Immigrant Or Latino? Multiethnic Mobilization and Collective Identity in the Immigrant Rights Movement

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Immigrant Or Latino? Multiethnic Mobilization and Collective Identity in the Immigrant Rights Movement Immigrant or Latino? Multiethnic Mobilization and Collective Identity in the Immigrant Rights Movement Trudy Sumiko Rebert Photo by Tyler Hicks, New York Times, 11 April 2006. Advisor: Professor David Blaney Political Science Macalester College April 30, 2007 For Eduardo who continues to inspire me and kept me laughing all year Abstract Immigrant rights protests drew millions of people into the streets during the spring of 2006. However, the mobilized immigrants had a very particular face in the national debate. ‘Immigrant’ came to signify Latino. This project explores collective identity formation within the immigrant rights movement through the experiences of the South Asian community. What was the extent of South Asian immigrant participation in New York and the Twin Cities mobilizations? How does issue framing affect prospects for multi-racial mobilization? I use semi-structured interviews with organizers to investigate collective identity formation and to understand how organizations frame the issues. Greater understanding of the process of identity construction and identity transformation for broader political mobilization are crucial for today’s increasingly pluralistic society. Table of Contents Foreword ................................................................................................................................1 1 Introduction...........................................................................................................................5 Case Studies...........................................................................................................................11 New York.................................................................................................................14 The Twin Cities.......................................................................................................17 Methodology and Data Limitations...................................................................................21 2 Literature Review...............................................................................................................25 Social Movement Theory ....................................................................................................25 Resource Mobilization.........................................................................................................27 New Social Movements.......................................................................................................28 Framing ..................................................................................................................................29 Collective Identity.................................................................................................................32 Revising Social Movement Theory ....................................................................................34 3 From “Hindoo Invasion” to “Model Minority”: Shifting Constructions of South Asians.......................................................................37 The First Wave of South Asian Immigrants.....................................................................38 South Asian Immigration Today........................................................................................42 The 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act........................................................42 The New Wave of South Asian Immigrants.......................................................44 Asian Indian Identity..............................................................................................45 The Emergence of a South Asian Pan-ethnicity..............................................................51 4 “Sí Se Puede” But “Kyaa Hum Kar Sakte Hain?”: The Immigrant Rights Movement in New York and the Twin Cities...............54 A Movement Unfolds ..........................................................................................................54 South Asian Participation....................................................................................................57 Factors Affecting Mobilization...........................................................................................60 Internal Factors.......................................................................................................60 Language.....................................................................................................60 Existing Networks.....................................................................................61 External Factors......................................................................................................62 Political Expediency..................................................................................62 Social Networks and World View...........................................................63 Class.............................................................................................................64 The Framing: Racialization ................................................................................................65 Differential Framing Power ................................................................................................71 Fighting for Different Goals.................................................................................73 5 Bridging the Gap: Mobilizing the Rainbow .............................................................84 The Panethnic Organizing Model......................................................................................86 Forging a Common Immigrant Identity............................................................................91 6 Conclusion: Are Immigrants Enough? ......................................................................96 Bibliography......................................................................................................................105 Acknowledgements This thesis owes its life to many people. For their intellectual help at some point in this process, whether talking about methods, reading the paper, offering feedback, or providing an uplifting remark when needed: Dianna Shandy, Paul Dosh, Adrienne Christensen, Paru Shah, Dan Trudeau, and the other Political Science Department faculty. David Blaney deserves a special (and gigantic) thank you. How