Vanguards of Consumption, Laggards in Politics? the Emergence of a New Middle Class in South China

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Vanguards of Consumption, Laggards in Politics? the Emergence of a New Middle Class in South China Vanguards of Consumption, Laggards in Politics? The Emergence of a New Middle Class in South China By Eileen Yuk-ha TSANG A thesis submitted to The University of Birmingham for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Sociology School of Government and Society The University of Birmingham August 2010 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. CONTENTS Abstract ..................................................................................................................... i Preface .................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgments .....................................................................................................v Introduction ............................................................................................... 1 Pre-reform China at a glance ................................................................................... 2 Post-reform China at a glance ................................................................................... 5 Overview of the thesis .................................................................................. 13 Chapter 1: An intellectual journey: from class theory to class analysis ... 19 Marxist class theories and derivatives .................................................................... 21 Weberian class analysis .......................................................................................... 23 Class ........................................................................................................................ 25 Status ..................................................................................................................... 26 Party ........................................................................................................................ 27 Neo-Weberian class model: John Goldthorpe ........................................................ 29 Bourdieu and the Sociology of cultures ................................................................. 32 Summary ................................................................................................................ 39 Chapter 2: (Re) framing class analysis in post-reform China ................ 42 Conceptualising class: China vs. the West.............................................................. 43 Political capital and other captials in Chinese context ........................................... 47 Hùk ǒu and how it affects the functioning of the Chinese new middle class .......... 51 Dānwei and how it creates differences in work situations of gu ānxi ...................... 58 Land and property restructuring ............................................................................. 61 Generational stratification and the Chinese parent-child relationship ................... 67 Defining the middle class for the purposes of this study ....................................... 72 Summary ................................................................................................................ 77 Chapter 3: Mapping the ethnographic terrain ...................................... 78 Research objectives and research questions ..................................................... 79 Getting inside information with gu ānxi : a problem of research ethics?.................. 87 From interview to text ............................................................................................ 91 The interviewees ..................................................................................................... 94 Entrepreneurs .......................................................................................................... 97 Cadres ..................................................................................................................... 97 Professional ........................................................................................................... 98 Choice of fieldsite ................................................................................................. 99 Summary .............................................................................................................. 107 Chapter 4: Class boundaries of the Chinese new middle class ......... 108 Older generation of the Chinese new middle class .............................................. 109 Factors encouraging pragmatic consumption ....................................................... 112 Collective memories ............................................................................................. 113 Confucian values, self-improvement, class boundary and admission................... 124 Major features of consumption of the older generation ....................................... 127 Entertainment activities ........................................................................................ 128 Tobacco and liquor ............................................................................................... 131 The cultural politics of food and eating ................................................................ 135 Consumption in fashion ........................................................................................ 139 Travel patterns of the older generation ................................................................. 144 Summary .............................................................................................................. 146 Chapter 5: Generational effects in the Chinese new middle class ... 149 The emergence of the consumerism ..................................................................... 150 Geography and spaces of consumption in post-reform China ............................. 153 Rising consumption of branded goods .................................................................. 159 The bar and self commodification......................................................................... 166 Fast food shops vs Chinese restaurants ............................................................... 168 Mobile phones and portable computers ................................................................ 