This Front Matter is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Law at Via Sapientiae. It has been accepted for inclusion in DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law by an authorized editor of Via Sapientiae. For more information, please contact [email protected]. et al.: Table of Contents DEPAUL JOURNAL OF ART, TECHNOLOGY & INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW Volume XXVII Spring 2017 Number 2

LEAD ARTICLE

Reading Jane Austen through the Lens of the Law: Legal Issues in Austen's Life and Novels ...... Maureen B. Collins 115

BRIEF

National Cultural Heritage Law Moot Court Competition Best Brief 2017 ...... Holden Benon, Nicholas Keats, Andrea Swanson 167

CASE NOTES AND COMMENTS

"It's Dead Jim!" - Fair Use in Fanworks Without Precedent ...... Morgan Drake 199

VMG Salsoul, LLC v. Ciccone, 824 F.3d 871 (9th Cir. 2016) ...... Victoria Campbell 231

CASE SUMMARIES

Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., Inc., 136 S. Ct. 1923 (2016) ...... Subarna Bhattacharya 255

Foster v. Svenson, 128 A.D.3d 150 (2015) ...... Mary Bessone 271

Samsung Electronics Co. v. Apple Inc., 137 S. Ct. 429 (2016) ...... Thomas DaMario 285

LEGISLATIVE UPDATE

Daily Fantasy Sports and the Clash of Internet Gambling Regulation ...... Joshua Shancer 295

Published by Via Sapientiae, 2019 1 DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 2 [2019], Art. 1

DePaulJournal ofArt, Technology & IntellectualProperty Law is published semi-annually for $40.00 per year by DePaul College of Law, 25 East Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois, 60604-2287. Second-class postage paid at Chicago, Illinois 60604-2287 and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send change of address notice to DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, 25 East Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois, 60604-2287.

Cite as 27 DEPAUL J. ART, TECH. & INTELL. PROP. L.

Price: $40.00 annual subscription; $20.00 single issue. Subscriptions are accepted only on a per volume basis, are payable in advance and will be renewed automatically unless notification to the contrary is received in writing. Change of address should be mailed to the Journal at least thirty days before the next issue is to be distributed. Please send the old and new address, including ZIP codes. Rates for advertising quoted upon request.

The Journal invites the submission of unsolicited manuscripts. Please confine the author's name and biographical information to a removable title page. Citations should conform to the Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation (20th ed. 2015) by The Columbia Law Review, the HarvardLaw Review, the University of Pennsylvania Law Review, and the Yale Law Journal. Send manuscripts to DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, 25 East Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois 60604. Manuscripts will not be returned unless specifically requested and accompanied with proper return postage. Comments and suggestions regarding the content of this publication are invited.

DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law DePaul University College of Law 25 East Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois 60604-2287

E-mail: [email protected]

Web Site: http://law.depaul.edu/student-resources/student- activities/journals/Pages/default.aspx

Printed in U.S.A.

Cover Design by The 2007-2008 Editorial Board The moral right of the 2007-2008 Editorial Board has been asserted.

https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol27/iss2/1 2 et al.: Table of Contents

DEPAUL JOURNAL OF ART, TECHNOLOGY & INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW

Volume XVl Spring 2017 Number 2

BOARD OF EDITORS

MADELAINE THOMAS Editor in Chief

NATASHA MANGAL TOM CALASCIBETTA SUKHPAL KOONER Case Notes And Legislative Updates Lead Articles & Business Comments Editor Editor Editor

DEBA ALAM LUMA ZAYAD LAUREN BURSEY Case Summaries Editor Technical Productions Seminar & Below-The- & Symposium Director Line Editor

WRITING STAFF

MARY BESSONE SUBARNA BHATTACHARYA VICTORIA CAMPBELL

STEPHEN CHOI TOM DAMARIO MORGAN DRAKE

JESSICA DE BELLA JOSH SHANCER

FACULTY ADVISOR.

