In Abscondito:Visuality and Testimony in Raphael's Transfiguration

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

In Abscondito:Visuality and Testimony in Raphael's Transfiguration chapter 12 In Abscondito: Visuality and Testimony in Raphael’s Transfiguration Xavier Vert When* dealing with Christian history, painting is confronted with the duplicity of places, things, and events, what Erich Auerbach and Jean Daniélou taught us to recognize as figure.1 Whether it be a question of flowers in a meadow, a feat, or a miraculous healing, large or small, these things, gestures, or events, situated in time, take on certain aspects, present themselves in a certain way: they are disguised and driven by a dynamic that turns them into temporary enigmas. This figurative duplicity, also recognizable as the very process of history, brings together what has happened with what has not yet happened and, by the anteriority of a future, looks at what is from the horizon of what will be, as its sign or testimony. A figure in the Christian sense of the word is an enigma that inverts and contracts time but also an enigma dispelled at the moment of its fulfilment. Such a secret disposition is deduced from the visual structure enunciated by Paul, and often, if not always, recalled within the exegetical tradition of the divine mysteries, as in 1 Cor. 13:12: ‘For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror [per speculum in enigmate]; then we shall see face to face’. Thanks to its singular plasticity, the figure allows us to settle the mystery into the visible. In other words, the infinite network of figures woven into the Christian vision of history organises the visible according to the economy of mystery. It thus follows that a mystery, a mysterium-sacramentum, is figuratively adduced – if not accessible only by figures – and implies that the representation of its historical manifestation depends on the enigmatic arrangement or distribution of the visible;2 in that respect, both visual and exegetical, the image – the pictorial mimesis – may be considered as a place * For their generous insights and feedback on earlier drafts of this essay, I would like to thank warmly Walter S. Melion, Michel Weemans, and Giovanni Careri. My gratitude for their as- sistance to Véronique Eme-Martinez and Peter Briggs. 1 E. Auerbach, Mimesis: Dargestellte Wirklichkeit in der abendländischen Literatur (Bern: 1946); J. Daniélou, Sacramentum futuri: essai sur les origines de la typologie biblique (Paris: 1950). 2 On the difficulty of determining in the patristic and exegetical tradition, after Paul, a stable semantic distinction between mystery-mysterium and mystery-sacramentum, cf. E. Schillebeeckx, L’économie sacramentelle du salut (De sacramentele Heilseconomie), trans. © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2020 | doi:10.1163/9789004432260_014 430 Vert of passage for figures, a polarised field, or a medium.3 Following on from this approach, this essay attempts to provide a comparative perspective on mys- tery and visuality, secrecy and temporality, through the last and most famous painting of Raphael Urbino: The Transfiguration (1516–1520) [Fig. 12.1]. Indeed, since Vasari’s time, the altarpiece commissioned by Cardinal Giulio de’ Medici for Narbonne Cathedral – neither the tavola nor the copy made on purpose by Raphael’s workshop has been sent to France4 – is considered as Raphael’s artistic and spiritual testament, albeit no single interpretation has received general recognition.5 Y. van der Have (Fribourg: 2004); R. Stefaniak, “Replicating Mysteries of the Passion: Rosso’s Dead Christ with Angels”, Renaissance Quarterly 45, 4 (1992) 677–738. 3 On this conception of medium, mediality, and image, see H. Belting, “Image, Medium, Body: A New Approach to Iconology”, Critical Inquiry 31, 2 (2005) 302–319. In an essay close to the questions discussed here, Marsha Libina presents and examines the medial status of the image in a theological and political context where images have been specifically involved in the debate on biblical hermeneutics: ‘In the early decades of the 1500s, religious images entered into a way of thinking that was fundamental to how Catholic exegetes at this mo- ment conceived of the biblical text: as figurative and referential in nature, in other words, as a “mediated truth.” Image-makers