2790 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 to the Committee on Merchant Marine and sage of House bills 2135 and 2136, known as maneuvers which, he said, would be the Fisheries. the Townsend plan; to the Committee on largest peacetime maneuvers in which By _Mr. TOLLEFSON: Ways and Means. the Navy had engaged. Feeling that I H. R. 7557. A bill to provide for local taxa 1958. Also, petition of J. H. Richmond and tion of real estate and improvements there others, West Palm Beach, Fla., requesting should acquire all the information I on owned by the United States, and for other passage of House bills 2135 and 2136, known could concernir.i.g our defense equipment purposes; to the Committee on Public Lands. . as the Townsend plan; to the Committee on and the skill with which it can be used, By Mr. SPENCE: Ways and Means. I desire to accompany the Secretary of H . Res. 500. Resolution providing for the Defense on the trip next week. There consideration of H. R. 7402, a bill to assist fore, I ask unanimous consent that I cooperative and other nonprofit corporations may be excused from attendance on the in the production of housing for moderate o{ income families; to amend the National SENATE sessions the Senate from March 6 to Housing Act, as amended; and for other pur March 9, inclusive . . poses; to the Committee on Rules. S ATURDAY, MARCH 4, 1950 The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob jection, the leave is granted. Judiciary. prayer: By Mr. BYRNE of New York: Eternal God, who puttest down the The VICE PRESIDENT laid before the H. R. 7559. A bill for the relief of Mrs. mighty from their seat -and exalteth the Senate the following message from the Honora Redman; to the Committee on the humble and the meek, look with compas President of the United States, which Judiciary. sion upon our Nation as we strive to was read, and, with the accompanying By Mr. FARRINGTON: bill, ordered to lie on the table: H. R. 7560. A bill for the relief of Mary mend its flaws and make it the fit in Frances Yoshinaga; to the Committee on the strument of Thy will in these troubled To the Senate: Judiciary. days. History's tragic pages but re In compliance with the request con By Mr. GRANGER: mind us that Thy providence knows no tained in the resolution of the Senate H. R. 7561. A bill for the relief of Dr. favorites, that none can bend Thy jus George Peter Petropoulos; to the Commit TRUMAN. turing Co., Inc.; to the Committee on the dom, we ask for the guidance of the THE WHITE HOUSE, March 4, 1950. Judiciary. Kindly Light to lead us on o'er crag and By Mr. LEFEVRE: torrent till the night be passed. Help us TRANSACTION OF ROUTINE BUSINESS H. R. 7563. A b111 for the relief of Dr. this and every day to live more nearly Mr. LUCAS. Mr. President, I ask Nicola Di Palma; to the Committee on the as we pray. Amen. Judiciary. unanimous consent that Senators be THE JOURNAL :i;:>ermitted to introduce bills and joint On request of Mr. LUCAS, and by unani resolutions, present petitions and memo PETITIONS, ETC. mous consent, the reading of the Journal rials, and submit routine matters for the Under clause 1 of rule XXII, petitions ·of the proceedings of Friday, March 3, RECORD, without debate and without and papers were laid on the Clerk's desk 1950, was dispensed with. speeches, and without taking the Sena and referred as follows: - MESSAGES FROM THI: PRESIDENT tor from Mississippi from the floor. The VICE PRESIDENT. Is there ob 1950. By Mr. SHORT: Petition of Homer Messages in writing from the Presi L. Clough and other citizens of Halltown, jection? The Chair hears none, and it is Mo., urging the passage of H. R. 2428; to the dent of the United States were commu so ordered. · · Committee on Interstate and Foreign Com nicated to the Senate by Mr. Miller, one of his secretaries. DREDGING OF CHANNEL AND MOORING merce. BASIN IN WELLFLEET HARBOR, MASS. 1951. Also, petition of Mr. and Mrs. L. G. MESSAGE FROM THE HOUSE Patrick and many other citizens of Howell PETITION County, Mo., urging the passage of the Bryson A message from the House of Repre Mr. LODGE. Mr. President, on behalf bill, H. R. 2428; to the Committee on In sentatives, by Mr. Swanson, one of its of my colleague the senior Senator from terstate and Foreign Commerce. reading clerks, announced that the Massachusetts [Mr. SALTONSTALL] and 1952. Also, petition of Mr. and Mrs. B. R. House had passed a bill SPEAKER: Petition of Peter funds necessary for the dredging of a Frost Muller and others, Miami, Fla., re Mr. LUCAS. Mr. President, I ask channel and mooring basin in the har questing passage of House bills 2135 and unanimous consent that when the Sen bor of Wellfleet. 2136, known as the Townsend plan; to 'the ate concludes its business today it take . There being no objection, the petition Committee on Ways and Means. a recess until Monday next at 12 o'clock was referred to the Committee on Pub 1955. Also, petition of J. F. Anstett and noon. others, Orlando, Fla., requesting passage of lic Works, and ordered to be printed in The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob the RECORD, as follows: House bills 2135 and 2136, known as the jection, it is so ordered. Townsend plan; to the Committee on Ways To -the Congress of the United States: and Means. LEAVES OF ABSENCE By unanimous vote of the town of Well 1956. Also, petition of B. W. Kellogg and Mr. ROBERTSON. Mr. President, fleet at the regular town meeting February others, St. Cloud, Fla., requesting passage 13, 1950, . the committee whose signatures of House bills 2135 and 2136, known as the several weeks ago the Secretary of De are attached to this petition were instructed Townsend plan; to the Committee on Ways fense urged all members of the Subcom to address the following memorial to the and Means. mittee on Armed Forces of the Commit Congress of the United States relative to an 1957. Also, petition of W. F. Lewis and tee on Appropriations to accompany him approved project for dredging a channel and others, St. Petersburg, Fla., requesting pas- to the Caribbean area to observe naval mooring basin in Wellfleet Harbor. The 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2791 committee wao . also 1nstructed to petition not want Federal bureaucrats to be.pok Whereas compulsory health insurance, -the General Court of the Commonwealth of ing their noses into the private health wherever tried, has caused a decline in na Massachusetts to concur with the town o! records of individual citizens. They do tional health and deterioration of medical Wellfleet in presenting this petition. not want to have to ask the approval of standards and facilities, to the detriment of "To the Congress of the United States: · bureaucrats for an operation or for an family welfare; and "We, ·the citizens of the town of Wellfleet, Whereas compulsory health insurance, Mass., respectfully petition the Congress of examination. The . people of Wisconsin wherever tried, has taken away the family's the United States to now appropriate the and of all America want the Federal Gov right to choosing its own family physician; funds necessary to complete the dredging ernment to assist our great private med and · of a channel and mooring basin in Wellfleet ical profession to improve our already Whereas invasion of family privacy and Harbor and thus bring to completion a proj high health standards, but this assist vic:>lation of the sanctity of the patient-physi ect to which the town has addressed itself, ance must come in the true American cian relationship have proved to be one of for which it has already provided its share way, of voluntary encouragement, rather the most objectionable features of compul of the funds, and which it believes to be tpan in the European way of dictator sory health insurance, wherever tried; and essential to its welfare, to the welfare of the ship. Whereas compulsory health insurance State, and to shipping passing through Cape would result immediately in a tax of 3 per Cod Bay. The State Medical Society of Wiscon- cent on the income of the American work "Whereas the gradual filling in o.f Well . sin has been in the forefront of advanc ingman, rising within a few years to 6 per fleet Harbor has been and ls detrimental ing America's medical frontiers. It has cent and higher, creating a new tax burden to the town of Wellfleet and particularly to constantly pioneered for finer health which would reduce household budgets and the fishermen of the town; and services, particularly to folks in the lower bring down family standards of living; and "Whereas this project was approved by and middle income brackets who cannot Whereas Government control of medical the Army engineers in 1939 and by the Mas a:fiord too heavy medical expenditures. services, by gradually undermining free en sachusetts Legislature in 1941; and I ask unanimous consent now to have terprise and establishing heavy new tax bur "Whereas the town of Wellfleet has appro dens and unprecedented national deficits, priated and set aside its share of the neces printed at this point in the RECORD, and would threaten national bankruptcy and en sary funds; and appropriately referred, the text of two of courage the spread of socialism, which would "Whereas with each year that passes the the many fine resolutions received from endanger the rights of our children to the cost of said project will increase because grass-roots women's organizations in my individual freedoms which have been the of the continual filling in of the harbor and State, in this instance a message from the American heritage: Now, therefore, be it consequent increase in dredging cost; and Rhinelander Woman's Club, as forwarded Resolved, That the Women's Civic Club of "Whereas the dredging of the harbo1· would to me by Mrs. T. E. Chaffee, and the text Gays Mills, Wis., does hereby go on record both greatly benefit the fishermen and bring against any form of compulsory health in in additional revenue to the merchants of of a resolution by another women's or the town from sports fishermen and visiting ganization, the Women's Civic Club of surance or any system of political medicine designed for national bureaucratic control; yachts; and Gays Mills, Wis. "Whereas the dredging of the harbor will There being no objection, the resolu That a copy of this resolution be forwarded enable the fishermen to inc1·ease production, to the President of the United States, to each tions were referred to the Committee on Senator and Representative from the State which is important to the economy of the Labor and Public Welfare and ordered Commonwealth; and of Wisconsin, and that said Senators and "Whereas Wellfleet Harbor is a natural to be printed in the RECORD, as follows: Representatives be and are hereby respect harbor of refuge for vessels in distress in RHINELANDER, WIS., February 28, 1950. fully requested to use every effort at their these waters; and Senator ALEXANDER WILEY, command to prevent the enactment of such "Whereas the rivers and harbors bill is now Washington, D. C. legislation. under consideration in Congress: DEAR SENATOR WILEY: As you no doubt Mrs. JOHN YOUNG, "Therefore, we, the citizens of the town know, the Wisconsin Federation of Women's President. of Wellfleet hereby petition the Congress Clubs at its 1949 convention went on record Mrs. WILLIAM YOUNG, of the United States to now appropriate the as opposed to Government control of health Secretary. funds necessary to the dredging of a channel services by passing the following resolution: Gays Mills, Wis., dated this 28th day of and mooring basin in the harbor of Well "Whereas needed medical and health serv February 1950. fieet; and we direct that copies of this peti ices should be placed within reach of every REPORT OF A COMMITTEE tion be sent forthwith to the President of individual within the United States; and the United States, to the Presiding Officer of "Whereas we believe the most effective ap The following report of a committee each branch of Congress, and to o~ repre proach to the national health problem lies was submitted: sentatives therein from this Commonwealth. in the extension and development of volun By Mr. McCARRAN, from the Committee on. "BEATRIX FAUST tary health insurance; and the Judiciary: "MARTHA C. PORCH. "Whereas we believe the extent of Fed H. R. 6670. A bill to incorporate the tiirl "LYNNE P.- TOWNSEND." eral grants necessary to aid the various Scouts of the United States of America, and COMPULSORY HEALTH INSURANCE States in providing care for the medically indigent can be determined by Nation-wide for · other purposes; without amendment Mr. WILEY. Mr. President, the June governmental supported surveys made by (Rept. No. 1321). 1949 Convention of the Wisconsin Feder State agencies: Therefore, be it BILLS INTRODUCED ation of Women's Clubs adopted a fine "Resolved, That the Wisconsin Federation of Women's Clubs in convention assembled, Bills were introduced, read the first resolution in opposition to Federal com time, and, by unanimous consent, the pulsory health insurance. Since then, it June 1949, goes on record against Govern ment control of health services which second time, and referred as follows: ~ has been my pleasure' to hear from many would jeopardize free enterprise, establish splendid women's organizations through By Mr. LANGER: heavy new tax burdens and unprecedented · S. 3182. A bill for the relief of Bairs out Wisconsin in endorsement of the ac national deficits, and infringe upon the Romba; powers of the Individual States; and tion takeri at their State convention. S. 3183. A bill for the relief of Zdenek These women are the ones primarily re "Resolved further, That copies of this res olution be sent to the proper authorities Marek; and sponsible for health in the American S. 3184. A bill for the relief of Talop Bin homes. It is they who have to look out and to the Members of Congress." At its last meeting on February 14, 1950, Padoh; to the Committee on the Judiciary. for the well being of their youngsters, of the Rhinelander Woman's Club voted to go By Mr. FERGUSON: their husbands, and of themselves. on record in support of the above resolution S. 3185. A bill for the relief of Nouhad Ann But these clear-sighted women realis and notify our district's Representative and Khoury; an~ tically recognize that government control Senators in Congress, and the State Medi S. 3186. A bill for the relief of Ann Arbor of medicine is not the answer to Ameri cal Society cif Wisconsin, of the club's re Construction Co.; to the Committee on ths ca's health needs. As a matter of fact, affirmation of that resolution. It is the Judiciary. government control of medicine will re club's desire that our Congressmen will use By Mr. BUTLER: sult in a lowering of America's health their every effort to prevent the enactment S. 8187. A bill to amend the Agricultural of compulsory health service legislation. Adjustment Act of 1988, and the Agricultural .standards and in a further move down Respectfully yours, in Act of 1949, to eliminate the distinction be the road to state socialism the United (Mrs. T. E.) ELIZABETH CHAFFEE, tween commercial and noncommercial corn States. Government control of medi· President, Rhinelander Woman's Club. prodUCilli areas; to the Committee on Agri cine will mean more national deficits be culture Mld Forestry. cause uncounted billions of dollars will be Whereas the American family has received By Mr. McCARRAN: squandered by bureaucrats. the finest quality of medical care available S. 3188 . .A bill t-3 amend the Uniform Code The people of Wisconsin, like the peo in any country in the world, developed under of Milita.~y JustiCJ3, and for other purposes; ple of every other State in the Union, do our system of free enterprise; and to the Com.m.ittee un Armed Services. 2792 CONGRESSiONAL RECORD-.SENATE MARCH 4 \ AMENDMENT OF DISPLACED PERSONS interested in the nomination may make Senator from Nevada [Mr. McCARRAN], ACT-AMENI'>ME'NTS such representations as may be perti chairman, the Senator from West Vir Mr. EASTLAND submitted amend nent. The subcommittee consists of the. ginia [Mr. KILGORE], and the Senator ments intended ·to be proposed by· him Senator from Nevada [Mr. McCARRAN], from North Dakota lMr. LANGER]. to the bill JUDGE OF THE UNITED STATES nominations, which were referred to the House bill 4567, supra, which was ordered· COURT OF APPEALS, DISTRICT OF CO appropriate committees. to lie on the table and to be p~inted. LUMBIA CIRCUIT Texas, to be an associate for other purposes, which was ordered to Thomas Washington, of the District of Columbia, to be a judge of the United judge of the United States Court of Customs lie on the table and to be printed. and Patent Appeals, vice Charles S. Hatfield, Stat es Court of Appeals, for the District Mr. THOMAS of Oklahoma title, and referred to the ator from Michigan ('Mr. FERGUSON]. ·united States district judge for the southern Committee on _Interior and Insular Af NOTiCE OF HEARING ON NOMINATION OF district of New York; - fairs. BURNITA SHELTON MAT '.I"HEWS TO BE Thomas J. Clary, of Pennsylvania, to be United States district judge for the eastern ERADICATION AND CONTROL OF HALOGE UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE, DIS .. district of Pennsylvania; and · TON ON PUBLIC LANDS-CHANGE OF TRICT OF COLUMBIA Owen Mcintosh Burns, of Pennsylvania, REFERENCE Mr. McCARRAN. Mr.· .President, on to be United States district judge for the behalf of the Comittee on the Judiciary, western district of .Pennsylvania. ' . Mr. THOMAS of Oklahoma. Mr. Pres · By Mr. KEFAUVER, from the Committee ident, there is now pending before the and in accordance with the rules of the. on the Judiciary: · Senat e Committee on Agriculture and committee, I desire to give notice that a · Robert L. ·Taylor, of Tennessee, to be Forestry Senate bill 3106, to authorize public hearing has ·been scheduled for United States district judge for the eastern appropriations for the eradication and _Saturday, April 1, 1950, at 10 :30 a. m., in district ·of Tennessee. room 424, Senatz Office Building, upon control of · halogeton on public lands, .SPECIFICATION~ FOR A REPUBLICAN which was introduced by the junior Sen the nomination of Hon. Burnita Shelton PROGRAM-ARTICLE . ~~ .. EE~~TOR ator from Idaho [.Mr. DWORSH AK]. The M ~tthews, of the District ef Columbia, to LODGE' - . junior·Senator from- Idaho· requests that be United Sta.tes district judge for the District of Columbia. Judge Matthews is [Mr. IVES asked and . obtained leave to the bill be referred to the Committee· on have printed in. the RECORD an article en Interior ahd ·Insular Affairs. As- chair ·riow serving under a recess appointment. ti'tled "Modernize the -GOP--'-Specifications man. of -the Committee. on -Agriculture .At. the .fnpic.ated time. and. pla.ce ail. per for. a Republican Program," written· by Sen and Forestry; I· ask "Unanimous· consent .sons_ interested .lil the .nomination may ator LODGE, · and· published in ·the Atlantic that the .Committee on .Agriculture -and .make- such representatiops as may be ~ Monthly, which' appea.rs rn t;he Appendix.] Forestry be discharge-ct from .the further pertinent. The.subc.ommittee .consists of -ExcrsE 'rAx R.E!Duc'i'ION_:sTA.TEMENT consideration of the bill, and that it be .the Senator from Nevada .[Mr. McCAR BY SENATOR CAIN referred to the Committee on Interior RAN], chairman, the Senator from Ten and Insular Affairs. ·nessee [Mr. KEFAUVER], and the Senator [Mr. CAIN asked and obtain_e~ leave to ·from Wisconsin [Mr. WILEY:]. have printe.d in the REcO.RD a statement The VICE PRESIDENT.. _ Is there ob broadcast· by him on February 27, 1950, on jection to. the :request of the· Senator · -NOT(OE OF HEARING ON NOMIN·ATION OF ·the· subject pf war-created excise ta;~es, which from Oklahoma. The Chair hears none, WILLIAM HENRY HAST.IE TO BE JUDGE · ·appears -in· the Appendix.] and .it. is so ordered. OF THE UNITED STATES -COURT OF AP:. - . . A, FRANK REyIEW .. O]f _THE. HOOVER_, RE NOTICE OF HEARING ON NOMINATION OF · PEALS; THIRD CIRCUIT ·' -r - • ...PORT-=-AnDRESS BY JAMES A.·. FARLEY ffiVING R . . KAUFM:A"N .TO ·aE . UNITED . .. Mr. Mc.CARRAN. · ·Mr. ·P,r.esiden( on [Mr. GEORGE asked E1-n~ : obtained leave· STATES OISTRICT JUDGE, SOUTHERN behalf of the Committee on tlie Judiciary, tp have printed in the RECORD an.address en DISTRICT _OF NEW' YORK · ;and in ac'ccirdance' with the rules of 'the titled "A Fran!{ Re.view · of the Hoover · Re M~. McCARRAN: "M1;. · Pre.3ident; ·on ·committee; I desire fo give notice that ·a port," delivered by former Postmaster Gen- behalf of the Committee on ·th'e Judici ·public hearing has beep scheduled f6r . e.ral James A: Farley _at the conventio~ ban quet of the New York Press Association, held ary, and in accordance with the rules of Saturday; April 1, 1950, at 10 :30 a. m., in at Syracuse, N. Y., .on February 10, 1950, the comml.ttee, I desire to give notice :room 42"4, Senate -Office· Building, upon . which appears in the Appendix.] · · · that a public hearing has. been scheduled ·the nomination of Hon. William Henry for Saturday, 'April 1, 1950, at 10: 30 a. in., Hastie, of the Vifgin Islands, to be judge -DANGER FROM SOCIALISM~ADDRESS BY JOHN TEMPLE .GRAVES in room 424, Senate Office Building, upon . of the United States Court of·Appeals for the nomination of Hon. Irvi-ng R; Kauf the Third Circuit. . Judge Hastie is now [Mr. BYRE> asked and obtained leave to man, ·of New York, ·to be United States serving unde"r · a recess appointment. have printed in the RECORD an address on ·the danger .of socialism, 9,el~vered by. John district judge for the southern district At the indicated time and place all per · Te.mple Graves, before the. National Auto of New York. Judge· Kaufman i~i how .sons interested in the nomination may .· mobile neafers' .Association, in· Atfo.iitic City, serving under a recess-appoilltinerit. -At "m..:-:-.ke such r·epresentations as may be per N. J ., Feb:·l.::ary 8, 19"50,"wJ:iich· appears iti the the inciicated time and place all persons . tir:.ent. The subcommittee consists of the · Appendix.] 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2793 · JOINT COMMITI'EE ON REDUCTION OF bill. I ask unanimous consent to have the unsurveyed area of not only the public NONESSENTIAL FEDERAL EXPENDI this statement inserted in the RECORD at land States, but the Nation, its off-shore TURES-EDITORIAL FROM THE MINNE-. this point. areas, and Territories. But until· such a APOLIS MORNING TRIBUNE survey is completed, it seems only logical to There being no objection, the state me to have the intent of Congress carried [Mr. BYRD asked · and obtained leave to ment was ordered to be printed in the out by apportioning the income from public have printed in the ~CORD an editorial from RECORD, as follows: lands to the States on the basis of the the Minneapolis Morning Tribune of Feb STATEMENT BY SENATOR WATKINS formula which I have set forth in S. 1324. ruary 27, 1950, discussing recent attacks on the Joint Committee on Reduction of Non The various public-land States are to re DEMOC'RATIC PROCEDURE IN MUNICH, essential Federal Expenditures. which ap- ceive title in fee, that is, title to ail surface GERMANY pears in the Appendif.] · and subsurface rights, to a certain number of sections-from two to four--out of each Mr. MORJE. Mr. President, I ask 1949 PROGRESS IN THE TENNESSEE township. The income from these lands is unanimous consent to have inserted in VALLEY-ADORES~ BY .JAMES P. POPE to be u_sed for the support of the common the body of the RECORD a statement [Mr. KEFAUVER asked and obtained leave schools. which deals with democratic processes to have printed in the RECORD an address de- I shall refer specifically to Utah, since that being placed in operation in Munich. livered by James P. Pope, Director of the is my home State and I am familiar with the situation there, but S. 3124 will apply equally Germany. The resident manager, or the Tennessee Valley Authority, before the American mayor. I might say, of Munich, Athens Kiwanis Club, at Athens, Tenn., on to the advantage of all other public-land February 15, 1950, which appears in the States where title to large areas of unsur Germany, is a very able Oregonian by Appendix.] veyed land still remains with the Go~rn the name of George Godfrey. The state ment. ment which I ask to have inserted in FEDERAL UNION FOR WORLD PEACE- In Utah, for example, four sections out of EDITORIAL FROM THE NASHVILLE each township of 36 sections are reserved to the RECORD shows, I think, very clearly, TENNESSEAN the State by the enabling act and by con that democratic processes can be put to firmation of such act by act of Congress set work in Germany. I commend the [Mr. KEFAUVER asked and obtained leave forth in title 43, United States Code, section to have printed in the RECORD an editorial statement to the reading of the Senate, entitled "The Time Has Come," published in 853. and I commend Mr. Godfrey for what I a recent issue of the Nashville Tennessean, Under Utah's enabling act, and by Federal think is a fine example of American statute, passed in 1902 (43 U. S. C. 853) the which appears in the Appendix.] State was to receive title to these afore leadership in Germany. VISIT TO THE UNITED STATES BY DELE mentioned four sections of land, but not I think the Town Hall Meeting pro_. GA'rION FROM WORLD CONGRESS OF until the townships involved had been sur gram which Mr. Godfrey has developed PARTISANS OF PEACE veyed. In Utah today. there are more than in Munich is a clear demonstration that 10,500,000 acres of unsurveyed land, the por [Mr. LUCAS asked and obtained leave to democratic process can work in Ger tion to which the State should receive fee many, and that the German people can have printed in the RECORD a State Depart title being more than 1,000,000 acres. ment release relative to the ·proposed visit to All .public-lands States are entitled to 37Y2 be led to an understanding of the values the United States by a delegation from the percent of all income from the public do of self-government. World Congress of Partisans of Peace, which main, whether surveyed or unsurveyed, re · In the fall of 1946 I visited Munich, appears in the Appendix.] ceived by the Federal Government from roy and I was satisfied then that the people EXPRESSIONS OF VIEWS BY SERVICE alty, leases, or any other income on such of that area of Germany were anxious OFFICERS-EDITORIAL FROM . THE public domain (30 U.S. C.191). If they are . to put into practice the principles of SATURDAY EVENING POST entitled to the ownership of four sections out of each township and are getting only 37Yz democracy. if they received from the [Mr. MARTIN asked and obtained leave to percent revenue from the entire ·township, United States the instruction, informa have printed in the RECORD an editorial en they are being deprived of substantial reve tion, and leadership which they needed titled "Can't a General Speak to a Senator, nue because of the failure of the Government Even in the Strictest Confidence?" from the in order to lead them away from a Fas to complete the survey of the public domain. cist type of government to a democratic Saturday Evening Post, which appears in the In other words they are entitled to 100 per. Appendix.] cent of the revenue from four sections. or _ one. Mr. Godfrey. as the American mayor of Munich. is apparently doing a CO~UNISTS IN GOVERNMENT SERVICE- one-ninth of the area, and 1n addition RADIO BROADCAST BY JACK BEALL thereto, the preva1ling 37Yz percent of the grand job in helping democratize the royalties, leases, or other income from the governmental processes of Munich. I [Mr. DWORSHAK asked and obtained leave remaining eight-ninths of the unsurveyed am sure the same results can be obtained to have printed in the RECORD a radio broad- area. cast by Jack Beall, on March 2, 1950, which If this computation were used, Utah would elsewhere in Germany. appears in the Appendix.] receive 44.4 percent return on royalties, leases, There being no objection, the state PURCHASING VALUE OF THE DOLLAR or other income from the public domain in ment was ordered to be printed in the stead of the present 37Yz percent, computed RECORD, as follows: [Mr. DWORSHAK asked and obtained leave as follows: to have printed in the RECORD a table show Democratization activities in the city and ing the purchasing value of the dollar as One hundred percent of revenue from one county of Munich, sponsored by or partici measured by the Consumers' Price Index, pre ninth or 0.111 percent of area equals 11.1 pated in by State Department resident offi pared by the Institute of Life Insurance, percent revenue. cers, amassed an attendance total of m9re which appears in the Appendix.] Thirty-seven and five-tenths percent or than 600,000 for the year just ended, ac revenue from eight-ninths or 0.889 percent cording to figures compiled by George H. UNEMPLOYMENT IN THE PACIFIC of area equals 33.3 percent revenue. · Godfrey, senior resident officer, who is in NORTHWEST Adjusted percentage ls 44.4 percent from charge of the office for United States State [Mr. MORSE asked and obtained leave to 100 percent of area. · - Department. · have printed in the RECORD a communication The other public-land States would like Actual events, such as town meetings, addressed by Mr. Matt Meehan, international wise benefit. It should be remembered, how forums, film sho~ings, youth meetings, dis representative of the International Long ever, that this applies only to unsurveyed cussion groups, and other affairs, totaled shoremen's and Warehousemen's Union, to lands because when surveyed, the title to more than ~.500 for the period. the members of the Oregon delegation in Con these reserved sections would go to the vari Assuming that half of this total attendance gress, relative to the unemployment situa ous States anyway and they would receive all figure represents duplications, this still tion in the Pacific Northwest, which appears of the revenue therefrom. means that approximately one-third of the in the Appendix. J All that S. 3124 would do, therefore, is to 900,000 ~itizens residing in the city and give to the public-land States their equitable county of Munich were reached by the de AMENDMENT OF MINERAL LEASING ACT share of public-land receipts and thus carry mocratization program, Mr. Godfrey pointed OF 1920-STATEMENT OF SENATOR out the . directly expressed intent Of Con out. WATKINS gress, despite the fact that the Federal-State The town meeting program, initiated early Mr. WATKINS. Mr. President.I have contract for passing title to the lands can last year, has been amazingly successful, and received so many inquiries regarding the not be 'consummated until the lands are can now be regarded as a permanent part of surveyed. the life of the citizens. Not only have the effect of S. 3124, to amend the Mineral It might be advisable at this point to men citizens themselves taken an active interest, Leasing Act of 1920, that I deemed it ad tion that I have also introduced a bill, S. but members of the city council and State visable to prepare a statement setting 2989, to provide for the orderly and acceler and county officials are enthusiastic in the forth both the purpose and effect of the ated program of surveying and mapping of support of the meetings. 2794 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENA'fE MARCH 4 During the year 118 town meetings were of State relative to security risks and the for security .and suitability prior to appoint held, with a total attendance of approxi loyalty program. ment. mately 35,000. The attendance was often There being no objection, the corre I trust that this information will be help- limited by the size of the meeting places, ful to you. . many OJ. which were so filled that people spondence was ordered tf) be printed in Sincerely yours, were turned away. the RECORD, as follows: JOHN E. PEURIFO_:Y, The most promising feature of the town DEPARTMENT OF STAT)!:, Deputy Under Secretary. meeting program is the attitude of the offi Washington, March 1, 1950. cials, it is pointed out. Citizens are often The Honorable WILLIAM F. KNOWLAND, severe and occasionally unfair in their crit United States Senate. . FEBRUARY 20, 1950. icism, and at some of the early meetings MY DEAR MR. KNOWLAND: I refer to your Hon. JoHN E. PEURIFOY, Deputy Under Secretary, Department of offi cials would show considerable resentment. letter of February 20, 1950, in whieh you re Now, they have not only learned to take it, quest additional information and ciarifica State, Washington, D . c. but to dish it out as well. In nearly every tion of certain points in my letter of Febru DEAR MR. PEURIFOY: Your letter of Febru c <::. se when the official. explained his side, and ary 16, 1950, concerning the processing of ary 16 h as been received in reply to mine of outlined his problems, he found the audience employees under the loyalty program. January. 