DOCSLIB.ORG

Nagarjuna's Madhymaka

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Nagarjuna's Madhymaka Nāgārjuna’s Madhyamaka This page intentionally left blank Nāgārjuna’s Madhyamaka A Philosophical Introduction jan westerhoff 1 2009 3 Oxford University Press, Inc., publishes works that further Oxford University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education. Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Copyright © 2009 by Oxford University Press, Inc. Published by Oxford University Press, Inc. 198 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 www.oup.com Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Westerhoff, Jan. Nagarjuna’s Madhyamaka: a philosophical introduction / Jan Westerhoff. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-0-19-537521-3; 978-0-19-538496-3 (pbk.) 1. Nagarjuna, 2nd cent. 2. Madhyamika (Buddhism) I. Title. BQ7479.8.N347W48 2008 294.3'92092—dc22 2008024577 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper to DSR “Don’t you mind dying, sir?” the consul asked. “Forgive me a little lofty talk,” van Gulik said, “but all movement is illusory. From Seoul to Kobe. From life to death.” Janwillem van de Wetering, Robert van Gulik: His Life, His Work Acknowledgments This book owes many different things to many different people. My greatest debt of gratitude is to David Seyfort Ruegg, who spent many hours with me talking through various incarnations of these pages and generously shared his encyclopedic knowledge of the Indian and Tibetan philosophical traditions. Ulrich Pagel provided invaluable support in academic as well as in administrative matters. On the linguistic side I have to thank Alexandra Leduc for organ- izing a splendid Sanskrit-Tibetan translation seminar in London (despite only narrowly avoiding appeal to the rule tres faciunt colle- gium), as well as Ulrike Roesler for attempting to arrange something similar at Oxford. Mattia Salvini acted as a guide to the perplexed concerning various points of Sanskrit grammar and, apart from being an excellent Sanskritist, showed himself to be a similarly excel- lent thinker and provided me with many very useful suggestions for understanding Nāgārjuna’s arguments. Geshe Sherab Gyatso kindly offered his help in trying to make sense of a rather terse passage in a Tibetan commentary on Nāgārjuna. Jay Garfield and Tom Tillemans read through previous versions of this material and made many useful suggestions which helped me to improve the discussion considerably. Ralf Kramer, former Tibetan librarian at the Indian Institute in Oxford, tracked down the most obscure texts in the shortest possible time and gave me countless fascinating Tibetological references. Support in various forms was viii acknowledgments provided by the Spalding Trust, the Society for South Asian Studies, and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and is gratefully acknowledged. Finally, thanks are due to Yuka Kobayashi for keeping the sun shining. J.C.W. New York City First day of the Male Earth Rat Year of the 17th Cycle Contents Abbreviations, xi 1. Introduction, 3 1.1 Nāgārjuna the Philosopher, 4 1.2 Nāgārjuna‘s Works, 5 1.3 Methodological Considerations, 6 1.4 The Philosophical Study of Nāgārjuna in the West, 9 1.5 Overview, 12 2. Interpretations of Svabhāva, 19 2.1 The Ontological Dimension, 20 2.2 The Cognitive Dimension, 46 3. The Role of Negation in Nāgārjuna’s Arguments, 53 3.1 Nyāya Theory of Negation, 54 3.2 Negation and Nondenoting Terms, 56 3.3 Negation and Temporal Relations, 64 4. The Catus.kot.i or Tetralemma, 67 4.1 Two Kinds of Negation, 68 4.2 Rejection of Two Alternatives, 70 4.3 Rejection of Four Alternatives, 73 4.4 Affirming Four Alternatives: The Positive Tetralemma, 89 x contents 5. Causation, 91 5.1 Causation: Preliminary Remarks, 92 5.2 Interdependence of Cause and Effect, 94 5.3 The Four Ways of Causal Production, 99 5.4 Temporal Relations between Cause and Effect, 113 5.5 Analysis of Time, 124 