Varieties of Stabilization Experience: Towards Sensible Macroeconomics in the Third World by LANCE TAYLOR
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This is a rekeyed full text file of the volume Varieties of Stabilization Experience: Towards Sensible Macroeconomics in the Third World By LANCE TAYLOR Originally published in 1988 by Oxford University Press the book is now out of print and the copyright has reverted to UNU-WIDER. File produced by Macmillan Publishing Solutions, Chennai WIDER Studies in Development Economics embody the output of the research programmes of the World Institute for Development Economics Research (WIDER), which was established by the United Nations University as its first research and training centre in 1984 and started work in Helsinki in 1985. The principal purpose of the Institute is to help identify and meet the need for policy-oriented socio-economic research on pressing global and development problems, as well as common domestic problems and their inter-relationships. Varieties of Stabilization Experience Towards Sensible Macroeconomics in the Third World LANCE TAYLOR CLARENDON PRESS · OXFORD 1988 Oxford University Press, Walton Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford New York Toronto Delhi Bombay Calcutta Madras Karachi Petaling Jaya Singapore Hong Kong Tokyo Nairobi Dar es Salaam Cape Town Melbourne Auckland and associated companies in Berlin Ibadan Oxford is a trade mark of Oxford University Press Published in the United States by Oxford University Press, New York © World Institute for Development Economics Research of the United Nations University 1988 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press This book is sold subject to the condition that it shall not, by way of trade or otherwise, be lent, re-sold, hired out or otherwise circulated without the publisher’s prior consent in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published and without a similar condition including this condition being imposed on the subsequent purchaser British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Taylor, Lance Varieties of stabilization experience: towards sensible macroeconomics in the Third World. 1. Developing countries. Economic conditions. Stabilisation I. Title 339.5’09172’4 ISBN 0–19–828638–4 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Data available Set by Cotswold Typesetting Limited, Gloucester Printed and bound in Great Britain by Biddies Ltd, Guildford and King’s Lynn WIDER PREFACE For more than a decade now, most developing countries have been subject to a succession of shocks emanating largely from changes in the international economic environment. These shocks invariably disrupted the working of their economies, forcing on them relatively long periods of stabilization and adjustment to restore equilibrium conditions. How can developing countries cope with such situations? What are the policy options open to them? Until recently these questions were sought to be addressed largely within the framework of orthodox macroeconomics. This is reflected in the stabilization packages advocated by the International Monetary Fund for a large number of developing countries in the recent past. By and large these involved a set of austerity measures sweetened with conditional balance of payments support under the auspices of the international financial institutions. The degree to which this standard approach was relevant or successful was the focus of a WIDER research project involving a series of country studies. More specifically, the research focused on whether alternative policy packages could have been devised in particular country situations which would contribute to desirable adjustment and development goals, i.e., an improved balance of payments and higher growth rates, at a lower social cost than that incurred by the country packages that were in fact negotiated. The general finding of the WIDER research studies was that countries were hard hit by the shocks; but adjusted in different ways, depending on their own local institutions, macroeconomic structure, and relationships among major political and social groups. The wealth of country-based experience has clearly established the need for a departure from the earlier perspective of a standard approach to the design of stabilization and adjustment programmes. The new ideas emerging out of the country studies highlight the need to formulate these programmes in a manner appropriate to the institutional and structural characteristics of the eocnomy in question. Orthodox macroeconomics, as reflected in the approach of the International Monetary Fund to stabilization problems, ran mainly vi PREFACE in terms of attaining equilibrium within a narrow monetary framework. In fact, this was defined as financial programming towards the goal of stabilization. The WIDER country studies provide ample evidence to suggest that there is no unified theory or policy to facilitate solutions to problems of stabilization and adjustment. A variety of policies involving a