Statement of Heritage Impact Tomago Resource Recovery Facility

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Statement of Heritage Impact Tomago Resource Recovery Facility Project Number: HN000056-B STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT TOMAGO RESOURCE RECOVERY FACILITY FINAL 11 / 11 / 2020 REMOND IS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD C/O JACKSON ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING Attn: Rylan Loemker Email: [email protected] HERITAGE NOW CONTACT [email protected] 0425 250 310 www.heritagenow.com.au Executive Summary Heritage Now has been engaged by Jackson Environment and Planning on behalf of REMONDIS Australia Pty Ltd to prepare a Statement of Heritage Impact for the proposed Tomago Resource Recovery Facility and Truck Parking Depot, located at 21D & 21F School Drive, Tomago. The assessment is required as part of the Environmental Impact Statement and Development Application process. The Project Area is located at 21D and 21F School Drive, Tomago (Lots 8 and 11 DP 270328, and part of lot 301 DP 634536) approximately 12 km north west of Newcastle. The closest heritage items are 350 m from the Project Area - Tomago House and Chapel – they are listed as two separate heritage items on the Port Stephens Local Environmental Plan 2013 and as a single listing on the State Heritage Register. Past land use of the Project Area by early settlers was likely agricultural. The land has since been heavily modified through industrial land use, including sandmining. There are no heritage items within the Project Area. No specific mitigation measures are needed In general, all on-site personnel are to be made aware of their obligations under the NSW Heritage Act 1977 and the below recommendation is to be followed. Recommendation 1 All on-site personnel are to be made aware of their obligations under the NSW Heritage Act 1977, including the reporting of any historic, or suspected historic material. This may be implemented through an onsite induction or other suitable format. TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B I Abbreviations, Acronyms, Terms and Definitions Acronym Definition DCP Development Control Plan DP Deposited Plan DPIE Department of Planning Industry and Environment EP&A Environmental Planning and Assessment LEP Local Environmental Plan NSW New South Wales OEH Office of Environment and Heritage SHR State Heritage Register SoHI Statement of Heritage Impact TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B II Contents 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 2 1.1 Project Area ............................................................................................................................ 2 1.2 Project Proposal ...................................................................................................................... 2 1.3 Methodology ........................................................................................................................... 2 1.4 Authorship .............................................................................................................................. 2 2 Historic Context .............................................................................................................................. 5 2.1 Development of Tomago ........................................................................................................ 5 2.2 History of the Project Area ..................................................................................................... 6 3 Legislative Context and Heritage Listing ......................................................................................... 8 3.1 Legislative Context .................................................................................................................. 8 3.2 Heritage Listings and other Relevant Instruments and Guidelines ........................................ 9 3.2.1 Statement of Significance ............................................................................................. 10 3.2.2 Development Control Plan ............................................................................................ 10 3.3 Summary ............................................................................................................................... 10 4 Site Visit and Physical Assessment ................................................................................................ 11 4.1 Project Area .......................................................................................................................... 11 4.2 Summary ............................................................................................................................... 11 5 Assessment of Heritage Impact and Mitigation............................................................................ 12 5.1 The Proposal ......................................................................................................................... 12 5.2 Significance Overview ........................................................................................................... 12 5.3 Impact Assessment ............................................................................................................... 12 5.4 Mitigation Measures ............................................................................................................. 12 6 Conclusions and Recommendations ............................................................................................. 13 7 References.................................................................................................................................... 