Bohemian Souls: a Facsimile of the Original Manuscript of “A Scandal in Bohemia” by Arthur Conan Doyle, with Annotations and Commentary

Home , Baker Street (musical), Irene Adler, Micah Clarke, The Baker Street Journal

An Index to

Bohemian Souls: A Facsimile of the Original Manuscript of “A Scandal in Bohemia” by Arthur Conan Doyle, with Annotations and Commentary

Edited by Otto Penzler, BSI

Index Prepared for the BSI by Adrian Nebbett

From the edition by The Baker Street Irregulars in association with The Harry Ransom Center at the University of Texas at Austin (2011)

5 February 2011

www.bakerstreetjournal.com

Bohemian Souls is part of The Baker Street Irregulars Manuscript Series. Books from that series, along with volumes from the International Series and the History Series, are available from The Baker Street Journal website at . An Index to Bohemian Souls

Bohemian Souls Table of Contents

General Editor’s Foreword and Preface to the Series by Andrew G. Fusco (pp. vii-xiii)

Introduction by Otto Penzler (pp. 1-7)

Initial Reflections on a Scandal by Phillip Bergem (pp. 9-15)

Manuscript Facsimile of “A Scandal in Bohemia” with Annotated Transcription by Phillip Bergem (pp. 17-94)

Description of the Manuscript by Randall Stock (pp. 96-103)

Revealing “A Scandal in Bohemia”: Its History and Manuscript by Randall Stock (pp. 105-124)

The Curious Case of the Very Odd Marriage by John Linsenmeyer (pp. 125-132)

As to Your Dates, That Is the Biggest Mystification of All by Andrew Jay Peck (pp. 133-138)

Cutting the Poetry: The Case Against an Affair Between Holmes and Irene Adler by Ray Betzner (pp. 139-143)

A Touch of the Dramatic by Curtis Armstrong (pp. 145-156)

The Late Irene Adler, of Dubious and Questionable Memory by Michael H. Kean (pp. 157-176)

Irene Adler in Dubious and Questionable Legend by Julia Rosenblatt (pp. 177-183)

Reflections on the Adler Problem by Donald Pollock (pp. 185-189)

Appendix: A Note from the Artist about the Jacket Illustration by Rikki Niehaus (pp. 191-195)

www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 2 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Conventions Used in this Index:

Page numbers in italics refer to illustrations or photographs.

Page numbers in bold refer to an entire article or section of the book.

‘n’ refers to a footnote or an endnote.

Material within the story “A Scandal in Bohemia” is not indexed.

Names of books, stories, and articles are all shown in italic.

Dates indexed are only those relevant to the chronology of the story / publication or main topic of an article, and appear at the end of this Index.

www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 3 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

221B Studies in Sherlock Holmes (Vincent Starrett, Baker Street and Beyond: Together with Some Trifling ed.), x (n), ix(n), xiii(n) Monographs (Edgar W. Smith), 163n Adler, Damian, 181-182 Baker Street Chronology (Ernest Bloomfield Zeisler), Adler, Irene, vii, 1-4, 6, 9, 12, 86, 89, 91, 125, 130, 133n 132, 134, 137-138, 139-143, 152, 154-155, 157- Baker Street Irregulars, ix-x, xi, 105, 114-115, 118, 157n, 176, 177-183, 185-189, 191-192, 192-195 177, 180, 191 age, 87, 159, 177-178, 186 annual dinner, 114-115, 118 bipolarism, 188-189 Manuscript Series, vii, viii, x-xii, 1, 5 marriage, 9, 125-132, 161, 173, 175, 185-189, 191 Baker Street Journal, The, ix, 116, 119, 140n, 162n, 163n, photographs, 3-4, 12, 134, 137-138, 143, 161, 167- 166n, 177-178, 179n, 180n 168, 170-176, 185-186, 188 Christmas Annual 1957, 160n pregnancy, 161, 163-176, 178 Christmas Annual 1999, 131n relationship with King of Bohemia, 1-4 Editor’s Gas-Lamp, The, ix(n) religion, 169 From the Editor’s Commonplace Book, 180n ‘The late…’, viii, 6, 157-158, 160-163, 174-176, Baker Street Miscellanea, 114n, 167n 177, 185, 189 Baltimore Weekly Sun, 11, 82 true identity, 178-180 Bannister, 131 Adler, Samuel, 169 Banns, 128 Adler, Scott, 140, 182 Bar of Gold, The, 149 Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, The, 113, 117 Barbados, 129n Oxford edition, 98n, 99n, 124, 127n, 158n, 160n Baring-Gould, William S., x, 139, 145, 155, 159, 178, 181 Adventuress, The: see Good Morning, Irene Annotated Sherlock Holmes, The, 129n, 139 Adventuress of Sherlock Holmes, Some Observations Chronological Holmes, The, 159n Upon the Identification of Irene (Julian Wolff), Nero Wolfe of West Thirty-fifth Street, 140 179n Sherlock Holmes of Baker Street, 139-140, 166, 178n Africa, North, 126 Bavaria, 85, 179 Agatha, 151, 171 Beeton’s Christmas Annual, 115, 117, 119, 122, 123n Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland (Lewis Carroll), Bell, H.W., ix, 135, 159 116 Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson: The Chronology of Altamont, 151 Their Adventures, 135n Annotated Sherlock Holmes, The (William S. Baring- Bell, Dr. Joseph, 142 Gould), 129n, 139 Benedict XIV, Pope, 129 Annotations for “A Scandal in Bohemia” (Phillip Berg Collection, 109 Bergem), 82-94 Bergem, Phillip, 5, 197 Another Gasp in re Irene (Donald A. Redmond), Annotations for “A Scandal in Bohemia”, 82-94 179n Initial Reflections on a Scandal, 9-13 Another Scandal in Bohemia: see Irene’s Last Waltz Bergquist, John, 6, 197 Armstrong, Curtis, 5, 197 Beryl Coronet, The, 148 Touch of the Dramatic, A, 145-156 bestofsherlock.com, 123n Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (Jon Betzner, Ray, 5, 136, 197 Lellenberg, Daniel Stashower & Charles Foley, Cutting the Poetry: The Case Against an affair Between eds.), 107n Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler, 139-143 As to Your Dates, That Is the Biggest Mystification of Biorhythmic Holmes: A Chronological Perspective, The All (Andrew Jay Peck), 133-138 (Carey Cummings), 138n Asimov, Isaac, 5 Black Peter, 147 Augustine of Hippo, St., 126 Blackbeard, Bill, 12 Augustinians, 126 Blakeney, T.S., vii, ix, 131n, 135-137, 151, 159 Aunt Clara, 180 Sherlock Holmes: Fact or Fiction?, 135n Austin, Texas, 94, 98n, 123 Blau, Peter E., 99, 100 Austin, James Bliss, 122 Blue Carbuncle, The, 133, 177n Austria-Hungary, vii Bobbitt, John Wayne, 2 Axelrad, Arthur M., Bock, Jerry, 181n ‘Late’ Irene Adler, The, 162n Baker Street (Musical), 122, 140, 181 What a Night This is Going to Be, 140n

