Dark Matter and Collider Phenomenology of Non-Universal Gaugino Masses
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Dark Matter and Collider Phenomenology of Non-Universal Gaugino Masses A dissertation presented by Michael Holmes to The Department of Physics In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the field of Physics Northeastern University Boston, Massachusetts April, 2010 1 c Michael Holmes, 2010 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED 2 Dark Matter and Collider Phenomenology of Non-Universal Gaugino Masses by Michael Holmes ABSTRACT OF DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Physics in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Northeastern University, April, 2010 3 Abstract Signals of minimal supersymmetric models with non-universalities in the gaugino sector of the theory are analyzed at the CERN Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and in experiments searching for dark matter. Signals of dark matter including direct and indirect detection are investigated at depth in various supersymmetric frameworks. The parameter space of deflected mirage mediation, in which the soft terms receive contributions from the three main supersymmetry breaking mediation mechanisms, is investigated with emphasis on the neutralino sector and dark matter signals. The potential for non-universal gaugino masses to explain the recent CDMS II data is studied and possible implications for indirect dark matter detection experiments and LHC signatures are considered. Collider implications of non- universalities in the gaugino sector are examined with attention paid to specific signatures which are targeted to track the non-universalities. Further, the complementarity of dark matter and collider measurements is discussed with emphasis on breaking model degeneracies which may arise in LHC data. 4 Acknowledgements The work presented here was carried out with my Advisor, Professor Brent Nelson (North- eastern University), and with collaborators Dr. Ismet Altunkaynak (Northeastern Univer- sity), Professor Gordon Kane (University of Michigan) and Dr. Phillip Grajek (University of Michigan and currently at KEK). • I would like to thank my Thesis Committee: Professors Brent Nelson, Pran Nath and Emanuela Barberis for all the help and guidance over the years. • I would also like to thank the Northeastern University Physics department and its members for support and help during my graduate career and in particular Professors Haim Goldberg and George Alverson. • I offer many thanks to my colleague Dr. Ismet Altunkaynak for all the help and useful discussions over the years. • I offer the sincerest thanks and appreciation to Professor Brent Nelson. I have been privileged to have you as my Advisor over the years and I truly appreciate all your guidance and support during my time at Northeastern. • Finally, I would like to thank my family. 5 Contents Abstract 4 Acknowledgements 5 1 Introduction and Overview 9 2 The MSSM 13 2.1 The MSSM framework . 13 2.1.1 Particle content . 14 2.1.2 Review of global and local SUSY . 16 MSSM 2.1.3 WMSSM and Lsoft ............................ 19 2.2 High scale models . 22 2.3 Higgs potential and EWSB . 23 2.4 Superpartner masses . 25 2.5 Gaugino sector . 29 2.6 Signals of SUSY . 31 2.6.1 Dark matter . 31 2.6.2 Colliders . 32 3 Dark matter and the LSP 33 3.1 Relic density . 34 3.2 Direct detection . 36 3.3 Indirect detection . 40 4 Dark matter signals in deflected mirage mediation 45 4.1 DMM parameter space . 45 6 4.2 Survey of DM signatures . 55 4.2.1 Relic density . 55 4.2.2 Direct detection . 58 4.2.3 Gamma rays . 61 4.2.4 Muons . 65 4.2.5 Anti-Matter from cosmic rays . 66 4.2.6 Benchmarks . 68 4.3 Summary . 71 5 Dark matter signals of non-universal gaugino masses? 72 5.1 Benchmark models for CDMS II signal . 73 5.2 Other DM signals . 78 5.3 LHC signatures . 82 5.4 Summary . 84 6 LHC phenomenology of non-universal gaugino masses 86 6.1 Background . 87 6.2 Benchmarks . 89 6.3 Signature lists and distinguishing models . 90 6.4 Benchmark model LHC analysis . 93 6.5 Summary . 101 7 Lifting model degeneracies in LHC data using dark matter observations 102 7.1 LHC inverse problem . 102 7.2 Classifying degenerate pairs . 105 7.3 Direct detection . 108 7.4 Gamma rays . 117 7.5 Summary . 