14 8 Plates ............................................................................................................................................. 15 Tables Table 1 Summary of Heritage Listings..................................................................................................... 9 Figures Figure 1 Project Area............................................................................................................................... 3 TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B III Figure 2 Project Proposal ........................................................................................................................ 4 Figure 3:1923 Parish Map showing location of Project Area and Tomago House.................................. 7 Figure 4 Project Area overlaid on the 1974 aerial photograph .............................................................. 7 Figure 5 Heritage listings near the Project Area ..................................................................................... 9 Figure 6 Survey Area ............................................................................................................................. 11 Plates Plate 1 Modern industrial buildings ...................................................................................................... 15 Plate 2 Modern fill from industrial activities ........................................................................................ 15 Plate 3 Disturbed contexts and modern rubbish .................................................................................. 16 TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B IV 1 Introduction Heritage Now has been engaged by Jackson Environment and Planning on behalf of REMONDIS Australia Pty Ltd to prepare a Statement of Heritage Impact for the proposed Tomago Resource Recovery Facility and Truck Parking Depot, located at 21D & 21F School Drive, Tomago. The assessments are required as part of the Environmental Impact Statement and Development Application process. 1.1 Project Area The Project Area is located at 21D and 21F School Drive, Tomago (Lots 8, and 11 DP 270328) approximately 12 km north west of Newcastle. The total area of the Project Area is 48455m2 (Figure 1). 1.2 Project Proposal REMONDIS intends to relocate their existing truck parking depot and resource recovery facility in Thornton to Tomago. This facility will involve the processing of waste, including hazardous materials. The proponent also intends on constructing a truck parking depot on the vacant lot of 21F School Drive (Figure 2). 1.3 Methodology This document has been prepared in accordance with the relevant Heritage Division guidelines, including, but not limited to: • Assessing Heritage Significance (OEH 2015) • Statements of Heritage Impact (OEH, formerly Heritage Office 2002) This Statement of Heritage Impact includes: • An overview of the heritage significance of features concerning the project proposal • What impact the proposed works will have on that significance • What measures have been proposed to mitigate negative impacts • Why more sympathetic solutions are not viable 1.4 Authorship This report has been prepared by Crystal Phillips, Heritage Consultant at Heritage Now and Tessa Boer-Mah, Principal Heritage Consultant at Heritage Now. TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B 2 Figure 1 Project Area TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B 3 Figure 2 Project Proposal TOMAGO STATEMENT OF HERITAGE IMPACT | HN000056- B 4 2 Historic Context This section provides the foundation for understanding the history of the region, as well as the Project Area. 2.1 Development of Tomago The traditional custodians of the land at Tomago are the Worimi people. The word ‘Tomago’ is said to derive from the Worimi word for ‘sweet water’ as they knew of the underground fresh water sources in the area long before European settlers invaded.1 One of the earliest European settlers in Tomago was Richard Windeyer in
Recommended publications
  • Port Stephens Local Environmental Plan 2013 Under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
    2013 No 755 New South Wales Port Stephens Local Environmental Plan 2013 under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 I, the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure, pursuant to section 33A of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, adopt the mandatory provisions of the Standard Instrument (Local Environmental Plans) Order 2006 and prescribe matters required or permitted by that Order so as to make a local environmental plan as follows. SAM HADDAD As delegate for the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure Published LW 23 December 2013 Page 1 2013 No 755 Port Stephens Local Environmental Plan 2013 Contents Page Part 1 Preliminary 1.1 Name of Plan 5 1.1AA Commencement 5 1.2 Aims of Plan 5 1.3 Land to which Plan applies 6 1.4 Definitions 6 1.5 Notes 6 1.6 Consent authority 6 1.7 Maps 6 1.8 Repeal of planning instruments applying to land 7 1.8A Savings provision relating to development applications 7 1.9 Application of SEPPs 7 1.9A Suspension of covenants, agreements and instruments 8 Part 2 Permitted or prohibited development 2.1 Land use zones 9 2.2 Zoning of land to which Plan applies 10 2.3 Zone objectives and Land Use Table 10 2.4 Unzoned land 11 2.5 Additional permitted uses for particular land 11 2.6 Subdivision—consent requirements 11 2.7 Demolition requires development consent 12 2.8 Temporary use of land 12 Land Use Table Part 3 Exempt and complying development 3.1 Exempt development 33 3.2 Complying development 34 3.3 Environmentally sensitive areas excluded 35 Part 4 Principal development standards 4.1
    [Show full text]
  • The Contribution of the Low Show Group of Artists MARGARET
