Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador Royal Commission on Renewing and Strengthening Our Place in Canada Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador By: Christopher Dunn March 2003 The views expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not necessarily refl ect those of the Royal Commission on Renewing and Strengthening Our Place in Canada. Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador Acknowledgements The author gratefully acknowledges the insightful comments on this paper made by Douglas Brown, Frank O’Brien, and the two anonymous reviewers. Any errors of fact or interpretation are, of course, the responsibility of the author. Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador Contents Introduction ........................................................................................................................39 Concepts of Representation...........................................................................................41 Territorialism and Representation Theory..............................................................41 Political Representation.............................................................................................42 Representative Bureaucracy .....................................................................................42 Reconciliation .............................................................................................................43 Theories of Federalism....................................................................................................45 The Evolving Role of the Function of Representation in Federal Institutions...........................................................................................................................47 The Present Role of the Function of Representation in Federal Institutions.......47 The House of Commons ........................................................................................47 The Senate of Canada ............................................................................................47 The Federal Cabinet...............................................................................................48 The Federal Courts and Judicial Hierarchies in the Provinces ..............................49 The Federal Public Service ....................................................................................50 Summary................................................................................................................51 Literature on the Evolving Role of Representation in Federal Institutions .........52 Lack of Intrastate Federalism.................................................................................52 National and Regional Effects of the Electoral System and Representation by Population ..............................................................................................................54 Decline of Regional Ministers ...............................................................................54 Defi ciencies Muting the Regional Role of M.P.s...................................................55 A Senate Based on Regions but Not Representing Them......................................55 Federal Judicial Appointments...............................................................................56 Insuffi ciently Representative Bureaucracy? ..........................................................57 Summary................................................................................................................58 Representation of Newfoundlanders and Labradorians in Federal Institutions Since 1949 ....................................................................................................61 Proportionate Representation in Federal Institutions............................................61 Representation Without Power.................................................................................64 The Secret Nation.......................................................................................................65 Survey of Major Options For Representation Reform .......................................69 Centralist Arrangements...........................................................................................71 Cooperative/Collaborative Federalist Arrangements.............................................71 Intrastate Arrangements ...........................................................................................73 Asymmetrical Arrangements ....................................................................................73 Third-Party or Hybrid Bodies ..................................................................................74 Method of Selection....................................................................................................75 Equality Versus Non-equality of Representation....................................................75 Functions and Types of Powers of Upper Houses ..................................................76 Appointment Procedures...........................................................................................77 Canadian-made Suggestions:.................................................................................77 Federal Representation of the People and Government of Newfoundland and Labrador International Models:.............................................................................................77 Provincial Involvement..............................................................................................78 Transparency vs. Obscurity ......................................................................................78 Enlarging the Supreme Court...................................................................................78 Problems in Establishing the Provincial “Representativeness” of the Federal Bureaucracy................................................................................................................79 An Explicit Policy on Territorial Representation ...................................................80 Conclusion and Recommendations.............................................................................83 The Changed Environment.......................................................................................83 The Basis of the Recommendations..........................................................................85 Long-term Strategies .................................................................................................86 Short-term Alternatives.............................................................................................87 General Federalism Issues .....................................................................................87 Intergovernmental Forums.....................................................................................87 Senate Reform........................................................................................................88 Legislative Reform.................................................................................................89 Cabinet Reform......................................................................................................90 Electoral Reform....................................................................................................90 Bureaucracy Reform ..............................................................................................90 Memorial University..............................................................................................91 Judicial Reform......................................................................................................91 Endnotes..................................................................................................................................93 Appendix 1...............................................................................................................................99 House of CommonsRepresentation Formula: Detailed Calculation for 2001 Census....................................................................................................................99 Appendix 2 ............................................................................................................................101 Regional Distribution of Federal Cabinet Ministers at the Beginning of Each Ministry................................................................................................................101 Appendix 3.............................................................................................................................103 Arguments For and Against Regionalization of the Federal Court and the Tax Court of Canada ...................................................................................................103 Appendix 4 ............................................................................................................................107 Region of Work for Departments and Agencies Coming Under Treasury Board Jurisdiction, March 2001 .....................................................................................107 Appendix 5.............................................................................................................................109 Change in Level of Federal Employees1 By Department in Newfoundland and Labrador Since 1995............................................................................................109
Recommended publications
  • The Criminalization of Stalking: an Exercise in Media Manipulation and Political Opportunism Rosemary Cairns Way*
    The Criminalization of Stalking: An Exercise in Media Manipulation and Political Opportunism Rosemary Cairns Way* Canada's new criminal harassment law criminalizes Los nouvelles dispositions canadiennes sur le harchle- behaviour more commonly known as "stalking". The stalk- ment criminel visent Acriminaliser un comportement com- ing law was the centrepiece of Bill C-126, a government ini- mundment d6sign6 par -stalking-i. Elles sont au coeur du tiative responding to increased public concern about vio- projet de loi C-126 qui rdpond ax inquidtudes croissantes lence against women and children. The author critically du public concernant la violence faite aux fenssnes et aux analyzes the stalking initiative as three phases of a "moral enfants. L'auteure analyse de fagon critique cette initiative panic". She argues that the combined impetus of media gouvernementale en ]a matihre, la qualifiant de ,ipanique manipulation and political opportunism led to the swift moraleo, en trois phases. Elle soutient que la manipulation enactment of Bill C-126 and resulted in an inadequate mddiatique et l'opportunisme politique sont b l'origine de response to the complex issue of violence against women. l'adoption rapide du projet de loi C-126, ce qui explique son The first phase of this "moral panic" was characterized incapacitd Afaire face A]a complexitd de la violence faite by the media's role in defining and sensationalizing the aux femmes. threatening behaviour. The typical media portrayal of stalk- La premihre phase de cette opanique morales a 6 ing incidents played upon a cultural pornographic imagina- caractdrisde par le sensationalisme des mdias quant h la tion.