170 Resident preferences and brands of car................................................................. 171 Gender relations or attitudes of the younger generation ....................................... 176 Parent-children relationship between generations................................................. 180 Anxiety and uncertainty over generations............................................................. 185 Summary ............................................................................................................. 188 Chapter 6: Gu ānxi networks and the Chinese new middle class ..... 190 Gu ānxi as an internalized process in China .......................................................... 191 How the cadres understand gu ānxi ? ..................................................................... 196 The influential role of cadre-entrepreneurship ..................................................... 199 Special businesses ................................................................................................. 223 The privileges of cadre-entrepreneurship.............................................................. 231 Limit of gu ānxi networks for the younger generation........................................... 231 Summary ............................................................................................................. 234 Chapter 7: Middle class culture and political development .............. 234 Reconceptualising the Chinese middle class culture ............................................ 235 The middle class culture of the older generation .................................................. 236 The middle class culture of the younger generation ............................................. 238 A Chinese middle class culture in the making ..................................................... 243 Debate on Chinese political development ............................................................ 246 Summary ............................................................................................................. 256 Chapter 8: Conclusion? ........................................................................ 258 Contributions of the study .................................................................................... 265 Bibliography and citations ................................................................... 268 Glossaries and abbreviations ............................................................... 298 Appendices ............................................................................................. 325 Appendix 1: Research questions to interview the Chinese new middle class....... 325 Appendix 2: General profile for the Chinese new middle class in Guangdong.....328 Appendix 3: Caselaw of Chen
Recommended publications
  • A Comparison of El Salvador and Hong Kong Avianne Boney
    Industrial Transformation in the Apparel Industry: A Comparison of El Salvador and Hong Kong A Comprehensive Exercise Avianne Boney Carleton College November 2006 Advisor: Alfred Montero Integration into the global market is a goal that all countries strive for. Some succeed in doing so; others are only partially and barely successful. Central America has recently succeeded in gaining access to international trading markets because of its export-oriented apparel industry. Throughout the 1990’s the apparel industry in Central America expanded to such an extent that it now represents more than 60 percent of total manufacturing exports for both Honduras and El Salvador (United States Industry Trade Commission, 2003). As the trends in the global apparel industry change, this places pressure on the Central American countries to also change the modus operandi of their industry. Managers of multinational clothing firms assert that competition between individual firms is now less important than competition between global apparel supply chains. As a result, the responsibility of the suppliers is increasing.1 Suppliers are not only expected to handle production but also to give input in design and pre- and post-production processes. Furthermore, the industry has become hypercompetitive. “Firms continually disrupt the status quo to create a series of temporary advantages... they create short-lived differentiation advantages that are easily and rapidly eroded through imitation and innovative new styles” (Richardson, 1996). In order to gain the competitive advantage, firms need to continually invent new processes and products. Since suppliers are also competing against each other, they also become entangled in this hypercompetitive environment which means that they also have to be innovative.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2020 Contents
    Embracing Change, Building Resilience Wing Tai Holdings Limited Annual Report 2020 Contents Strategic Review The M at Middle Road, 02. Chairman’s Message Singapore 04. Board of Directors p9 07. Key Management 08. Corporate Data G2000, Operating and Singapore Financial Review p15 09. Property 15. Retail 16. Year in Brief 17. Corporate Social Responsibility Corporate Governance 18. Corporate Governance Report Financial 33. Financial Reports On the front cover The front cover is inspired by the technical drawing of the façade of The M at Middle Road, showcasing its vibrant work-live-play attributes. Photos featured from top to bottom: Le Nouvel G2000, Uniqlo, facilities at The M at Middle Road - Jacuzzi Pool at the KLCC, Malaysia Sky Terrace and Club M. p11 Annual Report 2020 Embracing Change, Building Resilience 01. STRATEGIC REVIEW Chairman’s Message Overview Group Performance Singapore’s economy expanded by 0.7% For the financial year ended in 2019, slower than the 3.4% growth 30 June 2020, the Group recorded in 2018. In the second quarter of 2020, a total revenue of S$371.0 million. the Ministry of Trade and Industry This represents a 15% increase reported a decline of 13.2% on a year- from the S$322.6 million revenue on-year basis; the projected economic recorded in the previous year. This forecast is -7% to -5% in 2020. increase is mainly due to the higher contribution from development The Property Price Index (PPI) properties. The current year revenue increased by 1.3% in the third quarter from development properties was of 2019 to 152.8 and rose 0.5% to 153.6 largely attributable to the additional by the end of 2019.
