(Oncorhynchus Mykiss) Resources of the Eel River Watershed, California
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Steelhead/Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) Resources of the Eel River Watershed, California July 2009 Gordon S. Becker Isabelle J. Reining Cartography by David A. Asbury Prepared for California State Coastal Conservancy Center for Ecosystem Management and Restoration Steelhead/Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) Resources of the Eel River Watershed, California Gordon S. Becker Isabelle J. Reining Cartography by David A. Asbury This report should be cited as: Becker, G.S. and Reining, I.J. 2009. Steelhead/rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) resources of the Eel River watershed, California. Cartography by D.A. Asbury. Center for Ecosystem Management and Restoration. Oakland, CA. Center for Ecosystem Management and Restoration TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ................................................................................................................................................................................... p. 1 Methods .......................................................................................................................................................................................... p. 5 Results Steelhead resources of the Eel River watershed .................................................................................................................................. p. 9 Steelhead resources of the lower Eel River ......................................................................................................................................... p. 12 Steelhead resources of the Van Duzen River ...................................................................................................................................... p. 47 Steelhead resources of the South Fork Eel River ................................................................................................................................ p. 77 Steelhead resources of the middle Eel River ...................................................................................................................................... p. 177 Steelhead resources of the North Fork Eel River ............................................................................................................................... p. 201 Steelhead resources of the Middle Fork Eel River.............................................................................................................................. p. 221 Steelhead resources of the upper Eel River ........................................................................................................................................ p. 275 Discussion ...................................................................................................................................................................................... p. 333 Acknowledgments ........................................................................................................................................................................... p. 339 Appendices A. Characterization of Water Year Types for Water Years 1911 – 2008 .............................................................................................. p. 341 B. Number of Steelhead Captured Annually at the Van Arsdale Fisheries Station Upstream Migrant Trap from 1933 – 2008 .......... p. 343 Index of stream names .................................................................................................................................................................... p. 345 i Tables Table 1. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the lower Eel River .................................................. p. 39 Table 2. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the Van Duzen River ............................................... p. 71 Table 3. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the South Fork Eel River ......................................... p. 163 Table 4. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the middle Eel River ................................................ p. 195 Table 5. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the North Fork Eel River ......................................... p. 215 Table 6. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the Middle Fork Eel River ....................................... p. 267 Table 7. Distribution status and population features of O. mykiss in streams of the upper Eel River.................................................. p. 325 Table 8. Summary of O. mykiss distribution and related features in the Eel River basin .................................................................... p. 333 Figures Figure 1. Study area .......................................................................................................................................................................... p. 3 Figure 2. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the lower Eel River, California ......................................................................... p. 43 Figure 3. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the lower Eel River, California ............................................................................ p. 45 Figure 4. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the Van Duzen River, California ...................................................................... p. 73 Figure 5. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the Van Duzen River, California ......................................................................... p. 75 Figure 6. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the South Fork Eel River (northern section) .................................................... p. 169 Figure 7. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the South Fork Eel River (northern section) ....................................................... p. 171 Figure 8. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the South Fork Eel River (southern section)..................................................... p. 173 Figure 9. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the South Fork Eel River (southern section) ....................................................... p. 175 Figure 10. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the middle Eel River ...................................................................................... p. 197 Figure 11. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the middle Eel River ......................................................................................... p. 199 Figure 12. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the North Fork Eel River ............................................................................... p. 217 Figure 13. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the North Fork Eel River .................................................................................. p. 219 Figure 14. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the Middle Fork Eel River ............................................................................. p. 271 Figure 15. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the Middle Fork Eel River ................................................................................ p. 273 Figure 16. Historical status of O. mykiss in streams of the upper Eel River ........................................................................................ p. 329 Figure 17. Current status of O. mykiss in streams of the upper Eel River ........................................................................................... p. 331 ii INTRODUCTION Researchers characterizing the distribution of steelhead/rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) face a variety of challenges on a path to an inherently imperfect result. Most Eel River streams have not been systematically and consistently surveyed, and the historical survey record is dispersed and incomplete. There can be no doubt, however, that compiling a comprehensive set of historical references is a valuable step in any process of stream and steelhead restoration. This volume represents our attempt to synthesize available information to establish an authoritative record of steelhead distribution in streams of the Eel River watershed. These streams support the winter (ocean-maturing) and summer (stream-maturing) steelhead ecotypes as well as the non-anadromous, or resident, form of rainbow trout1. We conducted our analysis using the methods of Leidy et al. (2005), as this study (of San Francisco Estuary tributaries) has proven useful to resource agency staff, planners, consulting biologists, scientists, and interested members of the public. The method of Leidy et al. (2005) in turn was based on the approach of Titus et al. (in prep.) in examining coastal streams south of San Francisco. In short, this report presents a distillation of a substantial amount of readily available, reliable information regarding steelhead and steelhead habitat. As such, it is intended to serve as a comprehensive, stream-by-stream steelhead resources reference for the community of people working with these issues in the Eel River watershed. Our analysis describes presence/absence and other natural history and habitat features in specific streams to contribute to the understanding of how steelhead resources may have changed over time. Despite strong public interest in the conservation and restoration of anadromous salmonids in the Eel River, and substantial efforts toward improving habitat, these populations remain