    [Show full text]
  • The Requisites of Leadership in the Modern House of Commons 1
    Number 4 November 2001 CANADIAN STUDY OF PARLIAMENT GROUP HE EQUISITES OF EADERSHIP THE REQUISITES OF LEADERSHIP IN THE MODERN HOUSE OF COMMONS Paper by: Cristine de Clercy Department of Political Studies University of Saskatchewan Canadian Members of the Study of Parliament Executive Committee Group 2000-2001 The Canadian Study of President Parliament Group (CSPG) was created Leo Doyle with the object of bringing together all those with an interest in parliamentary Vice-President institutions and the legislative F. Leslie Seidle process, to promote understanding and to contribute to their reform and Past President improvement. Judy Cedar-Wilson The constitution of the Canadian Treasurer Study of Parliament Group makes Antonine Campbell provision for various activities, including the organization of conferences and Secretary seminars in Ottawa and elsewhere in James R. Robertson Canada, the preparation of articles and various publications, the Counsellors establishment of workshops, the Dianne Brydon promotion and organization of public William Cross discussions on parliamentary affairs, David Docherty participation in public affairs programs Jeff Heynen on radio and television, and the Tranquillo Marrocco sponsorship of other educational Louis Massicotte activities. Charles Robert Jennifer Smith Membership is open to all those interested in Canadian legislative institutions. Applications for membership and additional information concerning the Group should be addressed to the Secretariat, Canadian Study of Parliament Group, Box 660, West Block, Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0A6. Tel: (613) 943-1228, Fax: (613) 995- 5357. INTRODUCTION This is the fourth paper in the Canadian Study of Parliament Groups Parliamentary Perspectives. First launched in 1998, the perspective series is intended as a vehicle for distributing both studies prepared by academics and the reflections of others who have a particular interest in these themes.
    [Show full text]
  • Mortgage Defaulting Premiers Ask Caution
    : P~OV]:N~ r_,-~ ' , : ,.r~.', ..,.....,~ ''~," PARLI~T.-:;: ' ~';,'~ ;3 YX(II'O!~[A (J L; Winter• food hikes ar e on th e way annualOTTAWA autumn (CP) drop in foodThe level at the same time last The index is based on a mers to raise fluid milk beef prices. This puts the they jumped by 2.8 per cent would be greater if apples The beard recommends year. survey of a typical basket of . prices by two cents a quart beef component of the index during October. prices has. ended, says the . The board blames the in- 68grocery items in 60 super- Oct. 1. had not dropped in price by consumers take advantage 4l.S per cent higher thanone Tl~e board blames ad- 10.4 per cent as the new federal anti-inflation board, crease on higher prices for markets across Canada. Although retail beef prices of cheap apples to bring In its monthly report on beef, pork, oranges and most Milk costs were up one per year ago. vanees in the price of ira- harvest came on the market. down the cost of its weekly have not climbed back to Pork prices have also risen ported oranges-combined Fresh vegetabJe prices food prices, the board says fresh vegetables. The only cent during October. The zheir mid-summer peak nutritious diet. its foodat-home price index ' bright spots in the food doard attributed this in- substantially, partly because with the low value of the were up 3.6 per cent. This The diet, which fulfills all prices, there was a 5.8-per- consumers are buying pork Canadian dollar-- for most increase also was attributed L Jumped during October by survey were a decline in the crease to a decision of the cent jump in prices for the nutrition requirements for a 1.9 per cent.
