The Witwer Family of Earl Township: Part 1, Hans Wittwer
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A thorough study of civil records from the earliest years of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, results in important additions and corrections to a published genealogy on a Mennonite immigrant and his descendants. The Witwer Family of Earl Township: Part 1, Hans Wittwer by Denise Witwer Lahr and Thomas Witwer Richards The beginning genealogist will encounter many ited to the disbursement of land through the Herr and works compiled in the late 1800s and early 1900s that Kendig warrant.4 purport to give the accurate history of a particular fam Tax records are another source of information ily. Closer examination of these works often reveals a regarding land ownership. However, the examination of lack of reference to original sources. In large part they tax records requires a cautionary note. This caveat con appear to be based on oral history and the knowledge cerns the fact that this information was recorded in an gleaned from interviewing the oldest living members of age when spelling was not conventional and names the family. Although genealogists of a century ago cer were written according to the ear of the recorder, who tainly did their best, researchers now have access to new was often a speaker of English recording German technology and greater freedom of movement to explore names. Consequently, the researcher must take care in estate, land, church and government records. Therefore, assuming that any particular entry applies to a specific it is interesting to compare the oral traditions and older individual. genealogies with the information that can be obtained The name "Witwer" was written in the following from historical research. varied ways in situations where we are certain that the An interesting case in point is the Witwer family of person referred to is our ancestor: Widower (the literal Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. A 1909 genealogy pub translation), Widwar, Widwer, Witmer, Witwar, lished by Reverend George Witwer and Ananias Clime Witware, Whitware, Whitmore and Witworth. Witwer1 has been taken at face value by many genera Particular care must be taken with regard to the name tions. However, even a brief investigation into original "Witmer" since there was also a John Witmer, with a son sources reveals many discrepancies and errors, includ named Michael, who arrived in Lancaster County ing omission of any mention of the family patriarch, around 1717. To further illustrate this confusion, we Hans Wittwer. The purpose of this article is to compile refer to the Witmer genealogy by Roy Spaetzel which the information from original sources regarding the includes many of our Witwer ancestors listed as family of Hans Wittwer of Earl Township. Witmers.5 Given this warning, we return to tax records for Land Holdings of Hans Wittwer areas of Chester County which, in 1729, would become Hans Wittwer probably arrived in Lancaster County Lancaster County. These records were first compiled by in 1717 with the second wave of Swiss immigrants. In H. Frank Eshleman and published in a 1916 article.6 his 1939 article on Peter Bezaillion's road, Martin Hervin. Subsequently, they were reexamined and published by Brackbill stated that Hans Witwer was among the earli Gary T. Hawbaker and Clyde L. Groff? Since Hawbaker est settlers in Earl Township, having purchased a por and Groff attempted to reproduce names exactly as they tion of the Hans Herr and Martin Kendig warrant of were written, rather than in more conventional form, 1717. According to Brackbill, Hans Witwer's land lay they will be cited here. about two miles north of Peters Road and was probably In 1718, "John Widwer" is listed among "the Dutch surveyed as early as 1720. He does, however, concede Inhabitants." A second entry for John Wittmer is proba that records from this early period are incomplete and bly not our ancestor since his lands are described as that Wittwer's land was later resurveyed to inc~ude a being "on the north west side of the Conestogoe River." larger amount.2 Other entries are as follows: 1719, John Widmer; 1720, Much of the documentation involving land transac John Wittmar; 1721, John Witner, among the "Palatines"; tions from 1718 until the early 1730s was tied up by liti 1722, John Whitmer (East Conestoga Assessment); 1724, gation involving the estate of William Penn.3 Therefore, two entries, one for John Witmer and another for John even the most diligent researcher will not likely find Widmar; 1725, two entries for John Widwer and John warrants and surveys in the name of Hans Wittwer from Widner; and in 1726 one entry for Hance Widwer and this early period. Much of the Mennonite development another for John Widwer.8 of