In This Issue
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VOLUME 34 NUMBER 3 VOLUME Unitingews the Schools of Thought NAAPWorld Organization and Public Education Corporation - NationalN Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis In this issue • Was Emily NAAP’s 39th ANNuAl CoNference Dickinson a SATURDAY - OCTOBER 22, 2011 Neuroscientist • Psychoanalysis and Art • Rescue Fantasies and Therapist TRAUMA Subjectivity AND • Transformation Through Treat- RESILIENCE ment FAMILY MATTERS KEYNOTE SPEAKERS: FRANCOISE DAVOINE, PHD SUMMER 2011 JEAN-MAX GAUDILLIERE, PHD Adva the nc or em f e n n o t PRESIDENT’s rePORT ti o a f i P c s o y s c s h A o l a a NAAP n n a o l i y t s a i GROWING PSYCHOANALYSIS WITHIN s N 1972 NAAP AND ELSEWHERE THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR THE ADVANCEMENT How does OF PSYCHOANALYSIS psychoanalysis grow? Now to NAAP’s 40th Celebration PRESIDENT Let me count the Committees – the Event Planning Pamela Armstrong-Manchester ways…. Subcommittee and the History Subcommittee. The Event Planning PAST PRESIDENT Let’s begin by Committee needs many to carry Jennifer Harper Pamela Armstrong- Manchester working together out the various tasks required for EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR on two projects: the celebration. So join us on this Margery Quackenbush The Conference committee. The History Committee will SECRETARY Committees and NAAP’s 40th Celebration help put together the Celebration Souvenir Gladys Foxe Committees. Journal, which will include the history that NAAP NEWS led up to NAAP’s creation, as well as © 2011 The National Association for the In my past NAAP NEWS columns I spoke the initial and current years of NAAP to Advancement of Psychoanalysis about people power as the engine of highlight the contributions of all of NAAP’s Summer 2011, Volume 34, Number 3 NAAP. We have four opportunities to organizational members. Again, on these EDITOR-IN-CHIEF help power NAAP now. The time to form committees we would like representatives Pamela Armstrong-Manchester these committees is now. Call Margery from all schools of thought and all of EXECUTIVE EDITOR Quackenbush at 212-741-0515 and sign up NAAP’s member institutes. We all have a Kirsty Cardinale for one. NAAP would love for you to join lot to celebrate together. us in these endeavors. EDITORIAL BOARD Arthur Pomponio We have wanted psychoanalysis to be an Marge Blaine The following are the committees and, independent profession and to be inclusive Ginny Rachmani in brief, their responsibilities. I hope from of all the psychoanalytic schools of thought. CONTRIBUTORS reading my past columns you have been We have accomplished a lot and continue Patricia Harte Bratt thinking about which committee you to do so. NAAP has you to thank for all Anne Cutler would like to be on. that we have done collectively. We want Christine K. Durbak James Holmes to celebrate our accomplishments together Susan A. Klett To review: We would like the and as we do so we also want to think Millicent Lambert Conference Committees – the Think about where we want to go from here. Robert Marchesani th Linda A. Mayers Tank Subcommittee and the Event Come join us to plan for our 40 year Steve McCombs Planning Subcommittee to incorporate celebration. Eva D. Papiasvili representatives from all of NAAP’s schools Inna Rozentsvit Jack Schwartz of thought to reflect NAAP’s diversity. Call Margery Quackenbush at 212- Claire Steinberger 741-0515. She is looking forward to The Think Tank Committee will decide hearing from you. Let Margery know the INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENTS Ann Casement, England upon NAAP’s Annual Conference theme, committee of your choice: the Conference Alberto Fergusson, South America keynote speakers, and/or panelists, as well Think Tank, Conference Event Planning, John Gosling, South Africa as the workshops and their leaders. The 40th Celebration Event Planning, or the Roberto Pani, Italy Event Planning Committee will be the 40th Celebration History Committee. It ART DIRECTOR facilitators of the conference. All members is only with you that we can accomplish Elliott Hom of both subcommittees are essential to all that we have, need, and want to do ART CONSULTANT AND CARTOONIST the success of our conference and to to continue developing psychoanalysis as Robert Quackenbush the success of NAAP. Working on the an independent profession for you the Conference Committee is a chance to practitioner and for the public we serve. NAAP News, a quarterly publication of NAAP, reserves the right to edit all copy. provide superb, stimulating psychoanalytic Hopefully, our growth will never stop; let’s Subscriptions are part of membership and food for thought, as well as food for body celebrate and grow together. can be extended to non-members for $24 per and soul for our NAAP community and year. Single copies are available for $6. To subscribe, write to NAAP News, 80 Eighth