many professors would agree to advise an honor’s thesis while on sabbatical? Over the last four years, you have challenged my understanding of development, pushed me to think about poverty from many different angles, and opened the doors to political economy. Thank you for your intellectual guidance, personal support, and high standards. You have successfully stretched my brain. Hopefully the next time we meet, we will both be wandering around India, Tanzania, or somewhere farther afield. To MIRAC, AFFIRM, and all of the organizers I spoke with in New York and Minnesota, thank you for providing inspiration and hope. I will not list your names, but you know who you are. The work you do is vitally important and you are not recognized nearly enough. Although I have never met you, Monisha Das Gupta, I had tingles when I read your book and dissertation. Your work asked me to continue questioning my own and provided a model for undertaking engaged research. Over the last year, my friends in the Political Science Colloquium kept me motivated and working. We’re done! Wow. Ihotu, thank you for your thoughtful presence. I have enjoyed our growing friendship and conversation. Thank you for distracting me when I needed it! Elianne, thanks for being on the same page and for lots of side-whispering about identity during class. Molly – library explorer – you have been a wonderful support over the last four years. I promise I will let you drag me away from the books more often next year. Jess – we’re both going to graduate this year! Thanks for calling long distance and for making me figure out how to phone over the computer. Dad, thank you for always keeping me supplied with books and for not shutting the light off on me when I should have been sleeping rather than reading (and for providing glasses when my eyes started getting bad). Mom, you are ultimately responsible for this paper. Thank you for inspiring a deep sense of questioning within Jess and I, for your unyielding support, for your sometimes embarrassing daughter-advocacy, and for your sense of adventure. Finally, Eduardo, this paper would not have had any inspiration or come to fruition without you. Thank you for cooking dinner when I hadn’t eaten properly, for talking until 3am about organizing, for making me laugh, and for more things and ways than I can ever thank you for. I am still not sure how this all started, but the last three years have been wonderful. Foreword In the spring of 2006, I sat at a computer half-way around the world in Rajasthan, India, reading an article and looking at pictures of recent immigrant rights marches in Los Angeles, Chicago, and Minneapolis-St. Paul. A sea of people waving Mexican and American flags filled the picture. I had never seen marches so big in the twenty-two years of my life. Forty-thousand in St. Paul, where I normally attend college, was unheard of. That number would be equivalent to every single person in my hometown area turning out for a march – and then adding another ten thousand people. I longed to be home where friends were obtaining permits, printing flyers, and working to turn people out. However, as I continued to look at the pictures from March 25th, to April 9th /10th,
Recommended publications
  • Shut the War Down!
    workers.org Workers and oppressed peoples of the world unite! AUGUST 25, 2005 VOL. 47, NO. 33 50¢ No refuge for Bush as Madre de soldado ultimado en Irak confronta a Bush 12 El Pentágono gasta $500 millones en tropas en África 12 Anti-war activists From Black Teamsters’ Caucus: Farrakhan to address occupy Crawford By Dustin Langley Black labor Langley from Crawford While the events of the past few weeks have proven By Chris Silvera Aug. 17—People have converged here from all over—I just spoke to that the Pentagon is not capable even of successfully Chair of the Teamsters someone who drove overnight from Atlanta. Everybody’s walking occupying the Green Zone in Baghdad, as of Aug. 16 National Black Caucus around with so much enthusiasm. It’s a tangible feeling that we’re at the the anti-war movement in this country has success- center of something—of a movement that can really grow and stop the The Teamsters National Black fully occupied Crawford, Texas, the home of President war. I’ll be sending updates to Workers World. Visit www.workers.org. Caucus is an organization of Black George W. Bush. trade unionists fighting to defeat This remarkable development, which has given the discrimination inside and outside U.S. anti-war movement a new burst of vitality, is due of the International Brotherhood of largely to the efforts of Cindy Sheehan. Teamsters. We believe in educating Sheehan is from Vacaville, Calif. Her son Casey Sheehan was and activating the rank and file. killed in Baghdad’s Sadr City on April 4, 2004.
    [Show full text]
  • Huge Beirut Rally Rebuffs 'Gucci Revolution'
    workers.org Workers and oppressed peoples of the world unite! MARCH 17, 2005 VOL. 47, NO. 9 50¢ •EEUU amenaza a presidente venezolano Lebanese reject •Tribunal: ‘No pena de muerte para jóvenes’ 12 U.S. intervention FIGHT FOR EMPIRE? Recruiting takes Huge Beirut rally rebuffs ‘Gucci revolution’ nose dive 3 By Fred Goldstein to the demands by the Bush administration and its allies and stooges that Syria remove its troops from Lebanon and that The Lebanese people converged on Beirut from all the poor Hezbollah be disarmed. areas of the country on March 6 in a massive anti-imperialist, Reuters of March 8, referring to a speech by Hezbollah leader anti-Zionist showing. They gave a resounding rebuff to efforts Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah, reported that “Nasrallah said no one by the Bush administration to isolate Syria, attack Hezbollah and in Lebanon feared the United States, whose troops left Beirut in set the stage for expanding its war for “regime change” in the 1984”—a few months after a car bombing which killed 241 Middle East to Damascus. Marines at their headquarters in Beirut. “We have defeated them WOMEN’S Organizers said 1 million demonstrated. Even the most mod- in the past and if they come again we will defeat them again,” he HISTORY erate estimate by the big business press was half a million. is reported to have said. Overhead panning of the demonstration by video cameras show- Placards at the rally, according to the AP, said “Syria & MONTH ing it overflowing Riyadh Solh Square in central Beirut for as far Lebanon brothers forever,” “America is the source of terrorism,” as the eye could see in all directions.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Bring Troops Home Now!'
