GENDER EQUALITY: PSYCHO-SOCIAL PERSPECTIVES ON GIRLS’ EDUCATION
IN SOMALIA.
By
FARHIA ABDI
Integrated Studies Project
Submitted to Dr. Angela Specht
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
Master of Arts – Integrated Studies
Athabasca, Alberta
October, 2015
Table of Contents
Abstract………………………………………………………………………………………...3
Acknowledgements…………………………………………………………………………….4
Introduction…………………………………………………………………..5-8
Methodology…………………………………………………………………..9
PART ONE: Historical Preview of Somali Culture & Education Stages
A) Pre-colonial Era…………………………………………………….10-12
B) Colonial Era……………………………………………………… 13-14
C) Post-Independence………………………………………………….15-18
PART TWO: Cultural and religious interconnectedness with access and the constraints to gender biased education…………………………………………………………19-27
Conclusion…………………………………………………………………….....28-29
Recommendations………………………………………………………………30-32
References……………………………………………………………………...33-38
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 2
Abstract:
Cultural practices and religious conditions inform the social norms, politics, and bureaucratic frameworks that Somali women must negotiate to achieve their respective educational goals. The available literature regarding Somalia’s educational conditions indicate high illiteracy rates, especially among women due to gendered education that discriminates against women and girls. Part one of this study examines the context of pre-colonial, colonial and post-independence conditions and how these influenced Somalia’s cultural and educational practices. Given the complex conditions that restrict Somali women’s ability to access education, part two of this thesis investigates which cultural and religious conditions are intertwined with access and also serve as constraints to gender biased education. Strategic educational interventions could help women to achieve greater equality; therefore, this thesis searches for potential solutions to enable female education in Somalia.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 3
Acknowledgment:
I would like to take this opportunity to express my gratitude to my supervisor, Dr. Angela
Specht, whose expertise, understanding, and patience, added considerably to my graduate experience. I appreciate her vast knowledge and skill in many areas (e.g., education, governance and culture), and her assistance in supporting some of my own published articles. Dr. Specht's support in every aspect of my academic growth has motivated me to continue with my education endeavor.
I would also like to thank MAIS office staff, in particular, Janice Day, whose support and quick responses to my inquiries greatly helped in facilitating my work.
Very special thanks go out to my friends and colleague Kon Madut and Abdirizak Karod whose support and guidance early on my study gave me the motivation and the strength I needed. I appreciate their enthusiasm, and I owe them my eternal gratitude.
Finally, I would also like to thank my beautiful children Aman and Hanad Adan without whose love, encouragement and support I would not have finished this project. They are my guiding-light, and I love them very much. I would like to extend my gratitude to my sister Laila
Abdi who has been my rock, and who made it easier for me to continue with my dreams. She has always been there for me, especially when I needed her the most and for that I am grateful.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 4
Introduction
“Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world”.
Nelson Mandela
Literacy is considered a key foundation for sustainable development, thus it has a significant influence for building individual and community capacity as well as reducing poverty. Scholars have cited that literature has a potential to empower, enrich and enlighten people who are powerless, and in doing so, it enhances the dignity of human beings. The concept of the right to education has long been established and revised in international conventions and declarations like: Convention on the Rights of the Child (UN, 28, UNICEF, 49) and the United
Nations’ Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UN, 26). Indeed Africa set continental education targets, amongst others, to achieve Universal Basic Education [UBE] by 1980 at a
1961 conference in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia (UNESCO, Ch.1, 3). These conventions and declarations illustrate that there is an understanding around the world that education is indispensable for the elimination of illiteracy and elevating nations and populations out of poverty. Overall, according to Jandhyala B. G.Tilak however,
World enrolments in all levels of education increased five-fold, from about 227
million in 1950 to 1.1 billion by 1995. The number of adult literates in the world
trebled from 1.1 billion in 1960 to above three billion in 1995. More than 60 per
cent of the world population in the age group 6-24 is currently in schools and
colleges, as compared to the one-fourth who were in schools about four decades
ago. The number of teachers increased by 6.6 times from 7.9 million in 1950 to
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 5
52.3 million in 1995. Public expenditure on education increased by about 24 times
from $54 billion in 1960 to $1.3 trillion (in current prices) in 1994 (223).
Nevertheless, how education is deployed and dealt with is very differently on each continent and indeed in each country. Though Tilak’s study does not address gender inequality extensively, it does illustrate that in Asia women are lacking behind men in education. Gender inequality in
Africa’s education system, particularly in Somalia may show greater variation as education is gendered and largely practices along traditional lines. For example, “women’s secret associations and the homestead were the means through which societies ensured the successful transmission of its values and traditions to girls and young women, and graduation was almost nearly a guarantee” (Falola and Amponsah, 101).
Somalia is located in North-Eastern Africa and has a population of about 8 to 10 million people. Somalia was colonized by a series of European imperialists: the British, Italians, and
French. The North of Somalia gained its independence on June 26, 1960. Five days later, July 1st, it merged with the South, forming the Somali Republic. In ethnic terms, scholars like Lee
Cassanelli, I. M. Lewis, Nina J. Fitzgerald, and David D. Laitin considered Somalis as a homogeneous society. Scholars believe Somali people share the same culture, language, religion, and are divided along clan lines. A majority of Somalis are described as a nomadic pastoral society whose “politics lie in kinship and are composed of men who trace descent through a common male ancestor from whom they take their corporate name” (Lewis 4).
Furthermore, in terms of religion, Somalis are 99.9% Muslim Sunni, which have strong ties with the Islamic world in Africa and Arabia.
Although there are no consensuses, some scholars believe Somalis have Arabian and
African mix heritage. However, the British Anthropologist I.M. Lewis (5) believes, “Somali
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 6 genealogies go back to Arabian origins, to the Prophet Mohamed’s lineage of Quraysh and those of his companions. Yet, they do not think of themselves as Arabs, except in religion, as culturally
Arabian” (Lewis, 4). U.S. Department of State: Bureau of African Affairs adds more holistic view on Somalia’s history:
Today, about 60% of all Somalis are nomadic or semi-nomadic pastoralists who
raise cattle, camels, sheep, and goats. About 25% of the population is settled
farmers who live mainly in the fertile agricultural zone between the Juba and
Shabelle Rivers in southern Somalia. The remainder of the population (15% -
20%) is urban. Sizable ethnic groups in the country include Bantu agricultural
workers, several thousand Arabs and some hundreds of Indians and Pakistanis
which all speak Somali Language (2008, N.pag).
