram, O lson & Rossi. Admitted to the Bars Bread. He received a proclamation from was promoted to partner with Boornazian, of Cali fornia, Arizona, and Nevada, she San Francisco MAYOR WILLIE Jensen & Garthe in Oakl and. She writes, speciali zes in consumer and employment BROWN ('58) naming September 1, "My husband, Scott, and two sons, class ac tions. DAVI D REA D , an 2000, as Waukeen McCoy Day. A nthony, to, and Brian, 7, are doing well. I a ociate with the intellectual property CHRISTOPHER WANGER , an would love to hear from tho e with whom I firm Womble Carl yle andridge & Rice in intellectual property litiga tor, was elected have lost touch. " LAU RA LICHT, an Winston-Salem, North Carolina, passed the partner with Manatt Phelps & Phill ips' employ ment attorney, was elevated to patent bar exam and is admitted to Palo Alto office. JASON WHITING is partner with the Sa n Diego office of practice before the U.s. Patent and enior Counsel at Silicon Vall ey Bank in Pillsbury Winthrop (formerly Pillsbury Trademark Office. ENID RIVERA is an Santa Clara. Madison & Sutro). associate with Tomlinson Zisko Morosoli & Mase r in Palo Alto. She gives advice on CLASS OF 1993 CLASS OF 1994 employment matters and handles litigation SUSANNE ARONOWITZ was DAVID G . BECK was elevated from in volving commercial matters, unfair promoted to Assistant Dean for Law counsel to partner with the San Francisco competition, trademark, and othe r Career Services at Golden Gate University office of McC utchen, Doyle, Brown & intellectual property-related disputes in the School of Law in San Francisco. She Enersen. He is a patent attorney firm 's employ ment law and litiga tion married Rob Schulhof in October 1999. specializing in science, electronics, and groups. PETER R . SPURZEM is a BRENT BROUGHER, a commercial computers. LINDA DEMELIS was founding partner of Paxton & O'Brien in li tigator, was elevated to partner with the promoted to Special Coun el for Resea rch Holliste r. He also serves as President of the San Francisco office of Pillsbury W inthrop and Development at the Venture Law San Benito County Bar Association. (formerly Pillsbury Madison & Sutro) Group in Menlo Park. OTTO LEE, a RICHARD STEELE joined the Bay effective January 1, 200l. MATTHEW principal at Intellectual Property La w Area's RealNames Corp. as Director of DONOVAN joined the Phoenix office of Group in San Jose, was elected C hair of the Legal and Corporate Affairs. Previously, he Greenberg Traurig as an associate, Sunnyvale Planning Commiss ion for 2000- was a judicial law clerk for the U.S. 10th practicing corporate and securities law. 2001 and promoted to Lieutenant C ircuit Court of Appeals in Denver, ANDREA HACKETT Commander in the U.s. Naval Reserve. Colorado. FARZAD TABATABAI HENNINGSEN became a partner at RACHEL NUNES is an assoc iate with joined Haight, Brown & Bonesteel in Santa Steefel, Levitt & Wei s in San Francisco, the Law Offices of Peter]' Walls in Santa Monica as a se nior associate in Januar y. He where she focuses on commercial litiga tion, Rosa, where she specializes in corporate was married in July 2000. VIVIANA including matters that in volve trade secrets, work, estate planning, and business WAISMAN , in February, launched employ ment, and real estate, as well as state litiga tion. She li ves in Sonoma County Women's Link Worldwide: Linking Laws regulatory litigation. She represents the wi th her husband, Tom, and their 6-month Protecting Women Around the World, a California Department of Agriculture on old daughter. JAMES G . SNELL, an collaboration between nongovernmental milk standards and regulations, in addition intellectual property and antitrust litiga tor, organizations and academia to adva nce to her work advising telecommunications was promoted from associate to partner women's rights globall y. She and her corporations on matters before the Public with McCutchen, Doyle, Brow n & partners secured funds from the Ford Utilities Commission. ALAN S . Enersen's Palo Alto office. Foundation and th~ European HODES, a patent attorney and Commission to carry out this project in intell ectual property litigator, was elevated CLASS OF 1995 Latin America and Europe with local partners in each region. She will serve as from counsel to partner with McCutchen, JONI S. JACOBS, a former associate WLW Director. Headquartered in Madrid, Doyle, Brown & Enersen's Palo Alto office. with Davis Cowell & Bowe representing . 