    [Show full text]
  • THE G2000 GROUP Owner & Operator of G2000 & U2 Stores H a R V a R D a S I a P a C I F I C R E V I E W
    THE G2000 GROUP Owner & Operator of G2000 & U2 Stores H A R V A R D A S I A P A C I F I C R E V I E W V O L U M E VI • I S S U E 2 THE SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTION IN ASIA 6 Whither Biotechnology in Japan? Why biotechnology hasn’t yet taken off By Arthur Kornberg 10 Manchurian Plague Medicine and politics, East and West By William Summers 16 The Future of Chinese Education Educational reform and development in China By Chen Zhili 22 Libraries in Asia New life for libraries in the digital age By Hwa-Wei Lee 25 China’s Manned Space Program What is that all about? By Joan Johnson-Freese 34 Research and Development in China Traditions, transformations, and the future of science and technology policy By Zeng Guoping and Li Zhengfeng 37 Science and Technology in China Personal recommendations for the advancement of Chinese technology By Shing-Tung Yau 44 The Chinese Mindset What science and technology have done for modern China By Song Jian 46 Papermaking in China Ancient science and technology transfer By Pan Jixing 2 Fall 2002 – Volume 6, Number 2 CHINA China and the WTO 50 A report from one year after accession By Jin Liqun Globalization and Federalization 56 New challenges for Asia and the world By Wu Jiaxiang China’s Socioeconomically Disadvantaged 62 Breaking the surface of a challenging problem By Wu Junhua NORTHEAST ASIA Elections in Japan 66 How elections affect the economy By Junichiro Wada North Korea 69 Present and future By Robert Scalapino CENTRAL AND SOUTH ASIA Schooling in Iran 76 Education in Central Asia’s Most Enigmatic Country By Yadollah Mehralizadeh Globalizing What? 79 History, economics, equity, and efficiency By Amartya Sen PAN ASIA Cities and Globalization 83 The present and future of urban space By Saskia Sassen East and West 88 The ideogram versus the phonogram By Shigeru Nakayama Harvard Asia Pacific Review 3 H A R V A R D EDITOR IN CHIEF SAMUEL H.
    [Show full text]
  • Intellectual Property Rights Protection in China: Trends in Litigation and Economic Damages
    Topics in Law and Economics in China Intellectual Property Rights Protection in China: Trends in Litigation and Economic Damages By Kristina Sepetys and Alan Cox* Introduction As a result of external pressures and to meet its own economic objectives, China has been moving its intellectual property rights (IPR) regime closer to those found in many more developed nations. As China’s economy grows, its transition from manufacturing- based to knowledge-based production, more comprehensive laws, and more attention to enforcement have led to an increase in the number of IPR infringement cases being brought before the courts or taken up through China’s administrative procedures. Allowing IP owners to recover their economic damages from infringers is an important component of a system for IPR protection. Properly determined, damage awards can serve as an effective deterrent to IPR violations and protect the incentives to innovate. * Senior Consultant and Senior Vice President at NERA Economic Consulting. We wish to acknowledge helpful reviews and editorial suggestions from Gregory Leonard, Lauren Stiroh, Fei Deng, Phil Beutel, Hao Ma, Guizeng Liu, and Mark Cohen. We are grateful for research and data support from Yanina Koval, Dan Shapiro and Tyler Pines. Any remaining errors are the responsibility of the authors. While problems of intellectual property infringement are We find that, under the administrative systems established in widespread in many areas of the world,1 some Chinese and China, penalties and fines for IPR violations generally do not foreign observers continue to assert that more should be done appear to provide adequate deterrence to would-be infringers.
