DOCSLIB.ORG

State Succession and Minority Rights – a Case Study of the Diss

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
State Succession and Minority Rights – a Case Study of the Diss State succession and minority rights – a case study of the dissolution of the Former Yugoslavia By Antal Berkes LL.M. LONG THESIS COURSE: Human Rights Professor: Tibor Várady, Dr. habil. Central European University 1051 Budapest, Nádor utca 9. Hungary CEU eTD Collection © Central European University 20 November, 2009 Executive summary Dissolution and separation of States especially threaten minorities, whose protection serves not only the interests of the successor State, but also that of the international community. As a minimum, successor States should continue the human rights treaties to which their predecessor was party. Furthermore, the international community imposed on the successor States of the Former Yugoslavia a series of additional obligations protecting minorities which largely exceeded the minority rights standards of the Cold War period. The international instruments imposed on the new States contributed to a crystallization of a higher minimum standard of minority protection which shall bind all new States tending to be legitimized. CEU eTD Collection ii Table of Contents Introduction – Definition of the scope of the research ............................................................ 1 Research question: a higher standard of minority protection in case of dissolution of States............................................................................................................................. 1 Notion of minority rights.................................................................................................... 3 Notions of State succession – restriction of the research to the separation of States............ 4 Methodology ..................................................................................................................... 6 I. Chapter One: Majority opinion about State succession in respect of human rights treaties. ...................................................................................................................................... 9 1.1. State succession in respect of human rights treaties: a controversial way towards an automatic State succession ......................................................................................... 9 1.1.1. The irreversibility of human rights treaties............................................................... 11 1.1.2. Human rights as acquired rights: are they directly granted to individuals?................ 12 1.1.3. Human rights represent universal values.................................................................. 12 1.1.4. In case of separation, Art. 34 codifies the automatic State succession in respect of treaties ............................................................................................................... 13 1.1.5. The practice of most UN bodies supports the automatic State succession in respect of human rights treaties............................................................................... 15 1.1.6. The practice under the ECHR supports the automaticity rule .................................. 18 1.1.7. The practice of States partly supports the automatic State succession in respect of human rights treaties........................................................................................... 20 1.1.8. Summarizing the arguments .................................................................................... 21 1.2. Synthesizing the doctrinal views: signs of a regional custom of continuity in Eastern and South-Eastern Europe.........................................................................................22 CEU eTD Collection 1.3. Conclusion ............................................................................................................27 II. Chapter Two : Minority rights at the time of separation of States ..................................29 2.1. The connection between separation and minorities: a situation of instability ...........29 2.1.1. The need of stability through minority protection in the States concerned by separation or dissolution ......................................................................................... 29 iii 2.1.2. The stabilizing interests of the international community........................................... 32 2.2. Minority rights obligations beyond treaty context...................................................33 2.2.1. Going beyond the principle of automatic State succession: the possibility of a higher standard of protection .................................................................................. 33 2.2.2. The claim to consider minority rights as customary law........................................... 34 2.2.3. The claim to consider minority rights as jus cogens................................................. 37 2.3. Conclusion ............................................................................................................40 III. Chapter Three: The higher standard of minority protection imposed on successor States of the SFRY by the international community..............................................................42 3.1. International minority protection obligations of the SFRY before 1991 ..................42 3.1.1. Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye (1919) ................................................................ 43 3.1.1.1. International obligations of Yugoslavia under the Minorities Treaty........44 3.1.1.2. A basis for further comparisons – the threshold of minority protection ensured by the Minorities Treaty ............................................................46 3.1.1.3. The alleged termination of the Minorities Treaties ..................................49 3.1.1.4. The (historical) effect of the Minorities Treaty........................................51 3.1.2. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights ......................................... 52 3.1.3. The Osimo Agreement............................................................................................ 59 3.1.3.1. The standard of the Osimo Treaty ..........................................................60 3.1.3.2. The succession to the Osimo Treaty.......................................................62 3.2. International standards of minority protection imposed on successor States of the SFRY after 1991 .......................................................................................................64 3.2.1. The first independence wave (1991-1992): the minority rights requirements of the EC 66 3.2.1.1. The EC Peace Conference on Yugoslavia...............................................67 3.2.1.2. The EC conditions of recognition of the post-Yugoslav States...............72 3.2.1.3. Opinions of the Badinter Commission on the fulfillment of the Guidelines CEU eTD Collection ..............................................................................................................74 3.2.2. Conflict settlement in Bosnia-Herzegovina: international standards of minority protection............................................................................................................... 78 3.2.2.1. The Vance-Owen Plan ...........................................................................78 3.2.2.2. The Dayton Agreement ..........................................................................80 iv 3.2.3. Reactions of the international community to the second wave of independence: the 2000s................................................................................................................ 84 3.2.3.1. The standards required as a reaction of the Kosovo crisis .......................84 3.2.3.2. The standards required with respect of the independence of Montenegro ...........................................................................................89 3.3. Conclusion ............................................................................................................90 Conclusions of the thesis.......................................................................................................93 Appendices...........................................................................................................................96 Bibliography.......................................................................................................................113 CEU eTD Collection v Introduction – Definition of the scope of the research Research question: a higher standard of minority protection in case of dissolution of States Given the lack of a consistent State practice, the relation between State succession and minority protection seems to be an uncertain area of public international law, as it has not yet worked out the rules governing the conduct of successor States “in respect of minority rights treaties“. There are no written rules on the questions whether the duties of minority protection – binding the predecessor State before – continue to be in force or they cease to exist, and the new State starts with a “clean slate” or whether the new States has any additional obligations vis-à-vis minorities. However, the dissolution wave after 1990 served as a decisive legal and doctrinal precedent. Among the independent States stemming from the dissolution wave of the 1990s, especially the dissolution of the Social Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (SFRY) provided as an instructive example for the strong connection between dissolution and the protection of minorities. That is the reason why the present thesis has chosen the case of the dissolution of the SFRY
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Memorial of the Republic of Croatia
    INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE CASE CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF THE CONVENTION ON THE PREVENTION AND PUNISHMENT OF THE CRIME OF GENOCIDE (CROATIA v. YUGOSLAVIA) MEMORIAL OF THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA APPENDICES VOLUME 5 1 MARCH 2001 II III Contents Page Appendix 1 Chronology of Events, 1980-2000 1 Appendix 2 Video Tape Transcript 37 Appendix 3 Hate Speech: The Stimulation of Serbian Discontent and Eventual Incitement to Commit Genocide 45 Appendix 4 Testimonies of the Actors (Books and Memoirs) 73 4.1 Veljko Kadijević: “As I see the disintegration – An Army without a State” 4.2 Stipe Mesić: “How Yugoslavia was Brought Down” 4.3 Borisav Jović: “Last Days of the SFRY (Excerpts from a Diary)” Appendix 5a Serb Paramilitary Groups Active in Croatia (1991-95) 119 5b The “21st Volunteer Commando Task Force” of the “RSK Army” 129 Appendix 6 Prison Camps 141 Appendix 7 Damage to Cultural Monuments on Croatian Territory 163 Appendix 8 Personal Continuity, 1991-2001 363 IV APPENDIX 1 CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS1 ABBREVIATIONS USED IN THE CHRONOLOGY BH Bosnia and Herzegovina CSCE Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe CK SKJ Centralni komitet Saveza komunista Jugoslavije (Central Committee of the League of Communists of Yugoslavia) EC European Community EU European Union FRY Federal Republic of Yugoslavia HDZ Hrvatska demokratska zajednica (Croatian Democratic Union) HV Hrvatska vojska (Croatian Army) IMF International Monetary Fund JNA Jugoslavenska narodna armija (Yugoslav People’s Army) NAM Non-Aligned Movement NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organisation
