Punjabi Enabling Environment Project (PEEP)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PUNJAB ENABLING ENVIRONMENT PROJECT (PEEP) FINAL REPORT March 13, 2021 This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development. It was prepared by Chemonics International Inc. PUNJAB ENABLING ENVIRONMENT PROJECT (PEEP) FINAL REPORT Contract No. AID-391-C-14-00002, Cover photo: Collage of photos signifying PEEP’s interventions in subsectors of agriculture during the life of project. (Credit: USAID PEEP) DISCLAIMER The authors’ views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the United States Agency for International Development or the United States government. CONTENTS Acronyms ........................................................................................................... v Executive Summary .......................................................................................... 8 Project background ......................................................................................... 10 Performance Management Section .............................................................. 13 Component I: Private sector-led advocacy for policy reforms ................................... 13 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 13 Core Advocacy Groups: Horticulture, Livestock, and Dairy ............................. 13 Roundtable Meetings ................................................................................................... 20 Warehouse Receipt System: Support to Pakistan Agriculture Coalition to Establish a Collateral Management Company ........................................................ 21 Olive Sector Development ........................................................................................ 22 Support to Punjab Agriculture Department for Agriculture Policy 2018 Formulation ................................................................................................................... 29 Assist PAD in Implementing Punjab Agriculture Policy 2018: Matching Grants Scheme ............................................................................................................................ 30 Support the Punjab L&DDD for the Formulation of the Livestock Policy for Punjab 2020 ................................................................................................................... 31 Achievements and Sustainability ................................................................................... 32 Challenges and Lessons Learned .................................................................................. 34 Governmental and Non-governmental Institutions: Strengths and Weaknesses ............................................................................................................................................. 36 Component 2: Support Institutional Capacity building ................................................. 37 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 37 Punjab Halal Development Agency (PHDA): Phase 1 and 2 .............................. 38 Sahiwal Chamber of Commerce and Industry ....................................................... 40 Center for Applied Policy Research in Livestock (CAPRIL) .............................. 40 Assessment of Loose Milk Supply to Lahore ......................................................... 41 Horticulture Business and Policy Research Center at Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan ........................................................................................................ 43 Pakistan Cold Chain Development Company ....................................................... 44 Pakistan Agriculture and Dairy Farmers Association (PADFA) ......................... 44 Livestock Breeding Services Authority (LBSA) Punjab ........................................ 45 Sahiwal Cattle Breeders Society (SCBS) ................................................................. 46 Implementation of Grants to Nine Livestock Associations ................................ 47 .......................................................................................................................................... 49 PUNJAB ENABLING ENVIRONMENT PROJECT | ii .......................................................................................................................................... 49 Women Empowerment in South Punjab through Investment in Rural Economy (WEinSPIRE): Bahawalpur ........................................................................ 49 Women Empowerment in South Punjab through Investment in Rural Economy (WEinSPIRE): Dera Ghazi Khan .............................................................. 51 Women Investment in Networks of Dairy Sector (WINDS) ............................ 53 Support to L&DDD for Capacity Enhancement ................................................... 54 Achievements and Sustainability ................................................................................... 54 Challenges and Lessons Learned .................................................................................. 56 Governmental and Non-governmental Institutions: Strengths and Weaknesses ............................................................................................................................................. 57 Component 3: Mobilize Major Private Sector Investment .......................................... 59 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 59 Investment Promotion Seminars .............................................................................. 60 Transaction Advisory Services (TAS) Program ..................................................... 62 Matching Grants Program for Olive Sector Development ................................. 67 Milk Pasteurization Sector .......................................................................................... 69 Mustaqbil - Youth Engagement in Agriculture ....................................................... 70 South Punjab Private Sector Engagement Forum .................................................. 71 Achievements and Sustainability ................................................................................... 75 Challenges and Lessons Learned .................................................................................. 76 Governmental and Non-governmental Institutions: Strengths and Weaknesses ............................................................................................................................................. 78 Suggestions for Follow-on Programs ........................................................................... 80 Cross-Cutting ......................................................................................................................... 83 Monitoring and Evaluation ............................................................................................. 83 Assumptions and Challenges ..................................................................................... 83 Project Objectives and Indicators Performance ................................................... 84 Impact Studies Completed ......................................................................................... 88 Environmental Compliance............................................................................................ 96 Communications .............................................................................................................. 99 ANNEX A. PERFORMANCE MONITORING PLAN REPORT PROGRESS ON PROJECT INDICATORS FOR LOP ............................................................................... 104 ANNEX B. FINANCIAL REPORT .................................................................................. 108 ANNEX C: WORK PLAN STATUS AND DEVIATIONS ........................................ 109 ANNEX D. REPORT INDEX OF ALL REPORTS AND INFORMATION PRODUCTS ......................................................................................................................... 172 PUNJAB ENABLING ENVIRONMENT PROJECT | iii ANNEX E. ORGANIZATIONAL CHART ................................................................... 179 ANNEX F. SUCCESS STORIES FROM LIFE OF PROJECT ...................................... 180 PUNJAB ENABLING ENVIRONMENT PROJECT | iv ACRONYMS ADP Annual Development Program ADU Agriculture Delivery Unit BARI Barani Agriculture Research Institute BEE Business Enabling Environment BOO Build Own Operate CAG Core Advocacy Group CAPRIL Center for Applied Policy Research in Livestock CEFORT Centre of Excellence for Olive Research and Training CEO Chief Executive Officer COP Chief of Party CMC Collateral Management Company COR Contracting Officer’s Representative DGKCCI Dera Ghazi Khan Chamber of Commerce and Industry DO Development Objective DPP Department of Plant Protection EDF Environmental Documentation Form EMFP Establishment of Model Farms Project EMMP Environmental Mitigation and Monitoring Plan ERR Environmental Review Report FAQ Frequently Asked Questions FGD Focus Group Discussion FMD Foot and Mouth Disease FTE Full Time Equivalent GoPb Government of Punjab HICD Human and Institutional Capacity Development HRC Halal Research Council IEE Initial Environmental Examination LBSA Livestock Breeding Services Authority LDCMMC