    workers.org Workers and oppressed peoples of the world unite! OCT. 6, 2005 VOL. 47, NO. 39 50¢ Líder sindical asesinado FBI terror attack en Colombia 12 Monopolio imperialista de la tecnología 12 in Puerto Rico Snipers gun down independence hero, provoking anti-colonial outcry By Tom Soto Rosado and himself, leaving one FBI agent San Juan, Puerto Rico wounded. iHONOR ROSA PARKSi On Sept. 23, as hundreds of workers and Rosado speaks to media DEC. 1 STRIKE their families were participating in the annual Elma Beatriz Rosado addressed the media against racism, poverty pro-independence commemoration known on Sept. 26. As she did, the body of her hus- and war 10 as “El Grito de Lares,” agents of the Federal band was being viewed by thousands of sup- Bureau of Investigation descended on the porters gathered at the Ateneo town of Hormigueros in western Puerto Rico Puertorriqueño (Puerto Rican Literary and fired the shots that killed Puerto Rican lib- Society) and later at the Colegio de Abogados eration hero Filiberto Ojeda Ríos. (College of Attorneys) in San Juan. HURRICANE RITA El Grito de Lares—The Cry of Lares—marks “My husband Filiberto, fearing for my life, Evacuation plan the historic 1868 uprising carried out by peas- urged me to leave,” Rosado said. “He yelled ants and workers against Spanish colonial out to the agents, ‘Someone is coming out, 3 stuck in traffic rule. This rebellion is considered the birth of someone is coming out.’ We kissed and the Puerto Rican nation. hugged. ... When I finally came out of the FBI agents armed with helicopters, military house ..
    [Show full text]
  • Cogjm.Vol-5 Num-2.Pdf (4.524Mb)
    WORDS FROM THE WISE TO OPEN THE WORLD SOCIAL State of FORUM week before the World Economic Forum Disunion convened in Davos to discuss how to further SEE YOU IN THE STREETS A the control of transnational capital over the NUMBER OF NEW ORLEANS world, people from every part of the globe gathered FEBRUARY 2007 VOL. 5 NO. 2 in Nairobi under the banner, “Another World Is RESIDENTS PERCENT OF THOSE Possible” and because of this said Desmond Tutu, that have not returned who have not returned “God is smiling.” after Hurricane Katrina: that are African The World Social Forum began with a march 175,000 American: from Kibera (the largest slum in Africa) to Uhuru 80 A MOMENTMOMENT FROMFROM (peace) Park. Simultaneously, the ecumenical AMOUNT THAT platform was holding a service in front of the LOUISIANA NUMBER OF AN UNSEEN REVOLUTION Anglican, Basilica. Dispelling the capitalist myth was told it owed FEMA ADDITIONAL that greed and competition should be the operating for aid after Hurricanes MILITARY POLICE principles of social order, Archbishop Desmond Katrina and Rita: TROOPS Tutu declared, “We are made for interdependence 3,700,000,000 being sent to New and partnership. Each according to their ability, Orleans: each according to their need. We are made for NUMBER OF US 300 sharing.” HELICOPTERS “There can be no human being who exists on that have been shot NUMBER OF US his own…That we are bound to one another is the down in the last three TROOPS fundamental reality of our being….The only way weeks in Iraq: that have been killed we can ever be free is together.
