HONG KONG LAWYER the OFFICIAL JOURNAL of the LAW SOCIETY of HONG KONG 香港律師會會刊 H K - L a W Y E R
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
二零一三年十一月 NOVEMBER 2013 HK$280 HONG KONG LAWYER THE OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF HONG KONG 香港律師會會刊 h k - l a w y e r . org COMMERCIAL 商 業 Clicking in Place – The Impact of the New Trade Descriptions Law 蓄勢待發 — 新商品說明法的影響 COMPETITION 競 爭 The New Competition Ordinance – Headache or Opportunity? 新《競爭條例》 — 是帶來了難題還是機會? 中國實務 N ON CHINA OVEMBER How Hybrid Investments are Taxed in China 2013 中國對混合性投資如何實行徵稅 Justice Zervos: CRIMINAL 刑 事 “If you want to be Sound Interference Found to be Battery - respected, you have to Is the Judgment Sound? (Part 1) respect others.” 法庭裁定聲音干擾構成毆打 — 這判決是否合理?(第一部分) 薛法官: 「如果你要得到別人的尊重, 便必須先懂得尊重別人。」 UP FOR GRABS Three Shopping Vouchers Worth HK$400 Each - See Editor’s Note Cover Story 封面專題 (pg. 4) Face to Face With 專 訪 Kevin Zervos 薛偉成法官 Judge of the Court of First Instance, High Court 高等法院原訟法庭法官 1309003_T06_R2_13/09/2013_ 300dpi pdf 1.4 upload www.hk-lawyer.org Hong Kong Lawyer 香港律師 The official journal of The Law Society of Hong Kong (incorporated with limited liability) 香港律師會 (以有限法律責任形式成立) 會刊 HONG KONG LAWYER www.hk-lawyer.org THE OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF HONG KONG 香港律師會會刊 Editorial Board 編輯委員會 Chairman 主席 Huen Wong 王桂壎 Inside your November issue Jenkin SF Chan 陳少勳 十一月期刊內容 Charles CC Chau 周致聰 Heidi KP Chu 朱潔冰 Steven B Gallagher Julienne Jen 任文慧 Dave Lau 劉子勁 George YC Mok 莫玄熾 Anne Scully-Hill Michele Tsang 曾憲薇 Adamas KS Wong 黃嘉晟 Cecilia KW Wong 黃吳潔華 Tony Yen 嚴元浩 THE COUNCIL OF THE LAW SOCIETY OF HONG KONG 香港律師會理事會 President 會長 Ambrose SK Lam 林新強 16 COVER STORY Vice-Presidents 副會長 Stephen WS Hung 熊運信 Thomas ST So 蘇紹聰 Council Members 理事會成員 Denis Brock 白樂德 Charles CC Chau 周致聰 Brian Gilchrist 喬柏仁 Junius KY Ho 何君堯 Angela WY Lee 李慧賢 Joseph CW Li 李超華 Michael J Lintern-Smith 史密夫 羅志力 Peter CL Lo 30 COMMERCIAL Billy WY Ma 馬華潤 Amirali B Nasir 黎雅明 Gavin P Nesbitt 倪廣恒 Kenneth SY Ng 伍成業 Melissa K Pang 彭韻僖 Sylvia WY Siu 蕭詠儀 36 COMPETITION Cecilia KW Wong 黃吳潔華 Cover: 封面: Huen Wong 王桂壎 At the Foreign Correspondents’ Club Hong Kong 在香港外國記者會 Dieter LT Yih 葉禮德 Secretary-General 秘書長 4 EDITOR’S NOTE [PDF] [HKL online] 編者的話 [PDF] [HKL online] Heidi KP Chu 朱潔冰 6 PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE [PDF] [HKL online] 會長的話 [PDF] [HKL online] Law Society’s Contact: www.hklawsoc.org.hk 與律師會聯繫 Tel: +852 2846 0500 8 CONTRIBUTORS [PDF] [HKL online] 投 稿 者 [PDF] [HKL online] 10 FROM THE COUNCIL TABLE [PDF] [HKL online] 理事會議題 [PDF] [HKL online] Annual Subscription 全年訂閱: HK$3,360 12 LETTER TO HONG KONG LAWYER [PDF] [HKL online] 給《 香 港 律 師 會 》的 信 [PDF] [HKL online] Thomson Reuters 10/F, Cityplaza 3, Taikoo Shing, Hong Kong 14 FROM THE SECRETARIAT [PDF] [HKL online] 律師會秘書處資訊 [PDF] [HKL online] Tel: +852 3762 3200 封面專題 www.thomsonreuters.com 16 COVER STORY [PDF] [HKL online] [PDF] [HKL online] Face to Face With 專 訪 ISSN 1025-9554 Kevin Zervos, Judge of the Court of First Instance, High Court 薛偉成法官,高等法院原訟法庭法官 © Copyright is reserved throughout. No part of this publication can be reproduced in whole or 24 LAW SOCIETY NEWS [PDF] [HKL online] 律師會新聞 [PDF] [HKL online] part without the express permission of the editor. [PDF] [HKL online] 商 業 [PDF] [HKL online] Contributions are invited, but copies of work should 30 COMMERCIAL be kept, as Hong Kong Lawyer can accept no Clicking in Place – 蓄勢待發 — 新商品說明法的影響 responsibility for loss. The Impact of the New Trade Descriptions Law 36 COMPETITION[PDF] [HKL online] 競 爭 [PDF] [HKL online] The New Competition Ordinance – 新《 競 爭 條 例 》— Headache or Opportunity? 