2001. The Journal of Arachnology 29:249±252

EGG COVERING BEHAVIOR OF THE NEOTROPICAL HARVESTMAN PROMITOBATES ORNATUS (, GONYLEPTIDAE)

Rodrigo Hirata Willemart: Departamento de Zoologia, Instituto de BiocieÃncias, Universidade de SaÄo Paulo, Caixa Postal 11461, 05422-970, SaÄo Paulo, SP,

ABSTRACT. The egg covering behavior of the laniatorid harvestman Promitobates ornatus was studied. Females of this species laid eggs isolated, on soil. After laying an egg, the female started scraping the substrate next to the egg, picking up debris, and attached the earth particles to the egg. After she scraped one area, she rotated around the egg, stopped turning, and restarted the collection of debris from another site. Alternation of scraping and changing body position was repeated twice or more until the female completed the egg covering. Data on egg size, duration of egg laying and egg covering, and duration of embryonic development are also provided. Keywords: Laniatores, Mitobatinae, biology, care, maternal investment

In the Laniatorine suborder of Opiliones, MunÄoz-Cuevas 1971), Vonones sayi (Simon females lay eggs that are either clustered (Ca- 1879) () (Cokendolpher & Jones nals 1936; Capocasale & Bruno-Trezza 1964; 1991) as well as two other species of cosme- Mitchell 1971; Juberthie & MunÄoz-Cuevas tids and six species of gonyleptids (Canals 1971; Matthiesen 1975; Goodnight & Good- 1936) are known to cover eggs with debris. night 1976; Pinto-da-Rocha 1993; Ramires & The behavior of covering eggs has never Giaretta 1994; Gnaspini 1995; Machado & been described in detail. The only mention of Oliveira 1998) or isolated (Canals 1936; Jub- how egg covering occurs was by Canals erthie 1965, 1972; Cokendolpher & Jones (1936), who reported ``scraping of the sub- 1991), on a large variety of substrates, such strate with the anterior legs'' by the female. as leaves, moss, rocks, bark crevices and soil. Again, he did not specify which species did Among the Laniatores (unless otherwise in- this. This paper provides the ®rst detailed de- dicated, all species mentioned below belong scription of egg covering behavior in harvest- to the family Gonyleptidae), different forms men, based on data from Promitobates orna- of parental investment have been described in tus (Mello-LeitaÄo 1922) (Mitobatinae). the literature, ranging from the oviposition site Three female P. ornatus were used for this selection to egg guarding. Egg guarding has study. One of them (identi®ed as Po1) was been observed in one species of Cosmetidae collected on 24 January 1999 in Carlos Bo- and one of Stynopsidae and in seven species telho State Park, SaÄo Miguel Arcanjo county. of Gonyleptidae (see Gnaspini 1995 for ref- The other two (identi®ed as Po2 and Po3) erences), and is usually performed by females. were collected on 27 July 1999 in Paranapia- Paternal care has seldom been reported (Rod- caba (ϭ Alto da Serra), Santo Andre county. riguez & Guerrero 1976; Mora 1990; Martens Both localities are representative of tropical 1993) and there is no record of biparental care rain forest in SaÄo Paulo state, southeastern in harvestmen, although Machado & Oliveira Brazil. I maintained Po1 with a conspeci®c (1998) reported males of Goniosoma longipes male at room temperature in a terrarium with (Roewer 1913) near the eggs, and taking care damp soil, a wet piece of cotton, and hard of eggs when the female was experimentally surfaces such as stones and plastic blocks. removed. Po2 and Po3 were kept in a second terrarium Scotolemon lespesi Lucas 1860 (Juberthie under the same conditions, but with six other 1965), Cynorta cubana (Banks 1909) (Cos- conspeci®cs including males and females. In metidae) (Juberthie 1972), Pachylus quina- both of the cases, the arti®cial light : dark pe- mavidensis MunÄoz-Cuevas 1969 (Juberthie & riods were irregularly distributed throughout