    [Show full text]
  • October 2007 in This Pa111phlet
    .:/~ . Special Supplement $2 Internationalist Why We Fight for workers strikes Against the war (/) c (1) ~ 0 (Q (Q fill) Defeat U.S. Imperialist War and the Bosses' VVar "At Home"! Break with the Democrats - For a Class-Struggle Workers Party! An Internationalist Group Pamphlet October 2007 In this pa111phlet... Internationalist Group - League for the Fourth International Why We Fight for Workers Strikes Against the War (and the Trotskyism and One of a series of Opportunists Don't) ............................... 3 Internationalist Group Trade-Union Struggle British Antiwar Train Drivers class readings. Stop Arms .............................................. 6 Includes articles from Lenin and Trotsky on Oakland Dock Workers Honor Picket, trade-union struggle, Shut Down War Cargo Shipper ......... 7 articles from The Internationalist, plus a Protest Against Racist Cop Attack series of articles from on Bay Area Longshore Workers ........ 9 the 1970s on Mumia Abu-Jamal: Communist and Trotskyist work in the Beaten on the Docks .......................... 10 trade unions. Internationalist Group Class Readings ILWU Dock Workers Under Attack ....... 11 December 2005 S2 US$2 SL Rejects Calls for Labor Strikes Against Imperialist War Moves ........ 14 Order from/make checks payable to: Mundial Publications, Box 3321, Church Street Station, New York, New York 10008, U.S.A. ILWU: Defense Victory in Neptune Jade Picket Case ................ 17 Visit the League for the Fourth International/ Strike to Defend ILWU Union Gains Under Attack! ....................................... 21 Internationalist Group on the Internet Bush Uses Slave Labor Law Against http://www. internationalist. org West Coast Dock Workers ................. 24 Now available on our site: • Founding Statement of the Mobilize International Labor Action Internationalist Group to Defend the ILWU! ..........................
    [Show full text]
  • Utah Miners Protest Boss Plan to Hire Replacements for Unionists
    AUSTRALIA $1.50 · CANADA $1.50 · FRANCE 1.00 EURO · ICELAND KR100 · NEW ZEALAND $2.00 · SWEDEN KR10 · UK £.50 · U.S. $1.00 INSIDE How Red Army under Stalin's command stood by while Nazis slaughtered Poles — PAGES 6–7 A SOCIALIST NEWSWEEKLY PUBLISHED IN THE INTERESTS OF WORKING PEOPLE VOL. 69/NO. 13 APRIL 4, 2005 Utah miners protest boss plan to Schiavo case: Most oppose hire replacements for unionists gov’t intrusion BY JOEL BRITTON AND GUILLERMO into right ESQUIVEL PRICE, Utah—“Protest the il- legal fi rings by Co-Op mine.” to privacy “We want our jobs back.” BY KARL BUTTS “Kingstons: You can run but TAMPA, Florida—U.S. Congress met you can’t hide.” in an emergency session March 20 to pass “Cockroaches: We know where legislation aimed at determining the medi- your hiding hole is.” cal care of a single individual. Three days “Honk for support!” before the vote, with the demagogic claim These were some of the signs that the aim of the bill was to guarantee that in English and Spanish that Co- a “culture of life must extend to individu- Op miners held up at an informa- als with disabilities,” U.S. president George tional picket line March 23 as coal Bush gave his backing to the legislation, trucks and passenger vehicles titled “A bill to provide for the relief of the drove by on busy Ridge Road a parents of Theresa Marie Schiavo.” few miles south of Price. The measure aims to take the decision- The weather was cold, with making power over the fate of Terri Schiavo, freezing rain giving way to hail, a Florida woman who has been in what and fi nally sunshine as a dozen doctors describe as a “persistent vegetative miners and supporters pressed Militant photos by Terri Moss state” for 15 years, out of the hands of her their case to get their jobs back Miners fi ghting to win UMWA spouse and legal guardian, Michael Schiavo.