26. I wish to thank you for sending sympathetic and often won the enthusiastic In answer to point ( 1) of your letter, a me the mformation and would like clarifica support of the citizens. CrJ.ticism from the total of 27 individuals resigned and 11 were tion on the following points: floor at the meetings has often led to changes removed by administrative action, i. e., re 1. In addition to the three hundred and and i.mprovements on the part of the officials duction in force, completion of assignment, twe17~y-six who are now receiving active at and their offices. etc., prior to final adju'd.ication under the tention, how many (a) resigned during the course of the investigation, or (b) were re The people have found the town meeting Pre~dent's loyalty program. This, of course, a place to get together and plan projects for does not mean that these employees were dis moved by administrative action? the betterment of their communities. loyal or were security r isks as the investiga 2. When an employee resigns while under Munich, for example, planned and carried out tions had not been completed when they left investigation or is removed as a result of a gigantic clean-up day in which more than the department. the investigation, does such a notation show 12,000 people participated. A number of With regard to point (2), when an em on his record or is he free to go to some other Government department and gain a position home building pr~jects were also organized, ployee resigns while under investigation or and frequently residents of districts joined is removed as a result of the investigation, of responsibility without the previous facts together in improving their streets, parks, that information appears in the record of being known to the employing agency? and schools, doing much of the work them the employee. The Department of State is 3. Of the 326 cases which are receiving selves in their spare time. not in a position to prevent his employment active attention will you please break them For the pur;,x>se of town meetings the city .by another Government agency. However, down to show how·many of them have been was divided into 41 districts. The county the security files of the Department of State pending for 1 month, 2 months 3 months also has 29 towns. All districts and towns are available to authorized representatives etc., up to ~ year and how many of them hav~ held at least one town meeting during the of an agencies of the executive branch of the been pendmg for over 1 year's time? past year. Government. In addition to making the With best personal regards, I remain, The largest attendance was achieved by the files available to other agencies, the Depart Sincerely yours, film program, a project that provides free ment has advised the 0ivil Service Commis . WILLIAM F. KNOWLAND. showings to schools, clubs, and communities. sl.on of the names of all individuals who A total of 2,313 showings reached a total have been investigated by the Department JANUARY 26, 1950. attendance of ~75,000. These films acquaint since September 1, 1939, and this informa Hon. DEANG. ACHESON 1 the people with democratic activities in the tion is on file in the Commission's master Secretary of State, Department of State, United States and elsewhere. . index file which is available for checking by Washington, D. c. Other outstanding features of the State other Government agencies. MY DEAR M~. SEC.RET~RY: On March 21, Department program in Munich included In those cases where an individual re 1947, the President issued Executive Order promotion of a youth .forum, which held 46 signs while under investigation by the Fed 9835 which est'ablished a procedure for the meetings with an attendance of 1,860; junior eral Bureau of Investigation for loyalty rea investigation of the loyalty of Government chamber of commerce, 16 meetings, 485 at sons, a determination as to his loyalty has employees. This order was issued 34 months tendance; traffic safety board, composed of not as yet been made. The Civil Service ago and it seems reasonable to assume that leading city officials and transportation exec Commission is advised of the resignation by a final decision should have been rendered utives, 12 meetings, 250 attendance; other the Department. In the event the individual as to the loyalty of employees who were em forums of vari011s types, 56 meetings and is employed by another agency the Civil ployed by the Department of State prior to 12,225 attendance. Service Commission loyalty review board July 1949. The Munich office also cooperated with the forwards the FBI investigative reports to the Munich Amerika Haus, the State Department employing agency for processing under the I would appreciate it if you would advise information center, in promoting forums and loyalty program. me whether there are any individual cases other events, which during the year totaled With reference to point 3 of your letter, where a final decision has not been made approximately 1,700 with an attendance of our records indicate the following break as to whether the employee is considered loyal as set out in Executive Order 9835. If more than 150,000. down of the 326 cases which are still in United States resident officers attended procesi. Since this information applies to a final determination_ has not been made, nearly all of the town meetings, and many persons who were employed by the Depart I would appreciate knowing the total num of the other events. In nearly every case, ment prior to July 1949, they have all been ber of cases not yet cleared for loyalty and however, actual organization and conduct pending at least 8 months: 21 pending for 8 the number of those who have assignments of the meetings was left to the Germans. months, 10 pending for 9 months, 18 pending in the Far Eastern Division. Americans appeared on the programs only for 10 months, 10 pending for 11 months, 10 I will be pleased to receive the above in .formation as soon as possible. when requested, or wher~ encouragement was pending for 12 months, 257 pending for a needed. period of more than 1 year. Sincerely yours, "Munich was the birthplace of the Nazi The preponderance of those cases on which WILLIAM F. KNOWLAND. party, but it was also here that the Nazi re final results have not been achieved are gime was most actively opposed," Mr. God those whose forms had been returned by frey observes. "I am convinced that there the Federal Bureau of Investigation for DEPARTMENT OF STATE, is a basic desire on the part of an increas clearer fingerprints, inaccuracies, and for Washington, February 3, -1950. ingly large number of citizens to seek what · incompleteness. The Honorable WILLIAM F. KNOWLAND, we term the democratic way of life. The It should be understood that the Depart United States Senate. enthusiasm which they have shown for the ment and its 291 field posts throughout the MY DEAR SENATOR KNOWLAND: I refer to democratization program indicates that they wol'ld initiate several thousand personnel your letter of January 26, 1950, in which you are determined to make participation in their transfers in a single year. Due to distances request certain information with regard to government and cooperation in community and time required to recontact employees, the progres:; of the loyalty program in the welfare a definite part of their lives in the a considerable time lag necessarily develops Department of State. future." between th~ initial submission of a loyalty The material requested by you is being THE LOYALTY PROGRAM form and the resubmission of a corrected gathered and wm be forwarded to you as form. soon as possible. Mr. KNOWLAND. Mr. President, I ask As I pointed out 1n my letter to you o! Sincerely yours, unanimous consent to have printed in February 16, 1950, all persons proposed !or JOHN E. PEURIFOY, the body of the .RECORD correspondence employmont in the Department and the Deputy Under Secretary which I have had with the Department Foreign Service are carefully investigated (For the Secretary of State} . 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 279~ DEPARTMENT OF STATE, the direction of the President, that all in might even endanger their lives. We regard Washi ngton, February 16, 1950. vestigative reports are confidential docu the keeping of faith with confidential in The Honorable WILLIAM F. KNOWLAND, ments of the executive department and that formants as an indispensable condition of Unit ed States Senate. congressional or public access thereto would future efficiency. MY DEAR SENATOR KNOWLAND: I refer to not be in the public interest. Disclosure of information contained in your letter of January 26, 1950, and to my This accords with the conclusions reached the reports might also be the grossest kind acknowledgment of February 3, 1950, with by a long line of predecessors in t he office of injustice to innocent individuals. In regard to the progress of the loyalty program of Attorney General and with the position vestigative reports include leads and sus in the Department of State. t aken by the President from time to time picions, and sometimes even the statements As of June 30, 1949, the Department and since Washington's administration; and this of malicious or misinformed people. Even the Foreign Service had a combined total of discretion in the executive branch has been though later and more complete reports 13,917 American employees on its rolls. Of upheld and respected by the judiciary. exonerate the individuals, the use of par this number, all of those who are presently APRIL 30, 1941. ticular or selected reports might constitut e employed have been completely processed Hon. CARL VINSON, the grossest injustice, and we all know that under Executive Order 9835, except 326 which Chai rman, a correction never catches up with an accu are receiving active attention. Two of these House Committee on Naval Affairs. sation. individuals are employed in the Bureau of MY DEAR MR. VINSON: I have your letter In concluding that the public interest Far Eastern Affairs. A careful analysis of of April 23, requesting that your committee does not permit general access to Federal the administrative operations of the Depart- be furnished with all Federal Bureau of In- Bureau of Investigation reports for infor ment's participation in the loyalty program vestigation reports since June 1939, together mation by the many congressional commit indicates that the preponderance of those with all future reports, memoranda, and car- tees who from time to time ask it, I am cases on whom final results have not been respondence of the Federal Bureau of In- following the conclusions reached by a long achieved are those whose forms had been re- vestigation, or the Department of Justice, in line of distinguished predecessors in this of turned by the Federal Bureau of Investiga- connection with "investigations made by the fice who have uniformly taken the same view. tion f.or clearer fingerprints, inaccuracies, Department of Justice arising out of strikes, Examples of this are to be found in the fol and for incompleteness. The Department subversive activities in connection with labor lowing letters, among others: and its 291 field posts throughout the world disputes, or labor disturbances of any kind Letter of Attorney General Knox to the initiate several thousand personnel trans- in industrial establishments which have Speaker of the House, dated April 27, 1904, fers in a single year. Due to distances and naval contracts, either as prime contractors declining to comply with a resolution of the time required to recontact employees, it has or subcontractors." House requesting the Attorney General to been established that a considerable time Your request to be furnished reports of furnish the House with all papers and docu lag necessarily develops between the initial the Federal Bureau of Investigation is one ments and other information concerning the submission of a loyalty form and the resub- of the many niade by congressional commit investigation of the Northern Securities case. mission of the corrected form which ls ac- tees. I have on my desk at this time two Letter of Attorney General Bonaparte to ceptable to the Federal Bureau of Investlga- other such requests for access to Federal the Speaker of the House, dated April 13, tion for its loyalty-checking purposes. Bureau of Investigation files. The number 1908, declining to comply with a resolution I should like to emphasize that in addi- of these requests would alone make com- of the House requesting the Attorney Gen tion to the Department's participation in the pllanc~ impracticable, particularly where the eral to furnish to the House information President's loyalty program all persons pro- requests are of so comprehensive a char concerning the investigation of certain cor posed for employment in the Department acter as those conta!.ned in your letter. In porations engaged in the manufacture of and the Foreign Service are inv.estigated for view of the increasing frequency of these wood pulp for print paper. security and suitability prior to appoint- requests, I desire to restate our policy at Letter of Attorney General Wickersham to ment. During these preappointment inves- some length, together with the reasons which the Speaker of the House, dated March 18, tigations available sources which would in- require it. 1912, declining to comply with a resolution dicate subversive activities are checked and It is the position of this Department, re- of the House directing the Attorney General persons are appointed only after the Depart- stated now with the approval of and at the to furnish to the House information con ment is satisfied as to their security. direction of the President, that all investiga- cerning an investigation of the smelter trust. Sincerely yours, tive reports are confidential documents of Letter of Attorney General McReynolds JOHN E. PEURIFOY, the executive department of the Govern- to the secretary to the President, dated Au Deputy Under Secretary~ ment, to aid in the duty laid upon the Pres- gust 28, 1914, stating that it would be in ( For the Secretary of Sta ) • ident by the Constitution to "take care that compatible with the public interest to send 1 the laws be faithfully executed," and that to the Senate in response to its resolution C NGRESSIONAL ACCESS TO INVE - congressional or public access to them would reports made to the Attorney General by GATIVE REPORTS AND FILES OF not be in the public interest. his associates regarding violations of law by EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS Disclosure of the reports could not do the Standard Oil Co. Mr ANDERSON. Mr. President- otherwise than seriously prejudice law en- Letter of Attorney General Gregory to the . . forcement. Counsel for a defendant or pro- President of the Senate, dated February 23, Mr: EASTLAND. Mr. President, I ask spective defendant, coUld have no greater 1915, declining to comply with a resolution unammous consent tha~ the Senator help than to know how much or how little of the Senate requesting the Attorney Gen from New Mexico be permitted to address information the Government has, and what eral to report to the Senate his findings the Senate at this time. witnesses or sources of information it can and conclusions in the investigation of the The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob- rely upon. This is exactly what these re smelting industry. jection, the Senator from New Mexico ports are intended to contain. Letter of Attorney General Sargent to the may address the Senate without taking Disclosure of the reports at this particular chairman of the House Judiciary Commit the Senator from Mississippi off the time would also prejudice the national de- tee, dated June 8, 1926, declining to com fense and be of aid and comfort to the very ply with his request to turn over to the fioor. . subversive elements against which you wish committee all papers in the files of the De Mr. A'.NDER~ON. Mr. President, I do to protect the country. For this reason we partment relating to the merger of certain not desire to interrupt debate on the have made extraordinary efforts to see that oil companies. displaced persons bill; but I should like the results of counter-espionage activities In taking this position my predecessors to make a short statement, which will and intelllgence activities of this Depart in this office have followed eminent examples. not take more than 5 minutes, with ref- ment involving those elements are kept with Since the beginning of the Government, erence to Senate Resolution 231. First, in the fewest possible hands. A catalog the executive branch has from time to time I ask unanimous consent to have in- of persons under investigation or suspicion, been confronted with the unpleasant duty . . . and what we know about them, would be of of declining to furnish to the Congress and serted m the RECORD, at this pomt, an estimable service to foreign agencies· and to the courts information which it has ac opinion by the Attorney General with information which could be so used c~nnot quire.ct and Which ts necessary to it in the reference to access to executive reports be too closely guarded. administration of statutes. As early as and files in the possession of the execu-. Moreover, disclosure of the reports would 1796, the House of Representatives request tive departments. be of serious prejudice to the future use- ed President Washington to lay before the There being no objection, the opinion fulness of the Federal Bureau of Investi House a copy of the instructions to minis was ordered to be printed in the RECORD gation. As you probably know, much of ters of the United States who negotiated a as follows. ' this information is given in confidence and treaty with Great Britain, together with the • can only be obtained upon pledge not to correspondence and other documents· relat POSITION OF THE EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT disclose its sources. A disclosure Of the ing to the treaty. In declining to comply REGARDING INVESTIGATIVE REPORTS sources would embarrass informants; some- with the request, President Washington said: It is the position of the Department of Jus- times in their employment, sometimes in "As it is essential to the due administra tice, restated now with the approval and at their social relations, and in extreme cases tion of the Government that the boundaries 2796 CONGRESSIONAL RECt>RD-SENATE MARCH -· 4 fixed by the Constitution between the dif the successful working of this system that on December-, l.7 •.:: 1947, during the time ferent departments should be preserved, a. the persons entrusted with power in any one I was serving as Secretary of Agricul just. regard _to the Constitution and to the of these branches shall n'ot be permitted to ture, I received from the committee a dut y of. my office • - • • . forbids a com-: encroach upon the 'powers confided to the subpena directing me to produce all pliance with your req~est." (See Richard· others, but t hat each shall by the law of son, Iy,Iessages and Papers of the Presidents, its creation be limited to the exercise of the records in ·the custody or control of the vol. 1, pp. 194, 196.) powers appropriate to its own department Department of Agriculture for 1946 and In 1825, the House of Representatives re and no other." 1947, giving the names of tra der s on quested President Monroe to transmit cer In appeal of Hartranft, supra, the Court boards of trade. This was in connection tain documents relating to the conduct of said: with- the hear ings on speculation in com the officers of the Navy of the United States "We had better at the outstart recognize modity markets. on t h e Pacific Ocean, and of other public the fact that the executive depart ment is a agents in South America. In his reply, coordinate branch of the Government, wit h As I indicated at that time in my testi President Monroe refused to comply wit h power to judge what should or should not be mony, I believe it was the first t ime that the request, stating that to do so might done, within its own department, and what a congressional committee had sought to subject individuals to unjust criticism; that of its own doings and communications do what Congr ess itself had not tried the individuals involved should not be cen should or should not be kept secret, and to do·, and ·my posit ion on the matter sured without just cause, which could not that with it, in the exercise of these consti was in accordance with well-established be ascertained until after a thorough and tut ional powers, the court s have no more precedent. impartial investigation of their conduct; right to _interfere, than has the executive, and that under those circumstances it was under like conditions, to interfere with the So, perhaps as the only Member of the thought that communication of the docu courts." Senate who has been served by a Sen ate ments would not comport with the public The information here involved was col~ committee with a subpena to produce interest nor with what was due t o the parties lected, and is chiefly valuable, for use by the records, I have read with exceptional in concerned. (See Richardson, Messages and executive branch of the Government in the terest the portion of the CONGRESSIONAL Papers of the Presidents, vol. 2, p. 278.) execution of the laws. It can be of little, if RECORD for February 21 and 22 with ref• Li. 1833 the Senate requested President any, value in connection with the framing erence to Senate Resolution 231, which Jackson to communicate to that body a copy of legislation or the performance of any of a paper purporting to have been read by other constitutional duty of the Congress. wa s considered while I was absent from him to the heads of the executive depart We do not undertake to investigate strikes the Senate on public business. More ments, dated September 18, 1833, relating to as to their justification or the lack of it, but particularly, I am interested in the pro the removal of the deposits of the public confine investigation to alleged violations of cedure which is to be fallowed under money from the Bank of the United States. law, including, of course, violation of stat Senate Resolution -231 for the produc President Jackson declined. (See Richard ut es designed to suppress subversive activ tion of files and records. Had I been in son, Messages and Papers of the Presidents, ity, and to general intelligence to guide ex the Chamber at the time the resolution 3, 36.) ecutive policy. Certainly, the evil which vol. p. was under consideration, I believe I In 1835 the Senate passed a resolution would necessarily flow from its untimely requesting President Jackson to commu publication would far outweigh any possible would have joined in the discussion, nicate copies of the charges, if any, which good-. which was precipitated by the majority might have been made to him against the I am not unmindful of your conditional leader when he raised a question as to official conduct of Gideon Fitz, late sur suggestion that your counsel will keep this how much privacy generally results from veyor general south of the. State of Tennes information "inviolate until such time as executive sessions of committees and the see, which caused his removal from office. In the committee determines its disposition." desirability of insuring protection to reply President Jackson again declined to I have no doubt that this pledge wo_uld be confidential information. comply. (See Richardson, Messages and kept and that you would weigh every con Papers of the Presidents, vol. 3, pp. 132, 133.) sideration before making any matte1· public. As a member of the House Committee This discretion in the executive branch Unfortunately, however, a policy cannot be on Appropriations, I served as a mem has been upheld and respected by the ju made anew because of personal confidence of ber of ·the subcommittee appointed by diciary. The courts have repeatedly held the Attorney General in the integrity and the Speaker to consider charges made that they will not and cannot require the good faith of a particular committee chair by the Dies committee against hundreds Executive to produce such papers when in man. We cannot be put in the position of of Government employees. Five mem the opinion of the Executive their production discriminating between committees or of bers of the Appropriations Committee is contrary to the public interests. The attempting to judge between them, and their courts have also held that the question individual members, each of whom has ac heard charges on the question of whether whether the production of the papers would cess to information once placed in the hap.ds it was des~rable to continue on the pay be against the public interest is one for the of the committee. roll of the Government a great many Executive and not for the courts to deter Of course, where the public interest . has people against whom the charge had · mine. (Marbury v. Madison (1 Cranch 137, seemed to justify it, information as to par been made that they belonged to sub 169 ) ; Totten v. United States (92 U. S. 195); ticular situations has been supplied to con versive· organizations and were not fit Kilbourn v. Thompson (103 U. S. 168, 190); gressional committees by me and by former persons to be on the pay roll. We inves Vogel v. Gruaz (110 U.S. 311); In re Quarles Attorneys General. For example, I have tigated literally hundreds of charges. and Butler (158 U. S. 532); Boske v. Comin taken the position that committees called gor e (177 U. S. 459); In re Huttman (70 upon to pass on the confirmation of persons It is out of that experience, Mr. Presi Fed. 699); In re Lamberton (124 Fed. 446); recommended for appointment by the At· dent, that I suggest to the Senate that In re Valecia Condensed M i lk Co. (240 Fed. torney General would be afforded col).fiden.· possibly the Senate may find the Chief 310); Elrod v. Moss (278 Fed. 123); Arnstein tial access to any information tnat we have-: Executive may refuse to honor the sub v. United States (296 Fed. 946); Gray v. Pent because no candidate's name is submitted pena. I know that I found it necessary land (2 Sergeant & Rawle's (Pa.) 23, 28); without his knowledge and the Department to decline a subpena of the United States Thompson v. German Valley R. Co. (22 N. J. does not intend to submit the name of any person whose entire history will not stand Senate when it de_manded that I produce Equity 111); Worthington v. Scribner (109 list of names. The Congress of the Mass. 487); Appeal of Hartranft (85 Pa. 433, light. By way of further illustration, I may a 445); 2 Burr Trials (533-536); see also 25 mention that pertinent information .would United States recognized the correctness Op. A. G. 326.) be supplied in impeachment proceedings, of that decision by passing the supple:. In Kilbourn v. Thompson, supra, the C'ourt ~sually instituted at the suggestion of the mentary legislation releasing me from said: Department for the good of the administra the secrecy under which I was then oper:. "It is believed to be one of the chief merits tion of justice. ating, and making it possible for me to It is for the reasons given that I feel it my of the American system of written constitu release the names. · tional law, that all the powers entrusted to duty to decline your request, believing that government, whether State of National, are in them you will find justification for my The material which I have just in divided into the three grand. departments refusal. serted in the RECORD is material which the executive, the legislative, and the ju Respectfully, was called to my attenti9n by the Solici dicial. That the functions appropriate to ROBERT H. JACKSON. tor for .the Department of Agriculture at each of these branches of Government shall that time, and it quite clearly indicates, be vested in a separate body of public serv· Mr. ANDERSON. Mr. President, ants, and that the perfection of the system Members of the Senate, especially Sen I _believe, that the conflict between the requires that the lines which separate and ators who were members of the Com legislative and the executive depart divide these departments· shall be broadly mittee on Appropriations of the Eightieth ments has been going on for a long time, and clearly defined. It is also essential tb Congress, first session, will recall that and that it has n-ever been resolved by 1950 CONGRESSIONAL . RECO-RD-· ·sENATE 2797: one group trying to · subpena · anotl:i'er· nearly all the persons whose names-were. tions of displaced persons to enter this group. before that committee would concede to country. I think it has resulted in a I need only to call attention·to the fact this day that we treated them fairly, but great number of persons being admitted that in the recent Christoffel case, on that we did not. give them what many who otherwise would not have gotten three different occasions when the judge people regard, and perhaps properly so, into the United States. · insisted upon records being produced to be their sacred right, the right to be Mr. President, I now ask unanimous from a committee of the House of Repre confronted with their accusers. The consent to yield to my friend the senior sentatives, the House; I think properly, reason we did not confront them with Senator from North Dakota [Mr. within its ·rights, refused to produce the their accusers was that it would have LANGER], with the understanding that I records. At that time I did not hear a been necessary to reveal who was em shall not lose the floor. single Member of the United States Sen ployed by th_ FBI, and who perhaps was The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob ate protest against the action of the working in a clerical capacity next to a jection, it. is so ordered. House, nor have I seen in any newspaper whole group of persons, arid who was in Mr. EASTLAND. When the Senator a protest by any Member of the Senate reality an FBI agent. I thought, and from North Dakota has concluded, I against the action of the House. It many others thought, that it would be shall yield the floor. strikes me that if the legislative branch unfortunate to reveal who these people NORTH DAKOTA STATE BONDING FUND can refuse the subpena of the judicial were who had been long trained by the branch, it confirms the view long held by FBI, and were well directed by the FBI. Mr. LANGER. Mr. President, I thank the executive branch that it in turn may While I am sure all Members of the the Senator from Mississippi for yielding refuse the subpena of the legislative Senate are trying now to work this mat to me. I call the attention of Senators, branch. ter out on a proper basis, I regret my particularly those who wish to save some I am not trying to indicate what I think· absence from the Genate at the time the money for the Government of the United the duty of the President may be, or what debate took place. There are many States, to the great success of the State he may do, or anything of that nature. matters I would have liked to comment bonding fund in the State of North Da I merely wish the .Senate fo realize that upon. kota. The law providing that the State there are people who feel quite strongly I do, however, wish to suggest that if of North Dakota itself shall write all the on this question, and who believe it is the House of Representatives can. say· bonds for the men and women who hold well within the province of the executive to the judiciary, "There are three fiduciary positions with any North Da-· branch to determine the conditions un branches of this Government, and ·the kota municipality has been in effect in der which its files may be made available. legislative will not surrender to the judi-' North Dakota for 30 years. I had intended, Mr. President to re-. ciary its files, no matter if three times Mr. President, there appeared in the . quest the insertion in my remarks of a subpenaed by a judge," then by the same February 28 issue of the Fargo Forum, letter which I wrote to the committee token it strikes me that the executive one of the leading newspapers in North which had subpenaed the records from may say . to the legislative, "I will not Dakota, a newspaper which fought the me. I find however, that it ·is carried in surrender my files, no matter how many enactment of that l}leasure, and called it the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD, in volume 93, times they may be subpenaed." socialism, an article entitled "Bonded part 9, Eightieth Congress, first session, DISPLACED PERSONS ·Unit Making Money While Giving Serv ices Free." I have the article before me December 18, 1947,·on page 11616. But I The Senate resumed the consideration call the attention of the Senate to a docu now. I particularly regret that the Sen of the bill .::1CJ f.airly. I s~ · 11 believe that eign agency would initiate the applica- official had embezzled $35,00.0, r:efused to x ::vr--176 2798 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 pay without a lawsuit. It took the people a message to the Congress yesterday in and the Vice President, who now occu of North Dakota a year and a half in volving the acute crisis in the coal situa pies the chair, knows that what I shall which to collect on a $5,000 bond, follow tion throughout the Nation. Otherwise, say now is true. At the White House ing a $35,000 embezzlement. It so dis the Senate would have taken a recess meetings which have been held every gusted the Legislature of North Dakota until Monday. Some Members of the Monday morning with the leaders of the and certain of the State officials that, Senate have asked me whether there will House and the leaders of the Senate, without appropriating one thin dime, we be a vote this afternoon upon any amend whenever the coal situation has been dis passed a law by which the State of North ment or any part of the pending meas cussed-and that has been many, many - Dakota automatically insured all State, sure, and I have assured them that there times-the President of the United States county, and municipal officials. We will not be such a vote. The Senator has repeatedly said, "I have not wanted, practically said, "At the end of the year from Illinois hopes to have the Senate and do not want, the Government of the we will send bills to each municipality recess at approximately 4 o'clock this United States to seize the mines." It was representing its proportionate share of afternoon. only in the last extremity that he sent the cost." I repeat, that was 30 years While I am on my feet, I desire to com the seizure bill to the Congress yester ago. I want every Senator to know that mend members of the Committee on day. I simply mention that to tell the for a time the amount paid by the mu Labor and Public Welfare for the dili Senate and the country of the position nicipalities was about one-third as much gence pursued by each and every one of of the President of the United States in as an old-line company would have them in dealing with the bill which was respect to his theory regarding seizure charged for writing the same fidelity in introduced yesterday by the distinguished of the mines. It was the last thing he surance.. It later decreased to approxi Senator from Utah [Mr. THOMAS]. I am desired to do, and he said so many times. mately one-tenth as much, and finally advised that the committee is still work Mr. CAPEHART. Mr. President, will North Dakota had so much money on ing on the bill and that, with the ex the Senator yield to me? hand that the legislature substantially ception of a few minor details, it will Mr. LUCAS. I