A in 1927 Director Hans Posse (1879–1942) Estimated This Painting and Other Two Others (Gall
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ANNEX: ATTRIBUTION CHART Nr. Marx, 2005 Hübner, 1876 Morelli, 1880 Woermann, 1887 Morelli, 1891 Woermann, 1908 1 Fra Angelico (school of), Fra Angelico (school of), cat. Benozzo Gozzoli [p. 244] Fra Angelico (school of) Benozzo Gozzoli [p. 337] Fra Angelico (school of) Annunciation, gall. no. 7 no. 17 2 Sandro Botticelli, Virgin and Child Sandro Botticelli, cat. no. 2409 Sandro Botticelli [p. 234] Sandro Botticelli Sandro Botticelli [p. 336] Sandro Botticelli with the Infant Saint John the Baptist, gall. no. 8 3 Sandro Botticelli, From the Life and Sandro Botticelli, cat. no. 26 A Sandro Botticelli [p. 233–234] Sandro Botticelli Sandro Botticelli [p. 336] Sandro Botticelli Work of St. Zenobius, gall. no. 9 4 Sandro Botticelli (school of), Virgin Sandro Botticelli ?, cat. no. 27 Sandro Botticelli (school of) [p. Sandro Botticelli (school of) Sandro Botticelli (school of) [p. Sandro Botticelli (school of) and Child with Angels, gall. no. 10 235] 336] 5 — [Location unknown, Saint John the Sandro Botticelli, cat. no. 25 Sandro Botticelli (school of) [p. Sandro Botticelli (school of) Sandro Botticelli (school of) [p. Sandro Botticelli (school of) Evangelist, formerly gall. no. 11]a 233] 336] 6 — [Location unknown, Saint John the Sandro Botticelli, cat. no. 26 Sandro Botticelli (school of) [p. Sandro Botticelli (school of) Sandro Botticelli (school of) Sandro Botticelli (school of) Baptist, formerly gall. no. 12]b 233] [p. 336] 7 Lorenzo di Credi, Virgin and Child Leonardo da Vinci, Lorenzo di Credi (Dutch copy) Lorenzo di Credi Nordic painter [p. 341 ff.] Lorenzo di Credi with Saint John the Baptist, cat. no. 30 [p. 239–243, 248] gall. no. 13 8 Lorenzo di Credi, Virgin and Child Lorenzo di Credi, cat. no. 2386 Lorenzo di Credi [p. 245] Lorenzo di Credi Lorenzo di Credi [p. 362] Lorenzo di Credi with Saint Sebastian and Saint John the Evangelist, gall. no. 15 9 Filippino Lippi (school of), Virgin and Filippino Lippi, cat. no. 35 Filippino Lippi (school of) [p. Filippino Lippi (school of) Filippino Lippi (school of) [p. Filippino Lippi (school of) Child, gall. no. 19 245–246] 337] 10 Piero di Cosimo, The Holy Family, Luca Signorelli, cat. no. 21 Piero di Cosimo [p. 232–233] Piero di Cosimo Piero di Cosimo [p. 338] Piero di Cosimo gall. no. 20 a In 1927 director Hans Posse (1879–1942) estimated this painting and other two others (gall. nos 12 and 22) at 40,000 reichsmarks and sold them to a Dr. Wendland in Basle via the auction house Fischer in Lucerne, Switzerland. In exchange for these works, the Dresden Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister bought the gall. no. 1888 B (Hans Baldung, Mucius Scaevola, wood, 98 x 68 cm): Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden (SKD), archive, documents (‘Akte’) no. 6, vol. 16, Abgang und Verleihung von Gemälden, 1927/28, folio 106. b See Locatelli 2009/II, as note 1. 