    [Show full text]
  • By Wayne Price
    The U.S. Deserves to Lose in Iraq but Should We A New York anarchist takes a long look at the US occupation of Iraq, the resistance to “Support the Iraqi Resistance”? that occupation and where anarchists should focus their energies. Includes a look M A US Anarchist’s Opinion on the Iraqi War M at what the rest of the left is saying and what the historical anarchist position towards wars of national liberation have been M za la B a o b o k a s Z MM “ K “ n ! o e w e l r ed F ge be is the Key to by Wayne Price The U.S. Deserves to Lose in Iraq M Page 28 The U.S. Deserves to Lose in Iraq but Should We “Support the Iraqi Resistance”? M A US Anarchist’s Opinion on the Iraqi War M by Wayne Price Related Link: www.utopianmag.com Front cover graphic by Mike Flugennock from http://sinkers.org/stage/?m=200507 Debate on this text can be found online at: www.anarkismo.net/article/1016 M Zabalaza Books M “Knowledge is the Key to be Free! “ Post: Postnet Suite 47, Private Bag X1, Fordsburg, South Africa, 2033 E-Mail: [email protected] Website: www.zabalaza.net Wayne Price M Page 27 M Anarchists Oppose all Forms of Oppression To most modern anarchists, anarchism is not just against capitalism, but also against all forms of domination and oppression. Capitalism (the capital/labour relationship) does not stand alone. It is intertwined with other forms of oppres- sion: gender, racial, sexual freedom, sexual orientation, age, physical disabilities, ecological, and so on.
    [Show full text]
  • Justice for the Jena 6! Drop the Charges Now!
    · AUSTRALIA $1.50 · CANADA $1.50 · FRANCE 1.00 EURO · NEW ZEALAND $1.50 · SWEDEN KR10 · UK £.50 · U.S. $1.00 INSIDE March on Washington protests Iraq war — PAGE 3 A SOCIALIST NEWSWEEKLY PUBLISHED IN THE INTERESTS OF WORKING PEOPLE VOL. 71/NO. 36 October 1, 2007 Justice for the Jena 6! Minnesota meat packers Drop the charges now! rally to defend union We stand with the thousands march- ing in Jena, Louisiana, and in solidarity NLRB calls decertification election actions across the country on September 20 to demand justice for the Jena Six. These six Black youths face felony charges with possible decades-long prison terms because they stood up to racists who hung nooses at their high school. Far from an “innocent prank,” EDITORIAL nooses are aimed at terrorizing Blacks and anyone else who gets “out of line” in capitalist society. They recall decades Militant/Tom Baumann September 19 picket line outside Dakota Premium Foods preceded rally backing meat of legal and extralegal violence—from packers there defending their union from a company decertification drive. Klan lynchings to cop riots. The harsh prison sentences hang- BY REBECCA WILLIAMSON Premium Foods beef slaughterhouse ing over the heads of the Six are all SOUTH ST. PAUL, Minnesota, here. The plant is organized by the too familiar for millions of working September 16—The National Labor United Food and Commercial Workers Relations Board (NLRB) announced (UFCW) Local 789. The Daily Town Talk/Tia Owens-Powers people caught up in the capitalist “jus- July 31 march through Jena, Louisiana, de- tice” system.
    [Show full text]
  • Cogjm.Vol-5 Num-3.Pdf (2.073Mb)
    PRAEMONITUS PRAEMUNITUS, OR FOREWARNED IS State of FORARMED It’s not very uncommon these days to compare our “modern” culture to George Orwell’s Disunion I dystopian masterpiece “1984”. Indeed there are FREE THE MEDIA many frightening parallels in this post 9/11 world (the NUMBER OF Y EARS mantra of “War is Peace” that seems to be the policy that the Six Nations has NUMBER OF DAYS FEBRUARY 2007 VOL. 5 NO. 3 of our current administration for example). However been functioning as a that independent I would like to bring to your attention another literary democracy: journalist, Josh Wolf, work that may be even more poignant. 900+ has been in Federal “Revolt In 2100” by Robert A. Heinlein consists of costody: one novella and two short stories. The novella “If This PERCENTAGE 186 WELCOME TO THE UNDERGROUND Goes On” is the story of “the Second American OF U.S. HIGH Revolution”. Set in an America where Christian SCHOOLERS MINIMUM NUMBER n the lead up to the American War in Iraq than negative. Although the group has been fascism has a stranglehold on the populace and the who believe news of protesters killed and during the past four years, the anti- organizing anti-war protests lately, their main I war movement has been steadily growing. focus has been counter-recruitment in local country is run by the “Prophet Incarnate”. Non-believ- stories should require so far in the growing ers are referred to as “Pariahs” and summarily execut- “government approval”: confl ict in Guinea: More people are willing to stand up and voice schools.