MARGIT LIVINGSTON

Member, National Conference of Law Reviews

iii

Published by Via Sapientiae, 2019 3 DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 2 [2019], Art. 1

DEPAUL UNIVERSITY

GENERAL ADMINISTRATION

Rev. Dennis H. Holtschneider, C.M., Ed.D...... President Marten L. denBoer, Ph.D...... Provost Jeffrey Bethke ...... Executive Vice President Rev. Edward R. Udovic, C.M., Ph.D...... Secretary of the University Vice Presidentfor Teaching & Learning Resources Senior Executive for University Mission Jay Braatz ...... Vice Presidentfor Planningand Presidential Administration Gene Zdziarski, Phd...... Vice Presidentfor Student Affairs Erin Minn6...... Senior Vice Presidentfor Advancement Sherri Sidler ...... Controller Robert Janis...... Vice PresidentforFacilities Operations David H. Kalsbeek, Ph.D ...... Sen. V P. for Enrollment Management & Marketing Bob McCormick ...... Vice PresidentforInformation Services Elizabeth F. Ortiz, Ed.D...... Vice PresidentforInstitutional Diversity and Equity Jos6 D. Padilla, J.D...... Vice Presidentand General Counsel Linda Blakley ...... Vice President ofPublic Relations and Communications Stephanie Smith ...... Vice Presidentfor cluman Resources

COLLEGE OF LAW ADMINISTRATION

Jennifer Rosato Perea...... oEnlm tM ...... Dean ProfessorofvLaw

Allison Brownell Tirres ...... Associate Deanfor Academic Affairs Associate Professor ofuLaw

Barbara B. Bressler ...... Associate Deanfor Experiential Education Associate ProfessorofLaw

Sumi Cho ...... Pe ...... Associate Deanfor Non-JD Programs ProfessorofLaw

Margit Livingston ...... Associate Deanfor Faculty Development ProfessorofLaw

Allen Moy ...... Associate Deanfor Information Technology and Library Services Director, Rinn Law Library Associate ProfessorofLaw

Michael S. Burns ...... Associate Deanfor Student Affairs

William Chamberlain ...... Assistant Deanfor Law Career Services

Deborah Howard . Assistant Deanfor Institutional Planning, Strategy and Research

Erika Roditis ...... Director ofBusiness Administrationand Operations

Kortney Moore ...... Director of Communications

https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol27/iss2/1 4 et al.: Table of Contents

COLLEGE OF LAW FACULTY

Benjamin E. Alba ...... Director,Academic Support, Student Advising & Bar Passage B.S., DePaul University I J.D., Loyola University of Chicago Sioban Albiol...... ClinicalInstructor B.A., University of Texas at Austin I J.D., Loyola University of Chicago Susan A. Bandes ...... Centennial DistinguishedResearch Professor ofLaw B.A., State University of New York (Buffalo) I J.D., University of Michigan M . Cherif Bassiouni...... DistinguishedResearch Professor of Law President Emeritus, InternationalHuman Rights Law Institute J.D., Indiana University I LL.M., John Marshall Law School S.J.D., George Washington University I LL.B., University of Cairo M onu Bedi...... Assistant Professor of Law A.B., Dartmouth University I J.D., Harvard University M.Phil., University of Cambridge Barbara B. Bressler...... Associate Deanfor ExperientialEducation Associate ProfessorofLaw Director Emeritus, Centerfor Intellectual Property and Information Technology B.S., University of Minnesota I J.D., DePaul University Patrick F. Cassidy ...... Clinical Instructor B.A., University of Illinois IJ.D., Chicago-Kent College of Law Em ily C auble ...... Assistant Professorof Law B.B.A., University of Notre Dame I J.D., University of Michigan Law School Leonard F. Cavise ...... Emeritus Professor of Law FoundingDirector, Centerfor Public Interest Law B.A., Hamilton College I J.D., Georgetown University Sumi K. Cho ...... Professor ofLaw B.A., University of California-Berkeley I J.D., University of California-Berkeley Ph.D., University of California-Berkeley A lberto R . C oll...... Professor of Law Director, European and Latin American Legal Studies Program Director, InternationalLaw LL.M. Program Director, InternationalHuman Rights Law & Policy B.A., Princeton University I J.D., University of Virginia Ph.D., University of Virginia M ichelle C ue ...... Legal W riting Instructor B.A., University of Illinois J.D., University of Illinois John F. Decker...... Emeritus Professor of Law B.A., University of Iowa I J.D., Creighton University LL.M., New York University IJ.S.D., New York University Katheryn M . Dutenhaver...... Associate Professorof Law Director, Centerfor Dispute Resolution B.A., North Central College IJ.D., DePaul University M.A., University of Chicago W endy Netter Epstein...... Assistant Professor ofLaw B.A., University of Illinois IJ.D., Harvard Law School Rebecca Feinberg ...... Lecturer in Law B.A., Yeshiva University I J.D., University of Pennsylvania Law School M.B.E., University of Pennsylvania Medical School I M.S., Johns Hopkins University David L. Franklin...... Associate Deanfor InstitutionalCompliance Associate Professor ofLaw B.A., Yale College IJ.D., University of Chicago Jerold A. Friedland ...... Professor ofLaw Director, Asian Legal Studies Program Director, Master ofLaws in InternationalLaw- InternationalBusiness, Commercial &Trade law Director, Master ofLaws in Taxation Director, Vienna University ofEconomics Exchange Program B.A., New York University IM.A., New York University J.D., Brooklyn Law School I LL.M., Georgetown University

