Nota Bene, March 12, 2008
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
George Washington University Law School Scholarly Commons Nota Bene, 2008 Nota Bene, 2000s 3-12-2008 Nota Bene, March 12, 2008 Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.gwu.edu/nota_bene_2008 Recommended Citation George Washington University Law School, 22 Nota Bene 8 (2008) This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the Nota Bene, 2000s at Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Nota Bene, 2008 by an authorized administrator of Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY NOTA BENE A Forum for News, Features & Opinions in the Law School Community M w \ s II I \ <J I 0 N O c Wednesday, March 12, 2008 Vol. 22, No. 8 GW Wins ABA Client Counseling Competition Students Vote BY JAMES CHANG Competition included participants from were the client to engage us." Assistant News Editor law schools in Delaware, Maryland, New Crandall and Carbonneau fleshed in Annual Jersey, Pennsylvania, and DC. Crandall out the actual issues in all five prompts, clarifying the intentional vagueness to Over the weekend of March 7-9, and Carbonneau defeated a team from substantively counsel their clients. SBA Election GW Law students Emily Crandall and Georgetown and a team from the Uni All advancing competitors received Brianna Carbonneau won the national versity of Baltimore in this year's Region a new set of five problems with similarly round of the American Bar Association 3 final round. Sheats Ran Unopposed vague prompts for the National Competi (ABA) Client Counseling Competition, The Competition has a different tion. Crandall and Carbonneau said that which is held annually for members of theme each year for the issues that the for SBA President "[i]n preparing for the competition, as we the ABA Law Student Division. hypothetical client is seeking counseling. This year's theme is "Civil Rights and did for the regional, we [had] tried to an Crandall and Carbonneau advanced BY SARAH VALERIO ticipate likely problems from the prompts to the National Competition after they Civil Liberties," but beyond that there News Editor we [were] given. We... found, however, won the Region 3 Competion at the Uni is little guidance for what competitors that it [was] equally, if not more, impor versity of Baltimore School of Law on can expect. The prompts, as given by a fictional secretary, on this theme are tant for us to continue to work on our Feb. 16. At the Nation Competition at Recently, the SBA held its annual brief. For example, "Jack/Jane Smith counseling skills and conversational style. Pace University School of Law in White elections. Students voted on the portal to has scheduled an appointment to see you A primary goal of ours, which we... [car Plains, NY, Crandall and Carbonneau elect next year's representatives. about his/her child, Terry Smith, who is ried] over from the regional competition, competed against the winners from 12 Current SBA President, Bryan King, being denied needed medical treatment." [was] to create a relaxed and welcoming other regional competitions, including noted that, "We had more people vote this Or, "Mr. or Mrs. Brown and his/her environment for each of the clients we some held at Canadian law schools. year than last year." daughter Samantha have scheduled an met. We [also focused] on identifying Because the Competition aims to Current SBA Vice President and appointment to see you about a problem possible conflicts in the representation simulate a law office consultation with 2L, Brett Sheats, ran unopposed and was in Samantha's school." and other ethical concerns." a client, participants conduct interviews elected to take King's spot next year as All competitors have to prepare to The international round to this with an acting client based on short President. 2L and current SBA Senator, deal with clients and anticipate questions competition will be held in Bangalore, prompts provided to them and then ex Rahul Reddy, was elected to Sheats' cur and courses of action based on these India from April 3-6. This is the first time plain how they would proceed in the situ rent position, and will become SBA Vice short prompts. Crandall and Carbonneau that the international stage of the com ation. The Competition is similar to the President next year. described their approach to each client in petition is being held in South Asia, and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) "I just want to thank everyone who the Region 3 Competition. participants from law schools from over Client Counseling Competition held voted for me. I promise I'll put in 100% "Each counseling round last[ed] for 35 countries are expected to attend. every spring at GW Law. Both Crandall Crandall said the prompts for the as Executive Vice President next year. & Carbonneau got onto the ADR Board 45 