249 250 THE JOURNAL OF ARACHNOLOGY

idensis (Juberthie & MunÄoz-Cuevas 1971). The general egg-laying behavior was also similar among the species studied so far, and follows the general description of Juberthie & MunÄoz-Cuevas (1971). However, after laying an egg, P. ornatus waved legs I over the egg occasionally touching it. Thereafter, the fe- male started scraping the substrate next to the egg with alternate movements of legs I, pick- ing up debris. She then raised legs I and strongly pressed them simultaneously or one at a time against the egg, leaving earth parti- cles attached to it. While scraping, some big- ger particles were occasionally brought near Figure 1.ÐDrawing of an egg of Promitobates the egg, without adhering to it. After she ornatus after the covering was completed, showing scraped the substrate from one area, she ro- soil particles (black spots) and a fragment of root tated around the egg, stopped turning, and re- (arrow) attached to it. started the collection of soil particles from an- other site. The female's rotation was either the day. The harvestmen were fed once a clockwise or counterclockwise, with no ap- week with dead such as isopods, parent rule concerning direction or angle of mosquitoes, drosophilids, pieces of Tenebrio rotation. Alternation of scraping and changing obscurus larvae and a variety of plant items body position was repeated twice or more un- (papaya, sugar beet, boiled carrots, beans and til the egg covering was complete (Table 1). rice) and industrial food (cream cheese, The mean time spent during egg covering was cooked ground beef, and bread). They ac- 37 Ϯ 11 min (n ϭ 9, range ϭ 20±50 min). cepted all the items mentioned. All observa- Occasionally, between two events of scraping, tions were conducted between August 1999 the female would pass her legs I between the and December 1999. chelae of her chelicerae. This explains why Females of P. ornatus laid isolated eggs the total time is greater than the sum of partial over soil surfaces. During oviposition, the fe- time periods in Table 1. Before leaving the male P. ornatus stood at legs III and IV, with site, the female tapped the substrate around legs I and II extended forward. The ovipositor the egg with the ®rst pair of legs. In one case, extended forward to the genital operculum, at 2.3 h elapsed between covering one egg and 20Њ below the horizontal body axis, and the laying the next one. egg slid slowly along it, until the distal part Promitobates ornatus apparently does not of the ovipositor was reached. At this mo- always choose an appropriate site for collec- ment, the female bent the ovipositor bringing tion of soil particles. Female Po1 twice laid it close to the substrate and deposited the egg. an egg in sites where she was unable to turn Only one egg was laid in each event. In the herself around the egg, although she tried to, two cases in which I observed nearly the en- because the egg was laid too close to a vertical tire act of oviposition, the times spent for one substrate. In addition, females Po1 and Po2 egg to be laid were 3.4 and 3.5 min. The mean were observed scraping stones instead of earth egg length was 1.29 Ϯ 0.16 mm (n ϭ 8, range surfaces, using the same behavioral patterns ϭ 1.05±1.40 mm), approximately 25% of the described earlier. Thus, the quality of the sub- female body length (5.10, 5.15, and 5.20 mm). strate used for collection of soil particles is Females laid eggs in the morning (n ϭ 5; one probably not the factor that determines the not included in Table 1), afternoon (n ϭ 3) time spent in egg covering. It should be noted, and at night (n ϭ 2), and so apparently did however, that the females always laid their not favor a particular time of day for ovipo- eggs on soil, indicating that they probably rec- sition. ognized and selected soil surfaces for ovipo- The time spent by P. ornatus to lay one egg sition. was similar to that in other laniatorean spe- Females of P. ornatus did not abort egg lay- ciesÐe.g., 4±12 min for Pachylus quinamav- ing and egg covering when disturbed by light WILLEMARTÐEGG COVERING BEHAVIOR OF HARVESTMAN 251

Table 1.ÐChange of body position during nine covering events by three females of Promitobates ornatus (Po1, Po2, and Po3). The second column represents the positions adopted by the female. In all cases, 0Њ is horizontally at left and the angles of rotation have to be counted clockwise. Partial time periods follow the sequence of the location of the female relative to the egg. The lines are organized by and hour.

Location of female Partial time Total time Hour when egg Female relative to egg periods (min) (min) covering started Po1 0Њ/225Њ/0Њ/60Њ/0Њ/110Њ/180Њ 4/11/4/1/4/9/2 36 0830 Po1 0Њ/225Њ/180Њ/270Њ 13/9/6/5 34 0919 Po1 0Њ/225Њ/0Њ/65Њ/135Њ 9/10/7/10/5 45 1058 Po1 0Њ/270Њ/45Њ/135Њ 7/12/6/19 45 1135 Po1 0Њ/90Њ/135Њ 12/6/5 24 1500 Po1 0Њ/90Њ/225Њ 6/7/6 20 0010 Po2 0Њ/180Њ/340Њ 24/10/16 51 1836 Po3 0Њ/270Њ/180Њ/90Њ 15/10/4/19 49 1515 Po3 0Њ/45Њ/290Њ 10/11/7 29 1950