www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 4 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Bohemia, 82, 85 Christ, Jay Finley, 133, 134n, 135, 159 Bohemia, King of, vii, 1-5, 9, 12, 134, 136-138, 141, Irregular Chronology of Sherlock Holmes of Baker 151-152, 158, 160-164, 166-176, 178, 180, 186- Street, An, 135n 188 Chronological Holmes, The (William S. Baring-Gould), true identity of, vii-viii 159n Bohemian Scandal, A, 10, 82 Church of England, 126-129 Book of Common Prayer, 128 Cincinnati, 11 Boston Sunday Globe, The, 11, 12, 15, 82 Clark, John D., Brend, Gavin, 133, 135-136, 159 Some Notes Relating to a Preliminary Investigation into My Dear Holmes, 135n the Paternity of Nero Wolfe, 140n, 178n Brett, Jeremy, x Clotilde Lothman von Saxe-Meningen, 3-5, 9, 134, 164, British Library, 110 168-169, 175, 186 British Literary Culture and Publishing Practice, Columbia University, 118 1880-1914 (Peter D. McDonald), 109 Conan Doyle (Hesketh Pearson), 108 Brooklyn, 117 Conan Doyle of Wimpole Street (Richard Lancelyn Brooks, Mel, 1 Green), 124n Brown, Dan, Condom, Dr., 164 Da Vinci Code, The, 125n Coopersmith, Jerome, 181n Brownie camera, 3 Cornhill Magazine, 107 Bruce-Partington Plans, The, 134n Courier-Journal, The (Louisville), 10, 12, 82-94 Brundage, Paul H., 162, 170 Creeping Man, The, 133, 134, 134n, 137 In Defense of Irene Adler, 162n, 166n, 170n, 173n Crown Jewels, The, 181 Buffalo Courier, 10 Cummings, Carey, 138 Byerly, Ann, Biorhythmic Holmes: A Chronological Perspective, Sidney Paget: Victorian Black-and-White The, 138n Illustrator, 114n Curious Case of the Very Odd Marriage, The (John Cab fares, 89 Linsenmeyer), 125-132 Calhoun, Philo Clarke, 115 Currency, British, Carroll Atwood Wilson, 124n conversions, 87, 89 California, University of, 115 decimalization, 125n Canadian Holmes, 169n guinea, 89, 125n Canary Trainer, The (Nicholas Meyer), 181 pound, 87, 125n Canon Fire, 162n shilling, 89, 125n Captain Basil, 147 sovereign, 89, 125n Carr, John Dickson, 98-99, 102 Cutting the Poetry: The Case Against an affair Between Life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, The, 98 Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler (Ray Betzner), 139- Note on the Handwriting in ‘A Scandal in 143 Bohemia’, 98n Da Vinci Code, The (Dan Brown), 125n Carroll, Lewis, Daily Inter-Ocean, The (Chicago), 10, 12, 13, 82-94 Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, 116 Daily Picayune, The (New Orleans), 10, 12, 82-94 Carroll Atwood Wilson (Philo Clarke Calhoun), 124n Dakin, D. Martin, 135, 170 Case Book of Sherlock Holmes, The, 122 Sherlock Holmes Commentary, A, 136n, 163, 164n, Case of Identity, A, 112, 177n 170n Case of the Yankee Diva, The (Edward J. Vatza), Dannay, Frederic, 94, 97, 117-122 179n ‘The Dying Detective’ investiture, 118 Castle Rouge (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181n Date Being-?”: A Compendium of Chronological Data, Chambers’s Journal, 107 “The (Andrew J. Peck & Leslie S. Klinger), 134n, 159n Chancellor, Anna, 182n Davis, Elmer, ix Chapel Noir (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181n Descartes, René, 1 Charles II, 128 Description of the Manuscript (Randall Stock), 97-103 Charles Augustus Milverton, 126-127n, 133, 140n, Detective Short Story: A Bibliography, The (Ellery 151, 171 Queen), 121 Cheb, 85 Detroit Free Press, The, 11 Chicago, 10, 82 Devil’s Foot, The, 133, 134n De Waal, Ronald Burt, Universal Sherlock Holmes, The, 157 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 5 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Dickens, Charles, Jr., Dying Detective, The, 150 Dickens’s Dictionary of London 1888, 94n Edward VII, vii Dickens’s Dictionary of London 1888 (Charles Eger, 85 Dickens, Jr.), 94n Egria, 85 Disjecta Membra (Jon Lellenberg, ed.), 114n Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, 118, 121 Dispatch Box, The, 162n Emerson, Ralph Waldo, 115 Doings of Raffles Haw, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), Empty House, The, 147-148 111 English Channel, 160 Douglas, Carole Nelson, 9, 181 Escott, 140n, 151 Adventuress, The: see Good Morning, Irene Examiner, The (San Francisco), 11, 12, 14-15, 82-94 Another Scandal in Bohemia: see Irene’s Last Faber, Johann, 132n