    [Show full text]
  • CG(21)12 18 October 2011
    The Congress of Local and Regional Authorities 21st SESSION CG(21)12 18 October 2011 Local and regional democracy in Slovenia Monitoring Committee Rapporteurs: Jos WIENEN, the Netherlands (L, EPP/CD1) and Merita JEGENI YILDIZ, Turkey (R, EPP/CD) Draft recommendation (for vote) ................................................................................................................2 Explanatory memorandum .........................................................................................................................5 Summary This report on the situation of local democracy in Slovenia follows upon a first monitoring visit conducted in 2001 and aims at assessing the action undertaken following the adoption of Recommendation 89(2001). The rapporteurs express satisfaction that local democracy in Slovenia complies with the provisions of the European Charter of Local Self-Government and provides options for citizen participation. The report takes note of the improvements as regards the distribution of shared state taxes, good practices concerning the integration of Roma minorities and the status of the capital city. It notes, however, that the consultation process between the local authorities and the central government has not improved, the fragmentation of municipalities remains an issue and the process of regionalisation is still blocked. This being said, a consensus between the political actors seems to have been reached on the necessity to set up regions in Slovenia. The Congress recommends that Slovenia increase the local
    [Show full text]
  • The Far Right in Slovenia
    MASARYK UNIVERSITY FACULTY OF SOCIAL STUDIES DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE The Far Right in Slovenia Master‟s thesis Bc. Lucie Chládková Supervisor: doc. JUDr. PhDr. Miroslav Mareš, Ph.D. UČO: 333105 Field of Study: Security and Strategic Studies Matriculation Year: 2012 Brno 2014 Declaration of authorship of the thesis Hereby I confirm that this master‟s thesis “The Far Right in Slovenia” is an outcome of my own elaboration and work and I used only sources here mentioned. Brno, 10 May 2014 ……………………………………… Lucie Chládková 2 Acknowledgments I would like to express my gratitude to doc. JUDr. PhDr. Miroslav Mareš, Ph.D., who supervised this thesis and contributed with a lot of valuable remarks and advice. I would like to also thank to all respondents from interviews for their help and information they shared with me. 3 Annotation This master‟s thesis deals with the far right in Slovenia after 1991 until today. The main aim of this case study is the description and analysis of far-right political parties, informal and formal organisations and subcultures. Special emphasis is put on the organisational structure of the far-right scene and on the ideological affiliation of individual far-right organisations. Keywords far right, Slovenia, political party, organisation, ideology, nationalism, extremism, Blood and Honour, patriotic, neo-Nazi, populism. 4 Contents 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 7 2. Methodology .........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Misli Marec April
    MAREC - APRIL 2019 http://www.glasslovenije.com.au Print post publication number 100004295 ŠTEVILKA - NUMBER 2 LETO - YEAR 68 Misli Thoughts PB 1 Misli Jezus na Federation Square marec - april 2019 v Melbournu? »Kaj dela Jezus na Federation Square sredi Melbourna?« je vprašal svojo staro mamo Tilko njen vnuk, ko je bil pri maši za pokojnim starim atom Valentinom sredi letošnjega februarja. Na 2. postaji križevega pota je namreč prepoznal Jezusa na VSEBINA Federation Square v Melbournu. Kako je Jezus prišel tja? 3 Jezus na Federation Square Zanimivo vprašanje in kakšen je odgovor? Kako bi mu odgovorili? v Melbournu? 5 Dve materi Na 2. postno nedeljo, 12. marca 2019, smo imeli 7 Nedelja v Kew kot uvod v sveto mašo pobožnost križevega 8 Božji grob pota, kot imamo to redno v postnem času. Spet 9 ‘Velikonočni pirhi’ smo se pomikali od prve do petnajste postaje Cilke Žagar podob križevega pota, ki ga je leta 2013 naslikala 13 Svetovni dan molitve umetnica, cerkvena pevka v Kew, Zorka Černjak. World Day of Prayer 2019 Zapojva Nedelji Vstajenja! Zorka je vse te postaje Jezusovega križevega pota postavila v naše mesto, v znamenitosti Viktorije; v 19 Slovenska inovativnost p. Vladimir Kos DJ, Tokyo naš čas in prostor, zato mi ni bilo težko ob njenih v Avstraliji Oj, harfa, zapojva Nedelji Vstajenja! podobah iskati odgovor na gornje vprašanje. Tukaj 20 Izpod Triglava Vse najine pesmi so v zarji domá, in sedaj Jezus sprejema in nosi svoj križ in naše 24 Iz Kraljičine dežele ki zmeraj ta dan iz noči se razpenja križe življenja. Tukaj se dogaja življenje; tukaj 27 Iz Kluba Triglav Mounties čez vsako morjé tja v prerije neba.