(n ϭ 5) or by the approach of other harvest- less than the 30±60 days found for Gonioso- men of approximately the same body size [a ma spelaeum (Mello-LeitaÄo 1933) (Gnaspini conspeci®c male (n ϭ 1) and Ilhaia cuspidata 1995) and the 45±64 days for Goniosoma lon- Roewer 1913 male introduced in the terrarium gipes (Machado & Oliveira 1998). These dif- (n ϭ 1)]. On one occasion, a female stopped ferences are tentative since temperature great- egg covering and remained motionless when ly in¯uences the duration of embryonic touched on the dorsum with a thin paintbrush. development, and as mentioned above, the In this case, she waved her second pair of legs laboratory temperature was not controlled searching for the stimulus. Fleeing only oc- during this study. Egg development took 16± curred when she touched the paintbrush with 27 days for Cynorta cubana at 20±28 ЊC (Jub- her second pair of legs. erthie 1972), 13 days at 26 ЊC and 23±27 days This reluctance to abandon the eggs has at 20 ЊC for Erginulus clavotibialis (Cam- been described in two other Gonyleptidae. bridge 1904) (Goodnight & Goodnight 1976), Light did not cause females of Goniosoma and 20±38 days for Vonones sayi with the proximum (Mello-LeitaÄo 1922) with eggs to temperature ranging from 5±20 ЊC (Coken- ¯ee (Ramires & Giaretta 1994) and females dolpher & Jones 1991). of Acanthopachylus aculeatus (Kirby 1819) Several invertebrates are known to feed on guarding eggs ¯ed only under very intense harvestmen eggsÐfrom conspeci®cs to ¯at- light (Capocasale & Bruno-Trezza 1964). worms, ants, reduviid bugs, staphylinid beetle However, in contrast with the behavior dis- larvae, and crickets (Capocasale & Bruno- played by P. ornatus, females of Pachylus Trezza 1964; Juberthie & MunÄoz-Cuevas quinamavidensis, while laying an egg, reacted 1971; Mora 1990; Gnaspini 1995; Machado to approaching conspeci®c males springing & Oliveira 1998). In that context, the energy with the palps extended towards the male invested in parental care may be justi®ed be- (Juberthie & MunÄoz-Cuevas 1971). No droplets of exocrine gland secretion cause of the resulting (presumed) protection were noticed on P. ornatus' body while laying from predation (Alcock 1993). Egg covering or covering an egg, but it could be that secre- in P. ornatus lasts an average of 37 min, and tions are added to the legs as they are passed the process repeats for each egg laid. Never- between the chelicerae. Clawson (1988) noted theless, this investment is certainly not as females of two species of Palpatores would costly as the investments made by females of rub the exocrine gland openings over their Goniosoma spelaeum and G. longipes, which oviposition sites, and suggested this behavior lay clustered eggs and stay with their off- was to mark the sites. spring until the dispersion of the nymphs An average of 30 Ϯ 4.97 days (n ϭ 5; range (sometimes 60±80 days between laying eggs ϭ 23±36) of embryonic development was and dispersion) (Gnaspini 1995; Machado & necessary for nymphs of P. ornatus to hatch, Oliveira 1998). 252 THE JOURNAL OF ARACHNOLOGY

