DOCSLIB.ORG

The Temporal Dimension of Justice

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Temporal Dimension of Justice THE TEMPORAL DIMENSION OF JUSTICE Doctoral thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Graz submitted by Santiago Truccone-Borgogno at the Institute of Philosophy First expert assessor: Univ.-Prof. Dr. Lukas H. Meyer Second expert assessor: Univ.-Prof. Dr. Andreas Føllesdal 2021 1 To Romina 2 This page intentionally left blank 3 Acknowledgments This dissertation has been possible due to the support of many people and institutions. I hope to mention, in these lines all those who have so generously contributed in one way or another to this work. I first want to express my gratitude to my supervisor Lukas Meyer, with whom I have repeatedly discussed different parts of this dissertation. I thank him not only for his challenging insights with respect to all the different parts of my work but also for his support and counseling. His guidance immeasurably contributed to my academic and personal growth during my doctoral studies. I am also immensely grateful to my doctoral advisor Timothy Waligore who was always supportive while challenging my views and arguments. Without their guidance and support, this dissertation would not have been possible. A special thanks go to the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) as this work is part of research undertaken in the project “Supersession of Historical Injustice and Changed Circumstances,” funded by the research grant P 30084. Since coming to the University of Graz, I have learnt much about philosophy from my colleagues Laura- García-Portela, Seung Hyun Song, Rutger Lazou, Laura Siggelkow, Eike Düvel, Thomas Pölzler, Harald Stelzer, Norbert Paulo, Elias Moser, Daniel Petz, Pranay Sanklecha, Monica Cano-Abadía, Annika Böddeling, Adriana Placani, Kian Mintz-Woo, Susana Monsó, Jonathan Knutzen, Romina Rekers, Barbara Reiter, Sabine Hohl, Jeroen Hopster and Antoinette Scherz. A special thanks to Anna Klieber, Klemens Wieringer, and Lena Remich, without whose support and help, my first days in Graz would have been more challenging. I would also like to thank Gunter Schüßler, Patricia Hodajeu, Katharina Hiebaum, Benjamin Paul Hofbauer, and Benedikt Namdar for their help in the last stages of the project Supersession. The same goes for Deborah Biging, Daniel Lassnig and Henrike Sannecke. I also benefited greatly from the theoretical discussions I had with them. I am tremendously grateful to Kanita Kovacevic, who helped me countless times with the many issues I had to deal with in moving to Graz and during all these years. I also want to thank my colleagues from the Austrian Climate Research Program (ACRP) project LEXAT: Legitimate Expectations and Austria’s Transformation to a Low-Carbon Society and Economy, financed by the Austrian Klimafonds: Karl Steiniger, Eva Schulev-Steindl, Keith Williges, Miriam Hofer and Stefan Nabernegg. The discussions I had with them definitely improved the quality of this work. I also benefited from discussions with colleagues from the School of Law at the University of Graz. I want to thank to Christian Hiebaum, Matthias Klatt, Wolfgang Benedek, Hector Moralez-Zúñiga, Lisa Sonnleitner and Carolina Alves das Chagas. I benefited further from questions and comments from my students of the course I taught at the University of Graz, The Moral Dimensions of Harm. I would like to especially thank Eduardo Rivera-Lopez for discussing several parts of this dissertation at different events and for hosting me at Torcuato Di Tella University (Buenos Aires) when I was doing research there. I am also indebted to the free and public education system of Argentina. My previous studies at the Córdoba National University, and my previous position at CONICET and at the Center for Legal and Social Research of the Law School of Córdoba National University have undoubtedly contributed to this work. I presented different parts of this work at many conferences, workshops, and seminars in Europe and Latin America. I want to thank the attendees and participants of all of them, but especially thank the participants of the workshop The Temporal Orientation of Justice held at the University of Graz in 2018. Thanks to Jeremy Waldron, Andrei Marmor, Jeff Spinner-Halev, Amy Hondo, Daniel Butt, Burke Hendrix, Gordon Christie, Julio Montero, and Kerstin Reibold. I hope I could incorporate their comments, objections, and criticism in improving this work. Thanks to