White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DOCUMENT RESUME ED 355 141 SO 022 802 AUTHOR Fil.r, Anna May, Comp. TITLE Multictlturalism, 1992. INSTITUTION New York State Council of Educational Associations. PUB DATE Oct 92 NOTE 246p. AVAILABLE FROMRobin Wheeler, 59 Cascade Terrace, Schenectady, NY 12309 ($10). PUB TYPE Collected Works General (020) Reports Descriptive (141) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC10 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Art Education; Elementary Secondary Education; *English (Second Language); History Instruction; *Mathematics Education; *Multicultural Education; *Science Education; Second Language Learning; *Social Studies; Units of Study IDENTIFIERS New York ABSTRACT This monograph, developed to enrich the literature on multiculturalism, includes 25 articles on the subject. The articles are:(1) "Multiculturalism and an Assessment of Its Critics: Key to an Understanding and Acceptance" (A.J. Williams-Myers);(2) "The New Demographics" (Charles G. Treadwell);(3) "'Multiple Perspectives' or Courting Ethnic Strife?" (Albert Shanker);(4) "Fieldwork and Folklife Studies: Them, Us, and If" (Beverly J. Robinson);(5) "White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack" (Peggy McIntosh); (6) "Multiculturalism in Mathematics, Science, and Technology" (Gerry Madrazo, et al);(7) "Strategies for Implementing Multicultural Education" (Irene M. Lober; Kathryn Dunlop);(8) "Color Me" (James Hillestad);(9) "The Sociological, Psychological, and Pedagogical Implications of Multicultural Education" (Dolores M. Fernandez); (10) "Librarian-Teacher Partnerships: Serving the English asa Second Language Students" (Anne H. Filson);(11) "The Importance of the Teacher to Multiculturalism" (Maryann Fallek); (12) "Usage is Never Good or Bad but Thinking Makes It So" (Frances E. Blake); (13) "Creating Thematic Units with a Multicultural Focus" (Patricia Baker); (14) The New York State Social Studies Supervisory Association's "Regents' Letter"; (15) "Ways to Implement Multiculturalism: Twenty-One Lessons for American History witha Multicultural Focus" (Anna May Filor);(16) The National Science Teachers Association (NSTA) "Background Paper: Multicultural Science Education" and "NSTA Position Statement: Multicultural Science Education"; (17) "Multicultural Classrooms, Monocultural Teachers" (Terry Dean); (18) "Multicultural Education Mathematics Isa Great Place to Start" (Bill Collins); (19) "Let's Teach Our Common Heritage" (Anthony Cortese); (20) "1492-1992 The Columbian Quincentenary: An Educational Opportunity" (National Council for the Social Studies); (21) "Multicultural Assessment" (Jose S. Sanchez; Ed Yanson);(22) "Bilingual Education: Educating the Global Villager" (Carmen A. Vazqueztell; Ximena E. 'Late);(23) "Experiencing Other Cultures through Fiction" and "Multicultural Fiction: List of Books for Secondary Students" (Judity Gray); (24) "Foreign Language Instruction: Keystone to Multiculutral Education" (Sophie Jeffries); and (25) "Multicultural Art Education: Many Views, One Reality" (Patricia Barbanell). (LBG) U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION OffrCe or Educational Research and improvement EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) 41,1TMs document has been reproduced as received from the person or organization originating C Minor changes have been made to improve reproduction Quality it Points of view or opinions stated in this docu- ment do not necessarily represent official OERI position or DOI.Cy r \ )1MMEMM "PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE THIS MATERIAL HAS BEEN GRANTED BY TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC)." Multiculturalism 1992 NYSCEA Prepared by Constituent Associations Forming the New York State Council of Educational Associations Compiled by Anna May Filor, Chair Research and Development Committee October 1992 NYSCEA OFFICERS 1991-1992 OFFICERS 1992-1993 Harry Kranepool, President Harry A. Kranepool,President Louis Tul lo, President Elect Louis Tul lo, President Elect Susan Leahy, Secretary Susan Leahy, Secretary Jack D. Hickey, Treasurer Robin J. Wheeler, Treasurer Frances Bliven, Past President Frances Bliven, Past President ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Many individuals shoLid be applauded for their fine contributions to this monograph. Thank you Colleagues! Thank yous are extended to the Committee members who edited this Journal. These hard-working committed professionals included: Robin Wheeler, Bonnie McCaig and J. Stephen Bona. Each worked with energy and drive and contributed sensitivity and intelligence to this difficult project. Thank you Harry Kranepool for your hours of time and the ideas and materials you gave to complete this Journal. Thank you Sue Chlystun, artist and Art teacher at Poughkeepsie High School and Doris Navarra, typist and secretary. Thank you Filor Family for