DOCSLIB.ORG

For Gaza Carnage

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
For Gaza Carnage Rabbi Ascherman’s “Teshuva” for Gaza Carnage Rabbi Ascherman with a Palestinian in West Bank Our thanks to Carolyn Oppenheim for alerting us to this Times of Israel blog post, “Screaming Souls and an Elul Prayer,” from our friend, Rabbi Arik Ascherman, head of the Israeli NGO and activist group, Rabbis for Human Rights. The situation in Gaza informs his efforts at “Teshuva,” repentance, during this season of Jewish soul-searching leading up to Yom Kippur. It is, however, a fully Zionist piece as well. The following are excerpts: . The full enormity of how many bodies have been ripped apart by Israeli bombs, when their deaths were not necessary for our legitimate self defense, has finally penetrated the Israeli bubble that I live in. Painfully aware of grieving Israeli families, of friends and colleagues in bomb shelters, and of family members and children of RHR rabbis and staff fighting in Gaza, as well as believing in the right of self defense and having had to run for shelter a few times myself, it was convenient to coat my growing awareness of what we were doing in cerebral terms and balanced pronouncements. It is not just the numbers. Numbers alone don’t prove responsibility. I have moved . to the conclusion that those who have been giving the orders have to have known they [were] . leading to the deaths of innocents that cannot even be written off as essential to protect Israelis. When massive firepower killed 60-130 Palestinians to prevent the escape of Hamas gunmen with First Lieutenant Hadar Goldin z”l, they knew that Goldin either was already dead or would be killed by this “friendly fire.” B’Tselem has documented 72 incidents through August 4th in which 547 people, including 250 minors, 29 elderly and 129 women under the age of 60 died when residential homes were bombed. Theoretically, there could be information not at our disposal that changes the picture radically. That is why it is important that Israel’s comptroller has announced an independent and transparent Israeli investigation. I would be incredibly thankful to be proved wrong, but I doubt that will happen. It is already clear that in many of these cases there was no immediate danger, such as firing from the house. It is that awful reality that makes the numbers a horrible black stain that can never be erased. When Israeli citizens or soldiers were in immediate danger of death if we didn’t kill women, children and the elderly, there was a difficult judgment call to be made and we can blame Hamas for having forced us to make such choices. When we killed non-combatants to remove a potential, but non-immediate threat to Israelis, we caused unjustifiably disproportionate death. This clearly happened when we killed entire families because a Hamas operative was in the home. Now, before Hamas and its supporters begin having a field day with what I have written, let me be clear. I continue to believe that Hamas is an immoral violator of both Israeli and Palestinian human rights, a disaster for the Palestinian people, and a disgrace to Islam. I know that Hamas has intentionally sacrificed its own citizens to lay the trap we have unfortunately fallen into. You will not find me at demonstrations placing all of the blame on Israel, and where there is no condemnation of Hamas rockets and tunnels. I have not been convinced by those who have mocked me for paying a shiva call to a fallen soldier and neighbor. If I was asked 49 days ago what to do, after days of Hamas rocket fire, after Israel’s warnings about what would happen if the rockets did not stop, and the international lack of will or inability to put the brakes on Hamas, I also would have reluctantly given the order for a military response, albeit a different response than the one we chose. However, if I could turn back the clock, I would turn back the clock even further, I would turn the clock back to all those years in which territorial aspirations unrelated to real security concerns led us to thwart or ignore or talk to death every chance for a just and lasting peace. Our overwhelmingly greater power allowed us to influence the course of events in ways that Palestinians could not. With this power came responsibility, and we used it unwisely. To read more click on the following: Screaming Souls and an Elul Prayer | Arik Ascherman | The Blogs | The Times of Israel .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • September 2001
    September 2001 An Among Friends independent magazine serving the Thanks Are in Order Religious n the past couple of years, I have used this space in the magazine to reflect on the Society of articles we are presenting to you, to share a bit about our excitement over new Friends I projects and challenges, and to introduce new staff and volunteers. This column is written to say thank you. Editorial For me, one of the very best parts of working for Friends organizations is the Susan Corson-Finnerty (Publish~r and Ex~cutiv~ EditQr), Kenneth Surron (Smior Editor}, Robert opportuniry to meet and work with extraordinary individuals. As I think back over Dockhorn (Assistant Editor), Judirh Brown (Pomy the years at Powell House, Princeton Friends School, and FRIENDS JouRNAL, so many Editor}, Ellen Michaud (Book Rroiew Editor}, wonderful people come to mind-Board members, staff, and constituents of those ]. Brenr Bill (Assistant Book Rroi= Editor), Joan Overman (Book Rroi= Assistant}, Christine Rusch Friendly entities. What a privilege it is to have known and worked alongside of and (Mikstones Editor}, Julie Gochenour, Robert Marks, with these remarkable, dedicated folks! What a huge reservoir of wisdom and what a Cameron McWhirter (N=s Editors), Kara Newdl spirit of joyful service we have in the Religious Society of Friends! (Columnist), Lisa Rand, Marjorie Schier (Copyeditors}, Sarah Gray (Inurn) As you read these words, here at the JouRNAL we will be coming to the end of Production Kenneth Sutton's eight years of service on our staff, as he leaves Philadelphia to move Barbara Benron (Art Dir~ctor}, Alia Podolsky to Boston.