yield to the Senator said, "Do not send out any notices as soon be perfected. The coal strike is from Indiana. long as we have $1,000,000 on hand." In virtually settled. Apparently, there re Mr. CAPEHART. Mr. President, I 1947 the State legislature passed the law mains now only the question of the suspect that my State of Indiana has I have- already mentioned. lawyers representing the operators as been hit as hard by the strike in the coal In the United States Government what well as those representing the union industry as any of the other States, or do we find? Only a short time ago I at• drawing up appropriate contracts. If perhaps even harder. I urge that the tended a meeting of the so-called Five that be true, and I have every reason United States Senate and the entire Con Percent Committee. I listened to testi to believe that it is, I will say to the Sen gress pass legislation which will avoid mony given before a committee·of which ate that, so far as the majority is con any similar situation in the future, and · the distinguished Senator from North cerned, there will be no pressing for the will put a stop, once a.nd for all, to the Carolina [Mr. HOEY] was chairman, emergency legislation, a draft of which kind of situation we have had in the which showed that one company had in was sent to the Committee on Labor and United States during the past 30 days. I sured some ships, the premium for them · Public Welfare yesterday. do not think we should stop now, as a amounting to over $100,000. Why should I thought I should make this an result of the coal strike settlement; I the Government of the United States nouncement, in view of the fact that think we should pass legislation giving have any of its officials insured by a pri Senators have returned to the Chamber the President of the United States, who vate company and pay a big premium, today, primarily to ascertain whether ever he may be in the future, the power when as a matter of fact it can carry its there would be any action upon that bill. to deal with such situations. own insurance in a manner similar to I said yesterday that if the bill were re We should go further, and pass legis that followed in the State of North ported and if the differences between the lation which will permanently avoid in Dakota? operators and the miners were not set the future such a situation as we have I mention this particularly because I tled, we would take up the bill at the had during the last 30 days. I think am entirely satisfied that the Govern session this afternoon. we will be derelict in our duty as Senators ment of the United States can save hun I should like to read one paragraph of if we do not do so. dreds of millions of dollars a year. I am the President's message with respect to I strongly urge that within the next 60 delighted to see sitting upon the Senate ·the present coal situation. Apiong other d_ays the Congress of the United States floor the senior Senator from Georgia things, he said: once and for all time put a stop to any [Mr. GEORGE], chairman of the Finance I am not requesting this legislation as a recurrence of such situations as we have Committee. We can save hundreds of means of settling the issues in dispute be had in the United States during the past millions of dollars a year by enacting a tween the operators and the union. They 30 days. law similar to the one which has been in will have to settle their differences through Mr. LUCAS. Mr. President, in reply effect for 30 years in North Dakota, ,..,.hich their own collective bargaining, just as to the able Senator from Indiana, let me has proved to be very effective, and though Government operation were not in say that I do not think any Member of which, as I say, has saved the taxpayers effect. I do not propose to substitute the the Senate desires to see exist in this hundreds of thousands of dollars. Government's representatives for the private operators at the bargaining table. It will country chaotic conditions or serious I might add, Mr. President, that I in not be our purpose to establish wages, hours, trouble in any Nation-wide industry, af tend to introduce a bill which will carry or working conditions which would bind fecting the health and safety of the Na out the purposes which I have described either_the operators or the miners upon re tion. I agree with the Senator from and which may be referred to the Com sumption of private operations. Indiana that if there can be devised some mittee on Finance. At that time I shall When the country can be assured of suffi plan of legislation which will definitely ask permission to appear personally in cient supplies of coal, the Government will have no need to continue public operation have the effect of preventing a national behalf of the bill. In the meantime, I emergency of this kind, it certainly ought suggest to the distinguished chairman and the mines will be promptly returned to of that committee that if he wants any private hands. to be considered. But the best minds I have stressed these essential elements in in the country anll the best minds in information as to the economies which the plan for Government operation, so that may be effected by the passage of such a the Senate have worked upon this prob there will be no misunderstanding of the lem innumerable times. Of course, we measure, I shall be glad to furnish it to legislation I am recommending. him, based upon 30 years' experience of realize that in a free country such as the sovereign State of North Dakota. Mr. President, I am certain that that ours, it is rather difficult to frame legis statement contributed greatly to the set lation which .will do the job the Senator PROGRAM FOR THE DAY-RESTORATION tlement which has been made between from Indiana would like to have done. OF NATIONAL COAL PRODUCTION the union members and the operators in So long as we have free men and free Mr. LUCAS. Mr. President, the pri the coal industry. women in this country, a person who en mary reason why the Senate is in ses I wish to add a further word, which joys the privileges of the Government of sion today is because the President sent I have not been able to say heretofore; the United States has the right to work 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RE)CORD-SENATE 2799 where he pleases and when he pleases, A factor in the deteriorating economy, of This approach was also unsuccessful in ob and no one can tell him to do otherwise. course, is Nationalist bombardment and taining their release, although additional in I say that advisedly, Mr. President. blockade. Whatever its cost in other re formation regarding their welfare was ob I said on yesterday that neither the spects, it is apparently proving to be more tained. This information was transmitted Taft-Hartley nor the emergency effective in the economic field than many to you· in a memorandum on the Smith law persons had supposed it could have been. Bender case dated January 31, ~950. The measure . now contemplated, . involving. Chiang, who was upbraided for the lack of Department has requested the assistance of seizure of the mines, would put shovels will to resist on the part of his armies, is the British Foreign Office and the Interna into the hands of the miners if they showing more than a llttle ability to resist tional Red Cross in establishing a channel did not want to work. I believe they and to do real damage with his Navy and his of communications with Chief Smith and would have worked if our Government Air Force. At the moment he is forcing the Sergeant Bender and effecting their release, had seized the mines; I believe that as Communists to lose g'round economically. and is in the meantime investigating other a patriotic duty the miners would have This is a curious and fateful reversal of avenues of approach to the Chinese Com gone back to work. But t repeat that roles. It is easy to see that the effectiveness munist authorities. of the Chinese Communist movement de 2. General Soule and his staff are st111 at it is a difficult piece of legislation to rived to a very considerable extent from the Shanghai, awaiting transportation to the draft. . fact that its attack over a long period was United States. The Chinese Communist au A number of persons-some who live not on the ·field forces of the Nationalist thorities granted them exit permits in De in my State and some who live in other Army but on th~ basic economy of the _Gov cember, but these authorities have gen sections of the country-have written to ernment of China itself. The Communists erally refused permission to foreigners in me, expressing the opinion that the Taft- · boasted that when that viable economy had the Shanghai and Nanking areas to depart Hartley law is the solution to the prob been sufficiently undermined the resistance from China via ports other than Shanghai. lem. Of course, Mr. President, everyone of the Government would fall of its own Their departure from Shanghai has been de weight, and events justified their boast. The layed indefinitely due to the Chinese Na know now that it is not the solution situation has now swung around and it is the tional Government's endeavor to close that to the problem. It utterly failed in the Communists who must try to establish and port. present crisis as a result of the court sustain a working economy for China. Their 3. All American personnel of the Con decision of Judge Keech. Neither is present outlook is not bright. sulate General in Peiping have not yet ap seizure the solution to the prolJlem, and At the same time the character of Nation plied for exit permits, according to the De that it is a most difficult matter to enact alist resistance has improved. Chiang, in partment's latest information. The Consul legislation which will be effective in such resuming the Presidency, is simply respond General in Peiping has reported that local an emergency as the one we have faced ing to the logic of forces and events. _ He has regulations stipulate that an application for rehabilitated resistance on both Hainan and an exit permit debars the applicant from re until practically today. A serious study Formosa. He has at last put the real "lib-· must be inade by the Congress to ascer questing passes for local' travel. Therefore, erals" and "reformers" into key positions. In in view of the importance of maintaining tain, if possible, a workable solution place of some of the "liberal" followers of L1 which will give fair and equitable treat Tsung-jen, who came into office on the theory contact with the Consulate General in Tien ment to the laboring man as well as that it was possible to make an honorable ts1n, especially during this period when the management. peace with the Communists and wound up in two Consulates General are finalizing their Peiping, he has put authority into the hands plans for withdrawal, only a limited num THE SITUATION IN CHINA of such acknowledged leaders as Wang Shih ber of the official personnel at Peiping have Mr. LEHMAN obtained the floor. chieh, K. C. Wu, George Yeh, C. K. Yen and applied for exit permits. The remainder of Mr. KNOWLAND. Mr. President, will O. K. Yu. In the mllitary field he has the the personnel will apply shortly before the services of skilled and imaginative command estimated date of departure. It might be the Senator from New York yield, to ers such as Chen Cheng, Hsueh Yueh and noted, in this connection, that four official permit me to make an insertion in the Sun Li-jen. Americans, including the assistant military RECORD, and to make a statement not Mao's return, in this light, must be viewed attache, have already received their exit exceeding 5 minutes in length? as something short of triumphal. He has permit and have left Peiping. Mr. LEHMAN. I am glad to yield, won some of his battles in China. He may As requested by you, there is given below provided I may have unanimous consent or may not have won his battle in Moscow. the text of the shop guaranty used by of for that purpose, without losing the He ·still has an economic and political and ficial personnel in Ambassador Stuart's party floor. military war on his hands. · when they left Nanking. This shop guar The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob anty was exec_uted by Second Secretary Ba Mr. KNOWLAND. Mr. President, I con, of the Embassy, as a personal act. jection, it is so ordered. desire to read, for the information of the Mr. KNOWLAND. Mr. President, I "I hereby execute this bond to guarantee Senate, a letter i have received from that (blank) is in truth not involved in ask unanimous consent to have printed the State Department. The letter is any unsettled civil or criminal actions nor in the body of the RECORD an editorial dated March 3, 1950, and reads as fol disputes involving payment of rents, taxes, entitled "Mao Returns to China," ap lows: or other debts, and that while he is wait pearing in this morning's New York DEPARTMENT OF STATE, ing for exit (blank) wili definitely not com Times. Washington, March 3, 1950. mit any unlawful act, otherwise, the execu There being no objection, the editorial The Honorable WILLIAM F. KNOWLAND, tor of this bond is willing to be subject to was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, United States Senate. the reserved punishment." as.fallows: MY DEAR SENATOR KNOWLAND: The follow Sincerely yours, ing information is sent to you in response MAO RETURNS TO CHINA JACK K. McFALL, to your letter of February 18: Assistant Secretary. Mao Tze-tung, chieftain of the Chinese 1. The Chinese Communists are still de Ccmmunists, is now back in his native land taining Chief Smith and Sergeant Bender Mr. President, I merely wish at this aft er his extended pilgrimage to Moscow. incommunicado, without explanation. As time to say that so far as I know it is B: cause of the fact that he went there to indicated in previous correspondence on this the only time in the history of United negotiate a treaty most of th.e emphasis upon subject, the United States Government has his return has been placed, so far, on the sent five written requests for their release States diplomatic relations with other question: What did he come back with? It to Communist authorities at Peiping. In countries that our diplomatic officials is equally pertinent to ask: What did he addition, oral and written representations have either been required to sign or have come back to? to local Communist authorities have been signed a bond of this kind in order to It is not so easy to make an appraisal of made by United States diplomatic and con leave a country. I think it a most un the exact situation, but plainly Mao comes sular representatives at Nanking, Tsingtao, back to an inflation of the same sort as that Tientsin, and Shanghai. These representa precented action that American officials which undermined the Nationalist Govern tions have been ignored by the Communist should have been required to sign such a ment of China. The promise of $60,000,000 authorities on the pretext that United States bond. I think it a most unusual action a year for ·five years that he received from the representatives in China have no official that they should have consented to the Russians won't help much to halt the al status. To fully explore evel'y possible means signing of a bond in that manner. When ready downward spiral of Communist cur of effecting their release the Department re the camel once gets his nose under the rency. Apparently the policy of forced loans quested Capt. David Jones, master of the tent, we may find that additional pres was not enough. The tactics used in forced Flying Arrow, to approach Coll).munist au rice collections and return of them "loans" thorities at Tsingtao on an unofficial basis, sure will be · put on cur p9ople in the to get moral credit ani:arently won't . wor~ requesting that the men be allowed to re future. I slw.11 h::..ve more to say about when it c ~me s to money. turn to the United -States aboard his· ship. this at a later date. 2800 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 ORDER OF BUSINESS The VICE PRESIDENT. The Senator June 22, -1949, at the northern wage Mr. LEHMAN and Mr. IVES addressed from New York asks unanimous consent conference, the United Mine Workers the Chair. that he may yield to the Senator from· began a bargaining conference at White The VICE PRESIDENT. The junior Nebraska to make a statement, with Sulphur Springs, W. Va. Senator from New York is recognized. out losing .the floor. Is there objection? June 30, 1949, nearly a· year ago, the Mr. WHERRY rose. Mr. CHAVEZ. Reserving the right to 1948 contracts expired. Mr. LEHMAN. Mr. President, the object-and I shall not object-I think July 5, 1949, the 3-day workweek junior Senator from New York will not, it unfair to a Senator who is speaking~ began. Just think of it, Mr. President, yield for the making of any statements whether it be the Senator from New York nearly a year ago, 9 months ago, the at this time. He will yield to unani or any other Senator, for another Sen 3-day workweek began, limiting the pro mous-consent requests for the introduc ator to seek to insert something in the duction of soft coal. tion of bills or the insertion of material RECORD, and th~reby interrupt the Sen From September 19 . to :November 9, in the RECORD. ator having the floor. I say this, not for 1949, a general cessation of work took Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, will the sake of any particular Senator, but place. the Senator yield? for the .sake of all Senators. I do not October 7, 1949, the Federal Media Mr. LEHMAN. I yield for the pur-. object to the request. tion and Conciliation Service entered pose I have indicated. · Mr. WHERRY and Mr. MUNDT ad the situation at a conference of all Mr. WHERRY. I ask the Senator dressed the Chair. ·parties. from New York whether he does not Mr. WHERRY. I ask unanimous con sent that the Senator from New York October 27, 1949, Truman delays. believe it fair, inasmuch as the Senator The Baltimore Sun said: has yielded for several statements, that may yield to me in order to permit me those who might like to answer some to make a statement, without prejudice President Truman said today that he would to his rights to the floor. invoke the Taft-Hartley law in the steel and of those statements should have the coal disputes if either or both created what same privilege? I should like to have The VICE PRESIDENT.. Is there ob he regarded as a national emergency. unanimous consen-i, to make a statement jection? "There is no national emergency as yet," relative to the history of the coal crisis, Mr. MUNDT. Mr. President- the Chief.Executive told his weekly news con and I ask the Senator now for that priv The VICE PRESIDENT. For ·what ference, "and until there is, the national ilege. purpose does the Senator from South emergencies . provision of the law 1s in Mr. LEHMAN. For how long a time? Dakota rise? applicable." The VICE PRESIDENT. The Sena Mr. MUNDT. I ask unanimous con The Baltimore Sun, on October 27, tor from New York and all other Sena sent that I may make a unanimous-con 1949, said further: sent request. tors have control of the floor when they The President made it clear that it would occupy it. They cannot yield-- The VICE PRESIDENT. Only one be he who would make the determination Mr. WHERRY. I ask unanimous con unanimous-consent request can be pend as to when ·and if a national emergency had sent to be permitted to make a statement ing at a time. The question is is there been created by shortages of coal and steel. that will require not to exceed 10 min objection to the request of the' Senator from New York that he be allowed to October 27, 1949. The coal strike is in utes. its thirty-ninth day. The VICE PRESIDENT. Let the yield to the Senator from Nebraska for Chair finish his statement, please. The the purpose indicated? The Chair November 17, 1949. Truman delays. S::mator from New York can yield, or not hears none. The New York Times said: yield, as it suits his pleasure or conven Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, will the The Federal Mediation and Conciliation Senator yield? Service turned over the coal case to the ience, for any purpose. He cannot yield White House yesterday. The dispute has a even for the insertion of matters in the Mr. LEHMAN. The junior Senator history of nearly 6 months, including a 52- RECORD or for the introduction' of bills, from New York, of course, yields. day strike, and seems no nearer solution than except by unanimous consent. He can HISTORY OF THE COAL CRISIS ever. only yield for a question. After yielding Mr. Truman implied _he was in no hurry to to other Senators, he may discontinue Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, I get into the case. He was asked whether he the yielding, if lie sees fit to do so. The thank the distinguished Senator from was giving John L. Lewis a chance to work Senator from New York and all other New York for his sportsmanship and for out a settlement before using the Taft-Hart Senators have complete control of the the fair play he has accorded the Sena- ley law. tor from Nebraska. · The President replied th~t the emergency Senate floor while they occupy it. Does for the Taft-Hartley law had not arrived, and the Senator from New York yield to the A few moments ago, I heard from the that when he got to that bridge he would Senator from Nebraska? lips of the majority leader a defense of cross it. · Mr. LEHMAN~ The junior Senator the inaction of the President in regard has yielded, with the understanding, of to solving the coal strike. I repeat what December 3, 1949. United Mine Work course, in every instance, that it was I said yesterday that, in my humble ers announce signing of contracts with based upon a request for unanimous opinion, had there been a will to settle a few operators. , consent, to permit the insertion of cer the strike 2 or 3 months ago, as. much December J?, 1949. 'J.'hree-day week tain mate.rial in the RECORD. could have been accomplished then as again --instituted. Mr. WHERRY. Oh. was accomplished yesterday, without December 22, 1949. Truman delays. . Mr. LEHMAN. It is perfectly obvious even suggesting seizure legislation or a The Baltimore Sun sai~: that that has not been observed. great many other kinds of legislation President Truman said today that he would Mr. WHERRY. That is correct. which are now being advocated. I want take necessary a-ction if the coal strike short Mr. LEHMAN. If it is understood the RECORD to show that. I also want the age reach ed the emergency stage. that the junior Senator from New York RECORD to show the history of the coal However, the President would no"t venture does not lose his place in connection with crisis, about which Senators have been an opinion on whether the 3-day week John talking. L. Lewis is permitting in most of the coal the debate on the pending question, I industry is providing enough coal. shall of course be very glad to yield to May 25, 1949, nearly a year ago, at the Senator from Nebraska. the southern wage conference, . the Even. then, Mr. President, requests Mr. CHAVEZ. Mr. President- United Mine Workers began a bargain were coming in that coal be furnished in The VICE PRESIDENT. For what ing conference at Bluefield, W. Va. different sections of the Nation. purpose does the Senator from New June 8, 1949, a "brief stabilizing period _I proceed with article from the Balti Mexico rise? of inaction" was proposed for· the week more Sun: Mr. CHAVEZ. I thought the Senator of June 13 to 20. He also would not say whether he consid from Nebraska requested unanimous June 13, 1949, the captives and the ered the short week a sufficiently serious consent. United Mine Workers began a bargain threat to bi'ing the situation within the Mr. WHERRY. . I did. ing conference at Philadelphia. provisions of the Taft-Hartley Act. 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2801 The next date is December 28. The have the facts, and, given the facts, they will HICKENLOOPER], and the Senator from junior Senator from Nebraska, having make the right answer. Maine [Mr. BREWSTER]. gone from one end of the country to the "In foreign policy the Truman adminis tration has bypassed the people and Con On January 12, 1950, Truman delayed other, realized the seriousness of the gress, and especially the Senate. The Con while 90,000 workers were out of the pits national emergency which th~n existed stitution makes the Senate an integral part entirely in spontaneous strikes. by reason of the . coal strike, and the of our country's fore~gn policy making.'' I read now from the New York Herald junior Senator from Nebraska is quoted POLICY SHOULD BE DEBATED Tribune: in the Washington Star as saying: "Too frequently the administration has Despite an industry estimate that coal "It ls obvious," said Senator WHERRY, "that gone ahead and made commitments to for stocks at the end of this week will be at the industrial productivity of this country eign governments. Congress has been put their lowest point in 15 years, President Tru cannot long continue in high gear on the in the position of approving these agree man insisted today that there is still no meager tricl{le of soft coal that is now being ments or causing great damage to our pres national emergency in the coal situation. mined. tige abroad by repudiating them. His statement, in reply to a reporter's press "Unless the President acts; and acts forth "Of course, every thinking person , .. ants conference question, rejected for the time rightly, there will be a very serious industrial the United States to present a united na being demands by coal industry leaders and crisis within a few weeks." tional front to the world. But before the Members of Congress, including some leading Mr. President, I ask unanimous con President commits this country to a policy, Democrats, that he invoke the Taft-Hartley Congress and the people should have ample law's 80-day injunction pro:visions for han sent that all of the Washington Star opportunity to debate it and thresh it out. dling national-emergency strikes or strike item of December 28 be made a rart of The end result will be a united front." threats. my remarks at this point. A similar view was expressed recently by The President was asked: "Have you There being no objection, the article Senator VANDENBERG, Of Michigan, Republi reached .any new decision whether there is was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, can leader in foreign affairs. an emergency in coal that would warrant as follows: "Every foreign policy must be totally de using the Taft-Hartley Act?" WHERRY CALLS TRUMAN NEGLIGENT IN HAN bated,'' Senator VANDENBERG said, "and the "There is no national emergency in coal · DLING OF COAL SITUATION-SENATE GOP loyal opposition is under special obligation at the present time,'' he replied. to see that this occurs.'' He told reporters LEADER HITS BIPARTISAN POLICY, DEMANDS On January 18, 1950, counsel for the ECA SLASH there should be an "unpartisan" foreign policy in which neither party sought politi NLRB moved in court to end work stop President Truman was charged with "de c::i.l advantage. He said this would call for pages in suppqrt of alleged illegal de· . plorable negligence" in his handling of the . frank cooperation and free debate in reach niands in bargaining. coal situation by Senate Republican Leader ing a united front. WHERRY on his return to Washington for the January 20, 1950, Truman delays. The coming session of Congress. WANTS FULL ACCOUNl'ING Washington Post said: Senator WHERRY said yesterday the Presi Senator WHERRY insisted, too, that the peo The Chief Executive told a White House dent had not used his full power to restore ple must have a full accounting for every press conference that he, and he alone, will full-time production of coal; that he had dollar spent "in the billions upon billions of decide if and when ·there is an [coal] emer refused to invoke the provisions of the Taft their money that has been scattered over the gency. Hartley Act, apparently for political reasons. world.'' When the time comes, he will declare an Senator WHERRY also struck at the present . "There has not been enough nonpartisan emergency and take whatever f'.Ction neces bipartisan foreign policy, and demanded that approach in our foreign policy," he con sary, Mr. Truman said. ECA appropriations at the coming session of tinued. "Neither Congress nor the Ameri The President also said yesterday that he Congress te cut at least $1,500,000,000 below can people were consulted in the adminis had nothing whatever to do with the injunc the apprcpriations made by the first session tration's betrayal of China into the hands tion suit .filed against Lewis and the UMW of the Eighty-first Congrern. of the Moscow Communists of China. Some by an executive arm of the Government. He challenged the administration forces to day our country and the world may pay bring the antilynching bill before the Senate dearly for this tragic blunder, this coddling On January 25, 1950, James Boyd, Di during the first week of the session, assert of the Communists. rector of the Bureau of Mines, · told the ing that of all the civil-rights bill~ it was · . "Congress should take a firm hold on ECA. Senate Labor· Committee: ' the easiest tp get through the Upper House. W.e should be thinking of procedures for the . ·u .nless. there is an imme9-iate resumption SEES INDUSTRIAL EMERGENCY transformation from the present gifts and grants policy out of the pockets of the Ameri of substantially increased coal production, ''.All the administration and its lieutenants can taxpayer to resumption of private enter- tlie ·national· economy, health, and welfare 1:q Congress have done on civil-rights legis prise;" · ' is now or soon wiH ·be imperHed. · lation," said WHERRY, "is jus.t to talk about -· . ., it, promise, promise, and promise." URG:i:S JOINT COMMITTEE On Januar.y.27, 1950, the.Senate Com- ·Going further into the coal situation, Sen "Productivity of the ECA countriE.s i;:; now mittee on Labor and Public Welfare · ator WHERRY said the President's statement · above prewar · 1evels. The economic· prob.; postponed indefj.nltely · tl:ie c.o.nsidera- : lems that ccnfront these countries · can be that there is no emergency does not square · tipn of 'ser>:ate-Cpncµrre~t Resoltition:68 .· with statements that have come to him. solved ·only by- themselves ~ A reducti'on of ·"It is obvious,'' said Senator WHERRY, "that $1-,500,000,000 in the ECA appropriation for a1;1king the President .to invoke the Taft- · the industrial productivity of this country the next fiscal year is amply wa,rranted by Hartle·y law. · · · · cannot long continue in high gear on the conditions in the ECA countries and by the . Janu;:i,ry 31, 1S50, Truman delays. meager trickle of soft coal that is now being deficit of the United States budget.'' · . The New York Times said: Senator WHERRY called for the creation of mined. President .Truman moved into the soft "Unless the President acts, and acts forth a Joint Committee of the :Hom:e a~d Senate coal ~ispute today with a proposal -that Joh:n rightly, there will be a very serious industrial on Government Expenditures similar to the crisis within a few weeks." present Joint Committee on Internal Reve L .. ·Lewis .aJ:?-P.. the OJ?epi.tors ~ail .a 70:daY truce and submit their arguments to a fact Senator WHERRY also demanded. that the nue Taxation, with an ample staff. At -pres- 1 Federal tax · structure be given a . th_orough fil!ding board. He asked for an anf?wer by . ent, he said, Congre.ss is badly equip_p~d t.o tj.o 5 p. m. Saturday. · · · · · overhauling, and tha£ the wartime excise an e·tficient Job. ~n apprqpriations. H~ _ ap taxes be · repealed. ' prov'ed the idea of a single omnibus appro- Under the 'truce "normal" production of pr~ation biil. · . coal would· be ·resumed.- This was under URGES BALANCED .BUDGET stood -t<:> -mean a return to the 5-day work- , "The people want the cost of Government Mr. WHERRY. . Mr. President, on Jan week. by the members of the -United Mine cut drastically,'' he said. "And they want miry 11, 1950, Senate Concurrent Reso Workers, ·hea.d!'!d by Mr. Lewis. The wage the budget balanced. Instead of talking scale of the ~xpired union contract would be about increasing taxes, to give the spend lution 68, calling upon the President· to use the emergency powers of. the Taft paid. A board of three would make recom.. thrift Socialists more money to squander, mehdations in 60 days, but the recommen- Congress should bring the budget into _bal Hartley Act, was introduced by the Sen da·tions would not be binding. · · ance by cutting expenditures to fit the cloth ator from Michigan ·[Mr. FERGusoNJ., the . . - . . ., ~ . ' of.revenue." . . Senator from Ohio [Mr. TAFT], the Sen On February 4, 1950, a 70-day truce The foreign policy of the United States, ator from Wisconsin [Mr. WILEY], the was reject~d by Lewis. Senator WHERRY said, should spring from th·e will of the people. · · · Senator from Missouri [Mr. DONNELL]. .On February. 