Resettlement Plan
Document Stage: Final Project Number: 46375-002 May 2018
GEO: Secondary Road Improvement Project
Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) for Section 2 (Moliti-Chumateleti) Km 24.620 to Km 50.244
Prepared by the Roads Department of the Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure of Georgia for the Asian Development Bank.
This resettlement plan is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “terms of use” section of this website.
In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.
CONTENTS
ITEM Page List of Abbreviations 7 Glossary 8 Executive summary 10 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION AND PROJECT DESCRIPTION 17-21 1.1 Overview 17 1.2 Description of the Project 17 1.2.1 Design Feature 17 1.2.2 Right of Way and the Corridor 19 1.2.3 Location 19 1.3 Minimizing Land Acquisition and Involuntary 21 Resettlement 1.4 Scope of the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan 21 1.5 LARP related conditions for Project Implementation 21 CHAPTER 2 SCOPE OF LAND ACQUISITION AND 22-33 RESETTLEMENT 2.1 Approach and Methodology 22 A IMPACT ASSESSMENT 22 2.2 Total Land Requirement per Ownership 22 2.3 Impact on Private Land Acquisition (Total Affected 23 Parcel and Affected Area) 2.3.1 Type of Land Parcel and Area (Total) per Legal Status 23 2.3.2 Municipality and Village Wise Details on Type of Land 24 Parcel and Area 2.3.3 Use and Type of Affected Land 25 2.4 Impact on Trees 25 2.5 Impacts on Crops 26 2.6 Impact on Buildings and Structures 26 2.6.1 Physical Details of Residential Houses/Dwellings 27 2.7 Impact on Business and Livelihood 28 B AP CENSUS 28 2.8 Impact on Severely Affected Households 28 2.9 Impact on Vulnerable Households 30 2.10 Affected Households and Affected Persons 31 2.11 Affected Households and Affected Persons by Impact Categories 2.12 Summary Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement 32 CHAPTER 3 SOCIO-ECONOMIC INFORMATION AND PROFILE 34-43 3.1 1. General 34 3.2 Socio economic Profile 34 3.2.1 Type of Settlement 34 3.2.2 Demographic Features 34 3.2.3 Ethnic Composition of Households 34 3.2.4 Major Economic Activities 35 3.2.5 Major Cropping Pattern 35 3.2.6 Average Annual Income 35 3.2.7 Average Annual Expenditure 36 3.2.8 Possession of Durable Goods 36 3.2.9 Loans and Debts 37 3.2.10 Access to Health Facilities and Major Illness 38
2 3.2.11 Migration Pattern 38 3.2.12 Source of Drinking Water 39 3.2.13 Sanitation Facilities 39 3.2.14 Fuel for Cooking 39 3.2.15 Status on Electrification 40 3.2.16 Type of Dwelling 40 3.2.17 Connection to Road 40 3.2.18 Type of Access Road 41 3.2.19 Summary Findings 41 3.3 Women and Gender Issues 41 3.3.1 Literacy 41 3.3.2 Socio-Economic Activities of Women 42 3.3.3 Women’s Say in Decision Making 42 3.3.4 Expectation of Women from the Road Rehabilitation 43 3.3.5 Action on Gender Issues 43 3.4 Impact on Indigenous People/Ethnic Minority 43 CHAPTER 4 INFORMATION DISCLOSURE, CONSULTATION AND 44- 52 PARTICIPATION 4.1 General 44 4.2 Objective of Consultation 44 4.3 Methods of Consultations 44 4.4 Consultation during Feasibility Stage 46 4.5 Consultation during Detailed Design and Prior to DMS 47 4.6 Findings of the Community Consultations during 47 Detailed Design 4.7 Consultation during Dissemination of Leaflet 48 4.8 Findings and Minutes of Consultations during 49 Dissemination 4.9 Future Consultation Strategy 51 4.10 Disclosure 51 CHAPTER 5 GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS 53-57 5.1 Objectives 53 5.2 Formation of GRCE 53 5.3 Grievance Resolution Process 55 5.4 GRCE Records and Documentation 57 CHAPTER 6 POLICY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK 58-62 6.1 General 58 6.2 Laws and Regulation of Georgia 58 6.3 ADB Safeguard Policy Statement, 2009 59 6.4 Comparison of ADB SPS, 2009 with Georgian Laws and 60 Legislation 6.5 Core LAR Policy Principle for the Project 61 6.6 Land Acquisition Process 61 CHAPTER 7 ELIGIBILITY AND ENTITLEMENTS 63-69 7.1 Eligibility 63 7.2 Cut-off-Date 63 7.3 Entitlements 63 7.4 Entitlement Matrix 65 7.5 Valuation and Compensation Rates 68 7.5.1 Principles and Methodology 68 7.5.2 Determination of Compensation Rates 68 CHAPTER 8 RELOCATION AND INCOME RESTORATION 70-70
3 CHAPTER 9 RESETTLEMENT BUDGET AND FINANCING PLAN 71-72 CHAPTER 10 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS 73-78 10.1 General 73 10.2 RDMRDI 75 10.3 LAR Commission (LARC) 75 10.4 Eurasian Transport Corridor Investment Centre (ETCIC) 75 10.5 Municipality LAR Team 75 10.6 Local Governments 76 10.7 Consultants 76 10.8 Other Agencies and Institutions 76 10.9 Capacity Building on LAR 76 CHAPTER 11 IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE 79-81 11.1 General 79 11.2 Detailed Design Stage 79 11.3 LARP Implementation Stage 79 11.4 LARP Monitoring Stage 80 11.5 Implementation Schedule 80 CHAPTER 12 MONITORING AND REPORTING 82-84 12.1 General 82 12.2 Level of Monitoring 82 12.2.1 International Monitoring 82 12.2.2 Preparation of Compliance Report 82 12.2.3 Preparation of Evaluation Report 83 12.3 Monitoring Indicators 83 LIST OF TABLES Table 1.1 Geographical Jurisdictions along the Project Road 19 Table 2.1 Land Requirement per Ownership in Section-2 23 Table 2.2 Municipality and Village Wise Details of Land Acquisition 23 Table 2.3 Details on Land Acquisition per Legal Status 24 Table 2.4 Municipality and Village Wise Details on Type of 24 Affected Land Table 2.5 Agricultural and Non-Agricultural Land 25 Table 2.6 Impact on Trees 25 Table 2.7 Impacts on Crops 26 Table 2.8 Impact on Buildings and Structures 27 Table 2.9 Details on the Residential Houses/Dwelling 27 Table 2.10 Severely Affected Households 29 Table 2.11 Details on Vulnerable Households 30 Table 2.12 Details on AH/APs 31 Table 2.13 Summary Table on AH by Impact Category 31 Table 2.14 Summary Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement 32 Table 3.1 Type of Settlement 34 Table 3.2 Demographic Feature of APs 34 Table 3.3 Ethnic Composition of the Households 35 Table 3.4 Major Economic Activities of the Households 35 Table 3.5 Major cropping pattern and average Yield of different 35 Crops Table 3.6 Average Annual Income 36 Table 3.7 Average Annual Expenditure 36 Table 3.8 Possession of Durable Goods 37 Table 3.9 Taken any loans 37 Table 3.10 Sources of loan 37
4 Table 3.11 Reasons for Loans 38 Table 3.12 Direct Access to Health facility 38 Table 3.13 Major Illness in the Family 38 Table 3.14 Migration Pattern 38 Table 3.15 Period of migration in months 39 Table 3.16 Source of Drinking Water 39 Table 3.17 Type of Sanitation Facilities 39 Table 3.18 Type of Fuel Use for cooking 39 Table 3.19 Connection to Central Power Supply 40 Table 3.20 Age of the Structure 40 Table 3.21 Immediately Connected to Road 40 Table 3.22 Type of Access Roads 41 Table 3.23 Literacy Status 41 Table 3.24 Education Level of Male and Female 42 Table 3.25 Type of Activities of Women 42 Table 3.26 Women’s Say in Decision Making 42 Table 3.27 Women’s Participation in Decision Making 42 Table 3.28 Expectation of Women from the Project 43 Table 4.1 Method of Consultations 45 Table 4.2 Summary of Public Consultations during Feasibility 46 Stage Table 4.3 Summary of Public Consultations during detailed Design 47 Table 4.4 Consultation Findings during preparation of LARP 48 Table 4.5 Summary of Public Consultations during Leaflet 49 Dissemination Table 4.6 Findings and Minutes of the Meetings during 49 Dissemination Table 5.1 Grievance Redress Committee- Section-2 54 Table 5.2 Grievance Resolution Process 55 Table 6.1 Comparison of Georgian Laws on LAR and ADB's SPS, 60 2009 Table 7.1 Entitlement Matrix 66 Table 9.1 LAR Cost 72 Table 11.1 Implementation Schedule 80 Table 12.1 Monitoring Indicators 83 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1.1 Location Map of the Project Road 20 Figure 5.1 Grievance Redress Mechanism 56 Figure 10.1 Project Organization Structure 74 Figure 10.2 Institutional Arrangements for LAR 78 ANNEXURE 85-215 Annexure 1.1 Details on Width of The Right of Way as per Detailed 86 Design Annexure 2.1 Census Survey (Detailed Inventory) Questionnaire 93 Annexure 2.2 Findings of Inventory and Census Surveys 102 Annexure-3.1 Socio-Economic Survey Questionnaire (Sample 114 Household) Annexure 4.1 Records of Consultations during Feasibility Study 123 Annexure 4.2 Copy of Presentation during First Phase of Consultation 129 during Detailed Design Annexure 4.3 Records of Public consultations in the First phase of 143 Detailed Design Prior to DMS
5 Annexure 4.4 Records of Consultation during Disclosure of LARP 151 Leaflet Annexure 4.5 Copy of the LARP Leaflet 162 Annexure 4.6 Records of Recipients of LARP Leaflet by Affected 174 Persons during Dissemination Annexure 5.1 Complaints and Grievance Submission Form 184 Annexure 5.2 Log Book for Registered Grievance in GRCN 185 Annexure 6.1 Synopsis of Selected Georgia Laws and Regulations on 186 LAR Annexure 7.1 Methodology for Determining Compensation Rates By 191 The Valuation Company Annexure 9.1 Compensation Matrix 204
6 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
ADB Asian Development Bank AH Affected Household AP Affected Person DDC Detailed Design Consultant DMS Detailed Measurement Survey EA Executing Agency GEL Georgian Lari (Currency) ETIC Euroasian Transport Corridor Investment Centre GoG Government of Georgia GPS Geographic Positioning System GRCE Grievance Redress Committee GRCN Grievance Redress Commission GRM Grievance Redress Mechanism Ha Hectare HH Household IA Implementing Agency IP Indigenous People IR Involuntary Resettlement Km Kilo Meter LAR Land Acquisition and Resettlement LARC Land Acquisition and Resettlement Commission LARP Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan MOF Ministry of Finance MRDI Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure of Georgia NAPR National Agency of Public Registry PRRC Property Rights Recognition Commission RoW Right of Way RD Resettlement Division RDMRDI Roads Department of the Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure of Georgia RoW Right of Way SPS Safeguard Policy Statement, 2009
NOTE
In this report, “$” refers to US dollars $1.00=GEL 2.52 (21Dec, 2017)
7 GLOSSARY
BeneficiaryCommunity:Allpersonsandhouseholdssituatedwithinthegovernment- ownedoracquiredproperties who voluntarily seektoavailandbepartoftheProjectandrepresentedbyacommunityassociationthatisdulyrecognize dbythecommunityresidents,accreditedbythelocalgovernment,andlegallyregisteredwiththeapprop riateinstitutions. Compensation:Paymentincashorinkindofthereplacementcostoftheacquiredassets. Entitlement:Rangeofmeasurescomprisingcompensation,incomerestoration,transferassistance, incomesubstitution,andrelocationwhichareduetoaffectedpeople,dependingonthenatureoftheirlos ses,torestoretheireconomicandsocialbase. Improvements:Structuresconstructed(dwellingunit,fence,waitingsheds,animalpens,utilities,co mmunityfacilities,stores,warehouses,etc.)andcrops/plantsplantedbytheperson,household,institu tion,ororganization. LandAcquisition:Theprocesswherebyapersoniscompelledbyagovernmentagencytoalienateallo rpartofthelandapersonownsorpossessestotheownershipandpossessionofthegovernmentagency forpublicpurposeinreturnforaconsideration. AffectedPeople(AP):IndividualsaffectedbyProject-relatedimpacts. AffectedHousehold(AH):Allmembersofahouseholdresidingunderoneroofandoperatingasasingl eeconomicunit,whoareadverselyaffectedbytheProject.Itmayconsistofasinglenuclearfamilyorane xtendedfamilygroup. Rehabilitation:CompensatorymeasuresprovidedunderthePolicyFrameworkoninvoluntaryresettl ementotherthanpaymentofthereplacementcostofacquiredassets. Relocation:ThephysicalrelocationofanAP/AHfromher/hispre-Projectplaceofresidence. ReplacementCost:Therateofcompensationforacquiredhousing,landandotherassetswillbecalcul atedatfullreplacementcosts.Thecalculationoffullreplacementcostwillbebasedonthefollowingelem ents:(i)fairmarketvalue;(ii)transactioncosts;(iii)interestaccrued,(iv)transitionalandrestorationcost s;and(v)otherapplicablepayments,ifany.Wheremarketconditionsareabsentorinaformativestage,t heborrower/clientwillconsultwiththedisplacedpersonsandhostpopulationstoobtainadequateinfor mationaboutrecentlandtransactions,landvaluebytypes,landtitles,landuse,croppingpatternsandcr opproduction,availabilityoflandintheprojectareaandregion,andotherrelatedinformation.Theborro wer/clientwillalsocollectbaselinedataonhousing,housetypes,andconstructionmaterials.Qualified andexperiencedexpertswillundertakethevaluationofacquiredassets.Inapplyingthismethodofvalu ation,depreciationofstructuresandassetsshouldnotbetakenintoaccount.
Resettlement:AllmeasurestakentomitigateanyandalladverseimpactsoftheProjectonAP’spropert yand/orlivelihood,includingcompensation,relocation(whererelevant),andrehabilitationofthedama ged/removedinfrastructureandinstallations.
Sakrebulo:Thisistherepresentativebodyoflocalself- government.Themiddleleveloflocalgovernmentconsistsof67municipalitiesandsixcitiesinGeorgia:T bilisi,Kutaisi,Rustavi,Poti,BatumiandSukhumi.Therepresentativebranchofmunicipalitylevelisthem unicipalitylevelLocalCouncils(MunicipalitySakrebulo)andtheexecutivebranchisrepresentedbyMun
8 icipalityGamgeoba(Gamgebeli).Theself-governmentlevelconsistsofsettlements(self- governedcities)orgroupsofsettlements(municipalities).Settlementscouldbevillages,smalltowns(mi nimum3,000inhabitants)andcities(minimum5,000inhabitants).Therepresentativeandexecutive branchesofself- governmentarerepresentedaccordinglybyLocalCouncil(Sakrebulo)andtheGamgebeliofmunicipall evel.Theexclusiveresponsibilitiesofself-governmentincludeland- useandterritorialplanning,zoning,constructionpermitsandsupervision,housing,andcommunalinfra structuredevelopment.
9 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY i. Asian Development Bank (ADB) signed a loan with Government of Georgia in June 2017 for financing toward the rehabilitation of Dzirula-Kharagauli-Moliti-Pona-Chumateleti Secondary Road section (50 kilometer). Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure (MRDI) is the executing agency (EA) of the Project on behalf of the Government of Georgia (GoG) and the Roads Department of the MRDI (RDMRDI) is the implementing agency (IA). For implementation purposes, the project has been divided into 2 separate sections of about 25 km each. Given that civil works will be implemented in two separate contracts, final Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plans (LARP) have been prepared separately for each contract/section, during the detailed designs of the project. The first road section (Section-1) covers the western region comprising of 24.620 kilometre (Km) road length from Dzirula to Moliti and the second road section (Section-2) covers the eastern region comprising 25.624 km of road length from Moliti to Chumateleti. ii. This is an implementation ready LARP which has been prepared for the Section-2 road section from Moliti to Chumateleti (25.624 Km) as part of the detailed design. The project is classified category B for involuntary resettlement1 as per ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS), 2009. There are no indigenous peoples as defined in the SPS in the project area, and the project is classified category C for indigenous peoples. iii. The road has been designed keeping in consideration the best engineering solution. Detailed measurement survey (DMS) and 100% census of affected persons have been completed based on detailed and final engineering design and the final Right of Way (RoW). The LARP is based on the Georgian laws and regulations related to land acquisition and involuntary resettlement and ADB SPS, 2009. iv. Total land requirement for the corridor is estimated to be 50.77 hectare (ha) of which 46.16 ha (91%) is government owned/state land which is vacant land and is not under acquisition. Total land required for acquisition is 4.61 ha (9%) which has been considered in the LARP. Total land parcels being affected under acquisition in section-2 corridor is 208 of which 99 are registered/legal, 98 are legalizable and 11 parcels are non-legal. Total land required for acquisition in the section-2 road project is 46,098 sqm equivalents to 4.61. There are 202 numbers of agricultural parcel (45,806 sqm) of which of which 104 agricultural parcels (26,750 sqm land) is used as agricultural /arable and 98 agricultural parcels (19,056 smt land) are used as residential/commercial purpose. There are 6 numbers of non agricultural land parcels (293 sqm). A total of 3,375 numbers of tress will be affected due to land acquisition. Total area of crop loss is 4993 sqm. A total of 234 structures are affected of which 10 are residential structures such as houses/dwelling. No cases of residential tenants have been recorded. Additionally, 1 restaurant is affected which is not operational now. Remaining structures are auxiliary structures such as fence, garage, storage, cowsheds, and toilets etc. 11 structures will need physical relocation. Severely affected households are 35 and severely affected persons are 101. Total number of vulnerable households is 58. There are no indigenous peoples in the Project area. Total number of affected households is 171. The total numbers of affected persons are 378 of which 195 are male and 183 are female. Summary of impacts on land acquisition and resettlement is given in Table E-1.
1A proposed project is classified as category B if it includes involuntary resettlement impacts that are notdeemed significant which means less than 200 or less persons will experience major impacts, which are defined as (i) being physically displaced from housing, or (ii) losing 10% or more of their productive assets (income generating). The categorization is done for the entire road section (Section-1 and 2) and it is noted that the Project will not cause any significant IR impacts.
10 Table E-1: Summary Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement (Section 1 and Section-2)2 # Impacts Unit of Quantification Quantity 1 Total Land Requirement for the corridor Square meter 507,688 (ha) (50.77) 2 Government/State land/Vacant land (Not Square meter 461,590 under land acquisition) (ha) (46.16) 3 Total Private Land Requirement for acquisition Square meter 46,098 as per LARP (ha) (4.61) 4 Total Land parcels under acquisition as per Number 208 LARP (square meter) (46,098) 5 Registered/legal land Parcel as per LARP Number 99 (square meter) (19,642) 6 Legalizable land Parcel as per LARP Number 98 (square meter) (25,646) 7 Non-legal land parcel as per LARP Number 11 (square meter) (810) 8 Total Agricultural Land Parcel Number 202 (square meter) (45,806) 8.A Agricultural/Arable (agricultural land used as Number 104 agricultural land) (square meter) (26,750) 8.B Agricultural/Residential (agricultural land used Number 98 as residential/commercial land) (square meter) (19,056) 9 Non-Agricultural Land Parcels Number 6 (square meter) (293) 10 Area under Cereals Crop Cultivation Square Meter 4,993 11 Total affected Tress Number 3,375 12 Total Structures/Buildings including Auxiliary Number 234 Structures 13 Residential Houses/Dwelling Number 10 14 Commercial Structure/ Restaurant Number 1 15 Auxiliary Structures Number 223 16 Structures needing Relocation Number 11 17 Severely Affected Households and Affected Number 35 AH with 101 Persons (AH/APs) APs 18 Vulnerable Households Number 58 19 Affected Households Number 171 20 Affected Persons Number 378 21 Male Affected Persons Number 195 22 Female Affected Persons Number 183 Source: DMS and census Survey, June-July, 2017 (Sec-1) and September-November, 2017 (Sec-2) v. Households living in the project area are having a homogenous socio economic profile with low income activities. Due to lack of development activities, many of the families are confined to the traditional pattern of economic activities or depending more on the pension. From the socio- economic survey, it follows that the income level and the expenditure level is almost same which does not allow the people to save or invest for the future security. Besides this, the livelihood opportunities are very less as majority is relying on pensions. The issue related to health is a matter of concern because of no easy access to health facility due to long distance. The socio-
2The summary impact in the executive summary includes both section-1 and section-2 data for providing justification to overall Project Category which is category-B for Involuntary Resettlement as per ADB SPS.
11 economic benefit of the project is foreseen in terms of local employment during Project road construction and maintenance. The project impact will be aligned with the increased economic activity in the Kharagauli municipality and surrounding regions and national connectivity. The outcome will be increased mobility and accessibility of the residents of Kharagauli municipality and tourists visiting the project area by reducing vehicle operating costs and providing time savings for road users. vi. The project will pay particular attention to ensure that women are the recipients of the compensation pertaining to their activities and to ensure that women who are de-facto household heads are clearly listed as beneficiaries of compensation and additional allowance. The project will have positive impact on gender, because the civil works contracts will include provisions to encourage employment of women during implementation. Additionally, women headed households have been considered as the vulnerable and are eligible for special additional assistance as provided in the entitlement of the LARP. It is also likely that benefits to women and girls will be realized after project completion through outcomes such as increased access (i.e., greater public transport frequency, travel speed, days per year accessible) to schools, medical facilities, and markets. Two focus group (each with at least 8 women) discussions towards project end will be conducted to assess whether the project has reduced women's time, poverty and/or improved the quality of their lives. vii. Stake holders' consultations have been a continuous process. It ensured that the affected people and other stakeholders are informed, consulted and allowed to participate actively in the process of road development and preparation/finalization of LARP. During feasibility study, consultations/public meetings were held at 9 locations from 02 December 2014 till 10 Dec 2014 at various locations such as Kharagauli (45 participants), Sagandzile (17 participants), Aneula (5 participants), Chumateleti (18 participants), Dzirula (14 participants), Moliti (23 participants), Tsipha (3 participants), Lashe (8 participants) and Pona (3 participants). The consultations process was also continued during the detailed design stage for the road section-2 where consultations were carried out at 5 locations during the month of August, 2017 and the locations where consultations were held were Kharagauli municipality office (13 participants), Khasuri municipality office (11 participants), Chumateleti (12 participants), Moliti (22 participants), and Tsipa (17 participants). Dissemination of leaflets was done through consultations where all the APs were distributed with leaflet 21 November 2017 (Chumateleti- 45 APs, Moliti- 56 APs and Tsipa/Pona- 87 APs). Additionally, consultations meetings were held after the dissemination of leaflets at three locations such as Moliti (22 November, 2007 having 27 participants), Tsipa/Pona (22 November, 2017 having 67 participants) and Chumateleti (24 November, 2017 having 21 participants). The main objectives and contents of consultations during the detailed design were to sensitize people and to get the feedback from the people about the project design, potential losses due to land acquisition, eligibility and various entitlements, cut-off-date; institutional mechanism and grievance redress mechanism. Consultations are continuous process and will be carried out during the disbursement of compensation and also during the construction of road to resolve any further issues which may further arise. viii. Eligibility and entitlement of the affected people for the potential losses has been discussed through dissemination of LARP leaflet (Georgian version) to all APs and during the consultations meetings. Resettlement information leaflet containing information on road alignment, compensation, assistance, eligibility, entitlement, grievance redress mechanism, implementation schedule and cut-off date etc have been translated to local language (Georgian) and have been distributed to affected persons on 21 November 2017 at all the concerned affected villages. Copy of the final LARP (full report) will also be translated into Georgian language and will be made available at Roads Department, Municipality office and at affected village level upon approval. Copy of the final LARP will be disclosed in ADB’s website and in the website of Roads
12 Department within MRDI upon approval. The semi- annual monitoring reports will also be uploaded in ADB's website as well as in the website of Roads Department. ix. A grievance redress mechanism (GRM) has been established during the disclosure of leaflets and consultations related to disclosure to allow affected persons appealing any disagreeable decision, practice or activity arising from land or other assets compensation. The broad structure, procedure and function of GRM were discussed during the consultations meetings. APs were informed of their rights and of the procedures for addressing complaints whether verbally or in writing during consultation Grievance Redress Committees (GRCEs) have been established under the project at Municipality level such as at Kharagauli and at Khasuri with due representation from respective affected villages (Chumateleti, Moliti and Tsipa/Pona) including the representative of Gamgebeli/village, representative from APs and representative of women APs. First, complaints resolution will be attempted at Municipality level GRCE. If any aggrieved AP is unsatisfied with the GRCE decision at Municipality level, the next option will be to lodge grievances to the Resettlement Division of RDMRDI at the national level within 2 weeks after receiving the decision from GRCN. The grievance mechanism should not impede access to the country’s judicial or administrative remedies. Affected Persons can approach the court of law at any time and independent of grievance redress process. GRCEs are established at Municipality level. x. The legal and policy framework of the Project is based on national laws and legislations related to Land Acquisition and Resettlement (LAR) in Georgia and ADBSPS 2009. Based on the analysis of applicable laws and policies and ADB’s policy requirement, project related LAR principles have been adopted. APs entitled for compensation or at least rehabilitation provisions under the Project are: (i) All APs losing land either covered by legal title/traditional land rights, Legalizable, or without legal status; (ii) Tenants and sharecroppers whether registered or not; (iii) Owners of buildings, crops, plants, or other objects attached to the land; and (iv) APs losing business, income, and salaries. Entitlement provisions for APs losing land, houses, and income and rehabilitation allowance will include provisions for permanent or temporary land losses, buildings losses, crops and trees losses, a relocation allowances, and a business losses allowance. The DMS and AP census carried out during detailed design is considered as cut-off- date which is 30 September 2017 for section-2. The cut-off date was announced during the consultations prior to the start of DMS held at various affected villages during August 2017 and again discussed and clarified during the consultations held for dissemination of leaflets in November, 2017. The valuation of affected assets has been done based on the core principle of replacement cost and by the qualified valuation company. An entitlements matrix is provided in Table E-2.
13 E-2: Entitlement Matrix Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements Land Permanent loss of AP losing productive Registered Owner/Legal: Cash compensation at full replacement cost. agricultural land land regardless of Owner with full registration If the residual plot becomes unviable for impact severity cultivation, the project will acquire it if the owner so desire. Legalizable Owner: The ownership rights of these APs will be (APs with title formalization recognized, the land registered in NAPR and pending and APs who are the APs provided with cash compensation at full replacement cost. not registered but legitimately use the land and have residential land or agricultural plots adjacent to the residential land). Non-legal/Informal One time minimum subsistence allowance in Settler: cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month APs that are not legitimate x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) land users or squatters Agricultural Tenant One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) Non-Agricultural Land AP losing their Registered Owner/Legal: Cash compensation at full replacement cost. commercial/ (Owner with full residential land registration)
Legalizable Owner: The ownership rights of these APs will be (The owners legalizable recognized, the land registered in NAPR and according to active the APs provided with cash compensation at full replacement cost. legislation).
Non-legal/Informal Settler One time minimum subsistence allowance in (Without registration/valid cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month documents using land x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) permanently).
Buildings and Structures Residential and non All AHs regardless of their Cash compensation for building/structures residential legal ownership/ losses at full replacement costs free of structures/assets registration status depreciation and transaction costs (including legalizable and Informal Settlers) Loss Of Community Infrastructure/Common Property Resources Loss of common Community/Public Community/Government Reconstruction of the lost resource/asset in property resources Assets consultation with community and restoration of their functions Loss of Income and Livelihood Crops Standing crops All APs regardless of legal Crop compensation in cash at market rate by affected or affected status (including default at to gross crop value of expected agricultural land, used legalizable and Informal harvest. Settlers)
14 Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements permanently for crop cultivation. Trees Trees affected All APs regardless of legal Cash compensation at market rate on the status (including basis of type, age and productive value of the legalizable and Informal trees. Settlers) Business/Employment Business/employment All APs regardless of legal Owner: loss status (including (i) (permanent impact) cash indemnity of 1 legalizable and Informal year net income or in the absence of income Settlers) proof, One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH); (ii) (temporary impact) cash indemnity of net income for months of business stoppage. Assessment to be based on tax declaration or, in its absence, minimum salary. Permanent worker/employees: indemnity for lost wages equal to One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) Allowances Severe Impacts3 >10% income loss All severely affected AHs One time minimum subsistence allowance in and physically including informal settlers cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 displaced household months=1,042 GEL / AH) Relocation/Shifting Transport/transition All AHs to be relocated An allowance covering transport and costs livelihood expenses for the transitional period. (@ 250 GEL as vehicle hire charge + 347.4 GEL per month x 3 months =1,042 GEL) Total = 1,292 GEL/AH) Vulnerable People AHs below poverty line, One time minimum subsistence allowance in Allowances4 headed by Women, cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x disabled and refugees 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) and employment priority in project-related jobs where feasible Unforeseen impacts Impacts during All APs Due compensation to be assessed and paid during construction construction to when the impacts are identified based on the properties or assets above provisions. out of the corridor of impact or RoW
xi. The resettlement cost estimate for the Project includes eligible compensation, resettlement assistance and support cost for LARP implementation as per the entitlement matrix.
3Severely affected households in this project include those AHs (i) losing 10% or more than 10% of their productive assets/income generating which is the total land holding of the AH compared to the affected land by the project, (ii) physically displaced HH and (iii) households losing commercial/businessestablishments.
4Multiple vulnerability of one HH is considered as one and will be paid only one vulnerable allowance
15 The unit cost and the evaluation were done based on the inventory of assets and subsequently valued by an approved valuer considering the current market value/replacement cost of each lost assets. All LAR related costs, including cost of compensation for land acquisition and resettlement and administration, will be considered an integral part of Project cost and will be contributed as a counterpart fund by the Georgia Government, in particular RDMRDI. The total estimated cost for the LARP for Project is 2.01 million GEL equivalents to $ 0.80 million. Contingency provisions (@ 10% of the total cost) have also been made to take into account variations from this estimate. xii. RDMRDI will have lead responsibility for implementation of the Project as well acquisition of land and implementation of the LARP. RDMRDI is assisted by a number of other government departments and private agencies in the design, construction and operation of the Project. Pursuant to the active legislations, National Agency of Public Registry (NAPR) within the Ministry of Justice is in charge of the recognition of ownership rights of rightful owners, registration of land ownership, with process verification and certification from village communities, Notaries, Property Rights Recognition Commission (PRRC), and sakrebulo. Municipality NAPR is also responsible for registering transfer of acquired land from landowners to the RDMRDI. The local government at Municipality and sakrebulo levels are involved in the legalization of legalizable land parcels and subsequently land acquisition and resettlement of APs. The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Protection is responsible for environmental issues. The Project road will cover two administrative municipalitys such as Kharagauli and Khasuri xiii. The time for implementation of resettlement plan will be scheduled as per the overall project implementation. All activities related to the land acquisition and resettlement must be planned to ensure that compensation is paid prior to displacement and commencement of civil works. Public consultation, monitoring and grievance redress will be undertaken throughout the implementation of LARP and during construction. RDMRDI will monitor the progress of implementation of the LARP and will submit semi annual monitoring report to ADB. Monitoring reports will be disclosed to the APs semi-annually and will be disclosed in the website of ADB and RDMRDI. RDMRDI will monitor the progress of implementation of the LARP and semi-annual monitoring report will be submitted by RDMRDI to ADB.
16 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND PROJECT DESCRIPTION
1.1 Overview
1. Asian Development Bank (ADB) signed a loan with the Government of Georgia in June 2017 for financing toward the rehabilitation of Dzirula-Kharagauli-Moliti-Pona-Chumateleti secondary road section (50 kilometres). Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure (MRDI) is the executing agency (EA) of the Project on behalf of the Government of Georgia (GoG) and the Roads Department of the MRDI (RDMRDI) is the implementing agency (IA).
2. For implementation purposes, the project has been divided into 2 separate sections of about 25 km each. Given that civil works will be implemented in two separate contracts, final Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plans (LARP), has been prepared separately for each contract/section, during the detailed designs of the project. The first road section (Section-1) covers the western region comprising 24.620 kilometre (km) road length from Dzirula to Moliti and the second road section (Section-2) covers the eastern region comprising 25.624 km of road length from Moliti to Chumateleti.
3. This final Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan has been prepared for the Section-2 road corridor from Moliti to Chumateleti (25.624 Km) as part of the detailed design. The project is classified category B for involuntary resettlement5as per ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS), 2009. There are no indigenous peoples as defined in the SPS in the project area, and the project is classified category C for indigenous peoples. Potential impact on land acquisition and involuntary resettlement for both the sections has been provided in the executive summary (Table E-1) for justification of categorization of the Project.
4. The project impact will be aligned with the increased economic activity in the Kharagauli municipality and surrounding regions and national connectivity. The outcome will be increased mobility and accessibility of the residents of Kharagauli municipality and tourists visiting the project area by reducing vehicle operating costs and providing time savings for road users. The project’s output will be about 50 km of improved road between Dzirula and Chumateleti, including several short access roads to the nearby national park and to Kharagauli and other railway stations.
1.2 Description of the Project
1.2.1 Design Feature
5. The project road is a 50.404-km west to east secondary road, starting from E60 in Dzirula and ending at E60 junction at Chumateleti. Most of the project road is within Imereti Region with a few kilometres within Shida Kartli Region, through a gorge with mountain ranges with on both the northern and southern part. The road section starts at km 24+640 at Moliti as a continuation of the Dzirula to Moliti road section and ends in Chumateleti at the junction whit the E-60 at km 50+244. The road infrastructure rehabilitation is one of the most pressing needs of the society.It is envisioned that this road, when improved, will enhance connectivity to a number of towns and
5A proposed project is classified as category 'B' if it includes involuntary resettlement impacts that are not deemed significant which means less than 200 or less persons will experience major impacts, which are defined as (i) being physically displaced from housing, or (ii) losing 10% or more of their productive assets (income generating).
17 villages at the foothills of the mountain ranges and can act as alternative route to parallel segments along E-60.
6. Referring to the feasibility study carried out in 2014/20156, the details of the proposed road project are:
Rehabilitate and pave the project road from Dzirula to Chumateleti according to Georgian National Standard for Public Motor Roads (SST Gzebi 2009), Geometrical and Structural Requirements with 40 km/h design speed. Replace or repair of 19 bridges and 149 culverts. Construction of side drains and other drainage structures. Provision of retaining walls and river protection measures, where necessary. Provision of adequate road signing and marking. Provision of safety barriers such as guardrail
7. The road has been designed according to Georgian geometric design standard, and accordingly, it shall be sufficient to carry the traffic loading efficiently and with the vehicles from the opposite directions can pass safely. Effectively, these will be a two-lane road consisting of a carriageway width (sum of the width of lanes) and the width of the shoulders. The land acquisition plan has been prepared based on the detailed and final engineering design which takes in to account all the parameters such as elevation, embankment, curves etc. The design elements for the cross section of the project road are as follows:
Number of lanes: 2 Lane width: 3.00 m Carriageway width: 6.00 m Width of shoulder: 1.00 m (of which 0.50 m is paved) Increase of shoulder on embankment 0.50 m Total road width: 9.00 m
8. In most parts, the road runs along the Dzirula River and crossing the river from south bank to the north bank at around km 21+700 before the Marelisi Station. The project road starts at the west end with an elevation of around 210m, with its peak at 950 m at km 45 after Phona village and connects again at E60 in Chumateleti at elevation 720m. From west to east the road traverses primarily rural and agricultural setting, with the main urban town of Kharagauli at km 11.
9. The project will improve the national connectivity and reliability of the transport network by serving as an alternative route to the highway E60 and the railway. Secondly, it will improve the mobility of the municipality’s population. The Kharagauli area has been identified by the Government of Georgia as a region that has been isolated due to the poor transport connections. The road can no longer fully and efficiently function either as a local road or a strategic alternative for long distance transit traffic.
10. The project will directly benefit people living in the Municipality of Kharagauli (the largest town in the project area) and people from the villages that the road connects. The population currently suffers from the severe lack of employment opportunities. The project will serve the need of the population for new employment opportunities, in both existing and new areas of economic activity. In addition, the project will secure basic access to essential facilities and services.
6 GEO: Secondary Road Improvement project; Feasibility Study and Preliminary Design for ‘Dzirula – Kharagauli – Moliti – Pona – Chumateleti km 0.0 – km 50.0 Road Section, Prepared by Kocks Consult GmbH for the Asian Development Bank
18 Currently the population is severely underserved in terms of access to medical facilities and schools. The poor condition of the road means that for the majority of villages in the region, ambulance services require more than 3 hours to reach the patient, and a further 3 hours to arrive at the hospital. Schoolchildren walk upwards of 4km to get to school.There will be both short term and long term positive impacts of the Project. The short term positive impacts include access to markets for agricultural produce, availability of temporary unskilled jobs for villagers; and opportunity to provide food and restaurant services for construction workers. On the other hand, the long term positive impacts include, access to long distance transport services across the border; access to long distance markets (buying and selling through regional trade); easier access to health facilities and medical treatment; increased access to agricultural extension services, increased access to education; increased opportunity for the development of tourism; and diversification of income sources.
11. The detailed design provides improved technical solutions for individual aspects, especially the design of the slopes. As compared to the preliminary design this solution has resulted in a significant reduction of earthworks and hence a reduced project footprint with less impact on vegetation and aesthetics.
1.2.2. Right of Way (RoW) and the Corridor
12. The RoW varies according to the design feature. The minimum right of way is 11.60 meter and the maximum goes up to 47.04 meters. The average width of proposed RoW is 21.14 meter. Chainage wise details on the width of the proposed RoW are given in Annexure-1.