    [Show full text]
  • The Unfulfilled Promise of Information Management in the Government of Canada
    DRAFT for discussion only Not for publication without the permission of the author The Unfulfilled Promise of Information Management in the Government of Canada David C.G. Brown Doctoral Candidate, Carleton University Senior Associate, Public Policy Forum Ottawa Abstract The advent of new information and communications technologies in the 1990s gave a more prominent role to information management (IM) as a discipline of public administration, offering the prospect of knowledge-based government in the knowledge- based economy and society. In the federal government, the promise of IM enabled by networked computing and database technologies has been highlighted by the move towards citizen-centred service and the provision of information-based services to the public. There has also been a growing recognition in many areas of government that their knowledge base is a defining element and a significant asset. This promise has not been fully realized, however, for a number of reasons. These include the historical neglect of information and records management in public administration, compounded by the lack of a unified understanding of what those activities encompass or even of how they relate to each other. There has also been a weak recognition and consequent undervaluing of information as a public resource, compounded by increasingly poor management of that resource in the electronic era. Vulnerabilities arise across the board, from the practices of individual public servants to government-wide ‘enterprise’ information architecture. The treatment of IM as a sub-set of the management of information technology has been another limiting factor, as have wariness at the political level and a weak connection to senior public service governance structures and the public sector reform agenda.
    [Show full text]
  • Three Views of Atlantic Canada's Future
    THREE VIEWS OF ATLANTIC CANADA’S FUTURE Three people who have thought a lot about the problems of Atlantic Canada and what to do about them are Brian Crowley, President of the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies, Elizabeth Beale, President of the Atlantic Provinces Economic Council and Wade Locke, professor of economics at Memorial University. Policy Options’ editor William Watson sought their views on the region’s problems and what to do about them in a conference call in the second week of November. Au cours de la deuxième semaine de novembre, le rédacteur en chef d’Options politiques, William Watson, s’est entretenu par téléphone avec trois personnes qui ont longuement étudié les problèmes des provinces atlantiques et les solutions à y apporter, soit Brian Crowley, président du Atlantic Institute for Market Studies, Elizabeth Beale, présidente du Conseil économique des provinces atlantiques, et Wade Locke, professeur d’économique à la Memorial University. William Watson: I’d like to begin by ask- approach to business climate and so the reason for that poor performance. ing each of you for your overall view of on—lagging regions catch up with There’s a whole series of reasons for the questions I’d like to discuss today: more advanced regions at a rate of that but most have to do with the How would you characterize the poli- somewhere between two and three per excessive politicization that it intro- cies that Atlantic Canada has been cent a year. If you look at what we’ve duces into economic decision-making favoured (or cursed) with in the past? done in Atlantic Canada, we have not in the region.
    [Show full text]
  • Treasury Board Secretariat
    TREASURY BOARD SECRETARIAT PRESENTATION TO THE COMMITTEE OF EXPERTS OF THE MECHANISM FOR FOLLOW-UP ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE INTER-AMERICAN CONVENTION AGAINST CORRUPTION (MESICIC) FIFTH ROUND OF REVIEW APRIL 25-27, 2017 Values and Ethics, Office of the Chief Human Resources Officer Objectives 1 To give you an overview of the Canadian Federal Public Service 2 To give you an overview of the role of the Treasury Board Secretariat 3 To speak to Values and Ethics in the Public Sector 2 Structure of the Executive Branch Prime Minister Cabinet Cabinet Committees Treasury Board Central Agencies Public Service Commission Privy Council Office Treasury Board Secretariat Hiring Policy Department of the Prime Minister Management Office Staffing investigations Government’s Policy Agenda Budget Office Oversight of Political Activities People Management Departments 3 The Treasury Board Secretariat (TBS) • TBS: – Is a central agency and the administrative arm of the Treasury Board, providing advice and support to Treasury Board ministers by managing TB meetings and providing written advice – Is a department with roughly 1800 employees*. – Is led by the Secretary (deputy minister) and two other deputy ministers: the Comptroller General of Canada and the Chief Human Resources Officer. – Provides guidance to management functions within departments. – Provides direction, leadership and capacity building for functional communities across government (e.g. financial officers, human resources advisors, audit executives, etc.). • TBS supports TB in its four