6. Motion, 129 6.1 Arguments Concerning Motion, 130 6.2 The Beginning of Motion, 142 6.3 The Interdependence of Mover and Motion, 147 6.4 The Second Chapter of the MMK in Its Argumentative Context, 150 7. The Self, 153 7.1 The Self and Its Parts, 154 7.2 The Self and Its Properties, 158 7.3 Epistemology of the Self, 160 7.4 The Madhyamaka View of the Self, 162 8. Epistemology, 165 8.1 Means of Knowledge as Self-established, 167 8.2 Means of Knowledge and Their Objects as Mutually Established, 173 8.3 Temporal Relations between Means and Objects of Knowledge, 177 8.4 The Aim of Nāgārjuna’s Arguments, 179 9. Language, 183 9.1 Nāgārjuna’s View of Language and the “No-Thesis” View, 183 9.2 VV 29 in Context, 184 9.3 The Semantic Interpretation, 188 9.4 The Specific Role of Verse 29, 194 1 0. Conclusion: Nāgārjuna’s Philosophical Project, 199 10.1 Metaphysics, 199 10.2 Personal Identity, 208 10.3 Ethics, 212 10.4 Epistemology, 216 10.5 Language and Truth, 219 Bibliography, 225 Index, 239 Abbreviations References to works in verse give the number of the chapter and verse or half-verse (e.g., MMK 24:18, RĀ 1:49a), apart from works not usually subdivided into chapters, such as the YS., ŚS, VV, and VP, where only the number of the verse is given. References to works in prose give the page and line of the editions cited below (e.g. VV(S) 82:3–7). works by nāgārjuna MMK Mūlamadhyamakakārikā J.W. De Jong, Christian Lindtner (eds.), Nāgārjuna’s Mūlamadhyamakakārikā Prajn˜ā Nāma. Adyar Library, Adyar, Chennai, 2004. YS. Yuktis.as.t.ikā Cristina Anna Scherrer-Schaub: Yuktis.as..tikāvr. tti: Commentaire `a la soixantaine sur le raisonnement, ou, du vrai enseignement de la causalité. Institut belge des hautes études chinoises, Brussels, 1991. ŚS Śūnyatāsaptati “The Śūnyatāsaptati of Nāgārjuna,” chapter 3 of Fernando Tola and Carmen Dragonetti, On Voidness. A Study of Buddhist Nihilism, Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi, 2002, 53–99. xii abbreviations VV Vigrahavyāvartanī VV(S) Svavr. tti on the Vigrahavyāvartanī Kamaleswar Bhattacharya, E. H. Johnston, and Arnold Kunst (eds.), The Dialectical Method of Nāgārjuna. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi, 1998. VP Vaidalyaprakaran. a VP(S) Svavr. tti on the Vaidalyaprakaran. a Fernando Tola and Carmen Dragonetti, Nāgārjuna’s Refutation of Logic. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi, 1995. RĀ Ratnāvalī Michael Hahn: Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvalī. The Basic Texts (Sanskrit, Tibetan, Chinese). Indica et Tibetica, Bonn, 1982. works by other authors PP Candrakīrti’s Prasannapadā Louis de la Vallée Poussin (ed.), Prasannapadā Mūlamadhyamakavr. ttih. Bibliotheca Buddhica IV, St Petersburg, 1903–1913. J. W. De Jong: “Textcritical notes on the Prasannapadā,” Indo-Iranian Journal 20, 1978, 25–59, 217–252. (Corrections of the above edition.) MA Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra MAB Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatārabhās.ya Louis de la Vallée Poussin (ed.), Madhyamakāvatāra par Candrakīrti Bibliotheca Buddhica IX, St. Petersburg, 1907–1912. CŚ Āryadeva’s Catuh. śataka Karen Lang (ed.), Āryadeva’s Catuh. śataka. On the Bodhisattva’s Cultivation of Merit and Knowledge. Akademisk Forlag, Copenhagen, 1986. BCA Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra Louis de la Vallée Poussin (ed.), Bodhicaryāvatāra of Çāntideva, Asiatic Society of Bengal, Calcutta, 1907. abbreviations xiii NS Nyāyasūtra Taranatha Nyaya-Tarkatirtha and Amarendramohan Tarkatirtha (eds.), Nyāyadarśanam with Vātsyāyana’s Bhās.ya, Uddyotakara’s Vārtika, Vācaspati Miśra’s Tātparyat.