Download Download

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Download Download Pandemic Praxis Commentary on 'All Bodies': Indian perspective Satendra Singh, MD Deputy Editor­in­chief, RHiME and Associate Professor, Physiology, University College of Medical Sciences and GTB Hospital, University of Delhi, India Corresponding Author: Dr. Satendra Singh Department of Physiology, UCMS and GTB Hospital Delhi 110095, India Email: dr.satendra at gmail dot com Received: 19­MAY­2020 Accepted: 19­MAY­2020 Published Online: 21­MAY­2020 The commentary is in response to the graphic titled "All Bodies" which is accessible at http://rhime.in/ojs Artist Michaela Oteri @Ogrefairy "All Bodies" Source: Oteri M. All Bodies. RHiME. 2020;7:106­7. Unlocking Ubiquity the frame. The three in front have visible Absorbing the painting as a person with a disabilities as they clench their fists in disability in general and a doctor with a solidarity while being supported by their disability in particular, I can’t ignore the assistive devices (a prosthesis, a crutch, disabled lives lost in the pandemic (from and a wheelchair). The picture also COVID­19 or non­virus causes exacerbated embraces the much­neglected area of by pandemic). These people, to me, are the invisible disabilities and intersectionality. palest figures shown as trying to fade out of The message is loud and clear ­ all lives matter and nobody is disposable ­ be it Cite this article as: Singh S. Commentary on 'All Bodies': Indian perspective. RHiME. 2020;7:112-5. www.rhime.in 112 disabled people, elderly, people of color, (identifying procedures to tackle medical migrants, or transgender people. emergencies), rationing (identifying protocols to support multi­agency and multi­ Crip Camp, the Netflix documentary disciplinary collaboration), and triage released during the lockdown, explained (identifying how limited resources will be how a New York campground for people allocated to support medical care).[6] with disabilities inspired the American Disability Rights movement. For me, the The National Preparedness Survey on defining moment in the documentary was COVID­19 by the Department of when the protestors (some sitting in their Administrative Reform and Public wheelchairs and others leaning on Grievance uncovered what we were fearing crutches) abandoned their assistive devices ­ there are insufficient ICU beds and and began climbing the 78 marble steps up ventilators.[7] On March 29, eleven the Capitol. It was the coming of age of an Empowered Groups were constituted by the international disability rights movement. The Ministry of Home Affairs for planning and sight of protestors against the backdrop of ensuring the implementation of COVID­19 “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice response activities. The Chairman of everywhere” gels equally well with this Empowered Group­3 admitted that India artwork: #NoBodyIsDisposable. needed 75,000 ventilators and had only 19,000. Why ‘One Size Fits All’ Doesn’t Work in a Pandemic All of us struggle with the isolation of a On 24 March 2020, to fight COVID­19, the quarantined life and with the uncertainties Indian Government put in place a of a pandemic; however, many disabled nationwide lockdown under the provisions people have always had to manage such of the Disaster Management Act, 2005. The isolation, irrespective of pandemics. National Disaster Management Guidelines Moreover, with the acute shortage of (Hospital safety) describe how hospitals are ventilators, now doctors have to make the to act during a National Disaster. The dreaded decision of who lives and who section on triage contains merely a single dies. The disability sector is fearful that page guidance and utilizes the principle of these decisions will be based on “sickest first”.[1] The guiding ethical practitioners’ traditional prejudices and principles of ‘first­come, first­served’ are biases, especially on the surmised quality of clearly not suited for application to the life and the imagined social worth of people COVID­19 pandemic; however, even the with disabilities. ‘sickest first’ or ‘youngest first’ should be used with great caution and only when it Nothing About Us, Without Us aligns with the principle of maximizing The reason discrimination against disabled benefits.[2] people creeps easily into such medical decision­making is because of deficit­based Beauchamp and Childress’s bioethics perspectives (medical model of disability). It framework is built on four moral principles: took doctors with disabilities, in partnership respect for autonomy, beneficence, with activists and health professions nonmaleficence, and justice.[3] A deficiency educators, to frame disability competencies of this structure is that little experimental for health professions courses; the purpose proof exists showing that physicians utilize was to tackle such stereotypes and promote the four principles in ethical decision the human rights model of disability.[8] It is making.[4] Jonsen, Siegler, and Winslade unethical to use stereotypes about an bridged the gap by pioneering the “four­ individual's disability to ration care (some of quadrant” approach and establishing the the Crisis Standards of Care guidelines), field of Clinical Medical Ethics.