Published by Via Sapientiae, 2019 5 DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 2 [2019], Art. 1

Stefania Fusco ...... Visiting Assistant Professor ofLaw Visiting Faculty & Fellows J.S.D. & J.S.M., Stanford Law School I LL.M., Chicago-Kent College of Law M.B.A., University of Illinois at Chicago Dottore in Giurisprudenza (J.D.), Universita degli Studi di Torino Sarah Gelsomino ...... ClinicalInstructor

Patty Gerstenblith ...... Distinguished Research Professor ofLaw Director, Centerfor Art, Museum & CulturalHeritage Law A.B., Bryn Mawr College I Ph.D., Harvard University J.D., Northwestern University Robert Gevirtz ...... Clinical Instructor

Andrew Gold...... Professor ofLaw B.A., Dartmouth College I J.D., Duke University Steven R. Greenberger...... Associate Professor ofLaw B.A., University of Illinois I J.D., Yale University Michael Grynberg...... Associate Professor ofLaw B.A., Carleton College | J.D., University of Virginia Law School Susan C. Haddad ...... Clinical Instructor M.A., University of Chicago | J.D., John Marshall Law School Maria Harrigan ...... Clinical Instructor Director, Family Law Clinic J.D. Loyola University of Chicago Brian F. Havel ...... DistinguishedResearch Professor ofLaw Associate Dean for InternationalAffairs Director, InternationalAviation Law Institute B.C.L., National University of Ireland I LL.M., National University of Ireland Dip. Eur. L., National University of Ireland I B. Mod., University of Dublin M.A., University of Dublin I LL.M., Columbia University J.S.D., Columbia University M ax N . H elveston ...... Assistant Professor ofLaw B.A., University of Michigan I J.D., Yale University Donald H. J. Hermann ...... Professor ofLaw and Philosophy A.B., Stanford University I M.A., Northwestern University J.D., Columbia University I LL.M, Harvard University Ph.D., Northwestern University I M.A.A.H., Art Institute of Chicago M.L.A., University of Chicago Michael Jacobs...... DistinguishedResearch Professor ofLaw Co-Director,International Aviation Law Institute B.A., Dartmouth College I J.D., Yale University M.P.H., Johns Hopkins University Barry Kellman fLaww...... Professor Director, InternationalWeapons Control Center B.A., University of Chicago I J.D., Yale University Roberta R. Kwall...... Raymond P. Niro ProfessorofIntellectual PropertyLaw FoundingDirector, Centerfor IntellectualProperty Law & Information Technology A.B., Brown University I J.D., University of Pennsylvania Julie D . Lawton...... Assistant Professor ofLaw Director, Housing & Community Development Legal Clinic B.A., Florida A&M University J.D., Howard University L.L.M., Georgetown University W ayne K . Lewis...... Emeritus Professor ofLaw B.A., Rutgers University I J.D., Cornell University

https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol27/iss2/1 6 et al.: Table of Contents