thus took to their own pictorial medium to reflect on the unresolved questions of prophecy and scriptural exegesis. The theological debate and the [Lateran] council’s conflicted position on the mediation of scripture, in particular, prompted new ways of thinking about the figuration of divinity that were specific to questions concern- ing the hermeneutics of the man-made image and the medial status of art when representing the divine’. “‘False Prophecies,’ Scripture, and the Crisis of Mediation in Early Modern Rome: Sebastiano del Piombo’s Borgherini Chapel in San Pietro in Montorio”, I Tatti Studies in the Italian Renaissance 11, 1 (2018) 67–104, 78. 4 The panel of almost equal size (396 × 263 cm), dated ca. 1520–28, later became part of the collections of the Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid. See T. Henry and P. Joannides, Raphaël: Les dernières années (Paris: 2012) 174–177. 5 The modern literature on Raphael’s Transfiguration is endless; only the studies cited through- out the text are indicated here. With respect to the incompleteness of the painting, upon the artist’s death, cf. F. Mancinelli, “La Trasfigurazione e la Pala di Monteluce: Considerazioni sulla loro tecnica esecutiva alla luce dei recenti restauri”, in Shearman J. – Hall M.B. (eds.), The Princeton Raphael Symposium: Science in the Service of Art History (Princeton: 1990) 149–160. For a genetic and interpretive approach, cf. K. Oberhuber, “Vorzeichnungen zu Raffaels ‘Transfiguration’”, Jahrbuch der Berliner Museen 4 (1962) 116–149; H. Von Einem, Die “Verklärung Christi” und die “Heilung des Besessenen” von Raffael (Wiesbaden: 1966). On the figure of christus medicus, the discussion between Posner and Shearman remains essen- tial: K.W.G. Posner, “Raphael’s Transfiguration and the Legacy of Leonardo”, Art Quarterly 35, 4 (1972) 343–374; idem, Leonardo and Central Italian Art (1515–1550) (New York: 1974); J. Shearman, Raphael’s Cartoons in the Collection of Her Majesty the Queen and the Tapestries for the Sistine Chapel (London: 1972); idem, “Raphael’s Clouds, and Correggio’s”, in Sambucco Hamoud M. – Strocchi M.L. (eds.), Studi su Raffaello: Atti del congresso internazionale di studi. Urbino-Firenze, 6–14 avril 1984 (Urbino: 1987) 657–668; idem, Raphael in Early Modern Sources, 1483–1602 (New Haven – London: 2003). Also see E.H. Gombrich, “The Ecclesiastical .
Recommended publications
  • California State University, Northridge
    CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, NORTHRIDGE The Palazzo del Te: Art, Power, and Giulio Romano’s Gigantic, yet Subtle, Game in the Age of Charles V and Federico Gonzaga A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements For the degree of Master of Arts in Interdisciplinary Studies with emphases in Art History and Political Science By Diana L. Michiulis December 2016 The thesis of Diana L. Michiulis is approved: ___________________________________ _____________________ Dr. Jean-Luc Bordeaux Date ___________________________________ _____________________ Dr. David Leitch Date ___________________________________ _____________________ Dr. Margaret Shiffrar, Chair Date California State University, Northridge ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to convey my deepest, sincere gratitude to my Thesis Committee Chair, Dr. Margaret Shiffrar, for all of her guidance, insights, patience, and encourage- ments. A massive "merci beaucoup" to Dr. Jean-Luc Bordeaux, without whom completion of my Master’s degree thesis would never have been fulfilled. It was through Dr. Bordeaux’s leadership, patience, as well as his tremendous knowledge of Renaissance art, Mannerist art, and museum art collections that I was able to achieve this ultimate goal in spite of numerous obstacles. My most heart-felt, gigantic appreciation to Dr. David Leitch, for his leadership, patience, innovative ideas, vast knowledge of political-theory, as well as political science at the intersection of aesthetic theory. Thank you also to Dr. Owen Doonan, for his amazing assistance with aesthetic theory and classical mythology. I am very grateful as well to Dr. Mario Ontiveros, for his advice, passion, and incredible knowledge of political art and art theory. And many thanks to Dr. Peri Klemm, for her counsel and spectacular help with the role of "spectacle" in art history.
