DOCSLIB.ORG

Framing the Net - How Discourse Shapes Law and Culture

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Framing the Net - How Discourse Shapes Law and Culture Framing the Net - How Discourse Shapes Law and Culture PhD dissertation submitted at Roskilde University Department of Communication, Business and Information Technologies September 2011, Copenhagen By Rikke Frank Jørgensen 2 Acknowledgments .................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Danish Summary ..................................................................................................................................................................... 8 List of Key Research Notions................................................................................................................................................ 10 List of Abbreviations ............................................................................................................................................................. 12 1. MOTIVATION AND RESEARCH AIM ................................................................................ 14 2. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY .......................................................................................... 16 Research Design ................................................................................................................................................................. 16 Philosophical Foundation ................................................................................................................................................... 18 The Notion of Metaphors .................................................................................................................................................... 20 Construction of Research Metaphors .................................................................................................................................. 21 My Role in Internet Policy .................................................................................................................................................. 23 Case Studies ........................................................................................................................................................................ 24 Selection of Cases ............................................................................................................................................................... 26 Data Collection and Analysis.............................................................................................................................................. 27 Uganda Case Study ............................................................................................................................................................. 29 Wikipedia Case Study ......................................................................................................................................................... 30 3. THE INFORMATION SOCIETY .......................................................................................... 32 The Notion of an Information Society ................................................................................................................................ 32 Redistribution of Power ...................................................................................................................................................... 34 Modernity and Complexity ................................................................................................................................................. 36 Social Systems .................................................................................................................................................................... 37 The Role of Communication ............................................................................................................................................... 38 Internet as a Hypercomplex Structural Match .................................................................................................................... 39 4. HUMAN RIGHTS AND ICT POLICY .................................................................................. 41 Human Rights Basics .......................................................................................................................................................... 41 A Civil Society Perspective ................................................................................................................................................ 45 An Institutional Perspective ................................................................................................................................................ 51 A Business Perspective ....................................................................................................................................................... 58 A Research Perspective ...................................................................................................................................................... 60 The Impact of Human Rights on Global ICT Policy .......................................................................................................... 62 5. THEORIZING PUBLIC AND PRIVATE .............................................................................. 64 The Notion of Public and Private ........................................................................................................................................ 64 Public and Private Law ....................................................................................................................................................... 65 Public and Private as Different Domains of Society ........................................................................................................... 66 Public and Private as a Status Ascribed to Activities or Information ................................................................................. 70 Public and Private – From a Human Rights Perspective .................................................................................................... 73 3 6. FRAMING THE NET ........................................................................................................... 79 Introduction......................................................................................................................................................................... 79 Net as Infrastructure ............................................................................................................................................................. 