11 Raffaellino del Garbo and workshop, Raffaellino del Garbo, cat. no. Filippino Lippi (school of) [p. Raffaellino del Garbo Raffaellino del Garbo (school Raffaellino del Garbo Virgin and Child with Saints, gall. no. 36 246] of) [p. 338] 21 12 — [Location unknown, Virgin Lorenzo di Credi, cat. no. 34 Sandro Botticelli (school of) [p. Florentine, end of the 15th / Lorenzo di Credi Florentine, end of the 15th / Enthroned with Child and Saint John, 245] beginning of the 16th century (contemporary imitator) [p. beginning of the 16th century formerly gall. no. 22]c 361] 13 Sienese, 15th century, The Holy Andrea del Castagno, cat. no. Sienese, second half oft he 15th Sienese, 15th century Sienese, possibly Pietro di Sienese, 15th century Family, gall. no. 33 2381 century [p. 238] Domenico [p. 338] 14 Luca Signorelli (workshop), Painted Luca Signorelli, cat. no. 2384 — Luca Signorelli Luca Signorelli (workshop of) Luca Signorelli (workshop of) Pillar, gall. no. 36 [p. 338] 15 Luca Signorelli (workshop), Painted Luca Signorelli, cat. no. 2384 — Luca Signorelli Luca Signorelli (workshop of) Luca Signorelli (workshop of) Pillar, gall. no. 37 [p. 338] 16 Perugino (school of), Saint Crispin, Perugino ?, cat. no. 22 Perugino (school of) [p. 245] Perugino (school of) Perugino (school of) [p. 362] Perugino (school of) gall. no. 38 17 Bernardino Pinturicchio, Portrait of a Bernardino Pinturicchio, cat. Bernardino Pinturicchio [p. Bernardino Pinturicchio Bernardino Pinturicchio [p. Bernardino Pinturicchio Boy, gall. no. 41 no. 24 245] 361] 18 Umbrian, 15th century, Adoration of Niccolò dell’ Abbate, cat. no. — Marco Palmezzano Peruginische Schule (copy) [p. Marco Palmezzano the Magi, gall. no. 42 169 (supposedly) 362] (supposedly) 19 Francesco del Cossa, Annunciation, Pollaiolo ?, cat. no. 18 Francesco del Cossa [p. 129, Francesco del Cossa Francesco del Cossa [p. 166, Francesco del Cossa gall. no. 43 243–244] 172] 20 Francesco del Cossa, Nativity, gall. no. Florentine school, cat. no. 19 Unknown, second half of the Francesco del Cossa, (school Francesco del Cossa [p. 166] Francesco del Cossa (school 44 15th cenrtury [p. 244] of) of) 21 Ercole de’ Roberti, Christ on the way Ercole de’ Roberti, cat. no. 148 Ercole de’ Roberti [p. 131] Ercole de’ Roberti Ercole de’ Roberti [p. 177] Ercole de’ Roberti to Golgotha, gall. no. 45 22 Ercole de’ Roberti, The Taking of Ercole de’ Roberti, cat. no. 149 Ercole de’ Roberti [p. 131] Ercole de’ Roberti Ercole de’ Roberti [p. 177] Ercole de’ Roberti Christ, gall. no. 46 23 Ercole de’ Roberti (copy), The Florentine school, cat. no. 20 Ercole de’ Roberti (copy) [p. Ercole de’ Roberti (copy) Ercole de’ Roberti (copy) [p. Ercole de’ Roberti (copy) Israelites Gathering Manna, gall. no. 133] 181] 47 24 Francesco Francia, Baptism of Jesus, Francesco Francia, cat. no. 437 Francesco Francia [p. 161] Francesco Francia, Francesco Francia [p. 217] Francesco Francia gall. no. 48 25 Francesco Francia, Adoration of the Francesco Francia, cat. no. 435 Francesco Francia [p. 161] Francesco Francia Francesco Francia [p. 217] Francesco Francia Magi, gall. no. 49 26 Giacomo Francia, Virgin with Child Francesco Francia, cat. no. 436 Francesco Francia (workshop) Giacomo Francia Francesco Francia (workshop) Giacomo Francia and John the Baptist, gall. no. 50 [p. 161] [p. 217] 27 Andrea Mantegna, The Holy Family, — Andrea Mantegna [p. 166] Andrea Mantegna Andrea Mantegna [p. 225, 229] Andrea Mantegna gall. no. 51 c See Locatelli 2009/II, as note 1. 