Interpreting Medieval Effigies the Evidence from Yorkshire to 1400
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTERPRETING MEDIEVAL EFFIGIES THE EVIDENCE FROM YORKSHIRE TO 1400 APPENDICES BRIAN AND MOIRA GITTOS Oxford & Philadelphia Appendices contents 1: Catalogue 1 Notes 1 Acaster Malbis, W R 2 Acklam, N R 3 Adlingfleet, W R 5 Aldborough, W R 6 Aldbrough, E R 7 Allerton Mauleverer, W R 9 Alne, N R 11 Amotherby, N R 12 Ampleforth, N R 14 Appleton-le-Street, N R 15 Bainton, E R 17 Barnburgh, W R 18 Batley, W R 19 Bedale, N R 20 Beeford, E R 24 Beverley (Friary), E R 25 Beverley (Minster), E R 26 Bilton (in Ainsty), W R 28 Birdsall, E R 29 Birkin, W R 30 Bulmer, N R 31 Burton Stather, Lincolnshire 32 Butterwick, E R 33 Cantley, W R 34 Catterick, N R 35 Church Fenton, W R 36 Coverham Abbey, N R 37 Crathorne, N R 40 Danby Wiske, N R 42 Darfield, W R 43 Darrington, W R 45 Denton, Co Durham 47 Easby Abbey, N R 48 East Harlsey, N R 49 Eastrington, E R 50 Egglestone Abbey, N R 52 Escrick, E R 54 Appendices contents iii Etton, E R 55 Felixkirk, N R 57 Felkirk, W R 59 Filey, E R 60 Forcett, N R 61 Foston on the Wolds, E R 62 Fountains Abbey, W R 63 Garton-on-the-Wolds, E R 64 Gilling East, N R 66 Goldsborough, W R 67 Goodmanham, E R 69 Goxhill, E R 70 Great Langton, N R 72 Great Mitton, W R 73 Guisborough Priory, N R 74 Harpham, E R 75 Hauxwell, N R 76 Hazelwood Chapel, W R 79 Hedon, E R 81 Hickleton, W R 82 Hornby, N R 83 Hornsea, E R (see Goxhill for civilian and Nunkeeling for the knight and lady) 86 Howden, E R 86 Hull (Holy Trinity), E R 89 Hutton Cranswick, E R 91 Hutton Rudby, N R 92 Ilkley, W R 93 Ingleby Arncliffe, N R 94 Ingleby Greenhow, N R 96 Jervaulx Abbey, N R 97 Kellington, W R 98 Kildwick, W R 99 Kirby Sigston, N R 100 Kirby (in Cleveland), N R 101 Kirkby Fleetham, N R 102 Kirkleatham, N R 103 Kirklington, N R 104 Leeds, W R 106 London (Temple Church) 107 Loversall, W R 108 Lowthorpe, E R 110 Lund, E R 111 Melsonby, N R 112 Methley, W R 115 Middleton on-the-Wolds, E R 116 Moor Monkton, W R 117 Nafferton, E R 118 Normanby, N R (English Heritage) 120 Norton, Co Durham 121 Nunkeeling (now at Hornsea), E R 123 Nunnington, N R 125 Ormesby, N R 126 iv Interpreting Medieval Effigies Patrington, E R 127 Pickering, N R 128 Pickhill, N R 132 Rievaulx Abbey, N R 133 Ripley, W R 135 Ripon, W R 137 Romaldkirk, N R 139 Routh, E R 140 Ryther, W R 141 Scarborough (Museum), N R 143 Selby (Abbey), W R 144 Sheriff Hutton, N R 146 Skerne, E R 147 Slingsby, N R 149 South Anston, W R 150 Spofforth, W R 151 Sprotbrough, W R 152 Stainton, N R 154 Stanwick, N R 155 Startforth, N R 159 Stillingfleet, E R 160 Stonegrave, N R 161 Sutton-on-Hull, E R 164 Swillington, W R 165 Swine, E R 166 Thornhill, W R 169 Thornton Dale, N R 170 Thorpe Basset, E R 171 Throapham, W R 172 Thrybergh, W R 173 Thwing, E R 175 Treeton, W R 176 Upleatham (old church), N R 177 Wadworth, W R 179 Walton, W R 182 Watton Priory, E R 183 Weaverthorpe, E R 184 Welton, E R 185 Welwick, E R 186 West Tanfield, N R 187 Whorlton, N R 193 Wilton (in Cleveland), N R 194 Winestead, E R 196 Wintringham, Lincolnshire 197 Wistow, W R 198 Womersley, W R 200 Wycliffe, N R 201 Yarm, N R 202 York (Hob Moor) 203 York (Minster) 204 York (St George Fishergate) 206 York (St Olave) 206 Appendices contents v York (York Archaeological Trust) 207 York (York Museums Trust) 208 2: Methodology 210 A2a Archaeological approach 210 A2b Dating and identification 211 A2c Rejected effigies 212 3: Fieldwork 214 4: Review of sources 217 A4a Introduction 217 A4b Sources pre-1500 217 A4c Sources from 1500 to 1700 218 A4d Sources from 1700 to 1900 219 A4e Sources post 1900 220 5: The wider monument range 223 A5a Cross slabs 223 A5b Monumental brasses 223 A5c Composite slabs 224 A5d Incised slabs 224 A5e Painted slabs 224 A5f Memorials in glass 225 A5g Conclusions 225 6: Loss & Survival 226 A6a Estimating losses 226 A6b The Scropes: one family’s monumental history 226 A6c The churches: sample evidence 229 A6d Phases of loss 234 A6f Survival through antiquarianism 237 A6g Burial of monuments 238 A6h Conclusions 238 7: Downing’s ‘High Status Workshop’: a response 240 8: Comments on the dating of Series B knights 243 A8a The dating of the Septvans brass at Chartham (Kent) 243 A8b The de Ros effigy in Temple Church (London) 244 A8c Bedale 244 A8d Conclusions 246 Appendix 1: Catalogue Notes The entries in the catalogue are very