123 7 8 Conclusions 127 9 Appendix 130 Bibliography 133 8 Chapter 1 Introduction and Overview At the time of this writing the high energy community is entering a very exciting era. Up until now the Standard Model (SM) has been our best understanding of Nature which has been rigorously backed up by experimental observations. The SM is not complete however as it does not include neutrino masses (for example) and hence there must be some Beyond-the- Standard Model (BSM) physics. With data taking at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) on the brink of occurring soon there may be new exciting evidence for BSM physics [1]. There are an array of possibilities for what the BSM physics may be and many are motivated from a high scale theory. Among the possible theories of BSM physics supersymmetry (SUSY) is highly-motivated for reasons such as gauge coupling unification and the existence of a solution to the hierarchy problem. Another intriguing property of SUSY is that the minimal extension of the SM includes a possible explanation for the dark matter (DM) problem, which was discovered after the model was proposed. The general SUSY framework is described in terms of the Minimal Supersymmetric Stan- dard Model (MSSM) and the parameter space is large, of dimension 124. Many possible experimental outcomes may result within the MSSM framework, and in particular the gau- gino sector of the theory is very compelling as it is relevant for the DM properties as well as signatures which may arise at the LHC. By signatures we refer to distinct final state topologies which arise from decays of supersymmetric particles such as trilepton final states, for example. The gaugino sector of SUSY also offers clues as to the nature of SUSY breaking which is very important to understand. It gives insight to the type of string-inspired model or Grand Unified Theory (GUT) which may govern the nature of the SUSY breaking. The 9 gaugino sector of the MSSM is intimately related to the dark matter particle within the MSSM, as well as to understanding the nature of SUSY breaking in general, it is therefore very interesting. In this thesis the work focuses on non-universal guagino masses (NUGM), which result in a rich low scale gaugino sector of the MSSM and therefore of possible dark matter observables along with corresponding LHC signatures which soon may be discovered. From a high scale perspective SUSY is the low scale effective theory of string theory. There are many possible string theories which currently exist and if SUSY is discovered it may offer support in the direction of string theory. String theories generally suffer from a stabilization problem associated with the scalar fields in the theory resulting in unstable vacua. Recent work suggests methods for stabilizing the vacuum in a string theory require the existence of multiple sources of SUSY breaking to contribute to the soft SUSY terms which results in non-universal gaugino masses. One such scenario has recently been introduced called deflected mirage mediation (DMM) in which gravity, anomaly and gauge mediated SUSY breaking mechanisms may be simultaneously present. An analysis is given here on the prospects of neutralino dark matter within the DMM model framework and what possible observations are possible. It is shown that there exist regions of the parameter space where all three mediation mechanisms are present and give a thermal relic abundance of neutralinos in line with the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP). Direct detection, and indirect detection including gamma ray, muon and anti-matter experiments are considered, and the investigated parameter space is shown to be in line with current experimental bounds. Discovery prospects are discussed for relevant upcoming experiments. Recently a possible signal of dark matter may have been observed by the CDMS II direct detection experimental group. An explanation for the observed dark matter scattering events can be explained quite readily within the context of Minimal Supergravity (mSUGRA) with non-universal gaugino masses. An analysis is given which can explain the possible dark matter signal using the mSURGA + NUGM. Furthermore various other dark matter signals are given along with a basic survey of LHC signatures expected for such models. 10 There exists a string motivated framework, called mirage mediation, in which the gaugino masses can be parametrized by a single non-universality parameter. This scenario is a simplified version of the DMM model in which no gauge mediation contributes. This offers a convenient way to study the effects of such non-universal gaugino masses, specifically the resulting LHC signatures. Two possible string scenarios are parametrized in such a way and the resulting LHC properties are given. The integrated luminosity necessary to differentiate the values of the non-universality parameter are given for the models along with further analysis of LHC signatures and model properties. An important issue is also the so-called LHC inverse problem. This arises when more than one set of model parameters can fit the LHC data, thus resulting in degenerate theory models which describe the data. A analysis is given by which degenerate SUSY models at the LHC are used to investigate the utility of dark matter observables to untangle the model degeneracies. The degenerate pairs can have gaugino sectors which involve non-universalities and hence interesting dark matter signals. Specifically direct detection and indirect gamma ray detection experiments are investigated and it is shown that they can be quite helpful at resolving the inverse problem.