    [Show full text]
  • China's Connected Consumers
    China’s Connected Consumers When 10,000 Chinese shop... Insights from a 2015 survey kpmg.com/cn In association with Contents Did you Executive Market know? Summary landscape 01 03 05 The luxury Cross-border e-commerce shopping – shopper – The global The journey is a Chinese two-way street luxury buyer 27 45 Online payments – Non-bank payment systems on the rise 55 © 2015 KPMG, a Hong Kong partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved. Contents © 2015 KPMG, a Hong Kong partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved. 1 China’s Connected Consumers 2015 Did you know? • Online confidence is booming! 45 percent of luxury online shoppers now buy over half of their luxury goods online. We expect 50 percent of China’s domestic luxury consumption will be generated online by 2020. • Import duties reductions combined with brands’ recent moves to realign prices between overseas and China will boost China domestic full-price e-commerce, and challenge overseas websites. • From reviewing social media content, we noticed the emergence of retailer generated content alongside key opinion leaders’ and user-generated content. Brands need to adapt and publish more relevant and consumer-centric digital content or risk seeing their brand image diluted. • Although they remain value-driven, Chinese consumers – especially younger generations – are less price obsessed. This opens new opportunities for full price e-commerce for premium and luxury brands.
    [Show full text]
  • People's Republic of China Briefing on EU Concerns Regarding Human Rights in China Prepared for EU-China Summit 5 September 2005
    People's Republic of China Briefing on EU concerns regarding human rights in China Prepared for EU-China Summit 5 September 2005 In May of this year, representatives of the European Union decided to delay a move to lift the arms embargo against China, citing human rights concerns. They referred specifically to four areas of concern that would affect future consideration in lifting the embargo: the need for Chinese authorities to release citizens imprisoned in connection with the suppression of the 1989 pro-democracy movement; the need for reform of China’s “Re-education through Labour” (RTL) system; the need for the PRC to ratify the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR); and the need to ease media censorship. Amnesty International welcomes the fact that the EU has made the lifting of its embargo contingent on human rights reform and has detailed specific areas for improvement. In this briefing Amnesty International presents an update on developments in these four areas in the lead-up to the EU-China Summit in September, 2005. Amnesty International urges the EU to take these factors and other human rights concerns into consideration in its ongoing analysis of the human rights situation in China. Release of those imprisoned in connection with 1989 pro-democracy protests A core issue raised by EU representatives as an area of human rights concern is the continued detention of individuals imprisoned for their connection to the 1989 pro-democracy movement. The EU arms embargo was imposed on 27 June 1989 as a direct response to the armed suppression by the Chinese military of the peaceful protests calling for democracy and political reforms in and around Tiananmen Square in Beijing on 3-4 June.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. Ronald Lu
    Dr. Ronald Lu EDUCATION Chairman Doctor of Science, honoris causa, University of New South Wales, Australia (1999) Master of Architecture in Advanced Studies, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA (1973) Ronald received his B. Arch (Hons) at Bachelor of Architecture (Hons), University of New South Wales, Australia (1970) UNSW in Sydney, Australia, and went on to complete postgraduate studies at MIT graduating with a M. Arch. A.S. degree. PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS He worked in the office of the late Walter Gropius during this period. Registered Architect, New South Wales (NSW), Australia (1970) Architects Registration Board of the United Kingdom (1981) He returned to Hong Kong in 1973 and established his firm in 1976. With Registered Architect, Hong Kong (1991) his commitment to quality and client Authorized Person (Architect) (1974) service, he has nurtured the growth of Ronald Lu & Partners (RLP) into an Member, The Royal Institute of British Architect (1974) award-winning architecture and interior Member, The Singapore Institute of Architects (1975) design practice dedicated to the delivery Fellow, The Royal Australian Institute of Architects (1982) of world-class projects and green built environments. RLP has offices in Hong Fellow, The Hong Kong Institute of Architects (2001) Kong, Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou Fellow, The American Institute of Architects (2011) and Shenzhen, housing its strong team of over 550 staff. The achievement of RLP has been appreciated and honored SELECTED PROJECT EXPERIENCE in over 300 local and international accolades. It is also ranked by “BD WorldArchitecture” as the World’s Top COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT 44 architectural practices in 2020. Wuhan Chow Tai Fook Finance Centre - Wuhan, China (2015 - Present) Ronald is actively involved in both Wuhan Chow Tai Fook Finance Centre is a 475m tall super high-rise mixed-use professional and community work.