the members of the United Kingdom Latin American Political Philosophy Network (UKLPPN), and to those of the Research Group of the Article 19 of the Argentinian National Constitution (Córdoba National University) with whom I had discussions that, I hope, have advanced my scholarly work. Special thanks go to, Francisco García-Gibson, Juan Espíndola, Marcelo de Araujo, Maria Victoria Kristan, Juan Iosa, Carlos Villanueva and Jaqueline Brito. I would also like to thank 4 Cecilia Carrizo and Mauricio Berger, who helped me find a venue in Argentina for discussing many of the dissertation topics. The same gratitude goes for Daniel Loewe, who allowed me to discuss the supersession thesis at the University Adolfo Ibañez in Chile. Roberto Gargarella invited me to scrutinize part of my work with constitutional scholars of Argentina in the inaugural event of the Argentinian chapter of ICON-S. During these and other events, I had the opportunity to improve my work thanks to the comments and objections of many people. I want to specially thank to Mariela Tulian, Silvina Ramirez, Leticia Morales, Fernando Lizárraga, Catherine Lu, Esteban Llamosas, Anna Stilz, Ezequiel Monti, Gustavo Beade, Guillermo Lariguet, Andrej Kristan, Emanuel Olivares, Valeria Plaza, Ignacio Giufre, Vladimir Chorny, Liv Nielsen, Santiago Mollis, Isabel Lifante-Vidal, Ignacio Colombo, Josep Aguiló-Regla, Nahuel Maisley, Daniel Gonzales-Lagier, Liliana Ronconi, Cristian Dimitriu, Macario Alemani, Carmen Pavel, Manuel Atienza, Ramiro Moyano, Victoria Roca, Marco Billi, Fergus Green, Leandro Dias, Rodrigo Sanchez- Brígido and Alessandro Pinzani. A special “lockdown” thanks goes out to Lucas Misseri and Anna Bugajska for the remote on-line reunions during the pandemic that became regular bi-weekly meetings in which we discussed our draft papers. I am also incredibly grateful to Suyai Garcia-Gualda, whom I only meet in the last part of the dissertation but whose knowledge about the indigenous peoples in Argentina, particularly about the Mapuce communities, helped me revise many of my earlier arguments and views. My dissertation owes much to their comments. I thank Bruce Straight for editing my English and raising several questions and objections that helped me improve this dissertation. I also thank Otto and Ruth Reisch. During the many months when I was alone in Graz because my wife had to be in another country, they always made sure that I did not lack anything. They have always made my life in Graz easier. I would especially like to thank my parents Marcela and Pablo, my grandparents Esther and Nelso, and my brother Rodrigo. I could not have written this dissertation without their support. It has been almost two years since I have seen them in person, but despite the separation their support has been essential for me. Finally, I would especially like to thank my wife Romina Rekers for her robust and continual support. She was always there – in the difficult times and also in the exceptionally good ones. She helped me in my journey by moving to Graz, making my life unmeasurably happier and being at my side whenever I needed advice or psychological and emotional support. As she is also my colleague, she also helped me a great deal with her sharp and challenging philosophical arguments at various workshops, academic events, and seminars in which I presented my work. Without exaggeration, she has hear and discussed countless times every line of this dissertation. ¡Gracias! 5 This page intentionally left blank 6 This page intentionally left blank 7 TABLE OF CONTENTS Declaration of Authorship .....................................................................................................12 Abbreviations ........................................................................................................................14 INTRODUCTION: THE SUPERSESSION OF HISTORICAL INJUSTICES ............16 I. Redistribution, Compensation, and the Temporal Orientation of Justice.................... 19 II. Challenges to the Supersession Thesis ........................................................................ 23 i. The Conquest of the Desert ......................................................................................... 24 ii. Climate Change and the Distribution of the Remaining Global Carbon Budget ........ 26 III. Outline of the Project .................................................................................................. 29 IV. Principles, Examples, and Reflective Equilibrium ...................................................... 38 V. Critical Morality and Practical Problems .................................................................... 43 1. ON HOW TO JUDGE THE PAST: THE CONQUEST OF THE DESERT .............48 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 48 I. The Conquest of the Desert ......................................................................................... 49 II. The Denial of the Unjust Character of the Conquest of the Desert ............................. 51 III. Beneficial Consequences Do Not Justify the Conquest of the Desert
