Catholic Discussion of Seventh-Day Adventism
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Catholic Discussion of Seventh-day Adventism by Stephen Korsman Copyright and credits Copyright © Stephen Korsman, 2016 All rights reserved. Permission is granted to distribute this book, as a unit, electronically or in print. Bible sources Bible quotes have been taken from the King James Version, unless otherwise stated. Emphasis will be mine throughout. “...” will indicate verses omitted for brevity. Image credits Cover image: Icon of Christ Crucified, chapel of San Damiano, near Assisi, via WikiMedia Commons, Public Domain, http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Kruis_san_damiano.gif ISBN 978-0-620-72608-5 Other editions: 978-0-620-72609-2 – EPUB edition 978-0-620-72610-8 – Kindle edition 978-0-620-72611-5 – Print edition Further resources Catholic Discussion of Adventism blog – http://blog.theotokos.co.za Twitter: http://twitter.com/CatholicAndSDA Table of Contents Table of Contents..................................................................................................................................1 About the author...................................................................................................................................4 Introduction..........................................................................................................................................5 Section 1 – What Catholics Believe.....................................................................................................6 Chapter 1: What Catholics Believe – Introduction..........................................................................7 Chapter 2: What Catholics Believe – Sunday observance.............................................................10 Section 2: The sabbath........................................................................................................................15 Chapter 3: What does the Old Testament say?..............................................................................16 Chapter 4: What does the New Testament say?.............................................................................18 Chapter 5: The sabbath in the Gospels..........................................................................................24 Chapter 6: Matt 5 – will the law never pass away?.......................................................................28 Chapter 7: Matt 5 vs Heb 7 - who is right?....................................................................................30 Chapter 8: A sabbath commandment in Revelation?.....................................................................31 Chapter 9: It is finished – the law, the sabbath..............................................................................33 Chapter 10: Mark 2/Matt 12/Luke 6 – was the sabbath made for all mankind to keep?...............34 Chapter 11: Matt 24 – pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the sabbath day?.37 Chapter 12: Luke 4 – did Jesus set an example of sabbath keeping for us?..................................39 Chapter 13: John 7 – circumcision on the sabbath........................................................................40 Chapter 14: Matt 28/Mark 16/Luke 24/John 20 – Easter weekend and the sabbath / first day.....41 Chapter 15: Col 2:14-17 – does this refer to the 7th day sabbath?................................................43 Chapter 16: Col 2:16 – a weekly sabbath reference or not? Part 1................................................47 Chapter 17: Col 2:16 – a weekly sabbath reference or not? Part 2................................................50 Chapter 18: Rom 14:5-6 – do we need to keep the sabbath?.........................................................54 Chapter 19: Gal 4:10-11 – do we need to keep the sabbath?.........................................................55 Chapter 20: Hebrews 4 – what is the Christian sabbath?..............................................................56 Chapter 21: 1 Cor 16:2 – regular first day services?.....................................................................58 Chapter 22: 1 Cor 16:2 – Adventists take up monetary offerings on the sabbath?........................60 Chapter 23: Further analysis of 1 Corinthians 16 verses 1-2.........................................................61 Chapter 24: Acts 20:7 – a service on the first day of the week?....................................................70 Chapter 25: Acts 1 – do Christians keep the sabbath in Acts?.......................................................73 Chapter 26: Acts 13 – do Christians keep the sabbath in Acts?.....................................................74 Chapter 27: Acts 15 – do Christians keep the sabbath in Acts?.....................................................78 Chapter 28: Acts 16 – do Christians keep the sabbath in Acts?.....................................................80 Chapter 29: Acts 17 – do Christians keep the sabbath in Acts?.....................................................82 Chapter 30: Acts 18 – do Christians keep the sabbath in Acts?.....................................................84 Chapter 31: Gen 2:2-3 – Did Adam keep the sabbath?..................................................................86 Chapter 32: Isaiah 66 – sabbath keeping in heaven?.....................................................................87 Chapter 33: Isaiah 66 – from one sabbath to another....................................................................89 Chapter 34: Exod 31 / Deut 5 / Neh 9 / Ezek 20 – to whom was the sabbath given, as a sign of what?..............................................................................................................................................90 Chapter 35: The sabbath first revealed to man..............................................................................95 Chapter 36: The sabbath and the Old Covenant, part 1.................................................................97 Chapter 37: The sabbath and the Old Covenant, part 2...............................................................102 Chapter 38: The sabbath and the Old Covenant, part 3...............................................................105 Chapter 39: The 10 Commandments and the New Law in Catholic teaching.............................107 Chapter 40: Is the sabbath moral or ceremonial law?..................................................................123 1 Chapter 41: Rome's challenge to Adventists – prove what you say! aka Constantine, the Papacy, and the real origins of Sunday.....................................................................................................127 Chapter 42: Pope Sylvester I – who changed the sabbath?.........................................................130 Chapter 43: More on Sunday and Pope Sylvester I.....................................................................132 Chapter 44: Adventist misrepresentation of The Constitutions of the Holy Apostles.................134 Chapter 45: Socrates and Sozomen on Christian observance of the sabbath..............................135 Chapter 46: Adventist misrepresentation of St Patrick................................................................138 Chapter 47: Why Sunday is an improvement on the sabbath......................................................139 Chapter 48: Remember the sabbath day – what does “remember” mean....................................142 Chapter 49: From sunset to sunset...............................................................................................144 Chapter 50: 10 Commandments, Pentecost, and the Holy Spirit.................................................145 Chapter 51: St John Chrysostom on the sabbath.........................................................................146 Chapter 52: Will Catholics persecute Adventists for sabbath keeping?......................................147 Chapter 53: The sabbath ended on a Thursday............................................................................148 Section 3: Prophecy..........................................................................................................................149 Chapter 54: Did the papacy really uproot the 3 horns of Daniel 7:8,24?....................................150 Chapter 55: A Catholic understanding of St John's Revelation...................................................157 Chapter 56: Refuting an Adventist theory without providing a replacement theory...................159 Section 4: Dietary laws.....................................................................................................................160 Chapter 57: Clean and unclean meat, part 1................................................................................161 Chapter 58: Clean and unclean meat, part 2................................................................................163 Chapter 59: Debate about Old Testament food laws – Stephen Korsman vs “Annie” Adventist167 Chapter 60: Vegetarianism and Adventism..................................................................................175 Chapter 61: Why a bishop may not drink grape juice.................................................................176 Section 5: The afterlife.....................................................................................................................179 Chapter 62: Soul sleep – are the dead alive in heaven, or not?...................................................180 Chapter 63: And no man hath ascended up to heaven.................................................................188