    [Show full text]
  • An Examination of a Seventeenth- Century Copy of Raphael’S Holy Family, C.1518
    Uncovering the Original: An Examination of a Seventeenth- Century copy of Raphael’s Holy Family, c.1518. Annie Cornwell, Postgraduate in the Conservation of Easel Paintings Amalie Juel, MA Art History Uncovering the Original: An Examination of a 17th-Century copy of Raphael’s The Holy Family, c. 1518, The Prado Madrid. Introduction to The Project: This report has been written as part of the annual project Conservation and Art Historical Analysis, presented by the Sackler Research Forum at the Courtauld Institute of Art. Seeking to encourage collaboration between art historians and conservators, the scheme brings together two students - one from postgraduate art history and the other from easel paintings conservation - to complete an in-depth research project on a single piece of art. By doing so, the project allows a multifaceted approach combining historical research with technical analysis and, in this case, conservation treatment of the work in question. Focusing on the painting as a physical object with a material history, the project shows the value of combining art history with the more scientific aspects of the field of conservation. The focus of this project is a painting of the Virgin and Child with Saints Anne and John - a copy of Raphael’s Holy Family from the Prado - of unknown artist and date. It is owned by St Patrick’s Catholic Church in Wapping, where it had been recently found in a cupboard underneath the stairs. It came into the Courtauld Conservation Department to be treated by Annie Cornwell in November 2015, at which point it was in quite poor condition.
    [Show full text]
  • Barbara Böckmann Ludwig Gruner's Drawings After Raphael's Cartoons
    Barbara Böckmann Ludwig Gruner's Drawings after Raphael's Cartoons for the Tapestries in the Vatican A Discovery in the Kupferstich-Kabinett in Dresden Translation of the German version into English by Daniel Böckmann Erschienen 2021 auf ART-Dok URN: urn:nbn:de:bsz:16-artdok-72270 URL: http://archiv.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/artdok/volltexte/2021/7227 DOI: https://doi.org/10.11588/artdok.00007227 Ludwig Gruner's Drawings after Raphael's Cartoons for the Tapestries in the Vatican. A Discovery in the Kupferstich-Kabinett in Dresden © Dr. Barbara Böckmann Heidelberg [email protected] 1 Ludwig Gruner's Drawings after Raphael's Cartoons for the Tapestries in the Vatican. A Discovery in the Kupferstich-Kabinett in Dresden* __________________________________________________________________________ In the exhibition “Raffael – Macht der Bilder. Die Tapisserien und ihre Wirkung” in the Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, (6 July - 30 August 2020), six tapestries after the famous Raphael Cartoons - now in the Victoria & Albert Museum - were exhibited for the first time after long and spectacular restoration. Drawings, engravings and sculptures from the holdings of the Dresden State Art Collections as well as from international collections introduced the visitor to the history of the creation of the tapestries and their reception, which experienced a Europe-wide renaissance in the 19th century.1 Also on display were two large-format charcoal drawings after Raphael's cartoons “The Miraculous Draught of Fishes” and “The Death of Ananias”. The copies had been rediscovered “rolled up” in the Kupferstich-Kabinett Dresden on the occasion of the preparations for the tapestry exhibition, together with 13 other detailed studies.