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Conflicts and Cooperation in the Mountainous Mapuche Territory (Argentina) the Case of the Nahuel Huapi National Park
    Journal of Alpine Research | Revue de géographie alpine 98-1 | 2010 Parcs nationaux de montagne et construction territoriale des processus participatifs Conflicts and cooperation in the mountainous Mapuche territory (Argentina) The case of the Nahuel Huapi National Park Renaud Miniconi and Sylvain Guyot Electronic version URL: http://journals.openedition.org/rga/1151 DOI: 10.4000/rga.1151 ISSN: 1760-7426 Publisher Association pour la diffusion de la recherche alpine Electronic reference Renaud Miniconi and Sylvain Guyot, « Conflicts and cooperation in the mountainous Mapuche territory (Argentina) », Revue de Géographie Alpine | Journal of Alpine Research [Online], 98-1 | 2010, Online since 15 April 2010, connection on 19 April 2019. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/ rga/1151 ; DOI : 10.4000/rga.1151 La Revue de Géographie Alpine est mise à disposition selon les termes de la licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International. Conflicts and cooperation in the mountainous Mapuche territory (Argentina) The case of the Nahuel Huapi National Park Renaud Miniconi*, Sylvain Guyot** *Independent Geographer, Limoges. [email protected] **UMR 604 CNRS GEOLAB, Limoges University. [email protected] Abs rac : Over the past two decades, realities are more contrasted due to indigenous issues have ,ecome a ma-or regional sta6eholders2 divergent interests. concern for different countries all over In the particular conte9t of Argentina, the world. Argentina is one of these where a large part of the population countries, with 600 000 people who faces pro,lems gaining access to land, recogni.e themselves as indigenous, national par6s have emerged as a representing 1.01 of the nation2s entire relevant tool for indigenous peoples to population.
    [Show full text]
  • Urban Ethnicity in Santiago De Chile Mapuche Migration and Urban Space
    Urban Ethnicity in Santiago de Chile Mapuche Migration and Urban Space vorgelegt von Walter Alejandro Imilan Ojeda Von der Fakultät VI - Planen Bauen Umwelt der Technischen Universität Berlin zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Doktor der Ingenieurwissenschaften Dr.-Ing. genehmigte Dissertation Promotionsausschuss: Vorsitzender: Prof. Dr. -Ing. Johannes Cramer Berichter: Prof. Dr.-Ing. Peter Herrle Berichter: Prof. Dr. phil. Jürgen Golte Tag der wissenschaftlichen Aussprache: 18.12.2008 Berlin 2009 D 83 Acknowledgements This work is the result of a long process that I could not have gone through without the support of many people and institutions. Friends and colleagues in Santiago, Europe and Berlin encouraged me in the beginning and throughout the entire process. A complete account would be endless, but I must specifically thank the Programme Alßan, which provided me with financial means through a scholarship (Alßan Scholarship Nº E04D045096CL). I owe special gratitude to Prof. Dr. Peter Herrle at the Habitat-Unit of Technische Universität Berlin, who believed in my research project and supported me in the last five years. I am really thankful also to my second adviser, Prof. Dr. Jürgen Golte at the Lateinamerika-Institut (LAI) of the Freie Universität Berlin, who enthusiastically accepted to support me and to evaluate my work. I also owe thanks to the protagonists of this work, the people who shared their stories with me. I want especially to thank to Ana Millaleo, Paul Paillafil, Manuel Lincovil, Jano Weichafe, Jeannette Cuiquiño, Angelina Huainopan, María Nahuelhuel, Omar Carrera, Marcela Lincovil, Andrés Millaleo, Soledad Tinao, Eugenio Paillalef, Eusebio Huechuñir, Julio Llancavil, Juan Huenuvil, Rosario Huenuvil, Ambrosio Ranimán, Mauricio Ñanco, the members of Wechekeche ñi Trawün, Lelfünche and CONAPAN.