īkā and Viśvanātha’s Vr. tti, Munshiram Manoharlal, Delhi, 1985. This page intentionally left blank Nāgārjuna’s Madhyamaka This page intentionally left blank 1 Introduction The following pages contain an investigation of Nāgārjuna’s philo- sophy from a systematic perspective. Considering Nāgārjuna’s impor- tant place in Buddhist philosophy as well as in Indian thought more generally, it is not surprising that his works have given rise to an enor- mous number of commentaries, studies, and analyses in Asia, and, more recently, also in the West. A large amount of these take the form of commentaries on specific texts, following their structure and analyz- ing individual passages in considerable detail. While the importance and usefulness of such commentaries is beyond dispute, the present work sets out to approach Nāgārjuna’s philosophy from a different perspective. The idea is to present a synoptic overview of Nāgārjuna’s arguments concerning different philosophical problems in order to present an account of the whole of his philosophy, showing how its in- dividual parts fit together as elements of a single philosophical project. In order to achieve this goal, it is not sufficient to give a mere para- phrase of Nāgārjuna’s arguments (as is frequently found in the sec- ondary literature). We will have to analyze their philosophical contents, examine actual as well as possible objections, determine whether the arguments can in fact be made to work, and, if so, what kind of philo- sophical conclusion they support. Comparatively little work has been done in this direction. Since a great part of the contemporary Western studies of Nāgārjuna are interested primarily in philological, historical, or religious aspects of his works, genuinely philosophical studies have been rare. The aim of the present study is to help close this gap. 4 nāgārjuna’s madhyamaka The following pages should be of interest both to philosophers looking for a systematic account of Nāgārjuna’s philosophical position, and to Indolo- gists and scholars of Buddhist studies interested primarily in the philosophical aspects of Nāgārjuna’s works.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Form Without Matter, Was an Essay in the Philosophy of Perception Written in the Medium of Historiography
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by PhilPapers Sympathy in Perception Mark Eli Kalderon i I focused at intervals as the great dome loomed up through the smoke. Glares of many fires and sweeping clouds of smoke kept hiding the shape. Then a wind sprang up. Suddenly, the shining cross, dome and towers stood out like a symbol in the inferno. The scene was unbelievable. In that moment or two I released my shutter. Herbert Mason Contents Preface iii Acknowledgements ix 1 Grasping 1 1.1 The Dawn of Understanding ...................... 1 1.2 Haptic Perception ............................ 4 1.3 The Protagorean Model ......................... 10 1.4 Assimilation ............................... 13 1.5 Shaping .................................. 21 1.6 Active Wax ................................ 27 1.7 A Puzzle ................................. 30 2 Sympathy 37 2.1 Haptic Metaphysics ........................... 37 2.2 The Dependence upon Bodily Awareness ............... 39 2.3 Against Haptic Indirect Realism .................... 44 2.4 Sympathy ................................. 46 2.5 Sensing Limits .............................. 52 2.6 TheStoics ................................ 58 2.7 Plotinus .................................. 61 2.8 The Principle of Haptic Presentation ................. 69 3 Sound 79 3.1 Moving Forward ............................. 79 3.2 The Berkeley–Heidegger Continuum ................. 82 3.3 The Bearers of Audible Qualities .................... 87 3.4 The Extent of the Audible ....................... 91 3.5 TheWaveTheory ............................ 95 3.6 Auditory Perspective .......................... 101 3.7 Phenomenological Objections ..................... 104 i ii CONTENTS 4 Sources 117 4.1 The Heideggerian Alternative ..................... 117 4.2 The Function of Audition ........................ 118 4.3 Sources and the Discrimination of Sound ............... 121 4.4 Sympathy and Auditory Presentation ................. 125 4.5 Listening ................................