Waltz Feldman, Lew David, 99, 117, 119-122 Castle Rouge, 181n Looking Backward, 99, 117 Chapel Noir, 181n Femme Fatale (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181n Femme Fatale, 181n Ferdinand II, 85 Good Morning, Irene, 181n Final Problem, The, 147, 149-150, 153n Good Night, Mr. Holmes, 181n manuscript, 115 Irene at Large, 181n Fink, Joseph J., 166 Irene’s Last Waltz, 181n Joe Fink Tells Tall Sherlockian Tales, 167n Soul of Steel, A: see Irene at Large First You See It, Then You Don’t: Another Scandal in Spider Dance, 181 Bohemia (A.C. Roberts & Gene A. Leeb), 166n Downey, Robert, Jr., 141, 182n Five Ways to Compute the Relative Worth of a UK Pound Dowson, Baron, 156 Amount, 1830 to Present (Lawrence H. Officer), 94n Doyle, Adrian Conan, 99, 102, 122 Florizel, Prince, vii-viii Doyle, Arthur Conan, x, xi, 9-10, 11, 12-13, 82, 87, Foley, Charles, 97, 98-102, 105-114, 115, 117, 122-123, 142-143 Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (with Jon death, xi, 11 Lellenberg & Daniel Stashower, eds.), 107n diary, 105, 108-113 Folsom, Henry T., 134-135, 136n, 159 Doings of Raffles Haw, The, 111 Through the Years at Baker Street: A Chronology of estate, 98, 99 Sherlock Holmes, 134n family, 9-10, 99 Forsyte, Irene Heron, 179 favourite Holmes stories, vii, 157n Forsyte Saga, The (John Galsworthy), 179 finances, 105, 108, 112-113 Foss, Rachel, 110 handwriting, 98-100 France, 178, 180 letters from, 110, 114, 142 Franz Ferdinand, Archduke, vii London, living in, 94, 105-108, 110-111 Frewer, Matt, 182n manuscripts, see individual story titles From the Mind to the Body (Edward Shorter), 189 medical practice, 94, 105-106, 108, 111, 123 Fusco, Andrew G., 6, 197-198 Micah Clarke, 105 General Editor’s Foreword, vii-viii punctuation, 12-13, 82-94, 101 General Editor’s Preface to the Series, ix-xiii Refugees, The, 106, 111 Gabel, Martin, 181n spelling, 84 Galsworthy, John, spiritualism, 122 Forsyte Saga, The, 179 Voice of Science, The, 112 Gibbons, Rodney, 182n White Company, The, 105, 107 Gibbs, Nancy, writing style & method, 12, 86, 100, 111 Love, Sex, Freedom, and the Paradox of the Pill, 164n Doyle, Bev, 182n Gibran, Kahlil, 128 Doyle, Constance, 102 Gilbert & Sullivan, 115 Doyle, Denis Conan, 117 Gilchrist, 131 Doyle, James, 9 ‘Gloria Scott’, The, 155 Doyle, Jane, 9 God of the Hive, The (Laurie R. King), 181, 182n Doyle, John, 9 Golden Pince-Nez, The, Doyle, Lottie, 99, 102 manuscript, 122 Doyle, Louise ‘Touie’ Hawkins, 102 Goldfarb, Clifford S., Doyle, Mary Foley, 107 Sherlock Holmes: The Jewish Connection (with Hartley Dukedom Large Enough (David Randall), 124n R. Nathan), 169 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 6 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Good Morning, Irene (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181n Hudson, Mrs., viii, 152n Good Night, Mr. Holmes (Carole Nelson Douglas), Hungary, vii 181n Huxtable, Penelope “Nell”, 181 Good Night, Mister Sherlock Holmes (Edgar W. Hyde Park, 90 Smith), 163n, 178n Illustrious Client’s Second Case-Book, The (J.N. Great Game, The, ix-x, 5, 9, 139 Williamson, ed.), 119 Great Hiatus, The, 139, 166 Imperial Opera of Warsaw, 177 Greek Interpreter, The, In Defense of Irene Adler (Paul H. Brundage), 162n, manuscript, 122 166n, 170n, 173n Green, Richard Lancelyn, 98-99, 100, 116 In the Queen’s Parlor (Ellery Queen), 121 Conan Doyle of Wimpole Street, 124n Indiana University, Gribben, Alan, Lilly Library, 115 Harry Huntt Ransom, 121 Initial Reflections on a Scandal (Phillip Bergem), 9-13 Grolier Club, 115 International News Company, 10 Grudeff, Marian, 181n Irene Adler in Dubious and Questionable Legend (Julia Guggenheim family, 115 Rosenblatt), 177-183 Guinea (coin), 125n Irene at Large (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181n Gypsy Baron, The (Johann Strauss II), 152 Irene! (gasp) Irene! (Evelyn Herzog), 179n Haggard, H. Rider, 115 Irene’s Last Waltz (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181n Hall, Trevor, Irregular Chronology of Sherlock Holmes of Baker Street, Late Mr. Sherlock Holmes, The, 131n An (Jay Finley Christ), 135n Hardy, Thomas, 115 Jackson, Michael Robert, 182n Hare, John, 153 Jamison, Kay Redfield, Harnick, Sheldon, 181n Touched with Fire: Manic-Depressive Illness and the Harrison, Michael, vii, 159 Artistic Temperament, 188n Harry Huntt Ransom (Alan Gribben), 121 Jersey, 160, 179 Hawthorne, Nathaniel, 115 Jerseyanna (Marc Mappen), 160n Healy, David, Jessel, Raymond, 181n Mania: A Short History of Bipolar Disorder, 188n Joe Fink Tells Tall Sherlockian Tales (Joseph J. Fink), Heldenbrand, Page, 5, 159 167n Herzog, Evelyn, 179 Jones, Athelney, 146 Irene! (gasp) Irene!, 179n Judaism, 169 His Last Bow, 134n, 137, 151, 177n Kaye, Marvin, Histrionic Holmes, The (Marvin Kaye), 145, 150-151 Histrionic Holmes, The, 145, 150-151 Hoboken, 163, 177-178 Kean, Michael, 6, 198 Hoff, Ebbe Curtis & Phebe Margaret, 159 Late Irene Adler, of Dubious and Questionable Hogg Fund, see under W.C. Hogg Fund Memory, The, 157-176 Holder, Alexander, 148 Kelly, Grace, 2 Holmes, Mycroft, 153n Kemp, Julian, 182n Holmes, Sherlock, 192-195 Kinberg, Simon, 182n acting ability, 145-156 King, Laurie R., attitude to Irene Adler, 87, 139-143, 162, 166-167, God of the Hive, The, 181, 182n 172, 178, 180-182, 189 Language of Bees, The, 181, 182n attitude to King of Bohemia, 2-3 King’s Sweetheart, -or- Adventures in Search of a attitude to women, 130, 132, 136, 142, 143n Photograph, The, 11, 82 finances, 87, 153 Klinger, Leslie S., iconic image, 11 Date Being-?”: A Compendium of Chronological Data, jokes played on, 130-131 “The (with Andrew J. Peck), 134n, 159n retirement, 178, 180 Knights Templar, 125n Watson, relationship with, 142, 155, 180 Knox, Ronald, ix, 159 Holmesian Observer Annual 2, The, 162n Studies in the Literature of Sherlock Holmes, 131-132 Honeymooners, The, 167 Komorowska, Liliana, 182n Hound of the Baskervilles, The, Kramden, Ralph, 167 manuscript, 122, 123n Kurti, Richard, 182n House of El Dieff, 99, 117 La Scala, 177, 179 Howard, Elizabeth Ann, 160 Landsfeld, Countess of, 179 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 7 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Lang, Andrew, 131 Norwood, 111 Langham Hotel, 87 Palmer’s Green, 126n Langtry, Lily, 159-160, 179 St. Monica’s, 126n Language of Bees, The (Laurie R. King), 181, 182n Regent Street, 125 Lanza, Kenneth, 167 St. John’s Wood, 9-10, 125-126, 160 Scandal in Bensonhurst, 167n St. Monica, Church of, 125-127 ‘Late’ Irene Adler, The (Arthur M. Axelrad), 162n Serpentine Avenue, 100, 153-154, 156, 160 Late Irene Adler, of Dubious and Questionable Briony Lodge, 9, 100, 155, 160, 168, 171, 173-174 Memory, The (Michael H. Kean), 157-176 Southwark, 126 Late Mr. Sherlock Holmes, The (Trevor Hall), 131n Upper Wimpole Street, 78-79, 94, 97, 108, 110-111 Latest Treatise upon Pathology, The (J.N. Westminster, 126-127 Williamson), 180n St. Monica’s Priory, 126-127 Lauriston Gardens, 146 London Nights of Belsize (Vernon Rendell), 131 Lee, Manfred B., 94, 117-118 Longfellow, Henry Wadsworth, 115 Leeb, Gene A., Longman’s Magazine, 131 First You See It, Then You Don’t: Another Scandal Looking Backward (Lew David Feldman), 99, 117 in Bohemia (with A.C. Roberts), 166n Louisville, 10, 82 Lellenberg, Jon, Love, Sex, Freedom, and the Paradox of the Pill (Nancy Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (with Daniel Gibbs), 164n Stashower & Charles Foley, eds.), 107n Ludwig I of Bavaria, 179 Disjecta Membra (ed.), 114n Lycett, Andrew, Leo XIII, Pope, 129 Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes, The, 110 Leroux, Gaston, McAdams, Rachel, 141, 182 Phantom of the Opera, The, 181 McClure, Samuel S., 10, 112-113 Lestrade, Inspector, 127n McClure Newspaper Syndicate, 10-11, 12, 112 Letters Addressed to A.P. Watt, 110n McDonald, Peter D., 109-110 Lewis, Arthur H., x British Literary Culture and Publishing Practice, 1880- Life magazine, 116 1914, 109 Life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, The (John Dickson Maine, 115, 179 Carr), 98 Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes, The (Andrew Linsenmeyer, John, 6, 198 Lycett), 110 Curious Case of the Very Odd Marriage, The, 125- Man with the Twisted Lip, The, 146, 148, 150 132 Mania: A Short History of Bipolar Disorder (David Lippincott’s Monthly Magazine, 87 Healy), 188n Lola and Irene, Heavenly Twins (Alastair Martin), Manuscript, see under individual story titles 179n Mappen, Marc, London, 10, 106-108, 126, 128-129, 