80 From Military Research to Public Infrastructure ................................................................................................................ 81 Summing up on the Conceptualization of the Net as Infrastructure ................................................................................... 83 Policy Issues Related to the Infrastructure Framing ........................................................................................................... 84 Net as Public Sphere .............................................................................................................................................................. 93 The Notion of a Public Sphere ............................................................................................................................................ 94 Internet as Public Sphere .................................................................................................................................................... 97 Multiple Publics ................................................................................................................................................................ 100 Decentered Political Authority ......................................................................................................................................... 101 Public Sphere as Public Life ............................................................................................................................................. 102 Summing up on the Conceptualization of the Net as Public Sphere ................................................................................. 102 Policy Issues related to the Public Sphere Framing .......................................................................................................... 103 Net as Media ......................................................................................................................................................................... 116 The Concept of Media ...................................................................................................................................................... 117 Media Theory .................................................................................................................................................................... 117 Internet as a New Media ................................................................................................................................................... 118 Media and Publicness ....................................................................................................................................................... 120 Summing up on the Conceptualization of the Net as Media ............................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Army Acquisition Workforce Dependency on E-Mail for Formal
    ARMY ACQUISITION WORKFORCE DEPENDENCY ON E-MAIL FOR FORMAL WORK COORDINATION: FINDINGS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR WORKFORCE PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT THROUGH E-MAIL-BASED SOCIAL NETWORK ANALYSIS KENNETH A. LORENTZEN May 2013 PUBLISHED BY THE DEFENSE ACQUISITION UNIVERSITY PRESS PROJECT ADVISOR: BOB SKERTIC CAPITAL AND NORTHEAST REGION, DAU THE SENIOR SERVICE COLLEGE FELLOWSHIP PROGRAM ABERDEEN PROVING GROUND, MD PAGE LEFT BLANK INTENTIONALLY .ARMY ACQUISITION WORKFORCE DEPENDENCY ON E-MAIL FOR FORMAL WORK COORDINATION: FINDINGS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR WORKFORCE PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT THROUGH E-MAIL-BASED SOCIAL NETWORK ANALYSIS KENNETH A. LORENTZEN May 2013 PUBLISHED BY THE DEFENSE ACQUISITION UNIVERSITY PRESS PROJECT ADVISOR: BOB SKERTIC CAPITAL AND NORTHEAST REGION, DAU THE SENIOR SERVICE COLLEGE FELLOWSHIP PROGRAM ABERDEEN PROVING GROUND, MD PAGE LEFT BLANK INTENTIONALLY ii Table of Contents Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................ ii List of Figures ................................................................................................................................ vi Abstract ......................................................................................................................................... vii Chapter 1—Introduction ................................................................................................................. 1 Background and Motivation .................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Individuals' Attachment to Social Networking Sites
    Understanding Individuals’ Attachment to Social Networking Sites: An Empirical Investigation of Three Theories by Eric T. K. Lim M.Sc. (Information Systems), National University of Singapore, 2007 B.Comm. (Hons.), Nanyang Technological University, 2003 Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Segal Graduate School Beedie School of Business Eric T. K. Lim 2013 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Spring 2013 Approval Name: Eric T. K. Lim Degree: Doctor of Philosophy (Business Administration) Title of Thesis: Understanding Individuals’ Attachment to Social Networking Sites: An Empirical Investigation of Three Theories Examining Committee: Chair: Dr. Tom Lawrence Professor, Academic Director, PhD Program Dr. Dianne Cyr Senior Supervisor Professor Dr. Andrew Gemino Co-Supervisor Professor Dr. Leyland Pitt Internal Examiner Professor Dr. Matthew Lee External Examiner Chair Professor Department of Information Systems College of Business City University of Hong Kong Date Defended/Approved: March 27, 2013 ii Partial Copyright Licence iii Ethics Statement iv Abstract Social Networking Sites (SNSs) are a pervasive phenomenon in today’s society. With greater connectivity and interactivity enabled via web technologies, SNSs provide communication platforms for individuals to bridge geographical and temporal differences when making friends, sharing experiences, socializing with others and much more. This thesis therefore endeavors to shed light on this problem by decomposing members’ motives for participating within SNSs into identity-based, bond-based and comparison- based attachments. Each of these forms of attachment in turn affects members’ cooperative and competitive mentality towards participation within SNSs. In addition, it is further posited in this thesis that members’ identity-based, bond-based and comparison- based attachment within SNSs can be induced through the presence of deindividuation, personalization and tournament technologies respectively.
