Green Theory in Environmental
Policy Making in China
Javier Ghahreman
International Relations Dept. of Global Political Studies -Bachelor programme – IR103L 15 credits thesis Autumn 2018-81400-International Relations III/2018 Supervisor: Scott McIver
Abstract
Climate change has been a topic of discussion for quite some time now. International Relations Theory, which is widely used to study the politics of the world also has a subfield of Green Theory in IR which concerns itself with world politics in a combination of the environment. This study has been conducted as part of an investigation to study the effects of green theories on green policymaking, specifically in the case of China. For the study, a qualitative study was conducted where trends of environmental governance related results were examined to draw a conclusion to the research questions. This study is in hope to present the case of China which ranks among the most contaminated nation and is also a major contributor to the global environmental crisis of ecological damage. It presents how China has been able to turn the tables and has become a case exemplar instead for the world to follow in environment protection owing to strong laws and implementation by its government.
Keywords – “green policy”, “green theory”, “IR”, “China”, “environmental governance” Total Words - 14332
Table of Contents 1. Introduction ...... 1
1.1 The rising challenge of Environmental Conservation...... 1
1.2 Theorical framework and IR relevance ...... 3
1.3 Research Aim ...... 4
1.4 Research Objectives ...... 5
1.5 Research Questions ...... 5
1.6 Research Rationale ...... 5
2. Literature Review...... 7
2.1 International Theories and origin of Green Theory ...... 7
2.2 International Relations, Environment and Green Theory – the challenges ...... 9
2.3 Environmental Governance ...... 13
2.4 Environmental Policy Implementation Challenges in China ...... 15
2.5 Literature Gap ...... 16
3. Research Methodology ...... 17
3.1 Method Outline ...... 17
3.2 Case Selection ...... 17
3.3 Research Philosophy ...... 18
3.4 Research Approach ...... 19
3.5 Research Design ...... 20
3.6 Data collection process ...... 20
4. Analaysis and Data Findings ...... 21
4.1 Is green theory an important facet to consider when making environmental
policies? 21
4.2 How relevant is Green theory in China’s environmental policymaking process? ... 25
4.3 The success of China’s environmental governance is not just dependent on
adherence to green norms. What may be the other factors that could make it a success? ..... 30
5. Conclusion, Recommendation and Limitations ...... 38
6. Bibliography ...... 40
1. Introduction
1.1 The rising challenge of Environmental Conservation
Today the world is more complex and dynamic in behavior than any other time in recent past. Some say, people nowadays live in a constant worldwide malady, in a disorganized global framework, which even the most cynical ones were not ready to foresee after the end of the Cold War, since the present international order is not any category of that being unipolar, bipolar and not even multipolar (Sheppard, 2012). There is still no world government - despite the fact that, a nascent worldwide administration framework is evolving gradually. The way that the US has not been able to manage the world in the same manner in which it did in the 1990s, given the rise of new powers in the global field, appears to make it exceptionally difficult to recognize present power relations. Moreover, self-contradictorily, globalization is encouraging the resurgence of patriotism. According to few scholars (Krause and Renwick, 2016), this is because the rising monetary forces seek political powers through national re-affirmation as well as Western forces, to be specific in Europe, are starting to handle the ascent of patriot, bigot and xenophobic powers because of the failure to adapt effectively to the money related emergencies. Nevertheless, the universal network faces numerous worldwide issues, for example, the ones identified with the ecology, and except if it participates to dissolve them, the disorder may turn out to be significantly more noteworthy than what has been, as of late; observed (Baylis, Smith and Owens, 2017). Considering the colossal issue which can torment the worldwide framework without genuine participation systems in the following years and decades, the present reality cannot be regarded as confused, as what follows next, could possibly be more regrettable. Ecological issues, and the ones identified with the abuse of natural assets specifically spread worldwide, both in their pith and size of activity, and subsequently, the eventual fate of mankind generally relies upon the capacity to make a powerful mechanism for multilateral administration. Along these lines, one can contend that the world will move towards another worldwide order or disorder dependent on ecological difficulties and on the capacity or incapacity to manage them. It hence truly pointed out that globalization is a double-edged sword of the twenty-first century. 1
In a quite interconnected world that people live in, changes in different parts of the world are progressively felt nearer to home, both specifically through the effects of worldwide ecological changes, or in a roundabout way through escalated financial repercussions. Huge numbers of the nations that are most vulnerable to environmental changes are underdeveloped or developing countries. Frequently these nations are very reliant on atmosphere, for example, most of their national incomes get generated through activities of cultivation or even angling. Their adaptation limit fluctuates, yet is frequently fairly low, specifically, because of diligent neediness. Biodiversity has kept on declining comprehensively notwithstanding a couple of empowering accomplishments and expanded strategic activities. Even, the worldwide rate of species termination is heightening and is currently evaluated to be up to 1000 times the natural rate. The proof is only getting bigger that basic environment administrations are under great weight all over the world. As per one estimate, around one-fourth of the potential net essential production has been transformed by people, either through direct farming activities (53%) or through land-use instigated changes (40%) or human-actuated fires (7%) (Sheppard, 2012). Such figures ought to be treated with alert, they do give a sign of the significant effect of people on regular environments. It is the world's poor that endure the worst effects of biodiversity misfortune, as they are generally most straightforwardly dependent on the biological community administrations. Increments in neediness and disparity are probably going to additionally fuel strife and flimsiness in districts that are as of now characterized by frequent fragile administrative structures. Also, lessened genomic variety in harvests and cultivars infers future misfortunes of monetary and social advantages for countries in such serious zones as food grain generation and modern-day medicinal services. Worldwide extraction of natural assets from biological systems and mines developed pretty much consistently in the course of recent years, from 40 billion tons in 1980 to 58 billion tons in 2005. Asset extraction is unevenly dispersed over the world, with Asia representing the biggest portion as of in 2005 (48% of aggregate tonnage, contrasted with Europe's 13%) (Mochizuki and Ollapally, 2016). During this period, a comparative decoupling of worldwide asset extraction and financial development occurred: asset extraction expanded by approximately half and world monetary output (GDP) by around 110% (Sheppard, 2012).
2
Asset utilization and extraction areas of yet, expanding in supreme terms, exceeding increases in asset productivity. Such a composite marker does not, in any case, uncover data on any particular asset advancements. Worldwide sustenance, vitality and water frameworks have all the earmarks of being more powerless and delicate than thought a couple of years back, the variables responsible being expanded demands, diminished supply, and supply insecurities. Over-abuse, debasement and loss of soils are pertinent worries in this matter. 1.2 Theorical framework and IR relevance
The development of new international players, the developing reliance and associations on a worldwide scale, the disintegration of the customary division among national and universal levels and the coming of a worldwide administration framework have driven the order of International Relations to a mounting spotlight on globalization. This is since, relations among sovereign states are presently lacking to investigate and comprehend the political, monetary and social elements of the present world (Krause and Renwick, 2016). Today there is a rising relationship among states, which cannot be viewed as free, self-ruling and impermeable substances, just like balls in the game of billiards stirring in a table, knocking against one another just as a Westphalian trademark (Cropper et al., 2008). Instead, as an associated and interconnected character in the universal framework, compelled to cooperate based on aggregate endeavours and energies, something represented by the web model of world governmental issues. The immense helplessness of national economies to procedures that occur on the planet, the huge utilization of advanced innovations that enable people to convey utilizing uncontrolled means by governments, and the way that the most conspicuous issues on the planet, as the ecological ones, are naturally transnational, reveal to us that the Westphalian rationale of the worldwide framework is progressively flawed (Sheppard, 2012).One such bond that connects nations on a common platform is the communal accountability to conserve the nature and hence Green theory in International Relations is relevant in today’s state of manners on a global level. It is currently relatively required to incorporate the ecology in any rundown of present-day IR related worries, as consequently, in some time it has turned out to be important to incorporate peace, underdevelopment, sexual orientation, and race, as they properly ended up perceived as noteworthy parts of the field (Baylis, Smith 3 and Owens, 2017). What is noteworthy in every single such expansion is not only the oddity of the topic yet the way that it was by one means or another, left out of the past study fields. Ignorance is one conceivable clarification, if not a decent reason, but rather an - all the more fascinating hypothetical clarification would point to the fundamental classifications of the field that delimit what is incorporated, and prohibited, from the field of study. This might be affected to some extent by the authoritative structures of sociology, for example, scholarly divisions, publication choices, and research financing. Responsibilities to specific methods of thought and the endorsing of specific methods of research and grant are, obviously, ordinary, and maybe thought important to the systematic advancement of learning in any field. By and by, such responsibilities are frequently subject to trenchant evaluation, and innovative innovation. How much advancement is attractive at any crossroads in the improvement of organized information is itself a matter of some contention, thus it is that such political ideas as "preservationist" and "moderate," "radical" and "progressive" are likewise sent to portray scholarly patterns in the field (Krause and Renwick, 2016). The environment, as a generally novel topic, has normally conveyed some critique and advancement to the field. In any case, studies related to the environment are likewise subject to such descriptors as "standard" and "radical" in discussions about how best to handle the subject. As is frequently the situation, the discussions are most honed among those with the best enthusiasm for the subject. This has maybe permitted the more extensive ramifications of this specific subject for IR to be left aside as particular natural issues are tended to in detail. Additionally, the wide field of IR has possessed the capacity to continue on a course outlined by reference to the more natural milestones of a pluralist accord (Carley and Christie, 2017). 1.3 Research Aim
Through this study, I intend to explore the relevance of green theory in creating environmental policies. The scholar chose to study this in the context of China. China has specifically been selected owing to some exemplary success it has shown in terms of environmental laws in their nation and has turned the table of how the world sees them. Not as much as a culprit for adding to environmental woes, rather; as a nation who have made amends to their ways and given results when it comes to environmental protection. 4
1.4 Research Objectives
Economic progress comes at a cost, unfortunately, the cost in question here is the environment itself. The study aims to explore and examine the following through the research: a. How relevant is Green theory in today’s times in creation of environmental policies? b. If the green theory is at all relevant, how come there is still a looming challenge of environmental conservation facing people? c. How is China managing this challenge and where does green theory figure in all this?