    [Show full text]
  • Asamblea General Distr
    Naciones Unidas A/HRC/18/33/Add.2 Asamblea General Distr. general 4 de julio de 2011 Español Original: inglés Consejo de Derechos Humanos 18º período de sesiones Tema 3 del programa Promoción y protección de todos los derechos humanos, civiles, políticos, económicos, sociales y culturales, incluido el derecho al desarrollo Informe de la Relatora Especial sobre el derecho humano al agua potable y el saneamiento, Catarina de Albuquerque* Adición Misión a Eslovenia** Resumen Del 24 al 28 de mayo de 2010, la Experta independiente sobre la cuestión de las obligaciones de derechos humanos relacionadas con el acceso al agua potable y el saneamiento llevó a cabo una misión en Eslovenia. El objetivo de la misión era evaluar de qué manera el Estado estaba haciendo efectivo el derecho al agua y al saneamiento. En el presente informe la titular del mandato observa que hay un acceso casi universal al agua y al saneamiento en Eslovenia. Asimismo expresa especial preocupación por el acceso de la población romaní al agua potable y al saneamiento. Al final del informe se formulan algunas conclusiones y recomendaciones. * En todo el presente informe se hace referencia a la Experta independiente sobre la cuestión de las obligaciones de derechos humanos relacionadas con el acceso al agua potable y el saneamiento, que era el título del mandato en el momento de llevarse a cabo la misión. De conformidad con la resolución 16/2 del Consejo de Derechos Humanos, dicho título se cambió por el de Relatora Especial sobre el derecho humano al agua potable y el saneamiento. ** El resumen del presente informe se distribuye en todos los idiomas oficiales.
    [Show full text]
  • Slovenia's Transition
    SLOVENIA’S TRANSITION SLOVENIA’S TRANSITION CONTENts PREFACE vii 1 BEFORE THE NATION STATE (SIXTH CENTURY TO 1991) 1 2 TRANSITION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN SLOVENIA: THE FIRst DECADE OF INDEPENDENCE 25 3 THE TRANSFORMATION OF INSTITUTIONS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF CORPORATISM IN SLOVENIA 43 4 MONETARY AND EXCHANGE RATE POLICY DURING SLOVENIA’S TRANSITION 59 5 LABOR AND THE TRANSITION PART I: UNIONS AND THE EVOLUTION OF A NEW INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS 77 6 LABOR AND THE TRANSITION PART II 109 7 THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF THE SLOVENIAN TRANSITION: 1945–2004 145 8 POLITICAL CHANGE AND FISCAL POLICY: THE ROLE OF THE BUDGET IN THE SLOVENIAN TRANSITION 161 9 SLOVENIA AND THE EU: THE ACCESSION 169 AFTERWORD: SLOVENIA IN THE EU 185 REFERENCES 207 INDEX 213 ON THE AUTHORS 215 v PREFACE When I first arrived in 1986 in Ljubljana, Slovenia, at that time still a republic of the Yugoslav Federation, I was on a research sabbatical studying regional devel- opment policy under the country’s unique system of self-management. On this first of what became annual visits for over two decades, I managed to tour most of the country and meet with economic planners and researchers in many of the republics of the federation. My office, however, was located in the Centre for the Theory and Practice of Yugoslav Self-Management, Edvard Kardelj, a research institution that was associated with the Faculty of Social Science of the Univer- sity of Ljubljana. It was there that I met up with Bogomil Ferfila, a professor of political science at the faculty.