    [Show full text]
  • Demystifying the Saint
    DEMYSTIFYING THE SAINT: JAY L. GARFIELDʼS RATIONAL RECONSTRUCTION OF NĀGĀRJUNAʼS MĀDHYAMAKA AS THE EPITOME OF CONTEMPORARY CROSS-CULTURAL PHILOSOPHY TIINA ROSENQVIST Tampereen yliopisto Yhteiskunta- ja kulttuuritieteiden yksikkö Filosofian pro gradu -tutkielma Tammikuu 2011 ABSTRACT Cross-cultural philosophy approaches philosophical problems by setting into dialogue systems and perspectives from across cultures. I use the term more specifically to refer to the current stage in the history of comparative philosophy marked by the ethos of scholarly self-reflection and the production of rational reconstructions of foreign philosophies. These reconstructions lend a new kind of relevance to cross-cultural perspectives in mainstream philosophical discourses. I view Jay L. Garfieldʼs work as an example of this. I examine Garfieldʼs approach in the context of Nāgārjuna scholarship and cross-cultural hermeneutics. By situating it historically and discussing its background and implications, I wish to highlight its distinctive features. Even though Garfield has worked with Buddhist philosophy, I believe he has a lot to offer to the meta-level discussion of cross-cultural philosophy in general. I argue that the clarity of Garfieldʼs vision of the nature and function of cross-cultural philosophy can help alleviate the identity crisis that has plagued the enterprise: Garfield brings it closer to (mainstream) philosophy and helps it stand apart from Indology, Buddhology, area studies philosophy (etc). I side with Garfield in arguing that cross- cultural philosophy not only brings us better understanding of other philosophical traditions, but may enhance our self-understanding as well. I furthermore hold that his employment of Western conceptual frameworks (post-Wittgensteinian language philosophy, skepticism) and theoretical tools (paraconsistent logic, Wittgensteinian epistemology) together with the influence of Buddhist interpretative lineages creates a coherent, cogent, holistic and analytically precise reading of Nāgārjunaʼs Mādhyamaka philosophy.
    [Show full text]
  • Gold Medal IPO 2012 Tadas Krisciunas, Lithuania
    Tadas Krisciunas (Litauen) - Goldmedaille bei der IPO 2012 in Oslo Topic Nr. 4: “And when we question whether the underlying object is such as it appears, we grant the fact that it appears, and our doubt does not concern the appearance itself but the account given of that appearance – and that is a different thing from questioning the appearance itself. For example, honey appears to us to be sweet (and this we grant, for we perceive sweetness through the senses), but whether it is also sweet in its essence is for us a matter of doubt, since this is not an appearance but a judgment about the appearance.” Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism I. 10 (2nd century AD). Among the schools of Hellenistic philosophy, one of much interest for anyone with an interest in epistemology flourished. Skeptics, as they were called, combining the negative1 arguments of the rival- ing schools of Stoics and Epicureans, tried to disprove2 the possibility of knowledge. One of the key works in the tradition of Hellenistic skepticism is Sextus Empiricus’ “Outlines of Pyrrhonism.” As the title shows, in the work, Sextus Empiricus tries to outline the skeptical tradition started by Pyrrho. In this essay, I am going to discuss a certain distinction made by Sextus Empiricus. The distinc- tion is between what the philosopher calls appearances and underlying objects (D)3. I will try to compre- hend the motivation for such a distinction and the logical consequences of it. However, I will try to give some arguments against this distinction, showing how the problems the distinction addresses can be dealt with in other ways.
    [Show full text]
  • The Divine Within: Selected Writings on Enlightenment Free Download
    THE DIVINE WITHIN: SELECTED WRITINGS ON ENLIGHTENMENT FREE DOWNLOAD Aldous Huxley,Huston Smith | 305 pages | 02 Jul 2013 | HARPER PERENNIAL | 9780062236814 | English | New York, United States The Divine Within: Selected Writings on Enlightenment (Paperback) Born into a French noble family in southern France, Montesquieu practiced law in adulthood and witnessed great political upheaval across Britain and France. Aldous Huxley mural. Animal testing Archival research Behavior epigenetics Case The Divine Within: Selected Writings on Enlightenment Content analysis Experiments Human subject research Interviews Neuroimaging Observation Psychophysics Qualitative research Quantitative research Self-report inventory Statistical surveys. By the decree of the angels, and by the command of the holy men, we excommunicate, expel, curse and damn Baruch de Espinoza, with the consent of God, Blessed be He, and with the consent of all the Holy Congregation, in front of these holy Scrolls with the six-hundred-and-thirteen precepts which are written therein, with the excommunication with which Joshua banned The Divine Within: Selected Writings on Enlightenment[57] with the curse with which Elisha cursed the boys [58] and with all the curses which are written in the Book of the Law. Huxley consistently examined the spiritual basis of both the individual and human society, always seeking to reach an authentic and The Divine Within: Selected Writings on Enlightenment defined experience of the divine. Spinoza's Heresy: Immortality and the Jewish Mind. And when I read about how he decided to end his life while tripping on LSD I thought that was really heroic. Miguel was a successful merchant and became a warden of the synagogue and of the Amsterdam Jewish school.