1.5 Research Questions
• Is green theory an important facet to consider when making environmental policies? • How relevant is Green theory in China’s environmental policymaking process? • The success of China’s environmental governance is not just dependent on adherence to green norms, what may be the other factors that could make it a success?
1.6 Research Rationale
Ecological assertions and traditions give a rich asset of case materials for IR researchers, while universal establishments have dependably been integral to the field and are at the core of "institutionalism" as a critical IR hypothetical point of view. An expanding number of foundations have risen to address nature, making this a critical part of expanding participation around shared qualities and interests. This recommends a component of the convention, and yet the likelihood of something more. The most noteworthy of these have unpretentious yet profound ramifications for worldwide law and political practice. This research hopes to shed light on the relevance of Green Theory among other International Relations theories in present need of swift action needed to be taken collectively by different nations across the globe. It intends to showcase through the case of China, plagued by issues of pollution and other measures of environmental crisis, how using different steps and
5 intensities of environmental governance, the situation could be tackled, what are the challenges that could come up and possible solutions.
6
2. Literature Review
This section shall present the acquired knowledge by referring to the available literature. The section shall, first of all, examine the origin of green theory amid International Relations theories. This should explain the need for such a theory and what did the researchers aim for when they discussed and placed such a theory in International Relations. Thereafter, the next section shall put a focus on the relationship between climate and Green Theory. That should assist in understanding why when studying the environment or making policies on the environment, the green theory is relevant. The following section shall then examine the concept of environmental governance. This aspect of the study shall help shed light on the necessity to consider Green Theory when formulating or making amends to environmental governance. Thereafter, the gap in literature shall be analyzed and tried to be covered in this study. 2.1 International Theories and origin of Green Theory
To understand the need for green theory in context to environment conservation need, there must have been certain incidents which triggered the need for a concept or theory that gave rise to environmentalists and green advocates. This section shall assist in explaining why the green theory became a branch in International Relations in the first place and why does it still hold relevance. The first portion of the twentieth century was set apart with the landing of different concepts in International Relations (IR). This came about because of the immense state clashes, occurring within and outside nations, affecting the global political situation. During these times, the IR theories were just in their beginning stages (Thompson, 2017). This led to global politics get a different scholarly attention altogether. As a discipline by itself, it got overall acknowledgement and prevalence in the period between wars. This period is, likewise associated with the examination of wide assortments of political concepts in the research field of International Relations (Schmidt, 2016). Before 1919, there existed a lot of insurgency in International Relations (Calvert, 2016) with the period being referred to as a diplomatic history stage. The investigations usually were centred around the historical backdrop of strategic and political connection among countries. Until the point when the rise of Woodrow Wilson to seat in 1919 happened, there was a total absence of logical and hypothetical examination in International
7
Relations (Jackson and Sørensen, 2016). The following period between 1919-39, usually, the interwar period; was not without controversies surrounding the concepts of Idealism and Realism in the field of International Relations (Calvert, 2016). When it came to the comprehension of global behaviour, both Idealism and Realism displayed stark differences in their opinions, which were quite confronting. Idealism favoured legitimate and pacific solving of universal disagreements (Schmidt, 2016). They appended most noteworthy need for peace, security and collaboration. On the other hand, the Realist contended of a consistent Hobbesian rebellion in International Relations (Schmidt, 2016). According to them, it could be controlled through power administration instrument, for instance, parity of power, mediation, aggregate safety efforts and treaty organizations. Nevertheless, both the concepts subjugated the interwar political situation and stayed fruitful in systematizing International Relations. In this manner, both the hypotheses have sinuous scholarly and behavioral impediments which finally came to an end near the wake of Second World War in 1939. This was when, there were a rise in behaviouralism and scientific theory building practices giving rise to an absolutely new order in the field of International Relations (Jackson and Sørensen, 2016). The 1960s denoted the start of extensive public apprehensions around environmental dilapidation in the developed nations of the West. Be that as it may, it took almost nearly ten years of tenacious political disturbance over such issues as pesticides, atomic power plants, dangerous waste dumps, huge scale modern expansions, and environmental contamination before environmental emergency was formally perceived as an issue of local, domestic and universal stature (Brooks and Jones, 2017). The very first Earth day festivities in 1970, the rise of array of new ecological laws in Western nations towards the end of 1960s and beginning of 1970s, the advancement of interdisciplinary environmental examinations programs in advanced education institutions, and the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment in Stockholm in 1972, all spoke of critical milestones of national and worldwide recognition of ecological concerns (Brooks and Jones, 2017). Natural issues have never held focal concerns in the field of IR. Rather, they have customarily centred around inquiries of high-level governmental issues, for instance, safety and interstate clash. Nevertheless, the heightening in transboundary ecological issues from the 1970s onwards observed the development of a sub-field of IR (Dupuy and Viñuales, 2018).
8
This sub-field worried about worldwide natural collaboration, which concentrated basically on the supervision of common natural assets, for example, river systems, the seas, and the climate. This notion to protect the environment has only been developing broadly since the expanding worldwide monetary and biological reliance and the rise of exceptional worldwide environmental issues, for instance, environmental changes, diminishing of the ozone layer, and the disintegration of the world's natural biodiversity (Dupuy and Viñuales, 2018). The perplexing issue of global warming gives a particularly unique representation of assorted manners by which genuine ecological issues are interfaced with each other through various hypothetical viewpoints in the field of IR. In the principle IR hypothesis, realists normally expel the issue of nature as an outlying concern in the context of worldwide governmental issues. This is except if the results of the issue itself can be connected straightforwardly for the debilitation of the national security of the concerned nation (Schmidt, 2016). On the other hand, the neoliberals, interestingly, offer counsel on the most proficient methods to change inducement structures in taking care of the worldwide ecological issues to provoke interstate collaboration. These were interesting developments as the budding of a new IR field slowly gave rise to environmentalists who were bent on creating a unified worldwide approach to care for the environment, the challenge was how they were going to do it if not with the help of environmental governance in place in all nations. 2.2 International Relations, Environment and Green Theory – the challenges
The entry of environmental issues into the investigations of International Relations has unmistakably had an effect. It remains to be seen whether the ecological issues can be tackled by conventional means, or whether they are beyond reconciliation with current practice. On the off chance that the previous case prevails, then the ecological issues are just add-on; if the last case prevails, these issues are possibly transformational. The noteworthiness for IR pursues from such useful concerns since the hypothesis and practices are connected (Connelly et al., 2012), and as the ecology challenges the existing practices, it likewise brings up new issues that IR theories or followers needed to react to. The boundless acknowledgement of the practical test exhibited by the earth has not yet converted into a noteworthy effect on the order of IR, notwithstanding when hypothetical ramifications 9 are noted. One of the scholars (Thomas, 1992) saw that basic changes in governmental issues and financial matters requested by natural issues had not yet gotten a suitable down to earth reaction, a perception that still to a great extent remains constant as environmental change advances toward the highest point of the worldwide plan, and it appears that hypothetical improvement has likewise been to some degree constrained. In any case, an extensive literature has risen to handle an assortment of natural issues from various methodologies, which proposes a far-reaching base for reexamining the hypothetical premise of IR. Given the state-driven history of IR, it is not unusual this has been a focal component of ecological assessments. A scholar opined that the ecology raised a few anxieties about this conventional distraction with the state as a constitutive character in a universal arrangement of such actors (Liefferink, 1996). Particularly, the idea of authority has ostensibly been a focal idea of IR, since it indicates to be the key quality of state characters. Another scholar inspected the connection between authority and biology (Litfin, 1998), indicating how power could be reexamined, and commonplace political divisions and ideas problematized. Such a methodology could exhibit an impressive test to IR all alone terms. Another scholar was suggestive of moves from the state level to the worldwide level (Young, 1998), with shared anxieties crosswise over universal ecological and administrative issues, and this mirrored an administration situated (institutional) point of view on worldwide governance that drew familiarity with natural issues, this was also asserted by (Vogler, 2003). Another scholar pressed the test somewhat further, starting with two or three home realities, he mentioned that worldwide natural issues required worldwide arrangements (Elliott, 2004) and also that there were no straightforward arrangements in this case possible. This prompted some thought of how one ought to comprehend the 'worldwide' as an organizing standard, which without a doubt brings up issues about the state as an arranging guideline. The same scholar places basic first-order inquiries regarding governance and world order, and about assemblies and systems, which have turned out to be normal for ecological concerns, and in this manner proposes the way of IR's potential change (Bingham, Nabatchi and O’Leary, 2005). This literature gives a glimpse of the rising need they thought there was to combine environmental protection with power or authority, which could be centrally
10 driven in a state or maybe with a unified global arrangement. However, on a common note, all agreed that it needed to be driven by a power. Inside a pretty much conventional IR system, there are a few regions of commitment with the condition that is suggestive of the scope of issues raised and the profundity of their noteworthiness for the field. Some scholars even recognized fundamental, societal, and state-driven speculations, each adding to understanding the earth as an issue. However; each likewise recommended conceivable wellsprings of hypothetical change (Barkdull and Harris, 2002). Ecological covenants and pacts gave a rich asset of case materials for IR researchers, while worldwide organizations have dependably been integral to the field and are at the core of "institutionalism" as a noteworthy IR hypothetical point of view. An expanding number of foundations have risen to address the earth, making this a noteworthy part of expanding collaboration around shared qualities and interests. This recommends a component of custom, and yet the likelihood of something extra as well. The most amounting of these have unobtrusive yet profound ramifications for global law and political practice, for instance, the Aarhus Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision- Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters in 1998. This bolstered common society inclusion and related customary classifications, for example, sway (Birnie and Boyle, 1994). Be that as it may, another scholar takes note of IR's inability to perceive the mind-boggling association between natural debasement and its social inceptions and an "externalization" of the earth because of focusing on institutional improvements (Kutting, 2000). In this manner, she noticed an inability to satisfactorily address ecological strategy organizing. Along these lines, while the earth has brought expanded worldwide collaboration, IR hypothesis has not yet completely disguised an environmental point of view. In this manner, the distractions of IR tend to confine the anxieties to an objective viewpoint on the establishments, as opposed to the earth—the end product is that an emphasis on the earth would disturb such distractions. As institutional advancements go, the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development was of milestone centrality for setting another motivation for IR. The expansion carried some hypothetically unbalanced issues alongside it. For instance, in concentrating on developing nations, a scholar pointed (Desai, 1998) out that it fortified worry with abundant factors as populace, culture, religion, and morals, which were