Somalia’s education system is relatively informal. Communal interaction does predate the colonial era, and is required to be studied within its cultural context. In the pre-colonial era, education was mostly based in Islamic (Koran) teaching that was fairly instructed to both genders, but boys were often given more attention and priority. Daphne Williams Ntiri explains,
“Traditionally, Koranic education started twelve centuries ago and catered mostly to men…Women's educational needs were left largely unaddressed” (Ntiri, 1). However, during the colonial era (mid-late19th century), British and Italian colonizers slowly and steadily established formal programs of learning, and though the education system “differed and tremendous efforts had to be expended in later years to integrate both systems for national use” (Ntiri, 2).
Colonial education teachings were negligible and it was oriented toward meeting the basic needs of the colonizers, particularly in communication and other duties that were required for maintaining the order of the colony, whether it is translating the local language,
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 7 communicating with the community, or office duties. As Mudimbe and Bayart suggested,
“colonial educations were limited in scope and were essentially designed for the purposes of social and economic motives of colonialism in Africa, which have been presented through history in different versions” (Mudimbe, 88, Bayart, 93).
The traditional Somali education was favourable to the relative benefit of the socioeconomic development of its people. After independence in 1960, Somalia’s education sector developed very quickly especially under the military coup of Mohamed Siyad Bare in
1969, and indeed it made some improvement on women’s education and gender equality.
However, with the collapse of the Somali state in 1991, all education institutions and learning materials within the country were destroyed by the civil war, and Somalia has since been as
Cassanelli & Abdikadir put it a “country without any unified formal programs of education, and this civil strife has put women’s education into an even more dismal context” (10). Somalia’s patriarch and lineage based traditions and practices hinder women’s participation in education, economics, politics, and decision-making processes.
In order to examine how Somalia’s culture and religion create barriers and constraints to gender education as well as to seek potential solutions, this project addresses the following questions: To what extent does gender shape access to quality and equitable education for women in Somalia? How do culture, tradition, customs, and religion operate in fostering assumptions of a gender divide? Relatedly, how do social expectations (both for females and males) either hinder or help to shrink the gender gap? Given the above questions, how do we best address the conditions and mechanisms that hinder girls and women’s education? How do we help to improve female access to education?
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 8
Research Method:
In this research, I conduct an interdisciplinary project that studies and analyzes the practice of gender education in Somalia. This research is based in a review of literature that includes readings from historical materials, governmental documents, and scholarly examinations. I use Discourse Analysis as a method to critically analyze these texts. The discourse analysis explores how socio-cultural perceptions in Somalia hinder women’s progress and representation within both basic and higher-education systems. The term discourse analysis according to James A. Holstein and Jaber F. Gubrium is best understood as an “umbrella designation for a rapidly growing field of research covering a wide range of different theoretical approaches and analytic emphases” (Holstein, Gubrium, 1).
This research is expected to contribute to academic literature around gender inequity in education and particularly on how gender inequity shapes and limits the kind, quality, and access to education available to women in Somalia. There is very little literature on this subject, and this scholarly research contributes toward growing that literature, inspiring future research, and aid in future policy development for educational accessibility for women and girls in Somalia. The discourse analysis and anti-oppressive education approaches add extra perspectives to women’s education in Somalia, in that they seek to empower and aid those very women.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 9
PART ONE: Historical Preview of Somali Culture & Education Stages.
Pre-Colonial Education Prior to 1839
In 1800s Somalia was the trading hub for Arabian and Indian travelers, but it had it is own internal culture, practices and laws that were unique and constant. Pre-colonial Somali society consisted of small states, porous and not demarcated. Though, there were local variations within different areas, by and large, the broad principles in all the various systems were the same. Even under the country’s scarred and officially ungoverned system, some cities were still the centre of agricultural production and trade as well as acted as informal centres of governance.
According to Lidwien Kapteijns and Maryan Boqor, cities like Zeila, Harar, Mogadishu, Afgoye, and Brava served as trade and agricultural production networks. Each city acted as a kind of city- state that was ruled either by a sultan, emir, or by a group of elders (107). The community leaders (boqor, sultan, emir, or elders) managed their respective communities by creating codes of conduct to which the whole community and even those from outside of the community adhered; these rules functioned as a system of governance in pre-colonial era. I.M. Lewis pointed out that in pre-colonial Somalia “the people were not without government or political institutions” (3).
In the African context, education in pre-colonial tradition was very different and considered by some as more suitable than those of or following the colonial era. Muna Ndula, believes “the pre-colonial law in most African states was essentially customary in character, having its sources in the practices and customs of the people…there is broad agreement that in its present form customary law is distorted, and it is influenced by the recent interaction between
African custom and colonial rule” (88). Pre-colonial Somali culture was based on communal
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 10 and cohesive cultural values; however, this learned social cohesion was intended as a passage from elder generation to transfer knowledge and experiences to the younger generation in order to promulgate the community’s culture and values. As Somalia is a patrilineal society, boys are mainly the receivers of such a passage. Knowledge includes: social interconnectivity, such as clan affiliation, methods of social cohesion, responsibility and skills of both war and peace- times. This kind of traditional teaching by elders is known as ‘Xeer’ and it is a form of communal law with set of rules.
Saciid Ismail Samatar argues, “Xeer is a socially constructed organizational system to safeguard security and social justice within and among Somali communities, with other values being added as the people of the region embraced Islam in the eighth century” (630). In addition, not only is the ‘Xeer’ as Samatar puts it, an “organized system to safe guard security and social justice” (630), but it is also a method for elders or the communities’ wise men to observe the quality of young boys specially in the area of mental capacity and endurance which will then determine the boys’ future leadership credentials. Once suitable boys are found, elders groom them for leadership roles. However, there are different methods of education for pupils, and they were largely informal and included Qur’anic teachings. Ali. A. Abdi points out the “non- sedentary nomadic schools were introduced with religious men teaching children how to read, write and memorize the Koran, (the Muslim Holy Book)…this traditional system recognized and was responsive and reliable to the local needs” (239). The Koranic education was taught through handmade wooden tablets called ‘loox’ (in Somali), where the pupils would write and learn in
Arabic language.
The communal nature of Somali culture allows communities to rely and respect the decisions made by community elders, as it is a “institutionalized roles with leaders
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 11 and governance” (Laitin and Samatar, 43). The concept of Xeer is still used in rural areas that are typically less structured and institutionalized. Even though, the ‘Xeer’ system was considered a democratic system, it was also a gendered system where only men were allowed to lead and participate in it. I.M. Lewis pointed out that in Somali culture
“women cannot take part in the tribal or sanction assembly of the elders, and they hold structurally subordinate positions” (Lewis, 60). Mohamed Haji Ingiriis considers ‘Xeer’ a clan system that “From a gender point of view, fails to do justice to women… a case in point is its contradictory facet of the decomposition of women in treating them as a property” (377). Further, under ‘Xeer’ women are always under protection of male figures and blood compensations of women are usually is valued at half that of men.
