DOCSLIB.ORG

Download Download

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Download Download NARRATIVES The Story of Linda and Peter Biehl: Private Loss and Public Forgiveness Representing our daughter, Amy, we participated and gave testimony at the amnesty hearing for the four young men who murdered her. Recognizing the role of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa's healing process, we did not oppose the Amnesty Committee's decision to grant them their freedom. YJe believe, as did our daughter, in the importance of democratic elec- tions in South Africa. The amnesty hearings were hut one condition in making them a reality. V^e grieve our loss, yet forgiveness has freed us. We can honor our daughter, we can remain true to her convictions, and we can carry on her work. Our narrative describes and explains our experience, the media and others' response to our decisions, and the meaning this has had to us and the members of our family: Kim, 31; Molly, 27; and Zach, 20. by Prologue search each event for the ironies, Peter and Linda Biehl but the fax arrived from Cape e had expected the letter. Town on April 22nd: one day af- Peter and Linda Biehl, WErom the day Amy's kill- ter Linda's birthday and four the Amy Biehl Foundation. ers were sentenced to eighteen days before what might have years in prison for murder and been Amy's thirtieth. But irony public violence, we had known was quickly lost in the plain real- amnesty applications were ity of the words. Below is the let- probable. ter-fax from the Amnesty Com- Still, the timing of the let- mittee of South Africa's truth and ter was interesting. Perhaps we Reconciliation Commission. Tel:(0Z1 ) 24 5161 Fa>:(021 > 23 32BO AHIHiSTYCOHimiTTU o PO Box 3162 Dear Mr and Mrs P. Biehl Cape Town o The Amnesty Committee of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission has received an application for amnesty from Mongesi Manquina in respect of the o murder of your daughter, Amy BiehL o The hearing will commence in the week of 19 May 1997 to 25 May 1997 in Cape Town. We are hereby informing of such dates to enable us to o accommodate you should you wish to attend the hearing. Kindly advise us urgently as to a date suitable to youselves within the aforementioned week to o facilitate the necessary arrangements. o You shall be formally notiñed once we have heard from you by retum facsimile. o We look forward to hearing from you. o With our kind wishes hereby extended. o Yours sincerely, o ROBIN BRINK EVIDENCE LEADER REFLECTIONS: FALL 1998 11 PRIVATE LOSS AND PUBLIC FORGIVENESS NARRATIVES We knew Manquina's rected crimes was essential to ews of the hearing sched- application would be joined by the pro-apartheid regime before Nule spread quickly. So did the other three. That was a fore- it could open the ballot boxes to our indication to the Amnesty gone conclusion. But the others the certainty of Black majority Committee that we would not had until May 10,1997, in which rule. retain legal counsel or oppose to apply. That was the official Amy had said that Nel- amnesty, if granted. cut-off date for amnesty appli- son Mandela and his African Media representatives cations. National Congress (ANC) col- from South Africa and through- We were advised by John leagues had refused to accept a out the United States began tele- Allen of Archbishop Tutu's of- blanket amnesty provision and phoning us with their inevitable fice that the four applicants had compromised on case-by- inquiries. On a small scale, it would present themselves in a case amnesty, earned on the was reminiscent of the media single hearing. Given the imme- merits of the evidence present- blitz in the early hours and days diate proximity of the proposed ed, against a rigorous standard following Amy's death. May 19th hearing week, counsel for proof. Always, the questions: for the applicants could easily "... but, aren't you angry?" or appear and request a post- "... you mean you are pre- ponement to provide ade- pared to forgive your quate preparation time. We daughter's killers?" It re- could make a very long and minded Linda of the days in expensive trip for nothing. 1993 when producers from This seemed unreasonable the television tabloid news and unfair. "magazines" and popular Upon consideration of "talk" shows would tele- our request that the hearing phone her looking for an in- be re-scheduled to coincide dication that she might like with our planned visit to Cape to appear on camera and get Town in late June and July, the "mad." Linda was always so Amnesty Committee agreed to Given this background calm, rational, and unsensa- re-set the hearing for July 8-9, insight and Amy's passionate tional that the producers or 1997. We were thankful to be efforts to gain free and demo- "talent" people never called spared the expense and proba- cratic elections for all South Af- back. ble frustration of an early trip ricans, we could not ignore the Once again, we succeed- and were grateful for some ad- Amnesty Committee process. ed in boring the reporters with ditional time in which to pre- Our failure to appear and par- our peaceful resolve in our de- pare our statement for the hear- ticipate in the hearing could be cision not to oppose the amnes- ing. interpreted as displaying a lack ty applications from Amy's kill- There was no question of of respect for a healing process, ers. Generally, the reporters our participation in the hearing. honorably negotiated and now were not equipped with back- Amy had informed us four years publicly and unequivocally grounds which would enable earlier that the Truth and