[5] However, like weighing a patient's “worth” based on these principles get strained in case of the presence or absence of disabilities.[9] public health emergencies like COVID­19 Even in this pandemic International treaties which require the following: setting priority like the United Nations Convention on the www.rhime.in 113 Rights of Persons with Disabilities and has released COVID guidance prohibiting legislations like Americans with Disabilities discrimination based on disability.[9] In a Act, the Rights of Persons with Disabilities recent article, I proposed a Disability Ethics Act (Section 3.3; India), and Equality Act framework in employing anti­discriminatory (UK) are applicable. approaches to value disabled lives in triage. [11] The Bioethics Group of the Republic of The voices of disabled people are being San Marino has published similar guidance neglected in the response formulated to the but we need the voices of disability ethicists. COVID­19 Pandemic. The Disability­ [9] inclusive Disaster Risk Reduction (DiDRR) Guidelines from the Government of India The NoBody Is Disposable Coalition in the explicitly states that if DiDRR is to function, United States is campaigning against people with disabilities and their discrimination in triage. In their open letter organisations would have to be included in to medical professionals, they have an all decision­making that affects them unusual signatory listed among (Section IV, Point 15, page 27).[10] organisations supporting the cause ­ this is However, none of the circulars released by the Doctors with Disabilities: Agents of the Government of India includes disabled Change from India.[12] Society often forgets contributors. Canada stands out in this that disabled people are not always patients regard as perhaps the only country to but they may be health care providers too. establish a COVID19 Disability Advisory There are many doctors and nurses with Group by involving Disabled Peoples disabilities who are working at the frontline Organisation.[9] in this pandemic ­ we need look no further for evidence that the provisions that use of Kirschner, in her commentary on the above life expectancy and “life years” as the basis artwork, laments the medical and bioethics for allocating ventilators are discriminatory. communities for not showing solidarity in The presence in hospitals of providers with disability­inclusive COVID­19 response. disabilities shreds apart the false notion that Amidst growing protest by disability rights we should rely on ‘comorbidities’ to assess groups, the Office of Civil Rights in the US ‘long term survival’. References 1. National Disaster 3. Beauchamp T, Childress J. 7. Department of Administrative Management Guidelines: Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Reform and Public Grievance. Hospital Safety. A publication of 8th ed. New York, NY: Oxford National Preparedness Survey the National Disaster University Press; 2019. on COVID­19 responses of Management Authority, District Collectors and IAS Government of India. 2016 Feb 4. Page K. The four principles: Officers (2014­18 batches). 2020 [cited 2020 May 19]. Available can they be measured and do Apr 1 [cited 2020 May 19]. from https://ndma.gov.in/images/ they predict ethical decision Available from https:// guidelines/Guidelines­Hospital­ making? BMC Med Ethics. darpg.gov.in/sites/default/files/ Safety.pdf 2012;13:10. COVID­ 19%20Impact%20Feedback%20 2. Emanuel EJ, Persad G, 5. Teven CM, Gottliebhe LJ. The Report.pdf Upshur R, Thome B, Parker M, four­quadrant approach to Glickman A, Zhang C, Boyle C, ethical issues in burn care. AMA 8. Singh S, Cotts KG, Maroof Smith M, Phillips JP. Fair J Ethics. 2018;20(6):595­601. KA, Dhaliwal U, Singh N, Xie T. allocation of scarce medical Disability­inclusive resources in the time of Covid­ 6. Petrini C. Triage in public compassionate care: Disability 19. N Engl J Med. 2020 Mar 23. health emergencies: ethical competencies for an Indian doi: 10.1056/NEJMsb2005114. issues. Intern Emerg Med. Medical Graduate. J Family Med [Epub ahead of print] 2010;5(2):137­44. Prim Care [serial online] 2020 [cited 2020 May 19];9:1719­27. www.rhime.in 114 9. United Nations Human Rights 10. National Disaster 11. Singh S. Disability ethics in Office of the High Commissioner. Management Guidelines on the coronavirus crisis. J Family COVID19 and the Rights of Disability inclusive Disaster Risk Med Prim Care. 2020. Persons with Disabilities. 2020 Reduction. A publication of the [Forthcoming] April 29 [cited 2020 May 19]. National Disaster Management Available from https:// Authority, Government of India. 12. No Body Is Disabled. Open www.un.org/development/desa/ September 2019 [cited 2020 letter to providers and hospitals. disabilities/wp­content/uploads/ May 19]. Available from https:// 2020 [cited 2020 May 19] sites/15/2020/04/COVID­ gidm.gujarat.gov.in/en/ndma­ Available from https:// 19_and_The_Rights_of_Persons guidelines nobodyisdisposable.org/open­ _with_Disabilities.pdf letter/ www.rhime.in 115.