1.2.3. Location
13. Section-2 consists of two municipalities such as Kharagauli and Khasuri. There are three major sacrebulo in the section-2 road road section which are Moliti, Tsipa and Chumateleti Table 1.1 shows the geographical jurisdictions of the Project road and the project location map is depicted in Figure 1.1.
Table 1.1: Geographical Jurisdictions along the Project Road No. Location (Sacrebulo/Village) Municipalities Regions 1 Moliti (Moliti Village) Kharagauli 2 Tsipa (Pona and Tsipa Village) Imereti 3 Surami (Chumateleti village) Khasuri
19 Figure 1.1: Location Map of the Project Road and section-2
20 1.3 Minimizing Land Acquisition and Involuntary Resettlement
14. Due considerations have been given during the alignment selection and engineering design to minimize the adverse impacts of land acquisition and involuntary resettlement. Efforts have been put to incorporate best engineering solution in avoiding large scale land acquisition and resettlement. Following are the specific measures adopted for the selection of the route:
Road alignment route has been well tuned on site to avoid densely settlement areas Avoiding expansion of road in habitat area and sticking to the existing alignment Minimising the width of RoW in residential areas Avoiding widening in the section where railways department has already started rehabilitating the road.
1.4 Scope of the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP)
15. The LARP for the Section-2 is based on detailed engineering design and accordingly the impact assessment on land acquisition and involuntary resettlement has been done. This is a detailed and final LARP which is an implementation ready LARP. The RoW has been chosen keeping in consideration the best engineering solution. Detailed measurement survey (DMS) of affected land, assets and and 100% census survey have been completed. The LARP takes in to consideration the Georgian laws and regulations related to land acquisition and involuntary resettlement and ADB SPS, 2009.
1.5 LARP related conditions for Project Implementation
16. Based on ADB policy/practice, the approval of project implementation will be based on the following land acquisition and resettlement (LAR)-related conditions:
(i) Contract award for each Section: Conditional to submission and disclosure of the final LARP based on the detailed/final design and accepted by ADB. The final LARP will reflect final impacts, final AP lists and final compensation rates and be readily implementable. (ii) Provision of notice to proceed to contractors:Conditional to the full implementation of LARP (legalization of legalizable owners, and full delivery of compensation and rehabilitation allowances), verified by a compliance report.
21 CHAPTER 2: SCOPE OF LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT
2.1. Approach and Methodology
17. This chapter provides detailed assessment of impacts on land acquisition and resettlement. Detailed inventory of all the property and assets has been done along with the engineering team to assess the impact on land acquisition and resettlement. A detailed measurement survey and census of all affected households and a sample socio-economic survey of affected households were conducted between 30 September 2017 and 08 November 2017. The right of way was finalized by the engineering team based on the engineering survey. The numbers of villages were identified as per the alignment. A digitized cadastral map was collected from the National Agency of Public Registry (NAPR). The road corridor based on the approved right of way was superimposed in the digitized cadastral map in order to identify the number of land parcels and their demarcation including the quantification. The cadastral survey was the base for initiating further survey which was census and sample socio-economic survey. Based on the cadastral details, a team of survey enumerators were engaged to carry out the detailed measurement survey (DMS) and census survey. The filed survey was done with the help of global positioning system (GPS) and taking in to account the coordinates of each parcel. The DMS was done in the presence of the representative/head the affected households and was jointly verified on the spot with due consultation with the village authority. A licensed valuation company was engaged during the DMS that was responsible for the valuation of land and assets. A copy of the census questionnaire is provided in Annexure 2.1. The survey team was trained by the resettlement specialist and the survey was closely monitored on a regular basis. Additionally, a sample socio-economic survey was carried out in the project affected areas in order to gather the socio-economic condition of the affected households.
18. A cut-off-date was declared during the initial consultations held at affected villages prior to the commencement of impact assessment, DMS and AP census. The cut-off-date for section- 2 is 30 September 2017 which is the beginning of DMS and AP Census. People were made aware about the cut-off-date during the consultations that the eligibility to their compensation will be limited by this cut-off-date and any person person settling down or encroaching in the project affected area, after the cut-off-date, will not be eligible for compensation. In case of any minor change in the alignment, either in the design or any unanticipated impacts which may occur during the construction, will be assessed and will be compensated accordingly.
19. Preparation of LARP involves various tasks such as (i) detailed measurement/inventory surveys, (ii) asset valuation by independent and valuation entity, (iii) consultation with affected persons and stakeholders ; (iv) a 100% census of affected households; and (v) sample socio- economic surveys of the affected households etc. Findings of the census survey are described below. Summary details of inventory and census surveys are provided in Annexure 2.2. Following section describes the findings of (i) impacts assessment survey/DMS and (ii) AP census surveys
A. IMPACT ASSESSMENT
2.2. Total Land Requirement per Ownership
20. Total land requirement for the corridor is estimated to be 50.77 hectare (ha) of which 46.16 ha (91%) is government owned/state land which is vacant and ready for construction and does not require acquisition. Taking over of government owned/state land will not impact any affected persons as the land is unused. Total private land required for acquisition is 4.61 ha (9%) which
22 has been considered inthe LARP. Table 2.1 describes the overall land requirement in section-2 road sections.
Table 2.1: Land Requirement per Ownership in Section-2 Type of Land Square meter Hectare Percentage (%) Private Land for Acquisition 46,098 4.61 9 as per the LARP Government Land (State 461,590 46.16 91 Land/Vacant Land) Total Land (Corridor) 507,688 50.77 100 Source: Calculation made as per detailed engineering design
2.3. Impact on Private Land Acquisition (Total Affected Parcel and Affected Area)
21. The section-2 project road covers two municipalities such as Kharagauli and Khasuri. Total number of affected land parcels is 208 and total affected area is 46,098 sqm of which 159 parcels having 34,979 sqm of land belongs to Kharagauli municipality and 49 parcels having 11, 119 sqm of land belongs to Khasuri municipality. There are four major villages being affected by the land acquisition which are Moliti (57 parcels having 9,480 sqm of affected land), Tsipa (78 parcels having 20,253 sqm of affected land), Pona (24 parcels having 5,246 sqm of affected land) and Chumateleti (49 parcels having 11,119 sqm of affected land). Municipalityand village wise break up affected land parcel and area is described in Table 2.2.
Table 2.2: Municipality and Village Wise Details of Land Acquisition # Municipality/Village Total Number Total Affected Total Affected Affected of Parcels Area (sqm) Area (Ha) Household7 A Kharagauli Municipality A-1 Moliti 57 9,480 0.95 41 A-2 Tsipa 78 20,253 2.03 68 A-3 Pona 24 5,246 0.52 19 Sub Total-A (Kharagauli) 159 34,979 3.50 128 B Khasuri Municipality B-1 Surami, Chumateleti 49 11,119 1.11 43 Sub Total-B (Khasuri) 49 11,119 1.11 43 Total (Kharagauli+Khasuri) 208 46,098 4.61 171 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.3.1 Type of Land Parcel and Area (Total) per Legal Status
22. Total land required for acquisition for the project (section-2) is 46,098 square meter (sqm) equivalents to 4.61 hectare (ha). Total number of affected land parcels is 208 of which 99 are registered/legal, 98 are legalizable and 11 parcels are non-legal/encroacher. Summary details are given below in Table 2.3.
7Number of affected households are less than number of affected land parcels because some owners hold more than one parcel
23 Table 2.3: Details on Land Acquisition per Legal Status Type of Parcels Number of Parcels Total Area (sqm) Number of Households Registered / Legal8 99 19,642 81 Legalizable9 98 25,646 87 Non Legal10 11 810 3 Total 208 46,098 171 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.3.2 Municipality and Village Wise Details on Type of Land Parcel and Area per Legal Status
Total registered/legal parcels which are affected in Kharagauli Municipalityare 81 (17, 814 sqm of affected land), 74 number of parcels are legalizable parcels (16,489 sqm of affected land) and 4 parcels are non-lega (675 sqm of land). Khasuri municipality has a total of 18 affected registered/legal parcels (1,827 sqm of affected land), 24 affected parcels are legalizable (9,157 sqm of affected land) and 7 parcels are non legal (135 sqm of affected land). Tsipa village has highest number of affected land parcels. Details on types of land parcels and areas for each affected village and the municipality are described in Table 2.4.
Table 2.4: Municipality and Village Wise Details on Type of Affected Land # Village/Loca Registered / Legal Legalizable Non-legal tion Number of Affected Number Number Affected Number Number of Affecte Number Parcels Area of HH of Area of HH Parcels d Area of HH (sqm) Parcels (sqm) (sqm) A Kharagauli A1 Moliti 31 5,478 20 24 3,845 21 2 157 0 A2 Tsipa 42 10,907 37 34 8,827 30 2 518 1 A3 Pona 8 1,429 7 16 3,817 12 0 0 0 Sub Total-A- 81 17,814 64 74 16,489 63 4 675 1 (Kharagauli) B Khasuri B1 Surami, 18 1,827 17 24 9,157 24 7 135 2 Chumateleti Sub Total-B- 18 1,827 17 24 9,157 24 7 135 2 (Khasuri) Total 99 19,641 81 98 25,646 87 11 810 3 (Kharagauli+Kha suri) Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
8Parcels are registered and affected household have the legal rights 9These are the parcels which have previous documents as proof of their use and ownership and will be legalized 10The plots are non legal because the affected households are using the affected land parcel by encroachment and these parcels are adjacent to their registered or legalizable parcel. Households having non-legal parcel will be entitled for non-land asset compensation.
24 2.3.3 Use and Type of Affected Land
23. The land is categorized in to two types such as agriculture and non-agriculture. Agricultural land is again subdivided in to two categories such as (i) agricultural/arable (agricultural land used as agriculture purpose) and (ii) agricultural/residential (agricultural land used as residential/commercial land). Total number of agricultural land parcel is 202 having an area of 45,806 sqmof which 104 parcels (26,750 smt land) is used as agricultural land/arabale and 98 parcels (19,056 smt land) is used as residential/commercial land. Total non-agricultural land parcel is 6 comprising of 292sqm of land area. Table 2.5 describes the land use pattern.
Table 2.5: Agricultural and Non-Agricultural Land # Use/Type of Land Number of Land Parcel Area (Square meter) 1 Agricultural Land Parcel 202 45,806 1-A Agricultural/Arable (agricultural 104 26,750 land used as agricultural land) 1-B Agricultural/Residential 98 19,056 (agricultural land used as residential/commercial land) 2 Non-Agriculture Land Parcel 6 292 Total 208 46,098 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.4. Impact on Trees
24. A total of 3,375 numbers of tress will be affected due to land acquisition. Details on the impact of trees are given in Table 2.6.
Table 2.6: Impact on Trees # Types of trees Age of the Trees (Years) Total Numbers <5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 >25 of Trees 1 Walnut/kakali 30 41 34 18 27 132 282 2 Wild plum/tyemali 52 74 74 74 0 12 286 3 Hazelnut/Txili 50 213 377 65 4 11 720 4 Plum/qliavi 98 82 88 82 10 17 377 5 Plural capers/jonjoli 22 191 208 57 2 480 6 Apple/vaSli 14 26 11 13 1 40 105 7 Vine/yurZeni 21 140 271 221 0 4 657 8 Fig/leRvi 7 22 12 38 3 82 9 Cherry/alubali 15 34 4 3 0 0 56 10 Pear/msxali 7 4 11 11 1 24 58 11 Quince/komSi 5 26 25 17 0 5 78 12 Persimmon/xurma 10 8 18 6 0 3 45 13 Mulberry/TuTa 3 5 4 1 0 4 17 14 Cornel/Svindi 3 17 3 3 0 0 26 15 Bay-tree/dafna 4 4 2 0 0 0 10 16 Pomegranate/broweuli 4 0 0 0 4 17 Medlar/zRmartli 3 2 2 0 0 0 7
25 # Types of trees Age of the Trees (Years) Total Numbers <5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 >25 of Trees 18 Barberries/kowaxuri 1 1 0 0 0 2 19 Peach/atami 15 1 0 0 0 16 20 aluCa/cherry-plum 2 2 1 0 0 2 7 21 Cherry tree/bali 11 13 19 6 0 1 50 22 panta /crab-apple 2 0 4 0 0 0 6 23 smarodina /blackberry 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 24 wabli /chesnut 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 25 Werami/apricot 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 Total 377 909 1171 577 81 260 3,375 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.5. Impacts on Crops
25. There are 53 households being affected by loss of crops out of which 21 households cultivate corn and 14 household has bean and 8 household has vegetable as crop cultivation. Total area of crop loss is 4,993 square meter. Details are given in Table 2.7.
Table 2.7: Impacts on Crops # Name of the Crop Number of Households Total Cultivated Area (sqm/) 1 Corn 21 2850 2 Potato 4 110 3 Bean 14 1570 4 Vegetable 8 317 5 baRCeuli 6 146 Total 53 4,993 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.6. Impact on Buildings and Structures
26. A total of 234 structures are affected of which only 10 are residential structures such as houses/dwelling. No cases of residential tenants have been recorded. Additionally, 1 commercial structure such a small restaurant (currently not operational) is affected. Most of the affected structures are fences and gates which are 198 in numbers. Remaining structures are small/auxiliary such as garage, storage, cowsheds, and toilets etc which are 55 in numbers. 10 numbers of residential houses/dwelling and 1 number of commercial structure have been considered as physically displaced which requires relocation. The relocation of these structures will be on self relocation basis where APs will be compensated at replacement cost and will be provided with additional allowances such as shifting allowance etc and they will resettle by themselves. The physically displaced households are considered as severely affected households and entitled for additional severity allowances. Various types of structures being affected due to the Project is described in Table 2.8.
26 Table 2.8: Impact on Buildings and Structures # Types of Building/Structure Quantity Area (meter Number of (Number of for fence and Households Structures gate and sqm for other) Residential 1 House/Dwelling (sqm) 10 1331 10 Commercial 1 Restaurant 1 193 1 Fence/Gate/Wall 1 Fence/Robe 133 L= 4812 110 2 Gate/WiSkari 65 L= 170 58 Total (Fence/Gate/Wall)-length in meter 198 L= 4,982 168 Supplementary/Auxillary 1 Toilet/tualeti 11 44.945 5 2 Cowsheds/saZroxe 5 101.48 5 3 Pigsty/saRore 3 14.865 1 4 Alley/xeivani 3 25 1 5 Auxiliary/damxmare 8 207.03 5 6 abano/bath house 1 20.68 1 7 Garage/garaJi 1 37.52 1 8 Bakery/Tone 1 9.24 1 9 Carry wagon and reservoir/vagoni 1 7.4 1 10 Concrete staircase/betonis kibe 8 26.18 6 11 darn/sasiminde 5 20.39 1 12 Concrete pavement/ betonis safari 1 0.96 1 13 saqaTme /hen-house 2 8.16 1 14 sawnaxeli/winepress 1 2 1 15 avzi/reservour 1 3.16 1 16 wisqvili/mill 1 13.34 1 17 arasacxovrebeli/non-residential 1 98.975 1 18 marani/wine cellar 1 23.76 1 Total (Supplementary/Auxiliary)= (sqm) 55 665.08 35 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.6.1. Physical Details of Residential Houses/Dwelling and Commercial Structures
27. Physical details of the residential houses/dwelling are described in Table 2.9. Most of these buildings are very old and the construction is old. Foundations of these buildings are concrete and the roofs are mostly made of stone slabs (slate) or tin.
Table 2.9: Details on the Residential Houses/Dwelling # Name of Type/Use of the Year of Number of Floor Area Parcel the Structure Constru Storey (sqm) Foundation Walls Roof Number Village ction 1 Moliti Residential House/ 1990 1 67 Concrete brick Tin 91 Dwelling (ground floor) 2 Moliti Residential House/ 1988 1 41 Concrete brick Tin 106 Dwelling (ground floor)
27 # Name of Type/Use of the Year of Number of Floor Area Parcel the Structure Constru Storey (sqm) Foundation Walls Roof Number Village ction 3 Moliti Residential House/ 1985 1 80 Concrete stone Tin 108 Dwelling (ground floor) 4 Tsipha Residential House/ 1983 2 125 Concrete brick Tin 170 Dwelling (Ground+1) 5 Tsipha Residential House/ 1981 2 249 Concrete brick Tin 172 Dwelling (Ground+1) 6 Tsipha Residential House/ 1978 1 269 Concrete stone Tin 173 Dwelling (ground floor) 7 Tsipha Residential House/ 1975 1 237 Concrete brick Tin 174 Dwelling (ground floor) 8 Tsipha Residential House/ 1985 1 122 Concrete brick Tin 175 Dwelling (ground floor) 9 Tsipha Residential House/ 1988 1 101 stone and stone Tin 176 Dwelling (ground floor) wood 10 Tsipha Residential House/ 1975 1 70 wooden stone Tin 182 Dwelling (ground floor) 11 Moliti Restaurant/ 1975 1 97 concrete stone Tin 105 Commercial (ground floor) Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.7. Impact on Business and Livelihood
28. The project will affect only 1 commercial structure which is a restaurant. However, the restaurant has been closed for some time and not currently operational. There are no employees being affected as revealed during the surveys. The commercial structure/restaurant will be compensated and relocation/shifting allowance will be provided. Additionally, severity allowance will also be provided. Therefore, there will be no such loss on business and livelihood.
B. AP CENSUS
2.8. Impact on Severely Affected Household
29. Severely affected households are those who lose more than 10% of their productive asset (agricultural land) of the total land holding and or physically displaced. 24 households are losing more than 10% of their total land and 11 households are physically displaced which becomes total 35 severely affected households comprising of 101 severely affected persons. Severely affected households will be provided with additional allowances in addition to the compensation as outlined in the entitlement. Details on severely affected households and persons are described in Table 2.10.
28 Table 2.10: Severely Affected Households (Land and Physically Displaced) # Name of the Land Total Land Affected % of loss Number of Number Village Parcel No Holding (m2) Area of the Affected of (as per Parcel (m2) Households Affected survey) Persons A Land Loss 1 Moliti 105 1000 159 16% 1 4 2 Moliti 109 600 427 71% 1 2 3 Moliti 116 5000 816 16% 1 3 4 Golatubani 132 4500 510 11% 1 3 5 Golatubani 158 7500 1191 16% 1 4 6 Tsifa 159 7500 1545 21% 1 4 7 Tsifa 162 1800 417 23% 1 2 8 Tsifa 164 4500 472 10% 1 4 9 Tsifa 165 4500 836 19% 1 2 10 Tsifa 166 5000 995 20% 11 Tsifa 172 3000 435 14% 1 1 12 Tsifa 175 6000 731 12% 1 6 13 Tsifa 181 3300 364 11% 1 4 14 Tsifa 188 2000 307 15% 1 3 15 Tsifa 191 2000 417 21% 1 3 16 Tsifa 192 1400 180 13% 1 2 17 Tsifa 194 7500 784 10% 1 2 18 Tsifa 200 4500 453 10% 1 4 19 Pona 208 3000 484 16% 1 2 20 Pona 213 8000 996 12% 1 3 21 Chumateleti 226 6000 1000 17% 1 4 22 CumaTeleTi 227 6000 1000 17% 1 2 23 CumaTeleTi 228 2500 1000 40% 1 6 24 Surami, 231 5000 951 19% 1 1 Chunateleti 25 Surami, 232 8000 2600 32% 1 2 Chunateleti Sub Total - A 24 71 B Physical Displacement 1 Moliti 91 67 67 100% 1 4 2 Moliti 106 41 41 100% 1 2 3 Moliti 108 80 80 100% 1 2 4 Tsipha 170 125 125 100% 1 2 5 Tsipha 172 249 249 100% 1 2 6 Tsipha 173 269 269 100% 1 3 7 Tsipha 174 237 237 100% 1 3 8 Tsipha 175 122 122 100% 1 4 9 Tsipha 176 73 73 100% 1 4 10 Tsipha 182 70 70 100% 1 2 11 Moliti 105 97 97 100% 1 2 Sub Total-B 11 30 Total Severely Affected Households and Persons (A+B) 35 101 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
29 2.9. Impact on Vulnerable Households
30. Vulnerable households consist of women headed households, below poverty line households, disabled households and refugees households. There are multiple vulnerable households, i.e, one household falling under more than one category of vulnerability. Multiple vulnerability of single household will be considered as one unit in terms of vulnerability and eligibility for allowances. Total of 58 vulnerable households are affected of which 40 households are women headed, 15 are below poverty line households and 3 are disabled households. Details are shown in Table 2.11.
Table 2.11: Details on Vulnerable Households Affected HH # Type of Vulnerability Without double Remarks (Parcel Number) Number counting 1 Women Headed HH 40 from which: # 82, # 83.1, # 84, # 86, # 91, # 98, # (117+ 188+120), # 124, # 125, # 133, # 139, # 143, # 144, # 152, # 172, # (181+ 182), # 186, # 197, # 201, # Women Headed (only) 34 34 (204+217), # 205, # 207, # 211, # 218, # 226, # 227, # 231, # 233, # 236, # 245, # 246, # 247, # 229, and # 254 Women Headed+ Below 5 5 # 138, # 176, # 183, # 184 and # Poverty line (#251+ # 251.2) Women Headed+ Disabled 1 1 # 199 Households under Below 2 15 Poverty line from which: # 131.1, # 141, # 142, # (147 + 149), # 154, # 159, # (161 + 170), # (165 + Under Below Poverty(only) 13 13 166), # 175, # 188.2, # 192, # 200, and # 241
Under Below Poverty(only)+ # 190 and # (207 + 210 + 212), 2 2 Disabled 3 Disabled Households 3 3 # 132, # 220 and # 225 Total 58 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
30 2.10. Affected Households and Affected Persons
31. Total number of affected households is 171. The total numbers of affected persons are 378 of which 195 are male and 183 are female. Details are given in Table 2.12.
Table 2.12: Details on AH/APs Sl No Particulars Quantity 1 Total number of affected households 171 2 Total number of Affected Persons 378 3 Male Affected Persons 195 4 Female Affected Persons 183 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
2.11. Affected Households and Affected Persons by Impact Categories
Details about the impact categories in terms of loss of land, loss of structure, loss of crops,trees severity and vulnerability are described in Table 2.13 which provide both the relative and absolute counts in terms of number of affected households.
Table 2.13: Summary table on AHs by Impact Category Impact Category Number of Affected Households Number of Remarks Partial/Relative Absolute (no Net Affected double Persons counting) A. Land A1. Agricultural /residential 36 36 - A2 Agricultural land/Arable 129 129 - A3. Non-agricultural land 6 6 - Sub-total (A) 171 171 378 B. Crops /Trees B Crops Losses 53 - - All AH included in A-2 B2. Tree Losses 166 - - ALL AH included in A-1, A-2 and A-3 (A-1= 36 AH, A-2= 129 AH and A-3= 1 AH) Sub-total (B) - - C. Permanent Structure C1. Residential Structure 10 - - All AH included in A-1 C2.Commercial Structure 1 - - All AH included in A-3 C3. Fence/Gate 165 - - ALL AH included in A-1, A-2 and A-3
C4. Auxiliary Structure 35 - - ALL AH included in A-1, A-2 and A-3 Sub-Total (C) D. Relocated AH 11 - - 10 AH included in A-1 and 1 AH included in A-3 E. Vulnerable AH 58 - - ALL AH included in A-1, A-2 and A-3 F. Severely affected AH 35 - - ALL AH included in A-1, A-2 and A-3 Total 171 378 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
31 2.12. Summary Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement
32. Total land requirement for the corridor is estimated to be 50.77 hectare (ha) of which 46.16 ha (91%) is government owned/state land which is vacant land and is not under acquisition. Total land required for acquisition is 4.61 ha (9%) which has been considered in the LARP. Total land parcels being affected under acquisition in section-2 corridor is 208 of which 99 are registered/legal, 98 are legalizable and 11 parcels are non-legal. Total land required for acquisition in the section-2 road project is 46,098 sqm equivalents to 4.61. There are 202 numbers of agricultural parcel (45,806 sqm) of which of which 104 agricultural parcels (26,750 sqm land) is used as agricultural /arable and 98 agriculturalparcels (19,056 sqm land) are used as residential/commercial purpose. There are 6 numbers of non agricultural land parcels (293 sqm). A total of 3,375 numbers of tress will be affected due to land acquisition. Total area of crop loss is 4993 sqm. A total of 234 structures are affected of which 10 are residential structures such as houses/dwelling. No cases of residential tenants have been recorded. Additionally, 1 restaurant is affected which is not operational now. Remaining structures are auxiliary structures such as fence, garage, storage, cowsheds, and toilets etc. 11 structures will need physical relocation. Severely affected households are 35 and severely affected persons are 101. Total number of vulnerable households is 58. There are no indigenous peoples in the Project area. Total number of affected households is 171. The total numbers of affected persons are 378 of which 195 are male and 183 are female. There will be no impact on common property resources. There will be no impact on agricultural tenant or share croppers and residential and commercial tenant. Summary of impacts on land acquisition and resettlement is given in Table 2.14.
Table 2.14: Summary Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement-Section-2 # Impacts Unit of Quantification Quantity 1 Total Land Requirement for the corridor Square meter 507,688 (ha) (50.77) 2 Government/Stateland/Vacant land (Not under Square meter 461,590 land acquisition) (ha) (46.16) 3 Total Private Land Requirement for acquisition Square meter 46,098 as per LARP (ha) (4.61) 4 Total Land parcels under acquisition as per Number 208 LARP (square meter) (46,098) 5 Registered/legal land Parcel as per LARP Number 99 (square meter) (19,642) 6 Legalizable land Parcel as per LARP Number 98 (square meter) (25,646) 7 Non-legal land parcel as per LARP Number 11 (square meter) (810) 8 Total Agricultural Land Parcel Number 202 (square meter) (45,806) 8.A Agricultural/Arable (agricultural land used as Number 104 agricultural land) (square meter) (26,750) 8.B Agricultural/Residential (agricultural land used Number 98 as residential/commercial land) (square meter) (19,056) 9 Non-Agricultural Land Parcels Number 6 (square meter) (293) 10 Area under Cereals Crop Cultivation Square Meter 4,993 11 Total affected Tress Number 3,375 12 Total Structures/Buildings including Auxiliary Number 234 Structures 13 Residential Houses/Dwelling Number 10
32 # Impacts Unit of Quantification Quantity 14 Commercial Structure/ Restaurant Number 1 15 Auxiliary Structures Number 223 16 Structures needing Relocation Number 11 17 Severely Affected Households and Affected Number 35 AH with 101 Persons (AH/APs) APs 18 Vulnerable Households Number 58 19 Affected Households Number 171 20 Affected Persons Number 378 21 Male Affected Persons Number 195 22 Female Affected Persons Number 183 Source: DMS and census Survey, September--November, 2017
33 CHAPTER 3: SOCIO-ECONOMIC INFORMATION AND PROFILE
3.1 General
33. This section deals with the general baseline socio-economic profile of the project area and affected households of section-2 road section of the project. Socio economic details of the affected households were collected based on a sample survey of the affected households. In addition to social data collected during census survey, socio economic information was collected from affected households through a structured socio-economic questionnaire. This socio- economic questionnaire was administered in the project area covering a total of 41 sample households. A copy of the socio-economic questionnaire is provided in Annexure-3.1.
3.2 Socio economic Profile
34. The following section deals with various socio economic details of the sample households based on the finding of the socio-economic survey.
3.2.1 Type of Settlement
35. The alignment traverses mostly through the rural areas. Approximately 86 % of households (90 numbers) covered during the sample survey in project areas belong to the rural area and 15% households (15 numbers) belong to the semi urban area. Various types of settlements covered during the survey are given in Table 3.1.
Table 3.1: Type of Settlement # Type of Settlement Number of Households % 1 Rural 90 85.71 2 Semi Urban 15 14.29 3 Urban 0 0.00 Total 105 100 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.2 Demographic Features
36. The total households covered during the socio economic sample survey are 105. The family sizes are small in the project area and the average family size is 3.76. The sex ratio of the project area is 1026 females per 1000 males. Details are given in Table 3.2.
Table 3.2: Demographic Feature of APs # Particulars Quantity 1 Total Household 105 2 Sex Ratio 1,026 3 Average Household Size 3.76 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.3 Ethnic Composition of Households
37. There is no ethnic minority population or indigenous people. The project area is settled primarily by Georgian population except one household having Azerbaijan ethnicity. Details on the ethnic composition are given in Table 3.3.
34 Table 3.3: Ethnic Composition of the Households # Particulars Number of Households % 1 Georgian 104 98.61 2 Azerbaijan 1 1.39 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.4 Major Economic Activities
38. People in the project area have varied economic activities. However most of the households rely on income from government jobs (40% of the surveyed households) and another major section of people depend on pension which is 48% of the surveyed household. About 14 % of the households are engaged in agriculture activities. 10% of the households have reported to have daily wage as their source of livelihood. only 4% people are engaged in small enterprise and business as their prime economic activities. Details on major economic activity are described in Table 3.4.
Table 3.4: Major Economic Activities of the Households # Particulars Number of % Households 1 Agriculture 15 14.29 2 Working for other farmers 1 0.95 (Agricultural Labourer) 3 Small enterprise 2 1.90 4 Government jobs 42 40.00 5 Business and trading 4 3.81 6 Transport/Taxi 1 0.95 7 Daily Wage / Labour 10 9.52 8 Pension 50 47.62 9 Others (petty works/temporary) 11 10.48 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.5 Major Cropping Pattern
39. The major crops being cultivated in the project area is cereal such as corn. Similarly, many households cultivate hey.grass. All the crops are cultivated for one season. Details on cropping pattern are given in Table 3.5.
Table 3.5: Major cropping pattern # Type of Crops Number of Households Number of seasons 1 Cereal 58 1 2 Vegetables 3 1 3 Hey/grass 32 1 4 Nut.Fruits 9 1 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.6 Average Annual Income
40. The annual average income of the surveyed households in the project area is 9,078 Gel. Income from pension is reported from majority (65%) of the households followed by income from government jobs (23%). Income from agriculture is reported by approximately 8 % of the
35 households. The average annual income is reported to be highest from animal husbandry and it is 11,100 annually. The next highest average annual income is from government job which is reported to be 13,000 Gel and there are only 2% of households who are engaged in animal husbandry. Details are given in Table 3.6.
Table 3.6: Average Annual Income Percentage of Average Number of # Source of Income households Annual Income Households reporting (Gel) 1 Agriculture 8 7.62 5,187 2 Government jobs 24 22.86 8,905 3 Business 5 4.76 9,120 4 Labour 16 15.24 4,230 5 Professional 25 23.81 8,883 6 Pension 68 64.76 4,082 7 Animal Husbandry 2 1.90 13,000 Any other (Public 17 16.19 1,868 8 assistance Total Annual Average (Gel) 9,078 Did not report 3 2.86 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 201
3.2.7 Average Annual Expenditure
41. The total average annual household expenditure as reported by the surveyed household is 6,096 Gel. About 60 % of the expenditure is incurred on food which is the highest and the average annual expenditure is 3,657 Gel. The next highest expenditure is on health and reported to be 1,309 per annum. Expenditure on food and health is about 81 % of the total household expenditure. Further, the households spend about 7 % on energy usage (436 Gel). The expenditure on education, agriculture and social function is very low or minimum. Details about the expenditure are described in Table 3.7.
Table 3.7: Average Annual Expenditure # Type of expenditure Average Annual Percentage of Expenditure (Gel) Expenditure 1 Food 3,657 59.99 2 Health 1,309 21.47 3 Education 268 4.40 4 Energy (Cooking fuel and electricity) 436 7.15 5 Transportation 327 5.36 6 Agriculture (such as seeds, hiring of farm 65 1.07 implements etc.) 7 Miscellaneous (Social function, 34 0.56 entertainments, clothing, communication, Total Average 6,096 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.8 Possession of Durable Goods
42. Majority of the households i.e. about 96 % in the project area have television. 33% of households have gas connection. About 85 % of the households have refrigerators and 66 % possess a washing machine. For transportation, 30 % of the households have a car. 27 % of the households possess computer. Similarly, live stocks like poultry, cattle, and pig are possessed by
36 the households. About 37 % of the households possess cattle, 42 % of the households possess poultry and 12 % of the households possess pig. Details are given in Table 3.8.
Table 3.8: Possession of Durable Goods # Particulars Number of Households %Age Durable Items 1 Bicycle 6 5.71 2 Television 101 96.19 3 Gas Connection 35 33.33 4 Computer 27 25.71 5 Refrigerator 85 80.95 6 Washing Machine 66 62.86 7 Motor cycle/Scooter 1 0.95 8 Car 30 28.57 Live stocks 9 Cattle 39 37.14 10 Pig 13 12.38 11 Poultry 44 41.90 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.9 Loans and Debts
43. The survey revealed that nearly less than half of the households have taken loan. 41 households (39%) reported to have taken loan and remaining 644 households (61%) do not take loan. Details are given in Table 3.9. Table 3.9: Taken any loans # Particulars Number of % Households 1 Yes 41 39.05 2 No 64 60.95 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
44. The only source of availing loan is bank which is reported by 100 % of the households. The average amount of the loan is 5,404 Gel. Details are given in Table 3.10. Table 3.10: Sources of loan # Source Number of % Households 1 Bank 41 100 2 Relatives 0 0 3 Private money lender 0 0 Total 41 100 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
45. Most of the households (41%) have taken a loan for buying durable goods, 17% of household availed loan for meeting medical expenses and another 17% took loan to start new business. Nearly 5% of households have reported that they took loan for children's' education purpose. Details on the reason for taking loan are given in Table 3.11.
37 Table 3.11: Reasons for Loans # Reason for Taking Loan Number of % Households 1 Meeting the medical expenses 7 17.07 2 On education 2 4.88 3 To start/upgrade business 7 17.07 4 Improvement in house 3 7.32 5 Marriage/rituals 1 2.44 6 Durable/Non consumable goods 17 41.46 7 To meet the daily Expenses 4 9.76 Total 41 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.10 Access to Health Facilities and Major Illness
46. All the households have reported that they have the direct access to primary health facility. The average distance is about 5.04 kilometres from their home. Details on access to medical facilities are given in Table 3.12.
Table 3.12: Direct Access to Health facility # Particulars Number of Households % 1 Yes 105 100.00 2 No 0 0 Total 105 100.00 Average distance of a health facility 16.84 kms 5.04 kms Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
47. It is revealed from the survey result that 41% of the surveyed households have major illness of some kind in the last one year in the family and 62% of the households reported that they do not have any major illness. Details are given in Table 3.13.
Table 3.13: Major Illness in the Family # Particulars Number of Households % 1 Yes 43 40.95 2 No 62 59.05 3 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.11 Migration Pattern
48. Outward migration of the family members is less in the project area. About 12 % of the households (13 households) reported that one of their household members have migrated outside of their home for work. Details are given in Table 3.14. Table 3.14: Migration Pattern # Migration Number of Households % 1 Yes 13 12.38 2 No 92 87.62 3 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
38 49. Among the 13 household those reported of outward migration 1 household reported that migration was only for 4 months duration, 2 households reported that the migration was for 6 months and 10 households reported that one of their family members migrated about 12 months for work. Details are given in Table 3.15.
Table 3.15: Period of migration in months # Migration Number of Households % 1 4 months 1 7.69 2 6 months 2 15.38 3 12 months 10 76.92 Total 13 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.12 Source of Drinking Water
50. The major source of drinking water is piped water supply as reported by nearly 90 % of the households. Spring water supply is available for about 4 % of the households. Details are given in Table 3.16. Table 3.16: Source of Drinking Water # Sources Number of Households % 1 Piped Water Supply 94 89.52 2 Spring (Open) 4 3.81 3 Well 4 3.81 4 Stream 1 0.95 5 Others 2 1.90 Total 105 100 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.13 Sanitation Facilities
51. About 81 % of the households (85 households) use traditional latrine and the rest (19%) have flush toilets. Details are given in Table 3.17.
Table 3.17: Type of Sanitation Facilities # Type of Toilet Number of Households % 1 Flush Toilet 20 19.05 2 Latrine 85 80.95 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.14 Fuel for Cooking
52. Gas is the major source of fuel being used by the households (93%) for cooking and 7% of households use electricity as source of cooking. Details are given in Table 3.18.
Table 3.18: Type of Fuel Use for cooking # Sources Number of Households % 1 Wood 0 0.00 2 Gas 98 93.33 3 Electricity 7 6.67 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
39 3.2.15 Status on Electrification
53. In the project area, all the households are electrified and get power supply from central power supply. Details are given in Table 3.19.
Table 3.19: Connection to Central Power Supply # Particulars Number of Households % 1 Yes 105 100.00 2 No 0 0 3 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.16 Type of Dwelling
54. Most of the structures and dwellings are old. 45% of surveyed households stated that their houses have been constructed before 31 to 50 years and 30% of houses have been constructed since last 51 to 75 years. The average age of house/dwelling in the project area is 47 years. Most of the houses/dwelling is of wood made and the average room per building is 5 of which the average heated room is only 2. Age of the structures where people live is described in Table 3.20. Table 3.20: Age of the Structures # Age of the Structure Number of % Households 1 Up to 10 years 4 3.81 2 11 to 20 years 2 1.90 3 21 to 30 years 15 14.29 4 31 to 50 years 47 44.76 5 51 to 75 years 32 30.48 6 Above 75 years 5 4.76 Total 105 100.0 Average Age of the Structure 47 years Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.17 Connection to road
55. The survey finding revealed that 103 households (98%) households have immediate access to road and the remaining 2 households (2%) reported that they do not have immediate direct access to the road. However, the road is mostly in poor condition. Details are described in Table 3.21. Table 3.21: Immediate Connection to Road Number of # Particulars Households % 1 Yes 103 98.10 2 No 2 1.90 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
40 3.2.18 Types of Access Roads
56. Among the 105 households, about 46 % of the households are connected to village road, 44% households are connected to district road and 10% households are connected to highway. Details are given in Table 3.22. The average distance of the road from their respective households is 0.27 kilometre. Most of the households stated that the condition of the road is very poor. Table 3.22: Type of Access Roads # Type of Road Number of Households % 1 Village Road 48 45.71 2 District road 46 43.81 3 Highway 11 10.48 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.2.19 Summary Findings
57. The households living in the project area are having a homogenous socio economic profile with low income activities. Due to lack of development activities, many of the families are confined to the traditional pattern of economic activities or depending more on the pension. From the socio- economic survey, it follows that the income level and the expenditure level is almost same with lesser saving margin, which does not allow the people to invest for the future security. Besides this, the livelihood opportunities are very less as majority is relying on pensions. The issues related to health is a matter of concern as easy access to health facility is a problem due to long distance and most of families reported of a family member being sick during the last one year. Besides, large percentage of their expenditure is invested in getting health services. The proposed project will benefit the local population as this will bring development to the area in terms of local employment during Project road construction and maintenance. The local community is eager to provide paid labourer and they welcome the project and think that the project will enhance their economic activities and income level.