    CHANGING THE ART CULTURE OF NEWCASTLE: The contribution of the Low Show Group of artists MARGARET MCBRIDE Dip Art, BAVA, Grad Dip Art, Grad Dip Ed. (University of Newcastle) School of Drama, Fine Art and Music University of Newcastle Submitted in full requirement of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy January 2010 i STATEMENT OF ORIGINALITY This thesis contains no material which has been accepted for the award of any other degree or diploma in any university or other tertiary institution and, to the best of my knowledge and belief, contains no material previously published or written by another person, except where due reference has been made in the text. I give consent to this copy of my thesis, when deposited in the University Library, being made available for loan and photocopying subject to the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF AUTHORSHIP I hereby certify that the work embodied in this thesis is the result of original research, the greater part of which was completed subsequent to admission of candidature for the degree. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS To Emeritus Professor Elizabeth Ashburn I owe my special thanks for her support, scholarly advice and enthusiasm during the preparation of this thesis. As well I thank Emeritus Professor John Ramsland for his enthusiasm and guidance and the Newcastle Region Art Gallery for allowing me access to their files and providing me with copies of artworks from their collection. Finally I must thank my husband, Brian Cox, for his constant support, care and encouragement. iii CONTENTS Title Page i Declaration ii Acknowledgement iii Contents iv Abstract viii List of Plates x Introduction ........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Nsw T N Magazine in This Issue: 2015 National Trust (Nsw) Trust This National Issue:In 2015
    SUMMER EDITION: NOVEMBER-JANUARY 2016 NOVEMBER-JANUARY EDITION: SUMMER NSW NAT IONAL TRUST MAGAZINE TRUST NATIONAL IN THIS ISSUE: 2015 NATIONAL TRUST (NSW) ANNUAL REPORT NATIONAL TRUST | CHRISTMAS EVENTS | SHOPPING | QUILTS STITCHED WITH LOVE | COLONIAL ARCHITECTS/HOPE FOR CALLAN PARK ANNUAL REPORT 2015 of course, the 70th anniversary of the National Millers Point properties including the iconic Trust of Australia (NSW). Sirius Apartment Building, which we believe Our anniversary ends on a very positive are not adequately protected. The Trust is note. Thanks to the careful stewardship of the urging a review of the proposed disbanding Board, CEO and executive staff, the diligence of the Government Architect’s Office and and innovation of our staff and volunteers, the exemplary, award-winning Minister’s and the support we receive from you and Stonework Program. our other members and supporters, we have This issue includes the ballot forms and consolidated and indeed increased an upward candidate information for the upcoming financial trend for three consecutive years. A National Trust Board Election. On so many FROM THE PRESIDENT sound base has been developed to meet the occasions I have emphasised to you the challenges of the current economic climate, importance of a strong Board which has � Ian Carroll OAM and next year will see the launch of initiatives to the right mix of skills to meet the challenges This year has been very special for the Trust in build on this for the future. faced by the Trust today. Please give your many ways. We have celebrated a number of Our efforts to strengthen the Trust’s most careful consideration to the expertise anniversaries which have served to remind us financial base have in no way detracted from and experience of candidates standing for all of the vision, effort and compassion, that our work to advocate for the protection of election, and how they complement those of underpin our national culture.
    [Show full text]
  • Project Area Background Scope
    Our ref: PR144033-9 Unit 2A, 45 Fitzroy Street Carrington NSW 2294 T +61 2 4940 4200 Date: 09 December 2019 Raphael Shin Enterprises Pty Ltd 101 Bowden Street RYDE NSW 2112 Dear Raphael, Raphael Shin Enterprises Pty Ltd has engaged RPS to update the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for The Bay Resort at Anna Bay under State Significant Development (SSD13_5916). Project Area The Project Area is located directly north of Nelson Bay Road, being land within Lot 2 DP747399 and land within an un-named Council road to the immediate east of Lot 2 DP 747399. The Project Area is within the Port Stephens Council Local Government Area (LGA) (Figure1). Background A Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment (CHIA) was prepared in November 2014 for “The Bay Resort’, for land within Lot 2 DP747399. The purpose of this report was to inform the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) which was prepared in April 2015. Scope This letter report has been produced as an addendum to the EIS and provides: • An updated Aboriginal Heritage Impact Management System (AHIMS) search to ensure no newly identified sites have been registered within the Project Area; • Updated historic heritage database searches; and • An Aboriginal Archaeological Due Diligence Assessment for the proposed upgrading of the un-named Council road. Field survey for the due diligence assessment was undertaken December 2019, refer to Appendix A. RPS Australia East Pty Ltd. Registered in Australia No. 44 140 292 762 rpsgroup.com Page 1 ALLIS CRE N W EK Legend 2 Project Area Previously Surveyed Area k Karuah Cadastre Carrington Hawks Nest 2m Contours North Pindimar Soldiers Arm Cove Drainage Point Lemon Tree 2 Roads and Tracks Passage Nelson Bay Road Authority Mallabula Salamander Bay Fingal Bay Crown Local Government Authority Fishermans NSW Government Bay Location 2 0 2 2 4 2 6 8 IMPORTANT NOTE 1.
