PROJUST Quarter 2 FY 2019 Task 1 and 2 Quarterly Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PROJUST FOR USAID QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT April 1 – June 30, 2019 USAID/MEXICO PROMOTING JUSTICE PROJECT QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT APRIL 1 – JUNE 30, 2018 Management Systems International Corporate Offices 200 12th Street, South Arlington, VA 22202 USA Tel: + 1 703 979 7100 Contracted under AID-523-C-14-00003 USAID/Mexico Promoting Justice Project Cover page photo caption: Local state leaders from Mexico’s criminal justice system sit alongside USAID representatives to inaugurate PROJUST’s “Forum for Criminal Justice” held at La Salle University in Mexico City from June 17-19, 2019. DISCLAIMER This publication was produced at the request of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). It was prepared independently by Management Systems International. The author’s views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the USAID or the United States Government. CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4 ACTIVITY IMPLEMENTATION AND COVERAGE 6 ACCOMPLISHMENTS AND OVERALL STATUS 6 IMPLEMENTED A LOCAL SYSTEMS APPROACH FOR GREATER IMPACT 7 SUPPORTING CAPABLE JUSTICE SECTOR INSTITUTIONS 9 FOSTERED A MONITORING AND EVALUATION (M&E) CULTURE IN MEXICO’S JUSTICE INSTITUTIONS 23 NATIONAL LEVEL SUPPORT 25 UNITED CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANIZATIONS TO STRENGTHEN THE ACCUSATORY SYSTEM 25 RALLIED SUPPORT FOR THE ACCUSATORY SYSTEM THROUGH NATIONAL-LEVEL EVENTS 27 GENERAL AND CROSS-CUTTING ACTIVITIES 28 PROMOTED A GENDER PERSPECTIVE IN MEXICO’S CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM 28 LESSONS LEARNED 30 UPDATES ON EVALUATION AND LEARNING PLANS AND ACTIVITIES 31 ANNEX I: ACTIVITY COUNT AND SUPPORT COVERAGE 32 ANNEX II: SUCCESS STORY FOR Q3 33 ANNEX III: EARLY WINS AND SPOTLIGHTS OF Q3 35 ANNEX IV: ANALYSIS OF TRAINING DATA 49 ANNEX V: LIST OF PROJUST PRODUCTS TRANSFERRED AT THE “FORUM FOR JUSTICE” ON JUNE 19 52 ANNEX VI: FINANCIAL SECTION 60 2 | USAID/MEXICO PROMOTING JUSTICE PROJECT USAID.GOV QUARTERLY REPORT, JANUARY – MARCH 2019 ACRONYMS 100DC 100-Day Challenge AG Attorney General CONATRIB National Commission of Superior Justice Tribunals CSO Civil Society Organization FY Fiscal Year IMDHD Mexican Institute for Human Rights and Democracy MSI Management Systems International M&E Monitoring and Evaluation PD Public Defender PROJUST Promoting Justice Project PTS Pre-Trial Services Q3 Quarter 3 RRI Rapid Results Institute SSP State Secretariat of Public Security USAID United States Agency for International Development 3 | USAID/MEXICO PROMOTING JUSTICE PROJECT USAID.GOV QUARTERLY REPORT, JANUARY – MARCH 2019 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The USAID/Mexico Promoting Justice Project (PROJUST) is in its fifth year of implementation, with project activities in its third quarter bridging a period of transition from a focus on technical innovation and implementation to one focused on sustainability. This quarterly report covers the period from April 1 to June 30, 2019, which corresponds to the third quarter (Q3) of fiscal year (FY) 2019. It highlights the achievements and activities of Tasks 1 and 2, which are implemented by Management Systems International (MSI). In Q3, PROJUST closed out direct support to most target justice institutions, solidifying gains through the formal transfer of key project tools, guides and resources, and facilitating a series of high-level forums and events to concretize local networks and set a clear path ahead for criminal justice reform. Full details and context of progress and outcomes are provided in the body of this report, with key highlights summarized blow. PROJUST and the Rapid Results Institute (RRI) launched a new phase of support this quarter to sustain the gains of local systems initiatives, keep momentum going and support frontline teams and local leaders following up on their commitments to scale the impact of successful innovations. The consolidation of the Three-Level Case Prioritization model was a priority under support to Attorneys General Offices in new cities, with further emphasis on strengthening communication and collaboration via peer-to-peer learning networks between project- supported Crime Analysis and Specialized Investigation and Prosecution Units. Support to State Courts focused on bolstering the sustainability of project efforts through national forums and transferring key PROJUST models, methodologies and tools to the National Commission of Superior Justice Tribunals (CONATRIB), a key ally for scaling the impact of project resources nationwide. Five years of support to Pre-Trial Services (PTS) Units culminated this quarter in a National PTS Forum on April 11-12. PROJUST brought together over fifty participants representing 27 PTS Units to disseminate key tools developed, consolidated