6, 1950, Mr. Truman in· "Before any J'ne of policy is adopted by the the Senator from Indiana [.Mr. JENNER], voked the Taft-Hartley law and 370,000 administration," he declar-ed, "it should be the S:mator fr.om Pennsylv8.nia [Mr. w~rkers began a· Nation-wide work stop presented to the people. · The people must MARTIN], the Senator· from Iowa [Mr. pag e. · 2802 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 In my opinion, Mr. President, if that years, and that he thereby bears a heavy ployment, discomfort and danger which law had been invoked 3 months prior to share of responsibility for the mass unem hav.e a.ffi.icted the American people. And the the time it was invoked, and there had ployment, discomfort, and danger which people will not forget. have affiicted the American people. And the • DISPLACED PERSONS been a will to enforce it, we would not people will not forget. have had the emergency which now The Senate resumed the consideration exists. I think the American people, to There being no objection, the entire of the bill Berlin Document Center or a check HAM in the chair). Does the Senator or another n;ian came to a hearing and from· the Provost Marshal's Office to see from New York yield to the Senator from made an informal statement or whis whether any of the displaced persons who Indiana? pered into the ear of this Senator or that are coming to this country, and who are Mr. LEHMAN. For a question. Not Senator; but there was no proof. !'asked being processed, are Communists? for a speech or a statement. but for a. time and time again, "Give me the proof Does not the Senator from New York question which I will answer. of this." know that the head of the Displaced Per Mr. JENNER. Very well. Does the Mr. JENNER. Mr. Tripp testified at sons Commission in Europe testified last CIC, when the name of a displaced per a public hearing, and his .testimony is a night before the Senate Committee on son is referred to it for investigation, matter of public record. He is the one the Judiciary that the Commission is fol wait for the report from the Berlin Doc who said there are 30,000 doubtful dis lowing a calculated risk program, and ument Center or from the provost mar placed persons in this country. that he admitted to the members of the shal's office? Mr. LEHMAN; Let me point out to Senate committee last night that sub Mr. LEHMAN. In reply to that ques the Senator from Indiana that a great versives and criminals were coming into timi, I can say that of 134,000 immigrants point was made by the Senator from Mis this country, and that he knew that to admitted thus far to this country under sissippi [Mr. EASTLAND] that the chief be so? The witness said, however. the displaced persons law, only in the of the Visa Division of the State Depart "Don't worry about that. Such persons case of 70 were the papers representing ment, Mr. L'Heureux, had made certain can be deported." the investigation of the CIC not ap statements and asked that certain pro Does not the Senator from New York pended at the time of the arrival of the visions b.e included in the bill. I asked, know that, although known criminals immigrant into this country.. "Where IS the record of that?" Oh, no, have been brought in under the process Let me further state to the Senator Mr. President; the Senator did not give it. ing by the Displaced Persons Commis and he should know this--that there Mr. JENNER. But I have here the sion, there has not been a single de have been only three cases out of the record of Mr. Tripp's testimony, 1f the portation? 134,000 in which the immigrant has been Senator from New York wishes to have it. I know the Senator from New York accused of fraud or moral turpitude and Mr. LEHMAN; I shall be glad to have wants to be fair. That, at least, is some in which proceedings have. been taken it, because time after time the Senator C1ing which must be brought out. for his deportation to his native country. from Mississippi told the Senate that no 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2805 record of that was kept, but that the wit Mr. LEHMAN. Very well; that is a read more of his statement. The Sen ness came to the committee and the com ·fair question, and it deserves an answer. ator from New York is doing exactly mittee members talked informally, I Mr. JENNER. I think it should be what · the Senator from Mississippi did even pointed out that it was an unusual cleared up. yesterday. He wishes to develop his procedure for a committee which was Mr. LEHMAN. I will answer that in case. supposed to be holding a public hearing. my speech within the next 10 minutes. Mr. EASTLAND. .But the Senator Mr. CAIN. Mr. President, will the Mr. JENNER. Very well. from New York has used my name. Senator yield for a question? Mr. CAIN. Mr. President, will the Mr. LEHMAN. I certainly used the Mr. LEHMAN. I yield for a question; Senator yield for one more question? Senator's name, and I am perfectly will yes. Mr. LEHMAN. I yield for a question; ing ·to rest on the record which was Mr. CAIN. The Senator from New yes. made. That is what the CONGRESSIONAL York has expressed his own amazement Mr. CAIN. I simply wish to know RECORD is for. I have already told the at what he considered to be the stagger whether the reference the Senator from Senator that there were inaccuracies ing number of misstatements made on New York has just made to ·a given ex time and time again in the statements the floor of the United States Senate ample of what he considers to be an in made by the Senator in denying that the yesterday. Because a considerable num accurate statement made yesterday, screening was carried on by the consular ber of the Members of this body, of whom constitutes his resume of the many in service and by the Immigration and the Senator from Washington is one, are accurate statements made yesterday, as Naturalization Service, and claiming that endeavoring to understand and appre he has stated. the full authority and sole authority ciate every facet of this extremely dif Mr. LEHMAN. By no means. rested in the hands of the Displaced ficult, delicate, and complicated ques Mr. CAIN. I thank the Senator. Persons Commission. tion, I ask the Senator from New York Mr. LEHMAN. But that was the Mr. EASTLAND. Then the Senator whether he will be so kind a::. to state most important one, because it was the from New York desires to rest on a for the benefit of the RECORD, which a thesis of the Senator from Mississippi, misquotation; is that correct. He mis number of us will study in considering namely, that there was not sufficient se quoted me, and I now understand that this case, and to outline precisely, in curity. I propose to show in my own he wishes to rest on a misquotation. detail, his charges of misinformation and words that, in addition to what I have Is that correct? inaccurate statements or inaccurate ex read, displaced persons are going Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from amples which, according to what the . through the most rigorous inspection Mississippi can take the floor at the con Senator from New York has said in the and check that have ever been carried clusion of my remarks and can point past few minutes, were given by .so many on in immigration matters in this out where the Senator from New York other Senators on the floor of this body country. misquoted the Senator from Mississippi. yesterday. In addition to the seven rigid and new procedures carried on, and to which I Mr. EASTLAND. Mr: President, I Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from New congratulate the Senator from New York will be very glad, indeed, to inform have already referred, it is not conceiv able York, if that is an indication of his fair the Senator from Washington. The that the Catholic Church, the Fed ness. statement was made by the Senator eral Council of Churches of Christ in America, the Synagogue Council of Mr. LEHMAN. Does the Senator from Mississippi and, I think, by other from Mississippi wlsh the Senator from Senators who have spoken, that the sole America, and all the other major re ligious groups in the United States would New York to read the statement he put authority for the admission of the dis into the RECORD yesterday? It will take placed persons into this country rested be strongly supporting a program which would permit the infiltration of Commu- time to do so, and of course it is quite with the IRO, the International Refugee available to the Senator from Mississippi. Organization, and with the Displaced . nists into the United States. Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, will Mr. EASTLAND. I have read the Persons Commission. When I sugg-ested statement, but the Senator from New the inaccuracy of that statement, and the Senator yield for a question? Mr. LEHMAN. I yield for a question. York has just stated that I said the pointed out that the final authority and Immigration and Naturalization Service power rested with the Immigration and Mr. EASTLAND. I have just returned to the floor, and I am informed that the did no screening. What I said was that Naturalization Service and with the there was no adequate screening by consular service of the State Depart Senator from New York has stated that the Senator from Mississippi made them; and that they were bound, under ment, my assertions were denied. I had the elements that qualify under the the greatest difficulty, as some of my col numerous inaccurate statements yester day. I should like to have the Senator Displaced . Persons Act, by the deci leagues may recall, in obtaining per sion of the Displaced Persons Commis mission from the Senator from Missis from New York list the statements which he says are inaccurate. sion. I submit that that statement is sippi to insert into the RECORD state accurate. ments made on the authority of the head Mr. LEHMAN. The able Senator from Mississippi will recall that yesterday I Mr. LEHMAN. Very well. It is in the of the Immigration and Naturalization RECORD, and our colleagues can form their Service and the Chief of the Visa Divi refuted beyond any question or beyond any argument his statements -that the own judgment from what is in the REC sion of the State Department. I finally ORD. As I said yesterday, I am very will obtained that permission, and I inserted displaced persons coming into the United States under the Displaced Persons Act ing to rest my case on it. that statement into the CONGRESSIONAL Mr. EASTLAND. Where are the nu RECORD, where any Senator or any mem were not screened, first, by the Immi gration and Naturalization Service and, merous statements which the Senator ber of the public who has access to the from New York says are inaccurrate? CONGRESSIONAL RECORD can read it. second, by the consular· service. I put that into the RECORD. The Senator from Mr. LEHMAN. The Senate can form Mr. JENNER. Mr. President, will the Mississippi may go through the RECORD. its own judgment. Senator yield at this point? I said yesterday, in the presence of the Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, will Mr. LEHMAN. I yield for a question. Senator from Mississippi and other Sen the Senator yield for a question? Mr. JENNER. I think this is one of ators, that I was willing to rest my case The PRESIDING. OFFICER. Does the the points that is really confusing to all and his case on the RECORD, and that is Senator from New York yield to the Members of the Senate who have not what I propose to do. Senator from Nebraska? followed this subject closely: Is it not I intend now to develop. the evidence Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. correct that the Immigration officials which will show the extent and the thor Mr. WHERRY. Is my understanding and those in charge of the issuance of oughness with which the inspection is · correct that the Senator will comply with visas, for the State Department, have carried on. the answer he gave to the S3nator from jurisdiction over the immigration laws, Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, will Washington and will place in the REC but not over the Displaced Persons Com the Senator yield? ORD the inaccuracies in detail? mission? There is the conflict, it seems Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from Mr. LEHMAN. No, the Senator from to me. New York will not yield until he has N::!w Yo :rk did not say th:'..t. 2806 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 Mr. WHERRY. What did the Sena Mr. President, if I may answer the B. The displaced person's documents tor say? question of the Senator from Washing must be checked to determine whether Mr. LEHMAN. The junior Senator ton, who asked me about secret methods they are fraudulent or authentic. · said he would outline and sketch and pursued and the checks that are made, This CIC procedure should dispose, describe the procedure that is being fol I intend to cover that in my address. once and for all, of any claims that no lowed from the time an application is Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, will American official checks on the authen made by a displaced person for admis the Senator yield for a question? ticity of documents. Certainly no one sion to this country, until he arrives Mr. LEHMAN. No; if the Senator will is better equipped in these two fields than here. The Senator from New York in permit, I shall not yield at this time. the Counter Intelligence Corps of the tends to do that at this moment. I want to put this material in the REc United States Army, the so-called CIC. Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, will the GRD, after which I shall be glad, indeed, There has crept into these debates the Senator yield further, that I may ask to yield for as long a time and as fre innuendo, if not the assertion, that the a clarifying question? quently as the Senator from Mississippi Displaced Persons Commission ignores The PRESIDING OFFICER. Does the may wish. the security findings of the CIC. I am Senator from New York yield to the Sen Mr. EASTLAND. Very well. advised that this is completely untrue. ator from Nebraska? Mr. LEHMAN. It is not' conceivable The fact is this: Where the CIC reports Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. that the Catholic Church, the Federal that it appears that a person is a mem Mr. WHERRY. I should like to ask C::mncil of Churches of Christ in Amer ber of or has participated in a movement the distinguished Senator whether he ica, the Synagogue Council, and all. the hostile to the United States or the form does not feel that it is imperative; inas major religious groups in the United of government of the United States, such much as some of the hearings are not finding is regarded by the Displaced Per available, and in view of the fact that States would be supporting a program sons Commission as conclusive. Apart he made the charge that there were in which would permit the infiltration of from human errors, the Displaced Per accuracies in the statements not only Communists into the United States. sons Commission has always rejected of the Senator from Mississippi but of After careful study of the whole prob every person whom the CIC found to be other Senators, that he should state what lem, the special subcommittee of the a possible security risk. This is the Dis those inaccuracies are? If we are to House Judiciary Committee, in a docu- . placed Persons Commission's rule, and make up our minds on what the issue ment known as No. 1507, issued only last has been the instruction to all Displaced is, it would be most helpful to have the month, reported as follows: Persons Commission employees. complete viewpoint of the Senator from The number of screening agencies, screen· Mr. President, we all have been hear New York, as well as that of the Sena ing sessions, interrogations, investigations, ing and speaking at great length about and checks that a displaced person must tor from Mississippi. pass before reaching the United States is this displaced-persons program and the Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from New so extensive that the chances of a fraudulent displaced-persons legislation. Allega York has already stated the basic and statement or a forged document to slip tions were made before the Senate Ju main inaccuracies, and he put the state through is practically nil. diciary Committee about the calculated ment in the RECORD yesterday. I refer risks to our national security that we to the denial by the Senator from Mis Two specific <.,harges were made on are taking with these displaced persons, sissippi that the screening was done by this floor Wednesday. The first is that and the allegedly loose way in which the the Immigration and Naturalization the CIC's security screening is curtailed program has been administered by the Service and by the consular service, and to exclude investigation as to the au Displaced Persons Commission. his further statement that full authority thenticity of documents, with particular I think we may have become lost in a over displaced persons rested in the reference to alleged date-line, frauds. forest of words and symbols. We have hands of the Displaced Persons Commis This is not so. I again direct the atten heard so much about the DP Commis sion and the IRO. Those are inaccura tion of the Senate to the report of the sion, the IRO, the INS, and the many cies, which I pointed out. I put the House Judiciary Subcommittee, where other alphabetical agencies that we may proof of those inaccuracies into the there is reprinted testimony of the CIC's have lost sight of the actual individuals RECORD. Beyond that, the RECORD . is supervising officer overseas. On page 73 involved. We may have lost sight of the complete, and every Senator can read it. of this report you will find a copy of a physical process-the long and almost Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, will the CIC work sheet, which includes this line: endless process, which has been estab Senator yield for a further question? 3. Interrogation of subject. lished to evaluate, screen, and process Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. (a) Discrepancies from information listed these displaced persons. Mr. WHERRY. As I understand the on registration forms. It is a long process, and to the indi distinguished Senator from New York, The testimony shows that the CIC in viduals involved, no doubt a heart the inaccuracy which is really basic is terviews every single displaced person breaking one. If we Americans were the one he has just discussed. I think and conducts a neighborhood check on subjected to any such procedure in order I understand the Senator's viewpoint on every single displaced person. to get a visa to go abroad, or to get any that particular issue. Will the Senator In order to learn just exactly what this thing, we would complain-as many of say it is the main point with respect to interview encompasses, I have taken the us do anYWay-that here is bureaucracy which misrepresentation has been made, trouble to study the CIC's procedure for raised to its most maddening degree. or is there something else that is as vital investigation of immigrants, which was Yet we have heard in the Senate, in the as that, which the Senator has in his instituted on November of 1948, at the course of this debate, that there is not mind at this time? outset of this program. Since this docu enough bureaucracy, the process is not Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from New ment is classified and I have not had long or careful enough, that not enough York will answer the Senator from Ne .. enough time to request that it be de caution and delay are involved. braska by saying that the inaccuracies classified, I will not put it in the RECORD. I have prepared a· skeleton descrip which have just been pointed out are ex However, I am authoritatively informed tion of the various steps which an indi tremely important, and that they go to that the CIC has instructed its agents vidual in Germany, Austria or Italy has the heart of the matter. that in interviewing a displaced person- to take in order to come to the United Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, will A. The interrogation must include in States as a displaced person, and the the Senator yield for a question? quiry as to items of personal history processes to which his application is Mr. LEHMAN. In a moment. The listed on the registration form. As indi subjected. Senator from New York will not charac cated in the above-indicated testimony, I should like to describe this process to terize the importance of various state the purpose in part. is to determine the the Senate, so that my colleagues and ments made on the floor, which are in truth or falsity of such statements, in the country may judge whether the the RECORD. Every Senator has a right cluding, of course, such statements as .screening process is perfunctory or in to read the RECORD and may reach his relate to date lines and entry into the adequate--and please remember that own conclusions. areas in question; and this is a skeletonized description: 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2807 . First. The DP makes .known that he · Fourteenth. Simultaneously, pertinent Twenty-first. Simultaneously, the DP is a candidate for emigration to the . data on the DP is forwarded by the DP and his family are called for and from United States and requires an assurance Commission to the United States consul the camp or other place of residence to by- for checking agaip.st lookout records and tha resettle:ment center. ( a) Registering with a United States other information for special sources. Twenty-second. The DP and his fam voluntary agency; · · Fifteenth. Simultaneously, a form ily are given thorough medical exam (b) Communicating directly with containing complete data on the DP and inations by the United States Public Iriends or relatives in the United States; his family is forwarded to Washington Health Service, including chest X-rays or for submission to and check by the FBI. and serology tests. (c) Registering with !RO for eventual , Sixteenth. In the case of Czechoslo. Twenty-third. The DP and his family interview by the selection unit of the DP vakian refugees being considered under arJ called in bi a United Sktes vice cor.. Commission. section 2 (d) of the act, a similar form sul for a preliminary examination with S2cond. The DP awaits nomination on is forwarded to the United States consul respect to existence of appropriate and an assurance or selection by. DP Com for an additional special and confiden necessary documents. mission. tial investigation. Twenty-fourth. The DP and his fam · Third. After the necessary assurance Seventeenth. The CIC initiates its in ily are scheduled to reappear before the is given, the DP is called into the !RO vestigation, which includes- vice coL3Ul when fl:.ll consular examina resettlement office for the preparation (a) Check against CIC central regis tion is made for admissibility under nor of his documentation. try files for security and other infor mal immigration laws; the application is Fourth. Complete fingerprints of the mation. signed at this time, and the DP ·must DP and his family are taken on official (b) Check against CIC area registry swear as to the veracity of statements provost marshal forms, in duplicate. files for security and other information. contained in his file. If all is in order, Fifth. Photographs are prepared for I wish to point out, Mr. President, that the visa is made out. · each family member. what I am now reading, starting ·with Twenty-fifth. The DP and his family Sixth. The DP and his family are given (a), which wm ·continue to (j) involves are scheduled for examination by an in preliminary medical examination · by checks which CIC, a highly important spector of the Immigration and Natur IRO doctors. branch of the United States Army, makes alization Service, to whom the visa and Seventh. A resettlement registration routinely and intensively on all displaced · entire case file are passed. form is prepared, showing vital statistics, persons. Twenty-sixth. The Immigration and date of first entry into one of required (c) Check against Berlin Document Naturalization Service innpector reviews areas, employment history, data of dis- . Center records for information relating the case file and examines applicants for placement on .persecution, educational to German citizenship, Nazi Party affilia- · admissibility under normal immigration - background, documents available, dates. tions, or miscellaneous Nazi group activi laws and accuracy of all other factors of first registration with Army, UNRRA ties. relating to his immigration under Public or mo. 'rhis is signed by the DP. (d) Check against military govern L·aw 774. When approved, the visa is en Eighth. The DP returns to his camp or ment court records for information on dorsed by the examining inspector. other place of residence to await further arrests and convictions. Twenty.-seventh. The DP and his fam call. Meanwhille he is assisted by IRO ( e) Check against German police rec ily are scheduled -for transport to the legal officers in preparing affidavits and ords for information on arrests and port of embarkation and are placed on translations of documents on vital sta convictions. the shipping list for departure. tistjcs and civil status required by United (f) Provost marshal analysis of finger Twenty-eighth. Prior to embarkation, . states consuls. prints for establishing identities against the DP and his family are given a further, Ninth. The resettlement i·egistration previous applications for visas on crim- \ last minute medical examination by IRO · form is checked by the !RO against his inal records. doctors. original care and maintenance form at (g) Check against !RO local camp · Twenty-ninth. Upon arrival at United the !RO control center, co:'ltaining in States port, the DP receives a United · formation gathered at the time of his records for information relating to States Public Health S8rvice debarkation · original registration. Any discrepan identity and behavior. check. cies are noted on the registration form. (h) Interview by United States Army Thirtieth. Upon arrival at ·a United Certification of !RO eligibility is then CIC agent with the DP agent with the States port, the DP receives an Immi added by the IRO international officer. DP and his family, covering information gration and Naturalization debarkation · Tenth. The DP must procure a good contained in registration form, estab check. conduct certificate from the camp police lishment of identity, examination of I must emphasize that these 30 steps chief or, if he is an out-of-camp resi documents, comparison of fingerprints, are those which occur when no-I repeat, dent, from the German or Italian or and any other information that may be no-disqualifying, contradictory, or de Austrian police authorities. adduced. rogatory factors or information emerges. Eleventh. The !RO forwards the reg (i) Interview by United · States Army When unfavorable evidence does develop, istration form, fingerprints, photo CIC agent with at least three neighbors further investigative steps are taken and graphs, good-conduct certificate, medi of the DP, covering identity, behavior, the case is not concluded until all ques cal-examination report, documents ·on and general reputation of applicant. tions are satisfactorily resolved. If any vital statistics, affidavits, and any other (j) Investigation of any leads which doubt remains, the case is disqualified pertinent papers, to the DP Commission may develop. and the applicant is rejected. area office. Those are all parts of the CIC pro- · I have described the process in areas Twelfth. The DP Commission officer cedure. · where the United States Army CIC op reviews the entire documentation to de Eighteenth. The case file js returned erates. Similar sources of information termine existence of basic qualifications to the DP Commission by the CIC with are used in other areas and, with minor for preliminary determination of eligi the report of the investigation. differences in procedures, the same proc bility. If considered necessary, the DP Nineteenth. The DP Commission offi ess appl.ies. and his family are called into DP Com cer, other than the one who determined Now, Mr. President, it would be my . mission area office for interview. preliminary eligibility, reviews the entire judgment that I have disposed of the Thirteenth. If all documents and file, including basic eligibility and inves- : argument that insufficient security facts comply with the law, the r.egl,lla tigative report. If all factors are favor screening is provided in the admission tions and directives, the DP Commission able, he writes a report accordingly. of these displaced persons. I would say officer makes a notation of prelimillary Twentieth. The Commission's report that every possible effort is being made eligibility and the file is forwarded to the and entire case file is forwarded to the to screen these applicants and to reject Counter Intelligence Co ~· ~, of the United United· States consul for consideration the unworthy or even thcce regarding Ctates Army. · in the DP's application for a visa. whom doubt existed. I v;cal!.1 not \'! cm~ 2808 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE. MARCH 4 to tear down this machinery and build good, sound, loyal, hard-working Amer these people were expelled from Czecho new and different machinery. If there · icans, Mr. President, I am proud beyond slovakia. They are among the expellees. ' are any loopholes in· the machinery I words for the part which I have been Frankly, I have no sympathy for them. have described, they are invisible to the privileged to play in the administration They were disloyal to their country. eye of the junior Senator from New York. of the displaced persons program. I They wanted to be a part of Germany. Of course, Government officials and em want to see it made possible that others They supported Hitler and all the beasts ployees are human, and all of us are falli in the category of displaced persons may · who ~urroun ded Hitler. No, I have no ble. Some few mistakes may have been also have the chance of becoming loyal, sympathy for \,hem. . made not only in admitting one or two hard-working citizens of our country. Mr. EASTLAND. But the Senator or three individuals, but in hiring one I now yield to the distinguished Sen does not mean to infer, does he, that or two or three employees of the Dis ator from Mississippi. those people would be eligible under the placed Persons Commission, just as mis Mr. EASTLAND. The Senator has bill which the committee reported? takes are made in hiring employees of spoken very movingly of his feeling for Mr. LEHMAN. There. are 8,000,000 of any Government agency. But let us displaced persons, for whom I also have them, and I think that some of them not confuse this circumstance with any the same feeling. I wonder if the Sen would be eligible in the number of 54,000 large-scale condemnation of the DP pro ator's compassion extends to people of which has been mentioned. I think gram or of the DP Commission. Let German ethnic origin, who also meet the some of them, under the definition of us see this entire program and undertak qualifications prescribed in the bill. the committee bill, would be eligible in ing in perspective. Let us get on with it. Mr. LEHMAN. I can answer the Sen competition with the officially defined Mr. President, we have testimony from ator's question very readily. My parents displaced persons. virtually every responsible and reputa were German. My father came to this Mr. EASTLAND. Will the Senator ble relief and civic organization favor country 102 years ago. .. please point to the provisions of the com ing the liberalization of the old law Mr. EASTLAND. But the Sena mittee bill which would let in people who through the adoption of the minority tor-- cooperated with Hitler, as the Senator substitute. The head of the CIO and Mr. LEHMAN. May I answer the describes? If it does contain· such.a pro the president of the American Federa Senator's question? vision, we will certainly amend it, but it t ion of Labor have testified that the small Mr. EASTLAND. The bill does not was not my understanding that it did. number of additional persons who may include German nationals. Does not the Senator know that many of be admitted under the substitute will Mr. LEHMAN. My father left Ger these persons were in concentration in no way adversely affect the labor mar many, together with other rebels against camps established by Hitler before the ket in our country. We have their testi tyranny and oppression, like Carl Schurz war was over? mony and the testimony of thousands and other eminent Germans, because Mr. LEHMAN. Certainly the Senator of intelligent and high-minded people they hated and feared the German re from New York knows that, and certainly that displaced persons, carefully, rigidly, gime, which at that time was an auto such persons would qualify. and exhaustively screened, will be a cratic, repressive, and militaristic re Mr: EASTLAND. People of German great asset to our country. gime. I would have no objection to the ethnic origin? Then who besides that Mr. President, I know this ·situation admission of anyone who qualifies under class are eligible under the committee at first hand. I have visited displaced the displaced persons law, and whp ac bill? tively and sincerely fought na~ism, just persons camps. I have met many of Mr. LEHMAN. Of course they would these people. I have met them in the as I fought it, and as I" am fighting com munism and every other form of totali be eligible. The Senator from Missis camps. I have met them at embarka sippi refers to people of German ethnic tion and debarkation centers. I have tarianism. Mr. EASTLAND. The Senator adds origin; he himself has used that term. I met them in this country, where they do not believe the Senator claims that have taken their places in the economic "and those who fought nazism." Mr. LEHMAN. Does the Senator under the committee bill people of Ger and social life of our land. A few man ethnic origin, some of the 8,000,000 months ago I was one of the reviewing refer to persons who have been called "expellees"? · would not come into competition with officers of a great Polish parade, held those we know as displaced persons. in New York City. There was in· the Mr. EASTLAND. Yes. Mr. LEHMAN. I do not know the Mr. EASTLAND. Of ·course they parade a detachment of approximately would come into competition, but no 1,000 Polish displaced persons, led by identity of all of them. Under the terms of the bill, as the Senator knows, many man of German ethnic origin would be their priests, since they were all Cath disqualified under the committee bill olics. I had seen some of those people expellees will be admitted into the United States. because of his race, as he is now dis in the displaced-persons camps. If I qualified under the IRO constitution. had not seen the same persons, I had Mr. EASTLAND. But not under the seen their fellows, men like them. When substitute. Mr. LEHMAN. These people were dis I saw them in displaced-persons camps Mr. LEHMAN. I ·wonder whether the placed persons. they were cowed; they were fearful; they Senator knows that a great number of Mr. EASTLAND. The Senate com had hatred in their hearts; they were expellees were responsible, . at least in . mittee bill further