Fall 2010 Issue
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Notes from the Editor Welcome to another issue of Diplomacy World. This time, is that Diplomacy World needs more face-to-face was one of those issues where I didn’t seem to have any material. One person even suggested we dedicate real direction. I did my usual job of bugging people, space to particular clubs or tournaments in each issue. begging for articles and material…and it seemed to That isn’t really necessary; the fact is, if you run a game work. But there wasn’t any particular focus to my at your house and want to write about it, send it in! I’ve actions; in some ways I was simply going through the been begging people to write about their ftf experiences, motions. I think the issue came out rather well anyway, whether it's about international conventions or simple but it does concern me to feel less enthusiasm for my house games. Likewise, if you have an internet site work as Lead Editor. Hopefully it is just a passing where you play Diplomacy and want to write something phase. If not…well, then it will be time to begin giving about that, feel free to do so. There’s no need to serious consideration to looking for a successor. dedicate particular space for each club or website…we’ll just deal with that we receive on a per-issue basis. We are making a few changes with Diplomacy World. The biggest of those is that we are dropping the idea of One other comment I noticed on a few surveys is that planned theme issues, at least on a regular basis. Diplomacy World is simply too long. One person Perhaps we’ll schedule a theme issue once every three mentioned they are hesitant to submit any articles or four issues, but the idea has run out of steam. At first because they think with issues being so big, nobody will the themes seemed to inspire some new contributors to read it. If you take the other surveys as a guide, nothing submit something. Now it has reached the point where it could be further from the truth. So many responders is a problem finding ANY material that fits the theme. I’d mention they read every single page…so don’t be rather people write about what they WANT to write intimidated! But when it comes to length, it is true that about…so after the next two themes have been used, the last few issues have been quite long. The Known the idea will be tossed by the wayside. Back in my first World Demo Game has been a primary factor, but that stint as Lead Editor, I’d decide what the cover story section is coming to a close this issue, which should should be very close to the deadline, based on what I lighten the load quite a bit. had on hand and what I enjoyed personally. In the post- postal age, I don’t even know if that is necessary. Another comment that appeared on some survey was Nemanja Simic has been designing colorful and often the idea that Diplomacy World should actually come humorous covers for us, and I am sure he can continue out more frequently, either 6 times or 12 times a year. to do so without a theme or a “cover story” to guide him. While I’d like to accommodate all the ideas and Since each issue contains a wide variety of material, I requests, that one is simply not going to happen…not don’t see a reason to focus on one article over another. while I am Lead Editor, at any rate. Quarterly issues are about all I can handle, and almost every issue the This leads me (sort of) to the results of the Diplomacy majority of material arrives in the two to three weeks World Survey that appeared in last issue. I had hoped prior to the deadline. Back when Diplomacy World for more responses, but in truth we received nearly 40. started under Walter Buchanan, I believe it came out As a percentage of the number of times Diplomacy every two months. But that isn’t something you can World is downloaded per issue, that’s miniscule. But expect any time in the near future. Quarterly issues compared to other reader-participation ideas I’ve tried have been the standard for quite some time, and that’s over the last few years, it’s a veritable landslide. So I’ll the way it will stay. gladly look at that glass as half full. Thanks to all of you who took the time and trouble to I can’t say I was surprised by the survey results. The submit a survey. And I am happy to report that the Dirk general consensus from the Diplomacy World Knemeyer was randomly selected as the prize winner. I readership is: there isn’t a general consensus. Most of really appreciate all the feedback, folks! you really enjoy the Strategy & Tactics articles, but a small group of respondents list them as least favorite I’ll close by reminding you the next deadline for (mostly long-time hobby members). Others are devout Diplomacy World submissions is January 1st, 2011. variant fans, while some listed variant material as Remember, besides articles (which are always prized basically useless to them. Clearly, we have a wide and appreciated), we