Recommended publications
  • Satendra Singh, MD Professor (Physiology)
    Satendra Singh, MD Professor (Physiology) MBBS from GSVM Medical College, Kanpur, UP MD from PGIMS Rohtak, Haryana Joined the institute in 2008 as faculty Fellowship in Clinical Medical Ethics from MacLean Center, University of Chicago, (2019-20) Fellowship in Foundation for Advancement of International Medical Education and Research (FIAMER) from CMC Ludhiana (2011-13) Email: [email protected] Academic/Administrative Posts . Co-Chair of International Council for Disability Inclusion in Medical Education (2021- 23) . Visiting Scholar, MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics at University of Chicago (2019-20) . Bucksbaum International Scholar, Bucksbaum Institute for Clinical Excellence at University of Chicago . Member, Delhi State Committee for Research on Disability(2019-2022) . Adjunct Faculty, Department of Medical Education, KMC Manipal Academy of Higher Education (2018 onwards) . Ethics Committee Member & Executive Member, Delhi Medical Council (2015-2020) . Executive member and life member, Academy of Health Professions Educators . Honorary Lifetime Membership of Association for Transgender Health in India . Member, Indian Professional Association for Transgender Health (IPATH) . Member, Indian Academy of Cerebral Palsy . Life member, Indian Society for Sleep Research . Co-founder, Health Humanities Group . Member of the Standards Development Group to develop global WHO Standards for Wheelchair Service Provision . Domain expert (Health) in the State Advisory board for State Commissioner (Disabilities), Govt of Delhi . State
    [Show full text]
  • Docswithdisabilities Podcast #8 Satendra Singh, MBBS, MD Release Date: November 26, 2019
    DocsWithDisabilities Podcast #8 Satendra Singh, MBBS, MD Release Date: November 26, 2019 Satendra Singh, MBBS, MD: Transforming Medical Education in India Introduction: Lisa Meeks Doctors with disabilities exist in small but measurable numbers. How did they navigate their journey? What were the challenges? What are the benefits to patients and to their peers? What can we learn from their experiences? My name is Lisa Meeks and I am thrilled to bring you the Docs with Disabilities podcast. Join me as I interview Docs, Nurses, Psychologists, OT’s, PT’s, Pharmacists, Dentists, and the list goes on. I’ll also be interviewing researchers and policy makers that ensure medicine remains an equal opportunity profession. Lisa Meeks: We are excited to bring you a special international episode of the Docs with Disabilities Podcast. Today, I get to chat with Dr. Singh, about his incredible victories of late, including the addition of 8 disability focused competencies to the medical education curriculum in India. Let’s listen, or read along, as Dr. Singh talks about these new competencies within the new curriculum. Satendra Singh: We in India modified our curriculum after 22 years, and now the curriculum is a competency based medical education curriculum. Even in the previous curriculum, the similitude of the elephant in the room has been used to chronicle the experiences of patients with disabilities within the medical profession that she is present but unnoticed. And that was a reason why we for a very long time use the medical model of disabilities in our curriculum. So, when our curriculum was updated again, they came up with a new competency-based medical education curriculum, but unfortunately it still did not include the human rights approach towards people with disability.