    [Show full text]
  • Internet Hall of Fame Announces 2013 Inductees
    Internet Hall of Fame Announces 2013 Inductees Influential engineers, activists, and entrepreneurs changed history through their vision and determination Ceremony to be held 3 August in Berlin, Germany [Washington, D.C. and Geneva, Switzerland -- 26 June 2013] The Internet Society today announced the names of the 32 individuals who have been selected for induction into the Internet Hall of Fame. Honored for their groundbreaking contributions to the global Internet, this year’s inductees comprise some of the world’s most influential engineers, activists, innovators, and entrepreneurs. The Internet Hall of Fame celebrates Internet visionaries, innovators, and leaders from around the world who believed in the design and potential of an open Internet and, through their work, helped change the way we live and work today. The 2013 Internet Hall of Fame inductees are: Pioneers Circle – Recognizing individuals who were instrumental in the early design and development of the Internet: David Clark, David Farber, Howard Frank, Kanchana Kanchanasut, J.C.R. Licklider (posthumous), Bob Metcalfe, Jun Murai, Kees Neggers, Nii Narku Quaynor, Glenn Ricart, Robert Taylor, Stephen Wolff, Werner Zorn Innovators – Recognizing individuals who made outstanding technological, commercial, or policy advances and helped to expand the Internet’s reach: Marc Andreessen, John Perry Barlow, Anne-Marie Eklund Löwinder, François Flückiger, Stephen Kent, Henning Schulzrinne, Richard Stallman, Aaron Swartz (posthumous), Jimmy Wales Global Connectors – Recognizing individuals from around the world who have made significant contributions to the global growth and use of the Internet: Karen Banks, Gihan Dias, Anriette Esterhuysen, Steven Goldstein, Teus Hagen, Ida Holz, Qiheng Hu, Haruhisa Ishida (posthumous), Barry Leiner (posthumous), George Sadowsky “This year’s inductees represent a group of people as diverse and dynamic as the Internet itself,” noted Internet Society President and CEO Lynn St.
    [Show full text]
  • Quarterly Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector
    Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly http://nvs.sagepub.com/ A Network Perspective on State-Society Synergy to Increase Community-Level Social Capital Danielle M. Varda Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 2011 40: 896 originally published online 6 August 2010 DOI: 10.1177/0899764010378171 The online version of this article can be found at: http://nvs.sagepub.com/content/40/5/896 Published by: http://www.sagepublications.com On behalf of: Association for Research on Nonprofit Organizations and Voluntary Action Additional services and information for Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly can be found at: Email Alerts: http://nvs.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Subscriptions: http://nvs.sagepub.com/subscriptions Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav Citations: http://nvs.sagepub.com/content/40/5/896.refs.html Downloaded from nvs.sagepub.com at UNIV OF COLORADO LIBRARY on September 22, 2011 >> Version of Record - Sep 14, 2011 Proof - Aug 6, 2010 What is This? Downloaded from nvs.sagepub.com at UNIV OF COLORADO LIBRARY on September 22, 2011 Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 40(5) 896 –923 A Network Perspective © The Author(s) 2011 Reprints and permission: http://www. on State-Society Synergy sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/0899764010378171 to Increase Community- http://nvsq.sagepub.com Level Social Capital Danielle M. Varda1 Abstract “Can state–society synergy be created in the short run, or does it require historically deep institutional and normative foundations?” In other words, what role can an outside party—such as a government or state actor—play in constructing social capital when it is not a permanent fixture of the existing interrelationships within a community? Taking a network perspective, this exploratory research examines community-level social capital outcomes of a government-led intervention.
    [Show full text]
  • YOUTH PROGRAMS AS BUILDERS of SOCIAL CAPITAL Community Development to Help Us Better Understand How the Two Are Interconnected
    Through the lens of social capital, service-learning takes on greater meaning for rural youth, adults, and communities. 5 A community development approach to service-learning: Building social capital between rural youth and adults Steven A. Henness, Anna L. Ball, MaryJo Moncheski social capital brings something new to youth and community development perspectives that has not yet been fully explained by other approaches. By shifting the focus from the individual to the community, social capital allows us to better understand the broad public value of education and youth programs. Because social capi- tal is not age specifi c, it provides insights into cross-generational networks and connections that support building more inclusive communities. Social capital can help explain why some youth are more likely to get by or get ahead, why some adults are more effec- tive within leadership roles or professions, and why some commu- nities are better able to address poverty, bounce back from natural disasters, or seize new economic opportunities. In these ways, social capital can be a bridge between youth development and The opinions, fi ndings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily refl ect the view of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. NEW DIRECTIONS FOR YOUTH DEVELOPMENT, NO. 138, SUMMER 2013 © WILEY PERIODICALS, INC. Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com) • DOI: 10.1002/yd.20059 75 76 YOUTH PROGRAMS AS BUILDERS OF SOCIAL CAPITAL community development to help us better understand how the two are interconnected. Using 4-H and FFA case study fi ndings, we explore how com- munity service-learning supports the building of social capital between rural youth and adults and the positive effects this has on community viability.