Rec- championed by President them to understand our posi- onciliation process was a key Mandella, Archbishop Tutu and tion. So they covered the story pre-negotiated condition upon other respected South Africans. and went on to the next one. which free elections for all South We knew we must partic- The Houston Chronicle, Africans could be granted by the ipate in the process and, believ- however, sent South African re- National Party—in power at the ing in it, that we could not op- porter Tony Freemantle, who time. More importantly, a pro- pose amnesty if it were granted had written an award-winning cedure for granting of amnesty on the merits. We were certain feature piece on truth commis- in forgiveness of politically di- Amy would concur. sions in 1996. Tony spent an 12 REFLECTIONS: FALL 1998 PRIVATE LOSS AND PUBLIC FORGIVENESS NARRATIVES entire day with us in our home. We kept telling ourselves Amy had prepared us for He understood our attitude and that we would prepare a writ- this. On the subject of black vi- the basis for it-although he con- ten statement for presentation at olence against White South Af- ceded that he might not be ca- the amnesty hearing. We want- ricans, Amy repeatedly admon- pable of it, himself. His front- ed to be certain of our word ished us to remember that the page piece for the Chronicle ran choice. Every word must be just frustrated and angry Black on Sunday, May 11th—one day right. youth "... are only doing what after the cut-off date for amnes- Former Ambassador, Princeton has been done to them by gen- ty applications to South Africa's Lyman, who had officially in- erations of white oppressors." Truth and Reconciliation Com- formed Linda of Amy's death Moreover, Amy's admo- mission. It was also Mother's from Pretoria in 1993, volun- nition that ".. .when Black South Day (irony again), but Linda teered to review and comment Africans die in the struggle, only didn't seem to notice. on our prepared statement be- numbers are reported—but Freemantle's piece was fore our departure. He never when white people die, they get informed and insightful. People had the opportunity to be of ser- complete obituaries with names, told us they found it helpful in vice. families, pets, and everything," understanding our position be- When we boarded our was ringing in our ears. cause it was placed in a well-re- flight on June 26, we had no Her dismay at this indig- searched context. This is testi- written statement. nity had been prophetic in the mony to the utility of good jour- case of her own death in South nalism. e knew our feelings— Africa's struggle. We knew how W what was in our hearts Amy would feel about the me- ur preparation for Cape and in our heads. dia blitz which had followed her O Town really centered In so many ways, we had death. After all, she had confid- around our desire to arrange a been prepared for this event. ed to friends that—in the event meaningful experience for the For years, we had taken our kids of her death—she wanted the Kendall family of St. Louis, who to Sunday school. For years, we same impersonal press treat- would be traveling with us for had taught Sunday school class- ment accorded her Black col- the first ten days of the trip. The es in Christian ethics. Standing leagues in the struggle. Kendalls have become very im- at the kitchen telephone, mo- So... prepared by our portant in the educational out- ments after learning of Amy's own personal background expe- reach activities of the Amy death, Linda recalls fielding a riences and by our daughter's Biehl Foundation in the United constant stream of telephone words in the years and days be- States and—on their first visit to calls and visitors thinking the fore her death, there were never South Africa—we wanted them words, "Father, forgive them, any questions about our posi- to experience vividly the joys for they know not what they tion.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Leaders in Grassroots Organizations
    Crossing Boundaries: Bridging the Racial Divide – South Africa Taught by Rev. Edwin and Organized by Melikaya Ntshingwa COURSE DESCRIPTION This is a contextual theology course based on the South African experience of apartheid, liberation and transformation, or in the terms of our course: theological discourses from South Africa on “bridging the racial divide”. The course has developed over years – its origins go back to the Desmond Tutu Peace Centre of which the course founder, Dr Judy Mayotte was a Board member. We will look first at the South African experience of Apartheid and try to understand how it was that Christians came to develop such a patently evil form of governance as was Apartheid. We will explore several themes that relate to Apartheid, such as origins, identity, experience, struggle and separation. Then you will have a chance to examine your own theology, where it comes from and how you arrived at your current theological position. In this regard the course also contains sources that deal with Catholic approaches to identity and race. Together we shall then explore issues relating to your own genesis, identity, experience, struggle and separation – all issues common to humankind! All of this we will do by seeking to answer various questions. Each question leads to discussion in class and provides the basis for the work you will be required to do. In the course we examine the nature of separateness (apartheid being an ideology based on a theology of separateness). We will explore the origins of separateness and see how it effects even ourselves at a most basic and elementary level.