Although, there were variations in the models presented and transmitted as education by outsiders and Somali alike, a common factor according to scholars were provided by the
Islamic tradition of Koranic schools. Religious teachings were the method through which literacy developed in the pre-colonial era. In the Islamic teachings, there were no differentiation between genders in learning; however, culture did and still does have an effect on how the religion takes up issues of gender. In the 2002 report on Women’s
Rights in Islam and Somali Culture, the UNCEF described:
“The place of women in an Islamic society is determined by the Koran, the
tradition of the prophet, customs and practices…through the revelation of the
Koran and the Sunni of the Prophet Mohamed (PUB), Islam liberated women
from unacceptable conditions that prevailed in the tribal society of the pre-Islamic
Arabia…among the rights granted to women by Islam were the rights to life, and
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 12
education as well as right to inherit, manage, and maintain properties” (UNCEF,
5).
This contradicts on the contemporary, largely culturally influenced viewpoint of Islamic teachings where women’s right seems to be restricted and in many case completed averted.
In the context of the pre-colonial era and even contemporary era, Somali cultural practices downplay a girl’s access to formal education and indeed education is largely considered futile, since she is expected to get married and become the responsibility of her spouse, irrespective of her education standing. Boys on the other hand are expected to carry on the responsibility of their families, including their wives and children. In the larger African context, education and productive social activities were intertwined. The Somali culture facilitates women’s role as a significant part of the homestead and therefore, mothers pass on the culture’s value and expectation to their daughters but women and girls’ contribution and possible contributions to the broader community are largely circumscribed. Somalia’s long-standing culturally embedded gender segregation and it is traditional schooling methods, created
“expectations and anxieties about today’s education” (Cassanelli, and Abdikadir 92). It is in this regard that there are historical and culturally constituted ideological systems on the construction of gender and the organization of domestic, education, and political lives in Somali Society.
Colonial Education Era in Somalia in Early-Mid 1900
During the colonial era, the education system in Somalia was designed to maximize for the propagation of the colonizer’s agenda in order to extract the country’s resources. In this context, the colonizers implemented a minimum required educational skills to advance their respective goals. The introduction of colonial education could potentially be viewed as progress in terms of introducing the concept of universal education to the colonies, but it undermined
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 13 continuity of the culture and spiritual schema that existed in the pre-colonial time. V.Y.
Mudimbe argues, “colonial cultural disintegration of African Society was through cultural and religion levels, through schools, churches where it broke the culturally unified and religiously integrated schema of most African traditions” (4)
Somalis are considered a culturally entrenched society, and for centuries education reflected the values, norms and interests of the Somali traditional pastoralists. However, cultural shifts happened during the advent of colonialism and brought a new introduction of public social institutions that were connected to education but these institutions were foreign to the Somali people. The argument is that the intent of colonial educational practices was not to educate its colony for the benefit of local peoples, but rather to facilitate gaining control over African’s land and labour. The colonizer did come to Africa for it is resources, but they brought their own culture with it is own gender and class conscious that then permeated into the educational teachings in the colonies.
In The Birth of Gender: the Dichotomizing the Sexes in British Culture, Kumashiro and
Ngo, argue that prior to the eighteenth century, men and women although recognized as different were not seen as being two distinct genders, but rather perceived as one sex in which women possessed the inferior or deficient constituent of the same attribute (9). Though, the colonizers had their own gender bias, and did not change the state affairs for women, they did nevertheless provide a measured education to Somali children including girls. Ali A. Abdi states, “one of the first formal colonial schools operating in Somalia was opened by the Italian Dante Alighieri
Society in 1907 to teach Somali children the Italian language” (331). However, Abdi adds colonial education pupils were limited to only 1265 in number and not able to be educated higher than grade 7, for political reasons (331).
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 14
In general, gender inequality in education and social sphere is a common phenomenon almost everywhere in the world, and in some societies (including Somalia), the culturally entrenched gender gaps are worsening. The deepening gender gap and diminishing of women’s rights (such as access to education and employment) are considered by Nussbaum and Glover to require, “an urgent for moral stand-taking, since the majority of the world’s population received fewer portions of its opportunities and benefits” (2). Nevertheless, colonial education provided the Somali liberation groups as a means to see education an indispensable building block to fight colonialism and to create a clan-transcending Somali nationalism.
Post-Colonial Education in Somalia, 1960-To-Date:
Somalia, similar to other African countries, began to re-structure its own identity after independence from colonial rule, but it was also done with the back-dropped of their colonizers in full view. The effect of colonial structure and ideological blending was difficult to overcome; difficulties that I.M. Lewis called “conquest mode of state formation in which he believes produced much more difficult for one of the elements in the ethnic mosaic to establish its authority than it was for a group of foreign origin, blessed with technological superiority” (489).
In this sense, Somalis in post-independence were aware of gender education disparity, but it did not consider addressing gender disparity as a priority in the new Somali state. A 2002 UNICEF report indicated throughout the “nine years of civilian administration, the nascent Somali state continued implementing the same colonial rules without any major change to the status of women” (16). However, women still took active political and social roles in attempts to bring their rights at the forefront. For example, women expressed their feeling through traditional folk songs, which became their method of communicating to the Somali society in general and political leaders in particular. Somali women were given their suffrage and participated in
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 15 politics in 1963, and they exercised those rights by organizing themselves to run for an office or to have an influence on the elections of 1964 and 1969. Mohamed Haji Ingiriis states:
“The post-colonial government contributed involuntarily to women’s
transformational change by permitting them to be artists and to sing in theatres
when some traditional intellectuals critical of the government’s lenience regarding
what was considered to be the deterioration of societal tradition stood to defend
social patriarchy…male poets composed songs denouncing the so-called
modernisation process, questioning women’s attempts to act like men” (382).
The beginning of the post-independence movement in the new Somali Republic was considered a model post-colonial state, and indeed women’s political participations there outpaced many Western democracies.
Public education was also accelerated between1969 and 1978 during the Junta of
Mohamed Siyad Bare that ideologically valued scientific socialism. The military regime emphasized education as a key factor to alleviate high illiteracy in the country, especially for women. It announced compulsory primary education for all ages, sexes, and equal access to higher education for women; this was a great opportunity that ultimately enhanced a number of Somalia women’s employment opportunities. Laitin points out that during the independence process education of the Somali population was prioritized in
Article IV of the UN Trusteeship Agreement, which specifically required the setting up of modern education systems for Somali children and adult learners (qtd. In. Abdi, 332).