    [Show full text]
  • Egovernment in Slovenia
    Country Profile History Strategy Legal Framework Actors Who’s Who Infrastructure Services for Citizens Services for Businesses INSIDE WHAT’S eGovernment in Slovenia ISA Visit the e-Government factsheets online on Joinup.eu Joinup is a collaborative platform created by the European Commission under the ISA programme. ISA supports the modernization of Public administrations in Europe through the development of interoperable services, frameworks and tools. Joinup provides numerous services around 3 main functionalities: 1. An observatory on interoperability, e-government, e-inclusion and e-health 2. A collaborative platform of open communities 3. A repository of interoperability solutions This document is meant to present an overview of the eGoverment status in this country and not to be exhaustive in its references and analysis. Even though every possible care has been taken by the authors to refer to and use valid data from authentic sources, the European Commission does not guarantee the accuracy of the included information, nor does it accept any responsibility for any use thereof. Cover picture © Fotolia Content © European Commission © European Union, 2015 Reuse is authorised, provided the source is acknowledged. eGovernment in Slovenia, February 2016, Edition 19.0 Country Profile ...................................................................................................... 1 eGovernment History ............................................................................................ 7 eGovernment Strategy .......................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Darko Silovic (Šiloviæ) Introduction
    Darko Silovic (Šiloviæ)* Darko Silovic was a career diplomat of former Yugoslavia and its last Permanent Representative and Ambassador to the United Nations in New York (1990 - early 1992). He relinquished this post in protest to policies that led to conflicts and wars, immediately following the launching of the first UN Peace-keeping operation to Croatia, in which he played an important role. Following that he worked at the UN, in the Department of Humanitarian Affairs (today’s OCHA) in New York, as well as in the field, with the Departments of Political Affairs and for Peace Keeping Operations, as Zone Director in Somalia (UNOSOM II) and as Deputy Special Representative of the Secretary General and Head of the UN Mission of Observers in Tajikistan (UNMOT). He has since been teaching, writing and consulting and today lives between New York and Croatia. HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT REGIONAL STUDY ON HUMAN DEVELOPMENT AND HUMAN RIGHTS IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Submitted 15 November 1999 Introduction The twentieth century has been mostly characterized by technological advances and the globalization of the world markets. Besides that, and to a certain extent, because of that, the main feature of the end of this century is the advances made in democracy across the world. The achievement of human rights in many parts of the world and, even more, the awareness of their importance and central place for human development, political stability and good governance is certainly a breakthrough that has marked the last decade or two. * The author gratefully acknowledges his research assistant, Irina Alexeevna Sinelina of the New School for her invaluable aid.
    [Show full text]
  • Slovakia and Slovenia 1989-1998
    THE ROLE OF NATIONALISM IN TIIE DEMOCRATISATION PROCESS: SLOVAKIA AND SLOVENIA 1989-1998 Erika Harris Submitted in accordance with the requirements of degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Leeds Institute for Politics and International Studies May 2000 The candidate confirms that the work submitted is her own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to work of others ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to express my gratitude to the numerous individuals who supported the development of this thesis and made the experience much more pleasurable than it would have been otherwise. I wish to thank in particular my supervisors, Prof. David Beetham and Dr. John Schwarzmantel for their unreserved support. This thesis would not have been possible without their encouragement, their always helpful advice and their knowledge which they so generously shared with me. I extend a note of thanks to the Economic and Social Research Council for their funding and to the Department of Politics at the University of Leeds for giving me an opportunity to teach which proved an enriching experience. My appreciation also goes to the academic and library staff at the University of Ljubljana who have helped me with my research. I wish to thank Prof. Rudi Rizman for making my research visits to Ljubljana easier and for his interest in my work and to Alenka Krasovec for showing me the beautiful countryside of Slovenia. I wish to pay a special tribute to the Institute of Philosophy at the Slovak Academy ot Science in Bratislava, for funding a part of my research visit, with the help of the British Council.