    [Show full text]
  • Plant a Tree
    ADDRESS BY THE MINISTER OF WATER AFFAIRS & FORESTRY, RONNIE KASRILS, AT A TREE PLANTING IN MEMORY OF THE MURDER OF THE GUGULETHU SEVEN & AMY BIEHL Arbor Day, Gugulethu, 31st August 1999 I am very honoured to have this opportunity to greet you all. And today I want to extend a special message to all of you who experienced the terrible events that happened here in Gugulethu in the apartheid years. And also, after the disaster that struck early on Sunday morning, the great losses you are suffering now. I am here today in memory and in tribute of all the people of Gugulethu. I salute the courage you have shown over the years. And I want to express my deep sympathy and concern for the plight of those who have lost their family and friends, their homes and their property in the last few days. This commemoration has been dedicated to eight people. Eight people who were senselessly slaughtered right here in this historical community. The first event took place at about 7.30 in the morning on 3 March 1986 when seven young men were shot dead at the corner of NY1 and NY111 and in a field nearby. There names were Mandla Simon Mxinwa, Zanisile Zenith Mjobo, Zola Alfred Swelani, Godfrey Miya, Christopher Piet, Themba Mlifi and Zabonke John Konile. All seven were shot in the head and suffered numerous other gunshot wounds. Every one here knows the story of how they were set up by askaris and drove into a police trap. Just seven and a half years later, on 25 August 1993, Amy Elizabeth Biehl drove into Gugulethu to drop off some friends.
    [Show full text]
  • The Promise of Forgiveness Inner Healing Is a Path to Social Revolution
    RESTORATIVE JUSTICE The Promise of Forgiveness Inner Healing is a Path to Social Revolution Sarah Elizabeth Clark would she ever want to? Why does this move and inspire us? What can we learn from this amazing story and from welve years ago, near Cape Town, South Africa, four others like it? T South African men, Easy Nofemela, Ntobeko Peni, The process of forgiveness is not merely sentimental, it and two others, murdered Amy Biehl, a white American is extremely transformative. It is transformative because it Fulbright scholar. When South Africa’s Truth and creates a new relationship between the perpetrator and Reconciliation Commission granted the men amnesty for the victim. Through the act of forgiveness, an individual is their crime in 1998, Amy Biehl’s parents supported the able to overcome his or her victimhood, feel empathy for decision. their ‘enemy,’ and ultimately re- Linda Biehl, Amy’s mother, humanize the person who did wrote in an article called “Forgiveness is not just an occasional them wrong. As we will also “Making Change” in the Fall act; it is a permanent attitude.” see, the act of forgiveness on 2004 issue of Greater Good -Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. community, national and inter- magazine, “Easy and Ntobeko national levels can even pro- needed to confess and tell the mote a new political world truth in order to receive amnesty, and there was a genuine order based on cooperation and dialogue, rather than quality to their testimony. I had to get outside of myself threat and violence. and realize that these people lived in an environment that I’m not sure I could have survived in.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Long Night's Journey Into Day: South Africa's Search for Truth and Reconciliation'
    H-SAfrica Klausen on , 'Long Night's Journey Into Day: South Africa's Search for Truth and Reconciliation' Review published on Tuesday, January 1, 2002 Long Night's Journey Into Day: South Africa's Search for Truth and Reconciliation. Iris Films. Reviewed by Susanne Klausen Published on H-SAfrica (January, 2002) [editor's note: H-SAfrica is pleased to present this review essay from Susanne Klausen, whose critique comes from the perspectives both of a historian of South Africa and a documentary film producer (she is co-producer, with Don Gill, of the documentary 'The Plywood Girls,' (1999).--P.L.] <p> <cite>Long Night's Journey Into Day</cite> is a film documentary about the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC or Commission). The TRC was established in 1995 by the country's first democratically elected Parliament. According to former Justice Minister Dullah Omar, who introduced the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act (1995) that created the Commission, the TRC was envisaged as part of the bridge-building process designed to help lead the nation away from a deeply divided past to "a future founded on the recognition of human rights, democracy and peaceful co-existence."