3.3 Women and Gender Issues
3.3.1 Literacy
58. The overall literacy rate is 99 %. There is no discrimination in the male and female literacy. Both male and females are literate. Details on literacy rate are described in Table 3.23 and details on the education level are described in Table 3.24.
Table 3.23: Literacy Status # Particulars Total % Male Total % Female Total Total % Male Female Members 1 Literate 181 99% 189 99% 370 99% 2 Illiterate 1 1% 1 1% 2 1% 3 Total 182 100% 190 100% 372 100% Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
41 Table 3.24: Education Level of Male and Female # Particulars Male (%) Female (%) Total (%) 1 Children (0-6 years) not going to school 8.08 2.56 5.34 2 Pre-School 0.51 0.00 0.25 3 Primary 1.01 1.54 1.27 4 Secondary 65.15 65.13 65.14 5 College/ University 24.75 30.26 27.48 6 Illiterate 0.51 0.51 0.51 Total 100.00 100.00 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.3.2 Socio-Economic Activities of Women
59. The predominant activity of women is household work as reported by 100 % of the households. Besides household activities, the two other major economic activities of women are cultivation (15%) and trade and business (14%). Details of the activities of women are given in Table 3.25. Table 3.25: Type of Activities of Women # Activities Number of Households % 1 Cultivation 16 15.24 2 Small Scale business 15 14.29 3 Households Work 105 100 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.3.3 Women’s Say in Decision Making
60. Women do take part in the decision making process of the family. About 95 % of the households reported that women participate in the decision making process of the family and 5% of households reported that women do not have any say in the decision making process of the family matters. Details are given in Table 3.26.
Table 3.26: Women’s Say in Decision Making # Particulars Number of Households % 1 Yes 100 95.24 2 No 5 4.76 3 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
61. Women in the project area have a very positive say on all the matters related to the household affairs. Most of the women who do take part in decision making in various matters are described in Table 3.27.
Table 3.27: Women’s Participation in Decision Making # Issues Number of % Households 1 Financial matters 96 96 2 Education of child 75 75 3 Health care of child 80 80 4 Purchase of assets 100 100 5 Day to day activities 100 100 6 On social functions and marriages 95 95 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
42 3.3.4 Expectation of Women from the Road Rehabilitation
62. Women respondents from the surveyed households were asked about their expectation from the proposed road project. Majority of the women respondent expect reduction in travel time due to the new road which is 49% of the total response. 10% of the respondents expect employment opportunities due to better road. Details on their expectation are described in Table 3.28.
Table 3.28: Expectation of Women from the Project # Expectation from the Project Number of % Households 1 New employment opportunities 10 9.52 2 Overall Development 2 1.90 3 Cannot Say 18 17.14 4 Improvement in Life style 3 2.86 5 Increase in traffic 6 5.71 6 No expectation 3 2.86 7 Reduce in Travel Time 51 48.57 8 Easy Movement to other parts of Georgia 10 9.52 9 Opening restaurant near the road 1 0.95 10 to improve the existing business 1 0.95 Total 105 100.00 Source: Socio Economic Survey, September--November, 2017
3.3.5 Action on Gender Issues
The project will pay particular attention to ensure that women are the recipients of the compensation pertaining to their activities and to ensure that women who are de-facto household heads are clearly listed as beneficiaries of compensation and additional vulnerable allowances under the loan. Special attention will be given to the impact of resettlement on women and other vulnerable groups during implementation of the LARP. The project will have positive impact on gender, because the civil works contracts will include provisions to encourage employment of women during implementation. Additionally, women headed households have been considered as the vulnerable group and are eligible for special additional assistance as provided in the entitlement of the LARP. It is also likely that benefits to women and girls will be realized after project completion through outcomes such as increased access (i.e., greater public transport frequency, travel speed, days per year accessible) to schools, medical facilities, and markets. Two focus group (each with at least 8 women) discussions towards project end will be conducted to assess whether the project has reduced women's time, poverty and/or improved the quality of their lives.
3.4 Impact on Indigenous People/Ethnic Minority
63. No impacts on Indigenous Peoples (IP) are expected in the project. An assessment of impact on indigenous peoples was undertaken during the social impact assessment. The project will primarily affect Georgian people (99%) of the total population except one household belongs to Azerbaijan ethnicity and is mainstreamed. No indigenous peoples (IPs) per SPS (2009) definition have been identified and the requirements of the ADB Safeguards Requirement 3 (SR- 3) on IP will not be triggered in this project. The project is categorized as C for indigenous peoples.
43 CHAPTER 4: INFORMATION DISCLOSURE, CONSULTATION AND PARTICIPATION
4.1 General
64. Stakeholders' consultations have been a continuous process since the feasibility study till detailed design and finalization of LARP. Consultations were carried out with various stakeholders such as affected people, village community, representative from the municipality administration, representative from the roads department. It ensured that the affected people and other stakeholders are informed, consulted and allowed to participate actively in the process of road development and preparation/finalization of LARP. It assisted in identifying the problems associated with the project as well as the needs and expectations of the population likely to be impacted. Consultations were carried out various phases such as (i) during the feasibility study, (ii) first phase consultation during the detailed design and prior to start of the DMS and census survey and (iii) second phase consultation during the detailed design and finalization of LARP especially during the dissemination of LARP leaflet.
4.2 Objective of Consultation
65. The main objectives of the consultations during the detailed design are as follows:
to make the people aware about the road corridor, project features, potential loss and implementation arrangements to convey the cut-off-date and schedule of detailed measurement surveys and the AP census survey To seek their presence during the DMS and to involve all other relevant agencies during the assessment to discuss about the eligibility and entitlement of various losses to discuss on the grievance redress structures, procedures and mechanism to discuss about the status of registered and unregistered parcels and to make them aware about the legalized owners, legalizable owners and unlegalizable owners. to senitize the people for making advance action for completing the registration process with the help of roads department and the consultants prior to the receipt of the compensation and assistance to seek their overall participation for a smooth implementation of the project to make them aware about the next phase of consultation, disclosure and implementation schedule
4.3 Methods of Consultations
66. Various methods have been used during the stakeholder's consultations. Methods used for public consultation and participation with concerned stakeholders during detailed design and preparation of detailed LARP for section-2 is described in Table 4.1.
44 Table 4.1: Method of Consultations Stakeholders Purpose Method Roads Department of Georgia To collect government's policy Frequent individual including the Resettlement Division and to seek their participation in meetings and presentation under the Ministry of Regional the safeguards planning with the officials of Roads Development and Infrastructure of activities. Department and its Georgia (MRDI) To discuss about the progress of Resettlement Division. social safeguards planning activities and the broad policy principles, eligibility and entitlements etc. National Agency for Public Registry To collect the cadastral map and Consultation and (NAPR) under the ministry of Justice to know the details of the affected discussion with officials parcels and people Local Government at Municipality To seek their cooperation for Individual meetings with Level at Khasuri and Kharagauli carrying out the impact the officials of Khasuri and assessment survey and to sort Kharagauli out the problem related land parcels etc. To seek their participation and representation in public consultation. Property Recognition Commission in To seek their cooperation for Meetings the Municipality Level and Sakrebulo carrying out the impact assessment survey and to sort out the problem related to missing plots (Legalizable Owners) Affected People and Local For information sharing about the Consultation meetings Community during the first phase project of consultations prior to start of Awareness about the project and DMS/AP census survey at the Involvement of People in Project time of detailed design and LARP Planning and Implementation preparation Discuss future plan of action such as carrying out detailed measurement surveys such as Census Surveys, Inventory of Assets, Socio-economic household surveys, valuation of Assets and Legalization of Legalizable Discuss about the cut-off-date which is the start date of the Detailed Measurement Survey/Census Survey Discuss about the general Eligibility and Entitlement and Compensation and Allowances Discuss about Institutional Mechanism and Grievance Redress Mechanism Discuss about the legalization process
45 Stakeholders Purpose Method Affected People and Local Providing awareness on the Consultation meetings and Community during the second overall LARP through briefing phase of consultations which is at dissemination of leaflet the time of dissemination of LARP Seeking feedback on the leaflet eligibility and entitlement and assistance Clarification on loss of assets and compensation Providing awareness on the cut- off-date Providing awareness on GRM and GRCE Formation of GRCE and briefing of the GRM Seeking feedback from the people about the Project, LARP and other related issues
4.4 Consultation during Feasibility Stage
67. During feasibility study, consultations/public meetings were held at 9 locations from 02 December 2014 till 10 Dec 2014 at various locations such as Kharagauli (45 participants), Sagandzile (17 participants), Aneula (5 participants), Chumateleti (18 participants), Dzirula (14 participants), Moliti (23 participants), Tsipha (3 participants), Lashe (8 participants) and Pona (3 participants). People were aware about the Project as there were so many technical and engineering surveys which were already carried out prior to safeguards related consultations. People were supportive about the project as they did not have a good road and the improved road will facilitate their mobility and small scale business activities. APs losing their land and assets expected fair and adequate compensation. People wanted that advance notice shall be provided prior to the construction activities. People preferred cash compensation. People also expected proper safety measures to be adopted. Summary of locations, dates and number of participants during feasibility and preparation of draft LARP is provided in Table 4.2 and details on the records of consultations carried out during feasibility stage are provided in Annexure 4.1.
Table 4.2: Summary of Public Consultations during Feasibility Stage Sl No Name of the Date of Consultations Number of village Participants 1 Kharagauli 02-12-14 45 2 Sagandzile 02-12-14 17 3 Aneula 18.12.14 5 4 Chumateleti 02.12.14 18 5 Dzirula 02.12.1. 14 6 Moliti 02.12.14 23 7 Tsipha 15.12.14 3 8 Lashe 03.12.14 8 9 Pona 10.12.14 3
46 4.5 Consultation during Detailed Design and Preparation of LARP
68. Community consultations were arranged at various locations through public meetings in the month of August-2017 during the detailed design study and during final LARP preparation for section-2 which involved both men and women participants. Consultations were carried out through presentations and open discussions. A copy of the presentation is provided in Annexure 4.2. The contents of the presentations included various aspects such as project/design features, core policy principles, project impacts and losses, compensation, valuation, additional allowances, eligibility and entitlements, cut-off-date, future plan of action, concerns and appeals from the people. All these information on projects were shared with the people and their feedbacks were collected. Details on the venue, dates and number of participants of public meetings during detailed design and preparation of LARP are given in Table 4.3.
Table 4.3: Summary of Public Consultations during detailed Design # Name of the village Date of Number of Consultations Participants 1 KharagauliMunicipality Office 10.08.2017 13 2 Khasuri Municipality Office 10.08.2017 11 3 Chumateleti Village 24.08.2017 12 4 Moliti Village 24.08.2017 22 5 Tsipa Village 24.08.2017 17
4.6 Findings of the Community Consultations during Detailed Design
69. The major findings of the consultations held at various locations are summarized as follows and a summary detail of community consultations findings is provided in Table 4.4. Details on list of participants are presented in Annexure 4.3.
People are aware about the Project and welcome the project as they expect better road connectivity and also some opportunities in small scale business activities.
APs losing their land and assets expect fair and adequate compensation
People want that advance notice shall be provided prior to the construction activities
Most of the people prefer monetary compensation/ cash compensation.
People were concerned about the increase traffic volume and safety measures
People were concerned about the non legalizable owners and were concerned about their eligibility to which it was clarified that non legalizable APs will be eligible for non land assets.
People were also concerned about future unforeseen impacts which may happen during construction to which it was clarified that necessary measures will be taken by the contractor avoid un anticipated impacts failing which the losses will be compensated as per the provision in the LARP.
People were also concerned about maintenance of roads and existing infrastructure during construction and it was clarified that the contractor will follow and implement the environment management plan during construction and the same will be supervised by a supervision consultant.
47 Table 4.4: Consultation Findings during preparation of LARP Participants’ Opinion, Action taken or to be Taken Issues Comments and Suggestions General perception about the People are aware about the Consultations will be a continuous project and the awareness about proposed project because of process throughout project the proposed project. various consultations held implementation. since 2014 and they expect better road conditions and connectivity due to the project Support of local people for the People are supportive about RDMRDI through its consultants and proposed project? the project as they need the concerned local government will have improved road. However, continued consultation to seek people's some people (15%) have support and will sort out any problems reservation regarding the during construction with due involvement construction management and from the contractor. about unforeseen impacts. Any critical issue or concern by Increase in traffic may lead to Adequate road safety measures such as the local people regarding the road safety concern guardrail, traffic signs at curves and other project? sensitive area and speed limits etc have been considered while designing the road. Any criteria you would like to see Proper construction Contractor will follow the international considered during project management plan shall be construction standard and environment design, construction and followed. People should have management plan to mitigate any operation stage? uninterrupted facilities and all adverse impacts. The LARP has all the the damages shall be properly provisions for compensation of all losses. restored back to normal and compensation should be paid for all the losses Loss of community life like any No No such community establishments are Market Places or community affected. activities to be affected Perceived benefits from the Employment opportunities, RDMRDI will encourage the civil work project better transportation system contractor to engage local people (skilled and new business and unskilled labour) during the opportunities are main construction activities where feasible. perceived benefits from the project. Perceived losses from the Loss of land and structures Adequate compensation will be paid prior project to start of the construction work.
4.7 Consultation during Dissemination of Leaflet
70. Dissemination of leaflets was done through consultations where all the APs were distributed with leaflet on21 November 2017 (Chumateleti- 45 APs, Moliti- 56 APs and Tsipa/Pona- 87 APs). Additionally, consultations meetings were held after the dissemination of leaflets at three locations such as Moliti (22November, 2007 having 27 participants), Tsipa/Pona (22November, 2017 having 67 participants) and Chumateleti (24November, 2017 having 21 participants). The consultation meetings were held with due representations from the affected people, women APs, representatives from the municipality and gamgebeli, concerned official from the roads department including the GRCE members. Dates, venues and number of participants are summarized in Table 4.5 and the records are provided in Annexure 4.4.
48 Table 4.5: Summary of Public Consultations during Leaflet Dissemination # Name of the village Date of Number of Consultations Participants A Dissemination of Leaflet 1 Chumateleti 21-November-2017 45 APs 2 Moliti 21-November-2017 56 APs 3 Tsipa/Pona 21-November-2017 87 APs B Consultation on Disclosure 1 Moliti 22-November-2017 27 2 Tsipa/Pona 22-November-2017 67 3 Chumateleti 24-November-2017 21
4.8 Findings and Minutes of Consultations during Dissemination
71. The findings and minutes of the meetings are provided in Table 4.6.
Table 4.6: Findings and Minutes of the Meetings # Questions Asked by the Responses and Clarifications provided by the Participants consultant and Roads Department Location: Moliti Date: 22-November-2017 Number of Participants:27 1 How will the registration problem All the documents have been collected during the and issues be resolved and detailed measurement survey and AP census survey addressed for those whose plots and the ownership status has been categorized. Those are not registered yet. who are already registered, they will have nothing to additional. However, the legalizable owners will be A concern raised by one of the legalized and registered in the national agency of affected persons that whether public registry office with the help of Gamgebeli, the she will be compensated for nut village committee which has been formed for this trees, which are located outside project and roads department. Non-legalizable owners of her plot? will be receiving only the compensation for non land assets. It has been clarified and advised that the lady has to address the issue to the village committee and if the user right is confirmed then she will be compensated. It was further clarified that any such assets being used by any persons (other than land) will be compensated based on the proof of user right. 2 There is a high voltage tower near Based on requirements of the Road Department, high to plot and how will it be moved? voltage electric towerwill be shifted by the contractor and will not affect any one. 3 How will the compensation be paid This will be compensated as non-legalizable owner and for the land being used temporarily will be compensated for all lost assets other than land. without having any legal status 4 There are houses which are beyond The case will be evaluated during construction and if the stipulated road corridor and right damage occurs, the damage will be compensated as per of way; however, they are adjacent the LARP to the edge of the road corridor which means they could be potential damage during construction. How this issue will be addressed.
49 # Questions Asked by the Responses and Clarifications provided by the Participants consultant and Roads Department
Location: Tsipa/Pona Date: 22-November-2017 Number of Participants:67 1 Some participants voiced their All the questions were answered and clarified with detailed concern on clarification of certain explanation on its implication and implementation. terminology in the leaf let such as GRCE and GRM etc.
2 In Tsipa, 6 problematic houses are This is a future impact which is unforeseen at the moment. located along the road (Bantsadze However, prior to the construction, these will be re- municipality). All these 6 families assessed with the help of contractor and its construction have concern and appealed that technology prior to the construction and if any damage their property should be fully happens then the same will be compensated by the Roads compensated because they fear Department as per the provision of the LARP and with due that these houses may get affected consultation with the affected persons. during construction although it is beyond the corridor at the moment. 2 What would be the solution for Before construction all houses / buildings / facilities located vibration related impacts along the road will be examined by the construction contractor. If additional damages have occurred in the construction process, these damages will be compensated. 3 People asked whether adequate All engineering and environmental studies have been laboratory testing has been done for completed and will be implemented as per the geology, soil, water etc as they feel management plan and relevant protection measures are that the ongoing railway provided according active rules and regulations. There will construction is creating lots of be no blasting in the road project. The mock disposal will problems including rock fell and be done as per the environment management plan. The blasting etc. entire construction activities of the contractor will be supervised and monitored by international supervision consultant company and Roads Department to ensure all safety and restoration of any damages during construction 4 People were concerned that spring It was clarified that no mock disposal will be done in to water may be damaged river or spring and the water quality will be kept intact.
5 The road is very closed to the house, Protection wall, retaining wall and safety barrier such as what kind of protective measures are guardrail etc will be provided in this case where there are foreseen, if environment impact habitat areas. assessments have been made?
6 People asked about the restoration It has been clarified that contractor will do the utility plan of all utilities such as power line, shifting prior to the start of construction and will restore water line, gas line etc. fully with uninterrupted supply of these facilities.
Location: Chumateleti Date: 24-November-2017 Number of Participants:21 1 Concerns were raised to know about It has been clarified that if any partial damage leads to the mitigation and compensation plan non-viability of the houses or buildings, it will be fully for partially affected houses or compensated. In the LARP, partially damaged residential structures building or dwelling has been considered as fully affected and will be compensated fully.
50 # Questions Asked by the Responses and Clarifications provided by the Participants consultant and Roads Department 2 People asked about the safety and It has been clarified that the maximum spped limit is 40 protection measures due to the km/phr and usually the big trucks will not ply on this road movement of heavy trucks. as they will take the E-60 highways. Necessary safety signs will be put in the carves and and habitat area along with safety walls. 3 People were asking about the It was clarified that there will be strict supevision of all checking, verification, quality these concerns by a separate supervision team along control of the constructor with roads department. People were also advised that of they have any problem then can approach to the GRCE in the village/municipality level and the issues will be taken up for discussions and solution 4 Will there be solution for water It was discussed and clarified that if any existing water supply and drainage system as part supply is damaged then the same will be repaired or of the road project restored or may be rebuilt. As far s the drainage is concerned, the road design has the provision for drainage and foot path in the project as an integrated design practice. 5 Questions were asked about the It has been clarified that the design company has legalization of legalizable parcels prepared individual land map and land sketch plan. This will be provided to the eligible owners during the contract negotiation and the legalization will be done with the assistance from the Roads Department and in participation with the affected legalizable owners and the Gamgebeli. 6 People asked about the It has been clarified that non-legalizable owners will be compensation entitlement for the compensated for all non-land assets such as any non legalizable owners. structure or trees or any assets they built or use. However, they will not be compensated for lloss of land.
4.9 Future Consultation Strategy
72. The consultation will be continued throughout the project cycle especially during the disbursement of compensation and also during the construction of road to assess if any unforeseen impact occurs during construction. For future consultations, following steps are envisaged in the project:
Future consultations will be done during the disbursement of compensation if any disputes issues arise related to compensation. This will be done by the roads department.
Consultations will be carried out during the construction period to sort out any inconveniency caused due to construction. Roads department with the help of contractor will consult with people and will resolve any issues which may arise
Consultations will be carried out during the grievance redress process and during the hearing of GRCE.
4.10 Disclosure
73. The project information has been disclosed in the form of a resettlement leaflet (Annexure 4.5). The Georgian version of the leaflets has been disseminated to all affected households on 21 November 2017. Records of dissemination with the signatures of affected persons on receipt of the leaflets are provided in Annexure 4.6. Additionally, copies of the leaflets have been
51 provided to the respective municipality offices (Kharagauli and Khasuri) and respective village gamgebeli. Copy of the final LARP (full report) will also be translated to Georgian language and will be made available at Roads Department, Municipality office and at affected village level and will be made available for the APs as and when asked for. Copy of the final LARP will be disclosed in ADB’s website and in the website of Roads Department within MRDI upon approval. The semi annual monitoring reports will also be uploaded in ADB's website as well as in the website of Roads Department.
52 CHAPTER 5: GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS
5.1 Objectives
74. ADB procedures require Roads Department to establish a project specific Grievance Redress Mechanism (GRM) having suitable grievance redress procedure to receive and facilitate resolution of affected peoples’ concerns, complaints, and grievances. A grievance mechanism has been developed at municipality level (Kharagauli and Khasuri municipality) with member from affected villages, roads department and gamgebeli and at the head quarter of Roads Department to allow affected persons appealing any disagreeable decision, practice or activity arising from land or other assets compensation. The impact of the project on land acquisition is not significant and the municipality head quarter is not far from affected villages. Some of the villages have very less impact in terms of number of affected persons. Therefore, Grievance Redress Committee (GRCE) is proposed at the municipality level which is at local level/project level. There is a Grievance Redress Commission (GRCN) at the corporate level in the Roads Department. APs have been informed of their rights and of the procedures for addressing complaints whether verbally or in writing during consultation and dissemination. Care will always be taken to prevent grievances rather than going through a redress process. The grievance mechanism should not impede access to the country’s judicial or administrative remedies. APs can approach the court of law at any time and independent of grievance redress process. The broad grievance redress mechanism and its structures and functions have been discussed and briefed during the consultations meetings at each villages held during the preparation of final LARP and dissemination of leaflet. Grievance redresses committees (GRCE) have been formally established and briefing was provided to the members on the GRM and the APS were also sensitized on how to formulate their grievance during the consultation
5.2 Formation of Grievance Redress Committee
75. Some of the grievances may be solved by RDMRDI within the accepted policies and the legal framework and some can be solved at the field level informally with proper consultation and participatory engagement with the APs. The Roads Department has a centralized grievance redress mechanism. However, there may be certain grievances that are more complex and cannot be solved informally. To solve such grievances, GRCE has been established at the project level to examine and find solutions to the grievances in a most transparent manner to convince the people that their grievances are well examined. GRCE have been established at Municipality level (one at Kharagauli Municipality and one at Khasuri municipality). The structure and names of the representative of the GRCE is provided in Table 5.1:
53 Table 5.1: Grievance Redress Committee- Section-2 # Grievance Redress Committee Position Name of the Representative of GRCE and Member Contact Details 1 Representative of LAR Member Name: Mr. Archil Jorbenadze Commission (GRCN) of RDMRDI Designation: Coordinator of ADB projects (ETCIC, MRDI) Tel: 591403038 Email: [email protected] 2 Representative of Resettlement Convenor Mr. Shota Batsikadze Division at RD Designation: Project Manager of the Resettlement Division (RDMRDI) Tel: 577613302 Email: [email protected]
3 Representatives of Kharagauli Member Secretary Mr. Jaba Beridze Municipality: Tel: 558785455 Had of Economic Development Division 4 Representatives of Khasuri Member Secretary Mr. Teimuraz Lomuashvili Municipality: Tel: 599770372 Had of Supervision Division 5 Moliti Village 5-i Representative of Gamgebeli in Member Mr. Spartak Lacabidze the territory unit of Molitii Tel: 596117058 5-ii Representative of APs Member Mr. David Lezhava Tel: 577036189 5.iii Representative of Women APs Member Ms. Maka Talakhadze Tel: 577036189 6 Tsipa /Pona Village 6-i Representative of Gamgebeli in Member Mr. Besik Talakhadze the Tsipa territory unit Tel: 598523400 6-ii Representative of APs in Tsipa Member Mr. Vefkhia Beridze vilige Tel: 557 65 46 11 6-iii Representative of Women APs in Member Ms. Rusudan Gurgenidze Tsipa vilige Tel: 553 52 38 57 6-iv Representative of APs Member Mr. Emzari Nozadze in Pona vilige Tel: 571 197124 6-iv Representative of Women APs Member Ms. Meri Nozadze in Pona vilige Tel: 595 327 370 7 Chumateleti Village 7-i Representative of the Surami Member Mr. Valeri Chaduneli territory unit Tel: 599112984 7-ii Representative of APs in Member Mr. Zurab Korkotadze Chumateleti Village Tel: - 599345917 7-iii Representative of Women APs of Member Ms. Daria Korkotadze Chumateleti Village Tel: 599345917
76. The main responsibilities of the GRCE will be as follow:
The GRCE will examine all kinds of disputes or grievances arising out of implementation of the LARP and resolve such disputes and grievances in a most transparent manner. GRCE will not deal with matters pending in the courts of law. Only authorized members will be allowed to participate in the GRCE meetings. Decision of the GRCE will be communicated to the aggrieved APs through writing
54 5.3 Grievance Resolution Process
77. The members of the GRCE will be available during the office hour to address concerns and grievances.. A sample form for grievance to be recorded is attached in Annexure 5.1. The complaints and grievances from the APs will be addressed through the process described below in Table 5.2 and Procedure and steps of grievance redress mechanism is depicted in Figure 5.1. Table 5.2: Grievance Resolution Process Steps Process Step 1 When during the contract discussion any grievances arise, solutions acceptable to both Municipality’s LAR Team and the APs will be sought. If any aggrieved AP is not satisfied with the solutions, the next option will be to lodge grievances to the GRCE. Step 2 If the grievance is not solved at the previous level, the municipality level LAR representative will assist the aggrieved APs to formally lodge the grievances with the respective GRCE at Municipality level. The aggrieved APs will lodge the complaint if there is failure of negotiation at village level and produce documents supporting his/her claim. The GRCE member secretary will review the complaint and prepare a Case File for GRCE hearing and resolution. A formal hearing will be held with the GRCE at a date fixed by the GRCE member secretary in consultation with Convenor and the aggrieved APs. On the date of hearing, the aggrieved AP will appear before the GRCE at the village office and produce evidence in support of his/her claim. The member secretary will note down the statements of the complainant and document all proof. The decisions will be issued by the Convenor and signed by other members of the GRCE. The case record will be be communicated to the complainant AP by the LAR Team at the village level. The grievance redress at this stage shall be completed within 4 weeks Step 3 If any aggrieved AP is unsatisfied with the GRCE decision at Municipality level, the next option will be to lodge grievances to the Grievance Redress Commission (GRCN) at the Resettlement Division at RDMRDI at the national level within 2 weeks after receiving the decision from GRCE. The complainants, must produce documents supporting his/her claim. The GRCN will review the GRCE hearing records and convey its decisions to the aggrieved APs within 4 weeks after receiving the complaint. Step 4 If any aggrieved AP is unsatisfied the decision of GRCN, the aggrieved party may approach the local courts for resolution. Note: 1. The scope of the grievance may not necessarily be related to compensation and assistance and may go beyond the compensation issues 2. Affected Persons can approach the court of law at any time and independent of grievance redress process
55 Figure 5.1: Grievance Redress Mechanism
Affected Persons
Village/Community Level Team)-Contract Grievance Agreement Addressed
Not Addressed Step-2
Grievance Redress Committee at Municipality
Grievance Addressed
Step-3
Not Addressed
GRCN at Resettlement Division at RDMRDI
Step-4
COURT OF LAW (Affected Persons can approach the court of law at time during the Grievance redresal process independent of GRM/GRC and the grievance mechanism should not impede access to the country’s judicial or administrative remedies
56 5.4 GRCE Records and Documentation
78. Resettlement Division of RDMRDI at headquarters will keep record of complaints received for its use as well as for review by ADB during regular supervisions. Records of each each grievance will be kept in the Gamgebeli office and the same copy will be forwarded to the respective municipality office. Roads department will compile the grievance records and a status report will be prepared roads department as to show different kinds of grievances, number of grievances received, number of grievances resolved and the number of pending grievances for further action. The data base will be prepared and updated every six month. Six monthly data base will be compiled and will be incorporated to the semi-annual monitoring report which will then be submitted to ADB. Additionally, training to the construction contractor will be done within the first month of commencement of work. A sample form for the centralized grievance record is attached in Annexure 5.2.
57 CHAPTER 6: POLICY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK
6.1 General
79. The legal and policy framework of the Project is based on national laws and legislations related to Land Acquisition and Resettlement (LAR) in Georgia and ADB’s Safeguard Policy Statement 2009. Based on the analysis of applicable laws and policies and ADB’s Policy requirement, project related LAR principles have been adopted.
6.2 Laws and Regulation of Georgia
80. In Georgia, there are several legislative acts that regulate the issues of state's obtaining privately owned land parcels based on the necessary public needs such as public road constructions: (i) The Constitution of Georgia, August 24, 1995; (ii) The Civil Code of Georgia, June 26, 1997, (iii) The Law of Georgia on Protection of Cultural Heritage; (iv) The Law of Georgia on Notary Actions; (v) The Law of Georgia on Privatization of State-owned Agricultural Land, July 8, 2005; (vi) The Law of Georgia on Ownership Rights to Agricultural Land, March 22, 1996; (vii) The Law of Georgia on Registration Ownership Rights to Immovable Property, December 28, 2005, (viii) The Law of Georgia on the Rules for Expropriation of Ownership for Necessary Public Need, July 23, 1999; and (ix) The Civil Procedural Code of Georgia, November 14, 1997. A synopsis on georgian laws related LAR is provided in Annexure 6.1.
81. The existing Laws provide that compensation for lost assets, including land, structures, trees and standing crops, should be based on the current market price without depreciation. Overall the above laws/regulations provide that the principle of replacement cost compensating at market value is reasonable and legally acceptable. The laws also identify the types of damages eligible to compensation and indicate that compensation is to be given both for loss of physical assets and for the loss of incomes. Finally, these laws place strong emphasis on consultation and notification to ensure that the APs participate in the process. Income loss due to loss of harvest and business closure will be compensated to cover net loss. The above-listed laws and regulations give the possibility of applying the following mechanisms for legal application of the property rights:
(i) Obtaining the right on way without expropriation through the payment of due compensation (on the basis of negotiations or a court decision) prior to commencement of the activities. (ii) Expropriation which gives the possibility of obtaining permanent right to land and/or other real estate property on the basis of Eminent Domain Law or a court decision through the payment of due compensation;
82. Attempts should first be made to acquire private land on the basis of negotiation with individual affected entities. Should the negotiation fail, the power of eminent domain will be sought, and expropriation process will start. Under the existing Law in Georgia, Ministry of Economy and Sustainable Development will issue an order for expropriation based on the request from relevant state agencies. Relevant regional court will assess the presidential order and determine the case of public needs, and grant the expropriation entity rights to obtain land. The court will also appoint a third party to assess the market value of lost assets and determine the compensation payable to relevant land owners accordingly to the value of assets thus found.
58 6.3 ADB's Safeguard Policy Statement, 2009
83. ADB has adopted Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS) in 2009 including safeguard requirements for environment, involuntary resettlement and indigenous people. The objectives of the Involuntary Resettlement Safeguard policy is to avoid involuntary resettlement wherever possible; to minimize involuntary resettlement by exploring project and design alternatives; to enhance, or at least restore, the livelihoods of all displaced persons in real terms relative to pre- project levels; and to improve the standards of living of the displaced poor and other vulnerable groups.
84. The involuntary resettlement safeguards cover physical displacement (relocation, loss of residential land, or loss of shelter) and economic displacement (loss of land, assets, access to assets, income sources, or means of livelihoods) as a result of (i) involuntary acquisition of land, or (ii) involuntary restrictions on land use or on access to legally designated parks and protected areas. It covers them whether such losses and involuntary restrictions are full or partial, permanent or temporary. The three important elements of ADB SPS, 2009 are: (i) compensation at replacement cost for lost assets, livelihood, and income prior to displacement; (ii) assistance for relocation, including provision of relocation sites with appropriate facilities and services; and (iii) assistance for rehabilitation to achieve at least the same level of well-being with the project as without it. ADB SPS, 2009 gives special attention to poor and vulnerable households to ensure their improved well-being as a result of project interventions.
85. The rate of compensation for acquired housing, land and other assets will be calculated at full replacement costs. The calculation of full replacement cost will be based on the following elements: (i) fair market value; (ii) transaction costs; (iii) interest accrued, (iv) transitional and restoration costs; and (v) other applicable payments, if any. Where market conditions are absent or in a formative stage, the borrower/client will consult with the displaced persons and host populations to obtain adequate information about recent land transactions, land value by types, land titles, land use, cropping patterns and crop production, availability of land in the project area and region, and other related information. The borrower/client will also collect baseline data on housing, house types, and construction materials. Qualified and experienced experts will undertake the valuation of acquired assets. In applying this method of valuation, depreciation of structures and assets should not be taken into account. Followings are the basic policy principle of ADB SPS, 2009:
Identification of past, present, and future involuntary resettlement impacts and risks and determination of the scope of resettlement planning. Carry out meaningful consultations with affected persons, host communities, and concerned non-government organizations. Improvement or at least restoration of the livelihoods of all displaced persons, Ensure physically and economically displaced persons with needed assistance. Improvement of the standards of living of the displaced poor and other vulnerable groups. Development of procedures in a transparent, consistent, and equitable manner if land acquisition is through negotiated settlement, Ensure that displaced persons without titles to land or any recognizable legal rights to land are eligible for resettlement assistance and compensation for loss of non-land assets. Preparation of a resettlement plan elaborating on displaced persons’ entitlements, the income and livelihood restoration strategy, institutional arrangements, monitoring and reporting framework, budget, and time-bound implementation schedule.
59 Disclosure of resettlement plan, including documentation of the consultation process in a timely manner to affected persons and other stakeholders. Execution of involuntary resettlement as part of a development project or program. Provide payment of compensation and other resettlement entitlements before physical or economic displacement. Monitoring and assessment of resettlement outcomes, their impacts on the standards of living of displaced persons
6.4 Comparison of ADB SPS, 2009 with Georgian Laws and Legislation
86. Overall, the legislation of Georgia adequately reflects the major provisions of the ADB SPS, 2009 but a few differences are to be noted. The most significant of these differences is that under Georgian legislation/regulation, emphasis is put on the definition of formal property rights and on how the acquisition of properties for public purposes is to be implemented and compensated while in the case of ADB policy emphasis is put both on the compensation of rightfully owned affected assets and on the general rehabilitation of the livelihood of AP and AH. Because of this, ADB policy complements the Georgian legislation/regulation with additional requirements related to (i) the economic rehabilitation of all AP/AH (including those who do not have legal/formal rights on assets acquired by a project); (ii) the provision of indemnities for loss of business and income, (iii) and the provision of special allowances covering AP/AH expenses during the resettlement process or covering the special needs of severely affected or vulnerable AP/AHs. Also, in addition, the legislation of Georgia does not require any specific measure regarding the need to prepare LARPs based on extensive public consultations. The differences between Georgia law/regulation and ADB policy are outlined in Table 6.1.
Table 6.1: Comparison of Georgian Laws on LAR and ADB SPS, 2009 Georgia Laws and Regulations ADB Involuntary Resettlement Policy Land compensation only for titled landowners Lack of title should not be a bar to compensation and/or In practice legaliizable land owners are also rehabilitation. Non-titled landowners receive rehabilitation. compensated after they are issued with the necessary papers Only registered houses/buildings are All affected houses/buildings are compensated for buildings compensated for damages/demolition caused damages/demolition caused by a project by a project Crop losses compensation provided only to Crop losses compensation provided to landowners and registered landowners. sharecrop/lease tenants whether registered or not Land Acquisition Committee is the only pre- Complaints & grievances are resolved informally through litigation final authority to decide disputes and community participation in the Grievance Redress Committees address complaints regarding quantification and (GRCE), Local governments, and NGO and/or local-level assessment of compensation for the affected community based organizations (CBOs). assets. Decisions regarding LAR are discussed only Information on quantification, affected items value assets, between the landowners and the Land entitlements, and compensation/financial assistance amounts Acquisition Authorities. are to be disclosed to the APs prior to appraisal. No provision for income/livelihood ADB policy requires rehabilitation for income/livelihood, rehabilitation, allowances for severely affected severe losses, and for expenses incurred by the APs during or vulnerable APs, or resettlement expenses. the relocation process. No specific plan for public consultation is Public consultation and participation is the integral part of provided under the Georgian laws ADB’s policy which is a continuous process at conception, preparation, implementation and finally at post implementation period
60 6.5 Core LAR Policy Principle for the Project
87. To reconcile the gaps between Georgia laws/regulations and ADB Policy, RDMRDI has adopted this policy for the Project, ensuring compensation at replacement cost of all items, the rehabilitation of informal settlers, and the provision of subsidies or allowances for APs that may be relocated, suffer business losses, or may be severely affected. Based on the Georgian laws on land acquisition and ADBSPS, 2009, the core involuntary resettlement principles are adopted which are as follows:
Land acquisition, and other involuntary resettlement impacts will be avoided or minimized through all viable alternative project designs; where unavoidable, a time-bound LARP will be prepared and APs will be assisted in improving or at least regaining their pre-Project standard of living; consultation with APs on compensation, disclosure of resettlement information to APs, and participation of APs in planning and implementing sub-projects will be ensured; vulnerable and severely affected APs will be provided special assistance; non-titled APs (e.g., informal dwellers or squatters, or APs without registration details) will receive a livelihood allowance in lieu of land compensation and will be fully compensated for losses other than land; legalizable APs will be legalized and fully compensated for land losses; the LARP will be disclosed to the APs in the local language; payment of compensation, resettlement assistance and rehabilitation measures will be fully provided prior to the contractor taking physical acquisition of the land and prior to the commencement of any construction activities on a particular package; and appropriate grievance redresses mechanisms will be established to solve APs grievance if occurs.