Thus, Somalis embraced the values of education as an important vehicle for nationalism and economic development. The Somali Latin Alphabet was developed and as part of the
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 16 education campaign, Abdullahi Qarshe, a prominent Somali singer/composer, buoyantly sang this popular nationalist song:
Aqoon la’anni waa iftiin la’aane
waa aqal iyo ilays la’ aane
Ogaada, ogaada, dugsiyada ogaada
O aada, o aada
Walaalayaal o aada.
(Lack of knowledge is lack of enlightenment
Homelessness and no light
Be aware, be aware of schools
And go to schools, go to schools
Brothers and sisters, go to schools). (qtd. In. Abdi, 333).
Somali women benefited from the literacy campaign through adult education classes, especially those women in urban areas. In 1975, Somalia’s President Mohamed
Siyad Bare, with the collaboration of the Supreme Revolutionary Council, announced a new progressive law that protected Somali women’s rights and their equality with men.
For instance, the first article of the first Charter of the military Revolution in 1969 declares equal rights in marriage, divorce and family inheritance. Nevertheless, some
Somali scholars and women activists demonstrate that these laws contradict Somali customary law, or the ‘Xeer’. Further, women’s allegiance to country and family was used to ultimately advance and further entrench the patriarchal agenda. Clan loyalty also played key roles in cultural entrenchment of women’s education and position. Somali tradition values male superiority. This superiority is regarded as the normal order of
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 17 things, if not a natural way of organizing the society. In this context, both patriarchal culture and effects of colonialism have contributed to psychological inferiority and low self-esteem as women are taught and internalize subordination and are therefore habituated to tolerate such second-class status.
In patriarchal society such as Somalia, gender bias is embedded also within the education system. Kumashiro and Ngo argue,
Social justice pedagogies recognize that teaching is a political act...Because
teaching is a political project, it is never neutral and any perceived neutrality is a
political achievement. For social justice educators, this neutrality is not an
accurate representation of the position of the instructor, the politics of the
curriculum, or the ideology embedded within specific educational models (20).
Though there has been very limited educational research conducted in Somalia since the country’s state collapse, Abdullahi (Baadiyow) provides some useful statistics and cites that after the Somali script (based in Latin characters) was adopted in 1972, the government launched an ambitious educational plan:
As a result, the enrolment in primary schools rose from 28,000 in 1970 to 220,000
in 1976 and to 271,000 in 1982. The number of primary schools also increased,
rising from 287 in 1970 to 844 in 1975 and to 1407 in 1980. Furthermore, the
number of teachers reached a peak of 3,376 in 1981, The literacy rate reached to
almost 50 per cent of the population aged 15 years and above in 1980. However,
in the difficult decade of the 1980s, education declined due to a lack of funds and
political instability in the country. The literacy rate had dropped to 24 per cent by
1990 (2001, N. Pag).
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 18
In addition, the 2003 annual report of the Formal Private Education Network in Somalia,
Cassanelli and Abdikadir describe, “the enrolment of girls at the existing primary schools as being only 30% of the student population, and the percentage declined further to 15% at the secondary level…the obstacles therefore to achieving gender equality in access to education are also cultural” (13). While these gains should be applauded, nevertheless it also suggests that
Somalia is at or near the bottom in primary school access relative to all other countries. Indeed, women’s low literacy rates in Somalia are partly attributed to governmental policy, inadequate services, and lack of defined gender enabling policies. Therefore, both family decisions and historical Somali cultural values affect gender equality and hence, perpetuate the low expectation and reality of women's literacy and educational attainment.
PART TWO: Cultural and Religious Influences of Gender Gap in Somalia’s Education.
Gendered Culture and Religion: Shaping Access to Quality and Equity in Education.
Somalia has numerous problems ranging from military conflict to political instability to poverty to economic uncertainty to social upheavals and tension to disease and to gender inequality. However, though these challenges are influenced by contemporary globalization, colonial subjugation, and clannism, gender inequality is also deeply embedded within cultural and religious conditionings. Culture is viewed as people’s collective way of life including norms and values that shape how people in a society interact with one another. Historically, Somalia’s paternalistic culture undervalues and dismisses women, which perpetuates intergenerational cycles of gender inequality, and normalizes the subjugation of women. For example, Somali society is an oral society and messages are expressed through poetry, proverbs and other form of artistic expressions; however, most of Somali proverbs are very negative towards women.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 19
Israelite, Herman, and Alim point out that in “Somali patriarchal poetry proverbs and folk tales portray that intelligence and motherhood is incompatible” (81). Such popular proverb illustrates the sentiment of “a breast that contains milk cannot contain wisdom” (81). This kind of negative proverb undermines women’s ability to be taken seriously.
Women in many different ways express their disapproval of gender roles through poetry, and storytelling all of which are key elements of Somalia’s strong communal tradition. Through culture, one is able to see society in its strengths and weaknesses. Traditional education has always been both socio-cultural and religious in character, taking place within the context of the extended family and moving with its herds, as well as the Koranic schools. However, as modern
Somali society is becoming more urbanized and with crumpled infrastructure after the civil war, there are no adequate resources to support broad ranging education and what does occur relies largely on a foreign aid to facilitate such capacity. This civil instability negatively impacts the nation’s ability to develop its human resources and to eliminate illiteracy. It is worth noting that in patriarchal culture male domination is critical, and to address gender education and girl’s rights seriously may be even more challenging under these harsh conditions. Lidwien Kapteijns explains how for a girl, preparation for marriage begins at birth, and one of the songs her Somali mother would sing to her was:
Daughter, the wealth that comes by night belongs to the girl who is quiet.
Daughter, where there is no girl
Daughter, no wealth is received, Daughter, and no camels are milked....
A marriageable young man is in the house and men pass by its side....
Quiet down for us lest we become an empty space [by not receiving bridewealth for you]
Quiet down for us.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 20
Hooyo, gunnadii habeen guurtey gaagaabsi gabadh baaleh
Hooyo, meelayn gabadh joogin
Hooyo, gunno lagu ma qaato
Hooyo, geel lagu ma maalo.... geyaan baa guriga jooga rag baa goonyaha maraya....
Noo gaagaabi hadalka yaan gega cad la noqonin noo gaagaabi hadal ka (241).