[1] Its overarching mandate was to promote national unity and reconciliation. In order to fulfill it, the TRC set out to uncover "as complete a picture as possible" of the gross human rights violations committed between 1960 and 1994 (from the Sharpeville Massacre to the election of the first democratic government), in the belief that telling the truth about the violations from the various perspectives of those involved would lead to greater understanding and reconciliation between South Africans.
    [Show full text]
  • Findings and Recommendations
    Vo l u m e SIX • S e c t i o n FIVE • C h ap t e r ONE Findings and Recommendations THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK WITHIN WHICH THE COMMISSION MADE FINDINGS IN THE CONTEXT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW Vo l u m e SIX S e c t i o n FIVE C h ap t e r O N E Legal Framework THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK WITHIN WHICH THE COMMISSION MADE FINDINGS WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF CURRENT I N T E R N ATIONAL LAW ■ I N V E S T I G ATING GROSS HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLAT I O N S 1. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (the Commission) was charged with the task of investigating and documenting gross violations of human rights committed during the period March 1960 to May 1994. In the course of doing so, it was re q u i red to compile as complete a picture as possible of the conflicts of the past. DEFINING GROSS HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLAT I O N S 2. The Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act No. 34 of 1995, (the Act) defined a gross human rights violation as: the violation of human rights through (a) the killing, abduction, torture or severe i l l - t reatment of any person; or (b) any attempt, conspiracy, incitement, instigation, command or procurement to commit an act re f e r red to in paragraph (a), which emanated from conflicts of the past and which was committed during the period 1 March 1960 to the cut-off date [10 May 1994] within or outside the Republic, and the commission of which was advised, planned, directed, commanded or o r d e red, by any person acting with a political motive;1 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Bonhoeffer and Costly Reconciliation in South Africa – Through the Lens of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission3 P.G.J
    Chapter 2 Bonhoeffer and costly reconciliation in South Africa – through the lens of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission3 P.G.J. (Piet) Meiring Emeritus Professor, Faculty of Theology University of Pretoria South Africa Introduction: ‘And the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Prize goes to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission!’ It was a day to remember, the 25th of April 1999. In the French Cathedral, in Berlin, former Archbishop Desmond Tutu, chairman of the South African Truth and How to cite: Meiring, P.G.J., 2017, ‘Bonhoeffer and costly reconciliation in South Africa – through the lens of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission’, in ‘Ecodomy – Life in its fullness’, Verbum et Ecclesia, suppl. 1, 38(3), a1559. https://doi.org/10.4102/ve.v38i3.1559 3. See Meiring (2015). 18 Chapter 2 Reconciliation Commission (TRC) and Dr Alex Boraine, deputy chair, were given a resounding applause when the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Prize was handed to them. In the award document, it was stated that ’the Commission has courageously and energetically supported the process of finding out the truth and made forgiveness possible’ (Evangelical Church in Germany [EKD] 1999:1). The former General-Secretary of the World Council of Churches (WCC), Philip Potter, praised the achievements of Desmond Tutu and his colleagues during the difficult period of changeover from the apartheid system to democracy in South Africa. Desmond Tutu, in turn, thanked the Evangelical Church in Germany (EKD) for their support in the fight against apartheid, calling upon the ‘rainbow nation’ of South Africa to find peace with itself and with other peoples (EKD 1999:1).