137, 147, 161, Jerseyanna, 160n 175-176, 177, 179 Marriage laws, 127-129, 187 Baker Street, 83, 100, 135, 146, 152, 173, 180, 187 Martin, Alastair, Bond Street, 83 Lola and Irene, Heavenly Twins, 179n Charing Cross, 89 measuringworth.com, 94n Clifton Gardens, 9 Merchant of Venice, The (William Shakespeare), 155 Cricklewood, 129 Meyer, Nicholas, x Cricklewood Lane, 129 Canary Trainer, The, 181 St. Agnes, Church of, 129 Micah Clarke (Arthur Conan Doyle), 105 Curzon Street, 98n Milverton, Charles Augustus, 127n, 151 Washington Hotel, 98n Milverton’s murderess, 126-127n Edgware Road, 9, 100, 125-127, 129 Misadventures of Sherlock Holmes, The (Ellery Queen), Garrick Theatre, 153 118 Gray’s Inn, 160 MIT, 180 Hoxton Square, 126 Monaco, 2 Inner Temple, 125, 160 Monica, St., 126 Inns of Court, 125n, 160 Montenegro, 139, 166, 178, 181 Lincoln’s Inn, 160 Montez, Lola, 179, 181 Middle Temple, 160 Montgomery, Bruce, 180 Montague Place, 83, 108, 111 Montgomery, James, 180 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 8 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Montpellier, 181 Officer, Lawrence H., Moore, Roger, 140, 182n Five Ways to Compute the Relative Worth of a UK Moran, Colonel Sebastian, 139 Pound Amount, 1830 to Present, 94n Moran, Col. Sebastian II, Offord, Lenore Glen, 159 Sherlock Holmes’s University: Oxford or Ormstein, House of, 175 Cambridge, 131n Ostia, 126 Moriarty, Professor, 140, 142, 166, 180-183 Oxford University, 115, 132 Morley, Christopher, vii, ix, xii, 114-116, 159 Paget, Sidney, 11-12, 15, 114, 123, 127n, 191 Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson (ed.), xii(n) Paris, 106, 111, 181 Morrow, Daniel, Parke-Bernet auction house, 116 Who Was That Villain I Saw You With, Irene?, Patrick, Robert R., 159 162n Payn, James, 106 Morstan, Mary, 134-135, 180 Pearson, Hesketh, 110 Most winning woman, 142 Conan Doyle, 108 Murders in the Rue Morgue, The (Edgar Allan Poe), Peck, Andrew J., 6, 198 122 As to Your Dates, That Is the Biggest Mystification of Musgrave Ritual, the, x All, 133-138 My Dear Holmes (Gavin Brend), 135n Date Being-?”: A Compendium of Chronological Data, Napoleon III, 160 “The (with Leslie S. Klinger), 134n, 159n Nathan, Hartley R., Peckham, Anthony, 182n Sherlock Holmes: The Jewish Connection (with Penzler, Otto, 199 Clifford S. Goldfarb), 169 Introduction, 1-7 NBC, 140n ‘King of Bohemia’ investiture, vii, 1, 5 Nero Wolfe of West Thirty-fifth Street (William S. Perspective in Scholarship, A (Edgar W. Smith) ix(n), ix Baring-Gould), 140 Phantom of the Opera, The (Gaston Leroux), 181 Nevins, Francis M., Photography, 3-4 Royal Bloodline: Ellery Queen, Author and Picture of Dorian Gray, The (Oscar Wilde), 87 Detective, 124 Pittsburgh Press, The, 11, 12, 82-94 New Colophon, 117 Poe, Edgar Allan, New Jersey, 141, 159-160, 163, 177-178 Murders in the Rue Morgue, The, 122 New Orleans, 10, 82 Pollock, Donald, 6, 199 New Scandal in Bohemia, A (Manly Wade Wellman), Reflections on the Adler Problem, 185-189 162 Portia (Merchant of Venice), 155 New York, 10-11, 82 Portugal, 99, 102 Broadway , 140, 181 Profile by Gaslight (Edgar W. Smith, ed.), xii, 180n Broadway Theatre, 122 Pryce, Jonathan, 182n New York Herald, 10, 82 Punch, Mr., 150 New York Times, 160n Queen, Ellery, 19, 78-79, 94, 97, 117-119, 121, 123 Newnes, George, 159, 171 Detective Short Story: A Bibliography, The, 121 Newnes Publishing, 11, 101 Ellery Queen Collection, 121-122 Newton, G.B., 159 In the Queen’s Parlor, 121 Niehaus, Rikki, Misadventures of Sherlock Holmes, The, 118 Note from the Artist about the Dust Jacket Queen’s Quorum, 121 illustration, A, 191-195 Queen’s Quorum (Ellery Queen), 121 Nordica, Lillian, 179 Rainier II, Prince of Monaco, 2 Norton, Ed, 167 Rampling, Charlotte, 182n Norton, Edward, 167 Randall, David, 115-117 Norton, Godfrey, 9, 125, 127, 130, 139, 160-161, Dukedom Large Enough, 124n 163-165, 167-168, 170-176, 177, 181, 186-189, Ransom, Harry, 120-121 192-195 Red Circle, The, 133 Norton, Lily, 179 Red-Headed League, The, 133 Note from the Artist about the Dust Jacket manuscript, 108, 113 illustration, A (Rikki Niehaus), 191-195 Redmond, Donald A., 12, 179 Note on the Handwriting in ‘A Scandal in Bohemia’ Another Gasp in re Irene, 179n (John Dickson Carr), 98n