28 Antonello da Messina, Saint Sebastian, Antonello da Messina, cat. no. Antonello da Messina [p. 167– Antonello da Messina Antonello da Messina [p. 235, Antonello da Messina gall. no. 52 2382 168] 250] 29 Giovanni Bellini, (school of), Portrait Giovanni Bellini,cat. no. 210 Giovanni Bellini (copy) [p. Giovanni Bellini (school of) Giovanni Bellini (copy)d [p. Giovanni Bellini (manner of) of the Doge Leonardo Loredan, Half 163] 220] Length Portrait, gall. no. 53 KV 30 Girolamo da Santacroce, Adoration of Girolamo da Santacroce, cat. Girolamo da Santacroce [p. Girolamo da Santacroce Girolamo da Santacroce [p. Girolamo da Santacroce the Child, gall. no. 55 no. 213 166] 234] 31 Girolamo da Santacroce, Girolamo da Santacroce, cat. Girolamo da Santacroce [p. Girolamo da Santacroce Girolamo da Santacroce [p. Girolamo da Santacroce The Martyrdom of Saint Lawrence, no. 214 166] 234] gall. no. 56 32 Jacopo de’ Barbari, Christ Blessing, Jacopo de’ Barbari, cat. no. Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 169, Jacopo de’ Barbari Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 256, Jacopo de’ Barbari gall. no. 57 1802 174] 261] 33 Jacopo de’ Barbari, Saint Catherine, Jacopo de’ Barbari,cat. no. Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 169] Jacopo de’ Barbari Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 255– Jacopo de’ Barbari gall. no. 58 1803 256] 34 Jacopo de’ Barbari, Saint Barbara, Jacopo de’ Barbari, cat. no. Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 169] Jacopo de’ Barbari Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 255– Jacopo de’ Barbari gall. no. 59 1804 256] 35 Jacopo de’ Barbari (manner of), Sandro Botticelli ?, cat. no. 28 Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 170– North Italian Master, beginning Jacopo de’ Barbari [p. 257, Jacopo de’ Barbari Galatea, gall. no. 59A 171, 235] of the 16th century, gall. no. 294 337] 36 Andrea Previtali, Virgin and Child Andrea Previtali, cat. no. 2388 Andrea Previtali [p. 208] Andrea Previtali Andrea Previtali [p. 306] Andrea Previtali with the Infant Saint John the Baptist, gall. no. 60 37 Cima da Conegliano, Christ Blessing, Cima da Conegliano, cat. no. Cima da Conegliano [p. 166] Cima da Conegliano Cima da Conegliano [p. 234] Cima da Conegliano gall. no. 61 215 38 Cima da Conegliano, Christ, gall. no. Cima da Conegliano ?, cat. no. Cima da Conegliano [p. 166] Cima da Conegliano Cima da Conegliano [p. 234] Cima da Conegliano 62 217 39 Cima da Conegliano, Presentation of Cima da Conegliano, cat. no. Cima da Conegliano [p. 166] Cima da Conegliano Cima da Conegliano [p. 234] Cima da Conegliano the Virgin, gall. no. 63 216 40 Pietro degli Ingannati, Virgin with Vincenzo Catena, cat. no. 211 Pier Francesco Bissolo[p. 179] Pier Francesco Bissolo Pier Francesco Bissolo [p. 266] Pier Francesco Bissolo Child and Four Saints, gall. no. 64 41 Vincenzo Catena, Virgin with Child Giovanni Bellini, cat. no. 2387 Giovanni Bellini, (imitator, Giovanni Bellini (school of), Giovanni Bellini (school of) Vincenzo Catena Between Saint Peter and Saint Helena, possibly of Bartolomeo gall. no. 54 [p. 221] gall. no. 64A Veneto) [p. 163–164] 42 Vincenzo Catena, The Virgin and Andrea del Sarto (supposedly), Vincenzo Catenae [p. 179] Vincenzo Catena Vincenzo Catena [p. 267] Vincenzo Catena d Morelli recognized Giovanni Bellini’s Portrait of Doge Leonardo Loredan at the National Gallery in London (inv. NG 189) as the original of this painting. e Joseph Archer Crowe and Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle were the first to attribute this painting to Vincenzo Catena: Joseph Archer Crowe, Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle, eds, A History of Painting in North Italy. Venice, Padua, Vicenza, Verona, Ferrara, Milan, Friuli, Brescia.