6.6 Land Acquisition Process
88. Complete and accurate registration of private land as per current laws governing land acquisition in Georgia is the precondition for proceeding with acquisition of private land by agencies requiring land for land based infrastructure development. For construction of the Project road, RDMRDI will acquire private land under eminent domain through negotiated settlement wherever possible, based on meaningful consultation with APs, including those without legal title to assets. The land buyer will offer adequate and fair price for land and/or other assets. RDMRDI will ensure that the process of land acquisition with the APs openly address the risks of asymmetry of information and bargaining power of the parties involved in such transactions. In case the there is no agreement to land acquisition, expropriation will be sought. During the detailed design stage all the land parcels have been identified and an assessment was done to identify the registered and unregistered parcel. A detailed land acquisition and resettlement plan has been prepared, and estimate of compensation and entitlement of individual APs as per land acquisition and resettlement policy principle and entitlement matrix consistent with ADB SPS, 2009 has been done. The detailed land acquisition plan consists of individual parcel maps and geometric details etc.
89. Following the detailed land acquisition plan, LAR Working Group assisted by LAR Team at municipality level will offer to each of the APs the compensation rates defined in this LARP. Upon successful settlement, Land Purchase Agreements will be signed with legalized/titled owners of acquired land parcels and Agreement of Entitlement with the non-titled APs. Any grievances of the APs will be resolved through approved grievance redress mechanism of the Project. In case an AP does not accept the rates defined in this LARP even after a through the grievance redressing mechanism exercise, RDMRDI will seek concurrence of the appropriate
61 authority in the management for proceeding with Expropriation Process under the eminent domain for acquisition of the land through Municipality courts. Fresh maps of the acquired plots with geometric details required for legalization is being prepared under the detailed LARP. RDMRDI will provide these maps to the concerned legalizable owners. The process will be followed by endorsement of these maps and ownership documents by the municipality and finally getting them registered in the municipality registration office prior to the receipt of the project compensation.
62 CHAPTER 7: ELIGIBILITY AND ENTITLEMENTS
7.1 Eligibility
90. APs entitled for compensation or at least rehabilitation provisions under the Project are: (i) All APs losing land either covered by legal title/traditional land rights, Legalizable, or without legal status; (ii) Tenants and sharecroppers whether registered or not; (iii) Owners of buildings, crops, plants, or other objects attached to the land; and (iv) APs losing business, income, and salaries.
7.2 Cut-off-Date
91. Compensation eligibility is limited by a cut-off- date which was the start of final AP Census and DMS during the detailed design. The cut-off-date for section-2 has been considered to be 30- September-2017 which was the start of the DMS and AP census survey. APs who settle in the affected areas after the cut-off date will not be eligible for compensation. They, however will be given sufficient advance notice, requested to vacate premises and dismantle affected structures prior to project implementation. Their dismantled structures materials will not be confiscated and they will not pay any fine or suffer any sanction.
7.3 Entitlements
92. Entitlement provisions for APs losing land, houses, and income and rehabilitation allowance will include provisions for permanent or temporary land losses, buildings losses, crops and trees losses, a relocation allowances, and a business losses allowance based on tax declarations and/or existing minimum market rates. These entitlements are detailed below:
Agricultural land impacts will be compensated at full replacement cost. When more than 10% of total agricultural land owned by AP is acquired, they will be considered as severely affected APs for which APs (owners, leaseholders and sharecroppers) will get an additional allowance for severe impacts equal to one additional crop compensation or One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042,GEL / AH)11. In case of crop compensation, it is not applicable. Legalizable APs will be legalized and paid as titled owners. APs who are not registered but have residential land or agricultural plots adjacent to the residential land will be fully compensated but not legalized. APs that are not legitimate land users or squatters (these are APs who were not land leasers under the old system or occupy a plot illegally) will be compensated with One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169GEL / AH). If the remaining part of a particular plot becomes inaccessible or unviable for cultivation or for any use after the acquisition, then the same can be compensated if the owner offers.
Non-agricultural land (Residential/commercial land). Titled settlers will be compensated at full replacement cost free of depreciation. Legalizable settlers will be
11The figures used for minimum subsistence allowance are based on the minimum subsistence income x month calculated fora family of 5 persons. The most recent information from National Statistics Office of Georgia for June 2017 is 347.4 GEL perhousehold (of 5 people).
63 legalized, registered in NAPR and compensated as titled APs. Non-titled and non- legalizable land users will be compensated with One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169GEL / AH)
Houses, buildings, and structures will be compensated in cash at full replacement cost free of deductions for depreciation, and transaction costs irrespective of the registration status of the affected land. In case of partial impacts and unwillingness of the owner to relocate, compensation will cover only the affected portion of a building and its full rehabilitation to previous use. Full compensation will be paid if partial impacts imperil the viability of the whole building. Construction materials remaining after the demolition of the structures will be deemed as ownership of the AH.
Crops: Cash compensation at current market rates for the gross value of 1 year’s harvest by default. Crop compensation will be paid both to landowners and tenants based on their specific sharecropping agreements.
Trees: Cash compensation at market price based on type, age and productivity of trees.
Businesses: If business is lost permanently it will be compensated in cash equal to a 1-year income based on tax declaration or, if unavailable, based on the official maximum income waived from income tax; or One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169GEL / AH);. Temporary business losses will be compensated in cash for the business interruption period based on tax declaration or, if unavailable, official maximum income waived from income tax.
Agricultural Tenant: if agricultural tenants are affected, it will be compensated in the form of assistance equivalent to 1 year of cash return from the land under tenancy as per recorded proof, or in its absence, One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169GEL / AH).
Loss of wages/employment: if employees loss their wages due to the project interventions, they will be compensated in the form of assistance equivalent to One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042GEL / AH)
Relocation /Shifting Allowance: APs forced to relocate will receive a relocation subsidy sufficient to cover transport costs and living expenses for 1 month. This includes 250 GEL for vehicle hire plus one time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042GEL / AH)-Total = 1,292 GEL/AH)
Community Structures and Public Utilities: Will be fully replaced or rehabilitated so as to satisfy their pre-project functions with due consultation with local people.
Vulnerable people Livelihood: Vulnerable AH (below poverty line households, women headed households, disabled households and refugees households) will receive one time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042GEL / AH). Multiple vulnerability of one household will be considered as one vulnerable unit.
7.4 Entitlement Matrix
64 93. Tasks under the Project will be implemented according to compensation eligibility and entitlements principles in line with both Georgia laws and regulation and ADB's SPS, 2009. Entitlements matrix is provided in Table 7.1.
65 Table 7.1: Entitlement Matrix Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements Land Permanent loss of AP losing productive Registered Owner/Legal: Cash compensation at full replacement cost. agricultural land land regardless of Owner with full registration If the residual plot becomes unviable for impact severity cultivation, the project will acquire it if the owner so desire. Legalizable Owner: The ownership rights of these APs will be (APs with title formalization recognized, the land registered in NAPR and pending and APs who are the APs provided with cash compensation at full replacement cost. not registered but legitimately use the land and have residential land or agricultural plots adjacent to the residential land) 1.1 Non-legal/Informal 3.1 One time minimum subsistence allowance in Settler: cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month 2.1 APs that are not legitimate x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) land users or squatters Agricultural Tenant One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) Non-Agricultural Land AP losing their Registered Owner/Legal: Cash compensation at full replacement cost. commercial/ (Owner with full residential land registration)
Legalizable Owner: The ownership rights of these APs will be (The owners legalizable recognized, the land registered in NAPR and according to active the APs provided with cash compensation at full replacement cost. legislation)
Non-legal/Informal Settler One time minimum subsistence allowance in (Without registration/valid cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month documents using land x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) permanently.)
Buildings and Structures Residential and non All AHs regardless of their Cash compensation for building/structures residential legal ownership/ losses at full replacement costs free of structures/assets registration status depreciation and transaction costs (including legalizable and Informal Settlers) Loss Of Community Infrastructure/Common Property Resources Loss of common Community/Public Community/Government Reconstruction of the lost resource/asset in property resources Assets consultation with community and restoration of their functions Loss of Income and Livelihood Crops Standing crops All APs regardless of legal Crop compensation in cash at market rate by affected or affected status (including default at to gross crop value of expected agricultural land, used legalizable and Informal harvest. Settlers)
66 Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements permanently for crop cultivation. Trees Trees affected All APs regardless of legal Cash compensation at market rate on the status (including basis of type, age and productive value of the legalizable and Informal trees. Settlers) Business/Employment Business/employment All APs regardless of legal Owner: loss status (including (i) (permanent impact) cash indemnity of 1 legalizable and Informal year net income or in the absence of income Settlers) proof, One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH); (ii) (temporary impact) cash indemnity of net income for months of business stoppage. Assessment to be based on tax declaration or, in its absence, minimum salary. Permanent worker/employees: indemnity for lost wages equal to One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) Allowances Severe Impacts12 >10% income loss All severely affected AHs One time minimum subsistence allowance in including informal settlers cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) Relocation/Shifting Transport/transition All AHs to be relocated An allowance covering transport and costs livelihood expenses for the transitional period. (@ 250 GEL as vehicle hire charge + 347.4 GEL per month x 3 months =1,042 GEL) Total = 1,292 GEL/AH) Vulnerable People AHs below poverty line, One time minimum subsistence allowance in Allowances13 headed by Women, cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x headed by disables and 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) and employment refugees households priority in project-related jobs where feasible Unforeseen impacts Impacts during All APs Due compensation to be assessed and paid during construction construction to when the impacts are identified based on the properties or assets above provisions. out of the corridor of impact or RoW
12Severely affected households in this project include those AHs (i) losing 10% or more than 10% of their productive assets/income generating which is the total land holding of the AH compared to the affected land by the project, (ii) physically displaced HH and (iii) households losing commercial/business establishments. 13Multiple vulnerability of one HH is considered as one and will be paid only one vulnerable allowance
67 7.5 Valuation and Compensation Rates
7.5.1 Principles and Methodology
94. The valuation of assets being affected is done based on the core principle of replacement cost. The calculation of replacement costs is based on (i) fair market value at the time of dispossession, (ii) transaction/legalization costs, (iii) transitional and restoration (land preparation and reconstruction) costs, and (v) other applicable payments. In order to ensure compensation at replacement cost, good practice examples in compliance with ADB policy were followed for determining the replacement cost of acquired assets.
95. The calculation of unit value is done keeping in consideration the current market rate so as to meet with the replacement cost of the land and lost assets etc. An experienced, authorized and registered independent local audit/valuation company was employed to do the valuation of land, structures, buildings, trees, crops etc. The approach of the evaluator was to make the assessment for each type of land and assets by location. The valuation was done when the DMS and AP census were conducted. The valuation company engaged its experts for its respective areas that made site visits for physical verification of each category of the losses. The expert team also took into consideration the reference of previous valuation and also used their recommended periodic release of market survey. Based on this methodology the unit rate was derived. The unit rates used in this report is based on the evaluation agency’s assessment with their standard methods for calculating the sample assets.
7.5.2 Determination of Compensation Rates
96. Land: Replacement cost of land has been determined based on existing market rates to the extent possible and adding the applicable transaction cost like registration with the NAPR at the municipality level Registration Office and the municipality PRRC. Market rates where defined taking into account the type of land, its purported use, and location. The evaluation agency uses the comparative method by collecting prices from various sources such as public registry office, private company dealing with land and property and consulting with people. The land is first categorized by municipality which is Kharagauli and Khasuri. Further, the land is sub categorized in to its use such as agricultural, residential and commercial. Information on the sale deeds as per the public registry is collected on following parameters:
Name of the Place/Settlement/Location Registration code number Date of Transaction Cadastral code number/identified land parcel Type of use of the land parcel Total Area (square meter) Amount of money paid (total) Currency of transaction Exchange rate of currency Total Amount (GEL)
97. Buildings and Structures: Replacement cost of houses/buildings was determined based on construction type, cost of materials, transportation, types of construction, land preparation, labour, and other construction costs at current rates. No deduction for depreciation and transaction costs will be applied. The calculation for buildings and structures are based on the following parameters as collected by the valuation agency.
68 Type of Construction (Roof , wall, floor) Unit of measurement of materials (cubic meter/square meter) Amount of construction materials Price per unit Total amount for the materials Addition of construction cost (such as construction worker, labour etc) to the total amount of materials which becomes the total cost The unit price of material is collected from independent non government agency such as, Association of Construction Appraisal"
98. Crops: Market value of annual crops has been determined at net market rates at the farm gate for the first year crop. In the eventuality that more than one-year compensation is due to the APs the crops after the first will be compensated at gross market value. The valuation agency uses the following method to derive at the crop values and the data is collected from the statistical department.
Name of Crop last six years of total yield (kilogram) data as collected for all 3 municipalities Cultivated area of crops for last six years Average productivity (kilogram per hectare) Average productivity (kilogram/per square meter) Market price per kilogram Total amount per square meter
99. Trees:Market value of trees has been set based on different methods for wood and fruit trees. Wood trees are valued based on growth category and value of wood of the tree at the age the tree was cut. Fruit trees will be compensated differently if they are productive or not yet productive. Productive trees will be compensated based on the future income lost for the years needed to re-grow a tree at the same age/production potential in which was cut. Non productive trees will be compensated based on the value of the investment made to grow the tree to the age in which the tree was cut. Parameters used by the valuation company for assessing the cost of productive trees are as follows:
Name of the tree Age of the tree Average productivity/yield per year Starting age of the production (Year) Life of productivity (years) Price of the seed to plant the tree Price of the fruit in the market Yield from the tree (kilogram) Expenses related to maintenance of the tree The unit cost for productive tree is finally derived {(price of the fruit X total yielding - Expenses) X remaining years of productivity)}
100. The unit compensation rates recommended by the valuation company will be reviewed and approved by the RDMRDI and will be offered to the APs. Detailed methodology for determining valuations and compensation rates is included in Annexure -7.1. A separate volume containing individual assessment for each asset is also being submitted to roads department.
69 CHAPTER 8: RELOCATION AND INCOME RESTORATION
101. The project will adopt self relocation policy by the APs. There is no provision for land for land compensation or structure for structure compensation. The strategy will be based on cash based compensation which the APs have agreed during the consultation. A total of 234 structures are to be affected by the project of which only 10 structures are residential and 1is commercial/restaurant which needs relocation. Remaining structures are auxiliary structures. Households losing either a house or a business will be compensated in cash at replacement cost. Additional provision such as relocation assistance in terms of vehicle hire and minimum subsistence allowance 3 months will be provided to APs in addition to the replacement cost for the structures needing relocation. APs will be given advance notice to dismantle their structures and they will have right to the salvaged materials. The APs are mostly involved in small scale economic activities and dependent on pension etc, therefore, loss of income is not severe and also the one commercial structure which is a restaurant is also not operational as found during the survey. Provisions for additional assistances such as assistance for severely affected households, vulnerable households etc. have been made in the entitlement which will assist the APs in restoring their loss.
70 CHAPTER 9: RESETTLEMENT BUDGET AND FINANCING PLAN
102. The resettlement cost estimate for the Section-2 road project includes eligible compensation, resettlement assistance and support cost for LARP implementation as per the entitlement matrix. The unit cost and the evaluation is done based on the inventory of assets. A qualified and authorized evaluation company (Ltd ''ATOS'') was engaged to do the valuation of all assets. The assessment is done keeping in consideration the current market value/replacement cost of each lost assets. The LAR cost estimate includes the following:
Compensation for land compensation for structures and buildings Compensation for trees Compensation for crops Assistance for severely affected households Assistance for Relocation and shifting of the structures Assistance for vulnerable groups Cost for Monitoring Administrative cost for implementation of LARP.
103. All LAR related costs, including cost of compensation for land acquisition and resettlement and administration, will be considered an integral part of Project cost and will be contributed as a counterpart fund by the Georgia Government, in particular RDMRDI. The total estimated cost for the LARP for section-2 road section of the Project is approximately 2.01 million GEL equivalents to 0.80 million US Dollar. Contingency provisions (@ 10% of the total cost) have also been made to take into account variations from this estimate. In case of any over-run in cost, RDMRDI will provide additional funds as needed in a timely fashion RDMRDI is responsible for the timely allocation of the funds needed to implement the LARP. As per the land acquisition and resettlementfund flow, the budget for compensation and rehabilitation will be directly disbursed by RDMRDI to the AP. Summary of LAR cost is given in Table 9.1. Detailed compensation matrix for each individual parcels and individual affected households are provided in Annexure 9.1.
71 Table 9.1: LAR Cost # Item Unit Cost Quantity Amount (GEL) A Compensation A-1 Compensation for Land As per the assessment done by 46,098 (sqm) 248,650 the valuation company A-2 Compensation for Buildings As per the assessment done by 234 (numbers) 826,707 and Structures the valuation company A-3 Compensation for Trees As per the assessment done by 3,375 (numbers) 343,959 the valuation company A-4 Compensation for Crops As per the assessment done by 4993 (sqm) 1,375 the valuation company Sub Total A 1,420,691 B Assistance/Allowance B-1 Severely Affected One time minimum subsistence 35 36,470 Households allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) B-2 Structures Needing An allowance covering transport 11 14,212 Relocation (only residential and livelihood expenses for the and commercial structure in transitional period. (@ 250 GEL this case for relocation) as vehicle hire charge + @347.4 GEL per month x 3 months =1,042 GEL) Total = 1,292 GEL/AH) B-3 Vulnerable Households One time minimum subsistence 80 60,436 allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) Sub Total B 111,118 C Support Cost for RP Implementation C-1 Administrative Cost 300,000 Sub Total C 300,000 Total LAR Cost (A+B+C) 1,831,809 Contingency (@10 %) 183,181 Grand Total 2,014,990 Grand Total in Million GEL 2.01 Grand Total in Million US$ 1 USD= 2.52 GEL 0.80
72 CHAPTER 10: INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
10.1. General
104. MRDI is the EA of the Project on behalf of the Government of Georgia and the RDMRDI is the IA. ADB is the funding agency of the project. RDMRDI will have lead responsibility for implementation of the Project as well acquisition of land and implementation of the LARP. RDMRDI is assisted by a number of other government departments and private agencies in the design, construction and operation of the Project. Pursuant to the active legislations, National Agency of Public Registry (NAPR) within the Ministry of Justice is in charge of the recognition of ownership rights of rightful owners, registration of land ownership, with process verification and certification from Village Communities, Notaries, Property Rights Recognition Commission (PRRC), and sakrebulo. Municipality NAPR is also responsible for registering transfer of acquired land from landowners to the RDMRDI. The local government at Municipality and sakrebulo levels are involved in the legalization of legalizable land parcels and subsequently land acquisition and resettlement of APs. The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Protection is responsible for environmental issues. The Project road will cover two administrative municipalitys such as Kharagauli and Khasuri. The overall organization structure for implementaion of the loan as per the project administration manual (PAM) is depicted in Figure 10.1.
73 Figure 10.1: Project Organization Structure
74 10.2. RDMRDI
105. RDMRDI will act as IA and will have overall responsibility of planning and implementation and monitoring of the Project and the LARP. This includes preparation, implementation and financing of all LAR tasks and cross-agency coordination. RDMRDI has a specific division dealing with resettlement in the name of Resettlement Division (RD). The resettlement division will be responsible for the general management of the planning and implementation of all LAR tasks and will coordinate with other line agencies. The resettlement division of RDMRDI is staffed with LAR specialists, will be tasked with all LAR coordination tasks at central and local government level
10.3. LAR Commission (LARC)
106. LAR Commission (LARC) within RDMRDI has the authority to finally endorse all LAR related decisions and actions (i.e. approval of LARP, initiation of compensation payments etc.). LARC sits for reviewing issues for decision on as and when necessary basis. LARC will oversee and monitor implementation of the LARP to ensure that all APs are duly compensated and that mitigating measures are instituted by the civil works contractor as a result of unforeseen impacts. It is also the final pre-litigation authority to provide decision on grievances those cannot be resolved at the municipality level. LARC will ensure that the Project is implemented in accordance with the ADB policy requirements and the approved LARP.
107. The structure of the LARC and Working Group includes experienced and skilled experts of economics and law, who simultaneously take responsible positions in RDMRDI. In case of need, on the basis of agreement with RDMRDI management and LARC the structure of the working group can be expanded inviting professionals of different sectors in response of the volume of LAR work for a project. The specific tasks of the working group and resettlement division will be to (i) updating LARP following appropriate procedures as per detailed design and send to ADB for approval, (ii) supervise preparation of LARP for construction contracts and implement it after concurrence from ADB; (iii) establish LAR capacity at the municipality level and (iv) ensure proper internal monitoring. The LARC will also provide all necessary documentation to ensure the prompt allocation of land acquisition and resettlement budgets to the APs and will maintain the coordination of all land acquisition and resettlement related activities.
10.4. Euroasian Transport Corridor Investment Center (ETCIC)
108. Euroasian Transport Corridor Investment Center (ETCIC) as Legal Entity of Public Law, has been established pursuant to Presidents order #161, dated April 21, 2000. ETCIC provides financial management for ADB projects, receiving appropriate funds directly from the Ministry of Finance Georgia on project's account and disburses to APs following requisition from RD, RDMRDI. ETCIC will review, scrutinize and transfer the amount of compensation and allowances in the bank account of APs mentioned in the Compensation and Allowance Ledger prepared, confirmed and produced by resettlement unit for each AP.
10.5. Municipality LAR Team
109. Municipality LAR Team will assist the central LARC and provide assistance to APs in the process of legalization of legalizable owners. Based on the RDMRDI's LARC decision and the LARP prices, the offer of purchase of land parcels shall be undertaken. If an AP agrees on the acquisition he/she will confirm such agreement in writing by signing the sales/purchase agreement that will be registered with the Public Registry. This agreement will serve as the basis
75 for compensation payment processing and release. If agreement is not reached between the AP and the LAR Team, the later will inform the LARC, which will take decision to start expropriation.
10.6. Local Governments
110. Local government especially at Municipality level has direct jurisdiction for land administration, valuation, verification and acquisition. To confirm the surveys and the asset valuations carried out by the LAR consultants, RDMRDI through its consultants will establish in Municipality where LARPs are to be implemented a Municipality Level LAR team which will have designated officials from the Municipality administration. The LAR team at Municipality level will have close coordination with the village administration (sakrebulo) for the LAR activities.
10.7. Consultants
111. RDMRDI has been supported by the detailed design consultant to prepare the implementation ready l LARP.. In case of any additional or unforeseen impact, Roads Department will handle it thorough its Resettlement Division and Social Safeguard Specialist of theSupervision Consultant.
10.8. Other Agencies and Institutions
112. Several other institutions will participate to the preparation and implementation of LAR tasks. These are:
(i) Ministry of Finance: The budgets for the implementation of the LARP will be provided to RDMRDI by the Ministry of Finance following the official approval of the final LARP.
(ii) Ministry of Justice:The Ministry of Justice is responsible for legal matters regarding land ownership, and National Agency of Public Registry within the Ministry of Justice is in charge of the registration of land ownership and its transfer through purchase agreement from landowners to the Roads Department.
(iii) Local Courts: In case of expropriation issues RDMRDI will have to rely on the Municipality court which based on due legal process will have to review the expropriation cases, carry out a hearing and decide whether the land can be expropriated and at what price. In order to expedite the expropriation process RDMRI will negotiate with the courts a fast-tracked action plan.
(iv) ADB: Besides supervising periodically the Project, ADB will review the LARP and provide clearance to contract awards signing and initiation of civil works to all subprojects with LAR.
113. An organization chart showing the institutional mechanism to handle LAR activities is depicted in Figure 10.2.
10.9. Capacity Building on LAR
114. The detailed LARP has been prepared with due consultation and participation of the concerned LAR officials of Resettlement Division in Roads Department. In terms of capacity and manpower resources within Resettlement Division of Roads Department is concerned, dedicated staff related to resettlement planning and implementation have been designated and the Resettlement Division is headed by the head of the Resettlement Division of Roads Department
76 and is supported by the deputy head of Resettlement Division. These officials are experienced in implementing ongoing ADB financed projects and World Bank funded projects. The staff of the resettlement division was provided with the following training during the year 2015-2016 under the ADB TA 7433-REG (the RETA programMainstreaming Land Acquisition and Resettlement in the Central and West Asia Region) :
Training on Development of Grievance Redress Mechanism for ADB financed Projects - 7 July 2015, ADB Resident Mission, Tbilisi, Georgia. 2. “Monitoring Mechanisms in ADB Financed Projects” - 19-20 October 2015, Kvareli, Georgia. Participants: Mariam Gogishvili (Head of Resettlement and Environmental Protection Division, RD), Pikria Kvernadze (Head of Legal Division, RD) Nino Mtsuravishvili (Head of Resettlement Unit, RD), Gia Sopadze (Head of Environmental Protection Unit, RD), Mariam Begiashvili (Consultant of Resettlement and Environmental Protection Division, RD), Mamuka Gelekva (Local Consultant of Resettlement and Environment Protection Division, RD), Giorgi Iremashvili (Senior Specialist of Resettlement Unit, RD)Archil Jorbenadze (ADB Project Coordinator, ETCIC/TRRC)
Regional Valuation Workshop - Mainstreaming Land Acquisition and Resettlement Safeguards in Central and West Asia - 26-27 November 2015, Baku, Azerbaijan. Participants: Mariam Gogishvili (Head of Resettlement and Environmental Protection Division, RD)
General training for new staff of PIU/CC/SC – on ADB Environmental Safeguards Requirements and new Waste Management Code of Georgia – 25 January 2016, ADB Resident Mission, Tbilisi, Georgia. Participants: Gia Sopadze (Head of Environmental Protection Unit, RD), Rusudan Gholijashvili (Senior Specialist of Environmental Protection Unit, RD).
115. It is also proposed that further training will be provided under the ADB RETA for capacity building of executing agencies on involuntary resettlement. Training will cover the following topics: (i) Principles and procedures of land acquisition (ADB and GOG); (ii) Stakeholder engagement (iii) Public consultation and participation process; (iv) Entitlements and compensation and assistance disbursement mechanisms; (v) Grievance redress; and (vi) Monitoring of resettlement operations.
77 Figure 10.2: Institutional Arrangements for LAR
Government of MRDI MOF ADB Georgia
RDMRDI ETCIC
Resettlement LAR Detailed Design Supervision Division-RDMRDI Commission Consultant Consultant/EMA
LAR Working Group in Field
Municipality PRRC NAPR Administration Sakrebulo/Ga mgebeli
Affected Persons
78 CHAPTER 11: IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE
11.1 General
116. The time for implementation of resettlement plan will be scheduled as per the overall project implementation. All activities related to the land acquisition and resettlement must be planned to ensure that compensation is paid prior to displacement and commencement of civil works. Public consultation, monitoring and grievance redress will be undertaken throughout the project duration. This being a liner project, it might be difficult to complete the implementation of resettlement activities for the entire road section at one time which might delay the civil work construction. Therefore, a phase wise approach can be adopted for civil work construction, i.e., construction can be initiated in the section where compensation is paid.
11.2 Detailed Design Stage
117. Setting up relevant institutions for the LAR activities is in progress. Final LARP based on the detailed design has been prepared and is being submitted for approval of ADB and RDMRDI. The detailed and final LARP includes final impact assessment, detailed measurement surveys, preparation of individual parcel maps, and legalization of legalizable owners and updating of compensation rates etc. The final LARP is being sent to ADB for approval and upon the approval, the LARP will be disclosed. The pre implementation LAR activities during this detailed design stage are as below which are under progress:
Establishment of LAR Institutions; Legalization of legalizable parcels Updating of LAR Budgets Confirmation of updated impact data and of compensation amounts; Approval of LARP by ADB and Government and subsequent disclosure
11.3 LARP Implementation Stage
118. Upon the approval of detailed/final LARP, all the arrangements for fixing the compensation and the disbursement needs to be done which includes issuance of Identity cards (IDs), payment of all eligible compensation and assistance; initiation of rehabilitation measures; site preparation for delivering the site to contractors for construction and finally commencement of the civil work. Following task will be undertaken during the LARP implementation stage:
Signing of contracts with APs Grievance resolution Requisition to ETCIS for payment of compensation and allowances Transfer of compensation and allowance to APs' bank account and registration of land in NAPR on RDMRDI name Execution of eventual expropriation cases if required and if applicable Compliance review and reporting Notice to proceed for Civil works construction
79 11.4 LARP Monitoring Stage
119. Monitoring of the LARP implementation will be done simultaneously and will be reported in the form of a semi annual monitoring report.
11.5 Implementation Schedule
120. This is a tentative schedule for LARP implementation for the section-2 road section. However, pahse wise implementation mechanism may be followed in order to start the civil work in the completed section and to simultaneously proceed with the implementation of LARP for other sections. The schedule can be adjusted during detailed design. The tentative implementation Schedule is provided in Table 11.1.
Table 11.1: Implementation Schedule (Section-2) LARP Activities 2017 2018 2019
8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 Finalization of Detailed alignment by detailed design consultant and approval of RoW Community Consultation Issuance of notification on cut-off-date during detailed design Dissemination and Disclosure of Leaflet to the APs DMS and AP Census Draft LARP based on Detailed Design Submission of Final LARP for ADB Approval Disclosure of LARP in ADB and RDMRDI website Establishment of Municipality LAR team and designated staff at Resettlement Division at MRDI Legalization Process of the Legalizable B. LARP Implementation Issuance of IDs to APs and contract negotiation Payment of compensation to APs Payment of all eligible assistance All milestones linking LARP tasks and civil work tasks Preparation and submission of Compliance Report on LARP implementation
80 LARP Activities 2017 2018 2019
8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 All necessary approval from ADB and GoG and no objection from ADB Takeover possession of acquired property Handover land to contractors Schedule for Civil Work
C. Monitoring Internal Monitoring by RDMRDI Evaluation One year after completion of the implementaion of LARP and after complete disbursement of compensation and assitance etc.
81 CHAPTER 12: MONITORING AND REPORTING
12.1 General
121. RDMRDI will monitor and measure the progress of implementation of the LARP. In addition to recording the progress in compensation payment and other resettlement activities, RDMRDI will prepare monitoring reports to ensure that the implementation of the LARP has produced the desired outcomes. RDMRI will also ensure that a compliance report is prepared immediately after the completion of compensation and assistance program to ensure that the LARP activities have been completed and implemented as per the LARP. An evaluation report will also be prepared after one year of completion of LARP implementation.
12.2 Level of Monitoring
12.2.1. International Monitoring
122. Monitoring of LAR task in the Project will be carried out internally. Regular internal monitoring will be the responsibility of Resettlement division at roads department. The resettlement division will carry out regular internal monitoring for the RDMRDI with inputs from LAR teams at field operation. Internal monitoring will be carried out routinely by resettlement division in the roads department during implementation of the LARP. The results will be communicated to ADB semi- annually. The report of internal monitoring will contain: (i) accomplishment to-date, (ii) objectives attained and not attained during the period, (iii) problems encountered, and (iv) grievance redress and (v) future target for pending activities if any. The internal monitoring report will primarily be prepared by the resettlement division of roads department.
12.2.2. Preparation of Compliance Report
123. RDMRDI will ensure that a compliance report on the completion of LARP is prepared immediately after the completion of compensation process. The objective of the compliance report will be to vouch for the proper implementation of the LARP for all affected impacts and APs based on the impacts assessment figures, compensation rates and procedures set up in the document. The compliance report will be prepared immediately after the conclusion of the compensation process by an independent monitoring agency/consultant. A compliance report proving full compliance with the LARP will be a condition for the provision by ADB of no-objection to start civil works in the road sections with impacts. The compliance report will entail the following activities:
a thorough comparison of the impacts/AP figures provided by the LARP with the compensation tallies which will have to match. A reconciliation of differences between figures in the LARP and figures in the compensation tallies in case of changes in impact figures and AP number due to modifications in project design or errors in the LARP, an analysis of eventual complaints and of their solution, an AP satisfaction survey to be carried out through interviews with the APs a set of recommendations for the preparation and implementation of future LARPs.
12.2.3. Preparation of Evaluation Report
82 124. The task under the evaluation will entail the preparation of an Evaluation report assessing the degree to which the compensation program for the project managed to maintain the pre- project standards of living and incomes of the APs. The report will be prepared one year after the conclusion of the compensation program by and independent Monitoring Agency and will be based on a comparison of the data on income and living standards of the Aps before and after the compensation program
12.3 Monitoring Indicators
125. Broad monitoring indicator is described in Table 12.1.
Table 12.1: Monitoring Indicators Monitoring Indicator Responsible Agency and Basis for Indicators Reporting Location This will be done internally by Composition and structure: ages, the resettlement division at educational and skill levels Roads Department and will be Gender of household head reported to ADB on Semi- Ethnic group annual basis Access to health, education, utilities, and other social services Housing type Land and other resource ownership Basic Information and utilization patterns on AP Households Occupations and employment patterns Income sources and levels Agricultural production data (for rural households) Participation in neighbourhood or community groups Access to cultural sites and events Value of all asset forming entitlements and resettlement entitlements What changes have occurred in terms This will be done by the of patterns of occupation, production, RDMRDI and will be reported and resource use compared to the pre- to ADB on a semi annual basis. project situation? What changes have occurred in income and expenditure patterns compared to the pre-project situation? Benefit Monitoring What have been the changes in cost of living compared to the pre-project situation? Have APs’ incomes kept pace with these changes? What changes have taken place in key social and cultural parameters relating to living standards? Were house compensations made free This will be done by the of depreciation, fees or transfer costs to RDMRDI and will be reported Restoration of the APs? to ADB on a semi annual basis. Living Standards Have perceptions of community been changed? Have the AP achieved replacement of
83 Monitoring Indicator Responsible Agency and Basis for Indicators Reporting key social and cultural elements? Were compensation payments free of This will be done by the deduction for depreciation, fees or RDMRDI and will be reported transfer costs to the AP? to ADB on a semi annual basis. Were compensation payments sufficient to replace lost assets? Was sufficient replacement land available of suitable standard? Did transfer and relocation payments Restoration of cover these costs? Livelihood Did income substitution allow for re- establishment of enterprises and production? Have enterprises affected received sufficient assistance to re-establish themselves? Do jobs provided restore pre-project income levels and living standards? How much does the AP know about This will be done by the resettlement, procedures and RDMRDI and will be reported entitlements? to ADB on a semi annual basis. Do they know if these have been met? How do the AP assess the extent to which their own living standards and Levels of AP livelihoods Satisfaction Have been restored? How much does the AP know about grievance and conflict resolution procedures? How did resettlement implementers deal with unforeseen problems? Were the AP and their assets correctly This will be done by the enumerated? RDMRDI and will be reported Were land speculators assisted? to ADB on a semi annual basis. Effectiveness of Was the time frame and budget Resettlement sufficient to meet objectives? Planning Were entitlements too appropriate (wide or narrow)? Were vulnerable groups identified and assisted? Were there unintended environmental This will be done by the impacts? RDMRDI and will be reported Other Impacts Were there unintended impacts on to ADB on a semi annual basis. employment or incomes?