    [Show full text]
  • Israel and the Occupied Territories 2015 Human Rights Report
    ISRAEL 2015 HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Israel is a multiparty parliamentary democracy. Although it has no constitution, the parliament, the unicameral 120-member Knesset, has enacted a series of “Basic Laws” that enumerate fundamental rights. Certain fundamental laws, orders, and regulations legally depend on the existence of a “state of emergency,” which has been in effect since 1948. Under the Basic Laws, the Knesset has the power to dissolve the government and mandate elections. The nationwide Knesset elections in March, considered free and fair, resulted in a coalition government led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Civilian authorities maintained effective control over the security services. (An annex to this report covers human rights in the occupied territories. This report deals with human rights in Israel and the Israeli- occupied Golan Heights.) During the year according to Israeli Security Agency (ISA, also known as Shabak) statistics, Palestinians committed 47 terror attacks (including stabbings, assaults, shootings, projectile and rocket attacks, and attacks by improvised explosive devices (IED) within the Green Line that led to the deaths of five Israelis and one Eritrean, and two stabbing terror attacks committed by Jewish Israelis within the Green Line and not including Jerusalem. According to the ISA, Hamas, Hezbollah, and other militant groups fired 22 rockets into Israel and in 11 other incidents either planted IEDs or carried out shooting or projectile attacks into Israel and the Golan Heights. Further
    [Show full text]
  • Census 2020: an Overview for Michigan in This Issue… Farming While Black Author to Keynote Local Food Summit BIC Welcomes Debo
    Washtenaw Jewish News Presort Standard In this issue… c/o Jewish Federation of Greater Ann Arbor U.S. Postage PAID 2939 Birch Hollow Drive Ann Arbor, MI Ann Arbor, MI 48108 Permit No. 85 Vote Rabbis Pamela WZC Write Nadell Purim Gives Belin Lecture page 8 page 10 page 16 March 2020 Adar/Nisan 5780 Volume XIX Number 6 FREE BIC welcomes Deborah Sacks Mintz Census 2020: Beth Jarvis, Special ti wthe WJN transformative prayer leader and An overview for musician, Deborah Sacks Mintz has Aserved innovative institutions around Michigan the country as a teacher of Torah and commu- By Hayg Oshagan nal Jewish music. As the Community Singing he U. S. Constitution requires that Consultant of Hadar’s Rising Song Institute, the federal government count every Deborah combines musical scholarship and person living in the U.S. The U.S. practice to cultivate the grassroots musical and T Census has been conducted every 10 years spiritual creativity of the Jewish people. since 1790. Join Beth Israel Congregation's Scholar Every year, the federal government gives in Residence Deborah Sacks Mintz at 5:45 money it has collected from taxes back to p.m. on Friday, March 20, for “Niggun the states. How much money a state gets de- Preparation: New Melodies and Singing pends on how many people live in that state. as a Spiritual Process” to get us spiritually And the count of how many people live in prepared for Shabbat. Then stay for an up- a state is determined every 10 years by the lifting and participatory Kabbalat Shabbat Census.
    [Show full text]
  • Inspiration from Israel, 2019 Shabbat Pinchas 5779 July 26, 2019 Rabbi Barry H
    Inspiration from Israel, 2019 Shabbat Pinchas 5779 July 26, 2019 Rabbi Barry H. Block Israel can be infuriating. In July alone, Israel’s Education Minister declared American intermarriage to be “like a second Holocaust;” he then went on to proclaim his support for conversion therapy, a cruel pseudo-psychology that purports to “cure” gays and lesbians of the same-sex attractions that animate their lives. Tonight, though, I would like to pause from criticism of the Jewish State and even of its often-despicable government. Like our own United States, Israel is more than its government and better than its worst prejudices. Like the United States, Israel offers tremendous cause for celebration, particularly when we’re prepared to examine the country in all of its complexity. As most of you know, I spend time in Israel every year. My days there are not filled with protest marches or government-bashing. Sure, issues arise, and the Israelis and Americans with whom I share my time there are not shy about confronting harsh realities. Still, every summer, more than upset or depressed about the current state of affairs, I come away inspired by the beauty, the accomplishments, and the motivation of the Land and people of Israel. One day of my studies at the Shalom Hartman Institute is devoted to an in- depth excursion. My group visited the Development Town of Yerucham in a remote part of the Negev. Development Towns were an invention of the early State, as it strove to find places for new immigrants to settle outside of Israel’s already-crowded cities.