and refined between PROJUST and target units over the course of the project. In addition to the participation of 27 PTS unit directors, attendees also included three directors from units dedicated to adolescents, representatives from the National Executive Secretariat of Public Security, and civil society members, with over 800 other viewers logged in remotely to the live-streamed event. The highlight of support for Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) Units within target justice institutions this quarter was a two-day event held on May 7 and 8, in Cuernavaca, Morelos, where PROJUST convened participating operators representing each of the project- supported units for an engaging and participatory forum on “Evidence-Based Continuous Improvement.” Participants from both M&E Units and seven CSOs came together for expert panels, roundtable discussions, and exchanges of best practices and experiences in using data for evidence-based decision making within criminal justice institutions for the purpose of continuous improvement. 4 | USAID/MEXICO PROMOTING JUSTICE PROJECT USAID.GOV QUARTERLY REPORT, JANUARY – MARCH 2019 PROJUST worked with a broad spectrum of CSOs, academics, universities and representatives from the private sector1 to finalize the “legislative map” initiative to sustain national reform efforts and shape strategic operational laws by generating a systemic vision of criminal justice and identifying pending modifications necessary for optimum functioning. Finally, PROJUST debuted its documentary titled “Self-Defense?” which tells the story of an emblematic case of public defense supported by the project that highlights the use of a gender lens to achieve the acquittal of a domestic violence victim wrongly accused of her partner’s death. This case was the first acquittal in Mexico of homicide charges against a female defendant on the basis of self-defense. 1 Organizations involved in this effort include: The Confederation of Employers of the Mexican Republic (COPARMEX), Autonomous Institute of Technology of Mexico (ITAM), Center for Economic Research (CIDE), and the National Autonomous University of Mexico’s (UNAM) Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas as well as CSOs Borde Politico, Foundation for Due Legal Process (DPLF), Foundation for Justice and Democratic Rule of Law (FJEDD), Mexico Evalua, Research Center FUNDAR, Mexican Institute for Human Rights and Democracy (IMDHD), Causa en Comun, and Mexicans United Against Crime. 5 | USAID/MEXICO PROMOTING JUSTICE PROJECT USAID.GOV QUARTERLY REPORT, JANUARY – MARCH 2019 ACTIVITY IMPLEMENTATION AND COVERAGE In its third quarter, the Promoting Justice Project (PROJUST) successfully carried out 117 activities across 10 states, as well as national level activities. The bulk of the activities (83 or 70%) benefited Group 1 states and over half (70%) focused on promoting the legitimacy of the criminal justice system (Task 1). See the below reference map (Figure 1) of target states and refer to Annex 1 for a full breakdown of activities per Task. Figure 1: Geographic coverage in Q3-FY 2019 ACCOMPLISHMENTS AND OVERALL STATUS In Quarter 3 (Q3), PROJUST focused on winding down all direct technical support in target state justice institutions, while solidifying project-supported networks at both the state and national levels for future sustainability. Several high-profile forums served to bring key stakeholders from not only the justice sector, but also civil society, the private sector and academia, together to lay out clear, shared visions for the future. Finally, a number of key project resources and tools were finalized and distributed among all target states and institutions. This section of the report will detail the specific support provided to impact these and other key result areas in Q3 of FY2019. 6 | USAID/MEXICO PROMOTING JUSTICE PROJECT USAID.GOV QUARTERLY REPORT, JANUARY – MARCH 2019 IMPLEMENTED A LOCAL SYSTEMS APPROACH FOR GREATER IMPACT PROJUST and the Rapid Results Institute (RRI) launched a new phase of support this quarter to sustain the gains, keep momentum going and support frontline teams and local leaders following up on their commitments to scale the impact of successful innovations. Sustaining Results Follow-up sessions with local leaders and frontline teams occurred in four states (Baja California, Chihuahua, Coahuila and Zacatecas) to review progress since their recent 100DCs and solidify new ways of working that began during the challenges. Several teams continued to employ the Rapid Results methodology and reported that case resolutions continue to be more efficient. While PROJUST is in the process of confirming data on case Participants at the first follow-up session for the resolutions since the 100DCs, results self-reported by some sustainability of local systems initiatives in Tijuana, Baja California on April 4, 2019. teams for their advances