    [Show full text]
  • June 2019 Dear Christ College Reading
    June 2019 Dear Christ College Reading Alums: The love of good books and stimulating conversation is a Christ College legacy that lives on in the CC Alumni Reading groups found across the country. I’m happy to be contributing to this practice with this syllabus, and I hope to visit your book discussion group at some point during the next few years. Please let me know if you would like to set up such a visit. During the past twenty years of my scholarly life, I’ve done a lot of work in the area of African literature, and I thought I would share some of my favorite texts with you. Besides, after last year’s social and political theory, it’s time for some fiction! In good CC fashion, I’ve included a contextual and historical framework for each work, which you can consult as much or as little as you wish. While you and your reading group can determine how you want to use this syllabus, here are two possible structures. A number of other possible combinations could also be put together, based on your preferences. Books: Things Fall Apart, by Chinua Achebe Purple Hibiscus, by Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie Cry, the Beloved Country, by Alan Paton Waiting for the Barbarians, by J.M. Coetzee A Human Being Died that Night, by Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela The traditional five-meeting structure: Meeting 1: Read “Introduction,” “Jesus of the Deep Forest,” “A Thumbnail History of Africa,” “The Father of African Literature,” and Things Fall Apart. Reflection and Discussion Questions. Meeting 2: Read “The Granddaughter of Achebe,” and Purple Hibiscus.
    [Show full text]
  • Mother to Mother Study Guide V1 2020
    Mother to Mother Study Guide Brief Biography of Sindiwe Magona Sindiwe Magona was born in Umtata, a town in eastern South Africa, and grew up in Guguletu, a township outside of Cape Town. She attended primary school in Guguletu, but finished high school through a correspondence course. She then received a bachelor’s degree from the University of South Africa, and in 1981 moved to New York to work on a master’s degree in Social Work. In between, she did domestic work and worked as a schoolteacher. After receiving her master’s degree, Magona worked for the United Nations, first working in radio and then in the Public Information department until retiring to Cape Town, her home, in 2003. Magona wrote throughout her life, spending her earlier years writing autobiographical prose, short stories, and novels, and beginning to explore children’s literature in her retirement. Historical Context of Mother to Mother Portuguese traders first began to explore the coastline of South Africa in the 1400s, but Europeans didn’t begin to colonize the area until 1600s, when the Dutch East India Company created permanent settlements at what is now Cape Town. The settlements were a port to help passing ships on their way to Asia, but colonization expanded as greater infrastructure was required to serve said ships. Over time, the colony expanded along the coast and inland, with white colonists killing and enslaving (or forcing into indentured servitude) black Africans as they encountered them. Eventually British settlers also arrived, initially only interested in the Cape as a strategic port, but eventually going to war against Boers (or Dutch South Africans), officially taking control of South Africa in 1909.
    [Show full text]
  • Forgiveness: Re-Examining the Role of Forgiveness in Transitional Justice
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Duke Law Scholarship Repository No Future without (Personal) Forgiveness: Re-examining the Role of Forgiveness in Transitional Justice * 10 HUM. RTS. REV. 309 (2009) John D. Inazu * The original publication is available at: www.springerlink.com/content/n37h12mj1167k336/ Stories of personal forgiveness are powerful. They are also startling and uncomfortable. You asked a court for mercy on behalf of the terrorist who killed your child?1 You started a foundation to help the young men who murdered your daughter?2 You share meals with the person who hacked to death your husband and children?3 Many of us are incredulous about such acts. Some of us are even roused to moral indignation on behalf of the silenced victim or perhaps rattled by the loss of an abstract “justice” that seems sacrificed by this kind of forgiveness. Yet these acts happen and can inspire other such acts within a community. When they do, they have the potential to implicate, challenge, and move the politics of the community. This article is about the political possibilities of personal forgiveness and specifically, its role in transitional justice. There are, of course, some who reject the political utility of forgiveness, and still others who find immoral the very notion of forgiving a wrongdoer of grievous injustice (Wiesenthal 1997). However, stories of personal forgiveness in the well- known South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) contest these critical views and ought to leave us conceptually open to “the capacity of forgiveness to realize hopes that transcend the expectations of the most optimistic political realist” (Torrance 2006, 45).