    [Show full text]
  • Picone on Larson, 'The Conquest of the Desert: Argentina's Indigenous Peoples and the Battle for History'
    H-LatAm Picone on Larson, 'The Conquest of the Desert: Argentina’s Indigenous Peoples and the Battle for History' Review published on Wednesday, June 30, 2021 Carolyne R. Larson, ed. The Conquest of the Desert: Argentina’s Indigenous Peoples and the Battle for History. Diálogos Series. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 2020. Illustrations. 256 pp. $29.95 (paper), ISBN 978-0-8263-6207-0. Reviewed by María de los Ángeles Picone (Boston College)Published on H-LatAm (June, 2021) Commissioned by Casey M. Lurtz (Johns Hopkins University) Printable Version: https://www.h-net.org/reviews/showpdf.php?id=55740 In 1879, the government of Argentina unleashed a military campaign to northern Patagonia, known at the time as the “Conquest of the Desert.” What was the desert? For the Sarmientine generation, it was the vast lands that surrounded economic centers, unproductive, uninhabited, and usually beyond state control. Of course, the desert was far from empty. In fact, the raid of 1879 sought disarticulate indigenous chiefdoms in present-day Río Negro, Neuquén, and La Pampa. Behind the soldiers came authorities surveying, dividing, planning, and selling lands to whomever was willing to move to the “new” territories. This was the official story. The Conquest of the Desert joins a vast literature that challenges the official narrative of the Argentina military raid of 1879.[1] By shifting the attention to the experiences of Mapuche and Tehuelche living in northern Patagonia, this volume highlights the kaleidoscopic impacts of the violent removal of indigenous peoples from their territories during the raid and its aftermath. The volume brings together scholars from Argentina, the United States, and Canada in different stages of their careers and from different disciplines.
    [Show full text]
  • Aspects of Social Justice Ally Work in Chilean Historical Fiction: the Case of the Pacification of Araucanía
    Aspects of Social Justice Ally Work in Chilean Historical Fiction: The Case of the Pacification of Araucanía Katherine Karr-Cornejo Whitworth University Abstract Majority-culture writers often depict cultures different from their own, but approaching cultures to which an author does not belong can be challenging. How might we read dominant-culture portrayals of marginalized cultures that tell stories of injustice? In this paper I utilize the frame of identity development in social justice allies in order to understand the narratives dominant-culture authors use in fiction to reflect sympathetic views of indigenous justice claims. In order to do so, I study three historical novels set in Araucanía during the second half of the nineteenth century, considering historiographical orientation, representation of cultural difference, and understanding of sovereignty:Casas en el agua (1997) by Guido Eytel, Vientos de silencio (1999) by J.J. Faundes, and El lento silbido de los sables (2010) by Patricio Manns. I will show that fiction, even in validating indigenous justice claims, does not overcome past narratives of dominance. Representations can deceive us. The Mapuche warriors of Alonso de Ercilla’s epic poem La Araucana are safely in the past, and their cultural difference poses no threat to present-day nor- mative Chilean culture. However, that normative culture glorifies these fictional representations on the one hand and deprecates Mapuche communities today on the other. How did that hap- pen? Various Mapuche groups resisted Spanish colonization for centuries, restricting European expansion in today’s southern Chile. After Chilean independence from Spain in the early nine- teenth century, the conflict continued.