provides that no one hopeless. A few months later I saw part, for the hostilities which com who cooperated with Hitler, or with the these men marching up Fifth Avenue . menced in 1939. I refer particularly to Nazi movement, is eligible. in New York, men who had taken their what are known as Sudeten Germans. Mr. LEHMAN. The people whom I rightful place in the life of their new Mr. EASTLAND. They are not eligi have described, from Czechoslovakia, community and in the life of their ble under the committee bill. who are among the 8,000,000 we have church. I cannot describe the differ Mr. LEHMAN. May I answer the been discussing, are of German ethnic ence. Instead of frightened, hopeless, question? I refer particularly to the origin, and under the committee bill I bitter men, these men strode up the ave Sudeten Germans, who tried to destroy think some of them would qualify. nue with confidence, with hope, and with Czechoslovakia, a great democracy, of Mr. EASTLAND. Does the Senator a dignity which anyone could envy, either which they were citizens. They fought mean to tell me that· the ones who co here or in any other part of the world. against the country of which they were operated with Hitler, and were pro These men were proud of being on citizens. They were the on~s who helped Nazi-- the road to American citizenship. They Hitler overrun and conquer Czecho- · Mr. LEHMAN. They were all pro were eager to take their place in the Slovakia. · Nazi. community life of their adopted coun Mr. EASTLAND. But the Senator- Mr. EASTLAND. Does the Senator try. Mr. LEHMAN. I am answering the mean that women and children, little When I see these men, and many Senator's question. At the end of the children, who were 5 or "6 years old at thousands of others like them, who have war, when Czechoslovakia again became the time, were pro-Nazi? · come to us from displaced persons · a free country, with the help it received Mr. LEHMAN. I cannot·believe that camps, and have been transformed into from democratic nations of the world, the Senator does not recall the history 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2809 of the rape of Czechoslovakia. It hap Mr. EASTLAND. Can the Senator accuse the Senator from New York of pened only 10 years ago. point out a provision of the committee deliberately having made misstatements. Mr. EASTLAND. Of course, I do. bill under which a pro-Nazi or one who Mr. LEHMAN. I point out to the Sen Mr. LEHMAN. And the Sudeten Ger cooperated with Hitler can get into this ator from Mississippi that yesterday, in mans, who now are in Germany and who country? the debate, he made a number of state compose part of the 8,000,000 expellees. Mr. LEHMAN. I do not thing the ments which he attributed to Mr. Mr. EASTLAND. But the committee Senator will question that an expellee of L'Heureux, the head of Visa Dlvision of blll provides, as the Senator knows, that . German ethnic origin could be admitted the State Department. The Senator any individual who was a member of the into this country under .his bill. from Mississippi made persuasive state Nazi party, or who was pro-Nazi, who Mr. EASTLAND. The Senator spoke ments. cooperated with the· Nazis, is not eligible of the system of screening, which he said . Mr. EASTLAND. I should like to dis for admission into this country as a dis was adequate. Has the Senator attended cuss thr..t feature. But before doing so placed person. If some persons of Ger any of the meetings of the Subcommittee I should like to have an answer to the manic blood, who were pro-Nazis, as the on Immigration of the Committee on the previous que~tion I propounded to the Senator said, could get in here, I should Judiciary before which testimony was Senator from New York. The informa like to know under what provisions of taken from Government employees re tion I want is this. The Senator has de the bill. specting the system of screening in scribed the screening system, and he has Mr. LEHMAN. I point out to the Sen Europe? said it is adequate at every phase. The ator from Mississippi that he is certainly Mr. LEHMAN. Meetings of the sub Senator stated that he had never been to entitled to his own views and his own committee of the Committee on the a meeting of any committee, anywhere, preferences. If he thinks the Sudeten Judiciary? which took testimony bearing on screen Germans and many other persons who Mr. EASTLAND. Yes. ing of applicants to enter this country as were sympathetic and helpful to Hitler Mr. LEHMAN. No, the Senator from displaced persons. That was the ques and the Nazi cause, and who were harm New York was never invited to attend tion I asked the Senator. Is that cor ful to the cause of Czechoslovakia and any meetings of the subcommittee of the rect? other countries to which they owed al Committee on the Judiciary. Mr. LEHMAN. Certainly I h:1ve not legiance, should be put on the same plane Mr. EASTLAND. As a matter of fact, attended .those hearings. as the actual displaced persons, that is was not most of that testimony taken Mr. EASTLAND. The S3nator- certainly within his right. But that is before the Senator from New York was a Mr. LEHMAN. May I answer in my where we differ. Member of this body? own way? · Mr. EASTLAND. I could charge the Mr. LEHMAN. I assume ·that a great Mr. EASTLAND. Yes. Senator, as he did me, with making a deal was taken before that time, yes. I Mr. LEHMAN. Certainly I have not. misstatement, but I shall not do so. The a~ked the Senator whether it has all I could not attend the meetings until I Senator well knows that there is no pro been made a matter of public record, and ·took my seat in the Senate on the 3d of vision in the Senate coumittee bill un I understood the Senator to say no, that January. Since then I certainly have der which any Sudeten German or any- · it ·· has not all been a matter of -public never been invited to attend any of the one else who cooperated-with the Nazis record. meetings. As I understand, some of the could come into this country. Mr. EASTLAND. That is another in meetings at least-and I make -the Mr. LEHMAN. · I cannot prove it, that accuracy, Mr. President. I did not make statement based ·on what the· Senator is perfectly obvious, and the Senator cer such a statement. I ·stated I did not from .Mississippi has said-sonie of the tainly has a right to his own opinion and know, and I do not know. I am not in meetings at which it is alleb'ed that very to his own sympathies, but I believe that charge of the bill, nor am I chairman of important testimony was taken were the Sudeten Germans of· Czecl~oslovakia the subcommitee. But what I should executive in character. · were in the main or almost wholly pro like to ask the Senator is this: Has he iMr. EASTLAND. No; . the testimony Nazi. ever at.tended a meeting· oftlie Immigra I ·read,. with one exception that. bf a Mr: EASTLAND. Show me a provision tion Subcommittee at any time when former. Army colonel, was t3stimony in the bill under which they could come testimony .was taken respecting· the sys taken in open hearings which the S:m into this country. · tem of screening used in . the admission ator could have attended. · But that is 'Mr. LEHMAN. B~cause' -they are ex of displaced ·_persons to the United beside the point. · Will the Senator t211 pellees. · The bill, by its definition, places States? . me where he _has made a study of the expellees in virtually the same c·ategories - . :Mr'. LEHMAN. The Senator from New system of screening used in Europe. to as the others. · York, of course, has not attended any of screen applicants who desired to enter Mr. EASTLAND. Even the substitute - those meetings. He could not have at- · this country as displaced ·persons? permits them to use half the· German . tended the meetings · which were closed, Mr. LEHMAN. I ·can tell the· senator quota. - · · and he never was invited. that very easily. I visited the camps. 'Mr. LEHMAN . . We let them ·use half Mr. EASTLAND. The Senator does Mr. EASTLAND. When was that? the German quota after very, very c:are not mean to say that· the Senate com:. Mr. LEHMAN. ·In June 1949, 7 months ful screening. But the committee bill· mittee meetings were closed. · ago. I was at the ·chief· resettlement permits them to come in under two cate :Mr . . LEHMAN. Certainly, executive center at Butzbach, and I was in Frank gories. It permits them to come in un sessions were held. fqrt and K!'liSsel. · I -yisited other points der: the category we have Just· diseussed; :Mr. EASTLAND: Mr. President, that there artd·spoke ' t-0 rept!esentatives of the .. and also und-er .the category in competi is ~ another inaccur.acy.. . It is well known , !RO, whiah. is an · international organ:.. tion .with the reguiar a'fsp}a-ced person'S, that -the Senate committee meetin'gs at ization, .- as. the s~nator pointed . out. I as defined in the. substitute. which, testimony· was taken; were .operi, spoke to representatives of _the Displaced ·l\fr. CAIN. Mr. President, will the , and newspaper men were present. . Persor-s Commission, which-is an Ameri Senator yield? · .Mr .. ·LEHMAN. ·Does .· .the .. Senator can organization, as.the-Senator knows. , Mr. EASTLAND. Permit me to con claim there were no meetings . held in : I spoke to representatives of our consular · tinue. executiv.e session? service and I spoke to representatives of ·Mr. CAIN.- Very _wel.l. . ·Mr. EASTLAND. Of course, -there our . Immigration and - Naturalization .Mr. EASTLAND. Will the. Senator were meetings. in executive session. . Service. Their desks were alniost adja.:. from New York point out to me any pro- _ Mr. LEHMAN. Then, why should the cent. One could hand a· paper from one vision in the committee bill under which Senator presume to accuse me of making · desk to another. Of course, I know a ·pro-Nazi or any individual who has co an inaccurate statement? about that. .. operated with Hitler cr:n get into .this· .Mr .. EASTLAND. No; ldid not accuse Mr. EASTLAND. Did the Senator country? the Senator of. making an. inaecurate - study the system of ~creening? That Mr. LEHMAN. I did not . und:;rstand statement. I said I -had been accused of , was:t1:1e.questicm. · Did th~ Sena.t.or study the question. maldng such a statement. -I would -not · over there the system of screening? 2810 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 Mr. LEHMAN. I did not examine Mr. LEHMAN. ·No, I did not; that is prevent that. Furthermore, in every each. or any, of the applicants myself. to say, I did not say I had observed it. large organization there may be persons Mr. EASTLAND. Of course, the Sen Mr. EASTLAND. Where did the Sen who are unworthy of the trust which is ator did not; but I did not ask the Sen ator from New York get the information reposed in them. Unfortunately we had . ator that question. I asked him if he about the Berlin Document Center? many cases of that sort in our armed studied there the system of screening. Mr. LEHMAN. I get a great deal of forces and in the Government services. Mr. LEHMAN. I hope the Senator information. I think I try to keep fairly Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, while will understand that what I have read well abreast of the times. I was absent from the :floor the distin today into the RECORD-and I trust that Mr. EASTLAND. Where did the Sen guished Senator from New York told the it will be convincing-was a statement of ator from New York get the information distinguished Senator from Washington the methods, of the procedure followed. about the Berlin Document Center? [Mr. CAIN] that I made numerous mis Mr. EASTLAND. Did the Senator- Mr. LEHMAN. Where did the Sena statements and inaccurate statements on - Mr. LEHMAN. May I answer? I de tor from New York get the information yesterday, and I am informed that the scribed the great care with which the that George Washington was born on Senator from New York said he would CIC undertook to screen these people. February 22? list them in the RECORD. Now, if some individual member of the Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, I re Mr. LEHMAN. I wish to correct that; CIC fell down on his job, or if some in peat, where did the Senator from New I did not say that. The Senator from dividual member of the consular service York get the information about the Washington asked me, .. Will the Senator fell down on his job, I greatly regret it. screening by the Berlin Document Cen list the steps that are taken to screen But, as I pointed out, Government offi ter? these people?" My answer was, "Yes; cials, like other people, are human, and Mr. LEHMAN. I said the papers came I will . ., undoubtedly some mistakes have been from the Berlin Document Center. ' I further said, and I said it several made. That, however, does not affect Mr. EASTLAND. Does not the Sena times-and if the Senator misunderstood the rigidity or the soundness of the tor from New York know that the officials me or if I misspoke, of course, I wish that screening process, which, in my opinion, did not wait for a report from the Berlin corrected-that the statements and rep goes further than any similar process Document Center? resentations made by the Senator from ever undertaken by this country. Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from Mississippi and the representations and Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, the New York does not know that. replies made by the junior Senator from distinguished Senator from New York Mr. EASTLAND. Then does the Sen New Yorlr are in the R:t:coRn; they are has not answered my question. I asked ator from New York say that the testi a matter of the record which is before him if he studied the system used in mony of the officials of the Immigration the Senate and may be read. Europe to screen applicants? and Naturalization Service in that re Mr. CAIN. Mr. President, will the Mr. LEHMAN. I told the Senator spect is inaccurate? Senator permit me to make an observa that, of course, I studied it. And, what Mr. LEHMAN. I do not know to what tion? is more, I have also studied the system testimony the Senator from Mississippi The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. used by our consular officers and by our refers. The Senator may have the state LANGER in the chair) . Does the Senator Immigration Service. ment of some person stating a conclusion. from New York yield to the Senator from Mr. EASTLAND. Is the information Mr. EASTLAND. Would the Senator Washington? which the distinguished Senator has from New York believe Mr. Squadrilli? Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. given to the Senate today based on his Mr. LEHMAN. I think Mr. Squadrilli Mr. CAIN. I wish to make an obser study there? Is that information the is a reliable man. When was he ex vation only for the reason that the name Senator acquired in Europe as the result amined? of the junior Senator from Washington of his studies? Mr. EASTLAND. Does the Senator has been brought into this colloquy. Mr. LEHMAN. It is certainly based from New York know that Mr. Squadrilli Shortly after the distinguished junior on my knowledge of the system. I ean testified last night that they took a cal Senator from New York [Mr. LEHMAN] not give the Senator any assurance that culated risk in rushing the applicants on, began his statement earlier today, he of the many hundreds of officers em and in not waiting for a report? said, as I recall, that he was literally ployed in the various agencies everyone Mr. LEHMAN. But were not all those amazed by the number of inaccurate bits has done his duty, nor can I give the papers then forwarded to the CIC and of ·misinformation which had been of Senator any assurance that every one to the consular service and to the Immi fered on the floor of the United States of 134,000 displaced persons who have gration and Naturalization Service, as I Senate yesterday-- been admitted to this country is going stated? That does not mean that they Mr. LEHMAN. And Wednesday. to be a worthy citizen. were not processed. Mr. CAIN. The junior Senator from Mr. EASTLAND. Of course the Sena Mr. EASTLAND. Does not the Sena Washington merely rose to ask the tor cannot. But my question was: Is the tor from New York know that many per junior Senator from New York if he information which the Senator from New sons in this category have come into the would list, in as much detail as possible, York gave the Senate today based on United States? the instances which he considered to be either misinformation or inaccurate knowledge he acquired as the result of Mr. LEHMAN. I am inclined to doubt statements, for the benefit Of the other his study in Europe, or is it based on in that the Senator from Mississippi can formation received from the Displaced Members of the Senate. show that many of these persons have As I recall, I had no colloquy of any Persons Commission? been admitted into the · United States kind with the junior Senator from New Mr. LEHMAN. It is based on both. without screening by the Immigration York in regard to the steps leading to of course, and on information from other Service. the screening of such persons overseas. It agencies. goes back further than that, Mr. EASTLAND. That is the testi Mr. LEHMAN. I understood the Sen because I wish to state with great pride mony. ator from Washington to ask that ques- that for 3 years I was Director General Mr. President, did the Senator from tion. · of UNRRA, the greatest relief organi New York speak of fingerprinting? However, since the question has been zation in the history of the world, an Mr. LEHMAN. Certainly I did. raised, I repeat what I have said before, organization that saved millions of lives, Mr. EASTLAND. Does the Senator namely, that I think I have pointed out and, by the way, an organization which from New York know that the man in many misstatements and many inac made more friends for the United States charge of the fingerprinting in Berlin has curacies in statements made on this :floor. than has any other organization. - testified that it was a joke and that appli Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, will Mr. EASTLAND. I voted for the cants were not getting prop"'!' screening:' the Senator point out those inaccuracies? UNRRA legislation. Mr. LEHMAN. I do not recall that. Mr. LEHMAN. They are also in the Mr. President, the distinguished Sena But as I say, no matter what system is RECORD. tor spoke of the screening at the Berlin used, there may be men who will fall I said, and I do not think it can be Document Center. down on their jobs; it is impossible to denied, that on several occasions the 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2811 Senator from Mississippi baldly made the by the Displaced Persons Commission ple to come into this country rests with statement that the screening of the ap and is final. Is not that an accurate the Displaced Persons Commission, or plicants was inadequate and ineffective statement? with IRO. and was based on a desire to get as many Mr. LEHMAN. No; it is not an ac Mr. JENNER. What is the difference? relief cases into this country as possible. curate statement . Mr. LEHMAN. All the difference in Mr. EASTLAND. I made that state Mr. EASTLAND. It certainly is ac the world. ment. curate. Mr. EASTLAND. Did not the Senator Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator again Mr. LEHMAN. Let me point out that from Mississippi say, to be perfectly frank made the' statement--not once, but a the Immigration Service has control, and and fair, that the consular service and number of times-- has authority to exclude anyone on the the Immigration Service had the power Mr. EASTLAND. Will the Sanator grounds of moral turpitude, subversive to veto the application of a subversive, from New York yield right at this point, qualities, or ill health. but that they did not have the facilities to permit me to say that I plead guilty Mr. EASTLAND. Does not the S:m at hand with which to investigate the to having made that statement, and I ator from New York know that that is large number of people making applica supported it. under the general immigration law? tion, and that they were bound by a file Mr. LEHMAN. But I contend it to be Mr. LEHMAN. It makes no differ sent to them, a file which originated in an inaccuracy. ence; these people are screened under IRO, a file made up largely by displaced May I continue, inasmuch as the Sen the provisions of the general immigra persons, and that it went down the line to ator has asked me to state-- tion law. the consul, and that he was bound largely Mr. CATN. I hope the Senator will Mr. EASTLAND. But the factors the by the information contained in the file? continue. distinguished Senator from New York On that point, the Senator from New Mr. LEHMAN. i,et me say that the has just mentioned are grounds for ex York certainly remembers, if he desires Senator from Mississippi has made the clusion, under the general immigration to be fair, that the Senator from Mis statement several times that the com- · law; and the Senator from Mississippi sissippi placed in the RECORD the order or plete authority and power connected has always said the Immigration Service regulatioh promulgated by the Displaced with the admission of displaced persons has that power. Persons Commission, which gave that into the United States rested with the But in regard to eligibility under the power. I placed it in the RECORD yester IRO which he dubbed an international displaced persons law, let me ask the day, or the day before. If there is a org a~iza tion, as it is, of course, and with Senator whose decision is final. misstatement, it is bound to be based on the Displaced Persons Commission, which Mr. LEHMAN. What is the question? the order I placed in the RECORD. was manned by persons in whom the Sen Mr. EASTLAND. On questions of eli Mr. LEHMAN. The Senator from New ator from Mississippi said he had no con gibility under the Displaced Persons Act, York· may say to the Senator from Mis fidence; and he said that they had the whose decision is final? sissippi, I am glad to have his acknowl full authority. Mr. LEHMAN. Let me point out to edgment again that the determination The junior Sanator from New York the Senator from Mississippi that his with regard to the eligibility of displaced questioned him, and asked, "Is it not a whole thesis in this debate and the the persons to enter this country rests with fact that the final authority for the ad sis of some of my other distinguished the Immigration Service. mission of these persons rests with the colleagues-- . Mr. EASTLAND. That is under the Immigration and Naturalization Service Mr. JENNER. The S:;nator from In immigration law. and with the consular. service?" diana is one of them-- Mr. LEHMAN. It rests with the Im Mr. EASTLAND. Under the immigra Mr. LEHMAN. Is that this bill per migration and Naturalization Service, tion laws. mits subversives to enter this country. and with the consular officers. Mr. LEHMAN. Under the immigra Mr. JENNER. That is correct. Mr. EASTLAND. Under the general tion laws. Then. I read a statement, as Mr. LEHMAN. And that they are not immigration law. the Senator may recall. I am not sure properly screened; that they are persons Mr. LEHMAN. What difference does whether the Senator from Washington who would become a subversive danger it make? I fear I have not made myself was on the floor at the time. to this country; or that persons who suffer from moral turpitude will be ad clear. Mr. CAUL Yes; I was on the floor. Mr. EASTLAND. It is not a question . Mr. LEHMAN. I read a statement mitted into this country. I say there is less likelihood, I believe, of that, as I understand. It is a question from the head of the Immigration and.. of the misstatement or inaccuracy for Naturalization Service, and another that such perso·ns will come into this country under the Displaced Persons Act which I was indicted. I should like to statement from the head of the Visa know where it is. Division of the State Department, saying than there is that such persons will come that they not only had authority but into the United States under the old Mr. LEHMAN. I pointed it out, but I that they exercised their authority to immigration law, because under the Dis should like to point out another thing, pass on these cases; that they never had placed Persons Act there are not only which apparently the Senator does not surrendered it and would not surrender the same standards of admission, but realize, namely, that the Displaced Per it, and that the only thing they had as very much greater standards of admis sons Commission in Europe makes a de signed to the Displaced Persons Com sion, since the peq;ons are screened by termination with regard to the status mission was a determination and defini two additional organizations. of the applicant as a displaced person, tion as to whether a particular displaced Mr. EASTLAND. Now, Mr. President, but makes no determination whatever person qualified under the displaced-per will the Senator from New York answer with regard to his eligibility to enter this sons law. my question? country. That is a pretty definite state So I have pointed out what I think Mr. LEHMAN. Certainly. ment, which I am perfectly willing to are those gross inaccuracies. Beyond Mr. EASTLAND. I ask the Senator, stand on. that, I refer the Senators to the RECORD. was not the final determination of eligi Mr. EASTLAND. The Senator from Mr. EASTLAND. Mr. President, at bility under the Displaced Persons Act New York, as I understand, says it is this point let me say that if the Senator with the Displaced Persons Commission? done by the consular service. How can from New York will examine the RECORD, Mr. LEHMAN. Only the question of the consular service intelligently pass on I think he will find that what he said whether the applicants were eligible to be an applicant, when adverse reports have is exactly what the Senator from Missis considered as displaced persons. been taken from the files? sippi has said, namely, that under the Mr. EASTLAND. That is exactly cor Mr. KILGORE and Mr. JENNER ad immigration law, the determination of rect. dressed the Chair. eligibility by the Immigration and Nat Mr. LEHMAN. No; I beg the Senator's The PRESIDING OFFICER. Does uralization Service and by the con pardon. I think the Senator will find the the Senator from New York yield; and if sular service is final, and they can veto; RECORD will show that he claimed the de so, to whom? but the determinat.i.on of the factors un termination with regard to eligibility, Mr. LEHMAN. I yield first to the der the Displaced Persons Act is made propriety, and safety of allowing the peo- Senator from West Virginia. 2812 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 Mr. KILGORE. Mr. President. I may placed Persons Commission. He stated the Immigration Service to €Jforce com say to the Senator from New York it that although reports on applicants are pliance with our immigration laws, and seems to me we are dwelling on matters requested from the Berlin Document that the duty of the Displaced Persons of no consequence. It is true that for Center and the provost marshal's office, Commission is to determine whether, a short time, and in a few cases, an ad the displaced persons are sent to this according to the records they have, a verse report was withdrawn, but a copy country without first receiving the re man comes within the category of a dis of the report directing its withdrawal ports. Squadrilli commented that the placed person, within the meaning of was included. I wish to refresh the Sen Displaced Persons Commission did not the definition, and there the responsi ator's mind on that point. wait for the reports before sending the bility and the power of the Commission Mr. LEHMAN. That is quite right. displaced persons to the United States, end? Then, if the man has a criminal Mr. KILGORE. The practice of with because to do so would slow down the record, and the fact is ascertained by drawing adverse reports was discon program. He admitted he knew of a the State Department-and the Immi tinued after a short time. I am ·re number of cases of displaced persons gration and Naturalization Service have· minded of the statement that it applied being admitted to the United States on the same right--they are the ones who to many people. The question I ask is, the calculated risk policy, although the have the power to refuse an application how many? When it is said there were files from the Berlin Document Center on the ground of a criminal record. Is many, I ask, how many? and the provost marshal's office showed not that correct? Mr. EASTLAND. The head of the they had criminal records. He justified Mr. LEHMAN. I thank the Senator. Immigration Service estimated 30,000. the calculated risk policy on the ground He has expressed it and explained it very Mr. JENNER. That is correct. that after the criminals had been ad lucidly. I would only add one sentence, Mr. KILGORE. Thirty thousand mitted to the United States, they would that not only have they the power, but have come into the United States? be subject to deportation when the re they also have the duty. Mr. EASTLAND. That is, persons ports were received. The fact is, however, Mr. KILGORE. I thank the Senator. who are ineligible. That is the estimate. that not a single displaced person has as Mr. CAIN rose. I do not want to be charged with in yet been cited for deportation. The PRESIDING OFFICER. Does accuracy or misstatement. That is the Mr. LEHMAN. Whose statement is the Senator from New York yield to the testimony given by Mr. Tripp, who is at that? Senator from Washington? the head of the Immigration Bureau in Mr. JENNER. That is the statement Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. Ew·ope. of Mr. Alex E. Squadrilli, the European Mr. CAIN. I wish to obtain the floor Mr. KILGORE. May I inquire Coordinator of the Displaced Persons in my own right. whether his statement was, that he was Commission. Mr. LEHMAN. Very well. not sure as to their eligibility? Mr. LEHMAN. If the Senator from The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Mr. EASTLAND. That ls correct New York may inquire of the Senator Senator from New York yields the fioor. "of doubtful eligibility," is what he said. from Indiana, whose duty does .the Sen The Chair recognizes the senator from Mr. KILGORE. He had bis doubts. ator think it is? Is it not the duty of Washington. the Immigration and Naturalization Mr. EASTLAND. "Of doubtful eligi HOUSING AND RENT ACT OF 1949 bility," he said. Service and the consular service? Mr. KILGORE. Is it not also a fact Mr. JENNER. Of course, it is their Mr. CAIN. Mr. President, as every that it was admitted last night that be duty. But why admit criminals as dis Member , of the Senate undoubtedly cause of fraud with respect to the deter placed persons, in the first place? knows, the Housing and Rent Act of 1949, mination of eligibility status, Mr. Tripp Mr. LEHMAN. What justi:fication·has Public Law 31, expires on June 30, 1950. and his staff could turn down an appli the Senator for saying they are crimi The question of whether that law shall cant and that the consular service could nals? If they are criminals, would they be continued for an indefinite period in also do so? A great deal was said about not have been stopped by the Immigra the future will presumably come before fraud, but the final determination of the tion Service? The Immigration Service the Senate at some time between now question of fraud rests with the Immi has a right to stop them. and June 30. Yesterday the majority gration and Naturalization Service and Mr. JENNER. Of course. They would leader, the Senator from Illinois [Mr. with the consular service. not have been stopped, because the Im LucAsJ. and the majority whi~ the Sen Mr. EASTLAND. The displaced per migration Service must have the records ator from Pennsylvania [Mr. MYERS], in son's status? of the BDC, although the BDC has no troduced a bill which would extend Fed Mr. KILGORE. I refer to fraud on the interest in even checking them. The eral rent controls until June 30, 1951. part of a man in obtaining for himself a Berlin Document Center has no interest The bill was referred to the Senate Com false status. in checking the provost marshal's rec mittee on Banking and Currency. Mr. EASTLAND. The Senator means ords. All they would have had to do Everyone knows that there are mem as a displaced person? was to send notice here, and it would bers of this body who believe sincerely Mr. KILGORE. Yes. have been found that those persons were that Federal rent controls have served Mr. EASTLAND. Of course, they can criminals. But they were not interested their purpose and outlived their useful determine it. in that. The whole idea is to rush them ness, and that there is no good or sound Mr. KILGORE. Is that the Senator's over to America, to get 205,000 displaced reason for permitting the Federal Gov• expert legal opinion? persons into America before the law ex ernment to engage further in the man Mr. EASTLAND. Yes, it is my expert pires. That is WhY the Im.migration agement of private property. Those legal opinion. It is a correct opinion. Service and the consular service cannot senators believe that their case will pre I should like to ask the distinguished find fraud, because the fraud was per vail, and they are prepared and willing Senator, what about mo, which main petrated by the IRO, and because there to test the question on the floor of the tains a legal division for the purpose of is a. lack of interest on the part of the Senate at any time. getting paroles for convicts, so they can Displaced Persons Commission in Eu It is deserving of note that the bill to come to the United States as displaced rope, in tryjng to screen out criminals continue Federal rent controls beyond persons? In all the discussion of screen- and subversives. June 30, 1950, has been offered, not by . ing, I have not heard that mentioned. Mr. KILGORE. Mr. President, will administration spokesmen within the Mr. JENNER. Mr. President, will the the Senator yield? Banking and Currency Committee, but Senator from New York yield? The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. HEN by the majority leader and the majority Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. DRICKSON in the chair). The Senator whip. One would have expected that Mr. JENNER. I think it might throw from New York has the floor. Does the the chairman of the Senate Banking and some light on the subject to refer to the Senator yield? Currency Committee, the Senator from statement of Alex E. Squadrilli, the Eu Mr. LEHMAN. I yield. South Carolina (Mr. MAYBANK], or the ropean coordinator of the Displaced Per Mr. KILGORE. Is it not a fact that chairman of the Subcommittee on Hous sons Commission, who testified respect the duty is specifically cast by the act ing and Rents, th e Senator from Ala ing the calculated risk policy of the Dis- in force upon the I<,oreign Service and bama [Mr. SPARKMAN], would have in-
