Table of Contents I. Introduction
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION.....................................................................................................................1 II. THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS MATTER A: The Rule of Law B Historical Sources.............................................................................3 B. The Rule of Law B Judicial Interpretation ......................................................................6 C. Alternative to the Rule of Law .........................................................................................7 D. Section 2(b) of the Charter B freedom of Expression....................................................8 III. THE INCIDENTS AND PROBLEMS ..............................................................................12 A. Removal of the Protest Camp at the Museum of Anthropology .......................12 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................12 (ii)Argument ......................................................................................................................13 B. Establishment of Protest Zones....................................................................................15 (i) Facts 16 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................18 C. Undertakings ................................................................................................................21 (i) Facts 21 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................21 D. Confiscation of Dennis Porter=s Media Pass 22 (i) Facts 22 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................22 E. Flagpole Protest (Arrest of David Malmo-Levine) ......................................................25 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................25 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................26 F. Surveillance and Arrest of Jaggi Singh 28 Surveillance of Jaggi Singh (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................29 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................29 Arrest of Jaggi Singh (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................30 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................31 G. Green College ..............................................................................................................33 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................33 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................36 H. Tibetan Flag .................................................................................................................40 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................40 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................40 I. Arrest of Protest Leaders...............................................................................................41 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................41 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................42 J. Protests at the Fence and Gate 6....................................................................................43 (i) Introduction...................................................................................................................43 (a) The Fence 46 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................46 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................46 (b) Gate 6 48 (i) Facts 48 (ii) Argument 50 K. Treatment of Prisoners in Transit and at Richmond Cells...........................................57 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................58 (a) Decontamination ..........................................................................................................58 (b) Overcrowding in Transport..........................................................................................60 (c) Overcrowding of Cells .................................................................................................60 (d) Rudeness and Neglect of Duty by Guards ..................................................................61 (e) Notice of and Conditions upon Release ......................................................................62 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................63 (a) Cruel and Unusual Treatment......................................................................................63 (b) Breach of RCMP Policy..............................................................................................67 L. Searches........................................................................................................................69 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................70 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................71 (a) The Arrest must be Lawful...........................................................................................71 (b) The Search Must be Conducted Incident to the Lawful Arrest...................................72 (c) The Manner in which the Search is Carried Out must be Reasonable........................74 (d) Breach of Duty .............................................................................................................79 M. Access to Counsel .......................................................................................................80 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................80 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................80 N. Detention......................................................................................................................82 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................82 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................83 (a) Unlawful Detention ......................................................................................................83 (b) Arbitrary Detention .....................................................................................................84 O. Videotape Evidence .....................................................................................................85 (i) Facts..............................................................................................................................85 (ii) Argument .....................................................................................................................85 IV. INVOLVEMENT OF THE PRIME MINISTER AND THE PRIME MINISTER=S OFFICE (i) Facts ..........................................................................................................................................86 (ii) Argument .................................................................................................................................86 V. CONCLUSIONS ....................................................................................................................89 VI. RECOMMENDATIONS .....................................................................................................90 Substantive.....................................................................................................................................90 Procedural ......................................................................................................................................92 ROYAL CANADIAN MOUNTED POLICE PUBLIC COMPLAINTS COMMISSION RELATING TO events that occurred in British Columbia on November 23rd to November 27th, 1997 on or near the University of British Columbia (“UBC”) campus and subsequently at the UBC and Richmond Detachments of the RCMP. Final Argument of the B.C Civil Liberties Association B.C. PUBLIC INTEREST ADVOCACY CENTRE Counsel for B.C. Civil 815 - 815 West Hastings Street Liberties Association Vancouver, B.C. V6C