    [Show full text]
  • Alternative North Americas: What Canada and The
    ALTERNATIVE NORTH AMERICAS What Canada and the United States Can Learn from Each Other David T. Jones ALTERNATIVE NORTH AMERICAS Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars One Woodrow Wilson Plaza 1300 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, D.C. 20004 Copyright © 2014 by David T. Jones All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, scanned, or distributed in any printed or electronic form without permission. Please do not participate in or encourage piracy of copyrighted materials in violation of author’s rights. Published online. ISBN: 978-1-938027-36-9 DEDICATION Once more for Teresa The be and end of it all A Journey of Ten Thousand Years Begins with a Single Day (Forever Tandem) TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction .................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1 Borders—Open Borders and Closing Threats .......................................... 12 Chapter 2 Unsettled Boundaries—That Not Yet Settled Border ................................ 24 Chapter 3 Arctic Sovereignty—Arctic Antics ............................................................. 45 Chapter 4 Immigrants and Refugees .........................................................................54 Chapter 5 Crime and (Lack of) Punishment .............................................................. 78 Chapter 6 Human Rights and Wrongs .................................................................... 102 Chapter 7 Language and Discord ..........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Seven Vie for Three Council Seats the Daily Herald
    !,E,]I~I.,'~'/.~ I.~:~?: ~:Y, C~:£P.77178 : . ,:.. ,'.". :.. • ~,~ ..., :.. V8V-l>;~ Mayor acclaimed t~.rry Duffas John McCormac Lily Mielson Alan Sontar Seven vie for three council seats '-: ": .Dave Maroney Jack Tals/ra Doug Mumford Helmut Giesbreeht BY DONNA VALLIERES years. No one opposed Helmut Giesbrecht and two years, has said he Gerry Duffus, a former and varied issues but must of Skeenaview Lodge. assist the present ad- ., :.HERALDSTAFF WRITER Maroney for the mayor's Jack Talstra, also filed wants to continue because alderman on Terrace continue the important Lily Mielsen, lists herself ministration m becoming seat, so he will be elected by. nomination . papers he's practically/an old hand council who describes functions of looking after on her nomination papers- more efficient and thus put '. "Th_i_ngs .have definitely as a domestic engineer. She to better use the tax ~d~d up oa .the local acclamation. yesterday. at council business, himself as a property sewage, drainage, roads "electina scene with a sur- As for the ~est of council, Giesbrecht, a teacher with and sxdewalks. said "you must get in- dollar." seven persons have an- two years experience on Painter John MacCorrnac volved" in order to un- A more aggressive ~Prldng,vnsh of candidates campaign should be m effect declaring their intentions nounced their bids for three council, has stated he will will try for the first time to derstand an issue." aldermanic seats up for seek re-election because of. More election news enter municipal politics as • A resident of Terrace to r~luce the big overhead ~a~lnd~Y,f~ nomination since 1959, Mielsea said she on the arena and swimming • _ positions on grabs this term.
    [Show full text]
  • Upcoming Events
    Newsletter Vol XIV No.1 Summer 2017 IN LUMINE Rob ’65 and Penny Richards, Jocelyn Barnard ’63 and Judy Waters ‘63, Joan McConnell ‘78 and Stirling Walkes ‘64. This Issue UPCOMING EVENTS Convocation 2016 3 For more information on these and other events held at the Celebrating 150 Years 5 college please call Amy on 204-474-8531 Lunch & Lively Conversation College Events 9 Tuesday, 12th September at noon Jeffrey Thorsteinson discusses the architecture of the Fellow/Staff News 12 Chapel Alumni/Student News 14 Matriculation: Sunday, 17th September at 3pm In Memoriam 17 Convocation: Sunday, 5th November IN LUMINE SUMMER 2017 1 Warden’s Word! Being the Tenth Epistle by Christopher Trott For me, the most moving moment do we create, build and main- at our Gala 150th weekend was at tain those personal relationships lunch on Saturday. Ted Gammon within the overwhelming context stood up to speak and asked people of the University of Manitoba? to remember those from the College The key places where students who had passed away. He read out (and Faculty) meet and connect names from his years at the College are the Daily Bread, the stu- and then invited others to join in dent lounge and the carrel study and call out the names of people rooms. This summer, in coopera- from their years who had passed on. tion with the St John’s College Then Ted continued by reading out Student Association, we are a list of names of those people who Chris along with wife Terry Reilly refinishing and refurbishing the greet guests to the 150th Gala had sent their regrets, who could student lounge.