    [Show full text]
  • Ching Cheongwas Ondecember22, Born Photo:AFP/Gettyimages Ching Cheong
    CRF-2005-03-text.qxd 9/8/05 3:19 PM Page 133 Prisoner Profile: of an interview with the late purged leader husband’s innocence and reiterated his Ching Cheong Zhao Ziyang, which Ching was going to have unquestioned patriotism toward China. She published. The following day, Ching noted in particular that her husband had instructed his wife, Mary Lau, to bring his brokered meetings between researchers NO. 3,NO. 2005 COMPILED BY ZENOBIA LAI personal computer to Shenzhen. The com- from the Chinese Academy of Social Sci- puter apparently contained notes that ence (CASS) and various Hong Kong politi- Ching had kept on important policy discus- cal figures, including individuals branded as sions. dissidents, to give the central government During the first week of his detention, access to the uncensored views of critics Ching reportedly maintained regular con- of the current administration. In her letter, tact with his wife and told her not to dis- Lau urged Hu to recognize the whole- close his situation. Ching’s employer, The hearted sincerity of her husband and CASS Straits Times, soon learned of his deten- Scholar Lu Jianhua in protecting the welfare tion, but was similarly requested to keep of China, and pleaded for them to be CHINA RIGHTS FORUM the matter confidential. On May 29, Ching spared imprisonment. called his wife and urged her to visit his Although Ching Cheong is a Hong Kong Ching Cheong. Photo: AFP/Getty Images parents more often, as he did not expect to permanent resident, the Hong Kong govern- 133 return to Hong Kong any time soon.
    [Show full text]
  • Rosewood Hotel Group and Tongpai Hotels Partner with Trip.Com to Expand Growth in China
    NEWS RELEASE December 16, 2020 Rosewood Hotel Group and Tongpai Hotels Partner with Trip.Com to Expand Growth in China Rosewood Hotel Group, one of the world’s leading hotel companies whose three-brand portfolio includes New World® Hotels & Resorts, and Tongpai Hotels of Chow Tai Fook Enterprises, have entered into a strategic partnership with Trip.com to mutually expand both hotel brands’ footholds in mainland China. Rezen Hotels Group, a subsidiary of Trip.com, will carry out in-depth cooperation with New World Hotels & Resorts and Tongpai Hotels to grow the brands by leveraging both groups’ distribution networks, technology and customer databases for increased marketing strength and enhanced customer experience. “This partnership, in which all parties will fully utilize their respective advantages and resources, is a testament to our confidence in China’s travel industry and its unlimited potential,” said Sonia Cheng, chief executive officer of Rosewood Hotel Group. “Our China-focused and in-depth alliance with Trip.com Group is a move aligned to our expansion strategy and will further our mission to grow by creating service-oriented hotel brands that deliver transformative travel experiences.” “The collaboration between Trip.com Group, Rosewood Hotel Group and Tongpai Hotels is a pioneering approach within the hotel industry,” said Jane Sun, chief executive officer of Trip.com Group. “The continuing trend of rising consumption power in China is fuelling high demand and the need for sophisticated structures to accommodate; this partnership
    [Show full text]
  • When Is the Best Time to Go to Hong Kong?