11 discussed by few others (Maguire and Rasmussen, 1998; Gardiner, 2011). The significance of such factors is uplifted instead of lessened by the distributional issues brought up in transactions around environmental change (Eckersley, 2012), and their institutional indication in the Kyoto procedure and its potential successor administration, and henceforth the prospects for fruitful multilateral arrangements rather than one-sided national responsibilities and nearby activity (Dyer, 2014). These scholars pointed out that there was a need for a global arrangement to make environmental conservation a fruitful reality, they also pointed out the inability of any IR theory such as green theory itself in estimating with accuracy the rightful approach to solving the issues of ecological crisis. These are issues that can be tended to by sociologies (Carlsnaes et al., 2002) at the same time, in a less well-known kind of expansion to its worries, the standardization of characteristic science at the universal level has come to shoulder on IR (Litfin, 1998). As this has been driven to some extent by the requirement to decrease vulnerability, for political reasons among others, risk has entered the discussions through Beck's work on risk society and, specifically, his later work on natural governmental issues. The complexities are all around outlined by works of some scholars like (Schaeffer and Dickinson, 2003) and the hypothetical ramifications by critical works of some scholars (Jameson and Miyoshi, 1998), including cumbersome new issues, for example, climactic justice (Guerrero, 2011). There has been a huge basic commitment to security, or, in other words of its centrality to conventional state-driven IR with disciplinary starting points in the issues of war and peace. Ecological security has been a piece of this commitment (Rønnfeldt, 1997), however at times reluctantly so given the relationship with state-driven worries of politico-military security. A precedent including potential clashes is given by (Barnett, 2003), while the body of evidence against connecting natural issues to national security is made by (Dabelko and Dabelko, 1995). Normally, if natural issues, for example, water deficiencies can prompt savagery and, specifically, prearranged brutality, the earth would then be able to join the customary worldwide security plan. In the meantime, it is possibly challenging to the ritual by the virtue of reclassifying or weakening settled ideas of security, regardless of whether an elective thought of natural security has a widespread interest (Dyer, 2014). For a few, the earth is a contributing component (Renner and Patterson,
12
1997), while for other people, it is both major and transformational (Dabelko and Dabelko, 1995). Without a doubt, it is in such talks of IR that the possibilities of change are to be found in the midst of the connections of theories to practice. While it is that the practical interests have controlled the customary IR hypothesis, the inclusion of the earth requires deeper hypothetical guidance. The earth has repercussions both through its effect on interests and through its hypothetical commitments—thus an expansive front on which to conceivably subvert the convention. Since regulations are characterized by their hypothetical discussions as much as by their topic (the last being characterized by the previous), it is here that changes are tracked closely. For IR, the conditional idea of its establishing hypothesis (regularly just unrelated to the universal) has prompted acquiring from the "parent" field—in other words, political hypothesis. This, thus, made another opening for the environment in IR, by utilizing applicable developments in the political idea (Hay, 2002). Up until this point, IR may have demonstrated some worry with the change of political network (Linklater, 1998), yet the change of the human – environment relationship would be widely inclusive. So, it is that the conventional apprehensions of IR with war and peace, struggle and participation, and different other challenges encircled by the structure of interstate relations could be made repetitive by the hypothetical test of ecological issues. Such a change would rise through hypothetical improvements constrained by the substances of natural change, and consequent endeavours to consider them plainly and maybe along these lines environmentally. 2.3 Environmental Governance
The word governance is, nowadays, frequently utilized. The verbal meaning of the term governance means the activities or behavior of an organization, its administrative practices and frameworks of control (Durant, 2017). The Commission on Global Governance founded a standard meaning of global governance when it expressed that it is the whole of numerous ways people and organizations, public and private, deal with their regular issues. It is a proceeding within process through which conflicting or various interests might be suited and the co-cooperative move is made. It incorporates formal foundations and administrations enabled to uphold consistency, and in addition, casual plans that individuals and establishments either have consented to or see to be to their greatest advantage. The concept of 13 governance centres around acts and activities completed by recognized organizations, while the importance of 'government' centres around the instrument of policy-making and on frameworks of political theory, and one needs to give careful consideration to the point that governance entrusts action from public authorities (Biermann, 2017). It is important to affirm that legislatures as established bodies have the ability to make an authoritative move. Today, different administrations and structures of worldwide administration that were not seen amid the time of the Cold War have, as of late risen, both in the field of financial aspects and as to nature and universal security frameworks (Biermann, 2017). Based on the idea of global governance, a related idea known as environmental governance has come to be utilized frequently when talking about ecological issues. The purposes behind this are that, the expanding cooperation of actors and operators other than the country state and the outcomes of this are the inexorably wide assortment of actors taking an interest and an enhancement of economical devices with more noteworthy revelation of data, and a fortifying of deliberate activities other than by direct control as an instrument of policy. At the end of the day, people are starting to see a more adaptable, decentralized and helpful environmental regulative order (Durant, 2017). Ecological governance basically implies a structure that empowers society to deal with nature, similarly as a conductor brings together and modifies the general execution of a symphony. It is in this way, it is valuable to put the hypothesis of "governance" inside the field of environmental economics as it scans for an investigation that will give a solid policy arrangement to the atmosphere perceptive conservation society. Environmental governance is acknowledged when an assortment of actors utilize different instruments to work effectively through interrelationships and exchange to design and work an administration dependent on the point of preserving the earth when the concerns that influence the ecology are spreading into additional regions (Durant, 2017). As can be understood there are differing views related to IR theories and their incapability in solving the ecological crisis at hand. IR theories might as well just be a concept and do not offer proper guidance to tackle the situation. This makes it even more challenging to set parameters for global obedience or forming a case to get an agreement from nations, to join hands on a common platform for a common cause. This makes this study quite
14 challenging in terms of driving a definite conclusion related to the efficacy of green theory in green policymaking. 2.4 Environmental Policy Implementation Challenges in China
Despite the rise in economic strength and a firm position on the world political map, the country still struggles as environmental conditions in China has been quite serious. The damage is not only on the health of people, but it is also adding to social harm over a long period of time directly and indirectly (Khan and Chang, 2018). However, in the last 20 years, China has emerged and transformed itself into a strong implementer when it came to environmental policies for damage control. Extensive policies at national levels have been implemented such as the environmental protection Law of 2015, The Environmental Protection Tax Law of 2017 and so on (LI, 2006). The main challenge for China was the water resource. Agricultural activities reigned, however; almost 60-70% of groundwater resources were either poor or very poor (Khan and Chang, 2018). A quarter of their rivers were unsuitable for human contact. This was all due to improper waste disposal practices which went uncontrolled. This even led to prosperous lands becoming barren. Deforestation also added to the issue of land erosion affecting more than 400 million people. Then is the air contamination issue which is similar to Europe in the 1960s. It remains as the lowest per capita energy consumption, however, owing to the huge population base, it consumes the most energy on the planet. Most of the studies conducted, however large in numbers all faced a challenge as CO2 emissions are never publicly published (Chunmei and Zhaolan, 2010). The last one just belonging to one of three ever published, that in 2012. The researchers hence tried to resolve the issue by taking logical assumption steps and the previously available information from different varied sources (Khan and Chang, 2018). Even publication of certain perspectives of environmental studies is largely prohibited keeping in mind the sensitivities and State’s interests. The regulatory system of China is perceived as an indistinguishable and wide-ranging rule. Most of the environmental regulations’ implementations have been questionable and dubious, even weak.This shows that there could be more to environmental policymaking than green theory in China which may be posing as a barrier for implementation or even giving them improved results year or year.
15
2.5 Literature Gap
The reviewed literature presented a lot of information related to green theory, its place and importance in the current world political arena. However, it was difficult to find substantial study connecting environmental governance and green theory. The criticisms and critical analysis of green theory in IR did not reveal much in terms of current global scenarios. The literature consulted on Green theory has only pointed out so far that green theory is ineffective in the process of making environmental governance policies, however; there is still that could be done here. It must be treated as a guide to understanding the environmental policies nations are making, especially China to tackle the environmental challenges. All the more, about China, most of the information seemed quite restricted to air pollution and did not capture the entirety of the problem in China. It seems that this study might hence be helpful to scholars who want to understand how green theory affects environmental policymaking. It will produce the related information to understand the limitations and the challenges faced by nations in trying to mould their environmental policies as per prevalent green theories. Also, this would be probably the newest of the studies that would showcase the environmental policymaking in China in tandem with green theories.
16
3. Research Methodology
Research outline and strategy are viewed as an indispensable part for the task improvement as it includes the phases of the examination that will be valuable in gathering the information in like manner (Wiersema and Bowen, 2009). In this chapter, I would be discussing the various research methods and style for the data collection that will help for the data gathering. I will be explaining the various philosophies, approach and design to state the purpose of the research and provide information on the data collection method. Through this research, I intend to increase the awareness related to outcomes in environmental governance with changes in policies in line with green sustainable policy choices.
