ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Buildings Energy Efficiency Funding Schemes under the Environment and Conservation Fund

Purpose

This paper seeks –

(a) Members’ agreement to approve 76 funding applications and not to accept 14 funding applications for the Energy-cum-carbon Audits Projects (ECA) and Energy Efficiency Projects (EEP) of the Buildings Energy Efficiency Funding Schemes (BEEFS) under the Environment and Conservation Fund (ECF); and

(b) Members’ support to seek approval from the ECF Committee for two funding applications of values exceeding HK$2.0 million for the EEP of the BEEFS under the ECF.

Summary

2. Upon closing of the BEEFS on 7 April 2012, a total of 233 and 1,771 applications were received for ECA and EEP respectively. Since the circulation of papers for the Energy Conservation Projects Vetting Sub-committee’s (ECPVSC) approval in August 2012, 92 funding applications have been vetted. Out of these 92 applications, 76 funding applications are recommended for approval, 13 funding applications are recommended not to accept due to inadequate information received for assessment, one is not recommended to accept due to the project had commenced before ECPVSC’s approval and two funding applications of value exceeding HK$2.0 million are recommended for seeking approval from ECF Committee.

3. In addition to the above, nine funding applications were withdrawn by the applicants which are listed below.

Projects withdrawn by the Applicants

Project No. Applicant Funding Sought Energy Efficiency Project – The Owners' Committee of $87,789.00 Jardine Summit Jardine Summit (Ref. EEP-0722)

- 1 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project No. Applicant Funding Sought Energy Efficiency Project – The Owners’ Committee of $20,541.50 Convention Plaza Convention Plaza Apartments Apartments (Ref. EEP-1066) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of $208,588.00 Summit Building Summit Building (Ref. EEP-1071) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of $43,724.00 Foo Tat Building Foo Tat Building (Ref. EEP-1104) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of Fu $15,055.00 Fu Yau Building Yau Building (Ref. EEP-1130) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of $156,500.00 Hong Sing Garden Hong Sing Garden (Ref. EEP-1328) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of $39,000.00 Hong Sing Garden Hong Sing Garden (Ref. EEP-1329) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of $109,550.00 Peal Garden Peal Garden (Ref. EEP-1673) Energy Efficiency Project – The Incorporated Owners of $686,000.00 Shatin Park Stage I Shatin Park Stage I (Ref. EEP-1755)

$1,366,747.50

4. The following 13 applications have been rejected with the reason that inadequate information have been received from the applicants despite sending at least two reminder letters and a conclusion letter to each applicant. Thus, the information provided in the application is inadequate for the assessment to proceed further.

Projects Rejected with Inadequate Information

Project No. Application Funding Sought

- 2 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project No. Application Funding Sought One Silver Sea, Energy Efficiency EEP-0970 $86,619.20 Project Shan King Estate, Energy Efficiency EEP-0994 $556,225.00 Project Bonny View House, Energy EEP-1027 $228,835.00 Efficiency Project Man Hoi Mansion, Energy Efficiency EEP-1105 $223,000.00 Project Cable TV Tower, Energy Efficiency EEP-1210 $89,100.00 Project Pauline Building, Energy Efficiency EEP-1255 $300,000.00 Project Oriental Garden, Energy Efficiency EEP-1317 $158,540.00 Project Yan Lee Building, Energy Efficiency EEP-1380 $214,000.00 Project EEP-1475 JC Place, Energy Efficiency Project $166,100.00 Hankow Centre, Energy Efficiency EEP-1520 $2,000,000.00 Project Lung Yan Court, Energy Efficiency EEP-1616 $174,500.00 Project Far East Bank (Mongkok) Building, EEP-1625 $500,000.00 Energy Efficiency Project Hilltop Gardens, Energy Efficiency EEP-1631 $236,666.00 Project $4,933,585.20

5. The following application has been rejected with the reason that the proposed project had commenced works before the approval from the ECPVSC. Thus, the assessment of this application is unable to proceed further.

Project No. Application Funding Sought Ha Lung Building, Energy Efficiency EEP-1391 $299,000.00 Project $299,000.00

6. The following 76 funding applications with the applied funding of value not exceeding HK$2.0 million are recommended for consideration.