    [Show full text]
  • The Viscardi Voice Newsletter, Volume 9, Winter 2018
    VISCARDI VOLUME 9 | WINTER 2018 Voice Global Disability Innovators 2017 VISCARDI AWARD RECIPIENTS Vashkar Bhattacharjee Honored at Achievement Awards a2i Program/Prime Minister’s Office/ YPSA/GAATES Bangladesh Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu Ministry of Social Development South Africa Justin Constantine U.S. Marine Corps Veteran/ The Constantine Group New York, NY Col. Gregory D. Gadson U.S. Army Veteran/Patriot Strategies Alexandria, VA Matt King Facebook Menlo Park, CA Every year, The Viscardi Center is proud Dr. Henry Viscardi, Jr., who himself wore to recognize individuals with disabilities prosthetic legs. The Awards were once Dr. Satendra Singh, University College of Medical Sciences who, through the example of their profound again co-chaired by Former Senator Delhi, India professional accomplishments, are breaking Bob Dole alongside Sherwood “Woody” down barriers and reshaping how society Goldberg, Esq. retired U.S. Army Colonel perceives disability. and current Senior Advisor for Asian Affairs Yuval Wagner at the Center for Naval Analysis. Access Israel Drawing nominations from around Israel the globe, the 2017 Henry Viscardi The 2017 cohort is influencing change at Achievement Awards were bestowed home and abroad by making Facebook last December to nine remarkable more user friendly for all; fighting to elevate Thomas J. Wlodkowski individuals from six different countries, with accessibility standards in India’s health Comcast distinguished backgrounds in academia, care sector; revolutionizing disability and Philadelphia, PA health care, government, technology, and women’s rights in South Africa; raising nonprofit and corporate sectors. awareness for war veterans with invisible injuries; and, collectively, creating a world of Asim Zafar First conferred in 2013, the Henry Viscardi equal opportunity for future generations.
    [Show full text]
  • Government of India Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Kashipur IIM Kashipur Dated: 19/11/2019 To
    Print Government of India Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Kashipur IIM Kashipur Dated: 19/11/2019 To Shri Shri Mantosh Kumar Dr. Shakuntala Misra National Rehabilitation University, Male Hostel, Block -1, room no. 203 Mohan Road, Lucknow 226017 Registration Number : IIMKP/R/2019/00023 Dear Sir/Madam I am to refer to your Request for Information under RTI Act 2005, received vide letter dated 09/10/2019 and to say that point wise reply is attached for perusal. In case, you want to go for an appeal in connection with the information provided, you may appeal to the Appellate Authority indicated below within thirty days from the date of receipt of this letter. Mahesh Chandra Joshi FAA & CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER Address: IIM KASHIPURKUNDESHWARI, KASHIPURUDHAM SINGH NAGAR, UTTARAKHAND Phone No.: 7088270882 Yours faithfully ( Ravi Gupta) CPIO & Administrative Officer Phone No.: 9759588803 Email : [email protected] / Government of India Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Kashipur IIM Kashipur Dated: 19/11/2019 To Shri NARIMETI RAKESH 3-5-139/5 HYDERGUDA, SHIVANAGAR COONY HYDERABAD 500048 Registration Number : IIMKP/R/2019/80029 Dear Sir/Madam I am to refer to your Request for Information under RTI Act 2005, received vide letter dated 28/08/2019 and to say that point wise reply is attached for perusal. In case, you want to go for an appeal in connection with the information provided, you may appeal to the Appellate Authority indicated below within thirty days from the date of receipt of this letter. Mahesh Chandra Joshi FAA & CHIEF
    [Show full text]
  • POST-POLIO DIRECTORY 2021© Post-Polio Directory 2021©
    Post-Polio Health International’s POST-POLIO DIRECTORY 2021© Post-Polio Directory 2021© 1 Introduction 2 International Health Professionals and Support Organizations 11 United States Health Professionals and Support Organizations 27 Other Useful Contacts Post-Polio Directory 2021© is for information purposes only. A listing does not imply endorsement by Post-Polio Health International. ©Copyright 2020 by Post-Polio Health International (PHI). All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form without permission in writing from the copyright holder. Additions and corrections may be sent to [email protected] Printed copies are $15 each at http://shop.post-polio.org. 50 Crestwood Executive Center #440, St. Louis, MO 63126 USA 314-534-0475, 314-534-5070 fax [email protected], www.post-polio.org, www.polioplace.org UPDATED 4-24-21 Introduction: PHI, then Gazette International Networking Institute, published its first Post-Polio Directory in 1985 to assist survivors of polio who were experiencing the late effects of polio to find health professionals. At the 1983 Conference, the organization was charged with encouraging the formation of local support groups and the current Post-Polio Directory includes those groups, too. How it is organized: There are three sections. 1) International Health Professionals and Support Organizations, which are organized alphabetically by country with health professionals listed first in alphabetical order by city, followed by support groups listed by alphabetical order by city. 2) United States Health Professionals and Support Organizations, which are organized alphabetically by state with health professionals listed first in alphabetical order by city, followed by support groups listed in alphabetical order by city.