3.1 Method Outline
The research has been centred essentially around three research questions, which shall be dealt with in the next section of the study. Since the study aims to explore, analyses, examine and come to a definite answer related to its research questions, the approach selected is the in-depth case study of China. Specifically, to drive appoint, I have chosen to tread the following path step by step to reach a conclusion, as per applicability • Research Onion • Research Philosophy • Research Approach • Research Design • Data Collection • Sampling
I believe that with the help of this format and proper elaboration and understanding, I shall be able to fetch the required information accordingly for the benefit of the study. Also, by following the above steps, the research can find appropriate data for analysis. 3.2 Case Selection
The procedural tactic selected for this proposition is an in-depth case study – with a focus on the choice of green governance choices in China.
17
Case studies deliver examinations which might demonstrate a robust confirmation or a dispute for philosophies and premises (Ledford and Gast, 2018). Maximum findings steered from the actor viewpoint picked the usage of the case study technique (Crespy and Miller, 2011; Kopnina, 2016) as their intention was to thoroughly scrutinize a maintainable situation, yet; guided divergent research questions. According to some scholars (Halperin and Heath, 2016), directing a single case has the gain that it can be inspected expansively which is exactly what is required for this study. The case study is directed spending the elementary ideologies of the qualitative content analysis standards. It is apt for this examination as it qualifies a broad view of the subject due to the orderly way of considering textual information. The enquiry compels inspecting a sizeable number of documents apropos to Chinese environmental governance as well as Green IR theories and hence, the indicated method is applicable for the reasons of this thesis. Content analysis methodology is a non-invasive way to collect and analyze data and thus, the methodology will not be disrupting the case in action as data gathering is done in a nonobtrusive way. The core benefit of the content analysis method is that it restrains favouritism. Case studies permit a proportion of aspects to be composed that would not generally be straightforwardly attained by other investigation designs. The data collected is generally a lot lusher and of better depth than can be unearthed over other investigational ventures. Also, case studies incline to be piloted in rare cases where huge samples of alike contributors are not obtainable (Hays, 2004). One of the first objections is that the information accumulated cannot unavoidably be extended across the board to the more extensive populace. This central to information being created over longitudinal case analyses not constantly being relevant or overwhelmingly helpful. Roughly, case analyses are not thorough in terms of methods (Hays, 2004). It is additionally extremely endeavouring to draw a settled reason/impact from contextual analyses. 3.3 Research Philosophy
Research theory is crucial for the choice of the exploration procedure as it helps in understanding the idea of the examination as needs be (Lewis, 2015). For the vast majority of the examination that could be thought about, it is trusted that the theory controls the exploration appropriately. The
18 philosophies are either positivism, interpretivism or realism. These stages are most effective for the research. Positivism is assembled from the encounters and realities, which manages the actualities and information, which are accepted to be certain in nature. These are done through coherent, sane and numerical treatment, which helps the specialist in increasing proper data (Ellis and Levy, 2009). For this study, since a secondary research analysis has been selected. Most of the interpretations have already been carried out by scholars. Interpretivism and realism help the researcher in making the appropriate connection to the philosophy and believes that it helps in identifying the cause of the research more transparently. This is what I intend to do for connecting the studies conducted to this exploration. 3.4 Research Approach
The research approach is the stage, which aids the scholar in determining the research study further by understanding the different approach for the study. The approach will assist in shaping up the section consequently for data collection study. The research approach is divided on to 2 groups, mainly deductive or inductive. Deductive Approach is the methodology, which helps the scientist in making sensible prevailing upon profitable focuses and certainties, which are not powerless because of the nearness of the constant information and data. It has a few layers, which can help the analyst in making the examination more gainful and compelling (Freshwater, 2007). Inductive Approach can be clarified where the methodology expresses that it is inverse of the deductive methodology and utilization an appropriate clarification for the investigation, it is isolated into the phases of the recommendation and assumption that helps the analyst in making the means carefully for use. The specialist trusts that with the assistance of the deductive methodology, the scientist will have the capacity to give the data all the more successful as it utilizes a few layers, which are viewed as genuine in nature, and has proper data for the investigation (Harrison and Reilly, 2011). The Deductive methodology will help the analyst in making the appropriate introduction of the investigation.
19
3.5 Research Design
The researcher believes that with the use of the proper research design, the researcher will be able to point out the effective research data collection for the collection of the data and believes that with the help of the information gathered from the research, the researcher will be able to portray the data respectively. The research design is divided into 3 parts, which are, exploratory, explanatory or descriptive. Exploratory is where the analyst trusts that the data be gotten with the assistance of the sources and the best possible system, which will empower the grip of the investigation to be solid. Logical is the stage, which will bargain in the phases of the clarifications that be demonstrated useful for the investigation appropriately. Expressive research configuration will help the analyst in making information even more successful as it will include a constant information accumulation for the exploration and in this way the data will be totally crisp for the investigation (Cropper et al., 2008). I firmly believe that the utilization of the descriptive methodology of the examination will help me in making a legitimate exhibition of the investigation. 3.6 Data collection process
The purpose of the research is to collect data, which will help in providing the needed information for the study. The purpose of the research is to examine and explore the effect of green theory in environmental policymaking in the case of China. As explained in the previous section, the content analysis paradigm comprises of examining the obtainable data from a peripheral point of view. The first step of this research is to analyze the available documents relevant to all the three research questions. For this purpose, certain keywords were put in when searching for data such as ‘environmental governance’, ‘environmental policies in China’, ‘trends in Chinese environmental policies’, ‘effects of Chinese environmental policies’ were used to pick up relevant data. The data was mostly limited to the last 10 years, though efforts have been made to use the most recent research study on this only. As specified earlier a qualitative content analysis of such documents was conducted.
20
4. Analaysis and Data Findings
This section of the dissertation shall present the findings of the three research questions of this study. 4.1 Is green theory an important facet to consider when making environmental policies?
The Green Theory of IR is a sub-branch of International Relations discipline which contributes to an understanding of global politics in a combination of environmental issues. They study global politics by keeping the environment in its focus. It demands a political transformative approach towards conservation of ecology and suggests ecological modernization and collective solution designs. Environmental approach is any measure taken by an administration or partnership or some other public or private association with respect to the impacts of human exercises on the environment. The strategies are especially around those measures that are intended to anticipate or diminish the destructive impacts of human exercises on biological systems (Barnett, 2003). Green IR theory also demonstrates the same intentions of safeguarding the ecological preserves and not let it be ruined owing to uncontrolled economic activities conducted by mankind. Environmental strategies are required in light of the fact that ecological interests are generally not considered in the hierarchical priority list of any basic leadership. There are two primary explanations behind that exclusion. To begin with, ecological impacts are monetary externalities. Polluters do not bear the outcomes of their activities; the negative impacts happen somewhere else or later on (Hay, 2002). Second, natural assets are underpriced on the grounds that they are frequently expected to have unbounded accessibility. The pool of natural assets can be considered as a house that everybody can use to their own advantage (Jameson and Miyoshi, 1998). For an individual, it is discerning to utilize a typical asset without thinking about its confinements, however, that self-intrigued conduct will prompt the consumption of the common restricted asset—and that is not to anybody's greatest advantage. People do as such all things considered on the grounds that they receive the rewards for the time being, yet the chain pays the expenses of exhaustion in the longer time period. 21
Owing to the influence of Green IR theories and attempts, protests by various environmentalists, over the years, an assortment of standards have been formulated to help approach manufacturers. Precedents of such managing standards, some of which have procured a lawful premise in a few nations, are the polluter pays rule, which makes polluters at risk for the expenses of natural harm, and the prudent guideline, which expresses that an action is not permitted when quite possibly the outcomes are irreversible. Such direct managing standards do not, however; work in all circumstances (Cheng, 2011). For instance, some ecological difficulties, for example, a worldwide temperature alteration, light up the need to see Earth as a biological community comprising of different subsystems, which, once disturbed, can prompt fast changes that are outside human ability to control. Motivating polluters to pay or the sudden selection of the preparatory rule by all nations would not really move back the harm as of now, however, it would prevent future harm from happening. This is in line with what was promoted widely by the green theory lobbyists. They clearly wanted emphasis on the protection of natural resources. Alongside, also various policies put in place to incentivize market-based initiatives on the environmental protection front, different policies for encouraging improvement in the adaptive front as well as policies seeking a determination of internal and external costs all in line with the environmental economical approach (Jameson and Miyoshi, 1998). Since the mid-1970s, varied approaches have been made for avoidance and control of the issue. Such arrangements depended on the relief of negative impacts. Furthermore, if a negative impact was unavoidable, it could be made up for by putting resources into nature in different spots than where the harm was caused, for instance. A third arrangement, which created strategies that focus on adjusting the living conditions to change, is additionally conceivable. All the more particularly, measures that fortify a biological system's natural flexibility (i.e., an environment's capacity to keep up its ordinary process of supplement cycling and biomass creation), joined with measures that accentuate aversion and relief, have been utilized. One such precedent is in Curitiba, Brazil, a city where a few regions surge every year. The occupants of surge inclined regions were migrated to higher and dryer places, and their previous living regions were changed into parks that could be done without disturbing city life. From the mid-1970s, the United Nations (UN) has given the primary focus to worldwide arrangements and concurrences on natural