    [Show full text]
  • Studies in Comparative Federalism
    STUDIES IN COMPARATIVE FEDERALISM STUDIES IN COMPARATIVE FEDERALISM Argentina, the United States and Mexico Antonio María Hernández Autoridades UNC Rector Dr. Hugo Oscar Juri Vicerrector Dr. Ramón Pedro Yanzi Ferreira Secretario General Ing. Roberto Terzariol Prosecretario General Ing. Agr. Esp. Jorge Dutto Directores de Editorial de la UNC Dr. Marcelo Bernal Mtr. José E. Ortega Hernández, Antonio María Studies in comparative federalism: Argentina, The United States and Mexico / Antonio María Hernández. - 1a ed. - Córdoba: Editorial de la UNC, 2019. Libro digital, PDF Archivo Digital: descarga y online ISBN 978-987-707-120-7 1. Federalismo. 2. Constitucionalismo. 3. Sistemas Políticos. I. Título. CDD 321 Diseño de colección, interior y portada: Lorena Díaz Diagramación: Marco J. Lio ISBN 978-987-707-120-7 Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, 2019 CONTENTS Chapter I. A conceptual and methodological preamble 11 1. Introduction 11 2. Concepts and characteristic elements of federalisms 12 2.1 Origin and denomination 12 2.2 Federalism as a form of State 16 2.3 Concepts and essential characteristics of federal states 18 3. Classification of federalisms 22 3.1 Integrative and devolutive 22 3.2 Symmetrical and asymmetrical 22 3.3 Dual and coordinate 23 3.4 Centralized or decentralized 24 3.5 With presidential or parliamentary governments 25 3.6 For the purpose of division of power or identity-related 26 4. An interdisciplinary and realist methodology for the study of federalisms 27 5. The risks and importance of comparative studies 28 Chapter II. Comparative constitutional reflections on federalism in Argentina and The United States 33 1. Introduction 33 PART 1.
    [Show full text]
  • A Brief History of Argentina
    A Brief History of ArgentinA second edition JonAtHAn c. Brown University of Texas at Austin A Brief History of Argentina, Second Edition Copyright © 2010, 2003 by Lexington Associates All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage or retrieval systems, without permission in writing from the publisher. For information contact: Facts On File, Inc. An imprint of Infobase Publishing 132 West 31st Street New York NY 10001 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Brown, Jonathan C. (Jonathan Charles), 1942– A brief history of Argentina / Jonathan C. Brown. — 2nd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-8160-7796-0 1. Argentina—History. I. Title. F2831.B88 2010 982—dc22 2010004887 Facts On File books are available at special discounts when purchased in bulk quantities for businesses, associations, institutions, or sales promotions. Please call our Special Sales Department in New York at (212) 967-8800 or (800) 322-8755. You can find Facts On File on the World Wide Web at http://www.factsonfile.com Excerpts included herewith have been reprinted by permission of the copyright holders; the author has made every effort to contact copyright holders. The publishers will be glad to rectify, in future editions, any errors or omissions brought to their notice. Text design by Joan M. McEvoy Maps and figures by Dale Williams and Patricia Meschino Composition by Mary Susan Ryan-Flynn Cover printed by Art Print, Taylor, Pa. Book printed and bound by Maple-Vail Book Manufacturing Group, York, Pa.
    [Show full text]
  • Leoni Martinez
    Conference Proceedings : Fields Of Conflict, 2016; Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland http://fieldsofconflict.com CHALLENGES AND SPECIFICITIES OF BATTLEFIELD ARCHAEOLOGY IN ARGENTINA : T HE CASE OF C EPEDA BATTLEFIELD , 1859 Juan B. Leoni CONICET (Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas) – Departamento de Arqueología, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Argentina. [email protected] Lucas H. Martínez Instituto Cultural de la Provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina. [email protected] ABSTRACT The battle of Cepeda, 1859, was one of the high points in the crucial confrontation between the Argentine Confederation and the then rebellious Buenos Aires Province, which shaped the process of modern nation state building. Whereas the confederate army commanded by president Justo J. Urquiza defeated the provincial army led by Bartolomé Mitre, this victory would not be decisive and more fighting would follow until Buenos Aires’ definitive triumph in 1861. The battle has only been studied by historians, using the contradictory commanders’ battle reports. This paper presents the archaeological research on the battlefield. We discuss methods, finds, and interpretations, but also use this case study to address three major issues that differentiate this battlefield study from contemporary European and North American cases: 1) Heterodox battle tactics, which combined Napoleonic style tactics for infantry and artillery, with a locally developed emphasis on irregular and light cavalry; 2) A lack of written sources on both weapons employed and specific details of the battle; 3) Landscape transformations that significantly altered the original battle ground. As a whole, these issues - a widespread occurrence in Argentine XIXst century battles - challenge the development of battlefield studies and pose limitations to its interpretive potential.