www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 9 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Reflections on a Scandal in Bohemia, 98, 116 Scandinavia, 137-138 Reflections on the Adler Problem (Donald Pollock), Scandinavia, King of, 3-4, 137, 164 185-189 Scoundrels in Bohemia (Manly Wade Wellman), 178n Refugees, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 106, 111 Scribner’s Book Store, 115-117 Regent’s Park, 90 Seattle Post-Intelligencer, The, 10 Reigate Squires, The, 99, 146 Second Stain, The, 133, 143n Rendell, Vernon, Sellars, Crighton, 180 London Nights of Belsize, 131 Visit to Sherlock Holmes, 180n Revealing “A Scandal in Bohemia”: Its History and Shakespeare, William, Manuscript (Randall Stock), 105-124 Merchant of Venice, The, 155 Rhodes Scholarship, 115 Twelfth Night , 155 Ritchie, Guy, 141n, 182n Shearn, A.L., Rituale Romanum, Leo XIII, 1884, 129 Street and the Detective, The, 160n Roberts, A.C., Sherlock Holmes (2009 movie), 141, 182 First You See It, Then You Don’t: Another Scandal Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson (Christopher Morley, in Bohemia (with Gene A. Leeb), 166n ed.), xii(n) Roberts, F.W., 99n Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson: The Chronology of Roberts, S.C., ix, 136 Their Adventures (H.W. Bell), 135n Roman Catholic Church, 126-129 Sherlock Holmes and the Baker Street Irregulars (2007), Roman Empire, 126 182 Rome, 126 Sherlock Holmes Commentary, A (D. Martin Dakin), Roosevelt, 4 136n, 163, 164n, 170n Rosenblatt, Julia, 6, 199 Sherlock Holmes: Fact or Fiction? (T.S. Blakeney), 135n Irene Adler in Dubious and Questionable Legend, Sherlock Holmes in New York (1976), 140, 182 177-183 Sherlock Holmes of Baker Street (William S. Baring- Ross, Barnaby, 78-79, 94, 97, 118-119 Gould), 139-140, 166, 178n Royal Bloodline: Ellery Queen, Author and Detective Sherlock Holmes: The Jewish Connection (Hartley R. (Francis M. Nevins), 124 Nathan & Clifford S. Goldfarb), 169 Royal Scandal, The (2001) Sherlock Holmes’s University: Oxford or Cambridge Rudolph, Grand Duke of Austria-Hungary, vii (Col. Sebastian Moran II), 131n Russell, Mary, 181-182 Shorter, Edward, Sagal, Boris, 182n From the Mind to the Body, 189 St. Jean de Luz, 180 Sidney Paget: Victorian Black-and-White Illustrator (Ann St. (Saint), see under given name Byerly), 114n San Diego, 115 Sign of Four, The, 9, 83, 87, 105, 112-113, 130n, 134- San Francisco, 11, 12, 82 138, 142, 146-149 Sapinsley, Alvin, 182n manuscript, 115 Scandal in ‘A Scandal in Bohemia’, A (J.N. Silver Blaze, 83 Williamson), 163n, 178n Slavey, 84 Scandal in Bensonhurst (Kenneth Lanza), 167n Smith, Edgar W., vii, viii, ix-x, xi-xii, 157n, 159, 163, Scandal in Bohemia, A, 177, 180 alternate titles, 10-11, 19-21, 82, 97, 112-113, 123 Baker Street and Beyond: Together with Some Trifling chronology, 6, 84, 133-138, 158-159 Monographs, 163n illustrations, 11-12, 14-15, 114, 192-195 Good Night, Mister Sherlock Holmes, 163n, 178n manuscript, 5, 6, 11, 12-13, 18-81, 82-94, 96, 97- Perspective in Scholarship, A, ix(n) 103, 98, 100-102, 105, 106, 108-111, 109, 110, Profile by Gaslight (ed.), xii, 180n 112, 113-123, 119, 120 Smith, H. Greenhough, 105, 108, 112-114, 171 ownership, 94, 114-122 Soames, Hilton, 131 second transcriber, 12, 88, 90-91, 97, 98-102 Some Notes Relating to a Preliminary Investigation into value, 116-117, 119 the Paternity of Nero Wolfe (John D. Clark), 140n, popularity, 11, 157 178n publication history, 10-11, 114, 158 Soul of Steel, A: see Irene at Large variations in published versions, 5, 11, 12-13, 82- Southsea, 106 94, 123 Spider Dance (Carole Nelson Douglas), 181 Scandal of Bohemia, 10, 19-21, 82, 97, 112-113, 123