22 approaches and destinations. The 1972 Stockholm gathering was the primary worldwide meeting on ecological issues and was trailed by the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) summits in Rio de Janeiro in 1992 and in Johannesburg in 2002 (Cheng, 2011). The UN likewise facilitated largescale gatherings on environmental change, for example, those of 1996 in Kyoto and 2009 in Copenhagen. Those meetings and summits reacted to the worldwide character of probably the most difficult natural issues, which would require universal participation to fathom. Those meetings were viable in setting a universal motivation for provincial and national ecological approach making that brought about arrangements and conventions, otherwise called the hard law, and in nonbinding goals, articulations, and statements, or "delicate law." Whereas the 1992 Rio gathering understanding was a delicate law, the Kyoto Protocol was a hard law, with obvious focuses on lessening ozone-harming substance discharges for locales and nations (Barnett, 2003). Country states, in their endeavours to meet the objectives, could make utilization of three supposed adaptability components intended to bring down the expenses of consistency. Joint execution enabled nations to put resources into bringing down discharges in different nations that had confirmed the Kyoto Protocol and, in this manner, had a decreased focus to meet. For industrialized, developed nations, that had just put resources into outflow; decreases in their own economies, it was less expensive to put resources into emanation decreases in different nations with economies experiencing significant change, where a similar venture would prompt more prominent decreases. At the end of the day, the contributing nation might get acknowledgement for serving a nation experiencing a significant change to bring down its outflows. Uncontaminated improvement, the additional system, permitted developed nations that have sanctioned the convention to meet their objectives in any nation where it is least expensive to contribute (Linklater, 1998)—that is, in developing nations—regardless of whether that nation did not approve the convention. This is not undisputed. Solely because it included inquiries of intercession in the economies of developing nations, vulnerable to get affected by the monetary advancement of those nations. To keep industrialized nations from not diminishing their very own emanations, the system must be utilized in enhancement to household decreases, yet no meaning of such supplemental activity was given, which drove a few nations
23 to accomplish 50 per cent of their decrease focus through that component. The third component, carbon-emanation exchanging, is a market-based instrument and could be connected as willful markets or in a required system. An expert puts a cap on the general carbon discharges permitted in a nation or locale. Inside that limit, outflow rights are allotted to the polluters, and discharges created past those rights are punished. The thought is that polluters pick between putting resources into emanation decreases or discharge grants (Tang, 2015). By bringing down the cap after some time, add up to discharge decrease can be accomplished. The exchange of licenses will guarantee that outflows decrease is accomplished at the most reduced expenses. Developing nations are the way to accomplishing worldwide green development in two significant ways. Initially, the potential monetary and social effects of ecological debasement are especially vital for developing nations. They are the most defenceless against environmental change and tend to be more reliant than cutting-edge economies on the misuse of natural assets for monetary development. Besides, many developing nations confront serious monetary, social and environmental dangers from energy, sustenance and water shortage to environmental change and outrageous climate dangers. They additionally confront dangers from unexpected losses because of contamination, poor water quality and sicknesses related to an evolving atmosphere. These elements undermine their advancement. Furthermore, today most developing nations contribute just minorly to worldwide ozone-harming substance (GHG) outflows contrasted with the OECD and major rising economies, they will increment their emanations on the off chance that they pursue regular economic exercises. Progressively developing nations are getting to be wellsprings of worldwide financial development, emanations and, with these, more concentrated utilization of natural assets. With the end goal to handle huge numbers of the development and advancement challenges made reference to above without trading off future development and poverty decreasing objectives, the idea of green development has risen as another way to deal with reframing the conventional development models and to re-survey a significant number of the venture choices in meeting vitality, horticulture, water needs and the asset requirements for monetary development. Coming to the research question, if the green theory is vital to the formulation of environmental policies, the answer is undecided. This is
24 largely owing to the fact that there is no single standard being followed worldwide when it came to environmental protection. There is no global benchmark, even hard laws like Kyoto protocols are not being followed by all nations on the same requirements, there are still some few nations that are not bound by it. At the end of the day, every nation needs to create environmental policies based on their needs to be successful on this front.
4.2 How relevant is Green theory in China’s environmental policymaking process?
Sustainable advancement was the primary response to, and battle against, the gigantic emergency in the natural habitat in the second portion of the twentieth century (Carley and Christie, 2017). Very quickly, a worldwide agreement formed for sustained development actions. The United Nations Human Environment Conference held in Stockholm, Sweden, first of its kind, accepted the Declaration on Human Environment (Lauven et al., 2016). Ever since environmental concerns have found its place in international pacts. Mankind started to understand the connection between the earth and advancement, environmentalists and green theory activists led to the awareness, all actors eventually agreed to cooperate with each other to tackle the issue of the environmental crisis at hand. The idea of sustainable advancement was foremost suggested in the United Nations General Assembly in 1980 (Lauven et al., 2016). Basically, sustainable advancement is a reaction to the human biological-ecological difficulties made by a present-day society which is heavily industrialized. Worldwide, social and political accord quickly conformed to this idea. It held up capitalist generation to worldwide examination and made a restricted modification of the conventional improvement route. In any case, sustainable advancement speaks of an inactive, oblivious adjustment of free advancement (Rosenbaum, 2016). It likewise clarifies that since the industrial transformation, present-day improvement, with consumerism as the main impetus, has been described by intemperate assets and energy utilization, pollution emanations, and environmental harm; after the event has happened, sustainable advancement attempts to repair the situation (Carley and Christie, 2017). Under strain from the extending environmental emergency, western nations have, as a result, exchanged asset utilization, contamination discharges, and ozone-harming substance outflows to southern nations through financial globalization, exchange of modern industrial products, and 25 commerce (Johnson, 2009). Over the course of recent decades, proof has demonstrated that endeavours to change advancement to make it more manageable have not flourished, in fact; the situation turned out to be more unsustainable, unfortunately. With the conspicuous issue of environmental change, humankind has been made vulnerable to an uncommon natural emergency. As a developing nation, China is a latecomer in worldwide ecological governance and for an extensive stretch, was keeping hesitant to make any dedication towards the cause. In 1972, China did not consent to the last arrangement at the UN Conference on the Human Environment; at the UN Conference on Environment and Development in 2009, the then Chinese chief clergyman underlined financial improvement and national power as the nation's fundamental concern. All the more, recently, it counteracted with India and Brazil a worldwide pact of environmental change in 2009 (Dimitrov, 2010). As needs are, a few researchers even remarked that China is to a great degree incredulous towards remotely authorized measures that would undermine the potential for social and monetary advancement for environmental change (Lemos et al., 2016). In any case, China's natural strategy appears to change quickly in the course of the most recent couple of years – with its yearning activities and plans at the local level, China is progressively dynamic in worldwide ecological administration. Fighting environmental change appears the most noticeable segment of China's new ecological approach. Beginning from its eleventh Five-Year-Plan (FYP) set in 2005, the Chinese government saves no efforts to diminish national energy intensity and develop an arrangement of key low-carbon ventures (Lewis, 2014). In particular, since 2007; the state has closed down a large number of wasteful power and mechanical offices with the goal that its energy utilization per unit of GDP keeps on diminishing in the course of the most recent decade – 19.1% from 2005 to 2010 and 18.2% from 2010 to 2015, and an objective of a further 15% abatement by 2020 has been set in its thirteenth FYP. Even more, imperatively, in view of a solid approach for energy changes including the Renewable Energy Law propelled in 2006 and enormous state-drove venture, the extent of non-petroleum derivatives in China's vitality blend has come to 12% by 2015 and the carbon discharges per unit of GDP has been diminished by 20% somewhere in the range of 2010 and 2015. What's more, China has additionally started residential carbon exchanging to battle environmental change. China has begun seven
26 pilot markets at the city or local level in 2014 and the objective is to make a national cap-and-trade framework full in task somewhere in the range of 2017 and 2020 (Dong et al., 2016). Such advancement enables China to make goal-oriented promises in the worldwide field. In its intended nationally determined contribution submitted to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change in June 2015, China advances a few concrete and testing objectives of its atmosphere activities by 2030, including: cresting its CO2 emanations around 2030 and endeavor to cap early; bringing down CO2 outflows per unit of GDP by 60% to 65% from the 2005 level; expanding the offer of non-petroleum products in essential vitality utilization to around 20%; and expanding the woods stock volume by around 4.5 billion cubic meters on the 2005 level. Since 2014, China started to assume a key job in encouraging the conclusion of the Paris agreement by achieving a Joint Announcement on Climate Change with the US where China, out of the blue; show an objective on emanations crest. In September 2015, the Chinese and American pioneers put forth a Joint Presidential Expression on Climate Change to facilitate their situation for the Paris gathering. Amid the arrangements in last December, China is never again an obstructive player, but instead required a solid lawfully restricting character for general commitment (Dimitrov, 2016). At last, only half a month prior, China sanctioned the Paris Agreement together with the US and the two nations additionally reported their arrangement to address another imperative ozone-depleting substance – Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) – in a change of the Montreal Protocol and their sponsorship for activity on aeronautics emanations under the International Civil Aviation Organization (Hermwille, 2016). In June of 1992, the Heads of State Summit, then attended by the pioneers of 178 nations was held by the United Nations in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. China's Premier Li Peng went to the gathering and endorsed the Environment and Development Declaration in the interest of the Chinese government (Day, 2016). The same year in July, driven by the State Planning Commission and the National Science and Technology Commission, 52 offices, establishments, and social gatherings arranged China's Agenda 21—White Paper on China's Population, Environment, and Development in the Twenty-First Century or The Agenda (Tietenberg and Lewis, 2016). China's Agenda 21, otherwise called the White Paper on China's Population, Environment, and Development in the Twenty-First
27