beyond. It is also a chance to get to know What is happening elsewhere in Avenue, Suite 1501, New York, NY, 10011; one another in new, fascinating, and fun psychoanalysis? A lot! Here is some call 212-741-0515; or email [email protected]. ways by working and playing together for interesting news. Unless otherwise noted, no printed matter the benefit of you, psychoanalysis, and in NAAP News reflects the endorsement or NAAP. As Aristotle and David Brooks On May 24, 2011, I attended a New York official position of the National Association have said – we are social animals. Psychoanalytic Society & Institute (NYPSI) for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis or NAAP News. PAGE 2 SUMMER 2011 PRESIDENT’s rePORT meeting that is one small part of their year- more to advance our field of independent continue the discussion within NAAP, with long Centenary Celebration. The meeting psychoanalysis? Of course, the question for our member institutes, to help one another was entitled “100 Years panel on research: psychoanalysis is: What kind of research? develop the best forms of psychoanalytic Can science save the clinic? Evolution of (1) Evidence based? (2) Another form, research in keeping with each of our treatment research at NYPSI and by its more in keeping with psychoanalysis? (3) schools of thought. Effective research can members” It was a very interesting evening. Or, both? Would this be a worthwhile surely advance psychoanalysis as it has I was glad to see a few NAAP members in exploration? Could this exploration and in so many fields including ours. Freud attendance. The piece of information which its results enrich our scientific discourse? began psychoanalysis through a form of I found to be the most interesting was the Let’s not forget the comment Donnel research which he developed. Our field following statement: “If we want insurance Stern shared with us at our 2010 annual has evolved; we need to find the forms of to reimburse psychoanalytic treatment conference: “...as long as the practitioners research which can help psychoanalysis, then we have to demonstrate evidence of of conflicting theories are conducting and each of our schools of thought, to treatment through outcomes.” genuine conversations with one another, continue to develop and evolve. the existence of multiple conceptions of Research is hugely important. It is the practice is a sign of the field’s vigor.” inquiry and investigation into a subject to discover and/or review facts, theories Irwin Z. Hoffman is certainly one who has and applications to advance knowledge been a part of the research conversation. (Random House Dictionary, 2nd ed., On January 19, 2007, he gave the plenary unabridged, 1987). If we want to advance, address at a meeting of the American teach students, candidates, and graduates Psychoanalytic Association and gave the Pamela Armstrong-Manchester new knowledge, and educate the public same address to NPAP on October 12 President and insurance companies about what we that year. It would be worthwhile for all [email protected] have to offer and its efficacy, it behooves of us to hear his talk “Doublethinking us to do research. In our institutes many Our Way To “Scientific” Legitimacy: The of us do research. Would it help if we did Desiccation of Human Experience.” Then, EXCERPTS FROM THE LAST INTERVIEW WITH DR. JEFFREY SEINFELD (May 2010) by Jack Schwartz Forum: To get started, Dr. Seinfeld, tell us about the evolution Dr. S: Klein did a lot of her work during WWII in England with of your clinical approach? children who were under a great deal of duress and trauma. Winnicott, who was working as a psychiatrist at a Social Work Dr. S: What influenced me psychodynamically was ego- agency, picked up on Klein’s work and he saw the types of psychology, British object relations, and self-psychology. I dynamics that the children were displaying as a result of trauma, have also been influenced by various philosophical traditions, and Klein failed to take into account the environment into those especially the existentialist, like Sartre, also Martin Buber, and dynamics. A lot of the disintegration, spitting, aggression in kids on the spiritual side - Eastern philosophy, all which informed me was a result of the separation from their families, dropped into in my thinking. The first extensive reading I did was Freud and unfamiliar homes, exposed to violence; Klein didn’t take that into Melanie Klein, which I liked a lot. I read both thoroughly upon account enough. I see the type of aggression Klein talked about graduating Social Work school. more as a result of trauma, rather than innate. Forum: Why Melanie Klein? Forum: From the object relations perspective, we see the Dr. S: It was the emphasis in her work on destructiveness in connection from Klein to Winnicott, but what of Fairburn, which children and then their efforts at reparation. In my early training you mention in your writings? I worked at the JBFCS.