Factors Influencing the Construction of Individuals' Subjective Meaning When Visiting Pilgrimage Shrines. a Study of Pilgrims

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Factors Influencing the Construction of Individuals' Subjective Meaning When Visiting Pilgrimage Shrines. a Study of Pilgrims FACTORS INFLUENCING THE CONSTRUCTION OF INDIVIDUALS’ SUBJECTIVE MEANING WHEN VISITING PILGRIMAGE SHRINES. A STUDY OF PILGRIMS AND TOURISTS AT LOURDES IN SOUTH WEST FRANCE Simon Thomas A submission presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the University of South Wales for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy PhD September 2013 Declaration This work has not previously been submitted for a degree or diploma in any university. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the thesis contains no material previously published or written by another person except where due reference is made in the thesis itself. Name: Simon Thomas Signature:………………………………………………………… Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge the contributions of a small number of people to this thesis. I want to firstly thank my wife Esther and my daughters Rebecca and Catrin for their patience, support and encouragement. This thesis would not have been possible without the direction, contribution and support of my director of studies, Professor Anne Marie Doherty, and my supervisor Dr Brychan Thomas. I am grateful for the support of the Glamorgan Business School for funding this study. Finally I would like to thank the pilgrimage community at Lourdes who accepted me as an equal and were willing to share their stories with me. My hope is that they find this study interesting. Abstract This thesis addresses the research question ‘what factors influence the construction of individuals’ subjective meaning when visiting pilgrimage shrines?’ The context of the study centres on the pilgrimage shrine at Lourdes in south west France. The review of the literature is set out in three sections. Part One critiques the traditional definitions, approaches, theories and concepts in the study of pilgrimage and religious tourism. The seminal literature in the study of pilgrimage and religious tourism places emphasis upon the objectivity (external and generalised) of the pilgrimage experience. Part Two considers the intermediate, or bridging, literature in the study of pilgrimage and religious tourism. The intermediate literature is dominated by the work of Smith (1992), Stoddard (1996), Santos (2003) and the opposing Turnerian theoretical position of Marnham (1980), Sallnow (1981), Eade and Sallnow (1991), Eade (1991), Eade (1992) (competing discourses) and Reader and Walter (1993) (pilgrimage and popular culture). Part Three presents the contemporary theoretical perspective of pilgrimage and religious tourism which advocates a shift from objective to subjective theory. The main proponents of this view are Dora (2012), Andriotis (2011) and Collins-Kreiner (2010). The epistemological position of this study is grounded in the philosophy of interpretivism. The methodological position of this study is qualitative adopting an inductive view. The data collection consisted of convenience sample pilot interviews followed by conversational interviews as part of a larger micro-ethnographic study. The analysis of the data was conducted using the thematic analysis technique. The findings in this study are organised around four emergent themes; 1. The authority of the church and pilgrimage conflict 2. The contestation of dual space 3. The pull factors - experiencing Marian mysticism, cures and miracles - the meaning of pilgrimage 4. The testimonies of pilgrims – a confession of truth This study presents an alternative theoretical paradigm that has emerged from the traditional (objective), intermediate (bridging) and contemporary (subjective) literature. The response to the research question claims that ‘the construction process at Lourdes is multi-dimensional, multi-layered and influenced by self-constructed narratives which underpin multiple factors associated with belief, duty, observance, ritual, control, conflict, authority and most importantly, return’. This claim presents a new theoretical framework which embraces the multi-dimensional and multi-layered influences upon the construction process; both literal and metaphorical. The literature in the study of