    [Show full text]
  • Taamu Uru Winter Break Program December 21, 2015 – January 3, 2016
    Taamu URu Winter Break Program December 21, 2015 – January 3, 2016 Monday, December 21- Welcome to Israel! 3:00pm – Arrival and check-in Lev Yerushalayim (Lisa and Phil) 4:30pm – 5:30pm – Meet & Greet at CY Tour of the campus Rules and Expectations 5:30pm- Chavrutah Activity with Dr. Joshua Kulp (Rosh Yeshiva) 6:15pm- Maariv 6:30pm- Dinner (at Guest House) 7:30pm- Opening program or ice breaker led by Phil (Madrich) 8:30pm- Free time Tuesday, December 22- Getting to know Jerusalem and the Conservative Yeshiva 7:45am – Shaharit at CY 9:00am – “Introduction to the Conservative Yeshiva” - Rabbi Joel Levy 12:30pm – Lunch on your own 1:45pm – Depart for Neot Kedumim Park 2:30pm-Neot Kedumim Park- Biblical Landscape Reserve in Israel shows a unique recreation of the physical setting of the Bible in all its depth and detail allows visitors to see life as it was lived by our ancestors 3,000 years ago. 6:00pm- Depart for BBQ at Dr. Joshua Kulp’s House in Modin 6:15pm- Opening BBQ 8:00pm- Leave for CY Wednesday, December 23- Where it All Began 7:15 am – Meet at at CY to get bus to the kotel to daven Shacharit (Morning Services) at the Egalitarian Kotel 7:30 am – Shaharit at Kotel 8:30am – Breakfast at the Kotel - provided by CY 9:00- 12:30pm – Tour of the City of David and the Davidson Center - archaeological site of ancient Jerusalem of the pre-Babylonian exile era. It is located beneath the southern city walls of old Jerusalem.
    [Show full text]
  • There's a Part of Me That Would Love to Be Able to Stand up Here This
    Rabbi Andrea London Beth Emet The Free Synagogue In Defense of Liberal Zionism Kol Nidre 2014/5775 I want to share with you a story that I received via email earlier this week from Ron Kronish, an American-born rabbi who has lived in Israel for many years. “A few days ago,” Rabbi Kronish wrote, “my wife and I took a drive east of Jerusalem to show a friend from Boston some of the complicated geography in areas C and E of the West Bank. As we were strolling around, we noticed a strange sign on the nearby kiosk. It said in Hebrew: Am Shalem Doresh Falafel—"The people demand falafel." This was a play on a previous slogan from a few years ago: Dor Shalem Doresh Shalom—"An entire generation demands peace." At first I thought it was funny,” Rabbi Kronish continues, “and then I realized what it really meant. “The people," apparently, are not interested in peace any more. ‘There is no partner,’ they say (as if we ourselves were a serious partner for peace!). And even if there were a serious partner, it is not achievable. Instead, the people want falafel! They don't want to worry all the time about issues of war and peace. They just want a ‘'normal’ life!” He goes on: “I explained to my friend some of the background for this feeling. Many Israelis have given up on the ‘Peace Process.’ It is boring. It never really leads anywhere, so why continue to discuss it.” I wanted to share Rabbi Kronish’s email because this feeling of resignation in Israeli society is pervasive, and understandably so.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2003
    ANNUAL REPORT 2003 Destruction May Be… Continuity Shall Be… Al-Kahf Arts and Crafts Center The ‘Cave’ Gift Shop Music Conservatory Opening of Ad-Dar Cultural and Conference Center * Events The Bethlehem Media Center (BMC) Information Technology and Communications 2003 Dar al-Kalima Academy Dar al-Kalima Health and Wellness Center Dar al-Kalima Model School * Distance Learning Youth Work * Summer Academy 2003 * Guatemala Trip – ARK PROGRAM * Germany Trip – EUROMED PROJECT Global Servant Leader DESTRUCTION MAY BE… CONTINUITY SHALL BE… On April 2, 2002 the Israeli Invasion of Bethlehem caused much destruction to the Lutheran compound and to the ICB building, furniture and equipment. In this context, the staff and beneficiaries of the ICB were determined to never give up on Bethlehem. The ICB is committed to continue to build and rebuild, to train and educate, to empower, to create life in the midst of despair, and to continue to call for justice and reconciliation in the midst of conflict and violence. The year 2003 was a year which focused on rebuilding and completing our facilities. We were able to inaugurate two major facilities, Ad-Dar Cultural and Conference Center and Dar al-Kalima Health and Wellness Center. AL-KAHF ARTS AND CRAFTS CENTER Art Workshops For the year 2003, as in previous years, the art workshops held at al-Kahf Arts and Crafts Center continued to operate very successfully and many of the local community benefited from what they had to offer. The art workshops concentrated on various art mediums, focusing especially on the youth but not solely. As part of the mission of the ICB, there is always the training for the unemployed, with special concentration on women, in order to enhance their employability and increase their chances of making a living with dignity.