Century, is a wholesome tactical plan and program measure that proposes advancement of commonly planned and reasonable improvement of the economy, society, assets, nature, the populace, and edification. It is a document made for guidance and also represents a long haul plan for China's national monetary and social advancement. Long-term objectives (2010– ) (Lauven et al., 2016) include: reestablish and enhance the administrative limit of China's economic– social– biological framework. Also, keep China's monetary and social improvement functioning inside the limit of the ecology and assets. It also aims to locate a productive, amicable, and present-day way of practical advancement suited to China's national conditions; as well as, make proper commitments to the worldwide sustainable improvement process. Significant projects belonging to China's Agenda 21 addressed insurance of assets and the ecology; worldwide natural issues; populace control and socially supportable advancement; practical improvement capacity building; and feasible improvement of industrial traffic, agribusiness, and energy creation and utilization (Yi and Liu, 2015). On March 25, 1994, the sixteenth Executive Meeting of the State Council examined and endorsed The Agenda. They also planned China's priority projects to advance The Agenda. In 1995, China accepted sustainable advancement as a noteworthy national strategy and the nation was called upon to effectively take an interest in this extraordinary undertaking. Jiang Zemin likewise underscored that, as a nation, they should successfully secure assets and their environment (Rosenbaum, 2016). They should sort out current expansions, as well as make plans for future ages. They should not take the route of squandering assets or be advocates in action of - contaminate first, treat later. In China's operation of sustainable advancement, the nation ought not just to completely ingest the idea of sustainable advancement from a worldwide point of view, rather additionally, it needed to completely reflect variables particular to China (Heggelund, 2017). Slowly, China started to feature their innovation practically. They particularly set forward a manual for the foundation of supportable consumption outlines quite quickly for the first time. This addressed the basic restrictions of capitalistic advancement, showing that China's sustainable improvement actions had progressed in small steps past the western idea of sustainable improvements. Meanwhile, from 2003, the Communist Party of China or the CPC Central Committee has pursued the logical standpoint of advancement in which the archetypes of symphonic
28 improvement of humankind and nature framed the premise of creation and utilization patterns advantageous to asset preservation and contamination decrease (Day, 2016; Lauven et al., 2016). Their aim had been to create an asset saving, environment securing society to additionally develop comprehension of the connection between mankind and nature. With the end goal to design social and monetary advancement and also, deciding the administrations’ operational targets, the Chinese government declared like clockwork China's Five-Year-Plan (FYP) since 1976. The FYP was not a law, however, it had the capacity to prepare a stage towards creating another approach or law (Ray et al., 2015). In the first place, the FYP concentrated on financial development however ecological targets and measures were considered in later FYP also. In the eleventh FYP from 2005 to 2010, the declaration of monetary advancement "faster and better" was rephrased to "better and fast", which seems to include the change to a more manageable reasoning of China's administration. Moreover, the Chinese government headed towards an environment-friendly society with their twelfth FYP from 2011 to 2015 (Day, 2016). The accomplishments toward the finish of the period of the twelfth FYP outflanked the objectives which were set in the FYP. This was in line with the declaration of the previous president Hu Jintao at the eighteenth National Congress in 2012. He, through his report, had asked to build a beautiful China. He even advocated environmental advancement to a more conspicuous subject for the Chinese government. From the objectives of the twelfth FYP, it was very easily be inferred that the Chinese government had raised their political consciousness of ecological insurance. Through the Energy Saving and Emissions Reduction Comprehensive Plan, China aimed to diminish its energy utilization by 16 % per 10.000 Yuan GDP from 2010 till 2015. Other targets between the twelfth FYP period dependent on total sums can be expressed as the saving of 670mt of coal proportionate, and in addition, the decrease of chemical oxygen demand (COD) from 25.517kt in 2010 to 23.476kt in 2015. Additionally, the sulfur dioxide or SO2 outflows should diminish by 8 % and nitrogen oxides (NOx) emanations by 10 % (Rosenbaum, 2016; Tietenberg and Lewis, 2016). China's natural planning sets attention around goals to diminish SO2. This can be disclosed because of the way that China's energy structure which depends on coal, which contains a great deal of sulfur. In March of 2016, the thirteenth FYP was published with much more stronger targets towards
29 natural security and harsher punishments for polluters (Lauven et al., 2016). Because of the way that China could meet its twelfth FYP targets and furthermore, is on track to meet the Copenhagen Climate responsibility of 2009, where China had resolved to diminish their carbon emanations by 40 to 45 % in 2020 contrasted with 2005, it very well may be declared that China comes nearer to its objective to "building beautiful China". To conclude, the research question, “How relevant is Green theory in China’s environmental policymaking process?”, the investigation points out that it is very much relevant. China has in fact been a case exemplar to Asian continents in terms of planning and implementation when it comes to making their environmental policy processes successful. 4.3 The success of China’s environmental governance is not just dependent on adherence to green norms. What may be the other factors that could make it a success?
As the biggest producer of ozone-depleting substances and the biggest consumer of different items on the planet, China has been regularly observed as a noteworthy issue for worldwide progress to cleaner energy and more reasonable utilization of natural assets. Nevertheless, with its critical interest in clean energy and support to the Paris Agreement, China appears to end up as progressively dynamic in driving activities to secure nature (Sun, 2016). The monetary development of China throughout the last 30 years is phenomenally quick. It is now the 2nd largest economy and trusted to outperform even the US in few years for sure. Because of such development, China is all the time considered as a noteworthy rising force consistently expanding its effect on worldwide governance. Such developing effect lies not just in the financial and political domains, also in the natural one as well. Owing to the highest in terms of population, it has effects of energy utilization and subsequent contamination. Having consumed around the half of the coal expended on the planet, China is the biggest ozone-harming substance producer since 2007, and in charge of 27% of the worldwide emanations in 2014 – more than the US and the EU combined (Fritz, Levy and Ort, 2014). In the meantime, the rising living standards make China the biggest merchant of numerous crude materials and in this manner, prompt some harming ramifications for the worldwide ecology. From one viewpoint, China presents impressive difficulties to worldwide natural administration as the greatest polluter. With regard to ecological tact, China has been reprimanded for destroying the atmosphere transaction in 30
Copenhagen (Zhang, 2010). In addition, a few researchers have likewise communicated their worry on China's developing utilization which prompts a race to the base of ecological benchmarks for the production in the other developing nations (Kaplinsky, Terheggen and Tijaja, 2011). Then again, the world's most exceedingly bad polluter has just started to take aspiring activities and gained nontrivial ground before. Since the year 2004, there were manifold interests and subsequently related launches for power sources, sustainable by nature, this counted to almost 13% in 2010 and increased much further by 2015 as well to US$102.9 billion – by a wide margin the world's biggest investor (Kern and Rogge, 2016). To handle its air contamination issue, the nation additionally presented a complete action plan in 2013, promising an investment surpassing USD 200 billion from the central administration (Zhang et al., 2016). With different endeavours by its administration, China decreased its energy utilization by 18.2% and carbon footprint by 20% in the 2010-2015 period. Henceforth, it is not right to write off China as a danger to the planet, rather; an example to show the world how it could be done (Zhang, 2016). The International Energy Agency (IEA) performed basic appraisals of the aggregate results of energy-related carbon dioxide (CO2) discharges around the world (Levi and Cullen, 2018). The outcomes showed that monetary development was a priority need for China adding to the pollutant discharges. Petroleum products-based energy and atmospheric security challenges were recognized as difficult issues influencing sustainable monetary improvement. The outcomes also recommended that China has in place an appropriate administrative, regulatory, and political measures to control the issue of ozone-harming substance emanations. Also, that the environmental measures be set at national, regional, and local levels to address the difficulties of a sustainable background. The IEA appraisals showed administrative measures against resistant enterprises or power plants, to keep up the coveted quality environment all over the nation (Mol and Carter, 2006). Examination of different Five-Years Plans (FYPs) demonstrates constant Chinese government endeavours to limit the effect of industrial advancement in sustaining their environment. Monetary improvement and a sustainable setting might be viewed as the key segments of the advancement plans of the State. The National Climate Change Program (NCCP) was propelled in 2007 (Day, 2016) to keep up maintainable economic advancement and natural environment of the nation.
31
Discoveries of this nature were also reflected in the white paper, for instance, the 'China's Policies and Actions for Addressing Climate e Change' in 2008. The Chinese Legislature which is the ultimate law-making the body endorsed a draft decree on environmental change against the setting of ecological difficulties in 2009. Examination of reforms of energy shows national level arrangements for green sustainable power source assets, e.g., solar, wind, sea, and even thermal. The Chinese Government's endeavours contributed administrative measures to conquer ecological difficulties. Actually, China is presently leading in terms of wind power generation, with the greatest introduced power capacity contrasted with any state, and with always developing new facilities for the same (Mol and Carter, 2006). The FYPs for environmentally friendly power shows an anticipated measure of 250 GWs of wind energy generated power by 2020. In this context, 19.3 GWs of wind power was added to the current national limit, to achieve an aggregate limit of 149 GWs before the finish of 2017. Green wind energy ventures can be viewed as an accomplishment in the aggregate national endeavours to conquer existing difficulties of natural contamination. The policies for emissions endeavours to strike a harmony between modern or public emanations and sustainable financial advancement (Khan and Chang, 2018). A zero-tolerance approach was embraced to address natural issues and difficulties. In such a manner, national endeavours were made to elucidate the issue; by making levelheaded actions, functional and result- oriented systems to assemble and actualize the national ecological arrangements. The endeavours to address ecological difficulties can be followed back to the late 1990s when the Chinese government crushed its interests by applying the instruments of emissions trading. The government understood the results of a tremendous volume of emissions from wasteful power plants or manufacturing plants in its FYPs and stressed natural protection techniques to diminish public and even industrial ozone-harming substances emanations. The FYPs were created to welcome ecological sustainability as the top need by the government, natural analysts, and specialists, for emissions trading within China. The EPL (Environment Protection Laws) in China administers the national emissions trading mechanism; it thinks about ecological difficulties, strategy instruments, and measures, legislatures, environmental planning, and institutional settings in the ecological administration arrangement of China. The EPL is intended to adapt to natural difficulties, featuring the deficiencies in the present