    [Show full text]
  • The Young Talent in Italy
    Originalveröffentlichung in: Jonckheere, Koenraad (Hrsg.): Michiel Coxcie, 1499 - 1592, and the giants of his age : [...on the occasion of the exhibition "Michiel Coxcie: the Flemish Raphael", M - Museum Leuven, 31 October 2013 - 23 February 2014], London 2013, S. 50-63 und 198-204 Eckhard Leuschner THE YOUNG TALENT IN ITALY 4U ichiel Coxcie appears to have been in Italy between about 1530 and a.539.1 With just two exceptions (see below), no contemporary archival documentation relating to this phase of his career has so far been published. Giorgio Vasari mentions that he met Coxcie in Rome in M1532,2 and the surviving paintings, drawings and prints indicate that that is where he spent almost all his time in Italy. As far as the art history of Rome in the Cinquecento is concerned, the 1530s may well be the least studied decade of the century. 3 That is partly due to the political events of the previous years, especially the Sack of Rome in 1527 and its aftermath. When the troops of Emperor Charles V stripped the city of its treasures and political importance, they also weakened the finances of local patrons and the demand for art in general. However, the onset of the Reformation in the North had made itself felt even before then, and the number of works of art commissioned and produced in Rome had been in decline since the early 1520s.4 Although the city ’s artistic life never came to a complete standstill (not even during or immediately after the sack), the scarcity of information on artists active in Rome around 1530 speaks for itself.
    [Show full text]
  • Paul Barlow Imagining Intimacy
    J434 – 01-Barlow 24/3/05 1:06 pm Page 15 View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Northumbria Research Link Paul Barlow Imagining Intimacy: Rhetoric, Love and the Loss of Raphael This essay is concerned with intimacy in nineteenth-century art, in particular about an imagined kind of intimacy with the most admired of all artists – Raphael. I will try to demonstrate that this preoccupation with intimacy was a distinctive phenomenon of the period, but will concentrate in particular on three pictures about the process of painting emotional intimacy, all of which are connected to the figure of Raphael. Raphael was certainly the artist who was most closely associated with this capacity to ‘infuse’ intimacy into his art. As his biographers Crowe and Cavalcaselle wrote in 1882, Raphael! At the mere whisper of the magic name, our whole being seems spell-bound. Wonder, delight and awe, take possession of our souls, and throw us into a whirl of contending emotions … [He] infused into his creations not only his own but that universal spirit which touches each spectator as if it were stirring a part of his own being. He becomes familiar and an object of fondness to us because he moves by turns every fibre of our hearts … His versatility of means, and his power of rendering are all so varied and so true, they speak so straightforwardly to us, that we are always in commune with him.1 It is this particular ‘Raphaelite’ intimacy that I shall be exploring here, within the wider context of the transformations of History Painting in the period.
    [Show full text]
  • RAPHAEL's ACTS of the APOSTLES TAPESTRIES - the BIRTH of the TAPESTRY REPRODUCTION SYSTEM
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Textile Society of America Symposium Proceedings Textile Society of America 1994 Raphael’s Acts of the Apostles Tapestries: The irB th of the Tapestry Reproduction System Marjorie Durko Puryear University of Massachusetts ta Dartmouth, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/tsaconf Part of the Art and Materials Conservation Commons, Art Practice Commons, Fashion Design Commons, Fiber, Textile, and Weaving Arts Commons, Fine Arts Commons, and the Museum Studies Commons Puryear, Marjorie Durko, "Raphael’s Acts of the Apostles Tapestries: The irB th of the Tapestry Reproduction System" (1994). Textile Society of America Symposium Proceedings. 1047. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/tsaconf/1047 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Textile Society of America at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Textile Society of America Symposium Proceedings by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. Puryear, Marjorie Durko. “Raphael’s Acts of the Apostles Tapestries: The Birth of the Tapestry Reproduction System.” Contact, Crossover, Continuity: Proceedings of the Fourth Biennial Symposium of the Textile Society of America, September 22–24, 1994 (Los Angeles, CA: Textile Society of America, Inc., 1995). RAPHAEL'S ACTS of the APOSTLES TAPESTRIES - THE BIRTH of the TAPESTRY REPRODUCTION SYSTEM MARJORIE DURKO PURYEAR Professor of Textile Design/Fiber Arts, University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth College of Visual and Performing Arts, North Dartmouth, MA 02747 INTRODUCTION As a younger fiber artist at the beginning of my teaching career, I rarely found European tapestries of the 16th through 18th c.