combination of different approaches seems to have worked well, depending on the peculiarities of country situations. What comes out clearly from the WIDER country studies is the need to deal with each country situation within the framework of its own specific economic and social characteristics. A unique feature of the WIDER stabilization studies is the fact that most of the country authors are nationals, who have brought a wealth of local knowledge and experience to an area of macroecono- mics where the international discussion has for the most part been dominated by economists proposing policy on the basis of ideas popular in the developed world. The WIDER research findings in this area have clearly established that current policy and practice cannot be regarded as sacrosanct and needs to be modified if they are to be relevant and effective in dealing with stabilization problems in developing countries. In this context one should welcome the widening debate on these issues and some of the recent changes in policies advocated by the International Monetary Fund in its recommendations for developing countries in Africa. WIDER research will, I would hope, contribute to the evolving process of identifying improved solutions to stabilization and adjustment issues, without damaging the development process itself. Lal Jayawardena Director WIDER ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS If an academic author lifts ideas from two or three others, anyone would call it plagiarism. If she or he has access to ideas from 18 papers, then formulating a synthesis can safely be called ‘research’. This monograph reports on the results of such research. The unsung contributions are papers describing experiences with economic stabilization in 18 developing countries, supported by the World Institute for Development Economics Research (WIDER) in Helsinki. I am extremely grateful to WIDER, its staff, and its director, Lal Jayawardena, for sponsoring the stabilization project, and to Gerry Helleiner who did at least as much as I did to get it organized. Ford Foundation, personified by Tom Bayard, was also generous with research funding. In writing up the project, I have benefited from comments and discussion by all its participants. Reg Green and Gerry Helleiner contributed pages and pages of written observations. John Toye chipped in with very astute remarks on a summary version of the results presented as the Marshall Lectures at the University of Cambridge in May 1987. Other comments came from Jose Pablo Arellano, Korkut Boratav, Jose Maria Fanelli, Roberto Frenkel, Bill Gibson, Butch Montes, Jose Antonio Ocampo, Michael Roemer, Jaime Ros, Pronob Sen, Andres Solimano, Rolph van der Hoeven, Richard Webb, and Tito Winograd. I have tried to do justice to them all. Finally, my wife, kids, and pets put up with the burdens of authorship with their usual grace. Mick, in particular, deserves a vote of thanks for spending many hours wedged between the globe, bookshelf, and PC, trying to figure out what was going on. He probably succeeded as well as did the author. WIDER Stabilization and Adjustment Policies and Programmes Country Studies 1 GHANA by Reginald H. Green 2 THE PHILIPPINES by Manuel F. Montes 3 NICARAGUA by Bill Gibson 4 KENYA by Rolph van der Hoeven and Jan Vandemoortele 5 TURKEY by Korkut Boratav 6 COLOMBIA by Jose Antonio Ocampo and Eduardo Lora 7 MEXICO by Nora Lustig and Jaime Ros 8 PERU by Richard Webb 9 EGYPT by Gouda Abdel-Khalek 10 CHILE by José Pablo Arellano, René Cortazar and Andrés Solimano 11 BRAZIL by Dionisio Carneiro 12 ARGENTINA by Jose Maria Fanelli, Roberto Frenkel and Carlos Winograd 13 INDIA by Pronab Sen 14 REPUBLIC OF KOREA by Alice H. Amsden 15 SRI LANKA by Lai Jayawardena, Anne Maasland and P. N. Radhakrishnan 16 IVORY COAST by Jacques Pegatienan Hiey 17 TANZANIA by Benno Ndulu CONTENTS PREFACE V WIDER COUNTRY STUDIES viii 1. Economic Stabilization in the Third World 1 2. Macroeconomic Shocks and the Social Matrix 7 2.1 Internal Shocks 9 2.2 External Shocks 16 2.3 Political Considerations and the Social Matrix 20 3. Stabilization Theory 25 3.1 Demand-Supply Balance 26 3.2 Price-Cost Relationships 38 3.3 The Balance of Payments 47 3.4 Financial Markets 55 3.5 Other Markets, Black and Grey 66 3.6 A Checklist for Stabilizations 68 4. Country Experiences 75 4.1 Externally Strangled Small, Open Economies 76 4.2 Foreign Bonanzas, Short and Long Run 94 4.3 Redistribution and Liberalization Experiments 109 4.4 Heterodox Shocks 121 4.5 Two Special Cases 133 4.6 A Scorecard on Stabilizations 142 5. How Stabilization Can Be Made to Work Better 147 5.1 Theses on Bretton Woods 148 5.2 Financial Programming 154 5.3 Improving the Methodology 159 5.4 Other Perspectives 164 5.5 Questions of Strategy 168 REFERENCES 171 INDEX 177 1 Economic Stabilization in the Third World Early this century, William James published the thoughts on religion which suggested this essay’s theme. James was concerned to show that diverse religious experiences all probe a common well of sub- conscious spiritual strength.