the sacrificed farily meals and recreation times and family life you allowed me to miss so that this monograph could be finished. Special Plaudits are extended also to Charles Santelli, Phil Ellis and NYSUT for the printing of this journal. Thank you one and all. Anna May Filor Editor ii To Order this monograph, Multiculturalism 1992, contact NYSCEA Treasurer: Ms. Robin Wheeler 59 Cascade Terrace Schenectady, New York 12309 (518) 785-9397 Cost $10.00 * Printed by New York State United Teachers 4290a, fra11411111 iii or.7 SECTION I: GUEST AUTHORS Dr. A. J. Williams-Myers Charles G. Treadwell Albert Shanker Dr. Beverly J. Robinson Dr. Peggy McIntosh Gerry Madrazo, et al, (Dr. Charles Drew and Dr. Elroy Rodriguez Lessons) Dr. Irene M. Lober and Dr. Kathryn Dunlap Dr. James Hillestad Dr. Dolores M. Fernandez Anne H. Filson Maryann Fallek Frances E. Blake SECTION II: NYSCEA CONSTITUENT ASSOCIATIONS AND AFFILIATES Dr. Patricia Baker NEW YORK STATE COUNCIL FOR THE SOCIAL STUDIES: NYSCSS Regents Letter NEW YORK STATE SOCIAL STUDIES SUPERVISORY ASSOCIATION: NYS4A Anna May Filor NEW YORK STATE SOCIAL STUDIES SUPERVISORY ASSOCIATION: NYS4A NATIONAL SCIENCE TEACHER'S ASSOCIATION: NYSTA/NSTA Terry Dean NEW YORK STATE TEACHERS OF ENGLISH TO SPEAKERS OF OTHER LANGUAGES: NYSTESOL Bill Collins NEW YORK STATE ASSOCIATION OF MATHEMATICS SUPERVISORS: NYSAMS Antonia (Tony) Cortese NEW YORK STATE UNITED TEACHERS: NYSUT NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR THE SOCIAL STUDIES: NCSS Dr. Jose S. Sanchez and Ed Yanson NEW YORK STATE ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL PSYCHOLOGISTS: NYASP Carmen A. Vazqueztell and Dr. Ximena E. Zate NEW YORK STATE ASSOCIATION OF BILINGUAL EDUCATION: NYSABE Judith Gray SCHOOL LIBRARY MEDIA SECTION OF NEW YORK LIBRARY ASSOCIATION: SLMSNYLA Dr. Sophie Jeffries NEW YORK STATE ASSOCIATION OF FOREIGN LANGUAGE TEACHERS: NYSAFLT Dr. Patricia Barbanell NEW YORK STATE ART TEACHERS ASSOICATION: NYSATA iv INTRODUCTION Multiculturalism concerns problems, controversies, and implementations and are topics of powerful and great interest today in our country. This monograph has been developed to enrich the literature on this essential and crucial subject. Twenty-five different articles are in this monograph on Multiculturalism. Constituent organizations of NYSCEA have submitted very exciting ideas and materials. NYSAFLT, NYSTESOL, NYSABE, NYSCSS, NYSASP, NYLA, NYSAMA, are among the many professional organizations that have made outstanding contributions to the NYSCEA Journal, 1992. Additionally, national leaders such as Albert Shanker of the AFT and Gerry Madrazo ofthe NSTA and New York State leaders such as Toni Cortese of NYSUT have written essays. Academics, College Professors and classroom teachers, Librarians and students also submitted articles. Dr. Irene Lober and Dr. James Hillestad of SUNY New Paltz and Dr. Peggy McIntosh of Wellesley and Dr. Beverly Robinson of UCLA are some of the academics who shared their ideas. Frances Blake, a student from Florida &nd Mary Ann Fallek, a teacher from Poughkeepsie, and Judith Gray, a librarian wrote articles of great interest. Dr. A. J. Williams-Myers''article "Multiculturalism And An Assessment Of Its Critics: Key To An Understanding And Acceptance" examines the need for a multicultural education and analyzes the critics of multiculturalism. Charles Treadwell's graphs and comments illustrate the changing demographics of American Society. Albert Shanker's article on "Multiple Perspectives Or Courting Ethnic Strife" suggests that history and social studies taught from multiple perspectives sounds reasonable, but encourages intellectual dishonesty and promotes divisiveness. Dr. Beverly Robinson in "Fieldwork Studies "Them," Us" and "If" maintains that folk life research is a wonderful opportunity to break down cultural biases and ignorance. It helps communalize communities. Dr. Peggy McIntosh's significant article on "White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack" makes a real contribution to understanding the effects of Racism. Harry Kranepool shared the book by Gerry Madrazo et all, Multiculturalism In Mathematics ScienceAnd Technology. The lessons on "Drs. Charles Drew and Elroy Rodriguez" were selected to illustrate the contents of this new book. Drs. Lober and Dunlap in "Strategies For Implementing Multicultural Education" illustrate designs for curriculum development. Dr. James Hillestad's article "Color Ae" is a powerful philosophical statement suggesting that multiculturalism is intellectual deceit as well as dangerous and destructive. Dr. Dolores Fernandez wrote "The Sociological Psychological and Pedological Implications of Multicultural Education." She gives a lengthy, effective defense of Multicultural Education and suggests fighting institutional racism and helping students develop positive self-concept. She advocates restructuring education for cultural infusion rather