    [Show full text]
  • HUNTER 2000 Is Available· from the National Trust of Australia (N.S.W.) 123 Clarence Street, Sydney 2000
    HUI)fTEA 2000: HlJ�TEA2000: The National Trust of Australia (N.S.W.) Hunter Regional Committee Conservation and Landscape Committee W. A. Enright. Chairman R. S. Woodgate. Honorary Secretary S. C. Alley Mrs. H. A. Bond H. C. Dorman D. J. Lithgow K. McDonald D. D. Morris Prof. K. W. Robinson R. K.wark Mrs. K. H. White R. C. Winston Valuable assistance was also rendered by: J. Colman, Planning Consultant I. Sim, National Tr ust representative on the Aboriginal Relics Advisory Committee Published by the National Trust of Australia (New South Wales) 123 Clarence Street. Sydney Copyright© The National Trust of Australia (New South Wales) 1972 Reprinted 1973 National library of Australia and ISBN 0909723 06 0 Registered in Australia for transmission by post as a book Designed and Printed in Newcastle by Philip Samuels CONTENTS Introduction 1 ·11 Planning 3 III Proposals for Conservation 8 National Parl(s, State Parks & Nature Reserves 8 Open Space of Regional Significance 8 Scenic Preserves 8 State Forests & Timber Reserves 9 Catchment Areas 10 Crown Lands 10 Historic 'Buildings and Urban Areas of Special Significance 10 Aboriginal Relics in the Hunter Region 16 IV Concl"sion 18 Appendices 1. Descriptions of Park and Reserve Proposals 19 A. National Parks 19 B. State Parks 22 C. Nature Reserves 25 D. Open Space of Regional Significance ,29 E. Scenic Preserves 33 2. Historic Buildings 34 References and General Bibliography 39 Index 40 moves are under way to prepare a planning strategy for the I Introduction Hunter Region, the Trust is firm in its view that these issues are equally essential to planning in this Region.
    [Show full text]
  • To the Nev^Castle Morning Herald and Miners' Advocate 1977
    INDEX TO THE NEV^CASTLE MORNING HERALD AND MINERS' ADVOCATE 1977 Compiletj by The Newcastle Morning Heral(j Library Published by NEWCASTLE PUBLIC LIBRARY The Council of the City of Newcastle New South Wales, Australia 1978 H.K.H. IRISA 1977 ABATTOIRS ABORIGINES (Cont) 48 hour strike at abattoir 6.1:7 Aborigines rap B.H.P. 9.4:1 Cattle sales continue despite strike 7.1:7 -Aborigines report to lacial group 9.4:8 Meatworkers out again 8.1:3 UN praises report on Aborigines 14.4: 3 Calves' fate postponed by strike 10.1:3 Australia "racist": Aboriginal group 15.4:7 Calves' fate postponed again 11.1:9 Dead youth's gun'tocked" (Adelaide) 21.4:3 Maitland meat men may strike 12.1:6 Aborigines summons PM, Bjelke 4.5:18 Decision on meat row held 20.1:11 Aboriginal alcoholics find a way back among Abattoir not prospect "for long time" their own kind 14.5:7 (Lake Macquarie Municipality) 2.2:19 Aborigines allege bias by JP's 18.5:11 Meat row talks recommended 5.2:3 Black jobless "may be 50%" 27.5:5 Meat dispute relisted for hearing 10.2.:6 Black children "disadvantaged" 30.5:3 Bargaining over abattoir backed 11.2:5 New forum for Aborigines 31.5:3 Council will confer with meat union 12.2:5 Aboriginal identity erosion 31.5:7 Councils join on abattoir union talks Court case against PM 2.6:20 16.2:7 Soviet attack on "racist laws" 8.6:3 Joint abattoir talks 17.2:3 Aboriginal children "scavenging food" 13.6:13 Lake abattoir "would be costly" 17.2:LH1 Immunisation risk alleged 14.6:11 Contract let for abattoir survey 23.2:1 Aborigines wary of law reform commission
    [Show full text]
  • Combined Index/Table of Contents for Our Publications