    [Show full text]
  • How Innovation Works a Bright Future Not All Innovation Is Speeding up the Innovation Famine China’S Innovation Engine Regaining Momentum
    Dedication For Felicity Bryan Contents Cover Title Page Dedication Introduction: The Infinite Improbability Drive 1. Energy Of heat, work and light What Watt wrought Thomas Edison and the invention business The ubiquitous turbine Nuclear power and the phenomenon of disinnovation Shale gas surprise The reign of fire 2. Public health Lady Mary’s dangerous obsession Pasteur’s chickens The chlorine gamble that paid off How Pearl and Grace never put a foot wrong Fleming’s luck The pursuit of polio Mud huts and malaria Tobacco and harm reduction 3. Transport The locomotive and its line Turning the screw Internal combustion’s comeback The tragedy and triumph of diesel The Wright stuff International rivalry and the jet engine Innovation in safety and cost 4. Food The tasty tuber How fertilizer fed the world Dwarfing genes from Japan Insect nemesis Gene editing gets crisper Land sparing versus land sharing 5. Low-technology innovation When numbers were new The water trap Crinkly tin conquers the Empire The container that changed trade Was wheeled baggage late? Novelty at the table The rise of the sharing economy 6. Communication and computing The first death of distance The miracle of wireless Who invented the computer? The ever-shrinking transistor The surprise of search engines and social media Machines that learn 7. Prehistoric innovation The first farmers The invention of the dog The (Stone Age) great leap forward The feast made possible by fire The ultimate innovation: life itself 8. Innovation’s essentials Innovation is gradual Innovation is different from invention Innovation is often serendipitous Innovation is recombinant Innovation involves trial and error Innovation is a team sport Innovation is inexorable Innovation’s hype cycle Innovation prefers fragmented governance Innovation increasingly means using fewer resources rather than more 9.
    [Show full text]
  • Antonio Tajani MEP President of the European Parliament [email protected]
    Antonio Tajani MEP President of the European Parliament [email protected] 12 June 2018 Mr President, Article 13 of the EU Copyright Directive Threatens the Internet As a group of the Internet’s original architects and pioneers and their successors, we write to you as a matter of urgency about an imminent threat to the future of this global network. The European Commission’s proposal for Article 13 of the proposed Directive for Copyright in the Digital Single Market Directive was well-intended. As creators ourselves, we share the concern that there should be a fair distribution of revenues from the online use of copyright works, that benefits creators, publishers, and platforms alike. But Article 13 is not the right way to achieve this. By requiring Internet platforms to perform automatic filtering all of the content that their users upload, Article 13 takes an unprecedented step towards the transformation of the Internet from an open platform for sharing and innovation, into a tool for the automated surveillance and control of its users. Europe has been served well by the balanced liability model established under the Ecommerce Directive, under which those who upload content to the Internet bear the principal responsibility for its legality, while platforms are responsible to take action to remove such content once its illegality has been brought to their attention. By inverting this liability model and essentially making platforms directly responsible for ensuring the legality of content in the first instance, the business models and investments of platforms large and small will be impacted. The damage that this may do to the free and open Internet as we know it is hard to predict, but in our opinions could be substantial.