www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 10 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Starrett, Vincent, vii, ix-x, xii, xii(n), 105, 114, 118, Twelfth Night (William Shakespeare), 155 120, 121, 133 United States of America, 10, 13, 82, 112-114, 123, 140n, 221B Studies in Sherlock Holmes (ed.), x (n) , 141n, 145 xi(n), xiii(n) attitudes to royalty, 85 Stashower, Daniel, copyright act, 114 Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (with Jon Universal Sherlock Holmes, The (Ronald Burt De Waal), Lellenberg & Charles Foley, eds.), 107n 157 Stephens, Clara, 180 Untermeyer, Louis, xii Stock, Randall, 6, 123n, 199 Van Dieren, Bernard J., 178 Best of Sherlock Holmes website, 123 What Has Become of Them?, 178n Description of the Manuscript, 97-103 Vatza, Edward J., Revealing “A Scandal in Bohemia”: Its History Case of the Yankee Diva, The, 179n and Manuscript, 105-124 What Did Watson Mean by the Late Irene Adler?, 162n Stockbroker’s Clerk, The, 136 Victoria, Queen, 3 Stoddart,, J.M., 87 Vienna, 106-107, 110-111, 123 Stout, Rex, 178n, 180 Viola (Twelfth Night), 155 Watson was a Woman, 180n Visit to Sherlock Holmes (Crighton Sellars), 180n Strand Magazine, 10-11, 13, 82-94, 97, 101, 105, Voice of Science, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 112 108, 109, 111-114, 123, 131, 157n, 158, 159, 161, Von Bork, 151 171 Von Kramer, Count, 86-87 New York edition, 10, 82 Von Kramm, Count, 1, 87, 151, 158 Street and the Detective, The (A.L. Shearn), 160n Von Kramm, Wilhelm, 167 Street naming styles, 83, 90, 100 W.C. Hogg Fund, 121 Studies in the Literature of Sherlock Holmes (Ronald Wales, Prince of: see Edward VII Knox), 131-132 Wallenstein, Albrecht von, 85 Study in Scarlet, A, 9, 105, 106, 115, 119, 122, 135, Warner Brothers, 141n 145-146, 149 Warsaw, 168, 177 Sun, The (New York), 11 Washington Post, The, 10, 12, 82-94 Sussex, 178, 180 Watson, Dr. John H., Swenson, Inga, 181 handwriting, 136 Tagaste, 126 marriages, x, 83, 134-138, 173, 180 Texas, University of, 94, 99, 120-123 ‘my Boswell’, 117 Ellery Queen Collection, 121-122 Watson was a Woman (Rex Stout), 180n Harry Ransom Center, 98n, 99n, 115, 122-123 Watt, A.P., 108-110, 111-114 Humanities Research Center, 99n, 121-122 We Never Mention Aunt Clara, 180 Library, 120 Weaver, Fritz, 181n Thirteen Author Collections of the Nineteenth Wellman, Manly Wade, 159, 178 Century, and Five Centuries of Familiar New Scandal in Bohemia, A, 162 Quotations (Carroll A. Wilson), 117 Scoundrels in Bohemia, 178n Thoreau, Henry David, 115 Wesleyan University, 115 Three Students, The, 131, 132n What Did Watson Mean by the Late Irene Adler? (Edward Through the Years at Baker Street: A Chronology of J. Vatza), 162n Sherlock Holmes (Henry T. Folsom), 134n What Has Become of Them? (Bernard J. Van Dieren), Thucydides, 131, 132n 178n Time Magazine, 164n Whelan, Michael F., 6 Times-Star, The (Cincinnati), 11 White Company, The (Arthur Conan Doyle), 105, 107 Tit Bits, 11, 106 Who Was That Villain I Saw You With, Irene? (Daniel Toledo Blade, 11 Morrow), 162n Toledo Weekly Blade, 11 Wiener, Professor Norbert, 180 Touch of the Dramatic, A (Curtis Armstrong), 145- Wiesenfeld, Joe, 182n 156 Wigram, Lionel, 182n Touched with Fire: Manic-Depressive Illness and the Wilde, Oscar, Artistic Temperament (Kay Redfield Jamison), Picture of Dorian Gray, The, 87 188n Williams College, 115 Trenton, New Jersey, 178 Turner, Mrs., 152n www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 11 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