    Combined index/table of contents for our publications 1. search for words anywhere in this combined index. First open the search box (in Adobe Acrobat or Reader) using the menu or the CRTL F short cut Then type the word into the search box 2. to purchase our publications, see www.patersonhistory.org.au for details to purchase our books, see www.patersonhistory.org.au 1 - PATERSON ORANGE BY V ALMA P A TFIELD Published by Paterson Historical Society Inc 2016 to purchase our books, see www.patersonhistory.org.au 2 Adlam, S, 12, Haslam, Percy, 22, Alll;n River, 13, 19, Hartley, Dulcie, Annandale, 3 Hilldale, 14, Anderson, Val, 23, 25, 27,30 Hopson,E,12, Arnold, William, 4 Hudson, C, 11, Archer, Cameron, 27,30 Hudson, Tony,l2 Auckett, Dick, 12, Auckett, Frank, 11, 12, 19, 20, 23 Jarrett, H. 11 Johnstone, Major Edward,3 Benbow, Judy, 24, Jolliffe, George, 30 Bingleburra, 13, 18, 25, Jordon, Jin1, 25 Boughton, John Herring, 2, Jupp, J. 11 Boydell, William, 3 Jupp, William, Boyle, J, 7, Brisbane Grove, 6, 7, 9,14, 15, Keppie, Bill, 14, 20, 21, 22, 24, 25 Keppie, Mabs, 19, 24 Caerg-c.urle, 5, Keppie, Peter, 23 Cann, James, Keppie, William, 6, 14 Cmnpsie, 5, Carrabolln, 17, Lewinsbrook,5, 6, 15, 16,20 Clevedon, 6 Logan, Robert, 5 Corner, Keith, 21, 26 Lostock, 11 Cowley, George, 11, :tvlenger, Bill, 12 Daisy, 5, Mackay, J.K. 11 18 Dalkeith, 16, Maldi Gome, 6 Dangar, Henry, 2 Marquet, George, 12 Darr, Larry, 12, 25, Marquet, L, 7,1 Duns Creek,2 Myles, Fred" 25 Ecclestone, 16, Edler Bros, 11, Parish, D.].
    [Show full text]
  • The Whistler 13 2019
    WhistlerThe Features Brahminy Kite Beach Stone-curlew Black-necked Stork Regent Honeyeater Sharp-tailed Sandpiper Pallid Cuckoo Sooty Oystercatcher Birds of Tahlee, Gloucester Tops, Ash Island An annual publication of the Number 13 2019 The Whistler is the scientific journal of the Hunter Bird Observers Club Inc. ISSN 2208-9845 (electronic copy); ISSN 1835-7385 (hard copy) All papers are peer-reviewed prior to publication. The aims of the Hunter Bird Observers Club (HBOC), which is affiliated with BirdLife Australia, are: • To encourage and further the study and conservation of Australian birds and their habitat • To encourage bird observing as a leisure-time activity HBOC is administered by a Committee: Executive: President: Bob Stewart, Vice-President: Mick Roderick, Secretary: Marg Clarke, Treasurer: Helen McCall. Committee Members: Lucas Grenadier, Andrzej Karpiel, Rob Kyte, Greg Little, Judy Little, Lene Parashou. Publication of The Whistler is managed by a team: Alan Stuart (Joint Editor), Neil Fraser (Joint Editor) Liz Crawford (Production Manager), Rob Kyte (Cover design) Printed by NCP Printing, Newcastle Authors wishing to submit manuscripts for consideration for publication should consult Instructions for Authors on page 95 and then submit their manuscripts to the Editors at [email protected] © Hunter Bird Observers Club Inc. PO Box 24, New Lambton NSW 2305 www.hboc.org.au Front cover: Beach Stone-curlew Esacus magnirostris - Photo: Trevor Murray Back cover: Pallid Cuckoo Heteroscenes pallidus - Photo: Chris Tzaros Spine: Sharp-tailed Sandpipers Calidris acuminata - Photo: Rob Palazzi The Whistler is proudly supported by Editorial The Whistler 13 (2019): i-ii Editorial This is the first issue of The Whistler after the joint Cuckoo has a large home range and is vulnerable retirement of long-term editors Harold Tarrant and directly (effects on adults) and indirectly (effects Mike Newman.