• 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2813 troduced the bill to continue Federal have for removing the Federal Govern If anyone is qualified to know what is rent controls, but they did no such thing. ment from the control of private prop taking place within the District of Co The Senator from South Carolina has erty at the earliest possible moment. lumbia, it ought to' be Mr. Robert Cogs publicly stated that he had no intention The Housing Expediter is now feverish well, the District of Columbia rent ad of introducing such a bill, and so far as ly rushing around the corridors of our ministrator. One would think that Mr. I know, the Senator from Alabama has Congress in an effort to find those who Cogswell, rather than a Federal agent, said nothing. The State of Alabama, by will support his request for additional should be on that program tomorrow the way, is to ,be decontrolled on May deficiency sums. If, finally, he does not night. Was he invited, and if he was, 31, 1950, as a result of action taken by secure from the Congress what he might why did he reject the invitation? its State government. All of this is to reasonably need to operate his office un Fortunately, Mr. President, it happens suggest that the administration is faced til the rent law expires on June 30 of that Mr. Cogswell is a man who under with another awkward situation. In his this year, he will have only himself to stands his job and its responsibilities, state of the Union message the Presi blame. He saw fit, when before the Ap and he is a man of principle and char dent of the United States promised con propriations Committee, not to be fac acter. Mr. Cogswell was invited to take tinuing Federal rent controls and its tual and accurate, when accuracy and a part in the program, but he rejected the leaders in the Senate must make some disclosure of the complete truth would invitation, as he ought to have done. pretense of fulftlling this political prom have better served his own purpose. He said that his job was to administer ise. Thoughtful persons everywhere, Mr. I want to press this point of prejudice, the law and not to lobby for or against President, will be interested to observe self-interest, and perpetuating Federal its continuance unless or until he was that the administration has been. unable controls a bit further. called to offer his views to the appropri- to get its representatives on the Banking In this morning's Times-Herald I read -;-ate committees of the Congress. We and Currency Committee to offer a pro the following news item on page 3. Its can well afford to compliment Mr. posal to continue Federal controls. The title is "Round Table To Debate Rent Cogswell for his understanding of the members of the Banking and Currency Control in District of Columbia." The true relationship between executive Committee are students of this question item is brief, and states: agents and legislative bodies. of Federal property management. Many Whether rent control should be continued Without prejudice, as a person, to Mr. Senators on the committee voted most in the District will be discussed on the William G. Barr, special assistant to the reluctantly a year ago to continue Fed District Round Table on radio station WWDC Housing Expediter, I want to point out eral rent controls. It is obvious that at 10 p. m. Sunday. Participants in the and make very clear that he has no right some of them can see no present reasons forum will be Representative Miller, Re of any kind to participate in the radio of any kind to continue the Federal rent publican, of Nebraska; William Barr, deputy program to which I have referred. If law. The administration, however, pos administrator of the national office of the he does so he will be completely guilty, expediter of rent control; and Rufus. Lusk, sesses no such hesitancy. It is clearly president of the Washington Taxpayers As to my mind at least, of coming under the . much less interested in economics and sociation. provisions of title 18, Public Law 772, of facts than it is in politics. I have never the Eightieth Congress, second session, heard it said that either the majority As soon as I read this article I imme section 1913. This law provides that "no leader or the majority whip is an au diately began to telephone throughout member of the executiv·e branch shall thority or student of the rent-control the District to have someone tell me attempt to influence in any manner a question. What they do know is what why an agent of the Office of the Hous Member of the Congress to favor or op every other American knows, and that ing Expediter was going to discuss pose by vote or otherwise any legislation is that there are many more tenants whether rent controls should or should or appropriation by Congress, whether than there are landlords. This knowl not be continued in the District of Co before or after the introduction of any edge, in my opinion, will not result in lumbia. Every Senator knows that the bill or resolution proposing such legis continuing Federal rent controls as it District has it own rent-control law, and lation or appropriation." did a year ago. this law, like the Federal law, has a Mr. President, I should like at this I have made this observation, Mr. termination date of June 30, 1950. I was time, or at any time in the future, to President, because of my desire to assist told by those who sponsor the program, have any Member of this body or of the in focusing public attention on this the junior bar section of the Bar Asso House of Representatives stand up and question of the management of private ciation of the District of Columbia, that deny that that is the law of the land property by political procedures and Mr. Barr, the Federal rent agent, would and that it should be observed. It is agents of the Federal Government. appear on the program to explain what being broken, as we all know, by agents On Saturday, February 25, the Senate had taken place in those areas through of the executive branch of the Govern Appropriations Committee thought it out the land which have been decon ment, 365 days out of every year. proper to deny a large part of a defi trolled in recent months. Has one any If Mr. Barr takes part in the radio ciency approprfations request by the right, Mr. President, to expect that an program tomorrow night, he will simply Housing Expediter. I have no desire to agent of the Housing Expediter will be be lobbying for the continuation of the argue the merits of this action at the any more factual or accurate than was Federal rent law and the District of Co moment, but I do want to suggest that lumbia rent law. He will use the prestige the Housing Expediter when he so suc of what ought to be a high office, at least the action was taken, at least in part, cessfully defeated his own purpose when because the Housing Expediter and those an office which our people could respect, he recently appeared before the Senate to influence legislation which is the con of his staff who were with him when he Appropriations Committee in support of testified did not accurately or objective cern, not of the Office of the Housing Ex a deficiency request? One can only con pediter, but of the Congress of the ly provide the committee with the re clude that Mr. Barr will only use the sults of decontrol in various communi United States. If Mr. Barr understood ties and States throughout the Nation. inaccurate information which was em his responsibility, as Mr. Cogswell, the From reading the testimony offered by ployed by his superior. local agent, understands his, Mr. Barr the Housing Expediter and his asso I want someone to tell me what con would have been the first to appreciate ciates I gained the impression that those ceivable interest the Office of the Hous and then decline the invitation to talk who testified assumed that the Senators ing Expediter can have in whether or about a question which is none of his who listened knew almost nothing about not rent controls are continued in the official business. the operation of the Office of the Housing District of Columbia. The Housing Ex Mr. President, as an individual Sena Expediter or about the Federal rent pediter and his staff ·are Federal agents. tor I am far too busy to worry further at control problem. Any impartial and The administrator of rent control in this time about whether Mr. Barr does reasonably intelligent reader of the tes the District of Columbia can be accu or does not appear on tomorrow night's timony will begin to become convinced rately thought of as being a local agent program. As an individual I expect to that the Housing Expediter and his office in the sense that he administers and has listen to that program; I want to go to have a far greater regard for maintain jurisdiction over a local or municipal hear it, if time permits me to do so; and ing their jobs in perpetuity than they situation. I hope that any statements made by XCVI--177 2814 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH 4 anyone on the program will be accurate. It is quite clear that the Taft-Hartley parties-to have the guts to end this de.:. If the statements are taken out of offi law, far from being a decisive weapon plorable tottering on the brink of dis- cial Government documents, they had against strikes such as this, can be sabo aster. · better be accurate. If Mr. Barr; an ad taged by those who maladminister it. TRIBUTES TO THE VICE PRESIDENT ON ministrative assistant to the Housing Thus, the· President invoked the Taft THE THIRTY-SEVENTH . ANNIVERSARY Expediter' is on the program, and if he Hartley law too late to do any real good. OF HIS SERVICE IN 'lHE CONGRESS uses the information which the Housing Then when the contempt case was pre Expediter used before the Committee on sented in the courts, Department of Jus Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, the Appropriations of the Senate last week, tice attorneys miserably failed in their Senate has been discussing a very con which resulted in the Housing Expediter responsibility to present the affidavits troversial issue, namely, the question of not getting what he asked for, I shall be about the union complacency. In other displaced persons. As usual, on both privileged to draw that to the attention words, Mr. President, the basic problem sides of the aisle there have bee~ some of this body. Should Mr. Barr, howevey, that we face is: No single law which very forceful arguments presented on an see fit to relate what obviously are the the Congress has written thus far is fool issue which is far reaching. We have facts, which the Housing Expediter, Mr. proof against a national paralysis be- . such issueu before us very often. Dur Barr's employer and superior, did not cause the administration can and has ing my service here we have debated use, I shall likewise be pleased to call the maladministered the statute. some questions which to my mind have contradictions ·to the attention of the I submit, therefore, that those of my meant much to the future life of Amer Senate of .the United States. colleagues on the Senate Committee cm ica and the world. It would hardly be proper, but under Labor and Public Welfare should con: The question of displaced persons, al these circumstances it might be consid sider amendments to the Taft-Hartley though it is a very serious one, brings to ered to be absolutely necessary, for the law in connection with the injunction my mind one who now is in our midst and Housing Expediter to say one thing be provision, to tighten that provision and who is anything but a displac(.d person. fore the Senate Committee on Appropri to make it more foolproof against those I refer to our distinguished and beloved ations and for the Housing Expediter's who want to violate it ·in letter and in Vice President, ALBEN w. BARKLEY. He special assistant to say quite another spirit. became a Member of Congress 37 years thing on the same subject to those who America will no longer tolerate these ago today. He has served in the House listen to this local radio program tomor off-again, on-again lynchings of the of Representatives and in the Senate, row night. public welfare. We are sick of being and is now serving as Vice President. Mr. President, the Office of the Hous thrown from the frying pan into the fire. I should like to say, in a very serious, ing Expediter has been charged by the We demand a permanent solution to but also humorous vein, that he was past several Congresses, at least by the strikes in key industries in which the pretty well screened when he came from several in which I have been privileged national health, welfare, and safety is . the State of Kentucky, and certainly he to sit, with removing the Federal Gov involved. has been screened many times since ernment from the management of pri Let not our people for get the closing then. I believe no one gets a more thor vate property just as soon as that is pos of their schools, the shutting down of ough screening than a man in public sible. All their energy, their concentra their factories, the reduction of railroad life, particularly in the legislative branch tion, their loyalty, and their efforts operations, the shivering patients in the of the Government. Every time he has should be directed to this end. Until hospitals. Let not our people forget made an invasion, firet, as a Representa their mission has been achieved, it seems that five times the Government has tive from his district in Kentucky, then to me there is neither time, excuse, nor seized the coal mines. Let not our peo as a Senator of long years of service, and reason for any agent of the Housing Ex ple forget that the President has used finally as Vice President of the United pediter addressing himself to a District the Taft-Hartley law eight times, al States, he has been well received. Not of Columbia problem, with which the Of though he has repeatedly asked that this only has he been successful in his legis fice of the Federal Housing Expediter vital law be repealed. lative invasion but he has been most has no remote connection or legitimate The administration wants the people successful in his invasion recently of the interest. to forget these facts, but it is the job of State of Missouri in his domestic rela the Republican Part:' and all independ tions, when he brought a little of the CONGRESS MUST ACT TO PREVENT RE ent-minded citizens to repeat them again spirit of st. Louis back to Washington. CURRENCE OF STRIKE PARALYSIS and again so that the national interests So, Mr. President, on this thirty Mr. WILEY. Mr. President, with the will not again be endangered. seventh anniversary, to the day, of the announcement of the agreement be John L. Lewis pulled off his strikes at Vice President's arrival here, first as a tween the coal negotiators, the Nation will during the Second Wofld War. Representative and then as a Senator, has heaved a sigh of relief. Thus, once ·Dare we allow this situation to recur I wish to extend to him, having served again, by the mere whim of one labor in the event of world war III with with him when he was majority leader in union big shot and a few men across the atomic bombs falling on America? Has the Senate and since he has been Vice conference table, America has been any individual in the administration President, my wholehearted felicitations spared a complete national paralysis. thought of the terrible possibilities of and congratulations· on his 37 years of Now, the Democratic administration national suicide by allowing this sort of very valuable service, and I know that in will undoubtedly urge everybody to for situation to occur again? that statement I speak the sentiments of get the whole thing until the next big The master minds in the Communist every Senator on both sides of the aisle. national crisis looms. In my 11 Y4 years Kremlin must be rubbing their hands In concluding, Mr. President, i: should in the Senate, I have seen these off with glee. How delightful they must like to say that I am glad there has been again, on-again national stoppages, but think it would be for them to begin an long continuity in the service of the dis never has the Democratic administra atomic war on America when, let us say, tinguished Presiding Officer of the Sen tion had the guts to come forward with another coal strike is on, our railroads ate and when 1952 rolls around, if the permanent legislation for the statute are shut down, and 1 or 2 days' fuel is next Vice President must be a Democrat, books to prevent the public welfare from left in our factories. Do not the ad we would prefer to have ALBEN W. BARK being crtlcified time and again. The ad ministration leaders recognize that even ley, of Kentucky, return in that capacity. ministration hopes that the public will 1f such a strike were called off in the [Applause. J sit back in complacency and will not re event of an atomic attack, it takes lit Mr. GEORGE. Mr. President, the member how close it came to economic erally weeks and weeks before the fuel years since March 4, 1913, have covered disaster. But, Mr. President, I, for one, stock piles in our factories can be re a long period as we measure time. It will do everything I can in order to seek plenished and before the railroads can was in 1913 that we laid the foundations a permanent solution to this problem resume full operations. The adminis of all estimates of property values so far a solution that will be fair to the inter tration has been tampering with na as income-tax purposes were concerned. ests of both labor, management, and, tional suicide, and I say it is time for the That made that year peculiarly sig most important of all, the general public. Congress-for members of both political nificant in my mind. 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 2815 But there is a happy side to the pic Mr. KNOWLAND. Mr. President, I R:public has been in existence, few men ture. During these 37 years there has would not want this day to ~Jass without have served continuously for 37 years in served in the two Chambers of the Con adding a word to what has already so the Congress of the United States. Few gress a man who has always been a ably been said by the Senator from Ne men; if any, have given more of their most loyal partisan, yet without bitter braska [Mr. WHERRY] and the Senator time and effort in the promotion of the ness and without guile, an upstanding from Georgia [Mr. GEORGE]. I believe I ideals of the Republic than has the dis American in public service. am the only Member of this body who is tinguished Vice President, to whom we do Many things l.ave happened since a second generation Member, who has honor upon this occasion. March 4, 1913. Two great wars have served in either the House or the Senate When I first came to the s~nate some been fought. The soldiers of this Na with the distinguished Presiding Officer. 11 years ago, the present Vice President tion have marched away to fight in for It so happened that my father served in of the United States was then the ma eign lands, and in the Second World the House of Representatives with the jority leader of this deliberative body. War in almost all the areas of the earth distinguished Vice President of the Like all neophytes who come here and where men were called upon to fight. United States. One of my earliest recol do not have a clear understanding of par The distinguished Vice President of the lections is of the very high regard in liamentary procedure and the various United States lived through those wars which my father held the distinguished questions which come before the Senate as a public servant. He knew all the Vice President during the years he served from time to time, it was necessary for heartaches which men in public life were with him in the House of Representatives. me to seek advice and counsel. I sought called upon to hear in those eventful When I came to the Senate I had al that advice and counsel from the then years, and all the difilcult decisions they ready formed a very high regard for our majority leader, Senator BARKLEY, of had to make in 1917 and again in 1941. distinguished Presiding Officer. He was Kentucky. No one was ever more char Mr. President, it is a happy circum then occupying the position of majority itable, more kind, more constructive than stance that this distinguished public leader. I know o~ no majority leader was he. servant has lived to enjoy the good will, who carried a heavier burden than he As I sta~1d here today as the majority the confidence, the esteem, and the love did in the months immediately following leader of this great deliberative body, the of his colleagues on both Sides Of the the close of the great World War, when only one of its kind now in existence in aisle, in all parties, during this long a change had taken place in the national the world, I believe I am more conscious period of his distinguished service. administration. While debates on the of the burdensome problems which were There were in this body on March 4, - floor of the Senate were sometimes tense, on Senator BARKLEY'S shoulders than I 1927, when the distinguished Vice Pres always at the close of the discussion Sen realized when I was simply a Member ident became a Member of the Senate, ator BARKLEY, by some appropriate story without any particular responsibilities only two men who are here today, the or some felicitous remark, relieved the on the floor of the Senate. To one sit senior Senator from Tennessee [Mr. tenseness, so that when the time for ad ting on the side lines, he seemed to per MCKELLAR] and the senior Senator from journment came the Members of the form his work rather easily. It was, of Georgia, tbe present speaker. Time and Senate left the Chamber with that sense course, easy for him to carry the heavY politics have taken a great toll of the of fellowship for which this body has burden of work that rested upon him, Members of this body since March 4, been known throughout the years. because of his familiarity with parlia 1927. Particul~rly has that been true Mr. President, I wanted tO make these mentary procedure, because of his vast of both parties in the Congress since few remarks in paying my own high per experience in legislative work, and be March 4, 1913. sonal respects to one who I think is not cause of his profound knowledge of the Many things have · occurred in the only an outstanding public servant but rich traditions of America from the time world. It is doubtful whether in all the one of the great Americans of this period. of the founding fathers. history of mankind so many great events, Mr. LONG. Mr. President, I cannot Mr. President, I have always looked so many world-shaking events, have oc recall the day when the Vice President upon the Vice President as one who was curred as have taken place within that came to Congress. I was born 5 years the champion of oppressed humanity, as period of time. thereafter. I can say, however, that dur one who believed that this Government Yet, here is the Vice President, in good ing the brief period of my service in the of ours was a moving thing, not one that )lealth, and, as always, in a happy frame Senate I have had some occasion to ob was static but one that constantly kept of mind, because he has never borne serve the great qualities of leadership of pace with the march of events. malice against anyone in or out of public the present Vice President of the United Mr. President, it has been my great life. He has disagreed, but disagreements States. privilege and pleasure to serve with tl.1e do not always amount to a division or I recall well that when the statue of Vice President since I have been in the my father was dedicated in the Capitol dispute upon any essential or controlling S~nate. He has been of great illi'pira principle. He has· differed, of course, in building the then majority leader, now tion to me, and I know he has been of politics, because that has been the his the Vice President of the United States, great inspiration to other Senators who tory of American politics, and properly delivered an address in which he bespok3 have served with him, whether they were so; but · always without malice and al his admiration for a man with whom he Democrats or Republicans. He has been ways without guile the distinguished had frequently disagreed, but who stood and is eminently fair. He has attempted Vice President, who now has the honor forth and fought for what he believed to preside over this body, during all this was a righteous cause. The fairness and to mete out justice, both as majority long period of time has lived a life worthy impartiality of the Vice President have leader· and as Vice President, believing, of a great American statesman and pub always been typified by such events, and as the great Senator from Georgia said, lic servant. over the years, long before I came to the in charity for all and malice toward I am very happy to be here now-and . United States Senate, in my estimation none. I hope the Vice President will be here he had reached the highest possible Mr. PrE-sident, in the years to come many years after I have departed this stature. may you continue to work for justice and scene-to attest not only my own per As one who was born after the Vice peace, may you preserve faith in your sonal feeling but what I believe to be President of the United States com country, may you continue to have good the feeling of all Americans everywhere, menced his service in the Congress, I health, may you live long and enjoy regardless of party. Certainly no one certainly hope that those of us who fol unbounded prosperity. entertains for the Vice· President any low after him may be able to live up to The VICE PRESIDENT. · The Chair thing but that profound respect which the great traditions he has developed will ask the indulgence of the Members is due to a good public servant who has and the fine example of American states of the Senate to make a brief response 'borne his part in many a hard battle, manship he has established. to the very generous remarks which but without malice, and always relying Mr. LUCAS. Mr. President, this is a somewhat took the Chair by surprise. upon the worthiness and justice of his historic day in the Congress of the United I had not recalled today that this was cause. States. Over the long period of time this the thirty-seventh anninrsary of my 2816 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE MARCH · 4 entrance into the House of -Representa most 300 percent. vur wealth has. in have for the Members of the Senate will tives until our thoughtful, efficient, and creased by about 400 percent. During never diminish, and that statement ap beloved Secretary, Leslie Biffie, reminded those 37 years, our position and influence plies with equal force to the entire Gov me of it a while ago. . and responsibility among the other na ernment of the United States and all its When the Senator from Nebraska tions of the world have increased to an branches. CMr. WHERRY] began his remarks, I was extent far greater than it would have Mr. LUCAS. Mr. President, before to really in truth and in fact physically a been possible to have foretold at the day's session closes, I wish to say that I displaced person, because I was seated beginning of that period. Political par am sure all Members of the Senate deep on the ftoor of the Senate, where I so ties have changed. Administrations have ly appreciate what the distinguished Vice frequently sit, and which ;r enjoy doing. changed. President has just said, and all of us But I was not the possessor even at that I have served, in one capacity or an know what affection he has for all Mem time of a displaced heart, because I other, under every President from Wood bers of the Senate. always enjoy reminiscing about events row Wilson to Harry S. Truman. I had I am very happy that this is the thirty which took place during my service on the pleasure, of course, while serving in seventh anniversary of the distinguished the ftoor as a Member of the Senate. I either the House or the Senate, of en Vice President's coming to the Congress. really love to resume a seat there now gaging in many controversies affecting I am happy about it for many reasons . . and then and sit down by Members of our domestic affairs and our interna The last one I happened to think of while the Senate on both sides and talk about tional relationships. Many changes in I was listening just now to the Vice Presi anything that comes into our minds. viewpoint and in many of the basic con dent is that the observance of this anni Sometimes I perpetrate a story upon ceptions of the relationship of the Gov versary gives him an opportunity to make them. Which reminds me of the fact ernment to the people and of the people a speech in the Senate. Frequently he that Abraham Lincoln was the greatest to the Government have taken place dur has told me that he would like to leave story teller who ever held public office ing those 37 years. I am happy to say the rostrum and come down to the ftoor of in the history of the United States. that, without regard to the political the Senate and address the Members of There is a very amusing and lovable party in power or the identity of the ad the Senate and the country. I know that story about him when he was practicing ministration in control of the Govern as he presides over· the Senate he fre law in Springfield, Ill. Judge David Da ment at any particular time, nothing quently observes the majority leader and vis, whom he later appointed to the Su which has taken place has weakened my other Members of the Senate miss points preme Court of the United States, was faith in the fundamental honesty of the which he always caught so ably when he the presiding judge of the court. Mr. American people and the basic f ounda was serving as majority leader of the Lincoln was not engaged in the trial of tions of the sort of democracy and the Senate. the case that was pending, but was seated sort of Government under which we live. So I am glad the Vice President has had over in one corner of the courtroom I do not believe that any economic this opportunity to make a speech. I am telling stories to a group of lawyers and changes, any political changes, or any sure he appreciates the opportunity, too, friends. They were so amused at the social changes which may take place in because up until this time he has not stories that they were disturbing the this great Republic, either in the near niade a speech in the Senate since he has court. Finally Judge Davis rapped on future or in the distant future, will oper been Vice President. the bench, and said; "Mr. Lincoln, there ate to change the high regard and re The VICE PRESIDENT. I thank the can be only one court held in this court spect which the American people have Senator from Illinois for his reference to house, and I think I am going to hold for their Government and for their po me; but, in reply, I wish to say that I have it." litical and social institutions. Not only never observed the Senator from Illinois Whereupon the group disbanded, and during another 37 years, but during the . miss any points. To the contrary, he quiet was restored. centuries that are to come, I believe thinks of points that I never thought of A few minutes later Judge Davis called we shall continue as a democratic Na up to the bench one of the participants tion, a Nation in which Lincoln called during the time when I served in the posi in the previous disorder in the courtroom, a government of, by, and for the people, tion in which he now serves so ably. and leaned over and whispered to him, and what Jefferson referred to as a Mr. WHERRY. Mr. President, if I may ''What was that story Lincoln was tell government in which there should be say a word at this time, I should like to ing?" [Laughter.] equal rights to all and exclusive privi point out that I try to help the majority Since the Members of the Senate have leges to none, will be .maintained. It is leader think of those points. I do so as often as I can, for I do not want him to b~en so generous and kind as to recall my fervent and profound hope and that this is the thirty-seventh anniver prayer that the influence of our country miss any of them.. [Laughter.] sary of the beginning of my service in and of our Government and of our peo Mr. LUCAS. Of course the Senator the Congress, I have been thinking of ple upon the other nations and peoples from Nebraska is always very cooperative. what has happened since I .entered the of the world will be so effectiye and so The VICE PRESIDENT. Of course Congress of the United States as a young profound that before any of us here have whenever either the majority leader or man. When I entered the House of ''shuffled off this mortal coil," we may the minority leader wishes to confer with Representatives, I was approximately see all over the world democracy, free the Chair on such matters, he is always the same age that the Senator from dom, liberty, and self-government in at liberty to do so. Louisiana was .when he entered the Sen which all the people, without regard to Mr. LUCAS. That happens frequent ate. Today there is in the House of Rep race, color, creed, or national origin, may ly, so far as the Senator from Illinois is resentatives only one man who entered not only be permitted to participate, but concerned. the House with me at that time, and that which they may control for their own MESSAGE FROM THE HOUSE is the Speaker, SAM RAYBURN' of Texas. welfare. That is real democracy, that Only two Members of