    [Show full text]
  • Video Lecture by Rosa Maria Letts on the RAPHAEL CARTOONS
    3/29/2021 Video Lecture by Rosa Maria Letts on THE RAPHAEL CARTOONS View this email in your browser Video Lecture by Rosa Maria Letts on THE RAPHAEL CARTOONS In anticipation of the reopening in the V&A of the Raphael Cartoons Gallery, which has been under restoration for over a year, we narrate the story of the seven Cartoons commissioned in 1515 by Pope Leo X Medici, for Tapestries to be hung in the Sistine Chapel. This was the Pope’s Chapel, used during the most important religious, political and social events of a Pontificate. Raffaello, Feed My Sheep; Gouache on Paper, Raphael Cartoon Gallery, Victoria & Albert Museum, London Their design had to be dramatic, imposing, unique but rendered by the Tapestry Maker chosen, in this case Pieter van Aelst from Brussels, "The Tapissier du Roy" (the Kings’ Weaver) used by all European Kings, Emperor, aristocrats of the 16 C. Inspired by the Acts of the Apostles and created during the summit of Raphael's artistic career, he was able to see their realisation as tapestries in December 1519. He died three months later. In his famous Discourses written in 1778, Joshua Reynolds wrote "the most considerable and most esteemed works of Raffaello, are his Fresco Pictures in the Vatican and his Cartoons in England... and John Pope Hennessy writing in 1950 described as "the main scenes in the History of early Christianity interpreted by one of the world’s greatest artists in his full maturity." COST: Members & Friends £15 / Others £18 TO BOOK contact Accademia Italiana / Artstur - 07720812183 - [email protected] PAYMENT: should be made by bank transfer as follows: Bank: CARDONEBANKING - Name: Artstur Ltd; Sort Code: 23 18 84; Account: 78597529 or by cheque payable to Artstur Ltd, and posted to The Dell Pound Lane, Wood Street Village, Guildford Surrey GU33DT Accademia Italiana / Artstur 55 Exhibition Road, London SW7 2PN - Tel: 020 7591 0312 - Mob: 0772 0812 183 [email protected] - www.artstur.com https://us8.campaign-archive.com/?e=[UNIQID]&u=e67f2919d3986ae3c92f2c3bd&id=f47d3bcd8c 1/1.
    [Show full text]
  • Graphic Versus Photographic in the Nineteenth-Century Reproduction Trevor Fawcett
    GRAPHIC VERSUS PHOTOGRAPHIC IN THE NINETEENTH-CENTURY REPRODUCTION TREVOR FAWCETT I THE REPRODUCTIVE PRINT UP TO 1840 Good prints are no doubt better than bad pictures; or prints, generally speaking, are better than pictures; for we have more prints ofgood pictures than of bad ones; yet they are for the most part but hints, loose memorandums, outlines in little ofwhat the painter has done. How often, in turning over a number of choice engravings, do we tantalize ourselves by thinking 'what a head that must be', - in wondering what colour a piece of drapery is, green or black, - in wishing, in vain, to know the exact tone of the sky in a particular corner of the picture! Throw open the folding-doors ofa fine Collection and you see all you have desired realised at a blow- the bright originals starting up in their own proper shape, clad with flesh and blood, and teeming with the first conceptions of the painter's mind! So William Hazlitt, musing on reproductions and going on to console himself with the thought that at least their inadequacy made 'the sight of a fine original picture an event so much the more memorable, and the impression so much the deeper. A visit to a genuine Collection is like going a pilgrimage.'! Yet reproductive prints were indispensable. People had to rely on them. The masterpieces of Western painting were scattered through Europe or hidden away in private galleries. Even the assiduous grand tourist saw only a fraction and that relatively briefly. A heavy responsibility was placed on their printed simulacra to represent them justly.