Williamson, J.N., 163, 178, 180 1889, 3, 159 Illustrious Client’s Second Case-Book, The (ed.), February, 105 119 March, 135-138 Latest Treatise upon Pathology, The, 180n July, 158 Scandal in ‘A Scandal in Bohemia’, A, 163n, 178n August, 87 Wilson, Carroll A., 114-117, 119, 122, 123 1890, 10, 105, 109 Thirteen Author Collections of the Nineteenth August, 105 Century, and Five Centuries of Familiar December, 106 Quotations (Carroll A. Wilson), 117 1891, 12, 82, 84, 94, 97, 99, 102, 105-114, 123, 163, 169, Wolfe, Nero, 140, 178 177-178, 180, 185 Wolff, Julian, vii, 178, 183 January , 106-107 Adventuress of Sherlock Holmes, Some February, 106 Observations Upon the Identification of Irene, March, 106, 108-112 179n April, 97, 108-113 Woman’s Wit, 11, 82 May, 114 www.bestofsherlock.com, 123n June, 166 www.measuringworth.com, 94n July, 10-11, 114, 158 Zeisler, Ernest Bloomfield, 135, 136n, 137, 159 August, 11 Baker Street Chronology, 133n October, 11, 12 1892, 99, 178 DATES August, 111 December, 84 333, 126 1894, 143n 387, 126 1895, 133n 1215, 128 November, 134 1617, 85 1900, 1619, 85 December, 106-108 1629, 85 1902, 180 1637, 85 1903, 134, 178 1752, 129 September, 134, 137 1763, 128 1904, 1809, 169 June, 131 1818, 179 July, 131 1822, 160 1905, 1838, 109 October, 117 1850, 85 1907, 115 1854, 87 1908, 11, 115, 120 1857, 10, 112, 179 1910, 126n 1858, 159, 177 1911, 115, 131 1859, 87 1913, 114, 123 1860, 11 1914, 109, 179 1861, 179 April, 137 1864, 126, 160 August, 134 1881, 146 1916, 114 1884, 129, 179 1919, 108 1886, 143n 1920, 115 March, 105 1924, 108 May, 115, 127 1925, 1887, 115, 122, 134n, 135 May, 115 May, 159 1927, July, 136 March, 157n 1888, 87, 89, 115, 122, 128-129, 159, 177, 185 1928, 118 March, 84, 134-138 1930, 108 June, 136 July, xi July, 135, 137 September, 11 September, 135, 137 1932, 99, 102, 118 www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 12 of 13 An Index to Bohemian Souls

1934, 2009, 182 January, xi December, 141n 1935, 115, 120 2010, 87, 89 1937, 118 1940, 115 1941, 118, 121 1942, ix-x, 118 1943, 108, 115, 116, 123 January, 114 August, 118 1944, 118, 157n 1946, 97 April, 116 October, 116 1947, 115 June, 117 1948, 119 March, 117 June, 117, 119 July, 119 October, 117 1949, 10, 98, 112, 119 1950, 99, 117, 118, 120 1951, 78-79, 94, 97-98, 117, 119-120, 123 1953, ix(n) 1954, 98, 120, 122, 178 February, 119 December, 120 1955, 120 1956, x 1957, February, 120 November, 121 December, 121 1958, 94, 121 January, 121 1959, January, 99, 122 February, 121 1962, April, 99 1964, November, 122 December, 122 1965, 181 February, 122, 140n 1969, 122 1970, 121 1976, 120, 182 1982, 117 1983, 122 1986, 98-99 1987, 99, 100 1994, 99n, 157 2001, 182 2007, 182n www.bakerstreetjournal.com Page 13 of 13