是帶來了難題還是機會? NOVEMBER 2013 二零一三年十一月 HK$280 Managing Editor 執行主編 42 ON CHINA[PDF] [HKL online] 中國實務 [PDF] [HKL online] Vince Chong 張哲寧 How Hybrid Investments are Taxed in China 中國對混合性投資如何實行徵稅 [email protected] [PDF] [HKL online] 刑 事 [PDF] [HKL online] Chinese Editors 中文編輯 46 CRIMINAL Edmund Cham 湛樹基 Sound Interference Found to be Battery – 法庭裁定聲音干擾構成毆打 — Natalie Lee 李頴琳 Is the Judgment Sound? (Part 1) 這判決是否合理?(第一部分) Design and Production 設計及制作 52 INDUSTRY INSIGHTS [PDF] [HKL online] 業界透視 [PDF] [HKL online] Samson Pang 彭振生 [PDF] [HKL online] 案例撮要 [PDF] [HKL online] Sales and Marketing Director 銷售總監 62 CASES IN BRIEF Jane Lewis 劉真美 72 LEGISLATION UPDATES [PDF] [HKL online] 立法新知 [PDF] [HKL online] Commercial and Online Development Director 商業和網絡發展總監 73 PROFESSIONAL MOVES [PDF] [HKL online] 會員動向 [PDF] [HKL online] Robert Head [email protected] 76 AFTER WORK [PDF] [HKL online] 工餘閒情 [PDF] [HKL online] What to Do in Paris with a Baby 暢遊巴黎指南之嬰兒出行篇 Content Development Director 內容發展總監 82 CAMPUS VOICES [PDF] [HKL online] 法學院新聞 [PDF] [HKL online] Neerav Srivastava 史立楓 [email protected] 84 THE LAST WORD [PDF] [HKL online] 趣 聞 Translation team 翻譯組: Info Power Staff contributors 內部貢獻: Carmen Chu 朱慧敏 Vivian Leung 梁靜妍 Rocky So 蘇衍成 Special thanks to Hong Kong Law Reports & Digest and Reuters News 特別感謝 香港法律彙報與摘錄 及 路透社新聞 For marketing/promotion opportunities please contact: Gordon Ng 吳子鵬 [email protected] Tel: +852 3762 3223 For subscriptions contact: Traffic Administrator 統籌 42 ON CHINA Vivian Leung 梁靜妍 [email protected] Tel: +852 3762 3268 Publisher 出版人 Klaus Pfeifer 范梓樺 [email protected] All information and views expressed by contributors and advertisements in Hong Kong 46 CRIMINAL Lawyer do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of The Law Society of Hong Kong. Whilst every effort is made to ensure editorial and commercial integrity, no responsibility is accepted by the Publisher or The Law Society of Hong Kong for the accuracy of material appearing in this journal. Members are encouraged to contribute but the Editorial Board of The Law Society of Hong Kong reserves the right to publish only material it deems appropriate. 76 AFTER WORK • November 2013 EDITOR’S NOTE 編者的話 Every instance of change begs the question: is it for the better? 每次作出改變,大家總會問:這改變是好是壞? In this issue, lawyers tell us that new guidance for hybrid investments 今期有律師跟大家講解內地就混合性投資發出的新指引 over the border will better support how that market works (pg.42). 將如何有助該市場的運作(詳見第44頁)。不過,新修訂 The same optimism cannot be said of say, the new trade descriptions 的商品說明法例卻相反,有專家認為條例原意雖好,但 law, which another expert believes might trip up unwary and honest businesses, in spite of its good intentions (pg.30). So it is too with 可能令粗心大意而誠實的企業意外遭殃(詳見第33頁)。 the impending new competition law – is this a headache or an 即將實施的競爭法亦要面對同樣的利弊問題(詳見第39 opportunity (pg.36), asks another of our esteemed contributors. 頁),今期有一位資深的撰稿人為我們作深入剖析。 