4 1 . operations. 0 if you go on a cruise Internati o nal orporate Finan e at the .s. \'acation, it may be that the captain i ecurities and Exchange ommi 'sion operating the \'essel based upon procedures divi ion of corporation finance in written by a Ha tings alumnu . Prior to Wa hingto n, D .. BRYAN SNYDER i, attending Hastings, Betz spent nearly 20 staff coun el in the Legal Affair year working onboard large ea-going Department fo r the alifo rnia Department ves els, beginning as a seaman tying knots of Corrections in acramento. Previouly, and working hi way up the ranks to he pent two yea rs in eattle a a law clerk Captain on oil tankers. TRACI in the Washington tate ourt of App al . GRUNDON joined Davis Wright Tremaine's Portland, Oregon, office and CLASS OF 1997 works with both the telecommunication ADAM BELL, formerly a patent and energy law groups. Prior to thi attorney with Incyte G nomics in Palo pain, WLW fo ters the implementation of position, she practiced energy regulatory Alto, is patent counsel with the S uth Bay regional and international human rights law in California for Gruneich Resource biotechnology company ell Genesy , law and treatie and promote the u e of Advocates and in the Pacific Northwe t for Inc., which focuses on gene therapy and international and regional tribunals to Energy Advocates. BILL KILLEA is cancer vaccine. He i a member of the advance women' right, with an empha i Vice President for equity in titutional sales Board of Advisers of the We t Coast on reproductive right and violence. To at Merrill Lynch in ew York, He wa Patent and Trademark Depository Library support thi project, Wai man and her elected to the Town hip ommittee in (" ci3") in unnyvale, on the Board of the partners founded a not-for-profit Chatham, N.J., in 1999 and continues as an Scottish Technology Venture Fund of organization ba ed in Madrid called "Red ac tive reservist in the .. aval Reserve at Gla gow, cotland, and a scientific adviser d Mujere para 10 Derechos Humano ." th rank of ommander. MAGDALENA to asq uatch apital, a biotech equity MARK D. WEIDEMAN joined LAWSON is Corporate ounsel for Triad hedge fund in Po rtland, Oregon. H e and Pillsbury Winthrop's (formerly Pillsbury Financial Corporation in Huntington hi wife, Wendy, will spend summer 2001 Madison & utro) Sacramento office a an Beach, where her practice empha ize helping build a self-contained bio-habitat a ociate. He speciali zes in business con umer finance transactions and general in the Falkland Islands in the South litioation matters, with an empha is in corporate matter. LISA MEDEIROS Atlantic. TIEN CAl joined the telecom m u n ica tions la w. wa interviewed on a PB "Frontline" ecurities, intellectual property, and episode, "Real Ju tice," which aired in busine litigation firm of Bergeson CLASS OF 1996 November 2000. he is a defen e attorney Eliopoulo in San Jose as an associate. JOH N M. BETZ is the owner of a small in private prac tice in Boston and take Previously, she was an as ociate with bu iness that as esses operational tandards court-appointed case for indigent clients. Fabyanske, Westra & Hart in and crew competency onboard laroe, sea DON NA MOON EY, as a research Minneapolis. TAMARA COSTA joined going ve sels and then develops compliance attorney for the Alameda uperior Court, the family law department of McMani , trategies for hip owner. Bet: is home publi hed an article, "The earch for a Legal Faulkner & Morgan in San Jose as an ba ed in Los Angeles; however, his Pre umption of Employment Duration or as ociate. BETSIE