pilgrim-touristic construction supports a shift from the objective to the subjective - this study proposes a hybridisation of existing theory that supports three dominant paradigms/frameworks; 1. Meaning is not one-dimensional 2. Objectivity and subjectivity are not polarised concepts 3. The paradigmatic shift from objectivity to subjectivity is not a ‘whole concept’ A new definition of pilgrimage devised from this study is; ‘The process of pilgrimage (pre-visit, visit, post-visit) is a multi-dimensional activity constructed with symbiotic actions (objective and subjective) and present in the form of complex narratives that are experienced, interpreted and applied to form/construct an individual subjective meaning that has internal and external influence’. Glossary of Religious & Related Terms Allegory – The simplest form of allegory consists of a story/picture or situation written/painted or presented in such a way as to have two coherent meanings Apparition – an appearing; an appearance; re-appearance e.g. of a heavenly body after occultation; that which appears Basilica – Roman Catholic Church with honorific privileges Brancardier – Male Lay Helpers; specifically at the Grotto and Baths at Lourdes Communitas – a relational quality of full unmediated communication, even communion with other individuals, which combines the qualities of lowliness, sacredness, homogeneity, and comradeship; Turner (1978) “social antistructure – a relational quality of full unmediated communication, even communion, between definite and determinate identities, which arises spontaneously in all kinds of groups, situations, and circumstances. It is a liminal phenomenon which combines the qualities of lowliness, sacredness, homogeneity, and comradeship. The distinction between structure and communitas is not the same as that between secular and sacred; communitas is an essential and generic human bond” Ecclesiastical – relating to the church Eucharist – the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper; the elements of the sacrament, bread and wine Hierophanic - a direct manifestation of a deity on earth Liminal – meaning threshholdness, or the sense of crossing a threshold or portal from one mode of existence to another in which you live by different rules; derived from the Latin ‘limen’ meaning threshold the term liminal aptly describes the condition of ritual participants who have symbolically exited one social space or state but have not entered a new one; they are figuratively poised over the threshold, or betwixt and between, two social worlds Liturgy – the form of service or regular ritual of a church Marian – relating to the Virgin Mary – a devotee, follower, or defender of Mary Marker – external influence; tourism operator/ecclesiastical authority Penance – the act of humiliation or punishment either self-imposed or imposed by a priest, to express or show evidence of sorrow for sin; the sacrament by which absolution is conveyed; expiation; hardship – also penitent – suffering or pain or sorrow for past sin and feeling a desire to reform; contrite; repentant; undergoing penance. - a person who repents of his or her sin; someone who has confessed sin, and is undergoing penance; a member of one of various orders devoted to penitential exercises Profane – not sacred; secular; showing contempt of sacred things; uninitiated; unhallowed; vulgar or irreverent; to treat with contempt or insult in spite of the holiness attributed; to desecrate; to violate; to put to an unworthy use Sacrament – a Christian religious rite variously regarded as a channel to and from God or as a sign of grace – amongst Protestants generally Baptism and the Lord’s Supper – amongst Roman Catholics also Confirmation, Penance, Holy Orders, Matrimony and Extreme Unction; the Lord’s Supper especially; the bread or wine taken in celebration of the Lord’s Supper; a symbol of something spiritual or secret; a sign, token or pledge Secular – pertaining to the present world, or to things not spiritual; civil, not ecclesiastical; lay, not concerned with religion; not bound by monastic rules Semiotics – The study of signs. A method for the analysis of messages, both verbal and non- verbal. Explores the wider societal meanings of, and functions of, sign systems Shrine – a casket for relics or an erection over it; a place hallowed by its associations Symbol – an emblem; that which by custom or