    [Show full text]
  • Final List of Participants
    Final list of participants 1) States and European Community 2) Entities and intergovernmental organizations having received a Standing invitation from the United Nations General Assembly 3) United Nations Secretariat and Organs 4) United Nations Specialized Agencies 5) Associate Members of Regional Commissions 6) Other invited intergovernmental organizations 7) Non governmental organizations (NGOs) and civil society organizations 8) Business Sector Entities 1) STATES AND EUROPEAN COMMUNITY Afghanistan Representatives: H.E. Mr Mohammad M. STANEKZAI, Ministre des Communications, Afghanistan, [email protected] H.E. Mr Shamsuzzakir KAZEMI, Ambassadeur, Representant permanent, Mission permanente de l'Afghanistan, [email protected] Mr Abdelouaheb LAKHAL, Representative, Delegation of Afghanistan Mr Fawad Ahmad MUSLIM, Directeur de la technologie, Ministère des affaires étrangères, [email protected] Mr Mohammad H. PAYMAN, Président, Département de la planification, Ministère des communications, [email protected] Mr Ghulam Seddiq RASULI, Deuxième secrétaire, Mission permanente de l'Afghanistan, [email protected] Albania Representatives: Mr Vladimir THANATI, Ambassador, Permanent Mission of Albania, [email protected] Ms Pranvera GOXHI, First Secretary, Permanent Mission of Albania, [email protected] Mr Lulzim ISA, Driver, Mission Permanente d'Albanie, [email protected] Algeria Representatives: H.E. Mr Amar TOU, Ministre, Ministère de la poste et des technologies
    [Show full text]
  • Platform Power
    PLATFORM POWER Secrets of billion-dollar internet startups Sangeet Paul Choudary Based on the blog Platform Thinking (http://platformed.info) © 2013 Sangeet Paul Choudary All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law. For all queries, please email, [email protected] Introduction Credits: Fran Simo Creative Commons As internet startups, we often believe that we are in the business Airbnb enables hosts and travelers to interact and engage in of building technology. The essays in this book set out to debunk commerce. that view. Instagram enables photo creators to show off and discuss their Several monikers and catch-phrases have been used to creations with photo viewers. characterize trends in recent times. Web2.0, Crowdsourcing, These are all examples of platform business models connecting Collaborative Consumption, Sharing Economy, App Economy, producer and consumer roles and allowing them to interact with Gamification are some of the terms that come to mind. Observed each other. closely, there are three common threads that underlie all of these trends: The essays in this book aim at explaining the importance of these models, why these models are emerging at this point in time and 1) The focus on the user as someone who does work why they will be the dominant model for business in a networked 2) The notion of value created in an external ecosystem of users world.
    [Show full text]
  • IJAGR Editorial Board Editor-In-Chief: Donald Patrick Albert (Geo [email protected]), Sam Houston State U
    IJAGR Editorial Board Editor-in-Chief: Donald Patrick Albert ([email protected]), Sam Houston State U. USA Associate Editors: Jonathan Comer, Oklahoma State U., USA Thomas Crawford, East Carolina U., USA G. Rebecca Dobbs, Western Carolina U., USA Sonya Glavac, U. of New England, Australia Carol Hanchette, U. of Louisville, USA Tony Hernandez, Ryerson U., Canada Jay Lee, Kent State U., USA Shuaib Lwasa, Makerere U., Uganda John Strait, Sam Houston State U., USA David Wong, George Mason U., USA International Editorial Review Board: Bhuiyan M. Alam, The U. of Toledo, USA David Martin, U. of Southhampton, UK Badri Basnet, The U. of Southern Queensland, Australia Luke Marzen, Auburn U., USA Rick Bunch, U. of North Carolina - Greensboro, USA Adam Mathews, Texas State U., USA Ed Cloutis, U. of Winnipeg, Canada Darrel McDonald, Stephen F. Austin State U., USA Kelley Crews, U. of Texas at Austin, USA Ian Meiklejohn, Rhodes U., South Africa Michael DeMers, New Mexico State U., USA Joseph Messina, Michigan State U., USA Sagar Deshpande, Ferris State U., USA William A. Morris, McMaster U., Canada Steven Fleming, United States Military Academy, USA Petri Pellikka, U. of Helsinki, Finland Doug Gamble, U. of North Carolina - Wilmington, USA François Pinet, Cemagref - Clermont Ferrand, France Gang Gong, Sam Houston State U., USA Wei Song, U. of Louisville, USA Carlos Granell, European Commission, Italy Sermin Tagil, Balikesir U., Turkey William Graves, U. of North Carolina - Charlotte, USA Wei Tu, Georgia Southern U., USA Timothy Hawthorne, Georgia State U., USA Brad Watkins, U. of Central Oklahoma, USA Bin Jiang, U. of Gävle, Sweden Dion Wiseman, Brandon U., Canada C.