- 3 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Projects Recommended for Approval

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Casa De Oro of Casa De Oro to May 2013 See Note 1 (Ref. EEP-0880) (Annex I) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Siu Hei Court of Siu Hei Court to July 2013 (Ref. EEP-0949) (Annex II) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Tsui Man of Tsui Man Court to March 2013 Court (Ref. EEP-0990) (Annex III) Energy Efficiency The Owners’ Committee of March 2013 to Project – Grand December 2014 Promenade (Ref. EEP-1056) (Annex IV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Hong Sing of Hong Sing Garden to July 2013 Garden (Ref. EEP-1181) (Annex V) Energy Efficiency Le Prestige Owners October 2012 to Project – Le Prestige Sub-Committee July 2013 (Ref. EEP-1243) (Annex VI) Energy Efficiency Owners’ October 2012 to Project – Kornhill Committee February 2013 (Ref. EEP-1254) (Annex VII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Botania Villa of Botania Villa August 2013 (Ref. EEP-1301) (Annex VIII) Energy Efficiency The Owners’ Committee of December 2012 Project – Leighton Hill to November (Ref. EEP-1304) 2013 (Annex IX)

- 4 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Cliffview of Cliffview Mansion March 2014 See Note 1 Mansion (Ref. EEP-1307) (Annex X) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners March 2013 to Project – Tong Nam of Tong Nam Mansion August 2013 Mansion (Ref. EEP-1314) (Annex xI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Royal Knoll of Royal Knoll to October 2013 (Ref. EEP-1318) (Annex XII) Energy Efficiency Lido Garden Owners’ October 2012 to Project – Lido Garden Committee April 2014 (Ref. EEP-1323) (Annex XIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Wing Lock of Wing Lock House August 2013 House (Ref. EEP-1334) (Annex XIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Baycrest of Baycrest to January 2014 (Ref. EEP-1339) (Annex XV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Tung Yu of Tung Yu Building August 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1345) (Annex XVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Tung Yu of Tung Yu Building November 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1346) (Annex XVII)

- 5 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Harbour Court of Harbour Court January 2015 See Note 1 (Ref. EEP-1348) (Annex XVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Chiu Tat of Chiu Tat Factory to March 2015 Factory Building Building (Ref. EEP-1349) (Annex XIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Winfair of Winfair Building May 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1350) (Annex XX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Lead On of Lead On Industrial to March 2015 Industrial Building Building (Ref. EEP-1352) (Annex XXI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Che Wah of Che Wah Building June 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1356) (Annex XXII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Ming Nga of Ming Nga Court to February 2014 Court (Ref. EEP-1358) (Annex XXIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Baycrest of Baycrest to February 2014 (Ref. EEP-1362) (Annex XXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Kam Lung of Kam Lung Court March 2013 Court (Ref. EEP-1365) (Annex XXV)

- 6 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners February 2013 to Project – Fok Lin of Fok Lin Building October 2013 See Note 1 Building (Ref. EEP-1381) (Annex XXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Hilton Towers of Hilton Towers to February 2014 (Ref. EEP-1384) (Annex XXVII) Energy Efficiency Owner’s February 2013 to Project – The Cullinan Sub-Committee December 2013 (Ref. EEP-1395) (Annex XXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Kingsway of Kingsway Industrial March 2014 Industrial Building Building (Phase I & II) (Ref. EEP-1397) (Annex XXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Yue Yan of Yue Yan Mansion to June 2014 Mansion (Ref. EEP-1399) (Annex XXX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Hillier of Hillier Building to July 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1400) (Annex XXXI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Federate of Federate Building to July 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1401) (Annex XXXII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – On Wo Yuen of On Wo Yuen State One to September State One 2013 (Ref. EEP-1402) (Annex XXXIII)

- 7 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Fortress of Fortress Garden December 2013 See Note 1 Garden (Ref. EEP-1405) (Annex XXXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Wai Cheung of Wai Cheung Industrial March 2014 Industrial Centre Centre (Ref. EEP-1407) (Annex XXXV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners April 2013 to Project – Foon Tak of Foon Tak Building June 2014 Building (Ref. EEP-1409) (Annex XXXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Yuk Ming of Yuk Ming Towers to May 2013 Towers (Ref. EEP-1411) (Annex XXXVII) Energy Efficiency (Phase November 2012 Project – Tsuen King 2) Owners Committee to June 2013 Garden (Phase 2) (Ref. EEP-1412) (Annex XXXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Greenville of Greenville Gardens June 2014 Gardens (Ref. EEP-1415) (Annex XXXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Yuen Long of Yuen Long Shun Fat to August 2014 Shun Fat Building Building (Ref. EEP-1417) (Annex XL) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Evergreen of Evergreen Towers to December Towers 2014 (Ref. EEP-1418)

- 8 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought (Annex XLI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Castel Peak of Castel Peak Villas to November See Note 1 Villas 2014 (Ref. EEP-1421) (Annex XLII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Yue Yick of Yue Yick Building October 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1423) (Annex XLIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Gallant House of Gallant House March 2014 (Ref. EEP-1426) (Annex XLIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners May 2013 to Project – Westland of Westland Heights April 2014 Heights (Ref. EEP-1430) (Annex XLV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners April 2013 to Project – Castle Peak of Castle Peak Villas January 2014 Villas (Ref. EEP-1431) (Annex XLVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Midland of Midland Centre February 2013 Centre (Ref. EEP-1432) (Annex XLVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Evergreen of Evergreen Villa to March 2014 Villa (Ref. EEP-1435) (Annex XLVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners May 2013 to Project – Kwong Ga of Kwong Ga Factory April 2014 Factory Building Building (Ref. EEP-1443) (Annex XLIX)