convention represents something else; a type; a creed; or a typical religious rite Symbolism – representation by symbols or signs; a system of symbols; use of symbols; use of symbols in literature or art; a late 19th-cent movement in art and poetry that treated the actual as an expression of something underlying Theophanic - an event where a deity will give a message to a second party who will then interpret to others Theophany – a manifestation or appearance of deity to man Source: Turner and Turner (1978); Holy Bible (1996); Catholic Encyclopaedia Online (2011) Contents Chapter 1 – Introduction Page No. 1.0 Introduction - Rationale and Justification for the Study 1 1.1 The Background and Context of the Research 3 1.1.1 Religious tourism, pilgrimage and the new secular movement 3 1.1.2 Pilgrimage growth and motivations – From the general to the 8 specific – The Shrine at Lourdes 1.1.3 Lourdes 11 1.2 Research Aims and Objectives 14 1.3 Research Design and Methodology 15 1.4 Structure of the Thesis 15 1.4.1 Chapter 2 – Literature Review 15 1.4.2 Chapter 3 – Methodology 16 1.4.3 Chapter 4 – Findings 16 1.4.4 Chapter
Recommended publications
  • Carmelite Echoes in the Lourdes Grotto
    Carmelite echoes in the Lourdes Grotto Johan Bergström-Allen When the editor of Carmel in the World asked me to write an article about the link between Carmelite spirituality and Lourdes, the famous shrine of Our Lady in south-western France, I was very happy to do so because it’s a tremendously important place in my life. I’ve been lucky enough to have gone there on pilgrimage many times, including several visits in the Jubilee Year of 2008 which marks the 150th anniversary of Mary’s apparitions to Saint Bernadette Soubirous. Carmelite friar Fr. Tony Lester, O.Carm. preaching at the Grotto in Lourdes. But before I can tell you why I think there’s a strong link between the message of Lourdes and Carmelite spirituality, there’s something I feel I have to say first: I am not a big fan of apparitions generally. There, I feel better for writing that! Let me explain… When I was a teenager (all of a decade ago), I used to be very attracted by the extraordinary (even spooky) parts of our Catholic faith. Visions, weeping statues, saints who could reveal your past and your future, stigmata, Eucharistic miracles and so on – I was fascinated by it all. And when I first came to Lourdes aged thirteen I discovered all sorts of out-of-the-ordinary things to excite me: a vision story, miraculous healings, ‘holy’ water, and enough glow-in-the-dark crucifixes and tacky religious art to fill the town’s three basilicas and numerous chapels. There’s nothing wrong with piety, of course, but it needs to be balanced and sensible.
    [Show full text]
  • 11~I~M~~~~~~Moo~Oo~
    HIERDIE EKSEMPLAAR MAG OND,ER University Free State GEEN OMSTANDIGHEDE UIT DIE BIBLIOTEEK VERWYUER WORD NIE 11~I~m~~~~~~moo~oo~34300000110704 Universiteit Vrystaat IMAGES OF MARY IN THE MARIAN PRAISE POETRY OF AMERICAN RELIGIOUS SEEKERS WITH SPECIFIC REFERENCE TO THE SECOND QUARTER OF THE TWENTIETH CENTURY Lucia Antonia Whittle A thesis submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Philosophiae Doctor in the Faculty of Arts (Department of English) at the University of the Free State 30 November 1998 Supervisor: Or M M Raftery Un1versl~elt---------------~von die Oranje-VrYstaat BlOfMFONTEI N ~.11~ ~~.. 2 9 MAY 2000 .t.~ UOVS SASOL BIBLIOTEEK ...._'_....._-----...._--_...._ DEDICATION TO THE VIRGIN Sweet Virgin Mary, when your word you gave to be the mother of the Word made flesh you showed the valour of a spirit brave trading composure for a tangled mesh No whimper of regret blemished the birth That night in Bethlehem when the angels quired Quietly you bore and fed the Lord of earth, and heaven, Messiah long desired Your tender heart was riven by the sword that Friday when they nailed Him to a cross Woman of silence, you sustained your Lord eyes lifted to his eyes, no word of loss. Then did He speak, that suffering Son so mild: "Behold thy son" - and I became your child. Lucia A Whittle ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Hovering on the brink of a long-desired academic achievement, I have realised that without the efforts of many people in my life - some of whom are now long dead - a doctorate in English would ever have remained beyond my grasp as I am Dutch by birth and breeding.