    [Show full text]
  • Intelligent Social Network
    Intelligent Social Network Sandeep Kumar Sood Computer Science & Engineering Guru Nanak Dev University, India 1 Introduction During the past forty years, we have witnessed the realization of many of early researchers’ visions. We have seen computer system shrink in size and cost by several orders of magnitude. We have seen memories increase in storage capacity to the point where they match up with human brain’s storage capacity. We have seen the speed and reliability of system improve significantly. Similarly, Intelligent Social Network is one of the vision setup by the researchers for future. Social network is a communication means for likeminded individuals or organizations. When the information exchanged among different people is analysed to draw intelligence, it is referred as Intelligent Social Network. Different mathematical tools and software are designed and developed for Intelligent Social Network. Intelligent Social Network is a system of artificial intelligence to store large amount of information and process it at very high speeds which could emulate most of human abilities and capabilities. Intelligent Social Network is used to identify, represent, analyse, visualize or simulate nodes (e.g. agents, organizations, knowledge). It is a network analysis tool (software) that allow researchers to investigate representations of networks of different size ranging from small (e.g. families, project teams) to very large (e.g. Internet, disease transmission). Such kinds of tools provide mathematical and statistical routines that can be applied to the network model to draw intelligence. It is used for the visual representations of social networks that help to understand network data and analyse it according to the requirements.
    [Show full text]
  • Music As a Global Resource: Solutions for Social and Economic Issues Compendium - Third Edition
    Music as a Global Resource: Solutions for Social and Economic Issues Compendium - Third Edition Age of Connectivity: Cities, Magnets of Hope A Contribution in Support of the Millennium Development Goals, Habitat Agenda and the United Nations Sixth World Urban Forum, “The Urban Future” Fall 2011 United Nations Headquarters United Nations ICCC MUSIC AS A GLOBAL RESOURCE: Solutions for Social and Economic Issues Compendium, Third Edition EDITORS Professor Barbara Hesser New York University Dr. Harry N. Heinemann International Council for Caring Communities ASSOCIATE EDITORS Dr. Cathy Benedict Florida International University Dr. Peter Jampel New York University Dr. Patrick Schmidt Westminster College of the Arts-Princeton University Professor Roslyn Snow St. Johns University, Retired UNITED NATIONS HEADQUARTERS NEW YORK, FALL 2011 World Survey of Music Projects EUROPE Bosnia and Herzegovina Finland Germany Greece ASIA Ireland Afghanistan Italy THE AMERICAS China Kosovo Argentina India Norway Brazil Indonesia Spain Canada Japan United Kingdom Chile MIDDLE EAST Nepal Colombia Iraq Pakistan Costa Rica Israel Singapore Haiti Jordan Thailand Ecuador Lebanon Jamaica Occupied Palestinian Territory Mexico St. Lucia AFRICA United States of America Botswana Non-Autonomous Territory Ghana Puerto Rico Guinea Rwanda OCEANIA Sierra Leone Australia South Africa New Zealand Uganda TABLE OF CONTENTS Dedication…………………………………………………………………………………………. I Acknowledgements……………………………………………………………………………… III Introductory Statements H.E. Josephine Ojiambo……………………………………………………………………….
    [Show full text]