    [Show full text]
  • La Venaria Reale 2015 Raffaello Il Sole Delle Arti.Pub
    La Venaria Reale 2015 Raphael. The Sunshine of the Arts. La Venaria Reale – Communication & Press Office Piazza della Repubblica 4 – 10078 Venaria Reale (Turin) +39 011 4992300 (Main Switchboard - Offices) - +39 011 4992333 (Call Center) [email protected] - www.lavenaria.it 1 La Venaria Reale – Communication & Press Office Piazza della Repubblica 4 – 10078 Venaria Reale (Turin) +39 011 4992300 (Main Switchboard - Offices) - +39 011 4992333 (Call Center) [email protected] - www.lavenaria.it 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS • Page 04 Raphael. The Sunshine of the Arts. • Page 05 The exhibition • Page 11 General Information La Venaria Reale – Communication & Press Office Piazza della Repubblica 4 – 10078 Venaria Reale (Turin) +39 011 4992300 (Main Switchboard - Offices) - +39 011 4992333 (Call Center) [email protected] - www.lavenaria.it 3 Raphael The Sunshine of the Arts. "[…] the famous Raphael, in whose lifetime great Mother Nature feared to be outdone, and at whose death feared to die." Pietro Bembo Rooms of the Arts, Reggia di Venaria From 26 September 2015 to 24 January 2016 Curated by Gabriele Barucca and Sylvia Ferino Scientific Committee: Antonio Paolucci (chair), Cristina Acidini, Anna Imponente, Lorenza Mochi Onori, Maria Luisa Papotti, Mario Scalini, Maria Sframeli, Maria Rosaria Valazzi Organization: Consorzio La Venaria Reale, with the participation of MondoMostre srl and Fondazione per la Cultura Torino Partners: Intesa San Paolo With the support of: Compagnia di San Paolo Under the patronage of: The City of Turin Città metropolitana di Torino From 26 September 2015 to 24 January 2016 the Reggia di Venaria - the grandiose estate located just outside Turin, a masterpiece of architectural and landscape, enlisted as one of UNESCO's World Heritage sites - devotes an extraordinary exhibition to Raphael (Urbino, 1483 - Rome, 1520), the sublime artist who attained unprecedented heights of perfection in the 16th century, with loans from leading Italian and international museums.
    [Show full text]
  • The High-Resolution Recording of the Raphael Cartoons Factum Foundation for the V&A and Royal Collection Trust
    For immediate release – 24/09/2020 The high-resolution recording of the Raphael Cartoons Factum Foundation for the V&A and Royal Collection Trust The Raphael Court at the V&A during the recording process © Gabriel Scarpa for Factum Foundation In August 2019, a team of 3D-scanning and photography specialists from Factum Foundation carried out the recording of the Raphael Cartoons at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London. The Cartoons, lent to the V&A from the Royal Collection by Her Majesty The Queen, are among the greatest treasures of the Renaissance in the UK. After his election in March 1513, Pope Leo X commissioned Raphael to create a set of ten full-scale designs for a series of tapestries for the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican Palace, illustrating scenes from the lives of Saint Peter and Saint Paul. Once complete, the Cartoons were sent to the workshop of merchant- weaver Pieter van Aelst in Brussels, which transformed the monumental designs into tapestries. Seven of Inscrita en el Registro de Fundaciones por OM 24/09/2009 con nº 878. VAT no. ESG85614899 [email protected] calle Albarracín, 28 - 28037 Madrid, Spain. Telf +34 91 5500978 / 44 Lexington Street - W1F 0LP London, United Kingdom For immediate release – 24/09/2020 the Cartoons survive to this day and have been on public display in the South Kensington Museum – now the V&A – since 1865. In 2020 – to mark the 500th anniversary of Raphael’s death – the V&A are transforming the way visitors experience the Cartoons through a refurbishment of The Raphael Court and a new interpretive approach, which uses Factum Foundation’s recordings to reveal in-depth stories about the monumental works of art.