Somali society’s entrenched tradition of gender discrepancy becomes evident in the core of family structure. For instance, the right to lead or decide on a family asset when the father passes away is the responsibility of the son, even if there is an older sister or sisters. The Somali mother also feels pressure particularly if she has only girls because of the belief that she (the woman) is responsible for the baby’s sex. It is considered shameful to only bear girls, and if this happens can result in a husband either leaving the family or taking another wife in order to bear a son. The reason behind this behaviour is the belief that if the father passes away, he does not have sons to carry on the family’ name since girls are discounted. Similarly, as Catherine
Besteman points out, “mothers and the daughters have to manage the asset until the sons come of age or older sons by another wife… reclaim the land or asset until the young sons grew up” (5).
Somali males are considered heads of the family, and are responsible for the whole family, including spouses; therefore, women have very little influence outside the home. This domestic focus for women limits their standing in the community at least publicly and as I.M. Lewis illustrates, “women in the patriarchal character of Somali society do not have public power positions, but are as influential as men inside the house” (60). In addition to men’s power positions as the head of family, men reinforce cultural conformity because they have authority and leadership roles based on their standing in the broader community.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 21
Somali women have borne the brunt of cultural traditions, many of which have been described as oppressive, and which limit the advancement of women. Male dominance has been cited as a major obstacle to gender equality. Boys are also taught at the early age to be the head of the family and their success in education and in life are celebrated and encouraged. Hence, from early on, the boy’s self-steam and standing in the community is built and promoted. As
Kapteijns illustrates in Somali’s oral literature boys are also given a message very different from the message given to girls; a “mother is very proud of having a boy because she understands the value of having a boy in her marriage and of her standing in the community” (240). For example, woman’s marriage represents an opportunity to accumulate assets of her own, so she can be more independent from her husband’s financial control. Kapteijns points out that the cultural ideal inculcated in boys was very different, and the songs mothers sang to boys were:
Bile, you who are like the new moon to me
Bile, you who have made your tol (patri-clan) increase
Son, your tol is setting out to fight tonight
Son, they are fighting right now
Son won't you take up the injustice?
Listen, camels are preceded by men and rain by clouds
So to whom [but me] belongs the comfort of this world?
Son, may I find joy in you tomorrow
Son, may you take me to the land of the Arabs
Son, may you travel over the sea with me
War Bilow, aniga ii bil hoowaa
War Bilow, tolkii biirayow hoowaa
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 22
Hooyo, tolkaa caawa duulaya
Hooyo, haddana wuu dirirayaa
Hooyo, dannada soo qaadi maysid?...
War, raggii geel baa u horreeyaa
War, daruur roob baa u horreeyaa
War ayaaleh raaxadda adduun hoowaa
Hooyo, bilow beri kugu badhaadhi
Hooyo, bilow bari Carab i geysay
Hooyo, bilow badda igala dhooftay (242).
Children are impressionable to the world around them; and according to Kumashiro and Ngo, children “actively take up what they learn from parents, the popular media, religious teachings, and other influencers regarding gender roles and use of this often contradictory information to influence each other’s behaviors” (109).
Somali women have to navigate unequal social terrains and judgments that are built to keep them out of opportunities and into subordination. According to Reeve and Baden, “culturally determined gender ideologies define rights and responsibilities and what is appropriate behaviour for women and men, and these gender ideologies often reinforce male power and the idea of women’s inferiority” (4). Culture is the foundation of societies and a means to self-identity.
Lorber informs us that based on the societal expectation, “gender is produced and maintained by identifiable social processes and built into the general social structure and individual identities deliberately and purposefully” (18). Despite these assumptions, culture is fluid and enduring and dominant cultures reinforce the position of those with economic, political and social power, and
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 23 therefore, tend to reinforce a male power. Feminists of all walks of life have been identifying the structures that make up the concept of gender and people’s understanding of how it operates.
Society’s view of gender is what differentiates patriarchy culture from democratic ones.
Through The Conceptual Practices of Power, feminist scholar Dorothy Smith, fully understands the consequence of women’s disadvantages in patriarchal societies and suggests that
“both men and women normally come to a society governed by a pre-determined set of rules and regulations that favor men over women” (17). Smith emphasizing that the “circle of men” is an order to which women contribute yet from which they are excluded, to which women are confined yet in which they feel strangers (43). Smith accentuates that societies separated gender into a private sphere that is traditionally assigned to women and a public sphere that is traditionally assigned to men. She saw society as link of power in which patriarchal relations are at the center, and women’s experiences and work become subsidiary since they remain unaccounted for within it. Somali women are severing from socially constructed assumptions and expectations that confined them to traditional gender roles and limit their respective contribution to their society. In this context, cultural and religious expectations can influence women to conform and subsequently subjugation occurs.
In Somali society religious teachings had and still have a great deal of influence on the people. Though religious teachings are used for educational purpose, and were somewhat neutral, contemporary religious teachings have seen radical changes in the Islamic world and particularly in Somalia. Many religious teachers interpret the Qur’an differently, particularly when it comes to women’s agency. The moderate Islamic scholars believe Islam proclaims gender equality, but that gender equity has diverged from its spiritual meaning and application via cultural practices that entrenched gender bias in contemporary religious application. Fatuma
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 24
Mernissi believes Islamic religion supports women’s education. She recites a verses of the
Qur’an “the sura 33 of verse 35 of the Qur’an acknowledges the equality of all believers, male and female, before God, thus asserting their individual sovereignty” (118), where Claude Gilliot suggests that although there is proclaimed equality in religion terms “boys were favoured in training and instruction, and while it was deemed necessary to instruct girls in moral and religious things, there was no desire to lead them through other educational portals of intellectual development” (19).
Most religious scholars indicate that the Islamic religion has not always been anti-women as most people perceive it today. Fatima Mernissi reminds us that religious values and teachings were tempered by “misogynistic male companions of the prophet Mohamed who diluted the true
Islamic message substituting misogynistic principle which was then entrenched within the sacred literature and enforced through manipulation of the texts both within and after Muhammad’s lifetime” (18). She adds, “calls for religious validation of misogyny are at odds with the original egalitarian intent of the Prophet… she argues that these forces brought about the diminution of the original Islamic principle and created a rift between truly Islamic attitudes to women and those descended instead from pre-Islamic tribal traditions” (19).
Similarly, Qamaruddin Khan argues that in Islamic law, “God clearly defined and guaranteed the rights of women in the Qur’an, so that they could no more be subjected to those wrongs, injustices, and oppressions which had been inflicted on them since the beginning of the human species” (13). One of the other misinterpretations that scholars including Khan commented is the spirit, and equality in humanity; verses like,
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 25
“O mankind: Reverence your Guardian Lord Who created you from a single person created of like nature…. (Qur'an 4:1) It is He who created you from a single person and made his mate of like nature … (Qur'an 7:189)” (UNCEF, 12).