    [Show full text]
  • Constraints on an External Reality Under the Simulation Hypothesis
    Constraints on an external reality under the simulation hypothesis Max Hodak (Originally: 9 May 2020, Last Revised: 14 November 2020) Abstract Whether or not we are living in a simulation has become the subject of much lighthearted conjecture. Despite it being often considered an unfalsifiable question, here I present an argument that places strong contraints on the nature of any universe that contains ours as a \simulation," and I argue that these constraints are so strict that the most likely conclusion is that we are not living in a simulation. The crux of the idea is that almost any external world-simulation interface allows for Lorentz violations, and that these cannot be remedied in a simulation that implements quantum mechanics as we observe it. These arguments do not preclude all possibility that we are living in a simulation, but they impose significant constraints on what such a thing could mean or how the physics of the \external" universe must work. 1 Assumptions all practical purposes.1{3 The analysis that follows requires making three key Assumption A. A simulation should be somehow assumptions. accessible to its creators. Assumption C. The state of a valid universe Similarly, this is difficult to formalize fully gen- must be internally consistent at all times. erally, but for a quantum mechanical universe like ours with Hermitian observables, we can say some- Consistency is an essential property of any thing like the space of positive operator-valued mea- mathematically-describable physics; when we dis- sures available to the creators of the simulation is cover contradiction implied by our mathematics, we not empty; that is, they have some way to measure know that something must be wrong.
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical Engagement of Bostrom's Computer Simulation Hypothesis
    A Critical Engagement of Bostrom’s Computer Simulation Hypothesis Norman K. Swazo, Ph.D., M.H.S.A. Professor of Philosophy and Director of Undergraduate Studies North South University Plot 15, Block B, Bashundhara R/A Dhaka 1229, Bangladesh Email: [email protected]; [email protected] Abstract In 2003, philosopher Nick Bostrom presented the provocative idea that we are now living in a computer simulation. Although his argument is structured to include a “hypothesis,” it is unclear that his proposition can be accounted as a properly scientific hypothesis. Here Bostrom’s argument is engaged critically by accounting for philosophical and scientific positions that have implications for Bostrom’s principal thesis. These include discussions from Heidegger, Einstein, Heisenberg, Feynman, and Dreyfus that relate to modelling of structures of thinking and computation. In consequence of this accounting, given that there seems to be no reasonably admissible evidence to count for the task of falsification, one concludes that the computer simulation argument’s hypothesis is only speculative and not scientific. Keywords: Bostrom; simulation hypothesis; Heidegger; Dreyfus; Feynman; falsifiability 1. Introduction In a paper published in 2003, Nick Bostrom argued that at least one of several propositions is likely to be true: (1) the human species is very likely to go extinct before reaching a “posthuman” stage, i.e., (fp≈0); (2) any posthuman civilization is extremely unlikely to run a significant number of simulations of their evolutionary history (or variations thereof), i.e., (fI≈0); (3) we are almost certainly living in a computer simulation, i.e., (fsim≈1). (Bostrom 2003) Proposition (3) is characterized as the simulation hypothesis, thus only a part of Bostrom’s simulation argument.
    [Show full text]
  • Schwitzgebel May 12, 2014 1% Skepticism, P. 1 1% Skepticism Eric
    1% Skepticism Eric Schwitzgebel Department of Philosophy University of California at Riverside Riverside, CA 92521-0201 eschwitz at domain: ucr.edu May 12, 2014 Schwitzgebel May 12, 2014 1% Skepticism, p. 1 1% Skepticism Abstract: A 1% skeptic is someone who has about a 99% credence in non-skeptical realism and about a 1% credence in the disjunction of all radically skeptical scenarios combined. The first half of this essay defends the epistemic rationality of 1% skepticism, appealing to dream skepticism, simulation skepticism, cosmological skepticism, and wildcard skepticism. The second half of the essay explores the practical behavioral consequences of 1% skepticism, arguing that 1% skepticism need not be behaviorally inert. Schwitzgebel May 12, 2014 1% Skepticism, p. 2 1% Skepticism Certainly there is no practical problem regarding skepticism about the external world. For example, no one is paralyzed from action by reading about skeptical considerations or evaluating skeptical arguments. Even if one cannot figure out where a particular skeptical argument goes wrong, life goes on just the same. Similarly, there is no “existential” problem here. Reading skeptical arguments does not throw one into a state of existential dread. One is not typically disturbed or disconcerted for any length of time. One does not feel any less at home in the world, or go about worrying that one’s life might be no more than a dream (Greco 2008, p. 109). [W]hen they suspended judgement, tranquility followed as it were fortuitously, as a shadow follows a body…. [T]he aim of Sceptics is tranquility in matters of opinion and moderation of feeling in matters forced upon us (Sextus Empiricus, c.