    [Show full text]
  • Two Haaretz Reports on Settler Violence These Reports Are
    Two Haaretz Reports on Settler Violence These reports are included to provide background on settler behavior that is not often seen in the US media. Fighting the W. Bank harvest of hatred Haaretz, Published date November 15, 2002 In the olive groves: Zionist immigrants protect Palestinians from Zionist settlers A large number of American Zionist immigrants, some of whom are religious, joined two separate olive pickings in West Bank Palestinian orchards last weekend. These harvests were organized by Israeli Jews to help protect the Palestinian farmers and their harvest from other Israeli Jews. The results of the two harvests were remarkably different although only a night divided them. This was possibly because Chief of Staff Moshe Ya'alon, was just forming his soon-to-be heavily publicized campaign to end the `olive war' by offering the Palestinians rare IDF protection. Olives grow mainly in the upper half of the country and provide the main livelihood for many Palestinian families. An average family owns between 50-170 trees, each tree has 20-70 kilos of olives and 1 kilo usually sells for about 5 shekels inside the occupied territories. The official harvesting period is from October 15th until November 15th this year. Many farmers had hoped to finish early before the start of Ramadan on November 6th, when the pickers would be fasting daily from sunrise to sunset. What no one expected was Jewish settlers beating them to it, stealing olives from the trees even before the harvest period opened, and in some cases, attacking the farmers. One 24 year-old villager from Aqraba, Hani Beni Manieh, was killed and three others were wounded in one such attack on the 6th of October.
    [Show full text]
  • Ann Arbor's Home for Reform Judaism
    TempleAnn Arbor’s B ethhome for Reform Emeth Judaism Affiliated with the Union for Reform Judaism ...its ways are ways of pleasantness, 2309 Packard St., Ann Arbor, MI 48104 | Phone 734-665-4744 | Fax 734-665-9237 and all its paths are peace. Terri A. Ginsburg Religious School 734-665-5817 | www.templebethemeth.org May 2018 Iyar-Sivan, 5778 Announcing Genizah Event: Burial of Our Old Prayer Books Liturgical Calendar Sunday, May 6 | 11 am | Washtenong Memorial Park Cemetery Friday, May 4 5:45 pm Tot Shabbat Together, we will bury our old High Holy Day prayer books that we no longer use. 5:45 pm Step Up Shabbat There will be a short, meaningful service, and an opportunity for all to participate 6:15 pm Tot Dinner in burying our old books. Burying sacred books is a unique aspect of Jewish 6:45 pm Shira practice, and participating in this service is not to be missed. Likely, we will not 7:30 pm Shabbat Service: bury sacred items and books again for many years. This is a great opportunity Birthday & Anniversaries to bring young kids to a cemetery and introduce them to an important part of Saturday, May 5 Jewish life. 8:50 am Torah Study 10 am Bar Mitzvah Service: If you have items (tattered prayer books, Torah commentaries, tefillin, scrolls from Tyler Wilkins a mezuzah, tzitzit from an old tallit or prayershawl) that you would like to bury, please bring them to the TBE office by May 5, or email Regen Ainley, Sunday, May 6 [email protected], describing what you will be bringing.