In case law, our authors argue that a recent ruling that says sound 至於案例方面,最近法庭裁定聲音干擾(在別人耳邊吹口 interference (whistling at a person’s ear, without bodily contact) 哨而沒有身體接觸)構成毆打,有作者認為有關裁決必須 constitutes battery must be reviewed by higher authority (pg.46). Otherwise, there may be “far-reaching and unintended” implications. 由上級法院覆核(詳見第49頁),否則可能引起「深遠且 非預期」的影響。 And in our latest cover interview, our subject just happens to be someone in the midst of change: Justice Kevin Zervos recently moved 事有湊巧,今期專訪的主人翁正身處變化中:前律政司 from the Department of Justice, where he was Director of Public 刑事檢控專員薛偉成最近獲委任為高等法院原訟法庭法 Prosecutions, to the Court of First Instance, where he now sits as 官(詳見第21頁)。 judge (pg. 16). Well, as some say, any change beats stagnancy. What is key 正如有人說,有改變總比沒有改變好。重要的是,我們 and healthy is that outlets such as Hong Kong Lawyer allow for 有像《香港律師》這樣的渠道允許資訊得以自由和負責 information to be exchanged freely and responsibly, so that we can 任地交流,讓大家能夠從中學習並為自己下決定。學海 all learn and make up our minds for ourselves. As Justice Zervos 無涯的道理,相信薛官也會認同。 would agree, we can never learn enough. Talking about information, we also hope that readers will be able 談到資訊這個課題,本刊誠邀廣大讀者參與我們最新 to part with some in our latest online survey at https://www. 的網上調查,網址如下:https://www.surveymonkey. surveymonkey.com/s/65J95N5. This will as usual allow us to fine- com/s/65J95N5。是項調查將有助我們調整《香港律 tune Hong Kong Lawyer in terms of both editorial and advertising 師》在編輯及廣告方面的內容。讀者可以選擇以匿名 content. Readers can respond anonymously or otherwise, and the 方式回應,首五名參與調查並附上聯絡方法的讀者, first three readers to do so with their contact details will receive a HK$400 shopping voucher from a premium department store. The 可獲贈價值400港元的購物禮券,其後七名可獲贈 next seven will each get a White Book Notebook. As to be expected, White Book 筆記本乙本。一如大家所料,上述安排不適 this arrangement excludes relevant personnel such as Thomson 用於相關人員,如湯森路透的員工及其直系家屬。不勝 Reuters staff and their immediate families. Many thanks. 感激! Vince Chong 張哲寧 Editor, Hong Kong Lawyer 《香港律師》編輯 Managing Editor, Sweet & Maxwell Sweet & Maxwell執行主編 Thomson Reuters 湯森路透 [email protected] 4 www.hk-lawyer.org • November 2013 PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE 會長的話 To build a global network and enhance the profession’s European, North and South American ❝ jurisdictions than those from Asia. international image and capability, the Law Society has been There may be a variety of reasons for actively promoting the culture of reaching out. this phenomenon, including language and cultural diversities, that impact One way is to encourage participation the recent IBA Annual Conference on the membership development of a in international legal conferences. in Boston for example. With many particular organisation. These events create an environment other bar leaders also attending the In the course of attending events that is both rigorous and fun as well as Conference, I was fortunate enough to organised by international scholarly and social. Participants with be able to arrange meetings separately organisations, I have always wondered common interests in specific practice with the President of the Law Council why Hong Kong, being a renowned areas have the opportunity to gather of Australia, the President of the Law international city, is not itself home to and share achievements and problems Society of New South Wales, the an international legal organisation.