    [Show full text]
  • Writing Lourdes
    Emilie Garrigou-Kempton Writing Lourdes Faith, Miracles, and the Elaboration of an Official Story Late nineteenth-century France is a place of renewed religious fervor, particularly around the miraculous healings at Lourdes, where sick masses converge in hope of being healed of a wide range of ailments. The same period is also known for its belief in medical and scientific progress, leading to the production of com- peting narratives about faith, and the question of its role in the healing process becomes a concern in both medical discourse and Catholic literature. Lourdes itself crystallizes these questions and texts written by doctors, clerics, historians, journalists, and novelists illustrate a wide range of opinions about miracles and participate in the production of an ever-growing authoritative list of texts about the events at Lourdes. An analysis of famed neurologist Charcot’s The Healing Faith (1892) in conjunction with Lasserre’s Notre-Dame de Lourdes (1868) and Père Cros’s Histoire de Notre-Dame de Lourdes (1925) explores the role of faith in these narratives, along with the tensions and convergences between them. 1. Healing in Lourdes France, in the second half of the nineteenth century is a place of renewed reli- gious fervor, prompted, at least in part, by the multiplication of apparitions of the Virgin Mary, most famously in the small Pyrenean town of Lourdes. There, in 1858, a young and sickly shepherdess named Bernadette Soubirous reported seeing the Virgin Mary appear before her eyes. As a spring erupted at the site of the apparition and as her early followers reported being cured of a range of physical ailments, Lourdes’s reputation soon went far beyond the Pyrenees and, by 1873, an annual national pilgrimage was established by the Assumptionists bringing in thousands of miracle-seekers by train and making Lourdes one of the most popular sites of Catholic pilgrimage in the world to date.
    [Show full text]
  • Lourdes Slides
    Lourdes Slides ACC/2014/5 Series of slides created by Thomas Holmes Mason of Dame Street Dublin, relating to Sanctuary of Our Lady at Lourdes and its healing powers. The majority of the slides show individuals before and/or after their cure at Lourdes. Catalogued by Harriet Wheelock February 2018 © Royal College of Physicians of Ireland, 2018 Lourdes Slides . Contents Lourdes Slides ...................................................................................... 2 B1 Series ..................................................................................................................... 3 B2 Series ..................................................................................................................... 7 B3 Series ................................................................................................................... 12 B4 Series ................................................................................................................... 29 B5 Series ................................................................................................................... 46 1 Lourdes Slides LS Lourdes Slides [1930s] Series Extent: 140 slides Creator: Mason, Thomas Holmes, 1877-1958 Description: Series of slides created by Thomas Holmes Mason of Dame Street Dublin, relating to Sanctuary of Our Lady at Lourdes and its healing powers. The majority of the slides show individuals before and/or after their cure at Lourdes. Some have additional details including names, date cured, disease and date of recognition
    [Show full text]
  • Lourdes Letter Letter Lourdes in the Footsteps of Bernadette 2 US POSTAGE PAID PAID POSTAGE US
    Our Lady of Lourdes Hospitality North Letter American Volunteers humility and simplicity.” and humility “the Newsletter for friends of St. Bernadette and Our Lady of Lourdes” RETURN SERVICE REQUESTED REQUESTED SERVICE RETURN St. Bernadette in obedience, obedience, in Bernadette St. as exemplified by by exemplified as Decree as Public Association of the Christian Faithful VOLUME 2, ISSUE 1 at Lourdes and at home home at and Lourdes at First-Ever American Lourdes Hospitality Erected Under Canon Law WINTER 2005/2006 to serve the sick and suffering suffering and sick the serve to The first Hospitality was United States, Canada, of Mary, the Mother of God, God, of Mother the Mary, of founded in the Americas within Mexico and the Caribbean Inside this issue: “To extend the invitation invitation the extend “To the Syracuse Diocese in 2002 Islands. In response to the In Volunteer Service 2 OUR MISSION: MISSION: OUR after the inaugural group of 10 apostolate mission, hundreds Lady of Lourdes” of Lady “the Newsletter for friends of St. Bernadette and Our Our and Bernadette St. of friends for Newsletter “the PERMIT NO. 4393 4393 NO. PERMIT volunteers served at Lourdes. of volunteers have now offered About Our Mailings to You 2 SYRACUSE, NY NY SYRACUSE, www.LourdesVolunteers.org www.LourdesVolunteers.org Initially the new apostolate was their service at Lourdes. Lourdes Letter Letter Lourdes In the Footsteps of Bernadette 2 US POSTAGE PAID PAID POSTAGE US Visit us on the Web! Web! the on us Visit created as a private association ORGANIZATION ORGANIZATION “Evangelization! This is a Travel Tips: About Passports 2 and remained such for 36 US Toll-Free 1-866 LOURDES LOURDES 1-866 Toll-Free US mission of charity and love, all NON-PROFIT NON-PROFIT months.