‘O mankind’ was believed to be interpreted by men as a singular to male superiority over female, but in fact the term ‘mankind’ actually mean all worshipers including female and male. In
Somali context, the majority of women are not well versed with the Qur’an teachings. According to Saciid Ismail Samatar, adult Somali women were mostly uneducated in religious matters and depended greatly on men for Islamic education (qtd. In. Cawo Abdi, 197). In this context, religious teachings are done mainly by males who preach to women on the matters of Qur’anic values and expectations. This one-sided knowledge, interpretation and dissemination are where scholars like Fatima and Khan see the potential for misinterpretation of the Qur’an as well as ongoing entrenchment of women’s religious subjugation.
Similarly, journalist and an author, Sally Armstrong states the practice of “religion fundamentalism is to hinder women’s education and progress” (20). She talked about the debilitating effect of the Afghanistan Taliban’s rules on “women’s rights and education in the name of religion and Sharia Law” (20). Since culture and religion seemed intertwined, women are in positions of disadvantage and are significantly challenged with respect to breaking through these twin barriers. Other scholars stipulate that despite, the rigid laws and customs of Muslim countries towards women, the changing socio-economic conditions of the world as well as time may challenge these old traditions. However, hard-line interpretations of the Qur’an seem to be accepted more in societies where patriarchy is the cultural norms. Although, culturally Somali women face gender inequality, they had fought against cultural patriarchy through folk songs and
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 26 poetry such as Buraanbur that is considered the female style of poetry. Mohamed Haji Ingiriis further reminded us how Somali women struggled with cultural discrimination:
The post-colonial government contributed involuntarily to women’s
transformational change by permitting them to be artists and to sing in theatres
when some traditional intellectuals critical of the government’s lenience regarding
what was considered to be the deterioration of societal tradition stood to defend
social patriarchy. Male poets composed songs denouncing the so-called
‘modernisation process’, questioning women’s attempts to act like men. Oral
tradition records a renowned Somali poet and cultural critic, Ali Sugule,
composing a stirring song, ‘Habloow maad is bar qabataan’, meaning ‘Oh,
women why don’t you conduct yourselves (382).
These kinds of words are passive cultural shaming and it is aimed at hindering any positive and progressive female empowerment, cultural change, and gender transformation. It is often men who sense that their authority is being undermined through movement toward equity, and it thereby attempt to re-inscribe inequity through mocking women’s advancement or empowerment. In Somalia’s culture, family life is orientated around woman and see woman as critical domestic players in this respect, but this respect is confined to the household. During colonial rule and post-colonial transition, Somali women worked hard not only in the house, but in broader Somali society. Ingiriis suggests, “while women carried out initiatives to influence men in power, attempts to change women’s position in the society as well as the desire to create a gender-inclusive modern society has hardly bore fruit…they were restricted in such a way that they would be regarded by some as bourgeois feminists” (383). The attempts to
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 27 create educational and social change and equity, however, are pitted against long standing
Somali cultural and Islamic practice that enables and entrenches male ascendancy.
Women’s education was impacted even further through civil war (1991) subsequent social, political, and economic instability. Contemporary civil unrest has led to the dissolution of government, then the establishment of a weak government and destruction of most the country’s institutions and infrastructure. This civil unrest has made families more dependent on girls to substitute for or help their working mothers. However, very little attention is given to this ongoing gender gap because of the overall instability of Somalia. Scholars and governments
(both national and international) have largely focused only on the politics and civil strife of the country. Somalia remains largely a pastoral nomadic society; and female education is not something that is considered priority. Cawo Abdi states “more conservative Islamic interpretations often support and legitimize patriarchal gender roles and relations, causing relations of authority within society to become entrenched, especially with regard to gender relations” (194). In this context of instability, and cultural and religious patriarchy, gender does significantly shape the extent and define the quality of education awarded to women based on their expected role in Somali society. These expectations permeate Somali cultural and religious values that differentiate between gender roles in general and education in particular.
Conclusion:
This research revealed that there are gender gaps in Somalia’s formal and informal public education, and it is due to social-perspectives pervaded by cultural and religious values associated with girls and women’s education. Part one looked at various roles that the pre- colonial, colonial and post-independence regimes have played on gendered education and the cultural values that have shaped education of women and girls. The literature reveals that in the
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 28 pre-colonial era, the major influences on Somali people’s literacy was mainly through Islamic teachings of the Qur’an (Islamic holy book), which has had great influence on families. During this period both boys and girls were given educational opportunities in the Qur’anic teaching, the literature shows however, that boys were often favoured for this education. During the colonial era, the research also reveals that colonizers started educational institutions to educate Somali pupils including girls; however, its scope was very limited. Nevertheless, educational practice in this colonial era inspired an ideological scheme within the Somalia’s liberation movement to advance the call for independence and include women in broader Somali society. The research illuminated that during the post-colonial era, Somalia’s educational system surged and created universal primary education to all citizens and women’s education was increased particularly during the junta of Mohamed Siyad Bare (1969-1991).
This is also the period (1972) that the written Somali language was created, with education being the main mechanism of dissemination for this new written form. While deep- rooted cultural norms of male hegemony are the norm within Somali society, the co-education of boys and girls that was in operation in Somalia’s post-independence era, and particularly during the two decades of military regime, introduced a low level acceptance of equality between boys and girls. However, these educational reforms of the early 1970s could not overcome hundreds of years of traditional and religious practice that has favoured males. So although the Junta era fostered a degree equity and progressive change for Somali women, the collapse of the Somali state in 1991 has seen the retrenchment of inequality in contemporary Somali society.
Contemporary shifts toward fundamental religious philosophy and practice, in conjunction with already entrenched patriarchal cultural norms have indeed widened the education and equity gender gap for Somali girls and women.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 29
Part two of this project looked at how cultural and religious conditions intertwined with access and the constraints to gender biased education and cultural practices. The literature reveals that women’s education decline is partly to do with the role given to women as mothers, wives, sisters and daughters along with the cultural and religious expectations of subordination within the family and the broader society. The research also provided the views of many feminist and religious scholars including Fatima Mernissi who has challenged the misinterpretation of the
Qur’an by ‘misogynistic’ males (Mernissi, 18) who intent to subjugate women and retain male cultural and religious privilege. Feminist scholars and activists like Dorothy Smith, Judith Lorber,
Catherine Besteman, Linda Perschell and Carli Lorber illustrate that societies have pre-conceived views of gender and gender roles that often govern the rules, regulation, and lives of men and women; and, in the case of patriarchal cultures, privileges male over female.