the House who is real self-government, that is real lib A message from the House of Repre-· were there when I came, are still in the erty, and in my judgment democracy and sentatives, by Mr. Maurer, one of its House. One is the Honorable ROBERT L. liberty are ·interchangeable terms. reading clerks, announced that the House DOUGHTON, of North Carolina; the other Let me thank all the Senators who insisted upon its amendment to the bill is the Honorable ADOLPH SABATH, of Illi have been so gracious as to remember UNITED NATIONS RELIEF AND WORKS AGENCY the request of the gentleman from Cali message: FOR PALESTINE REFUGEES IN THE NEAR EAST fornia? Since the union and the operators have John B. Blandford, Jr., of Virginia, to be There was no objection. failed to resume production and since re the representative of the United States of Mr. DOYLE. Mr. Speaker, on yes course to the courts has so far proved in effective, it is now my plain duty to propose America on the Advisory Commission of the terday when the roll call was had on United Nations Relief and Works Agency for the Alaska statehood bill, I was recorded further action. Therefore, I recommend that the Congress enact legislation author Palestine Refugees in the Near East. as not voting. That is correct. How izing the Government to take over the coal IN THE NAVY ever, I wish to state that had I been mines and operate them as a public service. Vice Adm. Russell S. Berkey, United States here, I would have voted "aye." My Navy, to have the grade, rank, pay, and al reason for not being here was that I But, Mr. Speaker, taking such step, as lowances of a vice admiral while serving as was making a public service radio platter necessary as the President says it is, Chief o~ Information, Navy Department. in the radio room in another building, would again mean Government control IN THE COAST GUARD and I received no notice of the roll call. of the production of a natural resource. The following two officers of the United This is one of a very few number of times I am not criticizing the President, Mr. States Coast Guard for promotion to the that I was absent on roll call in my 4 Speaker. I say again I compliment him rank of rear admiral: years in the House. It was certainly not on the settlement. Collective bargain Capt. Arthur G. Hall intentional or deliberate. ing and good faith is the very basis of Capt. Norman H. Leslie The radio station platter which I was enduring, constructive, and lasting labor making was on a public service program relationships between labor and man of the radio station. I wish to make it agement. Apparently the President had perfectly clear, therefore, that it was not evidence that constrained him to also say HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES a political radio speech nor a partisan in his message to us: speech, and it was essential that it be We have arrived at the · present impasse SATURDAY,1MARCH4, 1950 made on yesterday. If, however, I had because. both the operators and the union known or had any reason to believe have failed, month after month, to make the The House met at 12 o'clock noon. that there would be a roll-call vote at efforts in genuine bargaining which could The Chaplain, Rev. Bernard Braskamp, about the same hour, I would have result in a mutually satisfactory settlement. D. D., offered the following prayer: made arrangements for some other hour They have been unwilling or unable to lay aside their charges and countercharges, mod O Thou infinite and eternal God, 1n during the day. Frankly, I would rather have missed erate their fixed positions, and undertake whom we find the meaning and majesty serious negotiation in a spirit of accommo of life, we are again approaching Thy the privilege of making the public service dation and mutual understanding. throne compelled by many needs which radio talk at all than to have missed the roll-call vote. For, Mr. Speaker and my And, then, further quoting the Presi Thou alone canst supply. colleagues, I believe my record of votes dent's message, he made it clear to those We pray that we may be men of vision in the almost 4 years I have been here critics of his and of the political party of anu of valor, richly endowed with clarity representing the great Eighteenth Con which he is the leader that the Federal of mind and courage of heart to meet gressional District of my native State of Government was not°desirous, either di and match the challenge of difficult California will reveal my vigilant atti rectly or indirectly, of getting into the problems, great responsibilities, and tude toward being present here on the glorious opportunities. field which is called nationalization by floor at least when any voting is called the critics of the Democratic Party. May we bear testimony to men and for. The President said: nations everywhere that, as citizens of CONGRATULATES PRESIDENT TRUMAN ON COAL this Republic, we are mindful of one an I am not requesting this legislation as a STRIKE SETTLEMENT AND AGAINST NATIONALI means of settling the issues in dispute be other's welfare and that in our com ZATION OF MINES tween the operators and the union. They mon remembrance we are eager to carry Mr. Speaker, I wish at this time to will have to settle their differences through one another's burdens and so fulfill the compliment the President of the United their own collective bargaining, just as law of Christ. States upon the valiant, tenacious, and though Government operation were not in May Thy name be glorified. Amen. effect. I do not propose to substitute the considerate, and yet firm, manner in Government's representatives for the private The Journal of the proceedings of yes which he and his distinguished associ operators at the bargaining table. It will terday was read and approved. ates handled the Federal Government not be our purpose to establish wages, hours, portion of the miserable coal strike or working conditions which would bind NAVAJO AND HOPI INDIANS which was this morning announced as either the operators or the miners upon re Mr. PETERSON. Mr. Speaker, I ask settled. sumption of private operations. unanimous consent to take from the More than once in this House I have And, finally, he said: Speaker's table the bill CS. 2734) to pro made it clear that I favor the use of This is the real challenge of the present mote the rehabilitation of the Navajo Government controls and compulsory situation. It is a test of our ability to find a and Hopi Tribes of Indians and a better regulations as little as possible in the way to achieve adequate production of a raw utilization of the resources of the Navajo field of labor-management or, Mr, Speak material basic to our national life, while pre and Hopi Indian Reservations, and for er, in most any field of human rela- serving the fundamental values of our free 2818 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-HOUSE MARCH 4 institutions. Both our friends and our de Mr. PRICE. Mr. Speaker, I join the I have an Irish friend who, at the end tractors in the rest of the world are watch gentleman 'from California [Mr. DOYLE] of a year, when his accident insurance ing to see how our democratic society will in extending sincere congratulations and policy ran out, said, "If I had only known meet this challenge. compliments to the President of the I was not going to have any accident bPECIAL ORDER GRANTED United States upon the dignified, sensi during the year, I would . never have ·Mr. MADDEN asked and was given ble, courageous, and intelligent manner spent the money on that insurance permission to address the House for 5 in which he acted in the recent coal sit policy." · minutes today at the conclusion of the uation. In my personal opinion, that Personally I never was'te any time re regular order of business. situation was prolonged for several gretting the money I pay for insurance, months due to the Taft-Hartley Act. I · and I am sun~ the Members of the ~ouse EXTE:r>TSION OF REMARKS have been of the opinion since the start ·will have no regrets over the inconven Mr. FLOOD asked and was given per that the mine operators of this country ience that may have been caused them mission to extend his remarks in the used this act, conceived as it was in the by having the insurance that the House RECORD and include a statement. · Eightieth Congress, as a punitive meas would be in session today so that if it had Mr. MANSFIELD asked and was given ure against labor, as a club in the hope been necessary for us to take action in permission to extend his remarks in the that they could drive the miners back connection with the coal strike, the RECORD in two instances and include in i~to the pits and back to work. The country would know that we were here one an article by Hal Boyle, of the As coal miners sought negotiations last on the job, ready and available. sociated Press, and in the other a state summer for a new contract, but as a We kept the pressure on, and the policy ment by George Burger, vice president result of the Taft-Hartley Act there paid off. of the National Federation of Independ has been no honest collective bargaining APOLOGY ACCEPTED ent Business, made before the Commit on the part of the operators in this situ tee on the Judiciary. ation. There can be no question that Mr. McCORMACK. Mr. Speaker, I ask Mr. JENSEN asked and was given per the Taft-Hartley Act has been the cause unanimous consent to address the HOUSP, mission to extend his remarks in the of chaos and confusion in the coal in for 1 minute. RECORD and include a report by Gerald dustry as in other industries. It should The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Bogan at the National Farm Institute be repealed. the request of the gentleman from Mas convention at Des Moines, Iowa, re I commend the President for refus sachusetts? cently. ing to be stampeded by the Republican There was no objection. THE BRITISH CABINET creators of the Taft-Hartley Act. Mr. McCORMACK. Mr. Speaker, it is very interesting to note the apology that Mr. F:;:.OOD. Mr. Speaker, I ask unan TREATMENT OF REPRESENTATIVES OF the gentleman from South Dakota makes imous consent to address the House for FOREIGN NATIONS to the House. That is the sum and sub 1 minute. Mr, RIVERS. Mr. Speaker, I ask stance of his remarks. He is apologizing The SPEAKER. Is there objection to unanimous consent to address the House for the arbitrary position he took yester the request of the gentleman from Penn for 1 minute and to revise and extend day when he knew that Monday was the sylvania? my remarks. earliest anything could be done in the There was no objection. The SPEAKER. Is there objection to ,House, and insisted on his position even Mr. FLOOD. Mr. Speaker, while it is the request of the gentleman from after being served notice by the leader directly no concern of the United States South Carolina? ship that there would be no business to as to the manner in which the British There was no objection. day. He insisted on the House meeting Cabinet is selected or the members there Mr. RIVERS. Mr. Speaker, I am to today. The apology is completely in of, for many reasons too numerous to day introducing a bill which will make order. Although the gentleman should mention in less than 1 minute, we have it a penal offense for anybody in the have thought of that and he had all the material indirect concern. To discover State Department, the Department of evidence to realize the situation last that the War Minister of the British Defense, or any other department of the night-as I say, he should have thought Cabinet, John Strachey, made this state Government to give to the representa of that yesterday, instead of thinking of ment in the British press yesterday, is tives of foreign nations any more rights, it today. Nevertheless, when one makes sufficient to alarm and prompt me to at privileges, or autonomies than our rep an apology, all decent-minded people ac least direct attention to it. I quote: resentatives get. I think what we ought cept it in the spirit in which it is made. It has always been public knowledge that to do to these babies is give them a little The SPEAKER. The time of the gen I supported the Communist doctrine in the tit for tat. You let them have their tleman from Massachusetts has expired. years which preceded the last war. phones tapped and have an FBI agent SPECIAL ORDER GRANTED Mr. Attlee and Mr. Strachey disclose shadow them everywhere they go, just Mr. HOFFMAN of Michigan asked and this belief has been recanted in recent as they are doing to our people. When was given permission to address the years. we have given them a little taste of this House for 10 minutes today following Mr. Strachey is to have charge of the medicine, as they are doing to our boys the disposition of business on the Speak tightening up of British security as a in the curtain countries and in the er's desk and the conclusion of special result of the Fuchs incident. . The fact Cominform countries, they may have a orders heretofore granted. that the British have a "red face" be little change of heart. When they throw cause of the Fuchs scandal is no reason one of our Navy captains off a fast THE COAL STRIKE to substitute a Red War Minister. I moving train, let us toss a few of theirs Mr. HOFFMAN of Michigan. Mr. have consistently supported all aid to off. Let us give them a little dose of Speaker, I ask unanimous consent to ad Britain; yes, and fought for it in com the Rivers medicine. This world would . dress the House for 1 minute and revise mittee and on the :floor. Under our pro be a much better place in which to live. and extend my remarks. cedure Mr. Strachey would be declared a THE POLICY PAID OFF The SPEAKER. Is there objection to security risk. The British make it diffi Mr. CASE of South Dakota. Mr. tl\e request of the gentleman from Mich cult to help them. igan? Speaker, I ask unanimous consent to There was no objection. MINE OPERATORS PROLONGED STRIKE address the House for 1 minute. Mr. CASE of South Dakota. Mr. BY USING TAFT-HARTLEY ACT AS CLUB The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Speaker, will the gentleman yield? OVER MINERS the request of the gentleman from South "Mr. HOFFMAN of Michigan. I yield. Mr. PRICE. Mr. Speaker, I ask unan Dakota? Mr. CASE of South Dakota. Mr. imous consent to address the House for There was no objection. Speaker, the gentleman from South 1 minute and to revise and extend my Mr. CASE of South Dakota. Mr. Dakota stands on what he did, and per remarks. Speaker, everyone has heard of the Irish sonally, I believe that the membership The SPEAKER. Is there objection to man who said he would give .$10,000 if he of the House, generally, is glad of the the request of the gentleman from knew the place he was going to die. fact that the RECORD will show the Con- Illinois? · When he was asked why he said, "Well, . gress was in session today, on this Satur There was no objection. because I would never go near the place." day, ready to act if the efforts to con- 1950 CONGRESSIONAL R~CORD-HOUSE 2819 elude the coal strike had not been suc SPECIAL ORDER GRANTED For my present purpose I want to cessful. Mr. HESELTON asked and was grant emphasize that in the first half of this Mr. HOFFMAN of Michigan. The ed permission to address the House for fiscal year we have apparently paid a gentleman means if we had a chance to 30 minutes on Tuesday next, fallowing total of $10, 786,209 for carrying charges do that-anC' you were not apologizing, the legislative business of the day and on these commodities. Judging by some were you? any other special orders heretofore en of the startling increases over the cost of Mr. CASE of South Dakota. No, not tered. these carrying charges for the full year in the least; by being in position to act, WASTE AT RATE OF $100 A MINUTE fiscal 1948, the total for fiscal 1949 will we kept the pressure on. run very substantially in excess of the Mr. HOFFMAN of Michigan. I did Mr. HESELTON. Mr. Speaker, I ask totals for fiscal 1948. not think you were, and did not so unanimous consent to address the House understand it. for 1 minute and to revise and extend my This should focus attention on the The SPEAKER. The time of the remarks and include some statistical resolutions introduced by the gentleman gentleman from Michigan has expired. matter. from Pennsylvania CMr. CORBETT], the gentleman from New York [Mr. KEAT EXTENSION OF REMARKS The SPEAKER. Is there objection to the request of the gentleman from Mas ING], the gentleman from Pennsylvania Mr. DONDERO asked and was given sachusetts? [Mr. HUGH D. SCOTT, JR.], and myself on permission to extend his remarks in the There was no objection. Febru~ry 2, 1950, and supported by 24 RECORD and to include an editorial. Mr. HESELTON. Mr. Speaker, on others of our colleagues. May I ref er to Mr. GAMBLE asked and was given per February 13, 1950, I reported on the of the RECORD on February 20, 1950, at page mission to extend his remarks in the ficial commodity inventories of the Com 2000. RECORD and incl\J.de a statement by the modity Credit Corporation of 10 items Let me quote the last sentence from New York State Housing Commissioner, which apparently could be utiiized as those resolutions: notwithstanding the fact that it exceeds surplus edible food. This was as of De The Secretary of Agriculture and the Com the limit fixed by the Joint Committee cember 31, 1949. The total amount ap.:. modity Credit Corporation may advance as on Printing, and is estimated by the Pub proximated 277,480 tons of--surplus food against handling and transportation costs in lic Printer to cost $191.34. commodities at a total cost of about making delivery up to the equivalent of 6 Mr. MEYER asked and was given per months' storage costs on any such commodi $265,000,000. It was exclusive of the 50,- ties turned over. mission to extend his remarks in the 000,000 bushels of surplus edible potatoes RECORD and include an editorial. involved in the order of · destruction If these carrying charges on these items MEMBERS COMPLETING 25 YEARS OF which fortunately appears not to have have continued at that rate during the SERVICE - been carried out to any su~stantial de first half of the fiscal year, they are run Mr. LECOMPTE. Mr. Speaker, I ask gree. ning in excess of approximately ~60,000 a unanimous consent to address the House There ~re some very significant statis day for a completely useless waste of for 1 minute. tics in the hearings before the Subcom public funds. From the date of the in The SPEAKER. Is there objection to . mittee on Appropriations for the Depart troduction of these resolutions, there is the request. of the gentleman from Iowa? ment of Agriculture which have been an accumulated waste which I am con There was no objection. released this week. vinced will finally be in the order of $2,- Mr. LECOMPTE. Mr. Speaker, many This afternoon I want to call your 000,000. For every day lost in trying to Members of the House have had long, particular attention to the table begin get action on these resolutions the tax distinguished careers as Members of the ning at page 1418 of those hearings payers will foot the bill to the tune of House of Representatives. My atten starting with average monthly storage better than $60,000. Putting it another tion was called to the fact that in the rates paid on commodities owned and, way, every hour's delay means a com earlier days the new Congress convened more especially the carrying charges on plete waste of Federal funds at the rate on the 4th of March, and that some price-support commodities, fiscal year of better than $2,700 an hour, or more Members have today completed exactly · 1949 and first half of fiscal year 1950. · than $100 each minute. 25 years of useful service. The Sixty There is a notation explaining that- I anticipate that someone will most ninth Congress convened on the fourth Carrying charges include transportation certainly come forward with the argu day of March, 1925. Of the group ·who costs, warehouse charges, and other costs ment that there have been net gains over came to that Congress six are here to associated with the commodity including cost of sacks used, sacking charges, cooper the entire period of substantial amounts. day. I want to mention the names of age, weighing !l-nd inspection fees, recon For instance, that since October 17, 1933, those who today have served their coun signment costs, etc., whicn are charged to when the price-support program for do try exactly 25 years, and I shall read inventory. Storage charges paid or accrued mestic cotton began, there is a net gain them in alphabetical order. on loan collateral while under loan is of $236,359,485, or, again, that on the The gentleman from Georgia CMr. charged to the cost of the commodities so price-support program on basic com Cox], the gentleman from New Jersey acquired and any costs incurred directly modities that there has been a net gain CMr. EATON], the gentleman from Ohio pursuant to purchase arrangements are in [Mr. JENKINS], the gentleman from Mas cluded in the purchase cost. in that period of $69,993,162. Of course sachusetts [Mr. MARTIN], the gentle it will be hoped by such an argument to I have taken the carrying charges for indicate that a $100-a-minute loss in woman from New Jersey [Mrs. NORTON], the list of commodities I previously re and the gentleman from Mississippi these specific carrying charges is a minor ported on so that we might have before item and undoubtedly will be absorbed [Mr. WHITTINGTON]. us the total cost of those charges, with The gentlewoman from Massachusetts the exception of canned Mexican meat by net gains. However, it will overlook [Mrs. ROGERS] came to the Congress just and I do not find the carrying charges the fact that the Commodity Credit Cor a few weeks later, as the result of a va on that item listed in the hearings be poration's own analysis of the program cancy. fore the Subcommittee on Appropria shows net losses from October 17, 1933, These folks all have served their coun tions. Then I call your attention to the through December 31, 1949, including the try well. statistics in the same hearings as to the wartime consumer subsidy program, of Mr. Speaker, of course, the very dis use made of these and other ·products in $2,101,850,443 for $2,242,642,877. tinguished gentleman from Illinois [Mr. the school-lunch program which we find And of even more importance any such SABATH], and others, have served many at pages 1499 and 1500. While many argument entirely overlooks the fact that years longer, but I mention those Mem other surplus food products are used, these carrying charges are a completely bers who happen to have exactly 25 there is no indication that butter, edi unwarranted and unnecessary cost to the years of service today and I hope they ble dried beans, edible pried peas, rice, taxpayer even though other parts of the will put in many more years of equally or turkeys have been distributed under program may well be justified upon fur useful . service in the House of Repre that program. I do not know the rea ther examination of the facts. I am glad sentatives, where they are all loved and son for this· but shall attempt to lo to report that I have received an en respected by their colleagues. cate it. couraging letter from the chairman on 2820 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-HOUSE MARCH 4
t~e House Committee.on Agriculture un cerning the donations of food as authorized cate distribution be avoided in any · city or der date of March 2 reading as follows: by section 416 of the Agricultural Act of local area. 1949 we have prepared the enclosed state State Departments of Public Welfare can Hon. JOHN w. HESELTON, ment for your use. House of Representatives, in most cases clear up questions of eligibility Washington, D . C. Irish potatoes, dried eggs, and nonfat dry concerning needy groups or families. In DEAR COLLEAGUE: Your -letter of February milk solids are, as of this date, available for quiries also may be directed to the appropri 27, with regard to" the various bills relating distribution under section 416. The enclosed ate area offices of the Food Distribution Pro to surplus commodities has been received. statement describes the groups eligible to grams Branch of the Department's Produc I have already requested a report from the receive these foods, how eligible recipients tion and Marketing Administration. Ad Department of Agriculture, and I hope that may order them, and the costs which must dresses of the latter offices are listed at the hearings may be held at some time in the 1:1 borne by the recipient. close of this statement. near future. Eligible groups which request your assist NOTICE ·oF AVAILABILITY ance ln placing orders for commodities Cordially yours, Foods offered under section 416 are an HAROLD D. COOLEY. should be referred to the area office of our Food Distribution Programs Branch serving nounced through the press and radio serv..; I am today sending a letter to the Sec your State. The area offices are in daily com ices, by field offices of the Department's munication with the State agencies handling Production and Marketing Administration, retary of Agriculture which 1·am quoting and by cooperating State agencies. for the information of my colleagues: · the distribution of section 416 commodities and thus can be of maximum assistance to Each official announcement describes the Hon. CHARLES F. BRANNAN, groups wishing to participate in the program. food offered, discloses its location, indicates Secretary of Agriculture, The addresses of these area offices are shown the size and type of containers, and gives Washington, D. C. at the close of the attached statement. other pertinent details. Each announce DEAR MR. SECRETARY: I am enclosing a copy RALPH S. TRIGG. ment also indicates the minimum and maxi of the remarks which I have placed in to mum quantities which may be ordered, and day's RECORD. Chairman COOLEY'S letter re whether the commodity will be available .for fers to H. R. 7135, H. R. 7136, H. R. 7137, and UNITED STATES an extended period of time. H. R. 7138. These were identical resolutions DEPARTMENT OF . AGRICULTURE, Available commodities will be located in filed on February 2, 1950, and, as you will PRODUCTION AND MARKETING warehouses or other storage places in various, note, were supported by 24 others of our ADMINISTRATION, parts of the United States. The foods offered. colleagues. February 27, 1950. will have been thoroughly inspected by au-· In view of the very 'substantial apparent STATEMENT ON DOMESTIC AVAILABILITY OF thorized USDA personnel and will be in accumulated and continuing waste of public COMMODITIES UNDER SECTION 416 OF THE good condition. The Department's inspec funds involved in this procedure, I am sure AGRICULTURAL ACT OF 1949 tion will assure wholesomeness of all prod:. that you will see to it personally that the Section 416 of the Agricultural Act of 1949 ucts offered. report of the Department is promptly filed provides the United States Department of HOW TO OBTAIN AVAILABL:::: FOODS with the House Committee on Agriculture. Agriculture with authority to donate to Any agency or organization wishing to ob I would appreciate the courtesy of having needy groups in this country certain food tain foods available under the program may you send to each of the authors of these products acquired by the Department under make application to the State agency acting resolutions copies of that report. its price-support operations. Sincerely yours, as distributing agent for section 416 foods, This statement summarizes what commod or to the area office of the Food Distribution JOHN W. HESELTON. ities are available, who may obtain them, Programs Branch. No special forms are I was much interested in the memo how they may be obtained, minimum con needed for the application. The applying randum from the Administrator of Pro ditions to. be met by the receiving agency, organization, if eligible, will receive a single duction and Marketing to Members of and where additional inquiries may be di sheet "Order Form." This is the only _form rected. required. It is all-inclusive and covers all Congress which I received Thursday. I matters relating to the order and acceptance think it would be useful to have it, the COMMODITIES AVAILABLE Food stocks that may be made available of the foods. statement on domestic availability of are those for which no market outlet in Only a few conditions need be met to _..commodities dated February 27, 1950, normal trade channels is foreseen during obtain these foods. The applying agency and the very simple order form which their storable life, thus exposing them to the must agree to limit its distribution of the can be used for requesting section 416 · danger of deterioration and spoilage. Such foods obtained .to eligible persons, and to see that all necessary. precautions are taken commodities in the RECORD. This is in ·commodities will be donated at the point of sharp and pleasant contrast to the in storage, and beyond that point, all expenses to keep the donated food from entering nor volved · mass of red tape which sur incidental to handling, transportation, and mal channels of trade. Also the agency repackaging must be borne by the receiving must agree not to reduce its expenditures rounded the distribution of section 32 organization. for food because of the receipt of the donated commodities. commodities, and which I placed in the As of" this date, February 27, 1950, three RECORD February 20 at page 2000. commodities-potatoes, dried eggs, and non Each order which includes these provisions I have written Mr. Trigg today to in fat dry milk solids-have beeh declared avail covers only a single delivery of a specific quire when other food commodities in able to designated groups. Potatoes were quantity of a commodity. When an agency surplus may be declared · available and so declared on January f7, and are obtain is informed that a commodity is available able at purchase points in approximately on a continuous basis, the agency may re hope to·have his advice early next week. order this food item without subsequent I have also asked him if anything is be 20 States. The other two items were an nounced February 8 as obtainable at storage notice of its ~vailability. ing done to simplify the procedure under points in a large number of cities :throughout SHIPPING CHARGES section 32 commodities. the country. The receiving agency, as specified in the Again I wish to point out the very ob WHO MAY OBTAIN THESE FOODS act, must pay handling and transportation vious inequities so far as a great many charges, including special charges for heat All three of the foods announced to date ing or refrigeration, if needed, from the point communities are concerned in requiring are available to schools for lunch programs, ther... 1 to pay transportation and other of storage or availability. Information con incidental costs from points of storage and to the Bureau of Indian Affairs and cerning the cost of transporting commodi State and local public welfare agencies for ties may be obtained from local transpor located some distance away. I submit the assistance of needy Indians and other that only through the enactment of the t ation companies. needy persons. In addition, privat e welfare Receiving agencies having their own trucks resolutions I have msntioned can this organizations engaged exclusively in welfare may, in most cases, pick up and transport inequity be eliminated. work are eligible to receive potatoes for the section 416 foods if they wish to do so. The statement and enclosures are as needy families assisted by them. follows: Patriotic and fraternal or service organi PACKAGING UNITED STATES zations, which are not basically devoted to Most section 416 commodities will be DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, welfare work, even though they maintain available only in large containers. Any PRODUCTION AND MARKETING well established welfare units, are not in repackaging that is necessary must be done ADMINISTRATION, themselves eligible for section _ 416 . foods. by the receiving agency. Repackaging, of Washington, D. C., February 28, 1950. However, the groups or individuals normally course, must be carried out in full compli To: Members of Congress of the United assisted by the organization may become ance with State and local sanitation laws. States. eligible upon certification as needy persons AREA OFFICES, FOOD DISTRIBUTION PROGRAMS From: Administrator. by the accredited public welfare agency. BRANCH, PRODUCTION AND MARKETING AD· Subject: Domestic availability of commodi Such regulations on the receipt and distri MINISTRATION, UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT ties under section 416 of the Agricultural bution of commodities by private welfare OF AGRICULTURE Act of 1949. groups are necessary in order to assure that Northeast area, ti41 Washington S'treet, To assist you in answering the many in commodities reach only needy persons as N. Y.; Connecticut, District of Columbla, quiries you are undoubtedly receiving con- specified in the act, and in order that dupli- Delaware, Maine, Ma~sachusetts, Maryland, 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-· HOUSE 2821 New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Penn Western -area, 30 · Van Ness Avenue, San sC:Utheast·area, 449 West Peachtree StrE!et sylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, West Vir Francisco: Arizona, California, Idaho, Mon NE, Atlanta: Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Ken ginia. For metropolitan area, New York City, tana, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, Washington, tucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, South 90 Church Street. . •Wyoming. Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia. Midwest area, 623 South Wabash Avenue, Honolulu, T. H., 418 Dillingham Building: Chicago: Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, Southwest area, 101 Norman Building, Hawaii. Minnesota, Missouri, North Dakota, Nebras Dallas: Arkansas, Colorado, Kansas, Louisi San Juan, P. R., P. 0. Box 4349: Puerto ka, Ohio, South Dakota, Wisconsin. ana, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Texas. Rico and Virgin Islands.