    [Show full text]
  • Notre Dame Scholastic, Vol. 99, No. 12
    The Notre Dame Scholastic February 7,1958 A new idea in smoking! refreshes your taste 4lr menthol • rich tobacco fresh taste Salem brings a wholly new Smoking was never like this Through Salem's pure-white, quality to smoking. ..Spring­ before.' You taste that rich modern filter flows the fresh­ time-softness in every puff. tobacco...then, surprise!... est taste in cigarettes. You Salem refreshes your taste there's an unexpected soft­ smoke refreshed, pack after the way a Spring morning ness that gives smoking new pack, when you buy Salems refreshes you. comfort and ease. by the carton. Created by B. J. Reynolds Tobacco Company We want engineers who like to We have plenty of it to be done. We have problems to be licked, and questions to be answered. Want to roll up your sleeves and tackle the fascinating world of petrochemicals? Union Carbide makes almost 500 of them—it's a world leader. Want to grab the atom by the tail and put it to useful work? Union Carbide's been in nuclear energy since the earliest days of the Manhattan Project. It operates three AEC plants plus Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and is building a private nuclear research center near New York. Want to dig in and really get down to the basics? Union Carbide is as basic as an industry can get. It's been called "chemist to the chemicals industry and metallurgist to the metals industry." Representatives of Divisions of Union Carbide Corporation, listed below, will be interviewing on many campuses. Check your placement director, or write to the Division representative.
    [Show full text]
  • Mass Schedule
    MASS SCHEDULE Daily:Da y: Mondayy - SaturdaySaSaturdayaturday 88:30 AMM (Rosary heldld aafter Mass)s) Saturday Vigil:Vigiligilil:il 4:004:00 PMPM 7:00 PM (En Español)Es ñol) SundaySunday 7:00 AM, 9:00:00:00 AM,AM 11:00 AM Sacramentent of PenancePPenenanceen ce Saturday 2:302:30 - 3:303: PMPM (or by appointment)ppointppoint nt)nt) Parochialarochial AdministratorAdministratrattooro Rev. Markark Wajdajdajda Parochial VicarVicacarr Rev. Markark LiLibrizzizi HispanicHispanic MinistrMinistrytrytry Rev. Gianninni AgAgostinellilli DeaconsDeaconononss Michaelchael McGinnityMcGinnitMcGiGinnitGinnityit Michaelael BalchusBa hushus Parish Office HoursHourururss Mondayay thruthrthruu Fridayay 8:00 AMM - 5:005: PMM www.ccstpaul.comwww.ccstpaul.comm email: [email protected] JOHN 15:9-17 OR JOHN 17:11-19 MISSION STATEMENT St. Paul Catholic Community builds disciples, grows our faith and serves others in Christ’s name. April 22 _________April 29____________________________ 1st $16,430.25 $16,803.7575 2nd 3,564.00 3,012.0000 (Food Pantry) (Security)ty) Vestments On Order: On-Line $3,535.80 $2,353.766 Purple Cope for use in Advent and during Lent, $1,750.00 This Week’s 2nd Collection: Catholicic Three Red Chasubles with Stoles, Communications $750 Each Next Week’s 2nd Collection: Ascension/ Two Red Dalmatics (for Deacons) with Stoles, Building Fund $750 Each Three White Chasubles with Stoles, $750 Each Holy Father’s Prayer Intention for May Two White Dalmatics with Stoles, The Mission of the Laity $750 Each (One Rose Chasuble with Stole, That the lay faithful may fulfill their specific $750—Donation Received ) mission by responding with creativity to the One Rose Dalmatic with Stole, challenges that face the world today.