    [Show full text]
  • Shalom 2015-12 December 2015.Indd
    Jewish Peace Letter Vol. 44 No. 9 Published by the Jewish Peace Fellowship December 2015 Arik Ascherman 4 A Hilltop Encounter and Stefan Merken 4 After Paris Philip Bentley 4 No to ‘BDS’ Alfred W. McCoy 4 American Hegemons Murray Polner 4 Our Bourbon Foreign Policy ISSN: 0197-9115 From Where I Sit Stefan Merken Aft er Paris, Quoi ? uch of the world was under- to join its murderous ranks. And the more standably shaken by the atrocities ISIS grows, the more it is able to fl ex its well- in Paris. While the French were funded and well-armed (by whom?) muscles Mstill reeling from last January’s killing of against civilians in Lebanon, Turkey, in a Charlie Hebdo’s graphic artists and cartoon- Russian airliner and now in Paris. ists, they now had to deal with even more Some in this country have called for terrorist murders. more US “boots on the ground,” ignoring Aft er 9/11 the Bush administration, sup- our military failures since 2003. Others have ported by overwhelming American pub- called for greatly enhanced surveillance of lic opinion, decided to pursue those they Americans. Th e domestic danger is that claimed were responsible. Soon aft er, US panic rather than reason oft en prevails in na- troops were in Afghanistan and then, in tional security “crises.” American history is 2003, in Iraq, and much of the blame for the replete with such witch hunts: John Adams’s rise of ISIS is due to the chaos created by the Alien and Sedition Acts; Woodrow Wilson’s US invasion.
    [Show full text]
  • American and Catholic William Bole on David O’Brien Donald W
    July 2-9, 2007AmericaTHE NATIONAL CATHOLIC WEEKLY $2.75 American and Catholic William Bole on David O’Brien Donald W. Shriver on honest patriotism International Authority and Iraq by Cornelius F. Murphy Jr. Israel’s Rebel Rabbi by Robert Hirschfield UST AS THIS TIME of the year On to the next day, for some native air involves picnics and beaches, so May in the Philadelphia suburbs. This time the America seems to be the time for installations occasion was a baptism for Hayden Pedro Published by Jesuits of the United States and things, things like graduations, Kelly, in from Chicago with his entourage J first Communions, confirmations, to be greeted by an even larger local one, Editor in Chief even retirements. All of these figured in members of St. Philip Neri parish in Drew Christiansen, S.J. my family’s doings this year. Being part of Lafayette Hill, Montgomery County. these celebrations provided a welcome There we were welcomed by Msgr. Managing Editor respite from the streams of bad news Charles Vance, who might have been a Robert C. Collins, S.J. globally. Two of them stand out in my clone of Msgr. Thomas Kelly in his gra- mind and memory because of what they ciousness and efficiency—and in his pride Business Manager evoked. in his own “living parish” and delight in Lisa Pope The first was at St. Gabriel’s Church his parishioners. It is no secret that the in Riverdale, in New York City’s borough feeling is mutual. My brother and sister- Editorial Director of The Bronx.
    [Show full text]
  • FDR, the Jews and World War II
    Jewish Peace Letter Vol. 42 No. 6 Published by the Jewish Peace Fellowship September 2013 Murray Polner FDR, The Jews And World War II FDR signs the declaration of war against Germany, Dec. 11, 1941 plus Stefan Merken • L’shana tova Rabbi Phil Bentley • Al Vorspan, JPF’s Heschel Award recipient Lawrence S. Wittner • Nukes: The past is still present Elana Bell • ‘Language in the mouth of the enemy’ Ken Butigan • Daniel Ellsberg, lifelong resister Rabbi Arik Ascherman • Justice for Israel’s Bedouin ISSN: 0197-9115 From Where I Sit Stefan Merken לשנה טובה L’shana tovah Y n behalf of the Shalom editorial staff and the JPF Board, we wish our friends and readers a very happy and healthy (5774) New Year. OAnd while I am on the subject of the New Year, please don’t forget the Jewish Peace Fellowship. All donations, large and small, are greatly appreciated. Y Stefan Merken is chair of the Jewish Peace Fellowship. People buying Rosh Hashana greeting cards from a street vendor in Tel Aviv, 1955. Peace, Justice and Jews: Reclaiming Our Tradition Edited by Murray Polner and Stefan Merken. A landmark collection of contemporary progressive Jewish thought written by activists from Israel, the U.S. and the U.K. $25.00 per copy, plus $5.00 for shipping Yes! Here is my tax-deductible contribution to the Jewish Peace Fellowship! $25 / $36 / $50 / $100 / $250 / $500 / $1000 / Other $ ____ Enclosed is my check, payable to “Jewish Peace Fellowship” Phone: ______________________________________________ (Please provide your name and address below so that we may properly credit your contribution.) E-mail address: _____________________________________________ Name _____________ City / State / Zip Below, please clearly print the names and addresses, including e-mail, of friends you think might be interested in supporting the aims of the Address ___________ Jewish Peace Fellowship.
    [Show full text]