    [Show full text]
  • Extractivism and Sacrifice Zones in Argentine Patagonia
    Connecticut College Digital Commons @ Connecticut College Anthropology Department Honors Papers Anthropology Department 2020 The Altar of National Prosperity: Extractivism and Sacrifice onesZ in Argentine Patagonia Jonathan Gomez-Pereira Connecticut College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.conncoll.edu/anthrohp Part of the Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons Recommended Citation Gomez-Pereira, Jonathan, "The Altar of National Prosperity: Extractivism and Sacrifice onesZ in Argentine Patagonia" (2020). Anthropology Department Honors Papers. 18. https://digitalcommons.conncoll.edu/anthrohp/18 This Honors Paper is brought to you for free and open access by the Anthropology Department at Digital Commons @ Connecticut College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Anthropology Department Honors Papers by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Connecticut College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The views expressed in this paper are solely those of the author. The Altar of National Prosperity: Extractivism and Sacrifice Zones in Argentine Patagonia Jonathan Gomez-Pereira 2020 Honors Thesis Presented to the Department of Anthropology Connecticut College New London, CT Thesis Advisor: Professor Catherine Benoît, Department of Anthropology ​ First Reader: Professor Leo Garofalo, Department of History ​ Contents Acknowledgements…………………………………..……………………..……………..……....3 Abstract………………….……………………………………………………………………...…5 Introduction………………………..…………..…………………………………………………..6
    [Show full text]
  • Coloniality and Anglican Missions in Argentine Patagonia in the Nineteenth Century
    humanities Article Lux et Tenebris? Coloniality and Anglican Missions in Argentine Patagonia in the Nineteenth Century Hugo Córdova Quero Department of Theology, Starr King School for the Ministry, Oakland, CA 94623, USA; [email protected] Abstract: Within the modern capitalist World-System, Missionary work was mostly developed through the connubiality with colonial powers. The missionary work of the Anglican Church is no exception. This article centers on the missionary enterprise carried out in Argentine Patagonia in the nineteenth century. Missionaries’ reports carefully narrated that venture. However, the language and the notions underlying the missionary work’s narration reveal the dominion of colonial ideologies that imbued how religious agents constructed alterity. Connecting the missionaries’ worldview with the political context and expansion of the British Empire allows us to unfold the complex intersections of religious, ethnic, racial, and geopolitical discourses that traverse the lives of indigenous peoples in South America. Keywords: Anglican missions; Argentine Patagonia; British Empire; Missionary reports 1. Introduction “Thus, we lived from week to week, seeking according to the grace given to us to be useful in opening the eyes of these poor people to see and follow the light of God’s truth, and to love and serve their God and Saviour”. Citation: Córdova Quero, Hugo. Thomas Bridges (Kirby 1871, pp. 140–41; emphasis mine) 2021. Lux et Tenebris? Coloniality With those words, the Anglican missionary Rev. Thomas Bridges concluded his report and Anglican Missions in Argentine to the South American Missionary Society (SAMS) for 1871 (Kirby 1871, pp. 137–41). His Patagonia in the Nineteenth Century. report was part of the work carried out by the missionaries in South America, who covered Humanities 10: 36.