84 ANNEXURE
85 ANNEXURE 1.1: DETAILS ON WIDTH OF THE RIGHT OF WAY AS PER DETAILED DESIGN (Km. 24.620 to km. 50.244 (Section-2) Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) Km. 24.620 to Km. 25.000 24.620 +24.700 22.29 24.700 + 24.800 18.05 24.800 + 24.900 19.91 24.800 + 25.000 20.97 Km. 25.000 to Km. 26.000 25.000 + 25.100 20.42 25.100 + 25.200 23.54 25.200 + 25.300 17.16 25.300 + 25.400 19.27 25.400 + 25.500 23.17 25.500 + 25.600 21.77 25.600 + 25.700 20.97 25.700 + 25.800 20.64 25.800 + 25.900 20.57 25.900 + 26.000 23.28 Km. 26.000 to Km. 27.000 26.000 + 26.100 22.75 26.100 + 26.200 23.89 26.200 + 26.300 27.59 26.300 + 26.400 47.04 26.400 + 26.500 29.74 26.500 + 26.600 23.7 26.600 + 26.700 25.14 26.700 + 26.800 21.53 26.800 + 26.900 25.2 26.900 + 27.000 21.94 Km. 27.000 to Km. 28.000 27.000 + 27.100 27.78 27.100 + 27.200 26.84 27.200 + 27.300 26.17 27.300 + 27.400 32.32 27.400 + 27.500 28.61 27.500 + 27.600 17.97 27.600 + 27.700 21.81 27.700 + 27.800 22.59 27.800 + 27.900 20.78 27.900 + 28.000 25.46 Km. 28.000 to Km. 29.000 28.000 + 28.100 16.24
86 Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) 28.100 + 28.200 17.69 28.200 + 28.300 20.88 28.300 + 28.400 19.65 28.400 + 28.500 21.87 28.500 + 28.600 25.29 28.600 + 28.700 26.11 28.700 + 28.800 14.62 28.800 + 28.900 14.93 28.900 + 29.000 18.55 Km. 29.000 to Km. 30.000 29.000 + 29.100 16.54 29.100 + 29.200 26.46 29.200 + 29.300 25.72 29.300 + 29.400 20.44 29.400 + 29.500 22.02 29.500 + 29.600 17.61 29.600 + 29.700 19.42 29.700 + 29.800 17.62 29.800 + 29.900 16.69 29.900 + 30.000 28.99 Km. 30.000 to Km. 31.000 30.000 + 30.100 22.41 30.100 + 30.200 18.15 30.200 + 30.300 20.64 30.300 + 30.400 22.26 30.400 + 30.500 22.35 30.500 + 30.600 16.02 30.600 + 30.700 17.79 30.700 + 30.800 30.800 + 30.900 30.900 + 31.000 Km. 31.000 to Km. 32.000 31.000 + 31.100 31.100 + 31.200 31.200 + 31.310 31.310 + 31.400 28.31 31.400 + 31.500 25.49 31.500 + 31.600 31.8 31.600 + 31.700 23.75 31.700 + 31.800 18.18 31.800 + 31.900 17.37 31.900 + 32.000 23.15
87 Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) Km. 32.000 to Km. 33.000 32.000 + 32.100 15.78 32.100 + 32.200 15.41 32.200 + 32.320 23.13 32.320 + 32.400 24.52 32.400 + 32.500 27.92 32.500 + 32.600 21.79 32.600 + 32.700 18 32.700 + 32.800 20.32 32.800 + 32.900 23.74 32.900 + 33.000 20.91 Km. 33.000 to Km. 34.000 33.000 + 33.100 23.18 33.100 + 33.200 22.24 33.200 + 33.330 21.27 33.330 + 33.400 35.82 33.400 + 33.500 19.8 33.500 + 33.600 19.6 33.600 + 33.700 21.73 33.700 + 33.800 18.69 33.800 + 33.900 20.45 33.900 + 34.000 17.87 Km. 34.000 to Km. 35.000 34.000 + 34.100 17.35 34.100 + 34.200 20.65 34.200 + 34.340 20.07 34.340 + 34.400 29.7 34.400 + 34.500 28.16 34.500 + 34.600 19.31 34.600 + 34.700 18.39 34.700 + 34.800 20.69 34.800 + 34.900 20.79 34.900 + 35.000 23.46 Km. 35.000 to Km. 36.000 35.000 + 35.100 24.33 35.100 + 35.200 18.55 35.200 + 35.350 19.77 35.350 + 35.400 15.46 35.400 + 35.500 19.36 35.500 + 35.600 17.8 35.600 + 35.700 21.23 35.700 + 35.800 21.89
88 Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) 35.800 + 35.900 25.2 35.900 + 36.000 21.12 Km. 36.000 to Km. 37.000 36.000 + 36.100 24.52 36.100 + 36.200 24.43 36.200 + 36.360 23.09 36.360 + 36.400 23.43 36.400 + 36.500 20.73 36.500 + 36.600 21.31 36.600 + 36.700 17.97 36.700 + 36.800 24.28 36.800 + 36.900 22.5 36.900 + 37.000 20.07 Km. 37.000 to Km. 38.000 37.000 + 37.100 22.92 37.100 + 37.200 17.66 37.200 + 37.370 20.34 37.370 + 37.400 21.72 37.400 + 37.500 18.3 37.500 + 37.600 15.97 37.600 + 37.700 20.41 37.700 + 37.800 19.39 37.800 + 37.900 31.33 37.900 + 38.000 29.62 Km. 38.000 to Km. 39.000 38.000 + 38.100 25.66 38.100 + 38.200 19.04 38.200 + 38.380 22.31 38.380 + 38.400 20.93 38.400 + 38.500 21.43 38.500 + 38.600 23.05 38.600 + 38.700 20.01 38.700 + 38.800 15.44 38.800 + 38.900 19.96 38.900 + 39.000 19.79 Km. 39.000 to Km. 40.000 39.000 + 39.100 24.38 39.100 + 39.200 22.52 39.200 + 39.390 28.15 39.390 + 39.400 19.08 39.400 + 39.500 18.29 39.500 + 39.600 20.62
89 Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) 39.600 + 39.700 16.31 39.700 + 39.800 18.58 39.800 + 39.900 20.24 39.900 + 40.000 19.37 Km. 40.000 to Km. 41.000 40.000 + 40.100 17.67 40.100 + 40.200 22.54 40.200 + 40.400 25.85 40.400 + 40.400 20.16 40.400 + 40.500 23.61 40.500 + 40.600 24.65 40.600 + 40.700 21.39 40.700 + 40.800 24.27 40.800 + 40.900 28.17 40.900 + 41.000 31.3 Km. 41.000 to Km. 42.000 41.000 + 41.100 26.22 41.100 + 41.200 22.07 41.200 + 41.410 24.58 41.410 + 41.410 21.48 41.410 + 41.500 19.18 41.500 + 41.600 24.01 41.600 + 41.700 21.15 41.700 + 41.800 22.2 41.800 + 41.900 21.4 41.900 + 42.000 22.21 Km. 42.000 to Km. 43.000 42.000 + 42.100 27.44 42.100 + 42.200 29.56 42.200 + 42.420 19.76 42.420 + 42.420 25.22 42.420 + 42.500 23.46 42.500 + 42.600 20.03 42.600 + 42.700 19.98 42.700 + 42.800 18.92 42.800 + 42.900 18.55 42.900 + 43.000 19.83 Km. 43.000 to Km. 44.000 43.000 + 43.100 16.92 43.100 + 43.200 18.44 43.200 + 43.430 20.59 43.430 + 43.430 19.32
90 Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) 43.430 + 43.500 13.79 43.500 + 43.600 14.45 43.600 + 43.700 16.4 43.700 + 43.800 15.95 43.800 + 43.900 20.32 43.900 + 44.000 18.25 Km. 44.000 to Km. 45.000 44.000 + 44.100 17.84 44.100 + 44.200 19.33 44.200 + 44.440 23.33 44.440 + 44.440 18.73 44.440 + 44.500 19.53 44.500 + 44.600 20.44 44.600 + 44.700 20.6 44.700 + 44.800 22.97 44.800 + 44.900 20.42 44.900 + 45.000 20.2 Km. 45.000 to Km. 46.000 45.000 + 45.100 20.62 45.100 + 45.200 22.03 45.200 + 45.450 21.99 45.450 + 45.450 21.53 45.450 + 45.500 18.43 45.500 + 45.600 19.09 45.600 + 45.700 16.28 45.700 + 45.800 17.18 45.800 + 45.900 17.77 45.900 + 46.000 15.24 Km. 46.000 to Km. 47.000 46.000 + 46.100 15.23 46.100 + 46.200 23.12 46.200 + 46.460 22.43 46.460 + 46.460 19.89 46.460 + 46.500 16.47 46.500 + 46.600 16.62 46.600 + 46.700 15.61 46.700 + 46.800 23.18 46.800 + 46.900 16.57 46.900 + 47.000 24.2 Km. 47.000 to Km. 48.000 47.000 + 47.100 22.81 47.100 + 47.200 34.27
91 Design Chainage Design Right of Way (Meter) 47.200 + 47.470 23.82 47.470 + 47.470 16.78 47.470 + 47.500 18.15 47.500 + 47.600 18.78 47.600 + 47.700 17.05 47.700 + 47.800 22.05 47.800 + 47.900 14.93 47.900 + 48.000 16.74 Km. 48.000 to Km. 49.000 48.000 + 48.100 15.57 48.100 + 48.200 17.61 48.200 + 48.480 25.17 48.480 + 48.480 26.41 48.480 + 48.500 14.58 48.500 + 48.600 14.45 48.600 + 48.700 16.6 48.700 + 48.800 16.19 48.800 + 48.900 17.95 48.900 + 49.000 25.33 Km. 49.000 to Km. 50.000 49.000 + 49.100 21.87 49.100 + 49.200 13.88 49.200 + 49.490 20.07 49.490 + 49.490 24.51 49.490 + 49.500 17.67 49.500 + 49.600 13.71 49.600 + 49.700 12.5 49.700 + 49.800 17.58 49.800 + 49.900 14.18 49.900 + 50.000 14.09 Km. 50.000 to Km. 50.244 50.000 + 50.100 11.6 50.100 + 50.200 16.58 50.200 + 50.244 27.44
92 ANNEXURE 2.1: CENSUS SURVEY (DETAILED INVENTORY) QUESTIONNAIRE
A. GENERAL A-1. Name of Project: Dzirula-Kharagauli-Chumateleti A-2. Village/Town : A-3. District:
A-4 Project Chainage/Km:
A-5. GPS Coordinate: X Y
B. DETAILS ON LAND PARCEL
B-1 Land Parcel No (as per survey number): B-1.1 Whether registered or un registered: 1. Registered 2. Un Registered In case of Registered Parcel, please mention the parcel number as per cadastral B-1.2 number: B-2 First/Last Name and ID Number of Owner/User B-2.1 First Name B-2.2 Last Name B-2.3 ID Number B-3 Total Area of the Parcel(m2): B-4 Affected Area of the Parcel (m2) Total Land Holding of the Household/Family in Hectare (affected and other land B-5 holding inside and outside project area) B-6 Ownership of Land: 1. Private, 2. State-owned B-8 Type of Owner 1 - Registered/legalized; 2 - Eligible/ Legalizable; 3 - Unauthorized/squatter/non- legalizable Legal Status of the Land Owner/User: B-9 1- Owner ; 2.- Formal lessee; 3- Informal lessee Type of Land Parcel: B-10 1- Agricultural ; 2- Non-Agricultural B-11 In case of Agricultural land What is the Use of Agricultural Land: B-11.1 1- Arable; 2- Orchard; 3- Pasture; 4- Other (Specify)...... Irrigation Status B-11.2 1- Irrigated; 2- Drained; 3- Non-Irrigated/drained B-12 In Case of Non-Agricultural land What is the use of land B-12.1 1- Residential; 2- Commercial; 3- Other (Specify) What would be the current market rate according to you per square meter (GEL)- B-13 (Affected Person's estimate/view)
93 C. DETAILS ON ASSOCIATED USERS/PERSONS ON THE LAND Agricultural Laborer C-1 1. Yes 2. No C-1.1 If Yes (How many in Numbers) C-1.2 Men C-1.3 Women Is there any formal rent agreement made between owner and agricultural Labourer C-1.4 1. Yes 2. No Agricultural Tenant C-2 1. Yes 2. No C-2.1 If Yes (How many in Numbers) C-2.2 Men C-2.3 Women Is there any formal rent agreement made between owner and agricutural tenant C-2-4 1. Yes 2. No C-3 Agricultural Share Cropper 1. Yes 2. No C-3.1 If Yes (How many in Numbers) C-3.2 Men C-3.3 Women Is there any formal rent agreement made between owner and agricutural share C-3-4 cropper 1. Yes 2. No
D. IMPACT ON PLANTS/TRESS ON AFFECTED LAND Type of Trees Yield Market price as 1. Fruit Trees (kg/tree) in Quantity Age per Affected Sl No Name of Plant/Trees 2. Non- case of fruit (Numbers) (Approximate) Person's Fruit/Timber trees per Estimate Trees season D-1 D-2 D-3 D-4 D-5 D-6 D-7 D-8 D-9 D-10 D-11 D-12 D-13 D-14 D-15 D-16 D-17
94 E. IMPACT ON CROPS Cultivated Area Average Yield (kg/From SL No Crop Name Market price per 1sq.m (m2) cultivated area) E-1 Cereals E-2 Vegetables E-3 Hay/grass
F. IMPACT ON BUILDING/STRUCTURES
Is there any building/structure in the Affected Land F-1 1-Yes; 2-No F-2 If yes, How many...... F-3 Current Type of market rate Building/Structure of Specify (Please write building/stru Building/Structure whether houses, Foto # X-Coordinate Y- cture (GEL) and GPS Coordinate shops, garage, Coordinate (as per cattle sheds or any Affected other) Person's Estimate) F-3-1 Structure1
F-3-2 Structure2 F-3-3 Structure3 F-3-4 Structure4 F-3-5 Structure5 F-3-6 Structure6 F-3-7 Structure7 F-3-8 Structure8
95 G. PHYSICAL DETAILS OF THE STRUCTURES
Description of Buildings/Structures
Building Building Building Building Building Building/Structure Building/Structur Building Description Structure Structure Structur Structure Structure No.1 e No.2 Structure No.3 No.4 No.5 e No.6 No.7 No.8 Purpose of G-1 Building/Structure G-2 Year of Construction G-3 Seismic Resistance G-4 Number of Storeys G-5 Total Area G-6 Mansard Area G-7 Basement Area Structural Components Building Building Building Building Building Building/Structure Building/Structur Building Description Structure Structure Structur Structure Structure No.1 e No.2 Structure No.3 No.4 No.5 e No.6 No.7 No.8 G-8 Foundation G-9 Walls G-10 Partitions G-11 Garret G-12 Roof Finish Building Building Building Building Building Building/Structure Building/Structur Building Description Structure Structure Structur Structure Structure No.1 e No.2 Structure No.3 No.4 No.5 e No.6 No.7 No.8 G-13 Exterior Finish G-14 Interior Finish G-15 Floor G-16 Ceiling G-17 Windows
96 G-18 Doors Utility Lines Building Building Building Building Building Building/Structure Building/Structur Building Description Structure Structure Structur Structure Structure No.1 e No.2 Structure No.3 No.4 No.5 e No.6 No.7 No.8 G-19 Sewer G-20 Water Supply G-21 Power Supply G-22 Heating G-23 Natural Air Supply Description of Fences and Gate Building Building Building Building Building Building/Structure Building/Structur Building Description Fencing Structure Structure Structur Structure Structure No.1 e No.2 Structure No.3 No.4 No.5 e No.6 No.7 No.8 1 Length 2 Height 3 Thickness 4 Perimeter of Plinth Wall 5 Used Material Building Building Building Building Building Building/Structure Building/Structur Building Description Gate Structure Structure Structur Structure Structure No.1 e No.2 Structure No.3 No.4 No.5 e No.6 No.7 No.8 1 Length 2 Height 3 Used Material
97 H. DETAILS ON ASSOCIATED USERS/PERSONS
Case of residential structure H-1 Residential Tenant 1. Yes 2. No H-1.1 If Yes (How many in Numbers) H-1.2 Men H-1.3 Women H-1.4 How much rent do you receive per month (Lari)...... Is there any formal rent agreement made between owner and tenant H-1.5 1. Yes 2. No Case of commercial structure H-2 Commercial tenant 1. Yes 2. No H-2.1 If Yes (How many in Numbers) H-2.2 Men H-2.3 Women H-2.4 How much rent do you receive per month (Lari)...... H-2.5 Is there any formal rent agreement made between owner and tenant 1. Yes 2. No
I. DETAILS ON ASSOCIATED BUISNESSES
I-1 Employees/Wage Earner 1. Yes 2. No I-1.1 If Yes (How many in Numbers) I-1.2 Men I-1.3 Women I-1.4 How much average salary do you pay per month per employee (Lari)...... I-2 Profit (Last fiscal year)
J. HOUSEHOLD DETAILS J-1 Head of Household J-1.1 Age J-1.2 Sex 1. - Male 2- Female J-1.3. Ethnic Background 1- Georgian2- Other (Specify) J-2 Number of family Members J-2.1. Male J-2.2. Female J-3 Vulnerability Status of the Household J-3.1 a. Is it a woman headed household? 1. Yes 2. No J-3.2 b. Is it headed by Below Poverty Line Households 1. Yes 2. No
98 J-3.3 c. Social Security ID J-3.4 d. Is it headed by physically/mentally challenged person? 1. Yes 2. No J-3.5 e. Is it a households headed by Elderly Person 1. Yes 2. No
J-5 Total Monthly Income of the Household/Family (Lari) Total
J-5.1. Agriculture...... J-5.2. Fixed Salary from Public Employment...... J-5.3. Fixed Salary from Employment in Private Company...... J-5.4. Private Business...... J-5.5. Irregular Remuneration (Wages)...... J-5.6. Pension...... J-5.7. Any other...... Resettlement/ Relocation Option J-6 1. Self Relocation 2. Project Assisted Resettlement Compensation Option for Land loser J-7 1. Land for land loss 2. Cash for Land loss
Compensation Options for Structure loser J-8 1. Structure for Structure 2. Cash for Structure
Income Restoration Assistance (The most preferred option) 1. Employment Opportunities in Construction work J-9 2. Assistance/ Loan from other ongoing development scheme 3. Vocational Training 4. Others (specify ...... In case of loss of land are you aware of availability of similar alternate land J-10 1- Yes ; 2- No
J-11 If yes then how far is it from the existing land (km
In case of loss of structure are you aware of availability of similar alternate land J-12 for relocation and reconstruction of houses 1- Yes ; 2- No
J-13 If yes then how far is it from the existing land (km
99 K. FAMILY DETAILS OF AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS Sl. Name of the Family Marital No Member Age Sex Status Education Occupation (in years)1. Male 1. Married 1.Illiterate 1. Service (Govt 2. Female 2. Unmarried 2.Literate 2. Business 3. Widow 3. primary 3. Agriculture 4.Widower 4. secondary 4. Study 5. Others 5. college 5. Housewife 6. University 6. Labour 7. Above 7. Unemployed 8. NA
8. Professional/self employed
9.No occupation
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
100 L. DETAILS ON SURVEYS L-1: Investigator Name and Signature of the Investigator Date of Survey Remarks
L-2: Owners Name and Signature of the Owner Date of Survey Remarks
L-3: Representative of Local Administration Name and Signature of the Representative of Local Administration Date of Survey Remarks
Note: The survey is based on Detailed Design. GPS Coordinate and other parameters such as exact area of plots/affected areas etc will be provided.
101 ANNEXURE 2.2: FINDINGS OF INVENTORY AND CENSUS SURVEYS ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- survey Parcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical Affected Household Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 1 Babi 25+810 361843 4648915 79 18001000278 1080 2 5000 Registered/Legal Non-Agri No 1 No No 2 Chartali 27+039 362821 4649181 80 56001003983 500 71 5000 Registered/Legal Non-Agri No 1 No No 3 Moliti 27+608 363277 4649002 81 56001014333 2200 292 5000 Legalizable agri/arable 10 No 1 1 No No 4 Moliti 27+687 363338 4648944 82 56001013873 2042 168 4000 Legalizable agri/arable 4 No 1 1 yes No 5 Moliti 27+803 363429 4648894 83 56001017284 1766 34 3500 Legalizable agri/arable 3 No 1 No No 6 Moliti 27+905 363482 4648799 83.1 35001040084 790 75 6000 Registered/Legal agri/arable 14 No 1 4 yes No 7 Moliti 27+980 363506 4648745 83.2 912 311 4200 Legalizable agri/arable 15 No 1 No No 8 Moliti 28+023 363541 4648727 84 01015022749 516 186 3000 Legalizable agri/arable 44 No 1 1 yes No 9 Moliti 28+041 363559 4648725 85 35001036469 285 38 5000 Legalizable agri/arable 9 No 1 No No 10 Moliti 28+052 363570 4648727 86 56001013558 226 49 4000 Legalizable agri/arable 6 No 1 6 yes No 11 Moliti 28+082 363601 4648728 87 01014003212 586 197 5000 Legalizable agri/arable 20 No 1 4 No No 12 Moliti 28+115 363630 4648736 88 56001014214 295 50 4000 Legalizable agri/arable 3 No 1 1 No No 13 Moliti 28+130 363644 4648741 89 56001005154 231 35 1000 Legalizable agri/arable 7 No 1 5 No No 14 Moliti 28+185 363694 4648765 89.1 56001014439 106 17 3000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 3 No No 15 Moliti 28+369 363837 4648861 90 57001008191 1093 10 4000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 3 No No 16 Moliti 28+332 363817 4648831 90.1 56001017284 1049 121 4500 Non Legal agri/arable 7 No 0 No No 17 Moliti 28+450 363908 4648906 91 56001014436 906 572 6000 Registered/Legal 23 1 4 yes yes agri/residential yes 18 Moliti 28+492 363949 4648911 92 1983 50 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 13 No 1 No No 19 Moliti 28+611 364070 4648906 93.1 56001006903 1210 151 2000 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 6 No No 20 Moliti 28+693 364143 4648941 93 56001006903 1331 36 6000 Legalizable agri/residential 2 No 1 3 No No 21 Moliti 28+763 364208 4648964 94 56001006903 1577 77 4200 Legalizable agri/arable 43 No 0 No No 22 Moliti 28+722 364166 4648966 95 56001006903 1230 286 4200 Legalizable agri/arable 4 No 4 No No 23 Moliti 28+789 364225 4648990 96 56001010619 2643 134 4000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 20 30 No 1 1 No No 24 Moliti 28+820 364251 4649003 97 56001010619 418 120 6000 Registered/Legal agri/arable 33 20 No No No
102 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 25 Moliti 28+826 364266 4648995 98 56001016872 540 154 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 11 No 1 6 yes No 26 Moliti 28+860 364293 4649014 99 01008031380 612 188 5000 Registered/Legal agri/arable 9 No 1 No No 27 Moliti 28+880 364311 4649026 100 499 91 6400 Legalizable agri/residential 6 No 1 No No 28 Moliti 28+910 364334 4649042 102 01008031380 204 48 6000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 47 No 3 No No 29 Moliti 28+925 364346 4649050 103 56001006282 885 83 6000 Registered/Legal 5 No 1 4 No No 56001001617 agri/residential 56001011343 30 Moliti 28+948 364367 4649058 104 60001098201 189 189 6400 Registered/Legal agri/residential 4 No 2 No No 31 Moliti 29+069 364486 4649051 105 56001002900 159 159 1000 Registered/Legal Non-Agri 3 Yes 1 4 No yes 32 Moliti 29+088 364504 4649051 106 01027020854 161 161 5000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 5 Yes 1 No yes 33 Moliti 29+105 364522 4649063 107 01007012070 565 4 4000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 5 No 1 No No 34 Moliti 29+132 364547 4649056 108 35001035110 324 324 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 7 Yes 1 No yes 35 Moliti 29+233 364644 4649083 109 01015023884 1380 427 600 Legalizable agri/residential 12 No 1 No yes 36 Moliti 29+280 364685 4649096 110 56001022229 797 249 2700 Registered/Legal agri/residential 35 No 1 3 No No 37 Moliti 29+310 364711 4649110 111 56001003199 1974 199 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 30 60 No 1 2 No No 38 Moliti 29+351 364741 4649133 112 56001019562 1908 426 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 187 140 No 1 2 No No 39 Moliti 29+400 364765 4649170 113 01007012070 654 160 4600 Registered/Legal agri/arable 36 No 4 No No 40 Moliti 29+560 364898 4649261 114 56001016789 2509 159 6500 Legalizable agri/residential 12 29 No 1 4 No No 41 Nebodziri 29+580 364903 4649282 115 56001016789, 337 137 5000 Registered/Legal 1 No No No 56001023360, 56001018155, agri/arable 56001025114
42 Moliti 29+640 364967 4649259 116 01010011654 4473 816 5000 Legalizable agri/residential 23 No 1 4 No yes 43 Moliti 29+705 365024 4649252 117 60001098201 14 14 7000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 5 yes No 44 Moliti 29+760 365082 4649257 118 60001098201 2537 417 7000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 37 140 No 3 No No 45 Moliti 29+832 365149 4649264 119 01027037771 1985 211 7000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 27 No 1 No No
103 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 46 Moliti 29+871 365187 4649276 119.1 01027037771 848 198 4000 Legalizable agri/arable 8 No 5 No No 47 Moliti 29+760 365079 4649238 120 60001098201 2615 54 6500 Registered/Legal agri/arable 29 No 3 No No 48 Moliti 29+820 365141 4649242 121 01027037771 4103 106 4500 Registered/Legal agri/arable 10 No No No 49 Nebodziri 29+926 365229 4649245 122 56001010233 2790 63 4600 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 No No 50 Moliti 30+184 365470 4649282 123 56001010233 1520 171 4500 Registered/Legal agri/arable No No No 51 Nebodziri 30+220 365509 4649301 124 56001017346. 332 142 4500 Registered/Legal 32 No 1 2 yes No 56001006569 agri/arable 52 Moliti 30+253 365532 4649309 125 56001019800 251 151 7000 Legalizable agri/arable 14 No 1 2 yes No 53 Moliti 30+440 365701 4649391 126 56001015826 129 36 4600 Non Legal agri/arable 3 No 0 No No 54 Aneula 30+473 365733 4649389 127 56001010300 2439 136 7000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 17 No 1 2 No No 55 Aneula 30+520 365780 4649378 128 56001010300, 1372 192 4600 Registered/Legal 13 No 1 4 No No 56001009154, 56001025224, agri/arable 56001025230, 56001018191
56 Nebodziri 30+600 365854 4649383 129 1028009335 3233 257 7000 Registered/Legal 49 30 No 1 2 No No 01033002394 agri/residential 57 Nebodziri 31+408 366371 4649854 130 56001020037 580 276 4600 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 No No 58 Tsipa 34+470 369002 4650732 131 56001007238 1582 183 4500 Legalizable agri/residential 4 No 1 No No 59 Tsipa 35+160 369569 4650674 131.1 56001021704 2216 170 4500 Legalizable agri/arable 7 No 1 3 yes No 60 Golatubani 35+360 369642 4650845 132 56001015073, 2373 510 4500 Registered/Legal 194 162 No 1 3 yes yes 56001010421, agri/residential 56001010422 61 Golatubani 35+300 369659 4650776 132.1 57601062174 2746 30 6000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 11 No 1 No No 62 Golatubani 35+350 369671 4650822 132.2 56001004151 6000 Legalizable agri/residential 16 No 1 5 No No 63 Tsipa 35+397 369667 4650872 133 57001014778 1240 242 4500 Legalizable agri/residential 71 No 1 3 yes No
104 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 64 Golatubani 35+424 369673 4650895 134 01033002726 1500 260 6000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 70 No 1 No No 65 Golatubani 35+463 369680 4650931 135 56001015363 2186 201 6000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 30 240 No 1 2 No No 66 Golatubani 35+520 369675 4650980 136 3169 312 6000 Legalizable agri/residential 6 No 1 No No 67 Golatubani 36+620 370029 4650930 138 56001010311 7000 21 7500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 6 No 1 3 yes No 68 Tsipa 36+650 370068 4650915 139 56001004149 1000 203 8000 Registered/Legal agri/arable 21 20 No 1 2 yes No 69 Tsipa 36+940 370245 4650918 140 56001010641 2772 24 6500 Legalizable agri/residential 21 No 1 No No 70 Tsipa 36+956 370265 4650935 141 56001010315 1538 169 5000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 94 20 No 1 2 yes No 71 Tsipa 36+980 370280 4650951 142 56001010463, 1801 170 5000 Registered/Legal 15 200 No 1 2 yes No 56001010469 agri/residential 72 Tsipa 37+020 370322 4650971 143 35001069098 2994 282 7500 Legalizable agri/residential 28 No 1 4 yes No 73 Tsipa 37+092 370359 4651011 144 56001010467 1860 565 7500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 55 50 No 1 yes No 74 Tsipa 37+110 370392 4651021 145 56001017786 2141 60 6500 Legalizable agri/arable 7 No 1 No No 75 Tsipa 37+148 370392 4651067 146 600030006478 1400 47 6500 Legalizable agri/arable 9 No 1 4 No No 76 Tsipa 37+170 370418 4651074 147 56001017947 2669 219 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 27 20 No 2 yes No 77 Tsipa 37+197 370444 4651074 148 56001011218 1505 148 6500 Legalizable agri/residential 26 20 No 1 No No 78 Tsipa 37+220 370462 4651081 149 56001017947 1344 171 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 3 20 No 1 2 yes No 79 Tsipa 37+310 370511 4651147 150 56001016674 3752 395 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 9 No 1 4 No No 80 Golatubani 37+360 370549 4651184 151 56001015072, 6391 205 6500 Registered/Legal 17 60 No 1 2 No No 56001011680, 54001002692, agri/residential 35001041358
81 Tsipa 37+420 370618 4651185 152 56001011909 1706 371 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 53 600 No 1 4 yes No 82 Golatubani 37+443 370642 4651187 153 56001019087, 1464 233 6500 Registered/Legal 11 542 No 1 4 No No 56001014680, 56001021758, agri/residential 56001022887
105 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 83 Golatubani 37+490 370675 4651212 154 56001004895, 2941 484 6500 Registered/Legal 130 65 No 1 6 yes No 57001033313 agri/residential 84 Tsipa 37+540 370720 4651230 155 0101101990 1871 203 6500 Legalizable agri/residential 123 30 No 1 2 No No 85 Golatubani 37+533 370721 4651212 156 57001005293 1685 7 6500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 2 No 1 No No 86 Tsipa 37+580 370762 4651240 157 01002002299 804 104 6500 Legalizable agri/residential 7 No 1 2 No No 87 Tsipa 37+566 370749 4651237 157.1 01011037197 739 98 7500 Legalizable agri/residential 11 No 1 2 No No 88 Golatubani 37+640 370787 4651275 158 56001010656, 2997 1191 7500 Registered/Legal 29 1070 No 1 7 No yes 56001010678, 56001010659, agri/residential 56001021759, 56001025672
89 Tsipa 37+880 370869 4651484 159 56001014985 2000 1545 7500 Legalizable agri/arable 6 No 1 5 yes yes 90 Tsipa 38+420 371293 4651624 160 595 19 7500 Legalizable agri/arable 15 No 1 No No 91 Tsipa 38+454 371318 4651652 161 56001006462 238 64 7500 Legalizable agri/arable 7 No 4 yes No 92 Tsipa 38+470 371325 4651667 162 417 417 1800 Legalizable agri/arable 23 No No yes 93 Tsipa 38+485 371335 4651681 162.1 139 101 2200 Non Legal agri/arable 4 No 6 No No 94 Tsipa 38+500 371351 4651660 163 56001003329, 1919 30 4500 Registered/Legal 4 No 1 No No 56001004148, agri/arable 56001004341 95 Tsipa 38+531 371387 4651656 164 3268 472 4500 Legalizable agri/arable 3 No 1 No yes 96 Tsipa 38+580 371404 4651620 165 56001009743, 2355 836 4500 Legalizable 25 No 1 2 yes yes 56001009742 agri/arable 97 Tsipa 38+660 371465 4651597 166 56001009743, 4392 995 5000 Registered/Legal 62 No 4 No yes 56001009742 agri/residential 98 Tsipa 38+740 371546 4651593 167 4849 23 10000 Legalizable agri/residential 1 No 1 No No
106 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 99 Tsipa 38+772 371572 4651611 168 56001009738, 3353 30 6000 Registered/Legal 8 No 1 3 No No 56001025667, agri/residential 56001010324 100 Tsipa 38+780 371570 4651639 169 56001003329, 2363 93 7500 Registered/Legal 20 No 7 No No 56001004148, agri/residential 56001004341 101 Tsipa 38+820 371610 4651647 170 56001006462 900 440 6000 Registered/Legal 122 10 Yes 1 1 yes agri/residential yes 102 Tsipa 38+850 371640 4651629 171 56001006462, 1515 15 7500 Registered/Legal 8 No 1 3 No No 56001006463, agri/residential 57001031773 103 Tsipa 38+860 371651 4651651 172 01002013671 2827 435 3000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 52 Yes 1 1 yes yes 104 Tsipa 38+894 371686 4651640 173 57001006106 1200 139 5300 Registered/Legal agri/residential 48 Yes 1 5 No yes 105 Tsipa 38+916 371706 4651631 174 01019047568 1200 210 6000 Legalizable agri/residential 53 Yes 1 6 No yes 106 Tsipa 38+960 371741 4651636 175 56001015062 1552 731 6000 Registered/Legal agri/residential 108 Yes 1 6 yes yes 107 Tsipa 39+007 371780 4651656 176 56001016843 2250 322 7500 Legalizable agri/residential 53 Yes 1 6 yes yes 108 Tsipa 39+140 371894 4651729 177 01024045056 1965 74 5000 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 No No 109 Tsipa 39+220 371956 4651784 178 01024015766, 7545 175 6000 Registered/Legal 14 No 1 No No 01024045056 agri/residential 110 Tsipa 39+230 371933 4651815 179 01023009251 1641 272 3400 Legalizable agri/arable 19 No 1 No No 111 Tsipa 39+294 371950 4651862 180 3836 395 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 5 No 1 No No 112 Tsipa 39+333 371997 4651877 180.1 417 417 6000 Non Legal agri/arable 18 No 1 2 No No 113 Tsipa 39+380 372027 4651898 181 57001027025 617 364 3300 Registered/Legal agri/arable 8 No 1 4 yes yes 114 Tsipa 39+400 372051 4651916 182 57001027025 3162 5 7550 Registered/Legal agri/residential 1 Yes No yes 115 Tsipa 39+440 372072 4651941 183 1516 39 6000 Legalizable agri/residential 2 No 1 yes No 116 Tsipa 39+430 372091 4651912 183.1 56001020397 2974 64 4300 Legalizable agri/residential 10 No 1 6 No No
107 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 117 Tsipa 39+520 372145 4651996 184 57001046048 2800 239 7500 Legalizable agri/residential 19 No 1 5 Yes No 118 Tsipa 39+500 372145 4651954 185 56001020301 1013 43 9500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 13 No 1 5 No No 119 Tsipa 39+600 372186 4652038 186 56001020365 3479 321 7500 Registered/Legal 19 380 No 1 2 yes No 56001017447 56001010286 56001002231 agri/residential 57001060885 57101063031 56001005190
120 Tsipa 39+645 372201 4652082 187 01004012062 4070 250 3300 Legalizable agri/residential 3 No 1 4 No No 121 Tsipa 39+667 372221 4652102 188.1 1030023382 600 62 4000 Legalizable agri/residential No No No 122 Tsipa 39+696 372257 4652107 188.2 35001078467 4500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 1 No 1 1 yes No 123 Tsipa 39+696 372241 4652121 188 01030023382 2050 307 2000 Registered/Legal 10 No 1 6 No yes 01030050220 agri/residential 124 Tsipa 39+757 372303 4652150 189 57001048047 704 8 7500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 3 No 1 7 No No 125 Tsipa 39+728 372280 4652124 190 56001010046 1126 9 7000 Legalizable agri/residential 3 No 1 4 yes No 126 Tsipa 39+786 372309 4652182 191 57001048047 1989 417 2000 Legalizable agri/arable 23 No 5 No yes 127 Tsipa 39+740 372268 4652160 192 56001004911 3900 180 1400 Registered/Legal agri/arable 17 100 No 1 2 yes yes 128 Tsipa 39+820 372330 4652206 193 56001010924, 1250 355 7500 Registered/Legal 10 200 No 1 4 No No 56001018851, 56001021423, agri/arable 56001018850, 56001011213
129 Tsipa 39+860 372346 4652236 194 57001010939 2700 784 7500 Legalizable agri/residential 34 No 1 No yes 130 Tsipa 39+900 372347 4652275 195 01033000566 1414 38 2300 Registered/Legal agri/residential 1 No 1 3 No No
108 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 131 Tsipa 39+920 372381 4652285 196 56001010924, 1200 169 3500 Registered/Legal 33 15 No 4 No No 56001018851, 56001021423, agri/residential 56001018850, 56001011213
132 Tsipa 39+951 372387 4652322 197 01007004891 3000 260 4500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 3 No 1 2 yes No 133 Tsipa 40+000 372422 4652351 199 01017028342 1968 292 4500 Registered/Legal agri/residential 61 200 No 1 3 yes No 134 Tsipa 40+060 372432 4652399 200 56001020379 1761 453 4500 Legalizable agri/arable 16 400 No 1 6 yes yes 135 Tsipa 40+120 372466 4652450 200.1 56001025664 4056 61 2900 Legalizable agri/residential 6 No 1 4 No No 136 Pona 43+280 374446 4653121 201 56001010043, 2929 13 6000 Registered/Legal 2 No 1 5 yes No 56001000935 agri/residential 137 Pona 43+393 374559 4653132 202 12001001016 830 205 4300 Registered/Legal agri/residential No 1 No No 138 Pona 43+420 374576 4653161 203 01023009251 1885 32 4500 Registered/Legal agri/residential No 3 No No 139 Pona 43+480 374641 4653165 204 56001010050, 808 14 3900 Registered/Legal 2 No 1 1 yes No 56001010313, agri/residential 56001012049 140 Pona 43+535 374689 4653187 205 56001012052 1560 57 12000 Legalizable agri/residential 12 No 1 1 yes No 141 Pona 43+656 374786 4653265 206 01008031952 460 68 5000 Registered/Legal 2 No 1 No No 01010020066 agri/arable 142 Pona 43+900 374944 4653451 207 57001026901 1560 171 11000 Legalizable agri/arable 2 No 1 2 yes No 143 Pona 43+868 374921 4653438 207.1 57001002224 1820 42 3000 Legalizable agri/residential 11 No 1 4 No No 144 Pona 43+940 374976 4653475 208 46001016743 1359 484 3000 Legalizable agri/arable 7 No 1 No yes 145 Pona 44+030 375047 4653532 209 1400 42 2500 Legalizable agri/arable 3 No 1 No No 146 Pona 44+080 375093 4653556 210 57001002224 1350 365 7500 Legalizable agri/arable 8 No No No 147 Pona 44+151 375160 4653587 211 57001043250 1000 94 5000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 1 yes No 148 Pona 44+200 375207 4653597 212 57001002224 1000 674 12000 Legalizable agri/arable 18 No No No
109 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 149 Pona 44+240 375241 4653617 213 56001010427 2319 996 8000 Registered/Legal agri/arable 21 No 1 No yes 150 Pona 44+280 375269 4653652 214 57001043415 1520 84 6000 Registered/Legal agri/arable 9 No 1 No No 151 Pona 44+410 375390 4653707 215 57001024214 3100 89 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 9 No 1 No No 152 Pona 44+460 375439 4653723 216 57001033291 1600 352 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 8 No 1 No No 153 Pona 44+495 375470 4653742 217 56001010050 1700 203 4800 Legalizable agri/arable 8 No 5 No No 154 Pona 44+514 375487 4653750 218 56001010132 1800 281 4500 Legalizable agri/arable 9 No 1 1 yes No 155 Pona 44+540 375506 4653758 219 57001008532 2378 312 4500 Legalizable agri/arable 4 No 1 2 No No 156 Pona 44+560 375524 4653767 220 57001042757 2173 312 5000 Legalizable agri/arable 4 No 1 5 yes No 157 Pona 44+588 375551 4653780 221 56001012052 2000 177 8000 Legalizable agri/arable No 2 No No 158 Pona 44+620 375568 4653803 222 56001011141 2172 19 4000 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 No No 159 Pona 44+700 375653 4653830 223 57301062967 1886 164 6000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 No No 160 D. Surami, 45+600 376510 4654088 224 57001019493 3103 145 6500 Registered/Legal No 1 4 No No Chumateleti agri/arable 161 D. Surami, 47+170 376591 4653999 225 01024055381 1356 596 8700 Registered/Legal No 1 5 No No Chumateleti agri/arable 162 Chumateleti 47+130 376619 4653958 226 57001026073 1000 1000 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 10 No 1 4 yes yes 163 Chumateleti 47+160 376596 4653967 227 57001038941 1000 1000 6000 Legalizable agri/arable 2 No 1 2 yes yes 164 Chumateleti 47+180 376572 4653972 228 57001035818 1000 1000 2500 Legalizable agri/arable 13 No 1 6 No yes 165 D. Surami, 48+220 377371 4654194 230 57001039625 1224 53 12500 Non Legal 5 No No No Chumateleti agri/arable 166 D. Surami, 48+153 377352 4654136 230.1 57001038166 800 67 7500 Legalizable 5 No 1 2 No No Chumateleti agri/arable 167 D. Surami, 48+143 377347 4654129 230.2 01001045052 800 62 8000 Legalizable 4 No 1 No No Chumateleti agri/arable 168 D. Surami, 48+260 377388 4654226 231 57001023399 2240 951 5000 Legalizable No 1 1 yes yes Chumateleti agri/arable
110 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 169 D. Surami, 48+320 377412 4654272 232 57001038590 2600 2600 8000 Legalizable 24 No 1 No yes Chumateleti agri/arable 170 D. Surami, 48+540 377384 4654117 233 57001026747 1212 61 9000 Registered/Legal 3 100 No 1 3 yes No Chumateleti agri/arable 171 Chumateleti 48+620 377337 4654062 234 57001018391 1300 37 9000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 No No 172 Chumateleti 47+891 377150 4654012 235 57001038316 1711 107 4300 Legalizable agri/arable 7 No 1 3 No No 173 Chumateleti 47+960 377219 4654019 235.1 01008041371 7200 339 4200 Legalizable agri/arable 23 No 1 No No 174 Chumateleti 48+720 377278 4653970 236 01013029860 2572 13 4300 Legalizable agri/arable 1 No 1 3 yes No 175 Chumateleti 48+880 377145 4653886 237 57001043993 4484 243 4300 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 4 No No 176 Chumateleti 48+940 377098 4653867 238 57001024008 1800 171 4200 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 5 No No 177 Chumateleti 48+960 377084 4653869 239 57001015350 1800 220 5000 Legalizable agri/arable 1 No 1 No No 178 Chumateleti 48+975 377069 4653865 240 57001007176 1800 320 5300 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 No No 179 Chumateleti 49+000 377043 4653872 241 57001044368 1540 377 4500 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 4 yes No 180 Chumateleti 49+020 377028 4653880 242 57001044329 1760 473 5400 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 No No 181 Chumateleti 49+040 377007 4653897 243 01029003106 2454 408 4500 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 No No 182 D. Surami, 49+050 376991 4653894 244 57001019493 1002 41 4500 Registered/Legal No No No Chumateleti agri/arable
183 Chumateleti 49+055 376987 4653889 245 57001010999 1000 34 14000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 5 yes No 184 Chumateleti 49+059 376981 4653884 246 57001032739 1000 18 3000 Legalizable agri/arable No 1 1 yes No 185 D. Surami, 49+290 377164 4653834 247.1 11001001750 1243 130 3500 Legalizable No 1 No No Chumateleti agri/arable
186 D. Surami, 49+350 377206 4653845 247 57001024573 1955 59 4500 Legalizable 5 No 1 5 yes No Chumateleti agri/arable 187 Chumateleti 49+460 377338 4653834 248 1100100738 1870 14 4500 Legalizable Non-Agri No 1 2 No No 188 Chumateleti 49+450 377316 4653866 249 57001028021 1674 60 4500 Registered/Legal agri/arable 13 No 1 3 yes No
111 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 189 Chumateleti 49+487 377352 4653867 250 57001021853 4052 33 4500 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 No No 190 Chumateleti 49+814 377641 4653993 251 57001024348 24 24 4500 Non Legal agri/arable 3 10 No yes No 191 Chumateleti 49+828 377655 4653996 251.1 57001012959 59 20 4500 Non Legal agri/arable No No No 192 Chumateleti 49+780 377616 4653971 251.2 57001024348 1370 47 4500 Registered/Legal agri/arable No 1 2 No No 193 Chumateleti 49+880 377724 4653970 252 243855128 10219 42 12190 Registered/Legal Non-Agri 3 No 1 No No 194 D. Surami, 49+907 377732 4654028 253 57001039625 915 21 4000 Legalizable 11 10 No 1 2 No No Chumateleti agri/residential 195 D. Surami, 49+950 377774 4654035 254 57001012030 1556 44 4500 Registered/Legal 10 No 1 3 yes No Chumateleti agri/residential 196 Chumateleti 50+000 377809 4654045 255 57001037577 739 103 12000 Legalizable agri/residential 14 No 1 4 Yes No 197 D. Surami, 50+000 377833 4654033 256 57001042793 1927 10 10000 Registered/Legal 2 No 1 4 No No Chumateleti agri/residential 198 D. Surami, 50+020 377845 4654055 257 01024023571 444 9 4000 Registered/Legal No 1 No No Chumateleti agri/residential 199 D. Surami, 50+027 377842 4654065 258.1 57001012220 133 3 5000 Non Legal No 1 3 No No Chumateleti agri/residential 200 Chumateleti 50+060 377844 4654096 258 1463 39 4000 Legalizable agri/residential 12 No 1 No No 201 D. Surami, 50+107 377854 4654134 259 01008024332, 1331 4 4200 Registered/Legal 3 No 1 4 No No Chumateleti 01008025847 agri/residential 202 Chumateleti 50+125 377864 4654145 260 57001015369 1500 2 5000 Registered/Legal agri/residential No 1 5 No No 203 D. Surami, 50+168 377867 4654196 261 01024050590 70 14 4000 Registered/Legal 5 No 1 5 No No Chumateleti agri/residential 204 D. Surami, 50+180 377876 4654205 262 01028003443 710 8 4000 Registered/Legal No 1 No No Chumateleti agri/residential 205 Chumateleti 50+188 377884 4654209 263 01024050590 13 11 4000 Non Legal agri/residential 1 No No No 206 Chumateleti 50+200 377896 4654213 264 54001051140 123 17 4000 Non Legal agri/residential 4 No 1 No No
112 ) 2 # Name Village of Chainage/Km Project Coordinate X- Coordinate X- surveyParcel(as per No Land No) No ID Parcel (m Land Area the of Affected Area(m2) (m2) Holding Land Total Owner of Type Parcel Land of Type Trees Number of Area Crop (sqm) Cultivated Displacement Physical AffectedHousehold Number of Aps Number of Household Vulnerable Severely Affected 207 Chumateleti 50+200 377898 4654191 265 57001011524, 915 61 4000 Registered/Legal 8 No 1 3 No No 57001040616, 57001040640, agri/residential 57001005986
208 Chumateleti 50+215 377915 4654216 265.1 577001012220 8 6 8000 Non Legal Non-Agri No No No
113 ANNEXURE 3.1: SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY (SAMPLE HOUSEHOLDS)
1. GENERAL IDENTIFICATION 1.1. Name of the Road Section Dzirula –Kharagauli-Chumateleti 1.2. Address a. Village/Town: ………………………………. b. District: …………………………………… c. Region: ……………………………………… 1.3. Settlement Type: 1 Rural 2. Urban
2. HOUSEHOLD INFORMATION 2.1. Name of the head of Household…………………………………………………. 2.2. Sex 1. Male 2. Female 2.3. Household Composition (Population) Sl. No. Category Male Female Total 1 15- years 2 15 – 65 years 3 65+ years 4 Total