It becomes apparent throughout the literature reviewed that Somali culture and religion intertwine and demonstrate embedded gender assumptions and expectations that perpetuate gender inequality towards education and social construction. Education, however, does have the capacity to create positive and progressive influences on women’s socio-economic and community standing. It is imperative, therefore, that all cultures, no matter how damaged by conflict or culturally or religiously entrenched in inequity learn to believe in and enact the value and full participation of women and girls in our societies if we are to instigate meaningful social and political change. Transformation does not necessarily mean abandoning the past or cultural or religious values, instead it can lead to a progressive transcendence that values and empowers all the people, regardless of their status and station.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 30
Recommendations:
Strategic educational interventions could help women to achieve greater equality, and this
project has led me to suggest the following potential solutions to aid gender equality via education
in Somalia:
I. Women's rights to education should be considered an integral part of Islamic and Somali
culture. This effort requires social education about women and their rights and one that
abdicates gender discrimination while also taking into account both Islam and cultural views.
II. Increase advocacy and visibility of Somali women and women’s agencies as the spokes
people for change for Somali women’s rights. Women themselves are the most important
catalysts for change by challenging and defying discriminatory attitudes in their
communities, women’s groups can advance the rights of girls and women for generations to
come.
III. A gender-mainstreaming policy that prioritizes male partnership is important too as men’s
involvement will facilitate positive changes on gender parity. Partnerships with progressive
men and boys with respects to advocacy, change, and inclusion can unite the voices for
change.
IV. Islamic and Somali (public and private) traditions and teachings should complement each
other in order to educate individuals, families, and the broader community about the
importance of women’s education. This kind of public and private support of women can
build the strength within families to treat girls and boys equally. It also enhances the family
dynamic as a whole, and contributes to broader community enhancement.
V. Somali society values Islamic norms that provide moral guidelines; therefore, women’s rights
to education should be addressed commensurately while challenging the religious and
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 31
cultural beliefs of women’s inferiority. This is particularly necessary in the rural areas where
access to education is limited and conservative cultural and religious values are practiced.
VI. Somali society also value clan affiliation and structure. Clan structure is another obstacle to
women’s education. Male elders decide the affairs of the family, against the backdrop of a
culturally promulgated female role that emphasizes women, and girl’s place is in the home
with their mothers, or with her children and husband in the case of wives. These beliefs must
be changed through education, activism, and enlightenment. These concepts need to be
challenged otherwise, gender inequality and inadequate female education will perpetuate in
Somalia (Farhia. A. Abdi, N. pag).
VII. Countries that are affected by conflict often do not have the leadership and resources to assist
or create strong educational institutions; therefore, there is a need for the international
community to support long-term educational assistance. This assistance must work with local
advocates in creating change.
VIII. Advocacy of the principles of equality and gender sensitivity must happen within the
government, in addition to creation of comprehensive strategies to develop and sustain
programmes on women's issues.
IX. Central and regional governments need to produce legislation that pivots on favourable
economic empowerment for women and strengthens women's economic security.
X. Somali government needs to implement awareness training to promote gender equality and
raise societal consciousness about the valuable contributions of women and girls.
Institutional change can be directed by and through educators and central and regional
government infrastructures and officers (ibid, Abdi. N. pag).
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 32
XI. Establish school curriculum with a focus on Somali women’s history and their contributions
to society. Teaching gender equality will lead to a new consciousness, gender analysis, and
greater access to Somali women’s narratives (ibid Abdi, N.pag).
XII. Building community involvement and creating new enthusiasm for education through
government-community programs that study, recommend, and develop programs that target
solutions of gender parity. Communities themselves can be agents for change to education
and society.
XIII. Academic scholars including Somali academics (young and old, inside and outside of the
country) must research, advocate, and address the cultural gender gaps that are deepening in
Somalia.
XIV. Certain foundational principles should guide educational planning, as these will set the
direction for the next generation. The most important are the principles of equal access and
opportunity for all Somali children, regardless of gender, clan affiliation, regional origin, or
economic status, and with full attention to the needs of those children handicapped or
disabled by the war.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 33
Works Cited:
Abdullahi, Abdurahman. M. (Baadiyow). “Penetrating Cultural Frontiers in Somalia: History of
Women’s Political Participation in Four Decades (1959-2000)”. 2001. Web. 12 August,
2015. http://www.mbali.info/womensnews.htm.
Abdi, Ali A. “Education in Somalia: History, destruction, and calls for reconstruction”.
Comparative Education, Rutledge. Nov 1998, Vol. 34 Issue 3, p327, 14p. Web. 11, July,
2015.
Abdi, Cawo Mohamed, “Convergence of Civil War and the Religious Right: Reimagining
Somali Women”. Journal of Women in Culture and Society 2007, vol. 33, no. 1. The
University of Chicago. 2007. Web. 20 August, 2015.
Abdi, Farhia. Ali. “Somalia: the Culture of Patriarchy and Women’s Place in It” published,
http://www.hiiraan.ca/op4/2015/july/100651/somalia_the_culture_of_patriarchy_and_wo
men’s_place_in_it.aspx. 31 July, 2015.
Armstrong, Sally. “Veild Threat”; the Hidden Power Of the Women of Afghanistan: Penguin
Group, Penguin Books Canada Ltd, 2002. Print.
Armstrong, Sally. “Ascent of Women”; our turn, our way--a remarkable story of worldwide
change. Random House Canada, 2013. Print.
Besteman, Catherine. “Unraveling Somalia”: Race, Violence, and the legacy of Slavery:
University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia, 1999. Print.
Cassanelli, Lee and Abdikadir, Farah Sheikh: “Somalia: Education in Transition”
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 34
Bildhaan an International Journal of Somali Studies Vol.7 (2008): 1-35. Web. 02 July,
2015.
Falola, Toyin and Amponsah, “Nana Akua .Women's Roles in Sub-Saharan”.
Greenwood.ABC_CLIO, LLC. 2012. Print.
Gilliot, Claude. “Education and Learning in the Early Islamic World”; the Formation of the
Classical Islamic World: Ashgate Publishing Limited, England, 2012. Print.
Holstein, James A. and Gubrium, Jaber F. “Constructionist Research”. The Guilford
Press.2008.Print.
Ingiriis, Mohamed Haji (2015). 'Sisters; was this what we struggled for?': The Gendered Rivalry
in Power and Politics. Journal of International Women's Studies, 16(2), 376-394. Web. 26
June, 2015.