    [Show full text]
  • Indigenismo and Mapuche Politics in Chile, 1920-1960
    Syracuse University SURFACE Dissertations - ALL SURFACE May 2018 To Plow a Lonely Furrow: Indigenismo and Mapuche Politics in Chile, 1920-1960 Henry John Stegeman Syracuse University Follow this and additional works at: https://surface.syr.edu/etd Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons Recommended Citation Stegeman, Henry John, "To Plow a Lonely Furrow: Indigenismo and Mapuche Politics in Chile, 1920-1960" (2018). Dissertations - ALL. 878. https://surface.syr.edu/etd/878 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the SURFACE at SURFACE. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations - ALL by an authorized administrator of SURFACE. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Abstract This study examines Mapuche political organization in Chile from 1920-1960 through the lens of transnational indigenismo. In that period, politicians, academics and social reformers across the Americas were questioning how to incorporate indigenous populations into modern national states. While many historical accounts of similar phenomena in other countries have drawn categorical distinctions between indigenismo (as a movement led by white elites) and indigenous activism (led by Indians themselves), this work places the two phenomena side-by-side to explore connections between them. That approach shows that collaboration, periodic conflict and strategic alliance making were important components of indigenous politics in Chile. It also brings indigenous agency to the fore, and in doing so challenges historical interpretations of indigenismo that have characterized it as a paternalistic mechanism of the neocolonial state. It joins a growing body of scholarship that recognizes indigenismo as an important influence on and precursor to identity-based indigenous social movements that emerged in the late-twentieth century.
    [Show full text]
  • Biblioteca Del Gioja 9. HISTORIA
    ajoiG led acteoilbiB AIROTSIH .9 Traducción del CDUCDU CDU AUTOR / RESPONSABLE TITULO LUGAR EDITOR AÑOAÑO AÑOSin ISBN IDIOMA NOTAS DESCRIPTOR Adquisición títulotítulo título 930930 930 Introducción a la filosofía de la historia A769A769 A769 : ensayo sobre los límites de la 950-516- Historia. Filosofía de la historia. Aron, Raymond Buenos Aires Siglo veinte 1984 español 19841984 1984 objetividad histórica : completado con 378-9 Objetividad histórica. T° 1T° 1 T° 1 textos recientes. T° I 930930 930 Introducción a la filosofía de la historia A769A769 A769 : ensayo sobre los límites de la 950-516- Historia. Filosofía de la historia. Aron, Raymond Buenos Aires Siglo veinte 1984 español 19841984 1984 objetividad histórica : completado con 378-9 Objetividad histórica. T° 2T° 2 T° 2 textos recientes. T° II 930930 930 La semiotica: teorías del signo y el Fondo de cultura 968-16- Historia. Lenguaje de la historia. Dr. Levaggi B566B566 B566Beuchot, Mauricio México 2004 español lenguaje en la historia económica 7189-9 Semiótica. Teoría del signo. UBACyT D006 20042004 2004 930930 930 La filosofía de la historia en la Universidad Nacional B894B894 B894Bruning, Walther Córdoba 1961 Sin ISBN español Historia. Filosofía de la historia. actualidad de Córdoba 19611961 1961 Historia. Filosofía de la historia. 930930 930 Metodología de la historia. Conocimiento Fondo de cultura C697C697 C697Collingwood, R. G. Idea de la historia México 1952 Sin ISBN español histórico. Historiografía. Grecia. Roma. económica 19521952 1952 Cristianismo. Historia científica. Historia humana. Biblioteca del 930930 930 Historia. Historiografía. Historiografía Instituto de Fondo de cultura C937C937 C937Croce, Benedetto La historia como hazaña de la libertad México 1960 Sin ISBN español política.
    [Show full text]
  • Visions of the National Past in Argentine Secondary School Textbooks (1861–1912)
    Torleif R. Hamre Histories for a New Nation: Visions of the National Past in Argentine Secondary School Textbooks (1861–1912) Torleif R. Hamre Histories for a New Nation: Visions of the National Past in Argentine Secondary School Textbooks (1861–1912) Table of contents Preface and acknowledgments ................................................................................................... 4 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 7 1. A brief presentation of the subject ..................................................................................... 8 2. Earlier research in the field .............................................................................................. 23 2.1 International research on history textbooks ............................................................... 23 2.2 Textbook studies in Latin America ............................................................................ 30 2.3 Textbook studies in Argentina ................................................................................... 32 3. The approach: Theoretical and methodological considerations ....................................... 46 4. The sources ....................................................................................................................... 57 5. Nineteenth Century Argentina: A summary of the historical background ....................... 61 Colonial antecedents: The Viceroyalty of the Río de la Plata
    [Show full text]