minutes. In that 45 minutes, we [had to] meet with the client and then hold a International Competition will be some Also, a special thanks goes to my friends through this internal competition, though who put up with my annoying election wrap-up session in front of the judges, in what more complicated than those for the Y>otE\ Yvave additionally enrolled in the cli tlc-rnc'.i 1101 and still were nfc-e enough to role, after the client ha[d] left the room. regional and national rounds. ent counseling class. help me campaignsaid Reddy. The timing [was] up to the competitors. "The problems... will continue to The GW ADR Board sends board deal with civil rights, albeit on a global "As far as running the Senate," We typically interview[ed] the client for added Reddy of his duties as next year's members to this ABA national, external scale, and will feature judges from a vari 30 minutes, and then conducted] a 15 VP, "I'm going to take what I learned from competition every year. This year, two ety of counties," Crandall said. "We are minute wrap-up. In this wrap-up, we Brett and use it as a blueprint. He did a teams were sent to Baltimore, Crandall thrilled that GW has yet another chance to identified] areas for research, discuss[ed] brilliant job last year, and I'm going to do and Carbonneau as well as 3Ls Rob make a name for itself in an international particular concerns relating to the client, my best to emulate him as moderator of Peccola and Ryan Foley. The Region 3 competition." and map[ped] out how we would proceed the Senate." Reddy also elaborated on goals he Mock Trial Board Chooses New Members hopes to achieve next year, including con prepare for the competition. aware of the points that opposing counsel tinuing to pursue a flexible exam schedule. He said, "This administration will work BY KATIE EARNEST Students had to prepare witnesses might try to highlight. Other than reading Staff Writer for their chosen side as well as become the depositions, I memorized the ques hard with the student body to accomplish familiar with the rules of evidence and tions for the direct, and looked at the list immediate goals such as ensuring Law Students competed in the 2008 the deeper nuances of trial advocacy, that my counsel had prepared of possible School events run smoothly. At the same mock trial competition on Feb. 23-24. The which was a challenge for many first-year questions that I might get asked. I had a time, we are also concerned with the contest was run by the Mock Trial Board, competitors. great time doing it." welfare of GW Law's future classes, and a student-run honorary society that, ac Several competitors viewed the Another witness, Morgan Cosby, will strive to achieve important goals such cording to its website, is "dedicated to the competition as a way to explore a new 1L, noted that many witnesses had to as instituting an effective flexible-exam pursuit of excellence in trial advocacy." legal career path. Joel Chorny, 1L, stated, balance their own views with those of scheduling system." The Board conducts its internal "There is something special about dress the competitors responsible for prepping In the evening division, Tory Silver competition each year to seek out top ing up in a suit and standing before a them. "As a law student it was difficult not was elected as the 4L Evening Senator, student litigators for board membership. judge in an actual courtroom. It felt great to bring my own opinions to the table, but while the 3L Evening Senator, 2L Evening Members of the Mock Trial Board also and I look forward to making a career ultimately, it was [someone else's] gig not Senator, and Evening Division Senator compete around the country in various out of it." mine, so I had to take orders!" positions were still being tabulated. interscholastic competitions, including the Aditya Luthra, 1L, enjoyed playing Chorny urged students who did In the day division, Kerry Coleman National Civil Trial Competition and the the part of Richard McKyton, a witness not compete in mock trial as counsel or was elected to serve as 3L Day Senator. John Sorrenti, Liz Westbrook, and Eric ABA Labor Law Competition. for the defense. He pointed out the diffi witnesses to consider participating next Malis were all elected as 2L Day Senators. The fact pattern for this year's com culties that many teams had in preparing year. He stated, "I definitely recommend One remaining 2L Day Senator position petition concerned a slander and libel suit their witnesses for trial. competing in mock trial. So far it has been has yet to be determined by run-off elec initiated by a fictitious law firm partner, "My group, compared to some other one of the most rewarding experiences tion, as well as the Day Division Senator Lukas Reiter, against another law firm groups, dedicated a lot of their energies to I have had in law school.