Operational Design Guidelines for High Occupancy Vehicle Lanes On
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Operational Design Guidelines U.S Department of Transportaton for High Occupancy Vehicle Lanes on Arterial Roadways November 1994 ITI TOOLBOX Orginally Published by Ministry of Transportation of Ontario, Canada 101625 TDFO-94-04 OPERATIONAL DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR HOV LANES ON ARTERIAL ROADWAYS INCLUDING PLANNING STRATEGIES AND SUPPORTING MEASURES MUNICIPAL/PROVINCIAL HOV/TDM COMMITTEE DEMAND MANAGEMENT AND FORECASTING OFFICE MINISTRY OF TRANSPORTATION OF ONTARIO McCormick Rankin November 1994 OPERATIONAL DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR HOV LANES ON ARTERIAL ROADWAYS TABLE OF CONTENTS Page PREFACE . i SECTION I:HOVs AS PART OF THE MUNICIPAL TRANSPORTATION PLANNING STRATEGY......................... I-1 I-l INTRODUCTION............................................. I-1 l-2 WHY HOV? COSTS, BENEFITS AND EXPERIENCE..................... I-1 l-3 HOV INITIATIVES IN ONTARIO TO DATE........................... l-4 l-3.1 Reserved Bus Lanes.................................... I-4 l-3.2 HOV Lanes.......................................... l-5 l-3.3 HOV Priority Programs and Initiatives........................ l-6 l-3.4 Provincial Policy....................................... l-8 l-3.5 Municipal Policy....................................... l-9 l-3.6 Funding Practice ..................................... l-11 l-3.6.1 HOV Lane Construction........................... I-11 l-3.6.2 Operational and Supporting Measures................. l-11 l-3.7 Documentation and Resources............................ I-12 l-4 HOV NETWORKS AND STRATEGIC PLANNING...................... l-13 l-4.1 The Transportation - Land Use Link ........................ l-13 l-4.2 Managing the Transportation System....................... l-14 I-4.3 HOV Strategic Planning at the Municipal Level ................ I-16 l-4.3.1 Municipal HOV Strategy .......................... I-16 l-4.3.2 Planning Steps................................. l-17 l-4.3.3 HOV Facility Principles and Preconditions .............. l-19 l-4.3.4 Justification Criteria for HOV Facilities ................ l-22 l-4.4 HOV Networks ...................................... l-23 l-4.4.1 HOV Network Planning........................... l-23 l-4.4.2 HOV Network Implementation ...................... l-24 l-4.4.3 Network Consistency ............................ l-26 l-4.5 Individual HOV Lanes.................................. l-28 l-4.5.1 Indicators of Suitable Corridors...................... l-28 l-4.5.2 Vehicle Eligibility and Related Issues.................. l-31 l-4.5.2.1 Vehicle Occupancy Criteria ................ l-31 l-4.5.2.2 HOV or RBL?.......................... l-32 l-4.5.2.3 HOV 2+ or HOV 3+? ................... l-37 l-4.5.3 Changing the Rules.............................. l-41 l-4.5.3.1 Modifying Use of an Existing HOV Lane .......l-41 l-4.5.3.2 Conversion of a General Purpose Lane to HOV Use................................. l-42 l-4.5.3.3 Dealing with HOV Lane Underutilization .......l-43 i TABLE OF CONTENTS (CONT’D) Page l-4.5.4 HOV Lane Implementation: Leading up to Opening Day.....l-44 l-4.5.5 Environmental Assessment Requirements for HOV Lanes....l-45 l-4.6 HOV Priority and Support Programs........................ l-45 l-4.7 Demand Modelling for HOVs............................. l-45 l-4.7.1 Modelling Techniques............................ l-45 l-4.7.2 Information Requirements......................... l-46 l-4.8 Costs and Benefits.................................... l-48 l-4.8.1 Capital Cost................................... l-48 l-4.8.2 Related Costs................................... l-48 l-4.9 An Administrative Challenge............................. l-50 SECTION II: HOV LANE OPERATIONAL PLANNING GUIDELINES . II-1 II-I ELIGIBLE VEHICLES . , . II-1 II-1.1 Buses............................................. II-1 II-1.2 Taxis............................................. II-1 II-1.3 Carpools, Vanpools and Motorcycles....................... II-2 II-1.4 Trucks............................................ II-2 II-1.5 Bicycles ........................................... II-2 II-2 VEHICLE OCCUPANCY........................................ II-3 II-3 TIME OF HOV DESIGNATION . II-4 II-3.1 Time of Day ........................................ II-4 II-3.2 Day of Week........................................ II-7 II-4 HOV LANE USAGE CRITERIA . II-7 II-4.1 Maximum Vehicular Capacity ............................ II-9 II-4.2 Minimum Volume for Viability............................ II-13 II-4.3 Non-Users, Turning Vehicles, and Violators................... II-15 II-4.4 Net HOV Lane Usage .................................. II-16 II-5 ENFORCEMENT . II-17 II-5.1 Legislation ......................................... II-17 II-5.2 Stationary Violations .................................. II-18 II-5.3 Moving Violations .................................... II-18 II-5.4 Occupancy Rate Violations ............................. II-18 II-5.5 Enforcement Facilities.................................. II-20 II-5.6 Other Enforcement Techniques........................... II-21 II-5.7 Public Involvement in HOV Lane Enforcement [“HERO” Program).... II-22 ii TABLE OF CONTENTS (CONT’D) Page SECTION Ill: OPERATIONAL DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR ARTERIAL HOV LANES ............................. Ill-1 Ill-1 ROADWAY TYPES.......................................... Ill-1 Ill-2 HOV LANES ON ROADWAY SEGMENTS .......................... Ill-1 Ill-3 QUEUEBY PASSES.......................................... III-5 Ill-4 INTERSECTION TREATMENTS.................................. Ill-6 III-4.1 Four Lane Approach................................... Ill-6 III-4.2 Six Lane Approach................................... III-10 III-4.3 Signal Phasing...................................... Ill-14 III-4.4 Signal Priority...................................... Ill-14 Ill-5 SIGNAGE ............................................... III-20 III-5.1 Experience ........................................ Ill-20 III-5.2 Pavement Markings.................................. Ill-20 III-5.3 Overhead / Roadside Signage ........................... Ill-21 Ill-6 TRANSITIONS............................................ Ill-27 Ill-7 ENFORCEMENT FACILITIES .................................. Ill-34 Ill-8 TRANSIT PROVISIONS...................................... Ill-36 III-8.1 Bus Bays.......................................... Ill-36 III-8.1.1 Intersections.............................. Ill-37 III-8.1.2 Mid-block ................................ Ill-37 III-8.2 Platforms / Shelters.................................. Ill-37 Ill-9 NON-HOV CONSIDERATIONS................................. Ill-39 III-9.1 On-Street Parking.................................... Ill-39 Ill-9.3 Snow Removal ..................................... Ill-40 Ill-9.4 Construction / Maintenance ............................ Ill-42 SECTION IV: HOV PRIORITY PROGRAMS - AN ESSENTIAL PART OF THE PACKAGE ........................... IV-1 IV-1 INTRODUCTION............................................ IV-1 IV-2 TRAVEL DEMAND MANAGEMENT............................... IV-1 . III TABLE OF CONTENTS (CONT’D) Page IV-3 HOV-SUPPORTIVE PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES . IV-5 IV-3.1 Transportation Management Associations.................... IV-5 IV-3.2 Ride Matching Service ................................. IV-5 IV-3.3 Vanpools .......................................... IV-8 IV-3.4 Guaranteed Ride Home................................ IV-10 IV-3.5 Fuel Pricing and Road Tolls............................. IV-10 IV-4 PARKING PRIORITY . IV-11 IV-4.1 Policy............................................ IV-11 IV-4.2 Park and Ride Lots................................... IV-11 IV-4.3 Carpool Lots....................................... IV-13 IV-4.4 Trip-End Parking .................................... IV-15 IV-4.5 Parking Fees....................................... IV-16 IV-4.6 Private Parking ..................................... IV-18 IV-5 TRANSIT OPERATION . IV-18 IV-5.1 Intermodal Coordination............................... IV-18 IV-5.2 Express Services.................................... IV-18 IV-5.3 Technological Advances............................... IV-20 IV-5.4 “People-Moving Companies”............................ IV-20 IV-6 MARKETING . , . IV-20 IV-6.1 Nomenclature...................................... IV-22 IV-6.2 Public Education .................................... IV-22 APPENDICES APPENDIX A MTO HOV AGENDA APPENDIX B HOV SIGNAGE (MUTCD) APPENDIX C SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY iv LIST OF EXHIBITS Page Exhibit I-1 Planning and Design Process for Municipal Road Projects........ l-18 Exhibit I-2 HOV Decision-Making Flow Chart ......................... l-20 Exhibit l-3 Rapid Transit Access Patterns by Mode ..................... l-34 Exhibit II-1 Time of Tripmaking by Mode............................. II-5 Exhibit II-2 Hourly Variation of Auto Occupancy Characteristics ............ II-8 Exhibit II-3 HOV Lane Capacity (I) (650 veh/lane/h arterial)................ II-10 Exhibit II-4 HOV Lane Capacity (II) (800 veh/lane/h arterial) ............... II-11 Exhibit II-5 HOV Lane Capacity (III) (900 veh/lane/h arterial)............... II-12 Exhibit Ill-1 Arterial Street HOV Lane Cross-Section Alternatives ............ Ill-3 Exhibit Ill-2 Design Issues for Arterial HOV Lane Alternatives............... Ill-4 Exhibit Ill-3 Urban Intersection Treatment (1).......................... Ill-7 Exhibit Ill-4 Urban Intersection Treatment (2).......................... Ill-8 Exhibit Ill-5 Urban Intersection Treatment (3).......................... Ill-9 Exhibit Ill-6 Suburban Intersection Treatment (1) .....................