Epigenetics Meets Metabolism Through PHB-Mediated Histone H3.3 Deposition by HIRA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Editorial Page 1 of 5 Epigenetics meets metabolism through PHB-mediated histone H3.3 deposition by HIRA Ronen Marmorstein1, Peter D. Adams2 1Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, the Abramson Family Cancer Research Institute, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA; 2Tumor Initiation and Maintenance Program, Sanford Burnham Prebys Medical Discovery Institute, La Jolla, CA, USA Correspondence to: Ronen Marmorstein. Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, the Abramson Family Cancer Research Institute, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA. Email: [email protected]. Provenance: This is an invited Editorial commissioned by Editor-in-Chief Zhizhuang Joe Zhao (Pathology Graduate Program, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, USA). Comment on: Zhu Z, Li C, Zeng Y, et al. PHB Associates with the HIRA Complex to Control an Epigenetic-Metabolic Circuit in Human ESCs. Cell Stem Cell 2017;20:274-89.e7. Received: 16 April 2017; Accepted: 25 April 2017; Published: 26 May 2017. doi: 10.21037/sci.2017.05.08 View this article at: http://dx.doi.org/10.21037/sci.2017.05.08 The regulation of chromatin, the histone-mediated pluripotency/self-renewal factors in human embryonic packaged form of DNA in the eukaryotic nucleus, underlies stem cells (hESCs), leading to the identification of the epigenetic control of gene expression (1). Epigenetic prohibitin (PHB) as one such factor (Figure 1). PHB is an regulators include DNA and histone modifying enzymes, evolutionarily conserved and ubiquitous expressed protein proteins that specifically target native or modified DNA that has previously been implicated in mitochondrial and histones, non-coding RNA molecules and histone function and morphology, cell signaling and transcriptional chaperone and ATP-dependent remodeling complexes regulation (6). To validate the importance of PHB as a that deposit, move or evict canonical or variant histones. pluripotency factor in hESCs, Zhu et al. observed that While the mode of chromatin targeting of many epigenetic PHB expression was high in undifferentiated hESCs and factors has been delineated (2), the mechanism of histone showed that PHB knock down (KD) induced extensive chaperone complex recruitment for specific histone differentiation in hESCs. A global gene expression analysis deposition is not understood. One such histone chaperone of a PHB KD in hESCs revealed that upregulated genes complex contains the proteins HIRA, Ubinuclein-1 (UBN1), are associated with cell differentiation and organismal CABIN1 and transiently associated ASF1 to deposit the development, while down-regulated genes are associated histone H3.3 variant at the promoters of active and poised with gene ontology terms chromatin modification, glucose genes, bodies of active genes, developmental genes, active metabolism and RNA processing, together suggesting that enhancers and sites of DNA and chromatin damage and PHB might mediate self-renewal through maintaining repair (3) (Figure 1). A recent study demonstrates that the hESC chromatin landscape and metabolic state. The the single stranded DNA-binding protein replication connection of PHB to chromatin regulation was reinforced protein A (RPA) cooperates with the HIRA complex to by the finding that, compared to control cells, PHB KD deposit newly synthesized H3.3 during the G1 phase of hESCs had higher levels of mono-, di-, and tri-methylated the cell cycle at gene transcription regulatory elements (4) histone 3 lysine 4 (H3K4), histone 3 lysine 27 (H3K27) as (Figure 1). However, how HIRA mediates H3.3 deposition well as tri-methylated histone 3 lysine 9 (H3K9) and histone independent of the cell cycle remained unknown. A recent 3 lysine 36 (H3K36). report by Zhu et al. sheds some light on this area (5). To understand more about the molecular function of Zhu et al. carried out a genome-wide siRNA screen for PHB, Zhu et al. searched for associated proteins through © Stem Cell Investigation. All rights reserved. sci.amegroups.com Stem Cell Investig 2017;4:46 Page 2 of 5 Stem Cell Investigation, 2017 H3.3 dep. at pluripotency and key metabolic genes including IDH PHB RPA PRC2 H3.3 H3.3 dep. at H3.3 dep. HIRA Complex developmentally regulated poised during G1 H4 genes ??? H3.3 dep. at promoters, enhancers, gene bodies and sites of repair Figure 1 HIRA-mediated histone H3.3 deposition pathways. An illustration of the different modes of HIRA complex-mediated histone H3.3/H4 deposition (dep.). The four pathways are not necessarily mutually exclusive. PHB, prohibitin; RPA, replication protein A. immunoprecipitation and mass spectrometry, leading to fate (7). One example of this is the metabolite α-ketoglutarate the identification of HIRA as an associated factor. This (α-KG), a TCA cycle intermediate generated by isocitrate interaction was validated through co-immunoprecipitation dehydrogenases (IDHs) (8). α-KG is also an essential (co-IP) experiments and