    [Show full text]
  • No. 850, June 10, 2005
    W(JRKERS IIIINfJlJlIRIJ soc No.SSO ®€Q9u~C'701 • 10 June 200S Occupation of Iraq and the "War on Terror" ies, orlure • • an - - moerla Ism In the year since the Abu Ghraib Thomas Friedman argues to close tortures came to light, one expose down Guantanamo because "I want after another has confirmed that the to win the war on terrorism," adding policies of torture and humiliation that the deaths of over 100 detai­ have come from the top of this gov­ nees in American custody "is not just ernment. The official use of torture deeply immoraL it is strategically extends well beyond Abu Ghraib­ dangerous'-' He concludes his col­ into other prisons in Iraq. Afghani­ umn by quoting the executive direc­ ,tan and the notorious concentration tor of Human Rights First: "If we camp in GuanUinamo Bay. Cuba. are going to transform the Middle where some 500 prisoners continue East, we have to be law-abiding and to be held with('c:t charge or trial. uphold the values we want them to The line of the Bush administration embrace-otherwise it is not going to ha~ been to deny every new report work'-' Meanwhile. in its recent report that comes out documenting more on Guantanamo. Amnesty Interna­ torture and brutality. When Amnesty tionaL too, is concerned that "the rule fnternational released its report last of law. and the:efore, ultimately_ month condemning the U.S. for its security. is heing undcrmincd. a.' j" mass detentions, torture, disappear­ any moral credibility the USA claims ances and elimination of the right to to have in seeking to advance human trial
    [Show full text]
  • The Richmond FREE
    I n t h e FREE S p i r i t o f G a b r i e l , N a n , N a t T u r n e r, The Richmond J o h n B r o w n , M a r y B o w s e r, E l i z a b e t h Va n L e w & John Mitchell Jr. Bimonthly Newspaper ofEFENDER The Richmond Defenders for Freedom, Justice & Equality Vol. 4, No. D4, Issue 28 Circulation: 16,000 copies July - August 2008 Nat’l anti-war forces unite to demand ... ‘NO WAR ON IRAN!’ Special to the Defender Representatives from a broad range of major anti-war coalitions, which in the past have national and regional anti-war coalitions and local not always worked together. These included Act organizations have issued a strong condemnation Now to Stop War & End Racism (A.N.S.W.E.R), of any military attack, sanctions or internal Troops Out Now Coalition (TONC), United for interference in Iran. Peace and Justice (UFPJ) and U.S. Labor Against In additon, several organizations are calling the War (USLAW). Dozens of statewide and for intensifying protests to press the issue. local networks were also represented. Responding to a call by Rostam Pourzal, U.S. the newly formed National president of CASMII, and Assembly to End the Iraq Defenders Phil Wilayto, editor of War and Occupation, more The Richmond Defender than 400 anti-war activists endorse call for and organizer of the gathered June 28 and 29 in 2007 People’s Peace Cleveland, Ohio.
    [Show full text]
  • Immigrants from Impact on the March, Which Made This a a Union Contract
    workers.org Workers and oppressed peoples of the world unite! MARCH 1, 2007 VOL. 49, NO. 8 50¢ February protests show Bush aumenta Struggle heats up amenazas contra Irán 12 • vs. Iraq war funding By Monica Moorehead WW COMMENTARY: New York INTERNATIONAL Congress could stop the war 9 The struggle from below to force Congress to vote NO on any WORKING additional funding for the racist occupation of and war on Iraq got Katrina survivors; stop the war at home—stop racist police ter- WOMEN a tremendous shot in the arm this past week with numerous anti- ror—stop ICE [Immigration and Customs Enforcement] raids; war protests organized across the U.S. From the West Coast to military recruiters out of our schools and communities and no • Immigrant fight-back then the East Coast, thousands of people and especially students took draft—education, not war.” to the streets to demand, “Cut off war funding now and bring the and now 5 Chapel Hill, N.C. troops home.” th • Stop execution The Feb. 15-17 protests sent a clear message that there is growing On Feb. 16, while Rep. David Price (4 District-N.C.) was of Iraqi women 9 mass awareness that Congress cannot be counted on as a whole to on the floor of the House debating a meaningless nonbinding stop the Bush administration’s objective of staying in Iraq for an resolution, six youth were sitting in on the floor of his office, • Campaign for indefinite amount of time—even after the Nov. 7 elections, which demanding that the funds for the war on Iraq be cut off and that the people’s needs start being met.
    [Show full text]