32 ecological security framework, and propose better solutions for sustainable settings (Lauven et al., 2016). In China, a noteworthy battle against natural infringement has so far punished in excess of 30,000 organizations and more than 5,700 authorities. The government examination groups have collaborated with various regional government offices in scopes covering 30 areas and locales. If anything, this cannot be just a lop-sided suppression: their government thereafter promised to proceed with biennial examinations as well. President Xi Jinping flagged that authorities ought to consider ecological matters important in his extensive discourse to the Nineteenth Party Congress in October (Carley and Christie, 2017). He said that the harm that done to nature will at always, in the end, come back to humankind itself, without fail. Of late, the enactments have given examiners new instruments and is increasing the efficiency of the battle. The investigations speak of a novel worldview in the natural application in China, upheld by stronger, meatier laws, new lawful and not the least, managerial foundations, bolstering in terms of policies from the most elevated level in the administration itself. Environmental targeting was further increased in the forthcoming Five-Year Plan, which was cleared up through a decade old ecological policy action statements – the "Air Ten," the "Water Ten," and, most as of late, the "Soil Ten" – and largely anticipated, severer rules and directions. Yet, this corrected Environmental Law (Day, 2016), which became effective towards the beginning of 2015, that guaranteed to change a way to deal with the economy that has since quite a while ago, supported development at any expense. Enforcement experts have improved mechanisms to target ecological infringers, in addition to the organization’s senior directors and controllers. The most powerful of such actions altered the premise of fining the actual culprits from a "per occasion" premise to a regular basis, heavily demanding as well as modifying the "contaminate versus consent" condition. Capable senior administrators could be tossed into regulatory detainment for up to 15 days on end for rehashed encroachments by their organization. Furthermore, in related principles, the professional success of government authorities was made dependent upon natural performances. To round out these progressions, some non- governmental organizations (NGOs) are presently made competent to bring public interest ecological claims (Levi and Cullen, 2018). NGOs are lashing acquiescence in different ways, as well. The much-regarded Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs realized its Corporate Information
33
Transparency Index (CITI) at the 2017 China Green Supply Chain Forum, giving CITI execution/scores to roughly 260 famous organizations. The progressions in progress speak of a major move. Before, environmental experts concentrated on advance endorsements, with most consideration paid to ecological effect evaluations and development endorsements. The accentuation is presently on community functioning consistence and mindful inaccuracy. The edict gives apparatuses, however; deprived of solid strategy bolster, it scuffles as an instrument of social change (Tan, Xu and Zhang, 2016). The progression of strategy activities clarifies that ecological implementation is here for the long haul and on same standards with anti- corruption as an administration significance. Extra causative variables are meeting up as well, for example, the expansion in the skilled staff of the nature experts and the development of ecological councils inside the court framework. The enforcement wave sees no difference amongst other international or even domestic homegrown enterprises. The move triggered constant requests at China's international business chambers and other expert associations, each requesting for opportunities to broadcast their suggestions and experiences of learning (Rosenbaum, 2016). Establishments have likewise begun performing more ecological reviews internally to pick up a more prominent level of solace in the new condition. Another ongoing law is intended to avoid localities going back on development at every type of costing model. The Environmental Tax Law shifted from the hands of neighbourhood specialists and handed over to common, combined platforms set up by duty and ecological agencies. The government offices at local levels might think that it's unsafe to keep evading ecological laws by forgoing or sponsoring the discharge charges of favoured neighbourhood organizations. The natural equation presently supports ecologically mindful organizations over polluters. Generally, organizations that proactively encourage their supply chain network for consistency are appropriately prepared to fight the climate progressions (Carley and Christie, 2017). Companies have begun screening their providers to all the more likely comprehend their vulnerabilities. So far, most endeavours have focused on air and water-related contamination, with soil and groundwater tainting – the highest deceptive of all contamination – for the most part, put in the "too hard" class. Quite a while back, a split review of the country's soil pollution featured the issue, provoking the ‘Soil Ten’ arrangement system and an administration’s vow to amend divided control. Consistent with its oath, the
34
Law on Soil Pollution Prevention and Control (Soil Law) is on track since inception. Effectively, new impermanent standards are empowering experts to test its ideas. As the results of ecological infectivity wind up as countable and recognized by the fresh natural courts, organizations will start to look for allocating obligation. This will prompt the development of natural protection items and advance the utilization of ecological advances. The present thoroughness in natural authorization is probably going to win. Proactive self-evaluation joined with a solid consistency approach, is the most ideal path for organizations to make preparations for unprecedented events (Ray et al., 2015; Rosenbaum, 2016; Heggelund, 2017), and to have a prepared barrier exhibiting hearty natural compliance arrangements. China also realized that the status quo of the public’s participation in the mechanism of environmental governance must also be uplifted to make it a true success. Before, this relationship between people and the environment was more of which that contained ignorance and disregard when it came to self-involvement and rights preservation. However, over recent few decades, this has changed. Before 1990, there was an overall lack of knowledge, hence people did not act consciously and so did not even involve themselves. Their primary targets were to make a livelihood. In the next 10- 15 years, the level of consciousness improved and became more or less involved in the wake of the environmental issues, especially; the pollution situations. From 2006 onwards, the national aims for energy saving and reduction in emissions were introduced, also rules for public participation and disclosure of information was enforced nationally, people gradually started to get appropriately involved and expressed their eagerness to protect their environment (Ge, Bi and Wang, 2010). Leading researchers also suggested that the government must renew the concept and make public participation a right of people, protected by law. Also, there should be appropriate environment information disclosure as part of people’s rights for environmental awareness and criticism. With the help of law and public supervision, the perpetrators must be brought to light and justice. It was also suggested that along with the public’s involvement and supervision environmental decision-making could be made stronger in its democratization. By pushing the non-profit lawsuits of the environment, the government could also help protect people’s environmental interests with the help of law. Even e-NGOs could be involved by the government to play a stronger role in the protection of the environment. The government hence
35 realized that it is important that the entire society is mobilized for a proper creation of an ecological civilization. It started building drafts to improve the supervision of society, information disclosure, preservation of people’s awareness, involvement and supervision by law, make appropriate development plans and allied infrastructure projects on a national level in public’s environmental interests, based on their opinions and supervision with assistance of public hearings, disclosures and discussions (Ge, Bi and Wang, 2010). The government also started planning to promote the mechanism for public’s participation, build a proper platform to aid participation of social forces, thereby encouraging exposing polluting activities and pushing environmental lawsuits of social welfare nature. Constitutional arrangements for the same were implemented for the preservation of social participation for environment protection. In 2006, Feb, Interim Measures of Public Participation in Environmental Impact Assessment was enacted. By doing this, the government put in a provision to encourage participation of the public in Public Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs). This was the first of its kind of environmental regulation of public participation. Following this, in 2007, Environmental Information Disclosure Measures on a trial basis was brought in place. This made it mandatory for polluting enterprises to disclose information related to emissions. This became the first normative document on disclosure of information and the first comprehensive sector regulation related to environment information disclosure (Ge, Bi and Wang, 2010). Since 2013, the Chinese government propelled a variety of activities with the end goal to build up a green economic framework. Following the arrangement to grow a corporate green bond market to help China's change to a low-carbon economy declared by the State Council, the People's Bank of China (PBoC) – China's national bank – and the UNEP started a Green Finance Task Force in 2014, which involves in excess of 40 Chinese and overseas specialists from administrative establishments, think tanks, the scholarly community and the private sector. In April 2015, this team proposed fourteen suggestions for a new structure for China's green economic framework. Then, in December, the PBoC distributed the guidelines for the Green Bond to the Green Bond Endorsed Project Catalogue. It has since been noticed that the green bond market is mounting amazingly quick in China. While in January 2016 , only two business banks issued more than US$ 4.5 billion securities, and in the later part of the year
36 itself - the Bank of China propelled the biggest multi-designated issue of green securities so far on global marketplaces, valued at US$3 billion (Sun, 2016). Without a doubt, China's inclination to green finance comprises an important component of a change on green economy distinguished by the nation's thirteenth FYP for the time of 2016-2020. This renditions towards manufacturing a green money related framework, create green credits, green securities, and build up green improvement reserves. All the more, as of late, China's administration demonstrates its assurance in this subject, by affirming on August 31, 2016, the "Rules on Establishing the Green Financial System" mutually disseminated by seven government offices. In advancing an extensive variety of budgetary appliances, these rules can be considered as the world's fundamental struggle at an incorporated strategy bundle to advance an eager move towards a green economy (Sun, 2016). On the worldwide stage, China additionally demonstrates its aim to lead a worldwide change. With its administration in this year, China puts green back high on the G20's plan; and the PBoC co-led with the Bank of England the G20 Green Finance Study Group to advance collaboration on a green budgetary framework and build up the engaging quality of a green fund. Subsequently, one astounding result of the G20 summit in Hangzhou is to perceive the significance of scaling up green financing and recognize a scope of endeavours required. Moreover, China's endeavours on greenback stretch out to its overseas speculation including the multilateral improvement banks under its authority. Using them, China intends to vitalize greenback on a worldwide balance, compelling the world to a slanting outlet (Dikau, 2018). To conclude, the third research question, “The success of China’s environmental governance is not just dependent on adherence to green norms. What may be the other factors that could make it a success?” shows that government’s resolve and fierce implementation plans strengthened by laws in the country for economic development has a huge contribution in making ecological governance and green policies nurtured by China a success.