    [Show full text]
  • 97: Proceedings of the Biennial National Conference of The
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 446 893 SE 060 472 AUTHOR Todd, John J., Ed. TITLE Earthlinks '97: Proceedings of the Biennial National Conference of the Australian Association for Environmental Education and the Marine Education Society of Australasia (9th, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia, January 13-17, 1997). INSTITUTION Australian Association for Environmental Education, Tasmania. Tasmanian Branch. ISBN ISBN-0-9586537-5-5 PUB DATE 1997-00-00 NOTE 322p.; Also produced by the Marine Education Society of Australasia. AVAILABLE FROM Australian Association for Environmental Education, P.O. Box 474, Griffith University, Nathan-Queensland 4111, Australia. For full text: http://www.education.uts.edu.au/projects/AAEE. PUB TYPE Collected Works Proceedings (021) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC13 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Educational Technology; Elementary Secondary Education; *Environmental Education; Foreign Countries; Higher Education; Instructional Materials; Multimedia Instruction; Teaching Methods IDENTIFIERS Australia ABSTRACT This document contains the proceedings of the 9th Biennial National Conference of the Australian Association for Environmental Education and the Marine Society of Australasia. The contents provide a valuable snapshot of the state of environmental education in Australia while moving towards the end of the 20th century. Papers include: (1) "Stand Up, Stand Up and Be Counted: Exploring Three Myths in Environmental Education" (Fien, J.); (2) "Learning through Landscapes: The Importance of School Grounds" (Lucas, B.); (3) "Using a Multimedia Approach
    [Show full text]
  • BRANCH CUTTINGS Issue 50 - June 2016 This Branch Is Affiliated with the Royal Australian Historical Society & National Trust of Australia (NSW)
    The newsletter of the Sydney & Northern New South Wales branch of the Australian Garden History Society BRANCH CUTTINGS Issue 50 - June 2016 This branch is affiliated with the Royal Australian Historical Society & National Trust of Australia (NSW) LA LOUVE by Angela Low Little Cuttlefish Bay La Louve After the AGHS conference in Adelaide we joined a long drought, that dry climate gardening had Trisha Dixon for the post-conference tour. On become compelling, and also told her we had just Kangaroo Island we visited a lovely property been to an AGHS conference and tour in called Little Cuttlefish Bay . The house and its Maryborough and seen beautiful gardens made in walled garden were right on the coast, approached the harshest of climates. She wrote straight back via a long driveway through dry paddocks, lined saying the garden was open once a month, that by stunted casuarinas. Just outside the mud brick there was a tour the next day and she would add and stone walls was an area with casuarinas our names to the list at the Office de Tourisme. clipped into tight balls, stones and a pebbled Rushing over there we found (of course) that they garden of local grasses, golden brown, placed in a were closed for 2 hours for lunch. We later formal pattern, with natural bush and the sea view presented ourselves and the lady at the desk said, beyond. ‘Ah oui, les Americains.’ My face must have fallen Years ago I bought a coffee table book called but, no, she meant ‘Australiens’ and we were in.
    [Show full text]