Margit Livingston ...... Associate Dean for Faculty Development Professor ofLaw Director, Centerfor Animal Law Director, Centerfor IntellectualProperty Law & Information Technology B.A., Augsburg College I M.A., University of Minnesota J.D., University of Minnesota I LL.M., University of Illinois A ngelica L opez...... Clinical Instructor B.W.S. & B.S. Missouri State University I M.S.W., University of Kansas J.D., Northwestern University Scott F. Main ...... Clinical Instructor A.B., University of Chicago I J.D., Loyola University of Chicago Jody Marcucci...... Legal Writing Instructor B.A., University of Wisconsin I J.D., DePaul University G regory M ark ...... Professor of Law B.A., Butler University I M.A., Harvard University J.D., University of Chicago Cary M artin Shelby ...... Assistant Professor of Law B.S., University of Illinois I J.D., Northwestern University Joey L. M ogul ...... D irector, Civil Rights Clinic B.S., Oberlin College I J.D., City University of New York School of Law M ark M oller...... Assistant Professor of Law B.A., Duke University I J.D., University of Chicago L.L.M., University of Cambridge D aniel I. M orales ...... Assistant Professor of Law B.A., Williams College I J.D., Yale Law School Allen Moye...... Associate Deanfor Information Technology and Library Services Associate Professor ofLaw Director, Rinn Law Library B.A., Howard University J.D., University of Richmond M.L.S., Catholic University John Q. Mulligan ...... FedEx/UnitedAirlines Resident Research Fellow B.A., University of Wisconsin-Madison I J.D., College of William & Mary M arlene Nicholson...... Emeritus Professor of Law B.A., University of California, Los Angeles I J.D., University of California, Los Angeles Allison I. Ortlieb ...... Legal Writing Instructor B.A., University of Chicago I J.D., University of Chicago Bruce L. Ottley ...... Professor ofLaw Director, DePaul University/UniversityCollege Dublin Cooperative Program Co-Director, InternationalAviation Law Institute B.A., University of Missouri-Kansas City I M.A., University of Iowa J.D., University of Iowa I LL.M., Columbia University Martha Pagliari...... Associate Director ofLegal Analysis, Research & Communication B.A., University of Notre Dame I J.D., DePaul University Jody Raphael ...... Visiting Professor ofLaw Senior Research Fellow Schiller DuCanto & Fleck Family Law Center A.B., Bryn Mawr College I J.D., University of Chicago Steven Resnicoff...... Professor of Law Co-Director, Centerfor Jewish Law andJudaic Studies B.A., Princeton University I J.D., Yale University Rabbinic, Beth Medrash Govoha John C . Roberts...... D ean E meritus Professor ofLaw B.S., Northwestern University I LL.B., Yale University Zot Robinson ...... Assistant Professor of Law B.Mus., Griffith University I B.A., Australian National University LL.B., Australian National University J.D., University of Chicago David Rodriguez...... D irector, Third year in Practice Visiting Professor ofLaw B.S., University of Illinois I J.D., University of Michigan

Published by Via Sapientiae, 2019 7 DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 2 [2019], Art. 1

Jen nifer R osato Perea ...... D ean Professor ofLaw B.S., Cornell University I J.D., University of Pennsylvania Howard M. Rubin ...... Associate Deanfor Lawyering Skills Associate Professor ofLaw Director, FieldPlacement Program B.S., University of Illinois I J.D., DePaul University Jane Rutherford ...... Professor ofLaw A.B., University of Chicago I J.D., University of Michigan Joshua D . Sarnoff ...... P rofessor of Law B.S., Massachusetts Institute of Technology I J.D., Stanford University Jeffrey M . Shaman ...... St. Vincent de PaulProfessor ofLaw Faculty Director, Center for Public Interest Law B.A., Pennsylvania State University I J.D., University of Southern California LL.M., Georgetown University Stephen A. Siegel ...... Distinguished Research Professor ofLaw B.A., Columbia University I J.D., Harvard University LL.M., Harvard University Terry Smith ...... DistinguishedResearch Professor ofLaw B.A., Brown University I J.D., New York University Raia Stoicheva ...... Clinical Instructor Susan Thrower...... Associate Professor of Law Director, Legal Analysis, Research and Communication B.A., University of Virginia I J.D., Wake Forest University Allison Brownell Tirres...... Associate Deanfor Academic Affairs Associate Professor ofLaw B.A., Princeton University I M.A., Harvard University J.D., Harvard University I Ph.D., Harvard University V incent V itullo...... Em eritus Professor ofLaw A.B., Loyola University of Chicago I J.D., Loyola University of Chicago LL.M., Yale University Anthony G. Volini ...... Senior Legal Writing Instructor B.S., Benedictine University | J.D., Loyola University of Chicago M ark C. W eber...... St. Vincent de PaulProfessor ofLaw B.A., Columbia University I J.D., Yale University Judge Warren D. Wolfson...... Distinguished Visiting Professor ofLaw B.S. University of Illinois at Chicago I LL.B., University of Illinois