    [Show full text]
  • OUR TAINTED NATURE's SOLITARY BOAST Mary, the Mother Of
    Lesson 4 OUR TAINTED NATURE’S SOLITARY BOAST Mary, the Mother of God “Mary’s uter willingness to magnify the Lord made of her a matrix of life. Te spring itself, in all its wild fecundity, is but a hint of the vitality that she unleashes.” - Bishop Robert Barron La Virgen Blanca. Fourteenth Century. Cathedral of Saint Mary of Toledo. Spain. ! MARY, THE MOTHER OF GOD Episode 4, Part 1 OUTLINE (Tracks 1-4 on DVD) I. The Annunciation A. The angel Gabriel: “Hail, O favored one, the Lord is with you!” (Lk. 1:28) B. Mary called to be the new Ark of the Covenant C. Mary’s response is her fiat, her humble and holy “Yes” (Lk. 1:38) D. Mary is the New Eve; she was conceived without sin, filled with divine life E. The Ave reverses Eva: the attitude of fiat (“let it be”) II. Mary and Zion A. The Bridge between Old & New Covenant B. Chartres Cathedral: Body of Mary C. Mary is a daughter of Israel, a true Jew D. Mary personifies Israel, the bridal people of God, faithful to the covenant E. Mary responded to God’s call, promptly, quickly, and obediently LESSON LESSON F. The model disciple III. The Mother of God 4 A. The Council of Ephesus (A.D. 431) PART , 1. Convened to combat Nestorius, the Patriarch of Constantinople 2. Christotokos (Christ-bearer) vs. Theotokos (God-bearer) 1 3. Twelve anathemas proposed by St. Cyril of Alexandria B. Jesus Christ is one Person with two natures, human and divine C.
    [Show full text]
  • Complete Dissertation
    VU Research Portal Miracles in the age of science Bersee, A.N.J.M. 2020 document version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Link to publication in VU Research Portal citation for published version (APA) Bersee, A. N. J. M. (2020). Miracles in the age of science: A philosophical analysis and evaluation of arguments used in the debate between science and Western theology. General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ? Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. E-mail address: [email protected] Download date: 30. Sep. 2021 VRIJE UNIVERSITEIT Miracles in the age of science: A philosophical analysis and evaluation of arguments used in the debate between science and Western theology ACADEMISCH PROEFSCHRIFT ter verkrijging van de graad Doctor of Philosophy aan de Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, op gezag van de rector magnificus prof.dr. V. Subramaniam, in het openbaar te verdedigen ten overstaan van de promotiecommissie van de Faculteit Religie en Theologie op woensdag 25 maart 2020 om 13.45 uur in de aula van de universiteit, De Boelelaan 1105 door Anthonius Nicolaas Johannes Maria Bersee geboren te Bloemendaal promotoren: prof.dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Potchefstroom Campus
    NORTH-WEST UNIVERSITY (Potchefstroom Campus) in cooperation with Greenwich School of Theology U.K. AN EVALUATION OF THE DOCTRINE OF MIRACULOUS HEALING WITHIN THE ROMAN CATHOLIC TRADITION Brother James Scott, o.st.~.,K.s.c., B.A. (Honr.), M.A.~.tii. for the degree Philosophis Doctor in Church History and History of Dogma of the North-West University (Potchefstroom Campus) Promoter: Professor 0. Rees Co-Promoter: Professor J.M. Vorster 2006 Potchefstroom PREFACE I should like to take this opportunity to extend my sincere thanks to the following individuals, societies, and organisations for their support in the production of this thesis: Greenwich School of Theology, Great Britain: for the privilege of being permitted to continue my theological studies through their institution and also to the North-West University (Potchefstroom Campus), South Africa. l am most grateful for the kindnesses and courtesy shown to me by the staff of both institutions. Revd. Professor Dr. Colin Warner, Revd. Professor Dr. Ben Rees and Prof Koos Vorster, my tutors, for their patient endurance and for their attention to detail, meticulously reading, correcting, suggesting: guidance gratefully received; and also to Peg Evans, my language reader. I am indebted to the following priests of the Roman Catholic Church who have so generously allowed me to learn from their ministry: Monsignor Michael Buckley; Father Jim McManus, CSsR, and Father Peter Rookey, OSM. Also I should like to thank June Lincoln from the parish of Our Lady of Lincoln for her insights. I wish to extend a particular word of gratitude to an old Anglican friend, Revd.