2.4. Ethnic Group: 1.Georgian 2. Others (Specify)......
3. ECONOMIC ACTIVITY OF HOUSEHOLDS 3.1. What are the economic activities of household? Categorize in the order of Sl No Type of Activities Priority 1 Agriculture 2 Working for other farmers(Agricultural Labourer) 3 Small enterprise 4 Government & NGO 5 Business and trading 6 Transport/Taxi 7 Daily Wage 8 Others (Specify)……………….
3.2. Landholding (In HA) ………….. Agrikultural Non-agricultural Total Cultivable Non -cultivable
114 Non- Non- Irrigated Irrigated Commercial Residential Irrigated Irrigated
4. CROPPING PATTERN How many Sl No. Type of Crops Total Yield (ton) Price per Ton (Lari) seasons per Year 1 Cereal 2 Vegitables 3 Hey/grass 5 Others
5. TOTAL HOUSEHOLD INCOME Sl. No. Source Monthly Income ( LARI) Annual Income ( LARI) 1 Agriculture 2 Service 3 Business 4 Labour 5 Professional 6 Pension 7 Animal Husbandry 8 Any other 9 Total
6. CONSUMPTION PATTERN Kindly indicate the consumption/expenditure on different items in last one year.
Expenditure (LARI) Sl. No. Particulars / Source Monthly Annual 1 Food 2 Health 3 Education 4 Energy (Cooking fuel and electricity) 5 Transportation 6 Agriculture (such as seeds, hiring of farm implements etc.)
115 Miscellaneous (Social function, 7 entertainments, clothing, communication, etc)
7. POSSESSION OF ASSETS/LIVESTOCKS: Do you possess following items? Sl. No. Items 1. Yes 2. No Items 1 Radio 2 Bicycle 3 Television 5 L.P.G Connection/ Gas Cylinder 6 Computer 7 Refrigerator 8 Washing Machine 9 Motor cycle/Scooter 10 Car 11 Air Conditioner Livestocks 12 Cettle (neat) 13 Pig 14 Sheep/goat 15 Horse/donkey 16 Poultry
8. INDEBTEDNESS (Lari)
8.1. Do you have debt or loan? 1. Yes 2. No 8.2. If yes, please indicate your borrowings during last one year (in Lari): 8.3. What is the source of borrowings? 1. Bank 2. Relatives 3. Private money lender 4 Others ______8.4. Reasons for Borrowing: 1. Meeting the medical expenses; 2. To repay debts; 3. On food; 4. On education; 5. To start/upgrade business; 6. Helping relatives; 7. Improvement in house; 8. Marriage/rituals; 9. last rites/ funerals 10. Religious visit; 11. Durable/Non consumable goods; 12. To meet the daily Expenses Others specify______
9. HEALTH STATUS 9.1. Do you have access to Health Care Centre? 1. Yes 2. No 9.2 What is the Distance from your home? In Km……………………….. 9.3. Was any member of your family affected by any major illness in last one year? 1 Yes 2 No 9.4. If 'Yes', please indicate the details No. of Cases Type of disease/ illness Treatment Taken*
116
* 1. Allopathic 2. Homeopathic 3. Herbal 4. Traditional 5. No treatment
10. MIGRATION 10.1. Does any family member migrate for work? 1 Yes 2 No 10.2. If 'Yes', for how many months in a year………………..… 10.3. Where do you migrate mostly? 1. Outside the District 2. Outside the country 10.4. What kind of job do you undertake? 1. Agricultural Labour 2. Non Agricultural Labour 3.Trade & Business 4. Others (Specify) 10.5. How much is the income per month? ……………………….... 10.6. Trend of Migration 1. Once in a year 2. Twice in a year 3. Every alternative year 4. Once in every three years 5. No regular interval/as and when required 10.7. At what time of the year do you migrate? 1 Summer 2 Winter 11. STATUS OF WOMEN 11.1. Kindly indicate what kind of economic/ non-economic activities female members of your family are engaged in? Sl. No. Economic/Non-economic Activities 1. Yes 2. No 1 Cultivation 2 Allied Activities* 3 Collection and Sale of forest products 4 Trade & Business 5 Agricultural Labour 6 Non Agricultural Labour 7 HH Industries (Tailoring, Cooking for sales etc) 8 Service 9 Households Work 10 Others (Specify): …………….. * Dairy, Poultry, Sheep rearing, etc. 11.2. If, engaged in economic activities how much they contribute to total family income of the year: (Lari)…… 11.3. Does your female member have any say, in decision making of household matters? 1. Yes 2. No 11.4. If 'Yes, give the following details? Sl.No. Issues 1 Yes 2 No 1 Financial matters
117 2 Education of child 3 Health care of child 4 Purchase of assets 5 Day to day activities 6 On social functions and marriages 7 Others………
12. EDUCATION Particulars Male Female Total Children (0-6 years) not going to school Pre-School Primary Secondary College/ University Illiterate Total
13. AMENITIES 13.1. Source of Drinking Water: 1. Piped-water supply 2. Spring 3. Well 4. Stream 5. Others 13.2. Type of Toilet: 1. Flush toilet 2. Latrine 13.3. Fuel for Heating: 1. Electricity 2. Wood 3.Gas 4.Diesel/Kerosene 5. Solar
14. STRUCTURE/ BUILDING INFORMATION 14.1. Use of Structure 1. Residential. 2. Commercial 3. Residential- cum- Commercial. 4. Other
14.2. Age of the Structure (Years)…………….. 14.3. Type of Construction 1 Mud made 2 Brick made 3 Cemented 4. Wooden 5.Others………. 14.4. Type of Structure 1Temporary 2 Semi Permanent 3 Permanent 14.5 Is your house connected to the central power supply. 1. Yes 2. No 14.6. How many rooms are there in your house? …………………….. 14.7. How many rooms are heated in your house? …………………… 15. TRANSPORT USAGE 15.1. Is your house immediately connected to road 1. Yes 2. No 15.2. If Yes, to which road 1. Village Road., 2 District Road, 3. High Ways 15.3. What is the distance of the village from the main road? ………………KM 15.4. How is the condition of the connected road? 1. Good, 2. Average, 3. Poor, 4. Very Poor 15.5. How much money do you spend per month on transportation? …………………..(Lari) ANY OTHER ISSUES (COMMENTS/ SUGGESTIONS)
118 ------GENDER ASSESSMENT (Respondent – any 25-65 year old woman in the household) A Role of women and development trend 1. Satisfaction degree of participants to current status of women 1. Satisfactory 2. un-satisfactory 3. un-clear
Why un-satisfactory 2. Labor division______workload______trend of recent years
3. Who is responsible for family finance 1. Man 2. Women 3. both
B Women’s development activities
4. Recent development interventions effectiveness activities organization /agency effectiveness (score 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 with 5 as the most effective) education health care
Other
5. Priority activities for the village in 3 years activities Why 1 2 3
C Food, nutrition and health
6. Self-sufficiency of food supply of the village (1) Yes (2) No (3) Yes in some years.
7. Common health problems of women and children All residents women Children 1 2 3
8. Treatment Treatment
119 See doctor Buy medicine by Take rest No care oneself
9. Attended baby delivery present 3 years ago Baby delivery at hospitals Reasons of changes Reasons for not going to hospitals
10. HIV/AIDS knowledge Knowledge: 1. heard of 2. Knew of 3. No idea 11. Prevention knowledge 1. Yes 2. No
D Mobility and migration of women
times Purpose township hospital Mobility (times/month) market county town others migration (persons) present years ago
E Knowledge/Impacts of the Project
12. How can the road rehabilitation project improve local livelihood?
13. What do you expect over the project road rehabilitation?
14. Do you have any particular concern related to the rehabilitation of the Project road?
15. Is there any way in which the road rehabilitation project can negatively affect you?
120 F Social Barrier for Women Involvement
16. Would you be interested to be employed or involved in the project implementation? (a) Yes (b) No 17. If Yes, as (i) Labor, (ii) Opening a small business (iii) Others
18. If no, is there any social barrier that negatively impacts your participation? (1) No (2) Yes, what is the barrier?
19. What is the skill women have in the locality and what kind of vocational training will you be interested in. Name of the Investigator) Date: ...... (Signature of the investigator)
121 ANNEXURE-4: CONSULTATIONS DETAILS
122 ANNEXURE 4.1: RECORDS OF CONSULTATIONS DURING FEASIBILITY STUDY
# Name of the Participant Age Male /Female Occupation Name of the Place: Kharagauli Date of Consultation: 02.12.14 Number of Participants: 45 1 Maka Buachidze 40 Female Librarian 2 Natia M eskhi 29 Female Economist 3 Nana Lursmanashvili 40 Female Deputy Director 4 Lika Devdariani 26 Female Librarian 5 Lika Kalandadze 34 Female Librarian 6 Marina Cubinidze 50 Female Librarian 7 Sofo Latsabidze 33 Female Librarian 8 Mamuka Cipashvili 43 Male Director of Tourism Center 9 Nikoloz Machavariani 46 Male Director of Central Library 10 Avtandil Kamkamidze 51 Male Deputy Director, Cleaning Service 11 Rezo Tutberidze 45 Male Cleaning Service employer 12 David Gabunia 58 Male Employee 13 Omar Machavariani 62 Male Manadjer 14 Zaal Lursmanashvili 61 Male Employee 15 Nodar Tsxiladze 53 Male Employee 16 Tamar Kiknadze 42 Female Employee 17 Paata Phtskiladze 46 Mail Civil Council representative 18 Tamar Shavidze 31 Female Employee 19 Nargizi Gorgodze 40 Female Unemployed 20 Murman Cipashvili 47 Male Economist 21 Nikoloz Magradze 57 Male Employee 22 Oleg Magradze 62 Male Employee 23 Zaza Katsitadze 47 Male Worker 24 Ketevan Ardjevanidze 50 Female Employee 25 Merab Gluchadze 53 Male Employee 26 Rusudan Phtskiladze 57 Female Employee 27 Nana Belashi 50 Female Employee 28 Liana Vephkhvadze 56 Female Employee 29 Mevlud Meskhi 50 Male Employee 30 Malkhaz Pkhaladze 53 Male Employee 31 Beka Khidjakidze 25 Male Employee 32 Bacho Guruli 20 Male Employee 33 Salome Tabukashvili 23 Female Employee 34 Salome Tabukashvili 37 Female Employee 35 Nino Buachidze 38 Female Employee 36 Khatuna Tsitskishvili 40 Female Employee 37 Revaz Okribashvili 53 Male Employee 38 Lasha Khidjakidze 27 Male Employee 39 David Kharadze 51 Male Employee 40 Tamar Magradze 22 Female Jornalist 41 Tamta Gogoladze 25 Female Jornalist 42 Akaki Machavariani 73 Male Member of Civil Cancel 43 Koba Lursmanashvili 44 Male Head of Municipality 44 Varlam Chipashvili 23 Male Member of Civil Cancel 45 Manana Barbaqadze 40 Female Head of Civil Cancel Name of the Village: Sagandzile Date of Consultation :02.12.14 Number of Participants: 17
123 # Name of the Participant Age Male /Female Occupation 1 Giorgi Meskhi 40 Male Teacher 2 S. Akvlediani 72 Male Pensioner 3 M. Tsuladzr 65 Male Pensioner 4 Ramaz Kamkamidze 54 Male Employee 5 Marine Beridze 54 Female Employee 6 Koba Kruashvili 50 Male Employee 7 Vardo Cipashvili 55 Female Employee 8 Eliso Kiknadze 44 Female Individual entrepreneur 9 Varlam Chipashvili 23 Male Civil council member 10 David Pavladze 29 Male Civil collaborator 11 Kakha Bakuradze 44 Male Employee 12 Sh.Chanua 70 Female Pensioner 13 Nargiz Kiknadze 68 Female Housewife 14 Vladimer Bluashvili 32 Male Unemployed 15 Ucha Gabunia 30 Male Unemployed 16 Avtandil Chipashvili 25 Male Unemployed 17 Nika Osanadze 29 Male Rescue Name of the Village: Pona Date of Consultation :10.12.14 Number of Participants: 03 1 Levan Nozadze 35 Male Unemployed 2 Kukuri Nozadze 62 Male Unemployed 3 Gela Nozadze 51 Male Unemployed Name of the Village: Moliti Date of Consultation :02.12.14 Number of Participants: 23 1 Aleqsandre Tchoidze 62 Male Self emploer 2 Davit Inasaridze 55 Male Individual Entrepreneur 3 Gela kvinikadze 56 Male 4 Akaki Kiknadze 38 Male Engineer 5 Maia Gachechiladze 47 Female Representative 6 Gocha Lacabidze 48 Male Citizen 7 Besiki Lacabidze 39 Male Deputy 8 Shorena Tchkoidze 41 Female Self emploer 9 Umanko Maghradze 72 Female Citizen 10 Iza Tsereteli 76 Female pensioner 11 Ketevan Lacabidze 26 Female Pharmaceutics 12 Madona Matcharashvili 37 Female Librarion 13 Guram Ghonghadze 41 Male Individual entrepreneur 14 Spartak Lacabidze 37 Male Meneger representative 15 Merab Talakhadze 43 Male Deputy 16 Kukuri Kvinikadze 65 Male Pensioner 17 Valeri Kakiashvili 31 Male Unemployed 18 Merabi Lacabidze 47 Male Individual entrepreneur 19 Giorgi Talakhadze 33 Male unemployed 20 Niko Kakiashvili 42 Male unemployed 21 Varlam Tchipashvili 23 Male City council member 22 Davit Pavladze 29 Male Board collaborator 23 Irakli Beradze 27 Male Board collaborator Name of the Village: Tsipha Date of Consultation :15.12.14 Number of Participants: 3 1 Eldar Kurdadze 66 Male Unemployed 2 Tengiz Bantsadze 52 Male Unemployed
124 # Name of the Participant Age Male /Female Occupation 3 Merab Gachechiladze 49 Male Unemployed Name of the Village: Aneula Date of Consultation :18.12.14 Number of Participants: 5 1 Kvinikidze Mamuka 41 Male Unemployed 2 Kakiashvili Valeri 31 Male Unemployed 3 Talakhadze Giorgi 34 Male Unemployed 4 Kakiashvili Gurami 57 Male Railway 5 Kakiashvili Niko 42 Male Unemployed Name of the Village: Chumateleti Date of Consultation :02.12.14 Number of Participants: 18 1 Daria qoridze 62 Female Mistress 2 Nona chaduneli 48 Female Mistress 3 Givi korkotadze 66 Male Pensioner 4 Dali suladze 50 Female mistress 5 Lia korkotadze 63 Female Businesswoman 6 Tamazi ulumbelashvili 67 Male Pensioner 7 Otari ulumbelashvili 61 Male Driver 8 Temuri korkotadze 52 Male Driver 9 Alika ulumbelashvili 27 Male Economist 10 Tamar korkotadze 40 Female Businesswonam 11 Manana tskhovrebadze 60 Female Pensioner 12 Levan korkotadze 69 Male Pensioner 13 Eter korkotadze 65 Female Pensioner 14 Nano gachechiladze 52 Female Mistress 15 Omar bliadze 79 Male Driver 16 Madona ulumbelashvili Female Mistress 17 Dimitri tarielashvili 34 Male 18 Nana bliadze Female Mistress Name of the Village: Dzirula Date of Consultation :02.12.14 Number of Participants: 14 1 Lamara lomidze 65 Female Pensioner 2 Nato giorgadze 50 Female Doctor 3 Bejani kalandadze 62 Male Unemployed 4 Nunu skhiladze 55 Female Unemployed 5 Bichiko kakhniashvili 64 Male Unemployed 6 Paata gelashvili 35 Male Unemployed 7 Eka zviadauri 36 Female Mistress 8 Onegi gelashvili 63 Male Unemployed 9 Avtandil ebanoidze 62 Male Unemployed 10 Juta kalandadze 75 Male Pensioner 11 Nugzar svanidze 45 Male Unemployed 12 Merab skhiladze 63 Male Unemployed 13 Ivane gvelesiani 31 Male Driver 14 Malkhaz ebanoidze 40 Male Unemployed Name of the Village: Lashe Date of Consultation :03.12.14 Number of Participants: 8 1 Lia ciskadze 45 Female Teacher
125 # Name of the Participant Age Male /Female Occupation 2 Amiran tkhelidze 63 Male Lecturer 3 Goderdzi grdzelidze 73 Male Pensioner 4 Nargizi manjavidze 63 Female Mistress 5 Giorgi labadze 26 Male Unemployed 6 Nugzari sakhvadze 63 Male Unemployed 7 Giorgi arjevanidze 78 Male Pensioner 8 Dali labadze 57 Female Unemployed PHOTOGRAPHS
126 127 128 ANNEXURE 4.2: COPY OF PRESENTATION DURING FIRST PHASE OF CONSULTATION DURING DETAILED DESIGN
ASIANDEVELOPMENT BANK
ROADSDEPARTMENT(MRDI)
PUBLIC CONSULTATIONSONLANDACQUISITION ANDINVOLUNTARYRESETTLEMENT (LAND ACQUISITIONANDRESETTLEMENTPLAN) SECTION-2: Km25 TOKm50
PreparationofDetailedDesignforRehabilitationof Dzirula– Kharagauli– Moliti– Pona –ChumateletiSecondaryRoad Section(50km),Bidding Documents,EnvironmentalImpact Assessmentand DetailedLandAcquisitionandResettlement Plan
129 MAPOFTHE PROJECTROAD-SECTION-2
130 PROJECTFEATURES
ThisisaDetailedDesignProject Improving theRoadto aTwoLane carriagewaywith shoulderson bothsidesandwithadesign speedof40km/h 25kmoftherehabilitatedand pavedroadfromMolitito Chumateleti(2 RoadSection)accordingtoGeorgian NationalStandard,Geometricaland Structural Requirementswith40 km/hdesignspeed. Constructionofside drainsand otherdrainagestructures. Provision ofretainingwallsand river protectionmeasures, wherenecessary. Provision ofadequateroad signingand marking. Provision ofsafetybarriers.
131 PROJECTFEATURES
Particulars EngineeringFeatures NumberofLanes 2
Lanewidth 3.00Meter
Carriagewaywidth 6.00Meter
Widthofshoulder 1.00Meter(0.50meteris paved) Increaseofshoulderon 0.50Meter embankment Totalroadwidth 9.00Meter AverageSpeed 40kilometerp/h
132 OBJECTIVEOFPUBLICCONSULTATIONS Awarenessaboutthe project andInvolvement of Peoplein Project PlanningandImplementation Discuss futureplanof actionsuch as carryingout detailedmeasurementsurveyssuch as Census Surveys,Inventoryof Assets,Socio-economic householdsurveys,valuationofAssetsand Legalizationof Legalizable Discuss about thecut-off-datewhichisthestartdate ofthe DetailedMeasurementSurvey/CensusSurvey Discuss about thegeneralEligibilityand Entitlement andCompensation and Allowances Discuss about InstitutionalMechanismand Grievance RedressMechanism
133 PROJECT IMPACTS (LANDACQUISTIONAND RESETTLEMENT) Lossof Registered Land Parcel Lossof Un-Registered Land Parcel LossofAgriculturalLand Lossof Residential and CommercialLand Lossof ResidentialHouses Lossof CommercialStructures Lossof OtherAssetssuch as Fencesetc Lossof Crops Lossof Trees Lossof Employment,Incomeand Livelihood Lossof Common Property Resourcesifany
134 COMPENSATION
TheapplicablepoliciesforLand AcquisitionandResettlementin theProjectwillbebased on relevantlegislativeActsofGeorgia andAsianDevelopmentBank’sSafeguardPolicy Statement, 2009. CompensationofAgricultural,ResidentialandCommercialLand CompensationforStructuresand Buildings(Residential, Commercialetc) CompensationofCropsand Trees CompensationofOtherassetsassociatedwithland(fences, Storage,garage,cattleshedsetc) CompensationforLossofIncome andLivelihood Compensationwillbebasedon replacementcostandwillbe determinedasperdetailedassessmentand valuation.
135 OTHERADDITIONALALLOWANCES
Relocationand ShiftingAllowancesforhouseholds tobe relocated
AllowancesforVulnerablePeople (WomenHeadedHouseholds, BelowPovertyLineHouseholds,PhysicallyChallengedand Refugees)
SeverelyAffectedHouseholds(Householdslosingmorethan 10%oftheirProductive AssetsandPhysicallyDisplaced SubsistenceAllowancesduringRelocation
TemporaryImpactsduring Constructionwillbecompensated basedon theassessment
136 ELIGIBILITYANDDEFINITIONOFAFFECTED PERSONS/HOUSEHOLDS
Ownerwithfullregistration/Legalized
LegalizableOwner
Illegitimatelandusersorsquatters/Non-Legalizable (EligibleonlyForNon-LandAssetssuchashouses, crops,etc.butnotforLand) Employeesandotherassociatedmemberssuchastenants
137 NEXT PLANOFACTION (TO BE FOLLOWEDSHORTLY)
DetailedInventory andcensusSurveysofallAffected Households(LastWeekofAugustor FirstWeekofSeptember- 2017)
Socio-EconomicHouseholdSurveys
VillageWisePublic Consultations
ValuationofLand andOtherAssetstobe affected
PreparationofLand AcquisitionandResettlementPlan
DisclosureofDraftLand Acquisitionand ResettlementPlan
Formationof GrievanceRedressCommittee
138 CONCERNSANDAPPEALFORFUTURECOOPERATION
Identificationof UnRegisteredland Parcelwiththe help ofLocal PeopleandAuthority
Stepsto Getthe Un RegisteredParcelsRegisteredat NAPRpriorto payment ofcompensation
Seeking Cooperation from Local peopleandAffectedPersons for ProvidingAdequateandActualInformationDuring the Survey
Seeking Cooperation from Local Peoplefor completion of smooth surveyswork.
SigningEach SurveyFormsespeciallytheDetailedMeasurementSurveyandCe
139 CONCERNSANDAPPEALFORFUTURECOOPERATION nsusSurveybyeachAffectedHouseholdandcertifiedandstampe dbytheVillageAuthority
140 CorePrincipleson InvoluntrayResettlementofAsianDebelopment Bank‘sSafeguardPolicy Statement,2009(SPS,2009) Objectives: Toavoidinvoluntaryresettlementwhereverpossible; tominimizeinvoluntaryresettlementby exploringprojectand design alternatives; toenhance,or at leastrestore,thelivelihoodsofall displaced persons in real termsrelativeto pre-project levelsimprovethestandardsoflivingof thedisplaced poorand other vulnerablegroups. ScopeandTriggers Theinvoluntaryresettlementsafeguards coversphysicaldisplacement (relocation,loss of residentialland,or loss of shelter)andeconomic displacement(loss ofland, assets,accesstoassets,incomesources,or means oflivelihoods)as a result of(i)involuntaryacquisitionof land,or (ii)involuntaryrestrictions on land use or on accessto legallydesignated parks and protectedareas. It coversthem whethersuch lossesand involuntaryrestrictions arefull or partial,permanentortemporary.
141 COMMENTS(ISSUES&CONCERNS)ANDQUESTIONS(Dzirula-Kharagauli- Moliti-Pona-ChumateletiRoad Section)
Name:
Address:
CommentontheRoadRehabilitationProject:
Questiononthe RoadRehabilitationProject:
142 THANKYOU FOR LISTENI NG
143 ANNEXURE 4.3: RECORDS OF PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS IN THE FIRST PHASE OF DETAILED DESIGN AND PRIOR TO DMS
144 145 146 147 148 149 PHOTOGRAPHS DURING PRESENTAION AND CONSULTAIONS
150 151 ANNEXURE 4.4: RECORDS OF CONSULTATION DURING DISCLOSURE OF LARP LEAFLET
152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 PHOTOGRAPHS OF CONSULTAIONS DURING DISCLOSURE
161 162 ANNEXURE 4.5: COPY OF THE LARP LEAFLET
163 Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan Leaflet for Section 2: Km 24.620 to Km 50.405 (Final) for Disclosure
Preparation of Detailed Design for Rehabilitation of Dzirula – Kharagauli – Moliti – Pona – Chumateleti Secondary Road Section (50 km), Bidding Documents, Environmental Impact Assessment and Detailed Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan
NOVEMBER, 2017
Prepared by: Roads Department Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure of Georgia
164 A. Introduction and Project Description
1. Asian Development Bank (ADB) signed a loan with the Government of Georgia (GoG) in June 2017 for financing toward the Rehabilitation of Dzirula-Kharagauli-Moliti-Pona-Chumateleti secondary road section (50 kilometre). Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure (MRDI) is the executing agency (EA) of the Project on behalf of the Government of Georgia and the Roads Department of the MRDI (RDMRDI) is the implementing agency (IA). For implementation purposes, the project has been divided into 2 separate sections of about 25 km each. Given that civil works will be implemented in two separate contracts, final Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plans (LARP) have been prepared separately for each contract/section, during the detailed designs of the project. The second road section (Section-2) covers the eastern region comprising 25.785 kilometre (km) road length from Moliti-Pona-Chumateleti.
2. This leaflet is based on an implementation ready LARPwhich has been prepared for the Section-2 road section from Moliti- Pona- Chumateleti (25.785 Km) as part of the detailed design. The project is classified as category 'B' for involuntary resettlement14 as per ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS) 2009. There are no indigenous peoples as defined in the SPS in the project area, and the project is classified category 'C' for indigenous peoples. The road has been designed keeping in consideration the best engineering solution. Detailed measurement survey (DMS) and 100% census of affected persons have been completed based on detailed and final engineering design and the final Right of Way (RoW). The LARP is based on the Georgian laws and regulations related to land acquisition and involuntary resettlement and ADB SPS 2009. The cut-off-date for this section-2 was set as the start date of DMS and AP census survey which is 30 September 2017.
3. The entire project road is primarily within Georgia’s Imereti region with a few kilometres at the eastern end which is part of Shida Kartli region. It starts from a junction with E60 in the municipality of Dzirula and connects again with E60 at the east end in the village of Chumateleti, which is part of Surami municipality.
14A proposed project is classified as category B if it includes involuntary resettlement impacts that are not deemed significant which means less than 200 or less persons will experience major impacts, which are defined as (i) being physically displaced from housing, or (ii) losing 10% or more of their productive assets (income generating).
165 Location Map of the Project Road
166 B. Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement
4. Total land parcels affected due to land acquisition in section-2 is 208 of which 97 are registered/legalized, 106 are legalizable and 5 parcels are non-legalizable/unauthorized (encroacher). Total land required for the project is 88,413 square meter (sqm) equivalents to 8.84 hectare (ha) of which 85,761 sqm is private land used by the legalized and legalizable owners and and 2,652 sqm of land used by non legalizable (encroacher) users. Total number of agricultural parcel is 198 and non-agricultural parcel is 10. Non agricultural parcels consist of 8 numbers of residential parcels and 2 numbers of commercial parcels. A total of 1,187 numbers of tress are affected due to land acquisition. 41 numbers of structures are affected of which 8 are residential structures such as houses/dwelling and 2 are commercial structures (shop). Remaining 31 structures are considered as other small structures such as fence, garage, storage, cowsheds, and toilets etc. 10 numbers of structures will need physical relocation. Total number of affected households (AH) is 174 comprising of 522 number of affected persons (AP) of which 266 are males and 256 are females. Total number of severely affected households is 35 and numbers of severely affected persons are 111. Total number of vulnerable households is 60 comprising of 182 numbers of vulnerable APs. Summary of impacts on land acquisition and resettlement is given in the Table below. Summary Impact on Land Acquisition and Resettlement (Section-2) # Impacts Unit of Quantification Quantity (Section-2)15 1 Total Land Requirement for acquisition Square meter 88,413 2 Private Land (Registered and Legalizable) Square meter 85,761 3 State Land being used by non legalizable/informal settlers Square meter 2,652 4 Land parcels Number 208 5 Registered Parcel Number 97 6 Eligible/Legalizable Parcel Number 106 7 Non-legalizable/unauthorized Parcel (Encroacher) Number 5 8 Agricultural Land Parcel Number 198 9 Non-Agricultural Land Parcels Number 10 10 Total Tress Number 1,187 11 Total Structures/Buildings including Auxiliary Structures Number 41 12 Residential Houses/Dwelling Number 8 13 Commercial Structures/ Shops Number 2 14 Auxiliary Structures Number 31 15 Structures needing Relocation Number 10 16 Severely Affected Households and Affected Persons Number 35 households and 111 Affected Persons 17 Vulnerable Households Number 60 18 Affected Households Number 174 19 Affected Persons Number 522 20 Male Affected Persons Number 266 21 Female Affected Persons Number 256
D. Consultation and Disclosure
5. Stake holders' consultations have been a continuous process since the feasibility study till the detailed design and will be continued throughout the project implementation. During feasibility study, consultations/public meetings were held at 9 locations from 02 December 2014 till 10 Dec 2014 and the locations where consultations were held were Kharagauli (45 participants), Sagandzile (17 participants), Aneula (5 participants), Chumateleti (18 participants), Dzirula (14 participants), Moliti ( 23 participants), Tsipha (3 participants), Lashe (8 participants) and Pona (3 participants). The consultations process was also continued during the detailed design stage for
15The figures are subject to minor modification based on the final analysis
167 the road section-2 where consultations were carried out at 5 locations such as Kharagauli municipality office, Khasuri municipality office, Chumatelati village, Moliti village and Tsipa village in the month of August 2017. It ensured that the affected people and other stakeholders are informed, consulted and allowed to participate actively in the process of road development and preparation/finalization of LARP. Community consultations involved both men and women participants. The consultation will be continued throughout the project cycle. Copy of the final LARP (full report) will also be translated into Georgian language and will be made available at Roads Department, Municipality office and at affected village level upon approval. Copy of the final LARP will be disclosed in ADB’s website and in the website of Roads Department within MRDI upon approval.