    [Show full text]
  • A to J.Title.Page
    Handbook on Access to Justice under the Aarhus Convention Handbook on Access to Justice under the Aarhus Convention THE REGIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER FOR CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE (REC) is a non-partisan, non-advocacy, not-for-profit organisation with a mission to assist in solving environmental problems in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE). The Center fulfils this mission by encouraging cooperation among non-governmental organisations, governments, businesses and other environmental stakeholders, by supporting the free exchange of information and by promoting public participation in environmental decision-making. The REC was established in 1990 by the United States, the European Commission and Hungary. Today, the REC is legally based on a Charter signed by the governments of 27 countries and the European Commission, and on an International Agreement with the Government of Hungary. The REC has its headquarters in Szentendre, Hungary, and local offices in each of its 15 beneficiary CEE countries which are: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, FYR Macedonia, Poland, Romania, Serbia and Montenegro, Slovakia and Slovenia. Recent donors are the European Commission and the governments of Albania, Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Canada, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland, Serbia and Montenegro, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States, as well as other
    [Show full text]
  • Slovene Language Status Planning
    SLOVENE LANGUAGE STATUS PLANNING Albina Nećak Lük* “…the study of language policy should not be limited to formal, declared and official policies but rather to the study of powerful mechanisms that are used in most societies nowadays to create and perpetuate ‘de facto’ language policies and practices.”1 Abstract This paper deals with the most significant aspects of language policy in Slovenia. Although language policy strategy is a wide-ranging endeavour in which relationships among individual languages in a linguistically diverse society are regulated, for operational reasons this paper concentrates on activities related to Slovene (i.e. the state, official and national language) and only touches on the basic language policy measures for minority languages in the Republic of Slovenia in order to round off the sociolinguistic picture of the country. It should be noted that the huge amount of documents related to language legislation makes thorough analysis impossible in such a short text and therefore only the most relevant legal material is presented. Keywords: language policy, status planning, legislation, Slovenia. PLANIFICACIÓ DE LA SITUACIÓ DE LA LLENGUA ESLOVENA Resum En aquest article es tracten els aspectes més significatius de la política lingüística d’Eslovènia. Malgrat que l’estratègia de la política lingüística és una empresa d’ampli abast en què es regulen les relacions entre les llengües d’una societat lingüísticament diversa, per motius operatius aquest article es concentra en les activitats relacionades amb l’eslovè (per exemple, l’estat, llengua oficial i nacional) i només esmenta de passada les mesures bàsiques de la política lingüís- tica per a les llengües minoritàries de la República d’Eslovènia amb l’objectiu de completar la imatge sociolingüística del país.
    [Show full text]
  • Executive Powers in Relations with the Parliament. Part I O
    AGORA International Journal of Juridical Sciences, http://univagora.ro/jour/index.php/aijjs ISSN 1843-570X, E-ISSN 2067-7677 No. 4 (2015), pp. 69-77 EXECUTIVE POWERS IN RELATIONS WITH THE PARLIAMENT. PART I O. ŞARAMET Oana Şaramet Faculty of Law, Department of Law Transilvania University of Braşov, Braşov, Romania *Correspondence: Oana Şaramet, Transilvania University of Braşov, Eroilor Boulevard no.25, Braşov, România E-mail: [email protected] Abstract: By art. 1 para. (4), Romanian Constitution, republished, enshrined the principle of separation and balance of powers. Therefore, this principle implies the existence of collaboration but also of a mutual control between these powers, including between the legislative and executive power, thus being expressed the balance between these two powers. By constitutional established powers, the two central authorities of the executive power - the President of Romania and the Government - will participate at the observance and application of this principle, including by those duties they perform in their relations with the legislative power. Keywords: head of state, legislative power, convening, dissolution, messages, promulgation Introduction Based on the constitutional provisions in force, we can identify two functions of the Romanian executive, namely the executive one and the administrative one. In our view, the determination of the powers which enable fulfilling these functions it is possible by reporting to the executive structures and, therefore, the specific functions of each of them. Motivation of this allegation is that the powers enshrined in the constitution and laws in the task of these structures, in fact represents their competence, namely of the head of state - the president or monarch, and of the government.
    [Show full text]