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, PRODUCTION AND MARK}!:TING ADMINISTRATION
ORDER FOR SECTION 416 CQMMODITY
1. State 3. Name of commodity
2. Agency order No. 4. Quantity (number and size units):
6. Origin of commodity
6. Consignee
7. Via
8. Send collect wire notice of shipment to: (Fill in only if desired) 9. Number of persons and quantity for commodities requested
Nu~ber persons Quantity ------ s'chooJs ______------(sti:·eei-a:D.a.· 11iiffiiier5------Institutions_------______. ______------Indians ___ ------______-----______------__ ------.----_ ------(oitY.f------· ·----··-··------{statcf------we1rare __ ------_____ ------______------__ ------__. __ _
The undersigned, being duly ~uthorized t~ act for and on ~o~alf of the below-named agency, hereby re_q!Jests and agr~es to accept the commodity under the terms and con· ditions
11. Agency representative's signature_ ------_------:------12. Date_ -- _------____ ------_------
TIIJS SPACE FOR USDA-CCC ONLY 13. Approved for USDA-CCC: I"· O'd" void ifundclive'od by,
The agency ordering the commodity speci . The SPEAKER. Is there objection to we come here. The-feeling has been so fied on the face hereof agrees to the follow-· the request of the gentleman from very intense because nothing was done ing terms and conditions regarding its re Nebraska? · about the coal strike that I, for one, am ceipt, handling, distribution, and/or use. There was no objection. very glad to be here in case something 1. Expenditures for food will not be reduced because of receipt of such food commodities. Mr. · MILLER of Nebraska. Mr. · could have been done. There has not 2. The commodity will only be distributed Speaker, personally I am glad that the only been great discomfort because of to eligible participants for their consumption House is meeting today. We folks from lack of coal but illness and real suffering. and will not be sold, traded, or otherwise the Midwest, 1,500 miles f!'om Washing I understand the gentleman from South · disposed of. ton, like to stay here at work. The work Dakota [Mr. CASE] a week or more ago 3. All costs incurred subsequent to the completed to date is not very imposing. had 'introduced a bill that might have transfer of title at the. CCC point of storage I listened very intently to the colloquy settled the coal strike if action had been will he promptly paid upon proper presenta between the gentleman from Massachu taken. I would like to commend him for tion by claimants. Such costs will include, setts [Mr. McCORMACK] and the gentle- his tin~less work since he has become a but are not neces:;arily limited to the cost of transportation, special protective services, . man from South Dakota [Mr. CASE]. I Member of this Congress. I was a Mem and handling charges. must confess it reminded me·of a patient ber when he first came here. Step by 4. Assumes entire responsibility for the I was treating at one time for cancer of step he has progressed in usefulness un adequate handling, storing, repackaging, the stomach, and he came to me com til he has reached great stature in the distribution, and/or use of the commodity plaining about a pimple on his nose. We House. He spent· endless time in study so that it will, insofar as practicable, be con ought to hold a meeting. There is work ing parliamentary procedure until he sumed by eligible participants. to be done. Let the leadership hasten has become an expert parliamentarian, The SPEAKER. The time of the gen the job so Members of Congress can go and he has been a very valuable member tleman from Massachusetts has expired. home and give the co~ntry a rest. of the Committee on Appropriations. He HON. FRANCJS CASE is highly respected for his great integrity EXTENSION OF REMARKS and sincerity, and he has been very Mr. JENNINGS asked and was given -Mrs. ROGERS of Massachusetts. Mr. helpful whenever he could be. He has permission to extend his remarks in the Speaker, I ask unanimous consent to ad been deeply interested in all veterans' Appendix of the RECORD. ' dress the House for 1 minute and to re and other problems in which I am espe Mr. MASON asked and was given per vise and extend my remarks. cially concerned. .111issit0n to extend his remarks in the The SPEAKER. Is there objection to The SPEAKER. The time of the RECORD and include an article by David the request of the . gentlewoman from gentlewoman from Massachusetts. has Lawrence. Massachusetts? expired. There was no objection. THE COAL SITUA'.... ION Mrs. ROGERS of Massachusetts. Mr. THE COAL STRIKE Mr. MILLER of Nebraska. Mr. Speaker, although I am here today at " Mr. SABATH. Mr. Speaker, I ask Speaker, I ask unanimous ·consent to ad considerable personal sacrifice, I am ex unanimous consent to proceed for 1 dress the House for 1 minute and to re tremely glad that the gentleman from minute, and to revise and extend my re- : vise and extend my remarks. South Dakota [Mr. CASE] insisted that marks. 2822 CONGRESStONAL RECORD-HOUSE MARCH 4
The SPEAKER. Is there objection to The SPEAKER. Is there objection to wo1~ k a year. The mine owners, in.many the request of the gentleman from Illi the request of the gentleman from-Mis- instances, find they have grave problems nois? souri? caused by the inroad of other types of There was no objection. There was no ob~ection. · fuel. These developments are having Mr. SABATH. Mr. Speaker, I also Mr. CHRISTOPHER. Mr. Speaker, I grave effects on this great basic industry. · congratulate, not only those who have think our President deserves the com- I hope the Congress will proceed to served here for 25 years, but also those mendation of every Member of this consider this proposal forthwith and set who have served longer-among them, as House on both sides of the aisle, and of all up a commission similar to the Hoover I recollect, ROBERT L. DOUGHTON' our be the people of the United States individ- Commission, a truly bipartisan commis loved Speaker, Mr. RAYBURN, CARL VIN ually and collectively. He has shown sion which will bring to the Congress SON, ROBERT CROSSER, DAN REED, ROY that he has · great patience, a thing a recommendations that may do away with WOODRUFF, EARL MICHENER, CLARENCE man at the head of this the greatest the misery and distress which exist in the CANNON, EMANUEL CELLER, JOHN KERR, nation in the world must have. I think coal fields, eliminate the recurring crises ALFRED BUL WIN.KLE, E. E. Cox, CHARLES he has demonstrated that he has force in production, and prevent future dis EATON, JOE MARTIN, Mrs. MARY NORTON, of character. He has handled this coal location of our economic life. and Mrs. EDITH ROGERS, and these who situation in a firm and dignified man- THE ECONOMIC SITUATION are now in their twenty-fifth year of ner. service-CLIFFORD HOPE, our majority In my opinion the Taft-Hartley law Mr. O'SULLIVAN. Mr. Speaker, I ask leader, JOHN MCCORMACK, RICHARD WIG is the reason for this strike, and the unanimous consent to address the House GLESWORTH, CHARLES WOLVERTON, and Taft.-Hartley law has worked a lot of for 1 minute and to revise and extend AUGUST ANDRESEN. harm in the United States; but the my remarks. But above all else, Mr. Speaker, I wish greatest harm it has worked is to the The SPEAKER. Is there objection to congratulate the President of the Republican Party. In my opinion the to the request of the gentleman from United States for the splendid judgment Taft-Hartley law is one reason the gen- Nebraska? he has exercised in the extremely trying tleman from Massachusetts [Mr. MAR- There was no objection. conditions that confronted him and the TIN] is not Speaker of the House today, Mr. O'SULLIVAN. Mr. Speaker, I country; that he did not permit himself and one reason that Mr. Dewey is still in feel rather favorable toward the adop"." to be forced one way or to act the ot1:1er New York. tion by Congress of the bill which the way. I think his action was that of the The SPEAKER. The time of the gen- gentleman from South Carolina [Mr. tleman from Missouri has expired. RIVERS] has introduced. I believe you prudent and courageous man that he is. must fight fire with fire. I believe that I realize that the President has been PERMISSION TO ADDRESS THE HOUSE one must always in any real fight give subjected to tremendous pressure from both sides. Even his greatest critics, in Mr. SIKES. Mr. Speaker, I ask unan- back as good and, if possible, better than cluding my Republican friends who were imous consent to address the House for one receives. I do not believe you can trying to :nake political capital out of the 1 minute and to revise and extend my kill a skunk by kissing him to· death. coal strike must concede that when it remarks. Here is another thing I want to men- became necessary for him to act, he did The SPEAKER. Is there objection to tion: I can probably tell Dr. MILLEIJ., my not hesitate, but acted. I am pleased to the request of the gentleman from Flor- good colleague from Nebraska, just why see he has brought about a satisfactory ida? that man came to him to have a pimple solution to this vexing problem, and that There was no objection. on his nose treated when he was dying in the years to come I know the histo [Mr. SIKES addressed the House. His of cancer. The man told me that he rians will credit him with extraordinary remarks appear in the Appendix.] thought Dr. MILLER was more capable of . EXTENSION OF REMARKS curing the pimple than in handling a resourcefulness and sound judgment. cancer. I wish to again congratulate him and Mr. RANKIN. Mr. Speaker, reserving the country upon the splendid judgment the right to object, and I shall not, I THE HONORABLE SAM RAYBURN, he has used. should like for some of these hilarious · SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE OF REP- Mr. Speaker, I have been here 44 years. speakers boasting about tb.e settlement RESENTATIVES If the Constitution had not been changed, of the coal strike to tell us just how it Mr. PATMAN. Mr. Speaker, I ask setting a new date for the termination . was settled. unanimous consent to address the House of the old Congress and the convening The SPEAKER. Is there objection to for 1 minute and to revise and extend of the new, I now would have completed the request of the gentleman from my remarks. 44 yea:i.-s of service. Notwithstanding the Oklahoma that he may extend his re- The SPEAKER. Is there objection Taft-Hartley Act that tried to enslave marks in the RECORD as indicated? to the request of the gentleman from American labor, it has not affected me in There was no objection. Texas? my position in this body. I have been There was no objection. enslaved here for 44 years. COMMISSION TO STUDY THE COAL Mr. PATMAN. Mr. Speaker, it is a I am sometimes asked how it is that INDUSTRY wonderful and inspiring thing to con- I can come back, and come back, and Mr. BIEMILLER. Mr. Speaker, I ask template the record of public service come back. I tell these friends who ask unanimous consent to address the House rendered by our distinguished and able me, "Do right by the people, and you for 1 minute and to revise and extend Speaker, the Honorable SAM RAYBURN. It can come back as many times as you my remarks. was 37 years ago today that he entered desire as long as you honestly represent The SPEAKER. Is there objection to upon his first term in the Congress of the your people." That is my advice, "Do the request of the gentleman from Wis- United States. right and fear nothing." consin? That period of time spans a substan- I know that most of those who have There was no objection. tial and eventful portion of the modern served here a quarter century or more Mr. BIEMILLER. Mr. Speaker, earlier history of our Nation, and in the mak have, at all times, had the interest of the this week I introduced a joint resolution ing of that history Mr. RAYBURN has people at heart, and I hope some who calling for the creation of a bipartisan played a significant and influential part. have not will follow their course in the commission to make a study of the long- But, with the true modesty that is the future. To these right-thinking col range problems of the coal industry and hallmark of his greatness, his a~com leagues of mine I extend the hope and to report in January 1951 to the Con- plishments in the field of statecraft have wish for many more years of continuolis . gress with its recommendations. I was not been shouted from the housetops. service, and that they may equal or sur delighted to note that yesterday the That he attained the position that pass my length of service which now has President included a similar recom- President Truman himself describes as reached the forty-fourth year. mendation as part of his message to the "the second most powerful office in the Congress. · United States" without fanfare, without THE COAL STRIKE All of us must recognize, I believe, that publicity seeking, and without self Mr. CHRISTOPHER. Mr. Speaker, I part of the difficulty we are in today is glorification, is evidence that his prog a.sk unanimous consent to address the because the coal industry is in economic ress was due to work: and not to words. House for 1 minute and to revis~ and ex distress. The workers in the coal in-. Spz.aker RAYEURI~ U; a do3r and not a tend my remarks. dustry fre9uently get less than 200 dzys talker. 1950 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-HOUSE 2823 The people of the Fourth Congres first time imposed safeguards for the gentleman has been talking about really sional District of Texas must have real public investors in stocks and bonds, and is not a pimple after all. It is simply ized that long ago, because they have a host of other measures. I could men part of a constructive program which has returned him to Washington every 2 tion. worked out with a profit to the Govern years for 19 consecutive elections. And, The years he has spent in Washington ment of the United States. This pro in doing so, they have not only assured have been years of accomplishment, of gram has provided a stabilization of themselves _of faithful representation of increasing responsibilities and burdens American agriculture, and in turn, has their affairs at the National Capital, but of office, and of growing influence in the produced a large measure of prosperity have given to the Nation a public servant councils of the Nation. for the entire Nation in addition to help of the highest order. Yet Mr. RAYBURN, with all his success, ing us win the war and the postwar peace It is a little difficult today to reorient with all his high position, with all the up to now. ourselves to March 4, 1913, the day that high respect and esteem in which he is WORKERS DEFENSE LEAGUE LIES ABOUT SAM RAYBURN first took the oath of office held, still is unchanged in character THE SOUTH as a Member of the House of Repre from the young man sent here by his sentatives. But let us glance backward neighbors and friends in Bonham and Mr. RANKIN. Mr. Speaker, I ask a moment. the surrounding area. unanimous consent to address the House Through the Mexican border inci He is straightforward and honest in for 1 minute and to revise and extend dents, through the First World War, his dealings with his fellowman, just as my remarks and include excerpts from through the so-called era of normalcy in his personal life he is simple in his a newspaper article. which followed it, through the dark days tastes, without affectation or pomp. ,:I'he SPEAKER. Is there objection to of depression in the early thirties, The greatness of this man is in his the request of the gentleman from through the period of relief, reform and plain dignity, the restraint with which Mississippi? recovery, through the crisis of Pearl he exercises power, the respect he holds There was no objection. Harbor and the momentous national ef for an opponent's views, the humility Mr. RANKIN. Mr. Speaker, the Com fort and ultimate victory of World War with which he carries his responsibilities, munist advocates of a world government II, anCl now through the postwar prob and, in his deep and abiding faith in our are using mysterious ways their wonders lem period-through all of this SAM democratic processes and in the collec to perform. RAYBURN has served his country; served tive wisdom of the Congress as the direct Yesterday the Associated Press carried it faithfully, effectively, and modestly. representatives of the people. a story of a representative of the so A whole panorama of national events, called Workers Defense League who went Mr. RAYBURN comes of pioneer stock. to the United Nations, that communistic of political upheavals, of personalities As a boy he labored in the fields. We can appearing and disappearing from the set-up in New York that wants to domi be thankful that this sturdiness and nate the American people and the peo scene could be recalled in connection strength maintains him in good health with the period of Speaker RAYBURN'S ple of every State, and told them that in to be with us to observe this anniversary the South the share croppers, cotton career. today, and this also makes us hopeful It embraces the term of Woodrow pickers, and others were reduced to a that we can continue every year to cele state of slavery. Wilson, his creation of the Federal Re brate many more such occasions. serve System and other notable domestic A more miserable lie could not have I beli.eve it was Alexander Hamilton been uttered at any time. contributions, as well as the tragic fail who said: ure of America to accept the League of He went on to say that the turpentine Nations. The amelioration of the condition of man workers are in the same predicament, kind and the increase of human happiness and that the fruit gatherers in the It covers the era of Harding, Coolidge, ought to be the leading objects of every po and Hoover, the calm before the storm litical institution, and the aim of every in Southwest and in California are in the of economic disaster. dividual according to the measure of his same predicament. Then he went so It includes the thrilling and active power, in the situation he occupies. far away as the Pribilof Islands and days of the early and later New Deal said that they are reducing the Eskimos under President Franklin D. Roosevelt, SAM RAYBURN has always acted toward who help to gather the sealskins on the the close and daily application to vital those noble ends. Pribilof Islands to slavery. problems of war and war production on EXTENSION OF REMARKS Now, that is just one of the few Com which the fate of the Nation itself hung Mr. HOLIFIELD asked and was given munist fronts that are trying to use this in balance. permission to extend his remarks in the set-up in New York to take over the Thus five Presidents have come and RECORD and include a short statement. Government of the United States and gone since Mr. RAYBURN first came to dominate the people of every State of Washington, and, in the House of Rep ACCUMULATION OF STORAGE CHARGES this Union. It is time the American resentatives, his term of service has en ON COMMODITIES people knew the truth about that compassed the regimes of seven Speak - Mr. WHITE of California. Mr. Speak would-be world government and that ers before him, none of whom served er, I ask unanimous consent to address Congress woke up and withdrew from it. longer continuously in that office. the House for 1 minute. The American people are capable of Only two Members in the House to The SPEAKER. Is there objection to conducting their own affairs under the day-the v.enerable dean, ADOLPH SA the request of the gentleman from Cali Constitution, without any help from peo BATH, of Illinois, and our friend Boa fornia? ple who have shown that they are DOUGHTON, of North Carolina, have been There was no objection. incapable. of governing themselves. here longer than Mr. RAYBURN. Mr. WHITE of California. Mr. Speak The SPEAKER. Under previous order Even before his elevation to the er, in answer to the gentleman from Mas of the House, the gentleman from In speakership, Mr. RAYBURN left a solid im sachusetts [Mr. HESELTON] as to the diana [Mr. MADDEN] is recognized for 5 print on the pages of legislative history storage charges accumulating on com minutes. of this country. He was for long the modities which are being held by the THE COAL STRIKE chairman of the Committee on Inter Department of Agriculture, may I point Mr. MADDEN. Mr. Speaker, I wish to state and Foreign Commerce, and later out that these charges are accumulating congratulate President Truman on his majority leader. He was responsible for mainly on the so-called basic or non masterly settlement of the coal strike. the enactment of a number of major perishable commodities such as cotton The devastating coal strike is now 99 laws having a basic effect upon the wel and wheat. Those commodities have percent settled. Informed sources say fare and economy of the Nation; among never cost the taxpayer of this Nation that the miners will be back to work them the Rural Electrification Act which one red cent in the final analysis. Very Monday. brought to the farmers of America the few people seem to realize that. I have This unnecessary tie-up of coal pro:.. benefits of the electrical age, the War before me the statement of the Com duction and its repercussions on other Risk Insurance Act which gave protec modity Credit Corporation from Octo industry should be classified by a mili tion to the servicemen and their kin, the ber 1933 through November 1949. The tary term as "Operations Taft-Hartley." Utility Holding Company Act, the. Fed program to date on those basic com Cyrus S. Ching, Federal Mediator and eral Securities Act, and the Stock Ex modities shows a net profit of $83,000,000 former rubber executive, publicly stated change Regalation Act, which fo1· the to the Government. So this pimple the several weeks ago that there had not been 2824 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-HOUSE any honest effort at collective bargaining also investigate the extent of the good Mr. MADDEN. I thank the niajoiity since contract discussions started last faith collective bargaining in other labor leader for his constructive remarks. summer. The response of the coal oper disputes which have tied UP. our economy ators to all collective bargaining pro since the Taft-Hartley Act has been in COMMITI'EE ON AGRICULTURE posals was an emphatic "No." The Amer force. Mr. COOLEY. Mr. Speaker, I ask ican people were compelled to endure the I am satisfied that the report of an· unanimous consent that the Committee inconvenience of a coal crisis because investigation of this kind will reveal the on Agriculture may have until midnight powerful interests in this country insisted necessity for the immediate repeal of the tonight to me a conference report on that President Truman be compelled to Taft-Hartley Act. the bill H. R. 2023. . use the injunction provision of the Taft Our American economy cannot afford The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Hartley Act. At a terrible cost, a crisis to wait for the Eighty-second Congress to the request of the gentleman from North developed wherein the President was repeal this unworkable law. Carolina? compelled to use the Taft-Hartley in Mr. McCORMACK. Mr. Speaker, will There was no objection. junction. This un-American provision the gentleman yield? REPEALING THE TAXES ON in the Taft-Hartley Act proved to be a Mr. MADDEN. I yield to the gentle OLEOMARGARINE 100-percent failure. Approximately 450,- man from Massachusetts. 000 miners refused to go back to work Mr. McCORMACK. While many of Mr. COOLEY, from the committee of in spite of the injunction. As soon as his critics and opponents were talking conference, submitted a conference re the operators discovered the monumental and creating straw men for the purpose port and statement on the bill