    Page 1 of 98 Chris’ Copyrights @ 2011 When Is The Best Time To Go To Hong Kong? Winter Season (December - March) is the most relaxing and comfortable time to go to Hong Kong but besides the weather, there's little else to do since the "Sale Season" occurs during Summer. There are some sales during Christmas & Chinese New Year but 90% of the clothes are for winter. Hong Kong can get very foggy during winter, as such, visit to the Peak is a hit-or-miss affair. A foggy bird's eye view of HK isn't really nice. Summer Season (May - October) is similar to Manila's weather, very hot but moving around in Hong Kong can get extra uncomfortable because of the high humidity which gives the "sticky" feeling. Hong Kong's rainy season also falls on their summer, July & August has the highest rainfall count and the typhoons also arrive in these months. The Sale / Shopping Festival is from the start of July to the start of September. If the sky is clear, the view from the Peak is great. Avoid going to Hong Kong when there are large-scale exhibitions or ongoing tournaments like the Hong Kong Sevens Rugby Tournament because hotel prices will be significantly higher. CUSTOMS & DUTY FREE ALLOWANCES & RESTRICTIONS • Currency - No restrictions • Tobacco - 19 cigarettes or 1 cigar or 25 grams of other manufactured tobacco • Liquor - 1 bottle of wine or spirits • Perfume - 60ml of perfume & 250 ml of eau de toilette • Cameras - No restrictions • Film - Reasonable for personal use • Gifts - Reasonable amount • Agricultural Items - Refer to consulate Note: • If arriving from Macau, duty-free imports for Macau residents are limited to half the above cigarette, cigar & tobacco allowance • Aircraft crew & passengers in direct transit via Hong Kong are limited to 20 cigarettes or 57 grams of pipe tobacco.
    [Show full text]
  • Board Appointment the Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation
    News Release 23 November 2020 BOARD APPOINTMENT THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION LIMITED The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited has appointed Cheng Chi Man (Sonia Cheng) as an Independent Non-executive Director of the Bank. Ms Cheng is currently the Chief Executive Officer of Rosewood Hotel Group. She is an executive director of New World Development Company Limited and a non-executive director of Chow Tai Fook Jewellery Group Limited, both listed on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited. She is also a director of New World China Land Limited. Laura Cha, Chairman of the Board of The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, commented: “Sonia’s wealth of experience in our key markets of Hong Kong and mainland China will be a great fit to the Board of The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, the flagship Asian entity of the HSBC Group. Her proven expertise in spearheading global expansion of her hotel brands will also bring value to our internationally focused business.” Ms Cheng will also be a member of The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited’s Risk Committee. ends/more This news release is issued by Registered Office and Head Office: The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking 1 Queen’s Road Central, Hong Kong SAR Web: www.hsbc.com.hk Corporation Limited Incorporated in the Hong Kong SAR with limited liability Note to editors: Photo Caption Sonia Cheng has been appointed Independent Non-executive Director of The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited. The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited is the founding member of the HSBC Group.
    [Show full text]
  • Greater China 2019
    IR Magazine Awards – Greater China 2019 Winners and nominees AWARDS BY RESEARCH Best overall investor relations (large cap) ANTA Sports Products China Resources Beer WINNER China Telecom China Unicom Shenzhou International Group Holdings Best overall investor relations (small to mid-cap) Alibaba Pictures Group Far East Consortium International WINNER Health and Happiness H&H International Holdings Li-Ning NetDragon Websoft Holdings Best investor relations officer (large cap) ANTA Sports Products Suki Wong Cathay Financial Holdings Yajou Chang & Sophia Cheng China Resources Beer Vincent Tse WINNER China Telecom Lisa Lai China Unicom Jacky Yung Best investor relations officer (small to mid-cap) Agile Group Holdings Samson Chan BizLink Holding Tom Huang Far East Consortium International Venus Zhao WINNER Li-Ning Rebecca Zhang Yue Yuen Industrial (Holdings) Olivia Wang Best IR by a senior management team Maggie Wu, CFO & Daniel Zhang, Alibaba Group CEO Tomakin Lai Po-sing, CFO & China Resources Beer Xiaohai Hou, CEO Xiaochu Wang, CEO & Zhu WINNER China Unicom Kebing, CFO Wai Hung Boswell Cheung, CFO & Far East Consortium International David Chiu, Chairman & CEO Ma Jianrong, CEO & Cun Bo Wang, Shenzhou International Group Holdings CFO AWARDS BY REGION Best in region: China Alibaba Pictures Group ANTA Sports Products China Resources Beer WINNER China Telecom China Unicom Shenzhou International Group Holdings Best in region: Hong Kong AIA Group Far East Consortium International WINNER Health and Happiness H&H International Holdings Yue Yuen
    [Show full text]