    [Show full text]
  • The Modal Future
    The Modal Future A theory of future-directed thought and talk Cambridge University Press Fabrizio Cariani Contents Preface page vii Conventions and abbreviations xi Introduction xii PART ONE BACKGROUND 1 1 The symmetric paradigm 3 1.1 The symmetric paradigm 3 1.2 Symmetric semantics 4 1.3 The symmetric paradigm contextualized 10 1.4 Temporal ontology and symmetric semantics 14 Appendix to chapter 1: the logic Kt 17 2 Symmetric semantics in an asymmetric world 19 2.1 Branching metaphysics 20 2.2 Branching models 21 2.3 Symmetric semantics on branching models 27 2.4 Ways of being an Ockhamist 32 2.5 Interpreting branching models 32 PART TWO THE ROAD TO SELECTION SEMANTICS 39 3 The modal challenge 41 3.1 What is a modal? 42 3.2 The argument from common morphology 44 3.3 The argument from present-directed uses 45 3.4 The argument from modal subordination 48 3.5 The argument from acquaintance inferences 52 iii iv Contents 3.6 Morals and distinctions 54 4 Modality without quantification 56 4.1 Quantificational theories 57 4.2 Universal analyses and retrospective evaluations 59 4.3 Prior’s bet objection 60 4.4 The zero credence problem 61 4.5 Scope with negation 64 4.6 Homogeneity 66 4.7 Neg-raising to the rescue? 69 5 Basic selection semantics 73 5.1 Selection semantics: a first look 74 5.2 Basic versions of selection semantics 78 5.3 Notions of validity: a primer 81 5.4 Logical features of selection semantics 82 5.5 Solving the zero credence problem 83 5.6 Modal subordination 85 5.7 Present-directed uses of will 86 5.8 Revisiting the acquaintance
    [Show full text]
  • Knowing and Unknowing Reality – a Beginner's and Expert's Developmental Guide to Post-Metaphysical Thinking
    Knowing and Unknowing Reality – A Beginner's and Expert's Developmental Guide to Post-Metaphysical Thinking Tom Murray1 Table of Contents Preface 129 Introduction and Some Foundations 131 The Metaphysics to Come 131 A Developmental Perspective 136 The Meaning-making Drive and Unknowing 140 Magical, Mystical, and Metaphysical Thinking 144 Meaning-making in Magical, Mythical, and Rational Thinking 144 Mysticism and Logic 153 Metaphysical Thinking and Action Logics 155 Interlude: Three Historical Arcs 157 (1) The Rise and Decline of Rationality 158 (2) A Brief History of Belief Fallibility 160 (3) An Evolution in Understanding Ideas vs. the Real 162 A Philosopher's Knot – Knowing and Being Entangled 165 Is there a God? – Philosophers as Under-laborers 165 Two Truths: One Problem 167 Truth, Belief, Vulnerability, and Seriousness 171 Contours of the Real 178 What is Really Real? 178 Constructing the Real 182 Reification and Misplaced Concreteness 191 Embodied Cognition and Epistemic Drives 195 From 4th into 5th Person Perspective 195 Embodied Realism and Metaphorical Pluralism 201 Epistemic Drives 211 Phenomenology and Infinity 220 Conclusions and Summary 230 References 238 Appendix – Developmental Basics 244 1 Tom Murray is Chief Visionary and Instigator at Open Way Solutions LLC, which merges technology with integral developmental theory, and is also a Senior Research Fellow at the University of Massachusetts School of Computer Science. He is an Associate Editor at Integral Review, is on the editorial review board of the International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, and has published articles on developmental theory and integral theory as they relate to wisdom skills, education, contemplative dialog, leadership, ethics, knowledge building communities, epistemology, and post-metaphysics.