    [Show full text]
  • Two Halves of a Whole: Raphael's Designs, Tapestries Reunite
    Two halves of a whole: Raphael’s designs, tapestries reunite VATICAN CITY – Like long-lost twins, two halves of an artistic masterpiece conceived by the Renaissance master Raphael will be reunited for the first time. The Vatican Museums and London’s Victoria and Albert Museum will exhibit side-by- side some of Raphael’s enormous tapestries for the Sistine Chapel and his preparatory paintings. The joint initiative is meant to coincide with Pope Benedict XVI’s first visit to the United Kingdom in September. Since the Renaissance, “the cartoons and the tapestries have led separate lives” and the Sept 8-Oct. 17 exhibit will bring together “the two halves of the same story,” Mark Evans, senior curator of the Victoria and Albert Museum, told Catholic News Service July 14. Reuniting the two halves will help people “contrast the two designs” and help them “understand how (Raphael’s designs) matured, developed and were finalized over time,” he said. Just four of the Vatican’s 10 Sistine Chapel tapestries will hang with Raphael’s seven surviving cartoons in London. To celebrate the initiative, the Vatican invited a select group of guests to preview the tapestries before they were shipped off to London for the special exhibit. To make the event even more unique, for one night only – July 14 – six of the tapestries were hung exactly where they were originally designed to be placed: on the lower walls of the Sistine Chapel. It was the first time in 30 years the tapestries hung from their original 16th-century location. Michelangelo completed the Sistine Chapel ceiling in 1512.
    [Show full text]
  • A Partial Bibliography of the Works of Raphael
    -f 1h -f- # "lip- . " : # -' 7^'" TIT' THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LIBRARY 4» 4^ 1903 f ^ # D78 . # # # ij^" ' 4" 4"- 'y ' 4^ : W -if^- t* r T > f ^ ^ + + * r 4 # ' # f f . ^ • . ^ ^ if- f * # # ^ # , t # f 4' * 3^ # # 1^ f , 4 f ^ ^ f ^ ^ ^ 4 3fk I ^ # ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ - 4 .4 # ^ -4- 4 # -4 ^ 0- ^ # if* ,^ # ^ ^ # # ^ ? <^ + f H^. ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ 4 # . * f t f # t it ^ ^ ^ # \ JL a A- ^ip-TT-^ir If' ^ If -1P^ ^ IF 1r ^ ^ f # lit, - . ^ # ^ ^ ir^ lr ^ ^ 1p T ^ IP ^ ^ ^ 4 ^^4^^ " . 1^ , / 1^ # T /? ^ ^ # # # ^ # ^ * ' ' # # # ^ 1 4 ^ ^ ^ A PARTIAL .BIBLIOORAPHY OP THE v.'OFLKS OF RAPJIAEL JEANNETTE IJAY IDRAKE THESIS PRESENTED FOR THE PEaREE OF BACHELOR OP LIPPJiRY SCIETIOE in the STATE LI3R/.RY SCHOOL UlIIVERSITY OP ILLINOIS JUPE 1903 13 0? 1178 I I, I I 11 N I V H R S I T Y OH L N O S THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE THESIS PUEPAIIED UNDER MY SUPERVISION BY ENTITLED ujTy\Jk/^ Q-^ ''"&DJ^;iJkjQsJL2.. IS APPROVED BY ME AS FULFILLING THIS PART OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF ..SoiAoXon ^Si^:. HEAD OF DEPARTMENT OF 50530 7k^ 1 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2013 http://archive.org/details/partialbibliograOOdrak h03m PREFACE. It has been founci in nany refei^-noe lilTarien that tlierf^ irj a large demand for rerf^rencer; to descriy^t ionr^ , critioirjr.n and repro- duG"'. ionn of noted v-orKs of art. An these references am ver^;* pcor.ly indexed and frequent not indexed at all, sorie special aids are necessary. in vie^" of this ne( rl, it has been the purpose of the cor:.- piler of the present liililiograp'iy to bring to^'^fthf-r references to descriptions, criticinr.s and reproductions of the '-orl'.s of Raphael Santi, found in bion;ra^'iies , his + o'^ies of art and of kindred subjects,' bo'^ks of travel aiid periodicals in the English language, '.Thich are in the TTniversity of Illinois li(;rary.
    [Show full text]