- 9 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners May 2013 to Project – Eightland of Eightland Gardens October 2014 See Note 1 Gardens (Ref. EEP-1446) (Annex L) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Cloudview of Cloudview Mansion March 2014 Mansion (Ref. EEP-1447) (Annex LI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – Technology of Technology Plaza to March 2014 Plaza (Ref. EEP-1453) (Annex LII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners March 2013 to Project – Fullview of Fullview Garden March 2014 Garden (Ref. EEP-1459) (Annex LIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners February 2013 to Project – Tak Lee of Tak Lee Building December 2013 Building (Ref. EEP-1460) (Annex LIV) Energy Efficiency Harbour Green Owners’ December 2012 Project – Harbour Green Committee to September (Ref. EEP-1461) 2013 (Annex LV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners December 2012 Project – Wah Chi of Wah Chi Mansion to May 2014 Mansion (Ref. EEP-1462) (Annex LVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Kam Yu of Kam Yu Building March 2014 Building (Ref. EEP-1463) (Annex LVII)

- 10 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners May 2013 to Project – Fu Yu Court of Fu Yu Court April 2014 See Note 1 (Ref. EEP-1465) (Annex LVIII) Energy Efficiency Owners’ Committee of November 2012 Project – Kornhill Kornhill Gardens to August 2013 Gardens (Ref. EEP-1472) (Annex LIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners March 2013 to Project – Kai Tsui Court of Kai Tsui Court November 2013 (Ref. EEP-1480) (Annex LX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Kin Tai House of Kin Tai House October 2013 (Ref. EEP-1498) (Annex LXI) Energy Efficiency Tierra Verde Owner’s February 2013 to Project – Tierra Verde Sub-Committee April 2014 (Ref. EEP-1561) (Annex LXII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners February 2013 to Project – Yue Tak of Yue Tak Building March 2014 Building (Ref. EEP-1624) (Annex LXIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Ka To of Ka To Building June 2014 Building (Ref. EEP-1630) (Annex LXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners March 2013 to Project – Kam Hay of Kam Hay Court June 2014 Court (Ref. EEP-1634) (Annex LXV)

- 11 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners May 2013 to Project – Sam Ying of Sam Ying Building April 2014 See Note 1 Building (Ref. EEP-1643) (Annex LXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners May 2013 to May Project – Kam Foo of Kam Foo Industrial 2014 Industrial Building Building (Ref. EEP-1644) (Annex LXVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Kwun Tong of Kwun Tong Mansion January 2014 Mansion (Ref. EEP-1652) (Annex LXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners January 2013 to Project – Lee May of Lee May Building March 2014 Building (Ref. EEP-1677) (Annex LXIX) Energy Efficiency Central Park / December 2012 Project – Central Park / Residential Owners’ to June 2013 Park Avenue Sub-committee (Ref. EEP-1754) (Annex LXX) Energy-cum-carbon The Owners' Committee of June 2013 to June Audit – Aqua Marine Aqua Marine 2016 (Ref. ECA-0223) (Annex LXXI) Energy-cum-carbon The Incorporated Owners August 2012 to Audit – Kundamal of Kundamal House March 2016 House (Ref. ECA-0224) (Annex LXXII) Energy-cum-carbon The Incorporated Owners September 2012 Audit – Visalia Garden of Visalia Garden to October 2015 (Ref. ECA-0228) (Annex LXXIII)

- 12 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy-cum-carbon The Incorporated Owners July 2012 to Audit – W Place of W Place August 2015 See Note 1 (Ref. ECA-0230) (Annex LXXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners November 2012 Project – No. 103-105 of No. 103-105 Fuk Wing to December Fuk Wing Street Street 2013 (Ref. EEP-1425) (Annex LXXV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated Owners October 2012 to Project – Pak On of Pak On Building September 2014 Building (Ref. EEP-1438) (Annex LXXVI)

$26,522,737.50

7. The following funding applications with the applied funding of value exceeding HK$2.0 million are recommended for seeking approval from the ECF Committee.

Projects recommended for seeking approval from the ECF Committee

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2013 to Project – Affluence Owners of Affluence August 2014 See Note 1 Garden Garden (Ref. EEP-1375) (Annex LXXVII) Energy Efficiency Owners’ Committee of November 2012 to Project – Kornhill Kornhill Gardens November 2014 Gardens (Ref. EEP-1471) (Annex LXXVIII) $4,750,000.00

- 13 - ECPVSC Paper 11/2012-13 For Discussion

Advice sought

8. Members are invited to support the recommendation as detailed in paragraph 6 & 7 above.

The Electrical and Mechanical Services Trading Fund September 2012

Note 1 : Please refer to the website of the Buildings Energy Efficiency Funding Schemes www.building-energy-funds.gov.hk

- 14 -