    [Show full text]
  • The Liberals: a House Divided Introduction
    The Liberals: A House Divided Introduction “I will fulfill my mandate and focus entirely on governing from now until February Focus 2004. At which time my work will be done and at which time my successor will be In an unprec- chosen. And then, at the age of 70, I will look back with great satisfaction as I take edented move against a sitting my rest with Aline, secure in the knowledge that the future of Canada is unlim- Canadian prime ited.” — Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, August 21, 2002 minister, a signifi- cant number of Struggle for Power media and political organizers, the buzz Liberal Party mem- The summer of 2002 will be remem- about his future grew louder and louder. bers appeared The Martin camp was particularly ready to vote bered for both the hot weather and the against Jean equally hot political battle waged within active in promoting their man for the Chrétien in a the ranks of the Liberal Party of next leadership campaign. They built a planned leadership Canada. Open political warfare raged powerful organization and raised sub- review next year. inside the heart of Canada’s most stantial funds. Incensed by this pressure The split in the to leave, Chrétien and Martin had a Liberal camp was successful political machine. A party highlighted this that traditionally rallied around its falling out, and Martin left cabinet. spring when Paul leader appeared ready to tear itself apart Liberals were increasingly divided Martin, one of the over the question of leadership. and feared an open battle at a planned main contenders to After the Liberal victory of 2000, convention to review Chrétien’s leader- replace the PM, attention was drawn to the question of ship in February 2003.
    [Show full text]
  • Celgene Corporation Appellant V. Attorney General of Canada
    [2011] 1 R.C.S. CELGENE CORP. c. CANADA (P.G.) 3 Celgene Corporation Appellant Celgene Corporation Appelante v. c. Attorney General of Canada Respondent Procureur général du Canada Intimé Indexed as: Celgene Corp. v. Canada Répertorié : Celgene Corp. c. Canada (Attorney General) (Procureur général) 2011 SCC 1 2011 CSC 1 File No.: 33579. No du greffe : 33579. 2010: November 10; 2011: January 20. 2010 : 10 novembre; 2011 : 20 janvier. Present: McLachlin C.J. and Binnie, LeBel, Deschamps, Présents : La juge en chef McLachlin et les juges Binnie, Fish, Abella, Charron, Rothstein and Cromwell JJ. LeBel, Deschamps, Fish, Abella, Charron, Rothstein et Cromwell. ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF EN APPEL DE LA COUR D’APPEL FÉDÉRALE APPEAL Legislation ­— Statutory interpretation — Scope of Législation — Interprétation législative — Portée des the Patented Medicine Prices Review Board’s price- pouvoirs de réglementation des prix et de réparation du regulating and remedial authority — Meaning of “sold Conseil d’examen du prix des médicaments brevetés — in any market in Canada” — Whether concept should Signification de « vente [. .] sur l[e] march[é] cana- be interpreted in accordance with commercial law prin- dien » — Le concept doit-il être interprété en fonction ciples or be responsive to surrounding legislative con- des principes du droit commercial ou doit-il plutôt être text and purpose — Patent Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. P-4, défini d’une manière qui tienne compte du contexte et de ss. 80(1)(b), 83(1), 85. l’objet de la législation pertinente? — Loi sur les brevets, L.R.C. 1985, ch. P-4, art.
    [Show full text]
  • The Forgotten Irish? Contested Sites and Narratives of Nation in Newfoundland"
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Érudit Article "The Forgotten Irish? Contested sites and narratives of nation in Newfoundland" Johanne Devlin Trew Ethnologies, vol. 27, n° 2, 2005, p. 43-77. Pour citer cet article, utiliser l'information suivante : URI: http://id.erudit.org/iderudit/014041ar DOI: 10.7202/014041ar Note : les règles d'écriture des références bibliographiques peuvent varier selon les différents domaines du savoir. Ce document est protégé par la loi sur le droit d'auteur. L'utilisation des services d'Érudit (y compris la reproduction) est assujettie à sa politique d'utilisation que vous pouvez consulter à l'URI https://apropos.erudit.org/fr/usagers/politique-dutilisation/ Érudit est un consortium interuniversitaire sans but lucratif composé de l'Université de Montréal, l'Université Laval et l'Université du Québec à Montréal. Il a pour mission la promotion et la valorisation de la recherche. Érudit offre des services d'édition numérique de documents scientifiques depuis 1998. Pour communiquer avec les responsables d'Érudit : [email protected] Document téléchargé le 9 février 2017 02:59 THE FORGOTTEN IRISH? THE FORGOTTEN IRISH? Contested sites and narratives of nation in Newfoundland Johanne Devlin Trew1 Queen’s University Belfast Newfoundland was entering a limbo… We had admitted, neither for the first nor the last time, that nationhood was a luxury we could not afford (Wayne Johnston, The Colony of Unrequited Dreams). The Irish in Newfoundland have developed their culture and identity over the past 300 years in the context of the island’s changing political status from independent territory to British colony, and to Canadian province (since 1949).
    [Show full text]