    [Show full text]
  • NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards
    The NCPEDP-MphasiS Universal Design Awards logo stands for the spirit of Freedom and Celebration. The person with disability appears to be throwing her/ his arms up in the air in celebration of the awards and the hope they bring to so many. The dynamic oval form gives an illusion of constant motion suggesting that people can achieve whatever they want, regardless of the odds stacked against them. The orange colour further enhances this optimism of the new universal and inclusive world. The NCPEDP-MphasiS Universal Design Awards Conservative estimates put the population of people with Working Professionals Awards in this category are given to disabilities in India at 70-100 million. Only a miniscule people who work for the cause of accessibility and Universal percentage of this population can be seen in the mainstream. Design in any of the areas such as built environment, The core reason for this is the basic lack of access. transport infrastructure, service provision, information Accessibility not only means access to physical spaces but also and communication technology (ICT), universally designed means access to information, technology, transport, services, consumer products, mobility & independent living aids, or aids and appliances, etc. Access, therefore, is an issue that assistive technology. cuts across disabilities and sectors and forms the very basis of empowerment of people with disabilities. A concept that She/ he may be an employee of an education institute/ NGO/ is intrinsic to any kind of access is ‘Universal Design’, which corporate/ government body that has taken up the cause, or means a design that is usable to the greatest extent possible may be a consultant or freelancer who has devoted her/ his by everyone, regardless of age, ability, or situation.
    [Show full text]
  • Disability Ethics in the Coronavirus Crisis Satendra Singh1 1Medical Humanities Group, University College of Medical Sciences, Delhi, India
    Invited Articles Disability ethics in the coronavirus crisis Satendra Singh1 1Medical Humanities Group, University College of Medical Sciences, Delhi, India ABSTACT The disability viewpoint is fundamental for understanding and advancing social justice for everyone in the population. Despite this fact, it is regularly dismissed by public health experts and policymakers. Understanding of disability rights is central in an all‑inclusive COVID‑19 preparedness. This paper attempts to explore disability ethics in understanding structural discrimination, equitable practices, respect for disability culture and ways to safeguard health care professionals with disabilities in the coronavirus pandemic. In crisis standards of care, resource allocations must not be solely based on a disabled person’s subjective quality of life. Health professionals should avoid stereotypes about an individual’s disability to ration care. Triage protocol committees and disaster risk reduction working groups should explicitly recruit people with disabilities and chronic illnesses in their response strategies. Disability ethics can reform medical rationing by removing prejudices and safeguarding fair protection of the interests of all patients, including those with a disability. Keywords: Clinical ethics, coronavirus, COVID‑19, disability studies, disabled persons, health equity, medical ethics, pandemics, resource allocation, social justice, standards of care/ethics*, triage The outbreak of a novel coronavirus—first reported in Wuhan, everyday activities.[3] In a pandemic like COVID‑19, the task China, on 31 December 2019—quickly erupted into a human of primary care teams becomes more challenging because crisis. In the past, respiratory outbreaks have been named without of lockdown restrictions. The prominent bioethics institute consideration of unintended negative impacts: like the “Swine Flu” Hastings Center has proposed 3 ethical duties for health care and “Middle East Respiratory Syndrome”.