E. Grievance Redress Mechanism
6. A grievance mechanism has been developed at municipality level (Kharagauli and Khasuri municipality) with member from affected villages, roads department and gamgebeli and at the head quarter of Roads Department to allow affected persons appealing any disagreeable decision, practice or activity arising from land or other assets compensation. APs are informed of their rights and of the procedures for addressing complaints during consultation and survey. The grievance redress committee (GRCE) at Municipality level consists of the following:
Representative of LAR Commission of RDMRDI : Member Representative of Resettlement Division at RD : Convenor Gamgebeli of Kharagauli Municipality and Khasuri : Member Secretary Municipality Representative of Gamgebeli in the territory unit of : Member affected villages such as Moliti, Tpsia and Chumateleti Representative of APs : Member Representative of Women APs : Member
7. The grievance redress process will follow three steps as mentioned below and a sample form has been attached in the appendix of the leaflet.
Steps Process Step 1 When during the contract discussion any grievances arise, solutions acceptable to both Municipality’s LAR Team and the APs will be sought. If any aggrieved AP is not satisfied with the solutions, the next option will be to lodge grievances to the GRCE. Step 2 If the grievance is not solved at the previous level, the Municipality level LAR representative will assist the aggrieved APs to formally lodge the grievances with the respective GRCE at Municipality level. The aggrieved APs will lodge the complaint if there is failure of negotiation at village level and produce documents supporting his/her claim. The GRCE member secretary will review the complaint and prepare a Case File for GRCE hearing and resolution. A formal hearing will be held with the GRCE at a date fixed by the GRCE member secretary in consultation with Convenor and the aggrieved APs. On the date of hearing, the aggrieved AP will appear before the GRCE at the village office and produce evidence n support of his/her claim. The member secretary will note down the statements of the complainant and document all proof. The decisions will be issued by the Convenor and signed by other members of the GRCE. The case record will be communicated to the complainant AP by the LAR Team at the village level. The grievance redress at this stage shall be completed within 4 weeks
168 Steps Process Step 3 If any aggrieved AP is unsatisfied with the GRCE decision at Municipality level, the next option will be to lodge grievances to the Grievance Redress Commission (GRCN) at the Resettlement Division at RDMRDI at the national level within 2 weeks after receiving the decision from GRCE. The complainants, must produce documents supporting his/her claim. The GRCN will review the GRCE hearing records and convey its decisions to the aggrieved APs within 4 weeks after receiving the complaint. Note: 1. The scope of the grievance may not necessarily be related to compensation and assistance and may go beyond the compensation issues 2. Affected Persons can approach the court of law at any time and independent of grievance redress process
F. Legal Framework, Compensation Eligibility and Entitlement
8. The legal and policy framework of the Project is based on national laws and legislations related to Land Acquisition and Resettlement (LAR) in Georgia and ADB SPS, 2009. Based on the analysis of applicable laws and policies and ADB’s policy requirement, project related LAR principles have been adopted. APs entitled for compensation or at least rehabilitation provisions under the Project are: (i) All APs losing land either covered by legal title/traditional land rights, Legalizable, or without legal status; (ii) Tenants and sharecroppers whether registered or not; (iii) Owners of buildings, crops, plants, or other objects attached to the land; and (iv) APs losing business, income, and salaries. Entitlement provisions for APs losing land, houses, and income and rehabilitation allowance will include provisions for permanent or temporary land losses, buildings losses, crops and trees losses, a relocation allowances, and a business losses allowance. The valuation of affected assets has been done based on the core principle of replacement cost. An entitlements matrix is provided in Table below.
Entitlement Matrix Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements Land Permanent loss of AP losing productive Registered Owner: Cash compensation at full replacement cost. agricultural land land regardless of Owner with full registration If the residual plot becomes unviable for impact severity cultivation, the project will acquire it if the owner so desire. Eligible/Legalizable The ownership rights of these APs will be Owner: recognized, the land registered in NAPR and (APs with title formalization the APs provided with cash compensation at full replacement cost. pending and APs who are not registered but legitimately use the land and have residential land or agricultural plots adjacent to the residential land). Non- One time minimum subsistence allowance in legalizable/unauthorized/ cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month Squatter/Informal Settler: x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) APs that are not legitimate land users or squatters Agricultural Tenant One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) Non-Agricultural Land AP losing their Registered Owner: Cash compensation at full replacement cost
169 Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements commercial/ (Owner with full residential land registration)
Eligible/Legalizable The ownership rights of these APs will be Owner: recognized, the land registered in NAPR and (The owners legalizable the APs provided with cash compensation at full replacement cost. according to active legislation). Non- One time minimum subsistence allowance in legalizable/unauthorized/ cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month Squatter/Informal Settler x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH) (Without registration/valid documents using land permanently). Buildings and Structures Residential and non All AHs regardless of their Cash compensation for building/structures residential legal ownership/ losses at full replacement costs free of structures/assets registration status depreciation and transaction costs (including legalizable and Informal Settlers) Loss Of Community Infrastructure/Common Property Resources Loss of common Community/Public Community/Government Reconstruction of the lost resource/asset in property resources Assets consultation with community and restoration of their functions Loss of Income and Livelihood Crops Standing crops All APs regardless of legal Crop compensation in cash at market rate by affected or affected status (including default at to gross crop value of expected agricultural land, used legalizable and Informal harvest. permanently for crop Settlers) cultivation. Trees Trees affected All APs regardless of legal Cash compensation at market rate on the status (including basis of type, age and productive value of the legalizable and Informal trees. Settlers) Business/Employment Business/employment All APs regardless of legal Owner: loss status (including (i) (permanent impact) cash indemnity of 1 legalizable and Informal year net income or in the absence of income Settlers) proof, One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 12 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 12 months=4,169 GEL / AH); (ii) (temporary impact) cash indemnity of net income for months of business stoppage. Assessment to be based on tax declaration or, in its absence, minimum salary. (iii) Permanent worker/employees: indemnity for lost wages equal to One time minimum subsistence allowance in cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) Allowances
170 Type of Loss Application Definition of AH/APs Compensation Entitlements Severe Impacts16 >10% income loss All severely affected AHs One time minimum subsistence allowance in and physically including informal settlers cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x 3 displaced household months=1,042 GEL / AH) Relocation/Shifting Transport/transition All AHs to be relocated An allowance covering transport and costs livelihood expenses for the transitional period. (@ 250 GEL as vehicle hire charge + 347.4 GEL per month x 3 months =1,042 GEL) Total = 1,292 GEL/AH) Vulnerable People AHs below poverty line, One time minimum subsistence allowance in Allowances17 headed by Women, cash for 3 months (@347.4 GEL per month x disabled and refugees 3 months=1,042 GEL / AH) and employment priority in project-related jobs where feasible Unforeseen impacts Impacts during All APs Due compensation to be assessed and paid during construction construction to when the impacts are identified based on the properties or assets above provisions. out of the corridor of impact or RoW
9. The project will adopt self relocation policy by the APs through adequate compensation at replacement cost and other additional assistances/allowances. RDMRDI will have lead responsibility for implementation of the Project as well acquisition of land and implementation of the LARP. RDMRDI is assisted by a number of other government departments and private agencies in the design, construction and operation of the Project. Pursuant to the active legislations, National Agency of Public Registry (NAPR) within the Ministry of Justice is in charge of the recognition of ownership rights of rightful owners, registration of land ownership, with process verification and certification from Village Communities, Notaries, Property Rights Recognition Commission (PRRC), and sakrebulo. Municipality NAPR is also responsible for registering transfer of acquired land from landowners to the RDMRDI. The local government at Municipality and sakrebulo levels are involved in the legalization of legalizable land parcels and subsequently land acquisition and resettlement of APs. The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Protection is responsible for environmental issues. The Project road will cover two administrative Municipalitys such as Kharagauli and Khasuri.
10. The time for implementation of resettlement plan will be scheduled as per the overall project implementation. All activities related to the land acquisition and resettlement must be planned to ensure that compensation is paid prior to displacement and commencement of civil works. Public consultation, monitoring and grievance redress will be undertaken intermittently throughout the project duration. RDMRDI will monitor the progress of implementation of the LARP and semi-annual monitoring report will be submitted by RDMRDI to ADB. Monitoring reports will be disclosed to the APs semi-annually. Tentative implementation schedule is described below in the table.
Tentative Implementation Schedule
16Severely affected households in this project include those AHs (i) losing 10% or more than 10% of their productive assets/income generating which is the total land holding of the AH compared to the affected land by the project, (ii) physically displaced HH and (iii) households losing commercial/business establishments. 17Multiple vulnerability of one HH is considered as one and will be paid only one vulnerable allowance
171 LARP Activities 2017 2018 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 A. Detailed Design Detailed Design and corridor Community Consultation Issuance of notification on cut-off-date during detailed design DMS and AP Census Final LARP based on Detailed Design Submission of Final LARP for ADB Approval Disclosure of LARP Establishment of Municipality LAR team and designated staff at REPB at MRDI Legalization Process of the Legalizable B. LARP Implementation Issuance of IDs to APs Payment of compensation to APs Payment of all eligible assistance Takeover possession of acquired property Handover land to contractors Schedule for Civil Work C. Monitoring Internal Monitoring by RDMRDI
172 APPENDIX 1: COMPLAINTS AND GRIEVANCE SUBMISSION FORM
Name of the Project: Name, Last name Contact Information (i) Mail: Please indicate the postal address: ______Please indicate the ______preferable means of ______communication (Mail, ______Telephone, E-mail) (ii) Telephone: ______
(iii) E-mail:______
The language desirable (iv) Georgian for the communication (v) English (vi) Russian
Describe the grievance/claim: What is the complaint about? What is the claim?
Date of Negotiation: Resolution of Negotiation:
Date of incident/claim
What is the basis of your claim?
Signature: ______Date: ______
173 CONTACT DETAILS OF ROADS DEPARTMENT
Address of the Roads Department:
Roads Department of Georgia Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure of Georgia 12 Kazbegi ave., 0160 Tbilisi, Georgia Tel: (995 32) 37-62-16 E-mail: [email protected]
Public Relations Unit Tel/Fax: (995 32) 37-64-18 E-mail: [email protected]
Communication and Information Unit Tel: (995 32) 37-05-08 E-mail: [email protected]
Contact Persons
1. Ms. Nino Mtsuravishvili Deputy Head of the Resettlement Division (RDMRDI) Tel: 595-026688
2. Mr.Shota Batsikadze Project Manager of the Resettlement Division (RDMRDI) Tel: 577-613302
3. Mr. Archil Jorbenadze Coordinator of ADB Projects (ETCIC, MRDI) Tel: 591-403038
174 ANNEXURE 4.6: RECORDS OF RECIPIENTS OF LARP LEAFLET BY AFFECTED PERSONS DURING DISSEMINATION
175 176 177 178 179 180 181 PHOTOGRAPHS OF DISSEMINATION OF LEAFLET
182 183 184 ANNEXURE 5.1: COMPLAINTS AND GRIEVANCE SUBMISSION FORM
Name of the Project: Name, Last name Contact Information (vii)Mail: Please indicate the postal address: ______Please indicate the ______preferable means of ______communication (Mail, ______Telephone, E-mail) (viii) Telephone: ______
(ix) E-mail:______
The language desirable (x) Georgian for the communication (xi) English (xii)Russian
Describe the grievance/claim: What is the complaint about? What is the claim?
Date of Negotiation: Resolution of Negotiation:
Date of incident/claim
What is the basis of your claim?
Signature: ______Date: ______
185 ANNEXURE 5.2: LOG BOOK FOR REGISTERED GRIEVANCE IN GRCN
Registration No complaint Date of Registering Complaint Name of Claimant ID Address Contact Details Entry Point (Where has been claim sent initially?) a)GRCE b)Directly GRCN c) Government d) President e) Other Date of Receipt of claim by Entry Point Notification on Registration of Claim has been sent 1. Date 2. By Whom Content of the Claim The list of attached materials (photos, maps, documents etc.) Level of Grievance Review a) Complaint accepted for processing at GRCN level b) Complaint immediately readdressed to GRCE Date of Consultation with the Claimant in GRCN Notification on Consultation Date and requested missing documents delivered to Claimant Date Link to the scanned copy of the notification letter with the list of requested documents Members of GRCN engaged in Consultations Agreed Actions and schedule a) Schedule and deadlines b) Link to the scanned protocole 1 Grievance Resolved a)Date b) Link to the Protocol 2 Assistance in lodging not Resolved Grievance to the Court or ADB a) Link to the package documents
186 ANNEXURE 6.1: SYNOPSIS OF SELECTED GEORGIA LAWS AND REGULATIONS ON LAR
A. The Constitution of Georgia
1. The Constitution determines the essence of private ownership and defines presumption of inviolability however also regulates the issues related to compensation and expropriation of land and immovable property for necessary public need. The Constitution of Georgia ensures the publicity of information. Pursuant to the Article 21 of the Constitution of Georgia “the right of ownership and inheritance is declared and secured”. Nobody is eligible cancel the universal right of ownership and legacy. Throughout of the necessary public need or if the urgent necessity has emerged, the Article 21.3 of the Constitution allows the expropriation of the private ownership however, only according to the Court Decision or under the rules identified in the organic law18 on basis of the appropriate and fair reimbursement.
2. Other articles of the Constitution of Georgia also create legislative basis in respect with Land Acquisition and resettlement issues. These considers the State actions for expropriation of land for urgent public need, i.e. exercising the right of expropriation (power of eminent domain), also information disclosure and public consultations, protection of cultural heritage and grievance redress related to land acquisition and resettlement of population.
3. The Constitution ensures the right of a citizen to live in safe and healthy environment and use natural and cultural environment. The State undertakes environment protection measures to secure safe environment for people. People have the right to obtain "full, true and timely information" in regard with their work place and residential environment. The Article 42 of the Constitution makes the citizens eligible to claim, in particular protects them and encourages appealing to the court for protection of their rights and freedom.
B. Civil Code of Georgia
4. The Civil Code of Georgia regulates private civil relationships and evolves property rights, obligations, family law and the law on inheritance. Those regulations of the Civil Code that describes ownership right to property and considers right to build, servitude and other rights directly apply to the given project.
Ownership Rights
5. The ownership right entitles its beneficiary to freely possess and use property. It may be limited under the legislation or contractual basis. Ownership on the land parcel gives implicit right to land owner to implement construction activities if it is not restricted by any agreement or law. Alienation of real property is not limited under the Civil Code of Georgia. Pursuant to the article 183 of the Civil Code of Georgia “in order to purchase real property the agreement shall be made in a written format and the ownership right shall be registered on the name of the buyer at the Public Register”. The agreement - based on which one person purchases and the other sells the real property may be notarized. The agreement also may be proved by the person identified under the law (Article 69 of the Civil Code of Georgia). Presently the agreement of sales transaction of real property may be proved by the representative of the Public Register. The presumption of veracity and completeness of entries operate with respect to the Public Register, pursuant to the paragraph 1, Article 312 “an entry in the Public Register shall be deemed to be accurate until its inaccuracy is proven
18 In the hierarchy of the laws the Organic Law stands between the Constitution and other laws, what highlights the significant importance of the latest.
187 Right to Build.
6. The owner is allowed to transfer a land plot to another person in temporary usage (not to exceed 59 yeMDFG) for charge or free of charge. The transferee obtains the right to build a building/construction on or under the land plot, as well as to assign and transfer this right under inheritance or tenancy, borrowing or renting. The construction right may cover such part of a land plot that is not necessary for the actual construction but allows a better use of the facility constructed on the basis of the construction permit. Termination of the construction right requires consent from the landowner. Based on the Article 180 of this Code, if a land parcel lacks the access to public roads that are necessary for its adequate use, the other owner may claim from a neighbour to tolerate the use of his land parcel by the owner for the purpose of providing the necessary access. The mentioned article may be used for road construction, though the determination of necessary right of way is rather complicated procedure and in case of road construction evolves the obligations to prove the existence of the elements of such rights. In case of necessary right of way, the implementer of road project shall have the right to undertake road construction notwithstanding the owner’s will.
Right of Servitude
7. This right shall also be noted that according to the Civil Code of Georgia means the restriction imposed onto a land parcel or real property in favor of the owner (beneficiary) of another land parcel or real property. The Beneficiary is granted the right to use land parcel under restriction with some conditions and /or restricts undertaking specific activities or prohibits land owner to exercise some rights against this land parcel. However, in regard with this project, terms and conditions for transfer of any right (among them ownership, construction, necessary right of way or servitude) shall be defined against each land parcel in accordance to the identified rule and on the basis of the agreement entered between the land owner and the party holding appropriate right to act so. This agreement shall be registered at the Public Register.
C. Law of Georgia on the Protection of Cultural Heritage
8. In addition to the Constitution of Georgia affirming the State's obligation to protect cultural heritage and requiring each citizen to care for, protect and preserve cultural heritage the Law of Georgia on Protection of Cultural Heritage defines the legislative principals for protection of existing cultural heritages in Georgia.
9. According to the Law, State protection of cultural heritage is undertaken by the Ministry of Culture, Monuments Protection and Sport, Ministry of Justice of Georgia, local self-government bodies, as well as other State Institutions, Public and Legal Persons of Private Law; On the territories of Abkhazia and Adjara autonomous republics the corresponding bodies of Abkhazia and Adjara autonomous republics within the scope of authority defined under the legislation of Georgia. It is worth to be mentioned that the State and local self-government bodies exercise their authorities in the sphere of protection of cultural heritage in accordance to the Constitutional Agreement between the State and the Orthodox Church of Georgia. The Ministry of Culture, Monuments Protection and Sports of Georgia provides general coordination and manages the activities undertaken in this sphere. In respect with the ownership rights, the Law identifies some differentiations. Namely, the alienation of the State-owned land parcel - located within the zone of State-owned monument, considered as cultural valuables, or located within archeologically protected area - with the right to possess and use the Law considers the agreement with the Ministry of Culture, Monuments Protection and Sports with the terms and conditions of protecting and care being identified ahead.
188 On the other hand, the Law directly restricts alienation of the monuments under private ownership that can only be alienated under the right to possess, and use and with the terms and conditions to care-and protect.
D. The Law of Georgia on Notary Actions
10. The stated law defines the types of notary actions and rule of their implementation. Also the law defines which insittutions and authorized persons except the Notaries have right to conduct Notary actions within the territory of Georgia and beyond it. On the basis of the Article 42 of the Law the local self-governments have right to implement Notary actions related to inheritance, accuracy of the copy to the original document, proving the fact that a citizen is alive, proving the fact of a citizen’s ceratin location. Rural population often apply to local self- governments to condact certain notary actions. Especially, when it is required to identify a person and a document, or the notary actions are required to replace the deceased head of the household with a new member. This rule is often utilized in regsitration of the land parcels when as the owner of the land parcel the other member of the household is registered in place of the deceased member. The representatives of the Consulates of Georgia (consuls) also other key persons at the Consulates are eligible to conduct notary actions on behalf of the State of Georgia beyond the territory of the country. (Article 43). Citizens being abroad may apply to the Consulate of Georgia in the county of their location.
E. The Law of Georgia on Privatization of State-owned Agricultural Land
11. The Law regulates the privatization of State-owned agricultural land. On the basis of this law the leased or non leased State-owned agricultural land subject to privatization. However, the categories of agricultural lands listed below do not subject to privatization: - grazing lands except the grazing lands which before law enactment were leased; grazing lands attached to existing structures being under ownership of legal and/or physical persons or state ownership in accordance to the rule refined by the Law; - Cattle-driving routs; - water fund land, except fish breeding artificial ponds and the lands of common water use category utilized as agricultural lands in accordance to the Law of Georgia on Water. - Forest fund land used under agricultural designation; - Recreation lands; - Lands allocated to Historical monuments, nature and religious monuments; - Land of protected areas; - Agricultural lands assigned as reform land in Adjara Autonomous republic; - Agricultural lands being used by Budgetary Institutions and legal entities of public law in the form of usufruct. 12. Privatization of the two categories (forest fund and recreation land) of agricultural land is still allowed, although only for development of resort-recreation infrastructure in accordance to the decision of the Government of Georgia.
F. The Law of Georgia on Ownership to Agricultural Land
13. The current law is completely different from the initial version adopted in 1996. The changes made in this law in different times (among them the amendments on the basis of the Law # 389 as of July 14, 2000) have significantly changed its initial format and simplified to maximum extend the procedures regulated by this Law.
189 14. Article 3.1. Defines that "a land parcel with or without household structure that is registered at the public register and used for cattle-breeding and plant cultivation produces is considered as an agricultural land parcel" with existing household and additional structures or without them. Also the share of a member of household community within the shared hay fields, grazing lands or forestry areas and the part of the agricultural land that may be the object "of separate ownership right" (Article 3.2).
15. The same Law determines that the ownership right to agricultural land is granted to the State, citizen of Georgia, household (komli) and legal person registered in accordance to the legislation of Georgia, which carries out his activities in agricultural sphere. Besides, the Law declares the State, private and community ownership right to grazing lands in the high mountain regions (Article 43).
16. Also, according to the limitations determined under this law, a foreigner and legal person registered abroad held ownership right only to the bequeathed agricultural land parcels and foreigners also in case when as citizens of Georgia they reasonably possessed agricultural land parcels. Besides, it is worth to be considered that foreigners and legal persons registered abroad are obliged to alienate privately owned agricultural land parcels to the citizen of Georgia, Komli and/or legal person registered in Georgia according to the legislation of Georgia within six months period since they obtained private ownership to the given land parcel. Besides, in case this legal requirement is neglected, private ownership to the agricultural land parcels privately owned by foreigners and legal persons registered abroad shall be taken away under the Court Decision and in return of due compensation. (The standards identified by the Law of Georgia on the Rules for Expropriation of Ownership for Necessary Public Need shall also be exercised in given case).
17. According to Articles 6 and 8, acquisition of agricultural land is allowed on the basis of ordinary rules and general restrictions. Ordinary rule considers land alienation without any permits and other limitations, and general restrictions consider land alienation only on the basis of the consent of co-owner of shared property. In case of agricultural land acquisition the lessee has the priority right to purchase the land. (Article10). Alienation is restricted if the area after this action will be less then 5 hectares (Article 9).
18. The Law defines Tax sanctions if land has not been cultivated for 2 yeMDFG and for non- payment of land tax and non transmission to the other person in lease condition. In such cases the law does not directly state any type of penalty and only refers that in described cases shall be exercised the sanctions under the Tax legislation (Article 20).
G. Law of Georgia on Registration of Rights to Immovable Property
19. The Law defines the rules, terms and conditions for registration of rights to immovable property (things), rights and obligations of the subjects participating in registration procedures. The goal of this Law is to declare and verify ownership rights for immovable property (things) within the territory of Georgia (so as some other rights out of subjective, guarantee and liability relationships) through registration of these rights into the Public Register. The Law describes the rules set for organization and functioning of Public Register. Pursuant to the Law ownership right to real property, mortgage, right to build, usufruct, servitude, lease, sub-lease, rent, sub-rent, lending subject to registration (Article 13.2).
20. This law ensures successful process of expropriation and obtaining of necessary right of way since in case of purchasing immovable property from an owner, it is required that land and real property is registered into the public register to provide legal validity to the sales agreement.
190 Pursuant to the active legislation of Georgia, acquisition (purchase) of private property is legally valid and ownership rights are declared only after its registration into the Public Registry.
H. The Law of Georgia on the Rules for Expropriation of Ownership for Necessary Public Need
21. The Law of Georgia of “Rules for Expropriation of Ownership for Necessary Public Need” (July, 23, 1999) specified the expropriation procedures, liabilities and implements the rules. The Rules for Expropriation of the ownership which has a possible usage in Georgia in some occasions including Road construction will be issued Regional (civil) Court verdict on the basis of the Presidential Decree.
22. According to the Constitution of Georgia the expropriation of the property in the process of construction of the magisterial motor road is permitted for necessary public need. The process of Expropriation is to be undertaken only by the Court Decision of the President of Georgia and corresponding instances. Expropriation is undertaking by means of compensation payment which is to be corresponding to market value and honest. The State of Georgia has a constitutional right to carry out acquisition property through Expropriation instead of payment of legislative compensation (Clause 21).
I. Procedural Civil Code of Georgia
23. The general courts of Georgia consider the cases according to the rules identified under the Procedural Civil Code of Georgia. The requirements of the procedural law are exercised during the lawsuit, during implementation of separate procedural actions or execution of the court decision.
24. The Procedural Civil Code of Georgia also regulates those cases when determination of the defendant is impossible. This may be important for the Project in the cases when the landowner is not found and correspondingly ownership to his/her land parcel cannot be obtained in legally valid manner, i.e. it is impossible to enter corresponding agreement with the landowner or him/her cannot sign other type of document. The above-listed laws and regulations give the possibility of applying the following three mechanisms for legal application of the property rights: Obtaining the road right of way without expropriation through the payment of due compensation (on the basis of negotiations or a court decision) prior to commencement of the activities; Expropriation which gives the possibility of obtaining permanent right to land and/or necessary road on the basis of Eminent Domain Law or a court decision through the payment of due compensation; Expropriation of private properties for urgent public necessity, which gives the possibility of obtaining permanent rights on land and/or necessary road for the purpose of national security or accident prevention. Expropriation is to be made on the basis of the Presidential Decree on Expropriation through the payment of due compensation to affected people. 25. If applied adequately the above listed mechanisms can ensure the appropriate consideration of lawful interests of all parties and the due observation of the existing legislations.
ANNEXURE 7.1: METHODOLOGY FOR DETERMINING COMPENSATION RATES BY THE VALUATION COMPANY
191 LAND Kharagauli villages Comparizon Analogue #1 Analogue #2 Analogue #3 Analogue Analogue Analogue elements #4 #5 #6 Description Non agricultural agricultural land, Non agricultural agricultural agricultural Non land, 500 sq. m 700 sq. m land, fluctuatio sq. land, 1716 land, 72 agricultural m1054 sq. m sq. m land, 800 sq. m Address Chartala Village, Nunisi Village, Goresha Village, Bazaleti Lashe Khvi Kharagauli Kharagauli Kharagauli Village, Village, Village, municipality municipality municipality Kharagauli Kharagauli Kharagauli municipalit municipalit municipalit y y y Unit cost for 7 GEL /1sq.m. 6 GEL /1sq.m. 5 GEL /1sq.m. 3.5 GEL 5.4 GEL 10 GEL bid and bidding (proposal) (proposal) (proposal) /1sq.m. /1sq.m. /1sq.m. type (negotiatio (negotiatio (negotiatio n) n) n) Source http://chemikharag https://gancxadeb http://nasp.gov.ge/ Public Public Public auli.com/?p=11340 ebi.ge/ka/ pages/show.php? registry registry registry #.WhVecVWWaUk postid=1333&pag data, data, data, e_id=45 cadaster cadaster cadaster code: code: code: 36.02.33.3 36.04.33.0 36.05.35.0 74 06 05 23.08,.201 27.10.201 10,07,2017 7 7 Price, 1 sq. m 7 6 5 3.5 5.4 10 Ownership complete complete complete complete complete complete transfer Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 7 6 5 3.5 5.4 10 price, 1 sq. m Financial typical typical typical typical typical typical conditions Correction no no no no no no Corrected 7 6 5 3.5 5.4 10 price, 1 sq. m Sell conditions typical typical typical typical typical typical Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 7 6 5 3.5 5.4 10 price, 1 sq. m Expences proposal proposal proposal negotiation negotiation negotiation related seller Correction -10% -10% -10% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 6.3 5.4 4.5 3.5 5.4 10 price, 1 sq. m Market current current current current current current conditions Correction 0% 0% 0% 100% 200% 300% Corrected 6.3 5.4 4.5 3.5 5.4 10 price, 1 sq. m adgilmdebareo similar similar similar better similar better ba Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% -20% Corrected 6.3 5.4 4.5 3.5 5.4 8.0 price, 1 sq. m Phisical better better similar similar better better properties: renewed Correction -10% -10% 0% 0% -5% -30%