MISSLER and omewhat different career path keeps him Custom of Arbitrary Dismissal in VLADIMIR BELO were married on on the road about 60% of the time and ha California 1 4 -1 872," 21 Berkeley I Emp. & May 27, 2000, in Columbus, Ohio. Bet ie tak n him to m'er 20 countrie since Lab. L 633 (2000). he attended the works for outheas tern Ohio Lega l graduation. Hi firm recently built the Harvard Law chool Program of ervice In hillicothe. EOL provides navigational operating procedure for one In truction for Lawyer in June. In late legal representation to poor client of the world' large t crui e hip operator summer, he climbed Mount Whitney in a th roughout southeastern Ohio. Vlad i and i pre entl\' a essing that company' day. In March, she became a Deputy City currently serving a judicial clerkship with engineering operation In preparing a Attorney for Alameda. AMY O 'BRIEN Ju tice Debo rah L Cook of the Ohio compamon \'olume for below-deck i pecial coun el in the Office of upreme Court in Columbus. JULIA --1 2 H A S TING S PARK practices civil litiga ti on with ha com pl eted graduate studie at the Ca rl smith & Ball in Honolulu. London School of Economics and returned AMANDA PEREZ joined O akl and's to the Los A ngel es office of Pa ul , Ha ti ngs, Bay Venture Counsel as an associate in Janofsky & Walke r. October. Her practi ce focuse on general corporate wo rk, alo ng with intell ectual CLASS OF 1999 property and licensing. he previously VINCENT CASIANO writes, "A li sa held an in-hou e po itio n w ith PeopleSoft, and I are the pro ud pa re nts of a baby girl, In c., where he specialized in tax-related Marissa Mari e Casiano, 6 lbs. to oz. he wa issues. LINDSAY (STURGES) bo rn on Wednesday, Novembe r 29, at 7:15 SAFFOURI is a business litiga to r with p. m. life is grand!" BRIAN COX is an Tay lor & Co. Law Offices in Alameda. A istant Staff Judge Advoca te for the U.S. ALFRED SPIELMANN joined the A ir Force at O ffutt A FB, Nebras ka, and limitations. RICHARD T. Santa Clara County Office of the Public e rves as a prosecu to r for cou rts ma rtial. In SCHWARTZ, formerl y an associate Defender as a Deputy Public Defender. He September 2000, he e rved as a legal with Day, Casebeer, Mad rid & Batchelde r was formerl y a criminal defe nse atto rney ad vi e r fo r an accid ent in ve tiga tio n board in C upertino, joined Telecom Italia with the Law Offices of Louis]. G oodman for an F-16 crash at Nelli s AFB, Nevada. Venture in an Franci co as Di rector of in Hay ward. After working at Federal ERIK HANSHEW works fo r H in haw Research and Legal Affairs. Defenders of San Diego fo r three years, & C ulbertson in Sa n Francisco. DAVID ZUGMAN and GARY KATHERINE HERTEL works fo r CLASS OF 2000 BURCHAM opened law offices in San Lyo n & Lyo n in Los Angeles. JOH N Diego specializing in federal criminal law. H U R LEY joined the San Francisco SANJEEV AYYAR joined G ray, Car y, office of Arter & Hadden as an as ociate Ware & Freide nrich in Palo Alto as an CLASS OF 1998 and wi ll focus his practice on general associate. JESSICA BARSOTTI RODOLFO L. FONG-SAN DOVAL business and comme rcial li t iga tion, with repre ent Iron Door, Inc., an hi to ric i a federal attorney with the National an emphas is on unfair competitio n and saloon and re tau rant we t of Yo emite Labor Relations Boa rd, Region 31, in Los consumer class actio n defense. JAY M. Nati onal Park in G roveland. SHAN Angeles. He specializes in labor law and the JACKMAN writes, "My wife, M yra, and BHATI wo rks fo r G ray, Car y, Wa re & N. L.RA Formerly, he practiced I have just returned f rom spending two Freidenrich in Palo Alto. NAVDEEP employ ment and labor law with Goldberg yea rs in Ithaca, New York, where I had a BISLA is Corporate Counsel fo r the & Gage in Los Angeles. STEPHEN chance to do two semesters at Cornell Law N iku Corpo ration in R edwood C ity. PEREZ HARRIS, a staff attorney at choo! before completing a judicial MICHAEL BLUMENTHAL works the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, taught