Israelite, Nieta Kay. Herman, Arlene Alima, Farduma Ahmed. “Waiting for "Sharci
a"Resettlement and Roles” Canadian Woman Studies. York University. Volume 19,
Number 3. 1999. Web. 09 July, 2015
Kapteihns, Lidwien. “Changing Conceptions of Moral Womanhood in Somalia”; Popular
Songs, 1960-1990. In “Gender and Islam in Africa”: Rights, Sexuality and Law.
Woodrow Wilson Center Press, Washington D.C., 2011. Web. 30 June, 2015
Kapteijns, Lidwien. “Gender relations and the transformation of the northern Somali pastoral
tradition”. International Journal of African Historical Studies, St v28 no2 p241-59 '95.
Web. 30 June, 2015.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 35
Kapteijns, Lidwien and Boqor, Maryan Muuse. “Memories of a Mogadishu Childhood, 1940-
1964: Maryan Muuse Boqor and the Women Who inspired Her”. International Journal of
African Historical Studies Vol. 42, No.1 (2009) 105. Web. 28 June, 2015.
Kevin K. Kumashiro, Bic Ngo. “Six Lenses for Anti-oppressive Education: Partial Stories,
Improbable conversations”. Peter Long Publishing Inc. 2007. Print.
Khan. Qamaruddin. “Status of Women in Islam.” Sterling Publishers Private Limited, New
Delhi, 1990. Print.
Kvale, Steinar The qualitative research interview: A phenomenological and a hermeneutical
mode of understanding. Journal of Phenomenological Psychology 14, (1983): 171-196.
Web. 31. July, 2015.
Laitin, D. (1976) Politics, Language and Thought (Chicago, Chicago University Press). Web. 19.
June, 2015.
Laitin, D. & SAMATAR, S.S. Somalia: Nation in Search of a State; Boulder, CO, Westview,
1987. Web. 19 June, 2015.
Lewis, I. M. “People of the Horn of Africa”: Lowe and Brydone Ltd, London, 1969. Print.
Lewis, I.M. “A Pastoral Democracy”: Oxford University Press. London, 1961. Print.
Lewis. I.M. “Visible and Invisible Differences: The Somali Paradox/ the Colonial and Post-
Colonial Framework for Ethnicity In Africa”: Journal of the International African Institute,
1/1/2004, Vol. 74, Issue 4, p. 489-515: Edinburgh University Press Language: English. Print.
Lorber, Judith. “Paradoxes of Gender”: Vail-Ballou Press, Binghamton, New York, 1994. Print.
Mernissi, Fatima. “Beyond the Veil”: Revised ed. Indiana University Press Bloomington and
Indianapolis, 1987. Print.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 36
Mudimbe, V.Y. “The Invention of Africa”; gnosis, philosophy and the order of knowledge:
Bloomington, IN, Indiana University Press, 1988. Print.
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral
Research. The Belmont Report. Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of
Human Subjects of Research. Washington, DC: National Institutes of Health, 1979. Web.
13 July, 2015.
Available: http://ohsr.od.nih.gov/guidelines/belmont.html.
Ndulo, Muna. “African Customary Law, customs, and Women’s rights”. Cornell Law Faculty
Publications, 2011.Web, 01 July, 2015.
Nussbaum, Martha Craven Glover, Jonathan. “Women, Culture, and Development: A Study of
Human Capabilities”: Oxford University Press. New York. 2001. Web. 28 May, 2015
Obermeyer, M. Carle. “Religious Doctrine, Stated ideology, and Reproductive Options in
Islam”; in Power and Decision. The Social Control and Reproduction(eds) Sen, G., &
Snow, R. Poston: Harvard University Press, 1994. Print..
Oyewumi, Oyeronke. “Gender Epistemologies in Africa”: Gendering Traditions, Spaces, Social
Institutions, and Identities: Palgrave Macmillan.US, 2011. Print.
Ouval, S. Somali Nationalism: international politics and the drive for unity in the Horn of
Africa: Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 1963. Print.
Reeves, Hazel and Baden, Sally. “Gender and Development: Concepts and Definitions”.
Institute of Development Studies. 2000. Print.
Rodney, W. “How Europe Underdeveloped Africa”: Washington, DC, Howard University
Press, 1974. Print.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 37
Samatar, Saciid Ismail. “Destruction of State and Society in Somalia: Beyond the Tribal
Convention” The Journal of Modern African Studies. Volume 30 / Issue 04 / December
1992, pp 625-641. Web. 10 August, 2015
Smith, Dorothy. “The Conceptual Practices of Power: A Femininity Sociology of Knowledge”.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 1990. Print.
Smith, Dorathy E. A peculiar eclipsing: Women’s exclusion from man’s culture. Women’s
Studies International Quarterly, 1(4), 281-296. 1978. Web. 19 May, 2015.
Smith, D. E. The everyday world as problematic: A feminist sociology. Boston:
Northeastern University. Press. 1987..Web 08 May, 2015.
Smith, D. E. The conceptual practices of power: A feminist sociology of knowledge. Boston:
Northeastern University Press. 1990. Web 08, May. 2015.
Smith, D. E. Sociology from women’s experience: A reaffirmation. Sociological Theory, 10(1),
88-98. 40. 1992. Web. 10 May, 2015.
Smith, D. E. Writing the social: Critique, theory and investigations. Toronto: University of
Toronto Press. 2004. Web. 15 May, 2015.
Smith, D. E. Institutional Ethnography: A Sociology for People. New York: Altamira
Press. 2005. Web. 11 May. 2015.
Tilak, Jandhyala B. G. “Education, Society, and Development: National and International
Perspectives”. National Institute of Education and Planning and Administration. New
Delhi. 2003. Print.
UNCEF. Women’s Rights in Islam and Somali Culture. Unicef.Som03-061, Taylor. 2002.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 38
United Nations [UN]. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Article 26). New York,
United Nations. 1948. Web. 03 August, 2015
UN. The UN Conventions on the Rights of the Child (Article 28). New York, United Nations.
1989. 03 August, 2015.
UNESCO. Addis Ababa Conference of African States on the Development of Education in
Africa Final Report. Paris: UNESCO and ECA. 1961. Web. 03 August, 2015.
UNICEF. Convention on the Rights of the Child. New York: UNICEF. 1990. Web. 04 August,
2015.
U.S. Department of State. “Background Note: Somalia”. Bureau of African Affairs. 2008. Web
15 August, 2015.
Accessed:http://0eds.a.ebscohost.com.aupac.lib.athabascau.ca/eds/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=2&
sid=8d4242a5-0fda-4bd8-bbb4-3807284bcd9e%40sessionmgr4003&hid=4102.
Gender Equality: Psycho-Social Perspectives on Girls’ Education in Somali. Page 39