192 Corrected 5.7 4.9 4.5 3.5 5.1 5.6 price, 1 sq. m Economic similar similar similar similar similar similar properties Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5.7 4.9 4.5 3.5 5.1 5.6 price, 1 sq. m existence of no no no no no no removable components Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5.7 4.9 4.5 3.5 5.1 5.6 price, 1 sq. m Ri 1 1 1 1.5 1.5 1.5 ∑ R 7.5 Vi 0.8 0.6 0.6 0.7 1.0 1.1 Vwa Market 5 price for 1 sq. m (GEL)
Inhabited section of Surami-Chumateleti section Comparizon Analogue #1 Analogue #2 Analogue #3 Analogue Analogue Analogue elements #4 #5 #6 Description agricultural land, agricultural land, agricultural land, agricultural non- agricultural 3035 sq. m 1700 sq. m with 1115 sq. m land, 368 agricultural land, 509 fruit trees sq. m land,198 sq. m sq. m Address Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri municipality, municipality, municipality, municipalit municipalit municipalit Surami, Itria; Tel: Surami, Surami, y, Surami, y, Surami, y, Surami, (+995 597) 736677 Chumateleti; Tel: Chumateleti; Chumatele Urtkhva; Chumatele 555697444 ti; ti; Unit cost for 45 GEL /1sq.m. 48 GEL /1sq.m. 45 GEL /1sq.m. 50 GEL 33 GEL 40 GEL bid and bidding (proposal) (proposal) (negotiation) /1sq.m. /1sq.m. /1sq.m. type (negotiatio (negotiatio (negotiatio n) n) n) Source http://www.geos.ge https://gancxadeb Public registry Public Public Public /search- ebi.ge/ka/ data, cadaster registry registry registry results/?country_id code: data, data, data, =538&category_id= 69.04.54.227 cadaster cadaster cadaster 7&city_id=135&pric 27,10,2017 code: code: code: e- 69.04.55.1 69.04.54.2 69.04.54.2 from=&searchObje 84 26 25 cts 01,05,201 29.09.201 05,10,2017 7 7 Price, 1 sq. m 45 48 45 50 33 40 Ownership complete complete complete complete complete complete transfer Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 45 48 45 50 33 40 price, 1 sq. m Financial typical typical typical typical typical typical conditions Correction no no no no no no Corrected 45 48 45 50 33 40 price, 1 sq. m Sell conditions typical typical typical typical typical typical Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 45 48 45 50 33 40 price, 1 sq. m
193 Expences proposal proposal negotiation negotiation negotiation negotiation related seller Correction -10% -10% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 40.5 43.2 45 50 33 40 price, 1 sq. m Market current current current current current current conditions Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 40.5 43.2 45 50 33 40 price, 1 sq. m adgilmdebareo similar similar similar better worst worst ba Correction 0% 0% 0% -5% 15% 10% Corrected 40.5 43.2 45.0 47.5 38.0 44.0 price, 1 sq. m Phisical similar better similar similar similar similar properties: renewed Correction 0% -5% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 40.5 41.0 45.0 47.5 38.0 44.0 price, 1 sq. m Economic similar similar similar similar similar similar properties Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 40.5 41.0 45.0 47.5 38.0 44.0 price, 1 sq. m existence of no no no no no no removable components Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 40.5 41.0 45.0 47.5 38.0 44.0 price, 1 sq. m Ri 1 1 2 1 1 1.5 ∑ R 7.5 Vi 5.4 5.5 12.0 6.3 5.1 8.8 Vwa Market 43 price for 1 sq. m (GEL)
Uninhabited section of Surami-Chumateleti section Comparizon Analogue #1 Analogue #2 Analogue #3 Analogue Analogue Analogue elements #4 #5 #6 Description agricultural land, agricultural land, agricultural land, agricultural agricultural agricultural 1331 sq. m 467 sq. m with 1009 sq. m land, 267 land, 44 land, 64 fruit trees sq. m sq. m sq. m Address Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri Khashuri municipality, municipality, municipality, municipalit municipalit municipalit Surami, Surami, Itria; Surami, y, Surami, y, Surami, y, Surami, Chumateleti; Chumateleti; vil. vil. Bijnisi; Urtkhva; Urtkhva; Unit cost for 5 GEL /1sq.m. 6.5 GEL /1sq.m. 8 GEL /1sq.m. 6.4 GEL 8.3 GEL 6 GEL bid and bidding (negotiation) (negotiation) (negotiation) /1sq.m. /1sq.m. /1sq.m. type (negotiatio (negotiatio (negotiatio n) n) n) Source Public registry Public registry Public registry Public Public Public data, cadaster data, cadaster data, cadaster registry registry registry code: 69.04.55.004 code: code: data, data, data, 30,01,2017 69.04.55.007 69.04.54.093 cadaster cadaster cadaster 15,03,2017 07,03,2017 code: code: code: 69.04.53.5 69.04.53.5 69.04.53.5 22 40 25 09,01,2017
194 09,01,201 03,07.201 7 7
Price, 1 sq. m 5 6.5 8 6.4 8.3 6 Ownership complete complete complete complete complete complete transfer Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5 6.5 8 6.4 8.3 6 price, 1 sq. m Financial typical typical typical typical typical typical conditions Correction no no no no no no Corrected 5 6.5 8 6.4 8.3 6 price, 1 sq. m Sell conditions typical typical typical typical typical typical Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5 6.5 8 6.4 8.3 6 price, 1 sq. m Expences negotiation negotiation negotiation negotiation negotiation negotiation related seller Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5 6.5 8 6.4 8.3 6 price, 1 sq. m Market current current current current current current conditions Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5 6.5 8 6.4 8.3 6 price, 1 sq. m adgilmdebareo similar similar similar similar similar worst ba Correction 0% 0% 100% 0% 100% 10% Corrected 5.0 6.5 8.0 6.4 8.3 6.6 price, 1 sq. m Phisical similar similar similar similar similar similar properties: renewed Correction 0% -100% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5.0 6.5 8.0 6.4 8.3 6.6 price, 1 sq. m Economic similar similar similar similar similar similar properties Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5.0 6.5 8.0 6.4 8.3 6.6 price, 1 sq. m existence of no no no no no no removable components Correction 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Corrected 5.0 6.5 8.0 6.4 8.3 6.6 price, 1 sq. m Ri 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 ∑ R 9 Vi 0.8 1.1 1.3 1.1 1.4 1.1 Vwa Market 7 price for 1 sq. m (GEL)
195 CROPS
maize production Average yield of Maize t/ha Region kg/1sq.m. Average yield t/ha Average yield Average Average yield 1 sq.m. for received for 1 sq.m received (GEL) sq.m 1 for Price 1 kg maize Price for (GEL)
200 200 200 200 201 201 200 200 200 200 201 201 2006- Maize compenseation amount 2006-2011 6 7 8 9 0 1 6 7 8 9 0 1 2011 Imereti 61.8 85.8 97.2 95.4 44.8 67.3 1.4 2 2.1 2.1 1.3 1.8 1.8 0.18 1.2 0.21 Samegrelo Zemo 77.2 83.9 95 93.3 35.3 66.7 2.3 2.4 2.4 2.2 1.1 2.1 2.1 0.2 1.2 0.25 Svaneti Guria 23.9 34.3 37.7 29.8 18.8 29.2 3 4.7 4.5 3.6 2.3 3.5 3.6 0.36 1.2 0.43 Kakheti 14.8 23.5 51.6 32.4 13.1 44 1.3 2.2 2 3.1 1.5 2.7 2.1 0.2 1.2 0.26 Kvemo Kartli 21.1 38 17.3 14.6 6.8 32.5 2.3 3.2 2.3 2.9 2.5 3 2.7 0.27 1.2 0.32 Other regions* 18.6 30.3 29.4 25.5 22.3 29.9 1.5 2.2 1.9 2 1.7 2.4 2.0 0.195 1.2 0.23 GEORGIA 217 296 328 291 141 270 1.8 2.4 2.3 2.4 1.4 2.3 2.1 0.21 1.2 0.25 * Ajara A/R, Samtskhe- Javakheti, Shida Kartli
196 cereal production Average yield of cereal t/ha Region kg/1sq.m. Average yield t/ha Average yield Average Average yield 1 sq.m. for Price 1 kg beanPrice for (GEL) received for 1 sq.m received (GEL) 1sq.m for
200 200 200 200 201 201 200 200 200 200 201 201 2006- Bean compenseation amount 2006-2011 6 7 8 9 0 1 6 7 8 9 0 1 2011 Ajara A/R 0.9 1.2 2.1 0.5 0.4 0.4 ------0.7 0.07 3 0.21 Imereti 1.5 1.9 2.5 2.2 0.4 1.4 ------0.7 0.07 3 0.21 Samegrelo Zemo 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.4 0.1 0.3 ------0.7 0.07 3 0.21 Svaneti Shida Kartli 1.5 1.9 2.8 1.4 1.4 2.7 0.4 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.5 0.7 0.5 0.05 3 0.15 Mtskheta-Tianeti 0.2 0.9 0.4 0.5 0.4 0.5 0.2 0.9 0.5 0.7 0.5 0.6 0.6 0.06 3 0.17 Kakheti 0.3 0.6 1 2 0.7 0.7 0.5 0.7 0.8 1.7 0.5 0.7 0.8 0.08 3 0.25 Kvemo Kartli 1.2 1.7 0.9 1.8 1.7 1.3 0.7 1 0.5 1.2 0.6 0.8 0.8 0.08 3 0.24 Samtskhe-Javakheti 0.6 0.6 0.4 0.7 0.3 0.9 0.7 0.7 0.7 2 0.4 0.7 0.9 0.09 3 0.26 Other regions 0.5 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.4 0.7 0.6 1.1 1.4 1.6 0.7 0.1 0.9 0.09 3 0.28 GEORGIA 7.6 10.5 11.6 10.2 5.8 8.9 0.5 0.7 0.6 1 0.6 0.7 0.7 0.07 3 0.21
197 vegetable production Average yield of vegetable t/ha Region kg/1sq.m. (GEL) Average yield t/ha Average yield Average Average yield 1 sq.m. for
200 200 200 200 201 201 200 200 200 200 201 201 2006- vegetable compenseation 2006-2011 amount received sq.m1 for 6 7 8 9 0 1 6 7 8 9 0 1 2011 vegetable1 kgPrice for (GEL) Imereti 17.2 15.3 15.9 14 17.9 20.8 4.3 5.3 5 3.3 4.7 3.5 4.4 0.4 2.5 1.09 Samegrelo Zemo 14.6 8.6 9 7 19.4 14.2 4.9 3.2 2.7 2.6 7 5.6 4.3 0.4 2.5 1.08 Svaneti Shida Kartli 34.4 36.9 32.9 25.4 29.3 47.1 8.2 6.7 6.1 5.9 7.4 7.7 7.0 0.7 2.5 1.75 Kakheti 21.4 11.6 41.4 17.4 19.9 22.9 5.5 2.8 6.1 3.3 4.3 5.7 4.6 0.5 2.5 1.15 Kvemo Kartli 62.2 79.5 28.9 66.8 57.7 40.5 8.5 8.3 7.5 9.4 8.8 12.9 9.2 0.9 2.5 2.31 Samtskhe-Javakheti 15.5 2.6 17 27.6 14 23.7 11.9 9.4 10.5 10.6 11.7 11.1 10.9 1.1 2.5 2.72 Other regions 14.4 17.8 19.9 12.1 17.5 16.6 4 4.5 8 3.3 7 6.7 5.6 0.6 2.5 1.40 GEORGIA 180 190 165 170 176 186 6.6 6.1 5.9 6.8 7.1 7.6 6.7 0.7 2.5 1.67
198 melon-type production Average yield of melon-type t/ha Region (GEL) (GEL) sq.m. kg/1sq.m. sq.m. Average yield t/ha Average yield Average Average yield 1 for
200 200 200 200 201 201 2006- 1 kg vegetable Price for 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2006-2011 vegetable compenseation 6 7 8 9 0 1 2011 amount received sq.m 1 for Imereti - 16 8.8 12.6 9 10.4 - 9.2 9.3 15.1 15.5 10.3 9.9 1.0 1 1.0 Kakheti - 41 36 22.9 29.6 29 - 15.7 14.8 15 16.2 12.7 12.4 1.2 1 1.2 Kvemo Kartli - 11.9 4.5 3.7 1.5 1.2 - 13.2 14.9 18 5.8 32.7 14.1 1.4 1 1.4 Other regions - 4.6 3.5 4.5 0.8 2.2 - 3.9 4.1 5.9 6.5 7.1 4.6 0.5 1 0.5 GEORGIA - 73.5 52.8 43.7 40.9 42.8 - 13 14 14 15 12 11.4 1.1 1 1.1
potato production Average yield of potato t/ha Region t/ha (GEL) Average yield Averageyield sq.m (GEL) sq.m Average yield for Averageyield for 1 sq.m. kg/1sq.m. 1 sq.m. 200 200 200 200 201 201 2006-
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2006-2011 1 kg potato Pricefor amount amount received 1 for 6 7 8 9 0 1 2011 potatocompenseation Ajara A/R 25.5 32 31.6 16.7 11.6 9 4.3 16 17 11.8 8.7 10.1 11.3 1.1 1.5 1.70 109. 108. 144. 128. 169. Samtskhe-Javakheti 54.3 4.9 13.2 10.6 17.7 12.6 16 12.5 1.3 1.5 1.88 3 1 1 5 7 Kvemo Kartli 69.8 59.9 24.9 35.3 63.3 58.4 8.2 9.8 4 7.8 13.8 17.3 10.2 1.0 1.5 1.52 Other regions 19.1 28 28.8 20.7 25.4 36.8 4 5.8 5 4.3 5.4 6.5 5.2 0.5 1.5 0.78
199 168. 229. 193. 216. 228. 273. GEORGIA 7.4 10.8 8.0 11.5 11.1 13.6 10.4 1.0 1.5 1.56 7 2 4 4 8 9
Grass productions Average yield of grass t/ha Region kg/1sq.m. Average yield t/ha Average yield Average Average yield 1 sq.m. for received for 1 sq.m received (GEL) 1sq.m for Price for 1 bunch Pricefor grass (KG) grass compenseation grass compenseation amount 2006- 2006- 1 bunch Price for grass (GEL) 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2011 2011 Shida Kartli 2.9 1.6 2.9 3.7 1.8 2 2.4 2.7 3.5 1.7 2.6 3.1 2.67 0.27 20 4 0.05 Kvemo Kartli 8.1 3.9 17.5 15.2 12.1 36.7 3.2 2.6 3.5 2.6 4.2 3.1 2.98 0.30 20 4 0.06 Samtskhe- 11 2.5 6 3.4 5.3 7.4 2.4 2.8 4.9 2.4 6.6 3.1 3.13 0.31 20 4 0.06 Javakheti Other 3.8 0.8 3.8 0.7 6.7 2.4 1.6 1.6 5.3 1 5.6 3.1 2.38 0.24 20 4 0.05 regions* GEORGIA 25.8 8.8 30.2 23 25.9 48.5 2.8 2.7 3.9 2.3 4.6 3.1 2.93 0.29 20 4 0.06 * Adjara A/R,Samegrelo and Zemo Svaneti, Mtskheta-Tianeti, Kakheti
200 TREES G=(C*N-V)*L Age year (GEL) (GEL) Name of Average Average 1 kg fruit 1 kg Plant/Trees to be repaid be to Value of plant of Value and plant careplant and Tree unit proce Tree unit productivity kg. productivity Land cultivation cultivation Land Number years Number of Start of breeding Startof cost cost year per GEL wholesale of price wholesale 1 in income Gross 1-5 2 3 5 5 2.0 4 3 5 6-10 10 3 10 5 2.0 20 15 50 11-15 50 3 10 5 2.0 100 80 200
quince 16-20 50 3 10 5 2.0 100 80 200 21+ 35 3 8 5 2.0 70 60 80 1-5 4 3 5 2 1.5 6 4 10 6-10 20 3 5 2 1.5 30 8 110 11-15 20 3 5 2 1.5 30 8 110
apricot 16-20 15 3 5 2 1.5 23 5 88 21+ 11 3 5 2 1.5 17 5 58 1-5 3 3 5 5 1.0 3 2 5 6-10 30 3 7 5 1.0 30 10 140 11-15 30 3 7 5 1.0 30 10 140
peach 16-20 15 3 7 5 1.0 15 10 35 21+ 10 3 7 5 1.0 10 10 0 1-5 3 3 5 5 2.0 6 3 15 6-10 10 3 7 5 2.0 20 10 70
fig 11-15 20 3 7 5 2.0 40 20 140 16-20 20 3 7 5 2.0 40 20 140 21+ 10 3 7 5 2.0 20 10 70 1-5 3 3 5 5 2.0 6 3 15 6-10 10 3 7 5 2.0 20 10 70 11-15 20 3 7 5 2.0 40 20 140
ki (kaki) 16-20 20 3 7 5 2.0 40 20 140 21+ 10 3 7 5 2.0 20 10 70 persimmon/karalio 1-5 3 3 5 5 2.0 6 3 15 6-10 10 3 7 5 2.0 20 12 56 11-15 20 3 7 5 2.0 40 25 105 16-20 20 3 7 5 2.0 40 25 105 mMushmala 21+ 10 3 7 5 2.0 20 12 56 1-5 2 3 5 5 2.0 4 3 5 6-10 10 3 10 5 2.0 20 10 100
apple 11-15 50 3 10 5 2.0 100 80 200 16-20 50 3 10 5 2.0 100 80 200
201 Age year (GEL) (GEL) Name of Name of Average Average 1 kg fruit 1 kg Plant/Trees to repaid be to Value plant of Value and plant care plant and Tree unit proce Tree unit productivity kg. productivity Land cultivation cultivation Land Number of years Numberof Start breeding Start of cost cost year per GEL wholesale of price wholesale 1 in income Gross 21+ 35 3 8 5 2.0 70 60 80 1-5 2 6 5 5 2.0 4 3 5 6-10 10 6 10 5 2.0 20 11 90 11-15 60 6 15 5 2.0 120 100 300 pear 16-20 60 6 15 5 2.0 120 100 300 21+ 60 6 13 5 2.0 120 100 260 1-5 3 5 5 4 1.5 5 1 18 6-10 10 5 10 4 1.5 15 8 70 11-15 30 5 10 4 1.5 45 32 130
(alucha) 16-20 30 5 10 4 1.5 45 32 130
r cherry-plum r 21+ 7 5 10 4 1.5 11 5 55 Plum/tkemali/sou 1-5 2 10 5 5 5.0 10 3 35 6-10 4 10 10 5 5.0 20 10 100 11-15 20 10 15 5 5.0 100 80 300
walnut 16-20 30 10 20 5 5.0 150 130 400 21+ 30 10 20 5 5.0 150 130 400 1-5 4 3 5 2 1.5 6 4 10 6-10 7 3 8 2 1.5 11 4 52 11-15 15 3 8 2 1.5 23 5 140 nut 16-20 12 3 8 2 1.5 18 5 104 21+ 10 3 8 2 1.5 15 5 80 1-5 6 3 3 1 1.0 6 5 3 6-10 15 3 5 1 1.0 15 10 25 11-15 30 3 5 1 1.0 30 15 75
vineyard 16-20 30 3 5 1 1.0 30 15 75 21+ 25 3 5 1 1.0 25 15 50 1-5 3 3 3 1 1.0 3 2 3 6-10 15 3 5 1 1.0 15 13 10 11-15 15 3 5 1 1.0 15 13 10
vineyard 16-20 15 3 5 1 1.0 15 13 10 21+ 15 3 5 1 1.0 15 13 10 1-5 4 3 5 2 1.5 6 4 10 6-10 20 3 5 2 1.5 30 8 110 11-15 20 3 5 2 1.5 30 8 110
mulberry 16-20 20 3 5 2 1.5 30 8 110 21+ 11 3 5 2 1.5 17 5 58
202 Age year (GEL) (GEL) Name of Name of Average Average 1 kg fruit 1 kg Plant/Trees to repaid be to Value plant of Value and plant care plant and Tree unit proce Tree unit productivity kg. productivity Land cultivation cultivation Land Number of years Numberof Start breeding Start of cost cost year per GEL wholesale of price wholesale 1 in income Gross 1-5 8 3 3 1 1.5 12 7 15 6-10 15 3 5 1 1.5 23 11 58 11-15 34 3 5 1 1.5 51 20 155
cherry 16-20 34 3 5 1 1.5 51 20 155
Cherry/sweet 21+ 25 3 5 1 1.5 38 20 88 1-5 4 3 5 2 1.5 6 4 10 6-10 15 3 5 2 1.5 23 8 73 11-15 20 3 5 2 1.5 30 8 110 16-20 15 3 5 2 1.5 23 5 88 pomegranat 21+ 11 3 5 2 1.5 17 5 58 1-5 2 3 5 2 1.5 3 1 10 6-10 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110 11-15 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110
berberis 16-20 8 3 5 2 2.3 19 1 88 21+ 5 3 5 2 2.3 12 1 57 1-5 2 3 5 2 1.5 3 1 10 6-10 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110 11-15 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110
capers 16-20 8 3 5 2 2.3 19 1 88 21+ 5 3 5 2 2.3 12 1 57 1-5 2 3 5 2 1.5 3 1 10 6-10 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110 11-15 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110
cornel 16-20 8 3 5 2 2.3 19 1 88 21+ 5 3 5 2 2.3 12 1 57 1-5 2 3 5 2 1.5 3 1 10 6-10 9 3 5 2 2.4 22 1 103 11-15 12 3 5 2 2.3 28 1 133
medlar 16-20 8 3 5 2 2.3 19 1 88 21+ 5 3 5 2 2.3 12 1 57 1-5 4 3 5 2 1.2 5 2 14 6-10 15 3 5 2 1.2 18 8 50 11-15 15 3 5 2 1.2 18 8 50 laurel 16-20 15 3 5 2 1.2 18 8 50 21+ 15 3 5 2 1.2 18 8 50 1-5 2 3 3 1 4.0 8 3 15 6-10 4 3 5 1 4.0 16 8 40 11-15 6 3 5 1 4.0 24 10 70 berries 16-20 6 3 5 1 4.0 24 10 70
203 Age year (GEL) (GEL) Name of Name of Average Average 1 kg fruit 1 kg Plant/Trees to repaid be to Value plant of Value and plant care plant and Tree unit proce Tree unit productivity kg. productivity Land cultivation cultivation Land Number of years Numberof Start breeding Start of cost cost year per GEL wholesale of price wholesale 1 in income Gross 21+ 4 3 5 1 4.0 16 10 30 1-5 2 3 5 2 1.5 3 1 10 6-10 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110 11-15 10 3 5 2 2.3 23 1 110
others 16-20 8 3 5 2 2.3 19 1 88 21+ 5 3 5 2 2.3 12 1 57
204 ANNEXURE 9.1: COMEPNSATION MATRIX
# (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) SurveyNumber Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance for Physical for Allowance Building and Structures and Building Allowances Severely for Allowances Allowances for Vulnerable Vulnerable for Allowances Affected Households (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affected for Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Trees(Gel) for Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 1 79 Babi 18001000278 Registered/Legal 2 11 0 0 1866 1877 0 1,877 2 80 Chartali 56001003983 Registered/Legal 71 499 0 0 0 499 0 499 3 81 Moliti 56001014333 Legalizable 292 1166 3800 0 0 4966 0 4,966 4 82 Moliti 56001013873 Legalizable 168 674 608 0 0 1282 1042 1042 2,324 5 83 Moliti 56001017284 Legalizable 34 137 379 0 0 516 0 516 6 83.1 Moliti 35001040084 Registered/Legal 75 301 1540 0 251 2091 1042 1042 3,133 7 83.2 Moliti Legalizable 311 1242 2260 0 0 3502 0 3,502 8 84 Moliti 01015022749 Legalizable 186 746 5123 0 114 5983 1042 1042 7,025 9 85 Moliti 35001036469 Legalizable 38 150 955 0 303 1408 0 1,408 10 86 Moliti 56001013558 Legalizable 49 198 770 0 126 1093 1042 1042 2,135 11 87 Moliti 01014003212 Legalizable 197 789 2948 0 790 4527 0 4,527 12 88 Moliti 56001014214 Legalizable 50 199 390 0 0 589 0 589 13 89 Moliti 56001005154 Legalizable 35 140 645 0 327 1112 0 1,112 14 89.1 Moliti 56001014439 Legalizable 17 67 0 0 230 297 0 297 15 90 Moliti 57001008191 Legalizable 10 41 0 0 626 667 0 667 16 90.1 Moliti 56001017284 Non Legal 121 0 535 0 289 824 0 824 17 91 Moliti 56001014436 Registered/Legal 572 2861 2278 0 55111 60250 1042 1292 1042 3376 63,626 18 92 Moliti Legalizable 50 252 1723 0 0 1975 0 1,975 19 93.1 Moliti 56001006903 Registered/Legal 151 603 0 0 0 603 0 603 20 93 Moliti 56001006903 Legalizable 36 181 540 0 9632 10353 0 10,353 21 94 Moliti 56001006903 Legalizable 77 306 3922 0 607 4835 0 4,835 22 95 Moliti 56001006903 Legalizable 286 1144 928 0 1036 3108 0 3,108 23 96 Moliti 56001010619 Registered/Legal 134 671 1975 6 237 2889 0 2,889 24 97 Moliti 56001010619 Registered/Legal 120 482 3565 4 1228 5279 0 5,279 25 98 Moliti 56001016872 Legalizable 154 617 1448 0 0 2065 1042 1042 3,107
205 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 26 99 Moliti 01008031380 Registered/Legal 188 754 1136 0 263 2153 0 2,153 27 100 Moliti Legalizable 91 453 858 0 447 1758 0 1,758 28 102 Moliti 01008031380 Registered/Legal 48 239 6128 0 938 7305 0 7,305 29 103 Moliti 56001006282 Registered/Legal 83 414 463 0 6663 7540 0 7,540 56001001617 56001011343 30 104 Moliti 60001098201 Registered/Legal 189 945 115 0 43169 44229 0 44,229 31 105 Moliti 56001002900 Registered/Legal 159 1112 425 0 41736 43273 1292 1042 2334 45,607 32 106 Moliti 01027020854 Registered/Legal 161 806 924 0 15436 17165 1292 1042 2334 19,499 33 107 Moliti 01007012070 Registered/Legal 4 21 343 0 456 820 0 820 34 108 Moliti 35001035110 Registered/Legal 324 1620 860 0 19444 21924 1292 1042 2334 24,258 35 109 Moliti 01015023884 Legalizable 427 2133 1316 0 0 3449 1042 1042 4,491 36 110 Moliti 56001022229 Registered/Legal 249 1245 4014 0 924 6182 0 6,182 37 111 Moliti 56001003199 Registered/Legal 199 993 2887 13 0 3893 0 3,893 38 112 Moliti 56001019562 Registered/Legal 426 2129 13027 21 2598 17775 0 17,775 39 113 Moliti 01007012070 Registered/Legal 160 640 2987 0 456 4083 0 4,083 40 114 Moliti 56001016789 Legalizable 159 793 978 0 3624 5395 0 5,395 41 115 Nebodziri 56001016789, Registered/Legal 137 549 100 0 0 649 0 649 56001023360, 56001018155, 56001025114 42 116 Moliti 01010011654 Legalizable 816 4079 3085 0 0 7164 1042 1042 8,206 43 117 Moliti 60001098201 Legalizable 14 56 0 0 1915 1971 1042 1042 3,013 44 118 Moliti 60001098201 Registered/Legal 417 2087 4291 56 28304 34738 0 34,738 45 119 Moliti 01027037771 Registered/Legal 211 1055 3882 0 3678 8616 0 8,616 46 119.1 Moliti 01027037771 Legalizable 198 793 620 0 740 2153 0 2,153
206 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 47 120 Moliti 60001098201 Registered/Legal 54 216 3930 0 789 4935 0 4,935 48 121 Moliti 01027037771 Registered/Legal 106 425 1915 0 352 2692 0 2,692 49 122 Nebodziri 56001010233 Registered/Legal 63 253 0 0 0 253 0 253 50 123 Moliti 56001010233 Registered/Legal 171 684 0 0 0 684 0 684 51 124 Nebodziri 56001017346. Registered/Legal 142 570 1502 0 1645 3716 1042 1042 4,758 56001006569 52 125 Moliti 56001019800 Legalizable 151 604 3053 0 1302 4958 1042 1042 6,000 53 126 Moliti 56001015826 Non Legal 36 0 244 0 176 420 0 420 54 127 Aneula 56001010300 Registered/Legal 136 678 839 0 237 1754 0 1,754 55 128 Aneula 56001010300, Registered/Legal 192 766 986 0 875 2628 0 2,628 56001009154, 56001025224, 56001025230, 56001018191
56 129 Nebodziri 1028009335 Registered/Legal 257 1283 3469 23 3388 8163 0 8,163 01033002394 57 130 Nebodziri 56001020037 Registered/Legal 276 1106 0 0 0 1106 0 1,106 58 131 Tsipa 56001007238 Legalizable 183 914 494 0 0 1408 0 1,408 59 131.1 Tsipa 56001021704 Legalizable 170 679 798 0 0 1477 1042 1042 2,519 60 132 Golatubani 56001015073, Registered/Legal 510 2552 10887 29 1310 14778 1042 1042 2084 16,862 56001010421, 56001010422 61 132.1 Golatubani 57601062174 Registered/Legal 30 149 1005 0 5402 6556 0 6,556 62 132.2 Golatubani 56001004151 Legalizable 0 0 1520 0 1446 2966 0 2,966 63 133 Tsipa 57001014778 Legalizable 242 1211 3128 0 1035 5374 1042 1042 6,416 64 134 Golatubani 01033002726 Registered/Legal 260 1299 7616 0 376 9290 0 9,290
207 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 65 135 Golatubani 56001015363 Registered/Legal 201 1007 4695 50 0 5752 0 5,752 66 136 Golatubani Legalizable 312 1562 2055 0 1622 5239 0 5,239 67 138 Golatubani 56001010311 Registered/Legal 21 107 880 0 1435 2423 1042 1042 3,465 68 139 Tsipa 56001004149 Registered/Legal 203 813 900 16 1357 3085 1042 1042 4,127 69 140 Tsipa 56001010641 Legalizable 24 118 2735 0 638 3491 0 3,491 70 141 Tsipa 56001010315 Registered/Legal 169 846 3602 22 579 5048 1042 1042 6,090 71 142 Tsipa 56001010463, Registered/Legal 170 849 1955 42 525 3371 1042 1042 4,413 56001010469 72 143 Tsipa 35001069098 Legalizable 282 1410 4192 0 405 6007 1042 1042 7,049 73 144 Tsipa 56001010467 Registered/Legal 565 2824 8470 39 8819 20153 1042 1042 21,195 74 145 Tsipa 56001017786 Legalizable 60 241 730 0 685 1657 0 1,657 75 146 Tsipa 600030006478 Legalizable 47 189 1554 0 564 2307 0 2,307 76 147 Tsipa 56001017947 Registered/Legal 219 1093 2338 4 1316 4752 1042 1042 5,794 77 148 Tsipa 56001011218 Legalizable 148 739 3150 4 969 4863 0 4,863 78 149 Tsipa 56001017947 Registered/Legal 171 857 518 4 1094 2473 1042 1042 3,515 79 150 Tsipa 56001016674 Registered/Legal 395 1974 1295 0 528 3797 0 3,797 80 151 Golatubani 56001015072, Registered/Legal 205 1025 698 13 1317 3053 0 3,053 56001011680, 54001002692, 35001041358 81 152 Tsipa 56001011909 Registered/Legal 371 1854 4170 126 630 6780 1042 1042 7,822 82 153 Golatubani 56001019087, Registered/Legal 233 1164 1970 151 991 4276 0 4,276 56001014680, 56001021758, 56001022887 83 154 Golatubani 56001004895, Registered/Legal 484 2422 6025 44 2464 10955 1042 1042 11,997 57001033313
208 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 84 155 Tsipa 0101101990 Legalizable 203 1017 16814 6 1542 19380 0 19,380 85 156 Golatubani 57001005293 Registered/Legal 7 35.01487 480 0 698 1213 0 1,213 86 157 Tsipa 01002002299 Legalizable 104 518.4704 930 0 163 1612 0 1,612 87 157.1 Tsipa 01011037197 Legalizable 98 491.0416 1750 0 471 2712 0 2,712 88 158 Golatubani 56001010656, Registered/Legal 1191 5957.23 3428 286 2631 12303 1042 1042 13,345 56001010678, 56001010659, 56001021759, 56001025672
89 159 Tsipa 56001014985 Legalizable 1545 6178.071 1000 0 0 7178 1042 1042 2084 9,262 90 160 Tsipa Legalizable 19 75.3723 1900 0 0 1975 0 1,975 91 161 Tsipa 56001006462 Legalizable 64 257.6118 1300 0 0 1558 1042 1042 2,600 92 162 Tsipa Legalizable 417 1669.2 5372 0 0 7041 1042 1042 8,083 93 162.1 Tsipa Non Legal 101 0 708 0 0 708 0 708 94 163 Tsipa 56001003329, Registered/Legal 30 120.9274 712 0 645 1478 0 1,478 56001004148, 56001004341 95 164 Tsipa Legalizable 472 1889.244 1200 0 486 3575 1042 1042 4,617 96 165 Tsipa 56001009743, Legalizable 836 3345.78 3891 0 0 7237 1042 1042 2084 9,321 56001009742 97 166 Tsipa 56001009743, Registered/Legal 995 4974.49 8042 0 4712 17729 1042 1042 18,771 56001009742 98 167 Tsipa Legalizable 23 113.1944 400 0 766 1279 0 1,279 99 168 Tsipa 56001009738, Registered/Legal 30 151.4954 1510 0 1075 2737 0 2,737 56001025667, 56001010324
209 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 100 169 Tsipa 56001003329, Registered/Legal 93 467.4157 2032 0 405 2904 0 2,904 56001004148, 56001004341 101 170 Tsipa 56001006462 Registered/Legal 440 2198.219 10561 11 75829 88599 1042 1292 1042 3376 91,975 102 171 Tsipa 56001006462, Registered/Legal 15 76.22551 735 0 2202 3014 0 3,014 56001006463, 57001031773 103 172 Tsipa 01002013671 Registered/Legal 435 2174.693 7555 0 84583 94312 1042 1292 1042 3376 97,688 104 173 Tsipa 57001006106 Registered/Legal 139 694.2837 4961 0 67254 72909 1292 1042 2334 75,243 105 174 Tsipa 01019047568 Legalizable 210 1051.771 3106 0 57455 61613 1292 1042 2334 63,947 106 175 Tsipa 56001015062 Registered/Legal 731 3652.509 10912 0 62614 77179 1042 1292 1042 3376 80,555 107 176 Tsipa 56001016843 Legalizable 322 1607.742 5894 0 50670 58171 1042 1292 1042 3376 61,547 108 177 Tsipa 01024045056 Registered/Legal 74 296.3955 0 0 359 655 0 655 109 178 Tsipa 01024015766, Registered/Legal 175 875.7577 1851 0 1041 3768 0 3,768 01024045056 110 179 Tsipa 01023009251 Legalizable 272 1086.099 4530 0 0 5616 0 5,616 111 180 Tsipa Legalizable 395 1581.144 656 0 0 2237 0 2,237 112 180.1 Tsipa Non Legal 417 0 2162 0 0 2162 0 2,162 113 181 Tsipa 57001027025 Registered/Legal 364 1454.413 2130 0 1445 5029 1042 1042 2084 7,113 114 182 Tsipa 57001027025 Registered/Legal 5 26.83338 260 0 34030 34317 1292 1042 2334 36,651 115 183 Tsipa Legalizable 39 196.1085 240 0 72 508 1042 1042 1,550 116 183.1 Tsipa 56001020397 Legalizable 64 318.4785 1662 0 1343 3323 0 3,323 117 184 Tsipa 57001046048 Legalizable 239 1196.202 2566 0 740 4502 1042 1042 5,544 118 185 Tsipa 56001020301 Registered/Legal 43 214.6559 593 0 1030 1837 0 1,837
210 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 119 186 Tsipa 56001020365 Registered/Legal 321 1606.214 566 80 3219 5471 1042 1042 6,513 56001017447 56001010286 56001002231 57001060885 57101063031 56001005190
120 187 Tsipa 01004012062 Legalizable 250 1250.233 261 0 215 1726 0 1,726 121 188.1 Tsipa 1030023382 Legalizable 62 308.8785 0 0 381 690 0 690 122 188.2 Tsipa 35001078467 Registered/Legal 0 0 400 0 749 1149 1042 1042 2,191 123 188 Tsipa 01030023382 Registered/Legal 307 1536.758 1700 0 4600 7836 1042 1042 8,878 01030050220 124 189 Tsipa 57001048047 Registered/Legal 8 41.2232 328 0 835 1204 0 1,204 125 190 Tsipa 56001010046 Legalizable 9 44.54179 280 0 630 954 1042 1042 1,996 126 191 Tsipa 57001048047 Legalizable 417 1669.453 3858 0 1354 6882 1042 1042 7,924 127 192 Tsipa 56001004911 Registered/Legal 180 721.2846 2515 109 2059 5404 1042 1042 2084 7,488 128 193 Tsipa 56001010924, Registered/Legal 355 1421.992 1305 42 165 2934 0 2,934 56001018851, 56001021423, 56001018850, 56001011213
129 194 Tsipa 57001010939 Legalizable 784 3918.491 1108 0 2990 8017 1042 1042 9,059 130 195 Tsipa 01033000566 Registered/Legal 38 190.2275 300 0 1864 2354 0 2,354
211 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 131 196 Tsipa 56001010924, Registered/Legal 169 846.7678 3904 15 825 5591 0 5,591 56001018851, 56001021423, 56001018850, 56001011213
132 197 Tsipa 01007004891 Registered/Legal 260 1299.298 930 0 2230 4460 1042 1042 5,502 133 199 Tsipa 01017028342 Registered/Legal 292 1461.943 2135 42 3477 7116 1042 1042 8,158 134 200 Tsipa 56001020379 Legalizable 453 1812.853 1018 84 2759 5674 1042 1042 2084 7,758 135 200.1 Tsipa 56001025664 Legalizable 61 305.4025 261 0 933 1499 0 1,499 136 201 Pona 56001010043, Registered/Legal 13 64.09637 435 0 850 1349 1042 1042 2,391 56001000935 137 202 Pona 12001001016 Registered/Legal 205 1023.786 0 0 0 1024 0 1,024 138 203 Pona 01023009251 Registered/Legal 32 161.4443 0 0 0 161 0 161 139 204 Pona 56001010050, Registered/Legal 14 67.841 115 0 846 1028 1042 1042 2,070 56001010313, 56001012049 140 205 Pona 56001012052 Legalizable 57 283.4798 1576 0 1450 3310 1042 1042 4,352 141 206 Pona 01008031952 Registered/Legal 68 271.2713 800 0 387 1458 0 1,458 01010020066 142 207 Pona 57001026901 Legalizable 171 682.752 162 0 0 845 1042 1042 1,887 143 207.1 Pona 57001002224 Legalizable 42 208.7846 1490 0 0 1699 0 1,699 144 208 Pona 46001016743 Legalizable 484 1936.511 1086 0 0 3023 1042 1042 4,065 145 209 Pona Legalizable 42 167.4681 166 0 561 894 0 894 146 210 Pona 57001002224 Legalizable 365 1461.611 521 0 0 1983 0 1,983 147 211 Pona 57001043250 Legalizable 94 375.089 0 0 0 375 1042 1042 1,417 148 212 Pona 57001002224 Legalizable 674 2696.294 2315 0 750 5761 0 5,761 149 213 Pona 56001010427 Registered/Legal 996 3982.401 2815 0 1163 7961 1042 1042 9,003
212 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 150 214 Pona 57001043415 Registered/Legal 84 334.4639 754 0 517 1606 0 1,606 151 215 Pona 57001024214 Legalizable 89 357.5881 504 0 0 862 0 862 152 216 Pona 57001033291 Legalizable 352 1407.058 840 0 0 2247 0 2,247 153 217 Pona 56001010050 Legalizable 203 811.6497 502 0 0 1314 0 1,314 154 218 Pona 56001010132 Legalizable 281 1122.932 1900 0 0 3023 1042 1042 4,065 155 219 Pona 57001008532 Legalizable 312 1246.619 208 0 0 1455 0 1,455 156 220 Pona 57001042757 Legalizable 312 1248.749 334 0 0 1583 1042 1042 2,625 157 221 Pona 56001012052 Legalizable 177 707.1845 0 0 0 707 0 707 158 222 Pona 56001011141 Registered/Legal 19 74.51236 0 0 393 468 0 468 159 223 Pona 57301062967 Legalizable 164 654.0897 0 0 0 654 0 654 160 224 Surami, 57001019493 Registered/Legal 145 1011.601 0 0 0 1012 0 1,012 Chumateleti 161 225 Surami, 01024055381 Registered/Legal 596 4172.855 0 0 0 4173 0 4,173 Chumateleti 162 226 Chumateleti 57001026073 Legalizable 1000 7002.413 876 0 0 7878 1042 1042 2084 9,962 163 227 Chumateleti 57001038941 Legalizable 1000 7002.782 104 0 0 7107 1042 1042 2084 9,191 164 228 Chumateleti 57001035818 Legalizable 1000 7003.041 766 0 0 7769 1042 1042 8,811 165 230 Surami, 57001039625 Non Legal 53 0 71 0 538 609 0 609 Chumateleti 166 230.1 Surami, 57001038166 Legalizable 67 470.8215 426 0 0 897 0 897 Chumateleti 167 230.2 Surami, 01001045052 Legalizable 62 435.1402 208 0 0 643 0 643 Chumateleti 168 231 Surami, 57001023399 Legalizable 951 6659.53 0 0 0 6660 1042 1042 2084 8,744 Chumateleti
213 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 169 232 Surami, 57001038590 Legalizable 2600 18198.16 2529 0 0 20727 1042 1042 21,769 Chumateleti 170 233 Surami, 57001026747 Registered/Legal 61 425.8449 75 21 355 877 1042 1042 1,919 Chumateleti 171 234 Chumateleti 57001018391 Legalizable 37 259.5484 0 0 0 260 0 260 172 235 Chumateleti 57001038316 Legalizable 107 748.8002 910 0 0 1659 0 1,659 173 235.1 Chumateleti 01008041371 Legalizable 339 2376.241 2819 0 0 5195 0 5,195 174 236 Chumateleti 01013029860 Legalizable 13 89.43968 70 0 0 159 1042 1042 1,201 175 237 Chumateleti 57001043993 Registered/Legal 243 1701.469 0 0 0 1701 0 1,701 176 238 Chumateleti 57001024008 Legalizable 171 1200.232 0 0 0 1200 0 1,200 177 239 Chumateleti 57001015350 Legalizable 220 1537.655 155 0 0 1693 0 1,693 178 240 Chumateleti 57001007176 Legalizable 320 2236.711 0 0 0 2237 0 2,237 179 241 Chumateleti 57001044368 Legalizable 377 2641.849 0 0 0 2642 1042 1042 3,684 180 242 Chumateleti 57001044329 Legalizable 473 3310.376 0 0 0 3310 0 3,310 181 243 Chumateleti 01029003106 Registered/Legal 408 2854.053 0 0 0 2854 0 2,854 182 244 Surami, 57001019493 Registered/Legal 41 286.2286 0 0 0 286 0 286 Chumateleti 183 245 Chumateleti 57001010999 Legalizable 34 239.0867 0 0 0 239 1042 1042 1,281 184 246 Chumateleti 57001032739 Legalizable 18 128.2628 0 0 0 128 1042 1042 1,170 185 247.1 Surami, 11001001750 Legalizable 130 912.5761 0 0 171 1083 0 1,083 Chumateleti 186 247 Surami, 57001024573 Legalizable 59 413.8598 50 0 2941 3405 1042 1042 4,447 Chumateleti 187 248 Chumateleti 1100100738 Legalizable 14 96.80812 0 0 2750 2847 0 2,847 188 249 Chumateleti 57001028021 Registered/Legal 60 421.4577 660 0 425 1507 1042 1042 2,549 189 250 Chumateleti 57001021853 Registered/Legal 33 228.7023 0 0 763 991 0 991
214 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 190 251 Chumateleti 57001024348 Non Legal 24 0 30 11 437 478 1042 1042 1,520 191 251.1 Chumateleti 57001012959 Non Legal 20 0 0 0 771 771 0 771 192 251.2 Chumateleti 57001024348 Registered/Legal 47 2346.342 0 0 0 2346 0 2,346 193 252 Chumateleti 243855128 Registered/Legal 42 2077.84 440 0 503 3021 0 3,021 194 253 Surami, 57001039625 Legalizable 21 895.1528 1055 0 3869 5819 0 5,819 Chumateleti 195 254 Surami, 57001012030 Registered/Legal 44 1911.959 400 0 7771 10082 1042 1042 11,124 Chumateleti 196 255 Surami, 57001037577 Legalizable 103 4413.569 1160 0 7033 12607 1042 1042 13,649 Chumateleti 197 256 Surami, 57001042793 Registered/Legal 10 425.3793 600 0 1990 3016 0 3,016 Chumateleti 198 257 Surami, 01024023571 Registered/Legal 9 372.3464 0 0 2871 3244 0 3,244 Chumateleti 199 258.1 Surami, 57001012220 Non Legal 3 0 0 0 337 337 0 337 Chumateleti 200 258 Surami, Legalizable 39 1681.835 1266 0 2836 5784 0 5,784 Chumateleti 201 259 Surami, 01008024332, Registered/Legal 4 156.1268 390 0 3369 3916 0 3,916 Chumateleti 01008025847 202 260 Surami, 57001015369 Registered/Legal 2 78.41539 0 0 2085 2164 0 2,164 Chumateleti 203 261 Surami, 01024050590 Registered/Legal 14 615.5456 408 0 471 1495 0 1,495 Chumateleti 204 262 Surami, 01028003443 Registered/Legal 8 356.3189 0 0 89 445 0 445 Chumateleti 205 263 Chumateleti 01024050590 Non Legal 11 0 3 0 882 885 0 885
215 # (Gel) relocation ID Number ID +Allowances) Survey Survey Number Total Allowances Total Households (Gel) Households Type Ownership of Type Name of the Village Name the of AffectedArea (sqm) Total Compensation Total Allowance Physical for Allowance Building Structures and Building Allowances for Severely for Allowances Allowances Vulnerable for Allowances Affected (Gel) Affected Households Comensation Land lost for Comensation Compensation Affectedfor Compensation Grand Total (Compensation (Compensation Total Grand Compensation for Treesfor(Gel) Compensation Compensation (Gel) Crops for Compensation 206 264 Chumateleti 54001051140 Non Legal 17 0 820 0 651 1471 0 1,471 207 265 Chumateleti 57001011524, Registered/Legal 61 2633.348 344 0 4405 7382 0 7,382 57001040616, 57001040640, 57001005986 208 265.1 Chumateleti 577001012220 Non Legal 6 0 0 0 95 95 0 95
216