LOVE to get letters, feedback, range of readers, with a similar wide range of interests. input, ideas, and suggestions too. So email me at [email protected]! See you in the New Year, I did learn a few things which were interesting. One, and happy stabbing! which those of us on staff have been saying for some Diplomacy World #111 – Fall 2010 -Page2 Diplomacy World Staff: Managing Lead Editor: Douglas Kent, Email: diplomacyworld of yahoo.com Co-Editor: Jim Burgess, Email: burgess of world.std.com Strategy & Tactics Editor: Joshua Danker-Dake, Email: jadddiplomacy of gmail.com Variant Editor: Jack McHugh, Email: jwmchughjr of gmail.com Interview Editor: Jim Burgess, Email: burgess of world.std.com Club and Tournament Editor: Vacant Demo Game Editor: Rick Desper, Email: rick_desper of yahoo.com Technology Editor: Chris Babcock, Email cbabcock of asciiking.com Original Artwork Nemanja Simic, Email: nemanja.painter of gmail.com Contributors in 2010: Chris Babcock, John Biehl, Jim Burgess, Suzanne Castagne, Steve Cooley, Larry Cronin, Joshua Danker-Dake, Rick Desper, Tom Droeshout, Greg Duenow, The Gamemaster, Richard Hannon, Toby Harris, Hyrum Hibbert, Not Jon Hill, Bobby Hinkle, David Hood, Andy Hull, Zachary Jarvie, Kit Jillings, Dirk Knemeyer, Kestas Kuliukas, John Kyker, Jeremie Lefrancois, Gwen Maggi, Richard Maltz, Chris Martin, Alex Maslow, Bill McCullam, Jack McHugh, Patrick McManus, Peter McNamara, Ricardo Moraes, Alfred Nicol, Jim O’Kelley, Hugh Polley, Lewis Pulsipher, Chris Sham, Matt Shields, Michael Sims, Adam Silverman, Nemanja Simic, Adam Silverman, Dave Simpson, Mark Stretch, Richard Walkerdine, Stacey Williams, Conrad Woodring. Add your name to the 2010 list by submitting something for the next issue! Contributions are welcomed and will earn you accolades and infinite thanks. Persons interested in the vacant staff positions may contact the managing editor for details or to submit their candidacy or both. The same goes for anyone interested in becoming a columnist or senior writer. Diplomacy is a game invented by Allan Calhamer. It is currently manufactured by Hasbro and the name is their trademark with all rights reserved. Themes for Upcoming Diplomacy World Issues: Diplomacy World #112: Russia – Surviving War on Multiple Fronts Deadline for #112 Submissions – Jan. 1, 2011 Diplomacy World #113: Using Social Networks in Diplomacy Deadline for #113 Submissions – Apr. 1, 2011 Diplomacy World #111 – Fall 2010 -Page3 In This Issue: Editorial: Notes from the Editor by Douglas Kent Page 2 Convention Report: The Top Board at World DipCon by Peter McNamara Page 5 Strategy & Tactics: Playing Two Countries by Mark Stretch Page 6 Theme Article: Press in Internet Diplomacy by Joshua Danker-Dake Page 7 Humor: Late Arrivals at the Diplomacy Players’ Ball by Richard Walkerdine Page 8 Game Review: Olympia: Large Scale Fantasy War Gaming – For Free by Tom Droeshout Page 9 Tournament Report: 3rd Annual DiplomaticCorp Winter Blitz! By Dirk Knemeyer Page 11 Cartoon: Above Board by Zachary Jarvie Page 16 Feature: The Epistemology of Strategy by Richard Maltz Page 17 Feature: Commentary on “The Epistemology of Strategy by Richard Maltz” by Jim Burgess Page 21 Demo Game: Diplomacy World Demo Game – “Rotary Phones & 8-Track Tapes” 1902 Results Page 24 Hobby History: El Conquistador by Bill McCullum Page 45 Convention News: Selected Upcoming Conventions Page 45 Theme Article: In Praise of Internet Diplomacy by Joshua Danker-Dake Page 46 Convention Report: World DipCon by Toby Harris Page 47 Convention Ad: World DipCon XXI Ad Page 48 Feature: Discovering Diplomacy by Peter McManus Page 49 Convention Report: My World DipCon 2010 Journey by Dave Simpson Page 50 Club Report: Rise of the Weasels by Jim O’Kelley Page 53 Convention Report: Trip to the World Diplomacy Championships by Conrad Woodring Page 58 Feature: Your Star Signs and Diplomacy by Richard Walkerdine Page 63 Convention Report: Den Haag, August 19th-22nd: A Time for the Brave by Gwen Maggi Page 66 Variants: Fantasy World Diplomacy Rules and Map by John Biehl Page 72 Hobby Service: Ask the GM – An Advice Column for Diplomacy World by “Game Master” Page 74 Feedback: Knives and Daggers – the Diplomacy World Letter Column Page 74 Demo Game: Diplomacy World “Known World” Variant Demo Game – Game Years 915 through 919, Plus End of Game Statements from all Players and Commentators Page 75 Diplomacy World #111 – Fall 2010 -Page4 The Top Board at World DipCon By Peter McNamara (Photos by Laurent Joly) There is a saying in poker that goes along the lines of "If, me to regain sole control of Marseilles and Iberia, and after the first twenty minutes, you don't know who the propelled Gwen's Germany to outright favoritism, with sucker at the table is, it's you." Well this saying holds the most likely challengers appearing to be Fabian and true in Diplomacy too, as I discovered on the top board Frank in Italy and Austria respectively.