    [Show full text]
  • Parish Library
    CALL NUMBER SUBJECT AUTHOR TITLE 241.6 Abortion Allison, Loraine Finding Peace after Abortion 241.6 Abortion Burke, Theresa Forbidden Grief: The Unspoken Pain of Abortion 241.6 Abortion Burnside, Thomas J. At the Foot of the Cross 241.6 Abortion Burtchaell, James Tunstead Rachel Weeping and Other Essays on Abortion 241.6 Abortion Condon, Guy Fatherhood Aborted 241.6 Abortion Coyle, C.T. Men and Abortion 241.6 Abortion Curro, Ellen Caring Enough to Help 241.6 Abortion DeCoursey, Drew Lifting the Veil of Choice: Defending Life 241.6 Abortion DeMarco, Donald In My Mother's Womb: The Catholic Church's Defense of Natural Life 241.6 Abortion Euteneuer, Thomas J. Demonic Abortion 241.6 Abortion Florczak-Seeman, Yvonne Time to Speak: A Healing Journal for Post-abortive Women 241.6 Abortion Gorman, Michael J. Abortion & the Early Church 241.6 Abortion Horak, Barbara Real Abortion Stories 241.6 Abortion Johnson, Abby Unplanned 241.6 Abortion Klusendorf, Scott Case for Life 241.6 Abortion Maestri, William Do Not Lose Hope 241.6 Abortion Masse, Sydna Her Choice to Heal: Finding Spiritual and Emotional Peace After Abortion 241.6 Abortion Morana, Janet Recall Abortion 241.6 Abortion Pavone, Frank Ending Abortion 241.6 Abortion Powell, John Abortion: The Silent Holocaust 241.6 Abortion Reardon, David C. Jericho Plan: Breaking DoWn the Walls Which Prevent Post- Abortion Healing 241.6 Abortion Reisser, Teri A Solitary SorroW: Finding Healing and Wholeness After Abortion 241.6 Abortion Rini, Suzanne Beyond Abortion: A Chronicle of Fetal EXperimentation 241.6 Abortion Santorum, Karen Letters to Gabriel 241.6 Abortion Terry, Randall Operation Rescue 241.6 Abortion Willke, J.C.
    [Show full text]
  • Bishop Tells Miracle' Of
    Diocese Joins U.S. THE VOICE P.O. Box 1059 Miami, Fla. 33138 In Observance *^VoiCEReturn Requested For Latin America Weekly Publication of the Diocese of Miami Covering the 16 Counties of South Florida The Diocese of Miami will belief it will prove a very VOL. VI, NO. 44 Price $5 a year ... 15 cents a copy JANUARY 15, 1965 participate in a nationwide week heartening act of solidarity for of prayer for Latin America in our Latin American brothers." conjunction with the first an- The aim of CICOP, which was nual observance of CICOP inaugurated in 1963 by the U. S. APPEAL MADE FOR BOYSTOWN, SOUTH FLORIDA Week from January 24 to Jan- Bishops' Committee for Inter- uary 30 in more than 80 arch- American Cooperation, is "to dioceses and dioceses through- bring U. S. and Latin American out the United States. Catholics together in mutual P %ry purpose of the week- understanding and friendship Bishop Tells Miracle' Of DDF "Tonij ..jtfervance is to encourage based on the principle that, re- Catholics in the United States gardless of social or economic Dramatic accomplishments of Board held at the Everglades thing very short of miraculous" the shepherd of the Diocese without responding very mag- to develop a concern for the circumstances of life, Christian the Diocesan Development Fund Hotel, Miami. and explained: nanimously." Church's welfare in the Latin people, indeed all peoples, in the past and the urgent need "It is indeed a pleasure to American countries. should know and accept each for its help this year were out- Bishop Coleman F.
    [Show full text]