    [Show full text]
  • Amnesty in South Africa Transitional Amnestyinsouth
    Amnesty in South Africa: A study of the Committee on Amnesty in Transitional South Africa By James Thomas Submitted to Central European University Department of Political Science In partial fulfillment of the degree of Master of Arts Supervisor: Professor Nenad Dimitrijevic Budapest, Hungary (2012) CEU eTD Collection Abstract Many countries have faced the pains of authoritarian governments. South Africa is one of them. Wracked by a history of violence and suffering, South Africa became an all inclusive democracy in 1994. The transition in South Africa has now become one of the most talked about transitions. Unlike the countries of Latin America, South Africa embarked on a search for not only truth, but for reconciliaiton as well. This thesis will provide the reader with an analysis of the transition. By analysing select cases from the Amnesty Committee, this thesis will provide the reader with a deeper understanding of the transistion, as well as the amnesty process in South Africa. CEU eTD Collection i Table of Contents Abstract ..........................................................................................................................................i Introduction .................................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1 – History of South Africa........................................................................................7 1.1 Colonization....................................................................................................................................7
    [Show full text]
  • Mother Keeps Amy Biehl's Voice Alive
    Friday, June 10, 2005 Mother Keeps Amy Biehl's Voice Alive Journal Staff Writer Amy Biehl was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time. Incited during a political rally earlier in the day, the young black men who pulled her from a car and killed her in South Africa's Guguletu Township saw just another South African white occupier. The four men who were arrested and imprisoned in connection with Biehl's August 1993 death would later learn that the 26-year-old woman was a Fulbright scholar from America who was working in support of their cause. A graduate of Santa Fe High School and Stanford University, Biehl was helping African leaders develop a new constitution and was conducting voter registration drives for the first all-race election that ended apartheid. The convicted killers applied for amnesty with the country's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, headed by Bishop Desmond Tutu, and in July 1997, Amy's parents, Linda and Peter Biehl, went to South Africa to address the commission. Remarkably, they didn't oppose amnesty. "We supported the process," said Linda Biehl during a recent phone conversation from South Africa. "Desmond Tutu told us to speak from our hearts, so our presentation was about Amy and linking arms where we could with the South African people to help them in their next steps toward nation building." Even more astonishing, the Biehls became quite close with two of the convicted men, who now work for the Amy Biehl Foundation Trust in South Africa. Peter Biehl died from colon cancer in 2002 at age 59.
    [Show full text]
  • Rethinking Subjectivity João Biehl, Byron Good, Arthur Kleinman
    31183_U01.qxd 9/15/06 2:29 PM Page 1 Introduction: Rethinking Subjectivity joão biehl, byron good, arthur kleinman This book is an extended conversation about contemporary forms of human experience and subjectivity. It examines the genealogy of what we consider to be the modern subject, and it inquires into the continuity and diversity of personhood across greatly diverse societies, including the ways in which inner processes are reshaped amid economic and political reforms, violence, and social suffering. It is an ethnographic conversation, with authors con- fronting specific forms of social life in particular settings, and it is a theo- retical conversation, exploring the debates and disciplinary disagreements about how we think and write about human agency today. The writings in this book suggest that contemporary social formations, with their particular ways of being and the theoretical frames available for analyzing them, have destabilized our observation, thinking, and writing about subjectivity. In editing this collection, we have sought to show the multiple ways in which scholars address the diverse phenomena we call sub- ject and subjectivity. Striving for a single analytic strategy would have been limiting and premature at best. This volume is thus exploratory, aiming to provide new directions for studies of subjectivity and intersubjectivity in today’s distinctive conditions. In the many settings in which anthropologists now work, the vagaries of modern life are undoing and remaking people’s lives in new and ominous ways. The subjects of our study struggle with the possibilities and dangers of economic globalization, the threat of endless violence and insecurity, and the new infrastructures and forms of political domination and resistance that lie in the shadows of grand claims of democratization and reform.
    [Show full text]