Viii

https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol27/iss2/1 8 et al.: Table of Contents

RINN LAw LIBRARY STAFF

Allen Moye ...... Associate Dean for Information Technology & Library Services Associate Professor B.A., Howard University I J.D., Universty of Richmond M.L.S., Catholic University Michael Schiffer...... Associate Directorfor Computer Services B.A., University of Chicago | J.D., University of Michigan M.L.S., Rosary College James Brownridge ...... Stacks Manager/CirculationAssistant Kim Gainey ...... InterlibraryLoan, CirculationAssistant Mark Giangrande...... Faculty Services, Reference Librarian B.S., Northwestern University I J.D., IIT Chicago-Kent College of Law M.L.S., University of Texas H eather H um m ons ...... Head ofAccess Services Kristy Lueshen...... Reservers Coordinator/CirculationAssistant M aria W illm er...... Librarian, Legal Research Specialist B.A., University of Michigan I A.M.L.S., University of Michigan L enore B oehm ...... A cquisitions Manager Denise Glynn ...... Associate Directorfor Technical Services & Processing B.S., Northern Illinois University I M.L.S., Rosary College Jack Gorman ...... Government Documents & InformationLibrarian D avid L abno...... C atalogingA ssistant E lizabeth Shivers...... Serials A ssistant D aniel U rsini...... A cquisitions A ssistant

Published by Via Sapientiae, 2019 9 DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 2 [2019], Art. 1

ADJUNCT FACULTY

Gwendolyn Alexis Jordan Labkon Jerome Taylor Michael Bergmann Era Laudermilk Theodore Thomas Richard Boonstra Eric Leafblad Mario Ventrelli Stephen Brandstedt Gil Lenz Elisabeth Ward Chalet Braziel Steven Levy Torrick Ward Mary M. Broshanan John Lillig Destiny Woods Patrick Bruks Lisa Lilly Lori Yokoyama Vince Browne Robert Loeb Michael Burns Mary Luecke John Callahan Terrence MacCarthy George Canellis Anne MacMillan Natalie Carlomango Alfredo Maldonado Patrick Cassidy Mitchell Marinello William Chamberlain Peter Matejcak Thomas Connolly Robert Mauser Karen Conti Terry Miller Daniel Cullen VY'Shaey Mitchell Jemelle Cunningham Joey Mogul Emily Czerniejewski Ralph Morris David D'Amato Craig Mousin Aaron Dozeman Brian Nach Kelli Dudley Kevin Noonan Katheryn Dutenhaver Jack O'Malley Maureen Egan Ginder Odom Katherine Faydash Paul Olszowka Rebecca Feinberg John Paniaguas David Ganfield Christina Pannos Sara Garber Angela Petrone Dean Gerber Todd Pugh Robert Gevirtz Shankar Ramamurthy Christopher Grohman Timo Rehbock Ellen Gutiontov Steven Sandier Susan Haddad John Schmidt Thomas Hennelly Katherine Schostok John Hynes Stanley Sklar Amy Jonaitis Barry Spector Thomas Judge Meghan Stack Susan Kennedy-Sullivan Denise Streff Brent Kidwell Andrew Suszek

https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol27/iss2/1 10