By laying isolated eggs P. ornatus avoids the Entomological Society of Washington 93:86± the risk of losing several eggs if an egg hap- 91. pens to be noticed by a predator. Covering Gnaspini, P. 1995. Reproduction and postembry- eggs with debris is interpreted as a way to onic development of Goniosoma spelaeum,a hide them from predators (Canals 1936; Jub- cavernicolous harvestman from southeastern Brazil (Arachnida: Opiliones: Gonyleptidae). In- erthie 1972; Cokendolpher & Jones 1991), vertebrate Reproduction and Development 28: thus increasing the chances of the embryo's 137±151. survival. I believe that, in addition to the fact Goodnight, M.R. & C.J. Goodnight. 1976. Obser- that camou¯age makes the eggs dif®cult to be vations on the systematics, development and seen, it may also be effective against predators habits of Erginulus clavotibialis (Opiliones, Cos- that use tactile clues. A wandering predator metidae). Transactions of the American Micro- may pass over the egg without noticing it be- scopical Society 95:654±664. cause of the soil particles adhered to the egg. Juberthie, C. 1965. DonneÂes sur l'eÂcologie, le deÂ- In theory, the greater the number of particles veloppement et la reproduction des Opilions. Re- attached and the more uniformly they are dis- vue d'Ecologie et de Biologie du Sol 2:377±396. Juberthie, C. 1972. Reproduction et deÂveloppe- tributed on the egg surface, the more effective ment d'un opilion Cosmetidae, Cynorta cubana would be the protection. I believe that there is (Banks), de . Annales de SpeÂleÂologie 27: a strong relationship between the act of chang- 773±785. ing the body position radially around the egg Juberthie, C. & MunÄoz-Cuevas 1971. Sur la ponte and the effectiveness of the process. As sug- de Pachylus quinamavidensis (Opilion, Gonylep- gested by Mitchell (1971) for eggs laid in tidae). Bulletin de la SocieÂte d'Histoire Naturelle crevices, egg guarding would be of little se- de Toulouse 107:468±474. lective value if the egg is dif®cult to ®nd. Machado, G. & P.S. Oliveira. 1998. Reproductive biology of the Neotropical harvestman (Gonio- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS soma longipes) (Arachnida, Opiliones: Gonylep- This paper has been greatly improved by tidae): Mating, oviposition behaviour, brood mortality, and parental care. Journal of Zoology the suggestions of my advisor P. Gnaspini, to 246:359±367. whom I am deeply grateful. I am also indebted Martens, J. 1993. Further cases of paternal care in to J. Berry, J. Cokendolpher, G. Machado, R. Opiliones (Arachnida). Tropical Zoology 6:97± Suter and an anonymous referee for helpful 107. comments. I thank M.R. Hara for rearing Matthiesen, F.A. 1975. Sobre a postura de Disco- some used in this study and R. Pinto- cyrtus pectinifemur Mello-LeitaÄo, 1937 (Opili- da-Rocha for identi®cation of the harvestmen. ones, Gonyleptidae). CieÃncia e Cultura (SaÄo Pau- F. Garcia provided assistance with computer lo) 27 suppl:372. matters. Mitchell, R.W. 1971. Egg and young guarding by a Mexican cave-dwelling harvestman, Hoplobu- LITERATURE CITED nus boneti (Arachnida). Southwestern Naturalist Alcock, J. 1993. Animal Behavior: An Evolution- 15:392±394. Mora, G. 1990. Paternal care in a Neotropical har- ary Approach. 5th ed., Sinauer Associates, Sun- vestman, Zygopachylus albomarginis (Arachni- derland. 626 p. da, Opiliones: Gonyleptidae). Animal Behaviour Canals, J. 1936. Observaciones bioloÂgicas em ar- 39:582±593. aÂcnidos del orden Opiliones. Revista de Chilena Pinto-da-Rocha, R. 1993. Invertebrados cavernõÂ- de Historia Natural 40:61±63. colas da porcËaÄo meridional da ProvõÂncia Espe- Capocasale, R. & L. Bruno-Trezza. 1964. Biologia leoloÂgica do Vale do Ribeira, sul do Brasil. Re- de Acanthopachylus aculeatus (Kirby, 1819) vista Brasiliera de Zoologia 10:229±255. (Opiliones: Pachylinae). Revista de la Sociedad Ramires, E.N. & A.A. Giaretta. 1994. Maternal Uruguaya de Entomologia 6:19±32. care in a Neotropical harvestman, Acutisoma Clawson, R.C. 1988. Morphology of defense proximum (Opiliones, Gonyleptidae). Journal of glands of the opilions (daddylonglegs) Leiobun- Arachnology 22:179±180. um vittatum and L. ¯avum (Arachnida: Opili- Rodriguez, C.A. & S. Guerrero. 1976. La historia ones: Palpatores: Phalangiidae). Journal of Mor- natural y el comportamiento de Zygopachylus al- phology 196:363±381. bomarginis (Chamberlin) (Arachnida: Opiliones: Cokendolpher, J.C. & S.R. Jones. 1991. Karyotype Gonyleptidae). Biotropica 8:242±247. and notes on the male reproductive system and natural history of the harvestman Vonones sayi Manuscript received 20 March 2000, revised 30 (Simon) (Opiliones, Cosmetidae). Proceedings of November 2000.