    [Show full text]
  • The Inception of Simulation
    The inception of simulation: a hypothesis for the role of dreams in young children Serge Thill ([email protected]) Henrik Svensson ([email protected]) Cognition & Interaction Lab, University of Skovde¨ PO BOX 408, 541 28 Skovde,¨ Sweden Abstract e.g. Shanahan 2006; Ziemke et al. 2005) of the functionality In the present paper, we present an argument and an initial of simulations and their neural substrate. model connecting research into the functional role of dreams However, current accounts of simulation do no address the with simulation theories. Traditionally, although theories that question of the phylogenetic origin and how simulations de- describe the refinement of simulations exist, the origin of these simulations is not considered in detail. Similarly, research into velop in the child. Hesslow (2002) emphasized that simula- the functional role of dreams tends to focus on adults, with less tion theory explains cognitive functions in terms of phyloge- regard to the dreams of young children. netically older brain functions, i.e., functions that evolved to Here, we suggest that a functional role of dreams in infants allow mammals to eat, move and reproduce. Thus, it might through to early childhood may be the inception of these simu- be possible to claim that part of the explanation can be off- lations. We show that the proposed model can present a unified explanation for functions of both the phenomenological expe- loaded to the explanation of the evolution and development of rience of dreaming as well as other aspects of brain activity perception and action processes themselves. However, while during sleeping, e.g.
    [Show full text]
  • The EFPA Test-Review Model: When Good Intentions Meet a Methodological Thought Disorder
    Perspective The EFPA Test-Review Model: When Good Intentions Meet a Methodological Thought Disorder Paul Barrett Cognadev Ltd., 18B Balmoral Avenue, Hurlingham, Sandton 2196, South Africa; [email protected]; Tel.: +64-21-415625 Received: 2 November 2017; Accepted: 27 December 2017; Published: 31 December 2017 Abstract: The European Federation of Psychologists’ Associations (EFPA) has issued sets of test standards and guidelines for psychometric test reviews without any attempt to address the critical content of many substantive publications by measurement experts such as Joel Michell. For example, he has argued that the psychometric test-theory which underpins classical and modern IRT psychometrics is “pathological”, with the entire profession of psychometricians suffering from a methodological thought disorder. With the advent of new kinds of assessment now being created by the “Next Generation” of psychologists which no longer conform to the item-based, statistical test theory generated last century, a new framework is set out for constructing evidence-bases suitable for these “Next Generation” of assessments, which avoids the illusory beliefs of equal- interval or quantitatively structured psychological attributes. Finally, with no systematic or substantive refutations of the logic, axioms, and evidence set out by Michell and others; it is concluded psychologists and their professional associations remain in denial. As with the eventual demise of a similar attempt to maintain the status quo of professional beliefs within forensic clinical psychology and psychiatry during the last century, those following certain EFPA guidelines might now find themselves required to justify their professional beliefs in legal rather than academic environments. Keywords: measurement; EFPA guidelines; assessments; psychometrics; standards 1.
    [Show full text]
  • A Practical Mathematical Solution to the Simulation Argument
    How Many Simulations Do We Exist In? A Practical Mathematical Solution to the Simulation Argument Hutan Ashrafian Institute of Global Health Innovation, Imperial College London and Institute of Civilisation Correspondence to: Dr Hutan Ashrafian Institute of Global Health Innovation, Imperial College London, 10th Floor Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother (QEQM) Building, St Mary’s Hospital, Praed Street, London, W2 1NY, UK [email protected] Key words: simulation; probability; future; kardashev; humanity; civilization; computer; philosophy; existence Abstract The Simulation Argument has gained significant traction in the public arena. It has offered a hypothesis based on probabilistic analysis of its assumptions that we are likely to exist within a computer simulation. This has been derived from factors including the prediction of computing power, human existence, extinction and population dynamics, and suggests a very large value for the number of possible simulations within which we may exist. On evaluating this argument through the application of tangible ‘real-world’ evidence and projections, it is possible to calculate real numerical solutions for the Simulation Argument. This reveals a much smaller number of possible simulations within which we may exist, and offers a novel practicable approach in which to appraise the variety and multitude of conjectures and theories associated with the Simulation Hypothesis. Key words: simulation; probability; future; kardashev; humanity; civilization; computer; philosophy; existence Introduction The Simulation Argument (SA) has gained significant public momentum and prominence in the contemporary public zeitgeist. This is because it exquisitely captures the large range of possibilities offered by the range, depth and fidelity of digital technology to address fundamental existential questions of humanity.
    [Show full text]