brief summaries 4. Military effigies wearing mail are assumed to have links intended to create a ready impression of the subject rather carved in relief, unless otherwise stated than presenting the depth of detail captured in the resurvey 5 References are only provided where they contribute records, which would have been impractical The following materially to understanding the effigy. Where they are is a guide to the entries not in the Bibliography, they are quoted here in full 1 The detail in the entries is presented in the following Most armoured effigies appear in I’Anson 1926, 1927 order (used as appropriate): and Downing 2014, 2015, so these references have not Place and Riding or County; Number within place, type routinely been given and identification (if any); Material; Date or date range; 6 References to the Johnston manuscripts are for drawings, Series or Affiliation; Location; Description; Notes; unless otherwise stated Selected references 7 Cross references to the main text are given only where 2. Double effigies carved on the same slab have separate there is significant discussion, so these are not a entries substitute for consulting the index 3 The descriptions assume that where visible or surviving, the hands are in a position of prayer (unless described otherwise) 2 Interpreting Medieval Effigies Acaster Malbis, W R describing him as on the ‘…south side the quire…’ 1 Military (de Malbys family) The accompanying sketch shows the legs still present Probably Magnesian Limestone By 1825, he was on the ‘south side of the communion c 1315–30 table’ and ‘completely green with damp’, (Glynne 2007, On modern plinth, south side of sanctuary p 57) In the early twentieth century, he was described Lower legs lost but mutilated lion remains Holding as covered in a ‘generous coat of whitewash’ (I’Anson heart; crossed legs; tied thong scabbard attachment; 1927, p 14) poleyns; dragon biting heraldic shield (Malbys) See A6c v for details of the 1328 translation of the The effigy was already in a similar position by the remains of Sir John and Agnes Malbys, from Acaster late seventeenth century, Johnston (C14, fo 145v) Malbis to Rievaulx Abbey Appendix 1: Catalogue 3 Acklam, N R Gittos 2013b (written before the resurvey of this figure 1 Male civilian in 2016 and judged on the basis of limited information) Coarse-grained (probably local) sandstone suggested this badly preserved figure was an ecclesiastic 1st half 14th century of the second half of the 13th century On the floor of the boiler house (2016) Extremely weathered, broken and feet lost Hood raised 2 Lady (Westerly) Book? in crook of elbow Single cushion with single Sandstone leaves (coming from below it) spread out on chamfer Late 13th century Likely to have been a churchyard monument Broken across and worn, fingertips lost. On new plinth under arch between chancel and the south chapel, west of No 3 Hair free at sides but in net behind nape of neck and over crown, broad fillet with alternating shields and fleurs- de-lys Veil overall but no wimple Sleeveless cote with deep armholes that show the belt of the lower garment Book in crook of arm (cf male civilians at Acklam and Stainton), feet on two adorsed dragons 4 Interpreting Medieval Effigies 3 Lady (Margaret Conyers?) Probably Magnesian Limestone c 1400 On new chest, under arch between chancel and south chapel, east of No 1 A little chipped and rubbed but otherwise well preserved Hair in jewelled net that is flat-fronted with a short veil behind. Straight-necked cote with large flower mounts down front Feet on dog, crossed cushions with carved shields of arms on each corner (Boynton, Conyers and three other coats) Morris 1931, p 42; Brown, T H , Coats of Arms in Cleveland, (Middlesborough, 1973), p 71 Appendix 1: Catalogue 5 Adlingfleet, W R a headless bird Hair dressed to sides of face with plaits 1 Lady brought upwards beside the face, under veil with frilled Pisolitic limestone edge. Wimple fits tightly to throat but covers the chin c 1320–30 and lower hair in a wide line Angel supporters On heraldic chest, in the south wall of chancel. Effigy Johnston C14 fo 158r (1670?) shows her as now (A4c) carved to be set against a south wall Richardson (1989) Lincolnshire Import Local damage, some parts lost, e g fingers, one angel’s head; some repairs in antiquity. Left knee flexed, feet on 6 Interpreting Medieval Effigies Aldborough, W R 1.