    [Show full text]
  • Infinite Ability: the Confluence of Disability and Medical Humanities
    20 International Journal of User-Driven Healthcare, 3(4), 20-23, October-December 2013 Infinite Ability: The Confluence of Disability and Medical Humanities Satendra Singh, Department of Physiology, University College of Medical Sciences, University of Delhi, Delhi, India ABSTRACT In June 2011, Infinite Ability, a new special interest group on disability within the Medical Humanities Group was formed to explore disability through creativity. Disability studies are sporadically used in Medical Humanities program. Since persons with disabilities constitute a large minority, we need to bridge the gap so as to move towards social model of disability. The author describe an innovation of reaching people with disabled attitude through medical humanities and believes further research can help in incorporating new evidences towards achieving new special interest group on disability and initial activities in sensitizing people Keywords: Disability, Disability through Creativity, Disabled Attitude, Medical Education, Medical Humanities BACKGROUND Article 1 of the United Nation’s Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities defines Deobrah Kirklin defines Medical Humanities PwD as those who have long-term physical, (MH) as “an interdisciplinary and an increas- mental, intellectual, or sensory impairments ingly international endeavor that draws on the which in interaction with various barriers may creative and intellectual strengths of diverse hinder their full and effective participation in disciplines including literature, art, creative the society on an equal basis with others. The writing, drama, film, music, philosophy, ethical list of disabilities include autism spectrum decision making, anthropology, and history in disorders, blindness, cerebral palsy, chronic neu- pursuit of medical educational goals” (Kirklin, rological conditions, deaf-blindness, dwarfism, 2009).
    [Show full text]
  • Infinite Ability
    Miscellanea Med Humanities: first published as 10.1136/jmh.2010.006841 on 16 February 2011. Downloaded from And concepts of the absolute Are naught but man-made things Born of a lust for certainty The natter of truth-mongering Alas, where can a heart like mine turn To make sense of this place Whether religion of science or of god Both are built on boundless faith If freedom is found in belief’s pursuit Then I starve to be free Yet faith shan’t be freed from reason’s grasp And my reason comes only from me. Daniel S Barron University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio Correspondence to Daniel S Barron, 8403 Floyd Curl Dr., San Antonio, TX 78229, USA; [email protected] Competing interests None to declare. Provenance and peer review Not commisioned; not externally peer reviewed. Published Online First 19 April 2011 J Med Ethics; Medical Humanities 2011;37:44e45. doi:10.1136/jmh.2011.007559 Infinite ability The uneasy fumble, the continued struggle and the visible cripple Became part of his life since inception The orthopedic surgeon diagnosed PPRP 70% The proud parents interrupted, it’s motivation 100% The weakened quadriceps were encircled by iron callipers And two crutches were provided as limp stabilizers Hydrotherapy, electrotherapy, surgical therapy Everything was tried without reluctance No defiance, this was sheer persistence http://mh.bmj.com/ The tortoise began his education amongst hares The damaged motor neurons were equally compensated with able mentors Partial cerebral hypertrophy stabilized the atrophied limb And the affective domain overpowered the psychomotor defect Stairs were his biggest fear They still are on October 1, 2021 by guest.
