A Thesis Entitled Satire and Sympathy in American Psycho
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Thesis entitled Satire and Sympathy in American Psycho by Alaina Simon as palÿial fulfillment of the requirements for the Bachelor of Arts Degree with Honors in English Thesis Director: Professor Reising Honors Advisor: Dr. Melissa Valiska Gregory The University of Toledo DECEMBER 2012 Abstract American Psycho by Bret Easton Ellis was originally dismissed as flippant and distasteful because critics focused on the novel's excessive violence, misogyny, and shallow characters. The book remains controversial to this day, though later critics have shed light on the novel as a satirical representation of Wall Street in the late 1980s. In this thesis, I explore the ways in which Ellis satirizes Patrick Bateman and his society through dialogue, physical behavior, and relationships with each other. I argue that Patrick is essentially a victim of the possessive, technologically obsessed, patriarchal culture, ignored by others despite his cries for attention. In addition, I analyze specific passages in order to determine whether or not the novel can provoke sympathy for Patrick from the reader. Ultimately, I assert that American Psycho is a satire that attempts to expand traditional boundaries by including sympathy. ii Acknowledgements I would like to thank Russell Reising and Melissa Gregory for their extensive help in the drafting, revisions, and overall creation of this thesis. Without their guidance, this project would not have been possible. I would also like to thank my parents and loving boyfriend for their continuous suppolÿ and words of encouragement throughout the semester and all of my schooling. iii Table of Contents Abstract .................................................................................................................. ii ,., Acloaowledgments ...................................................................................................... 111 Table of Contents ................................................................................................................ iv Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 1 Patrick as a Representative Character .................................................................................. 5 Culture of Cruelty .............................................................................................................. 15 Unhappiness ....................................................................................................................... 22 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 30 Works Cited .................................................................................................................... 34 Works Consulted ................................................................................................................ 35 iv Introduction Bret Easton Ellis's American Psycho has been a subject of controversy ever since excerpts from the novel were released in Spy and Time magazine months before its publication in 1991. Both snippets from the novel depicted main character Patrick Bateman torturing female victims in explicit detail. Due to the backlash American Psycho received almost immediately after excerpts were out, publishing company Simon & Shuster decided not to print the book, which was ultimately published by Random House instead (Mack 19). When Amertcan Psycho hit the shelves in April of 1991, it was dismissed by critics for its misogyny, extreme violence, and what was thought to be a lack of depth and characterization. An opinion article in The Tech by Bill Jackson notes that Patrick kills males much quicker and less painfully than females, briefly summarizing gory examples from the novel in the simplest terms: "page 217: Bethany, nail gun, scissors, dead; page 290: Elizabeth and Christie, butcher knife, two dead" (4). Jackson goes on to say that although the book has "literary merits" (4) and elements of black comedy, it falls short of being a great book because the shocking details inside only amount to a weak point about late 1980s culture. The violent passages, particularly against women, are what caused the Los Angeles chapter of the National Organization foÿ Women to stage a boycott against Random House, calling American Psycho a "how-to novel on the torture and dismemberment of women" (qtd. in Freccero 50). Other critics included Todd Stiles who wrote the Spy article before publication, saw violence in the novel as a poor attempt at 2 shock value. Stiles claimed that because Ellis "couldn't write the same book for a third time" (43), referencing Ellis's earlier works Less Than Zero and Rules of Attraction which both deal with careless college kids, that he instead had to create a book so disturbing it would garner attention. After the uproars concerning misogyny and excessive violence began to fade, American Psycho was analyzed from a different view, "as a satire on the coke-fuelled hedonistic money culture.., of the Reagan-Thatcher years" (Tighe 105). Rather than isolating and dismissing violence and misogyny, these elements were now looked at as literary plot devices used to create the bigger picture of the novel, which Ellis said to be "alienation, pain, America, the overall tone of the culture" (qtd. in Tighe 104). American Pyscho's violent passages are now often read as echoing both the Gothic tradition as well as the postmodern. American Psycho is commonly read as an exaggeration of Gothic conventions. Helyer states that Patrick Bateman is "highly stereotyped," and the "predicted nature of his appearance" (728) as a young, rich, and masculine Wall Street executive follows the typical characterization pattern in Gothic style. The horrifying ways in which Patrick tortures, murders, and dismembers the bodies of his female victims is another exaggeration of a typical Gothic device. Throughout the novel, Patrick describes in great detail how he saws, rips, and even chews offpieces of the female body and, as Russel Potter remarks -- "from its inception, the Gothic has posited and reproduced a legion of partial, disjointed, or decomposed body parts, which by their very existence accuse the waking world of a fundamental illegitimacy" (Potter 14). These findings on American Psycho as a Gothic novel have helped to legitimize 3 the novel among scholars. But the Gothic is not the only literary tradition scholars now see at work in the novel. Descriptions included in Bateman's tortm'ing are also true to the terror typical in postmodern writing. At first, reading passages where Patrick is killing, dissecting, and dismembering women can incite feelings of disgust and make the reader uncomfortable. These violent descriptions become so gory and so out of line that by the end of the book, they are hardly believable and hit a point of ridiculousness that the reader cannot help laughing at. Though his descriptions are gross and often too detailed, there comes a point where we have to ask: what is the point of being so excessive, so exaggerated? It seems that Patrick is slipping further and further out of touch with his sanity, and we begin to question whether or not this is all actually happening, or if Patrick has become so deranged that he has been imagining the murders all along. I believe that Ellis's intention behind this is to incite and bring out emotion in the reader, just as Patrick does to his victims in the book. In this sense Ellis continually blurs the line between horror and comedy in order to cause the reader to shift between being disgusted and amused by Patrick's actions. Although the analyses of American Psycho as a contemporary Gothic novel and a postmodem experiment explain its detailed violence, they do not account for an element within the novel that I argue is thematically central; the sympathy it invites for its main character. On one hand, American Psycho appears to be a ruthless black comedy that cautions its readers against vapid materialism in society. On the other hand, the novel contains a host of surprising, sometimes offhanded moments that suggestively portray the murderous Patrick Bateman in a more sympathetic light. Despite the fact that Patrick is egotistical, narcissistic, and psychopathic, his failure to understand himself and the world 4 around him suggests that he is also a victim of society. In this paper, I will argue that Ellis not only uses satire inAmerican Psycho, but that he also creates a portrait of Patrick as a victim which suggests that we are not as different from Patrick as we believe ourselves to be. I argue that Ellis's depiction of Patrick as a victim occurs in three ways. First, Patrick is portrayed as a representation of his society that deliberately draws connections between Patrick and his readers rather than ta'eating him as a freakish anomaly. Secondly, he depicts the culture in which Patrick lives as extremely cruel and unsympathetic in the same way that he is to everyone else. Finally, Ellis repeatedly shows ways in which Patrick is personally unhappy, a sad and lonely human being who does not even recognize the level of his own isolation. These various modes of representing the novel's main character, so often seen as profoundly unsympathetic, implicitly invite the reader to sympathize with him. Ultimately, I suggest that it is the novel's sympathy for Patrick that may help to account for its initial reception even more than its violence. Patrick as a Representative