subsequently mapped, through cofactor of dioxygenases, such as jumonji (JMJ) family deletion analysis to primarily an N-terminal WD40 histone demethylases (9) and ten-eleven translocation (TET) repeat of HIRA and a central conserved PHB domain of family methylated DNA hydroxylases (10). While the TET PHB. Interaction of these two proteins was subsequently enzymes can mediate one or more steps in a multi-step DNA demonstrated with recombinant proteins, thus implicating a demethylation process, at least some of the JMJ enzymes are direct interaction. bona fide histone demethylases. Given that HIRA forms a complex with UBN1 and Given that the elevated histone methylation phenotype CABIN1, the authors asked if PHB could interact with induced by PHB or HIRA KD in hESCs resembled the these other subunits of the HIRA complex. As expected, histone methylation alterations observed with IDH1 the authors found that PHB could co-IP each of the HIRA mutations and reduced α-KG production, Zhu et al. asked complex subunits from HEK293T cells. Moreover, gel whether disruption of the PHB and HIRA complexes could filtration analysis indicated that PHB and each of the HIRA affect the IDH/α-KG metabolic pathway. They found that complex subunits and H3.3 coexist in the same gel filtration PHB or HIRA KD in hESCs decreased IDH and α-KG fraction. PHB was also found in HIRA free fractions, levels, and that the levels of α-KG correlated inversely with suggesting that a proportion of PHB exists unbound to the same methylated histones after KD of PHB and HIRA HIRA. To validate the functional importance of the PHB/ levels in hESCs. Taken together, this data links PHB and HIRA complex interaction in expression of pluripotency the HIRA histone chaperone complex to the expression genes in hESC, Zhu et al. demonstrated that, like PHB KD, of IDH genes and hence production of α-KG and histone HIRA−/− hESCs displayed a differentiated cell morphology demethylation (Figure 1). and had reduced expression levels of core pluripotency To understand how PHB and HIRA are functionally factors, with concomitant upregulation of various lineage connected to IDH gene expression and thus α-KG levels, marker genes, and exhibited the same perturbed histone Zhu et al. carried out genome wide H3.3 ChIP-seq in modification patterns as thePHB KD. hESCs stably expressing H3.3B-HA treated with NT Metabolic states of the cell have been shown to impact (control), PHB, or HIRA siRNA. As anticipated, they found the role of epigenetic mechanisms in determining stem cell that H3.3 is selectively enriched at transcriptionally active © Stem Cell Investigation. All rights reserved. sci.amegroups.com Stem Cell Investig 2017;4:46 Stem Cell Investigation, 2017 Page 3 of 5 genes over less active genes. In addition, KD of PHB or chromatin dynamics in non-proliferating senescent cells (12). HIRA reduced H3.3 levels at active genes. Bioinformatics The important role of HIRA in contributing to the analysis of the H3.3 regions with >1.5 reduction of ChIP- maintenance of both senescence and hESCs through histone seq reads in both PHB and HIRA KD cells indicated that H3.3 deposition implicates a broader role of the HIRA these regions were enriched at genes involved in cellular histone chaperone complex and the histone H3.3 histone metabolic processes, the cell cycle, chromatin binding, and variant in maintaining cell identity. Consistent with this, Allis transcription regulation. Subsequent ChIP-seq of PHB and and coworkers previously revealed a role for HIRA in lineage HIRA demonstrated that these proteins were simultaneously determination in ESCs (13). recruited to IDH genes, as well as other pluripotency and The mechanism for how PHB contributes to HIRA- development-associated genes in hESCs, such as OCT4 and mediated histone H3.3 deposition is not clear. The studies NANOG (11). Moreover, KD of PHB and HIRA decreased by Zhu et al. demonstrate that HIRA and PHB directly H3.3 deposition at all these genes, and decreased the active interact. Given that PHB has been shown to interact transcription markers H3K4me3, RNA polymerase II S5P with DNA-binding transcription factors such as nuclear and elongation RNA polymerase II S2P. This data links receptors (14,15), it is possible that it might mediate the PHB to HIRA-mediated H3.3 deposition to activation of recruitment of the HIRA histone chaperone complex to transcription of IDH genes to produce α-KG, a cofactor for specific chromatin regions for histone H3.3 deposition. histone demethylation. Gel filtration analysis of proteins from hESC cells reveals To further investigate the temporal relationship between a fraction that contains PHB and each of the components PHB function, the epigenetic-metabolic circuitry and of the HIRA complex and histone H3.3. However, the hESC identify, Zhu et al. characterized PHB-depleted elution pattern of each of the proteins does not precisely hESC cells from 0 to 4 days. These studies suggested that a co-migrate, suggesting that both HIRA and PHB are also reduction of HIRA complex components could be the first part of other complexes.