    [Show full text]
  • Online Directory 2016 Delhi Govt
    Directorate of Information & Publicity DELHI GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL DIRECTORY 2016 GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI 1 Directorate of Information & Publicity DELHI GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL DIRECTORY 2016 Published by: THE DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF INFORMATION AND PUBLICITY Government of NCT of Delhi Block No. IX, Old Secretariat, Delhi-110054 Website: www.publicity.delhigovt.nic.in Complied, Designed, Edited & Printed by: DISHA COMMUNICATIONS PVT. LTD. 6-G, 6th Floor, 25, Gopala Tower, Rajendra Place, New Delhi-110008 Ph.: 011-25714083, 42322051 Telefax: 011-25714083 Website: www.dishacom.com ABBREVIATIONS USED IN THIS DIRECTORY FOR COMMUNICATION COLUMN O: - Office R: - Residence F: - Fax M: - Mobile P: - Phone 2 Directorate of Information & Publicity PERSONAL INFORMATION Name: Occupation: Office: Pin: Phone: Residence: Pin: Phone Fax: Telefax: Mobile: E-mail: Accreditation No.: Passport: Credit Card: Driving Licence: Blood Group: Bank: Insurance Policy: Income Tax: PAN No.: Doctor: Contact: Solicitor: Contact: Tax Consultant: Contact: In case of Emergency: 3 Directorate of Information & Publicity IMPORTANT TELEPHONE NUMBERS Police 100 24 HOUR CHEMIST Delhi Fire Service 101 Max Medical Center 26515050 Ambulance 102 AIIMS 26560110 CATS 23860524, 23860525, 23860531 Vasant Lok Hospital 26142730 Holy Angels Hospital 26143411 HOSPITALS AIIMS 26588500, 26588900, 26588700 BLOOD BANK Batra 29958747, 29957485-87 Blood Bank Organisation 25721270 Fortis Escorts Heart Institute 47135000 Red Cross 23716441 Ganga Ram Hospital 25735218 Pusa Road 25721870 Hindurao Hospital
    [Show full text]
  • Criteria-Vii Innovations and Best Practices
    CRITERIA-VII INNOVATIONS AND BEST PRACTICES 0 7.1 Environment Consciousness 7.1.1 Does the institution conduct a Green Audit of its Campus The institution is conscious of its green responsibilities and endeavours at every step to be as environmentally friendly as is feasible in is functional constraints as will be outlined from the responses below. However apart from self awareness and internal efforts at being green it has not undergone and external or third party audit at its campus thus far. 7.1.2 What are the green initiatives … Energy conservation – The institution has started converting all its electrical lighting, from compact Fluorescent lamp based to LED based lighting systems, in an ongoing effort to reduce its energy utilization foot print, in a phased manner. At present we are making our way through this initiative, several buildings have been fitted with LED lighting. Use of renewable energy – The institution has rooftop located solar water heating system for energy conservation and use of renewable sources of energy. These are installed in heavier demand areas such as the wards and OT Block. The use of solar water heating system is also being extended to other blocks of the institution, however, as there is limited roof space available in the multistoried blocks, further scope of solar power for water heating has become limited. Water harvesting – all the building drainage and rain-water run off systems of the campus have been designed and constructed by the PWD in a manner so as to enable ground water recharging. Solar panels – Due to limited roof area available in the multistoried blocks.
    [Show full text]
  • Action Report (June 2011-May 2012)
    1 Enabling Unit, UCMS ACE (Access, Communication, Education) action report (June 2011-May 2012) OBJECTIVES ACTION PLAN STATUS ACCESS Breaking barriers Needs assessment On target (Audit survey sent to Persons with Disabilities [PwD]) Accessible teaching Leniency towards students on On target room arriving late because of physical (Notice issued) disability & inaccessibility Accessible parking Accessible parking Behind schedule (Separate parking allowed but place not ear marked) Accessible library To explore the possibility of Major challenge making library (1st floor), reading (UGC HEPSN proposal sent to room(2nd floor) and Medical Principal, UCMS) Education Unit (2nd floor) (SIDPA proposal sent to Secy. accessible to PwD MSJE) Accessible post office To explore the possibility of In process making post office (1st floor) (Letters sent to Postmaster, MS, accessible to PwD XEN) Accessible bank To explore the possibility of In process making bank (1st floor) accessible (Letters sent to Branch Manager, to PwD MS, XEN) COMMUNICATION 2 Disability statistics Maintenance of PwD case histories Complete Website with important circulars, Ahead of schedule UGC guidelines & announcement (http://enablingunit.yolasite.com) Collaboration with EOC, DU On target (In touch with DU EOC) Creating Providing information’s from On target Opportunities various disability listserve’s & (Student selected for SYRACUSE associations Conference) (Student participation in PARWAZ) Latest updates on website On target (Infinite Ability website applauded in Times of India)
    [Show full text]