externship and getting m y JD from for White & Case in Los Angeles. TODD legal writing and research at Has tings in Ha tings. I continue to work as a forensic BRIGGS i an associate w ith Skje rve n, the fall of 2000 and currently teaches Moot psychiatrist specializing in criminal law. I Mo rrill, MacPherson in San Francisco. Court. He coached the H as tings look forward to reconnecting with PATRICIA BURKE works for Pedde r, Entertainment Law Moot C ourt Tea m to a classmates, e peciall y from section two." Stover, Hesseltine & Walke r in Lafayette. th ird-place finish in the National KEITH KASSAN works fo r Berke & RANDEL CAMPBELL works for Entertainment Law Moot Court Associates in Tho usa nd Oaks. Lynch G il ardi & G rummer in an Competition last fall and also has coached ALEXANDRA NARANCIC works Francisco. VINCENT CARTER works two of the Coll ege's Evidence Moot Court for A rthur Anderse n in Sa n Jose. fo r G irardi & Kee e in Los A ngeles. Tea ms. RONDA JAMGOTCHIAN co PRASANNA RASIAH joined the EUGENE CHANG works fo r hosted the daytime talk sh ow "live with Berkeley C ity A t torney's O ffi ce as Deputy PricewaterhouseCoopers in Sa n Franci co. Regis" in October. She was selected out of C ity Attorney, where he works on local JOHN CONNOLLY works fo r 15,000 people vying to be Regis Philbin's election matters such as cam paign fi li ng Manwell & Schwartz in Sa n Francisco. co-host for a day. CHIP ROBERTSON requirements and expendit ures J E NNIFER COSGROVE works in 43 HA TI G~ thL' S,\l1 Francl co Publtc Defender's McNAMARA work for Folger Levin 4' !" ·IN MEMORIAM tllLe RACHEL FOLBER G i a & Kahn in an Francisco. AI MORI i a .'f1' ::.talt attorney In an Franci co for the judicial staff attorney at the California Department of Industrial Relation, Labor Court of Appeal in San Diego. DAWN RICHARD W. ABBE '53 ~ tandard ,and Enforcement. ERICA N EWTO N works for Fi tzgerald, Abbott GAU DET Joined the Oakland offices of & Beardsley in Oakland. MATTHEW ALAN B. AXELROD '61 rosby, Heafey, Roach & Maya an NORFLEET is an attorney for the U.s. a ociate in December. he practice in Postal Service in an Francisco. STEVE ROBERT K. BOOTH, JR. '65 the firm' tru t and e tate groups. O 'HAGAN work for the Law Office of SAMUEL K. BRANTLEY '38 EUGENE GODWIN is working for Jeffrey Walsh in an Francisco. JOAN the Law Office of William Kennon in PODOLSKY works for Digital Island, a JONATHAN A. COVAULT '95 Tu tin. J U LI E GREY is a judicial clerk network service provider in San RICHARD H. CRAGIN '72 for Judge Barry i1verman in the Franci co, as an attorney in the network Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, in engineering division. JONAH NICHOLAS DERIMAN '51 Ph oenix. M . RAY HARTMAN III is RIVERA works for Winingham, an attorney with Gray, Cary, Ware & Robert, Fama, Kramer & Ramberg in ALAN L. DETHLEFSON '72 Freidenrich in an Diego. TANI an Franci co. NATASHA SPASIC is WILLIAM H. DICK '37 HUE RT A works for the Northern Trust an associate with Zelle H fmann Voelbel Bank of California in an Diego. & Gette in San Francisco. BENJAMIN MARK U. EDWARDS '50 DYLAN HUGHES works for the STOCK works for McDonough, Holl and Department of Labor in an Franci co. & All en in Oakland. SHAN NON ALBERT G. EVANS '32 DAVID HUNTER works for Law & SUPPLE works fo r O'Melveny & HON. EARL B. GILLIAM '57 Partners in Fremont. JAMES ISON Myers in San Franci co. NIRLIP works for Ropers, Majeski, Kohn & SYAN is a law clerk at the U.S. District JAMES A. HAYES '49 Bentley in Redwood City. WARREN Court, orthern Di trict of California, in JACKSON is an as ociate with Filice, an Francisco. THOMAS TUNNY is STEPHEN HEYMAN '86 Brown, Eas a & McLeod in Oakland. an associate with anger & O lson in San FREDERICK A. HINDEN '63 CHAD JACOBS works for the Office Francisco. THOMAS WALLACE is a of the City Attorney in an Francisco. legal research attorney in the criminal STEPHEN H. KAUFMANN '60 AENGUS JEFFERS i an attorney courts divisio n of the San Francisco with