Lancaster County in this period can be directly cred- In his 1917 work on the Swiss and German migra- Pennsylvania Mennonite Heritage 14 July 2003 tion to Pennsylvania, H. Frank Eshleman also stated the his Mennonite community. Martin Brackbill wrote that name on the 1718 tax list was "John Widwer"9 although Hans was a "minister in the Mennonite Church, as was in his 1916 article, he had changed the name to "John his son-in-law, Wendel Holl17 and his son, Michael Widmer."10 Given independent reports of Hans Witwer."18 Although the reference to his being a minister Wittwer's presence in the county, it is certainly reason may be inaccurate, Hans, at the very least, was a respect able to assume that many of these tax entries refer to the ed member of his religious community. Witwer family patriarch. Further, Hans was a respected member of the com Hans Wittwer's principle tract of land, approxi munity-at-large. On August 3, 1736, at a meeting of the mately 632 acres, was located in present-day Earl Quarter Sessions Court of Lancaster County, Hans was Township. The Paxtang Road passed through the north appointed to a five-man committee charged with deter east corner and a stream ran from south to north. Even mining the best route for a road through Caernarvon today, this tract maintains its rural character, with many Township. The course of this road had been a matter of farms and little development. The fact that Hans was some dispute. Two previous attempts at laying it out had able to obtain such a large and valuable piece of land resulted in quite different solutions and a good deal of also attests to his early arrival in the county. By the 1720s controversy. Hans and the other committee members much of the prime, fertile land along the Conestoga were instructed to review both previously proposed River had already been claimed by others. courses "with a regard to the future as well as present Hans apparently obtained a survey of this property Advantage of the public" and report to the next court.19 in 1731, although that document could not be found. Its It appears that Hans was considered a wise individual existence, however, is inferred from a warrant dated who could act fairly in this matter. No further record of June 10, 1741, which states: the committee's action could be found in the abstracted records of the Quarter Sessions Court. Whereas in or about the year of our Lord 1731 a Survey was obtained and made for Hans Widdower, of the County of Lancaster on a Tract of about six hun dred and thirty two acres of Land Situate on a branch of Conestoga Creek in the said County which said Tract of Land was Soon after the survey thereof settled ~ V1rA_cA,'vliJ;~ and Improved by the said Hans Widdower who having ... paid to our use the consideration money due for the same he now requests that we would be pleased to The signature of Immigrant Hans Wittwer is found on the grant him a warrant in order that the said survey may administration bond of Aprill, 1728, for Theodorus Eby. be duly retumed ... n Hans Wittwer and his descendants maintained a On June 15, 1738, Hans obtained a warrant for an close relationship with the family of Theodorus Eby. additional 50 acres to be surveyed on the western edge of They likely emigrated together or in close proximity to his Earl Township tractP On the same day he purchased each other. Evidence of their relationship is documented a warrant for 200 acres on the "Middle Muddy Creek" in in Chester County records for the estate of "Doren" Eby dated April 1, 1728. Hans Wittwer was one of the three Brecknock TownshipY Hans Wittwer never obtained individuals posting bond in the administration of the patents on any of his properties, and his rights eventual estate.20 Several years later Theodorus' son Jacob died. ly vested in other persons. However, his flurry of land On January 4, 1745/6, Hans' son Michael Witwer joined dealings in 1738 suggest that Hans was hearty and look Michael Grebil in posting the bond.21 The family connec ing to expand his holdings, perhaps due to the arrival in tion was cemented by many marr~ages over the ensuing Pennsylvania of individuals soon to be related by mar years. riage, as will be discussed below. Nonetheless, we know that by March 8, 1741, when Will of Hans Wittwer his estate was inventoried, Hans was deceased.14 On Written in German but showing some English influ March 12, 1741, his will was filed for probate.15 Since the ences, the will of Hans Wittwer was probated on March will is undated, we do not know when it was written or 12, 1741/2, but was not translated at that time. It is a very exactly when Hans died. In fact, Hans may have died crudely-drawn document which contains many mis before June 16,1740, since a survey prepared on that date spellings and is extremely difficult to read.