Horan, Lloyd, Karachale, Dyer, uperior Court. DANIEL JAMES T. LINDSEY '49 chwartz, Law & Cook in Monterey. J 1- WEISENFELD works fo r Bell, JOSEPH A. MALLERY '57 HYUN HELENA KIM is an a ociate Ro enberg & Hughes in Oakland. JAE with O'Melveny & Myers in Los Angeles. YI i an attorney with Bartko, Zankel, FRANCIS L. MCCARTY '33 CHRISTOPHER LEUNG is a law Tarrant & Miller in San Francisco. NORMAN MELLER '36 clerk for Judge Oliver Wanger in the U.S. KRISTINE Yoo works for Howie Di rrict Cou rt, Eastern District of Long LaForce & Smith in Burlingame. MONS M. NICHOLL '57 California. JENNY LlU work for Gna::oThill in an Francisco. Yupo PRUDENCE K . POPPINK '75 LI U i an attorney for Winterland, a JOHN H. RAMSAUR '74 mu ic and entertainment merchandising company in an Leandro, and prepare ROLAND SELMAN '71 licen ing agreement and conrract . J ILL McINERNEY work for the Law JAMES M . SHIELDS '66 Office of Chri tiane M. Hipps in an WAYNE O. VEATCH, SR. '35 Franci co. C H R IS T OPHER 44 H AST I NGS ALUMNI! LET Us HEAR FROM You Use thi convenient fo rm to update us on yo ur activities. We'll includ yo ur new in the "Class Notes" section of the Has tings Community, and we'll update yo ur alumni records. Information about yo ur profes ional emphas is is especiall y helpful when we are a ked fo r referral from othe r attorneys and a si t us in matching student with prospecti ve alumni me n tors. It al 0 enabl s us to in vite yo u to events of special interest to yo u. Mail this form to Has tings Community, c/ o College Relations, 200 McAlli ter St., Room 209, San Francisco, CA 94102. Photos are es peciaHy appreciated! You also may fax yo ur note to (415) 621-1479, e-mail it to alumni@uchas tings.edu, or submit it via Has tings' Alumni Web Page, accessed through the Has tings H ome Page at www.uchastings.edu. AME ______T O DAY·S DATE ADDRES,______ CITY______STATE ___ ZIP ______ HOME PHONE( GRADUATIO YE A R__ PROFESSIONALEMPHASI S, ______ JOB TITLE ______ BUS INE PHONE ( I ______~X( FIRM ADDRESS,______ CITY ______STATE____ _ ZIP ______ E-MA IL ADDRESS ______ N E WS (Remember to answer the questions "who, what, where, and when" and to include your title and information about your former position, as well as your new position.) . 45 · JUNE 23. 2001 LAKE TAHOE/RENO ALUMNI RECEPTION JULY 2001 NEW STUDENT RECEPTIONS AUGUST 6 , 2001 ABA ANNUAL MEETI N G, ALUMNI RECEPTION , CHICAGO SEPTEMBER 7 . 2001 CALIFORNIA STATE BAR , ALUMNI RECEPTION , ANAHEIM FOR ADDITIONAL EVENTS, VISIT HASTINGS' WEB SITE, WWW.UCHASTINGS . EDU HASTINGS Direccor of College Relations Hastings College of the Law HASTINGS COLLEGE OF THE LAW Board of Directors Nonprofit O rganization University of California U.S. Postage Direccor of Alumni Relations PAID Chair College Relations Dehra Holcomh Permit No. 13797 Eugene L. Freeland ('51) 200 McAllister Street San Francisco, CA Di reccor of Hrut i ngs 1066 San Francisco, CA 94102 Foundation Vice Chair :u:anne eedle, james E. Io- Iahoney ('66) ADDRESS SERVICE REQUESTED Direccor of Publrc Affairs! Maureen E. Corcoran ('79) Edicor, Hastings Community john T Knox (,52) Fr.m l\Ltrsh j,ln Lewenhaupr Design Brian D. Io-I onaghan ('70) flelmela Fern.lnde: tUllio B Hon. Blaine E. Pettitt ('41 ) (,54) Photographs joh n K. ("jack ") nllth Bruce Cook Directors Emeriti Dehra HolCllmh Hun. I-. Iarvm R. Baxter ('66) Fran ~br,h Hon. William R. Channell (, 49) \\'ide \\ brld P11llw, jo~rh \X' Corchett (,64) Prln!lng ~ II ron E. Etienne, jr. (,52) L nlwr,lry 01 Clldornia Hon. LUI, Haight Herringcon ('65) Pnnrm~: nX6 1-.1,,, K. jaml>on (,45) flerkeh, C-\ Kneeland H. Lohner ('44) Hon. Charlene Padov.ml I-. lltchdl Ci7) john A. praul l "ruhil,heJ three time, a year for .lluml1l .md irlend, of the College. Matenal for "Cia" otes" and correspondence are alwa welc he addre,...,J to H"mn~\ CommunI!) c ° College Relation" ,tt 200 \1cAIII,ter treet, Room 209, an FranCISCo CA 94102 or '4nd c-m ·1 t . 1 yc:. I omed andd sh ould , ~ al 0 (,I uml1l <.!J uc 1astlngs.e U). Printed "n RecycleJ P.lrer @