37
5. Conclusion, Recommendation and Limitations
Making strides toward environmental friendliness has been a developing issue overall, driving organizations to persistently upgrade their green abilities and execute imaginative green practices to ensure the earth and enhance business execution. This examination gives a few research augmentations. The study showcased that owing to industrialization, the environmental crisis came into being in the first place. This is the primary reason why nations across the planet want to adopt ‘going green’. They are constantly innovating their approaches to amplify their green capabilities and bring in place appropriate green policies as part of implementation to improve their status in global politico scenario and economic space as well as protect the environment in the same go. The studies started with the introduction section which touched upon these issues and provided the necessary backdrop of the current crisis and put forward the reasons for conducting this study in the first place. It also touched upon the relevance of Green IR theory in today’s present world as one such bond that connects nations on a common platform is the collective responsibility to conserve the nature and hence Green theory in International Relations is relevant in today’s state of manners on a global level. The next section of Literature Review spoke of origin of green theory, why it came into existence in the first place to explain the need of such a theory in the global scene, thereafter also the challenges the theory faces in the current backdrop of environmental crisis. Since the study specifically studies China, a section to elaborate the Chinese perspective of affairs when it came to challenges it faced when it came to green implementation has also been discussed as put forward in different kinds of literature. The Research methodology chapter explains the necessary logic which was used to conduct the research while also portraying the advantages and disadvantages of conducting a case study-based research. The fourth section of analysis is where the available data, secondary in nature, has been analyzed for the research questions that guided this study. For the first research question, “Is green theory an important facet to consider when making environmental policies?” The answer remained hugely undecided and no firm decision could be reached as there is no clear study available which has connected these two aspects, specifically for China. A large reason of this could be the fact that China never makes its environmental information public, there have only been three such instances where it has done so and the major analysis 38 done by professionals in the field hugely rely on previous data and trend nature to draw conclusions. For the second research question, “How relevant is Green theory in China’s environmental policymaking process?” It was found through various implementation trends of China when it came to environmental policies and governance structures, it indeed paid attention to green needs suited as per their requirements and results were for the world to see. For the third research question, “The success of China’s environmental governance is not just dependent on adherence to green norms, what may be the other factors that could make it a success?” It was found out that stricter laws, empowered institutions, officials, strict punishment and engaged network right from the government to the private companies across localities and making the performance linked to their careers, giving teeth to the laws for bringing the perpetrators under the law has affected this machinery of environmental governance built on structures of green needs. Despite the fact that this exploration conducted for the study gives profitable bits of knowledge, it has impediments, which should serve to invigorate additionally research. In terms of limitation, the scholar found lack of enough information, such as statistics to put forward the latest reports, except what was available on certain journals. The scholar has focused on recent available information, dated back to maximum 5-6 years, however, a trend study could be conducted for the past 2 decades and linked to the FYP of China in these time phrases to actually check the efficacy and success of the mechanism. A study of such large scale would not be possible for the scholar to conduct without appropriate aids and permissions and that was also a limitation of this study as access to data was very limited. The scholar would recommend that China could further strengthen their laws and create a firmer machinery for compliance of industries to combat the air pollution battle being fought by them. Better public awareness campaigns could be administered whereby every citizen would have the information and could act as an eye and ear for the government. They could also notify government for mis-happenings and hence would ensure appropriate implementation at grass root levels with implementation of proper environment protection standards. Its next stop of plans could include least carbon footprint economy. If there is a need then good innovations around the same should also be boosted to make it a reality.
39
6. Bibliography
Barkdull, J. and Harris, P. G. (2002) ‘Environmental Change and Foreign Policy: A Survey of Theory’, Global Environmental Politics, 2(2), pp. 63– 91. doi: 10.1162/15263800260047835. Barnett, J. (2003) ‘Security and climate change’, Elsevier, pp. 7–17. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959378002000808 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Baylis, J., Smith, S. and Owens, P. (2017) The globalization of world politics: an introduction to international relations. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=FwyDDQAAQBAJ&oi=fn d&pg=PP1&dq=the+universal+network+faces+numerous+worldwide+issue s&ots=OZqGb970zi&sig=T2bWhEjTlJG4KqCZXC0PX_STl64 (Accessed: 22 October 2018). Biermann, F. (2017) A World Environment Organization: Solution or threat for effective international environmental governance? Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351961431 (Accessed: 11 October 2018). Bingham, L. B., Nabatchi, T. and O’Leary, R. (2005) ‘The New Governance: Practices and Processes for Stakeholder and Citizen Participation in the Work of Government’, Public Administration Review, 65(5), pp. 547–558. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6210.2005.00482.x. Birnie, P. and Boyle, A. (1994) International law and the environment. Available at: https://trid.trb.org/view/453399 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Brooks, R. and Jones, R. (2017) Law and Ecology: The rise of the ecosystem regime. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351922913 (Accessed: 10 October 2018). Calvert, P. (2016) ‘Revolution and International politics’. Carley, M. and Christie, I. (2017) Managing sustainable development. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351559362 (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Carlsnaes, W. et al. (2002) Handbook of international relations. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=f90C7zgrcXYC&oi=fnd& pg=PR9&dq=Wight,+2002+environment&ots=dL_8RuNg0O&sig=Ivyjc86 yV-rMFlOmOsynXyQX9u4 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Cheng (2011) ‘Theories and Interpretations of Environmental Policy’. 40
Available at: https://www.e-ir.info/2011/07/06/theories-and-interpretations- of-environmental-policy-2/ (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Chunmei, W. and Zhaolan, L. (2010) ‘Environmental Policies in China over the Past 10 Years: Progress, Problems and Prospects’, Procedia Environmental Sciences, 2, pp. 1701–1712. doi: 10.1016/j.proenv.2010.10.181. Connelly, J. et al. (2012) Politics and the environment: from theory to practice. Available at: https://content.taylorfrancis.com/books/download?dac=C2009-0-25502- 0&isbn=9781136484605&format=googlePreviewPdf (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Crespy, C. T. and Miller, V. V. (2011) ‘Sustainability reporting: A comparative study of NGOs and MNCs’, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 18(5), pp. 275–284. doi: 10.1002/csr.248. Cropper, S. et al. (2008) The Oxford Handbook of Inter-Organizational Relations. Edited by S. Cropper et al. Oxford University Press. doi: 10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199282944.001.0001. Dabelko, G. and Dabelko, D. (1995) ‘Environmental security: Issues of conflict and redefinition’, wilsoncenter.org, pp. 3–13. Available at: https://www.wilsoncenter.org/sites/default/files/report1a.pdf#page=3 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Day, K. (2016) China’s environment and the challenge of sustainable development. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781315497686 (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Desai, U. (1998) ‘Environment, economic growth and government in developing countries’, books.google.com, pp. 1–46. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=cakayuBUF8QC&oi=fnd& pg=PA1&dq=Desai+(1998+environment&ots=JTlqvVjKNT&sig=GywOa3 piZcQcr9DL8JgmA2kn1-A (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Dikau, S. (2018) ‘Central Banking, Climate Change, and Green Finance’. Available at: https://www.adb.org/publications/central-banking-climate- change-and-green-finance (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Dimitrov, R. S. (2010) ‘Inside Copenhagen: The State of Climate Governance’, Global Environmental Politics, 10(2), pp. 18–24. doi: 10.1162/glep.2010.10.2.18. Dimitrov, R. S. (2016) ‘The Paris Agreement on Climate Change: Behind
41
Closed Doors’, Global Environmental Politics, 16(3), pp. 1–11. doi: 10.1162/GLEP_a_00361. Dong, C. et al. (2016) ‘Sustainability investment under cap-and-trade regulation’, Annals of Operations Research, 240(2), pp. 509–531. doi: 10.1007/s10479-013-1514-1. Dupuy, P. and Viñuales, J. (2018) International environmental law. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=OwdZDwAAQBAJ&oi=fn d&pg=PR13&dq=rise+of+environmental+laws+in+1960s&ots=XTm5L2w G5p&sig=EAaJlQQaNh13JIZSMLAsAqCkz48 (Accessed: 10 October 2018). Durant, R. (2017) Environmental governance reconsidered: challenges, choices, and opportunities. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=oGYyDwAAQBAJ&oi=fn d&pg=PR9&dq=environmental+governance&ots=y0lqm6167C&sig=E0CR OTfcJzGDFCQSSMf5RQ6fqBA (Accessed: 11 October 2018). Dyer, H. (2014) ‘Climate anarchy: creative disorder in world politics’, academic.oup.com, 8(2), pp. 182–200. Available at: https://academic.oup.com/ips/article-abstract/8/2/182/1796344 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Eckersley, R. (2012) ‘Moving Forward in the Climate Negotiations: Multilateralism or Minilateralism?’, Global Environmental Politics, 12(2), pp. 24–42. doi: 10.1162/GLEP_a_00107. Elliott, L. (2004) ‘The Global Politics of the Environment’, in The Global Politics of the Environment. London: Macmillan Education UK, pp. 223– 238. doi: 10.1007/978-0-230-80209-4_11. Ellis, T. and Levy, Y. (2009) ‘Towards a Guide for Novice Researchers on Research Methodology: Review and Proposed Methods.’, books.google.com. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=qLqIK3HomoEC&oi=fnd &pg=PA323&dq=Ellis+and+Levy,+2009&ots=PngnYc2ylV&sig=7sJZzx3o rxQrCv7qLiYr3lH77mI (Accessed: 17 October 2018). Freshwater, D. (2007) ‘Reading Mixed Methods Research: Contexts for Criticism’, Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 1(2), pp. 134–146. doi: 10.1177/1558689806298578. Fritz, V., Levy, B. and Ort, R. (eds) (2014) Problem-Driven Political Economy Analysis: The World Bank’s Experience. The World Bank. doi:
42
10.1596/978-1-4648-0121-1. Gardiner, S. (2011) A perfect moral storm: the ethical tragedy of climate change. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=5ohoAgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd &pg=PP1&dq=Gardiner+(2011)&ots=77ZyBMLzP6&sig=3F_-0cSk- nru4RURdi34ce5zFn8 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Ge, J., Bi, J. and Wang, S. (no date) Chapter 2 Public Participation in China’s Environmental Protection. Available at: http://www.ide.go.jp/library/English/Publish/Download/Jrp/pdf/153_ch2.pdf (Accessed: 19 October 2018). Guerrero, D. (2011) ‘The Global Climate Justice Movement’, in Global Civil Society 2011. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, pp. 120–126. doi: 10.1057/9780230303805_10. Halperin, S. and Heath, O. (2016) Political research: methods and practical skills. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=7wqDDQAAQBAJ&oi=fn d&pg=PP1&dq=Halperin+and+Heath+single+case+study&ots=V3iXgqiMV o&sig=vTArzWsulugVGS5X3DjMvQuUVtk (Accessed: 24 October 2018). Harrison, R. L. and Reilly, T. M. (2011) ‘Mixed methods designs in marketing research’, Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, 14(1), pp. 7–26. doi: 10.1108/13522751111099300. Hay, C. (2002) Political analysis: a critical introduction. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=P2cHCwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd &pg=PP1&dq=Hay,+2002&ots=AOeAT80TX3&sig=Z2MS79QIMCG13cx FXts6h8nL7Xk (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Hays, P. (2004) ‘Case study research’, books.google.com, pp. 217–234. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=SbCPAgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd &pg=PA217&dq=case+study+research&ots=B2CUe6Og1s&sig=BxhloIFI WtLgDIby88wYX-z1jIU (Accessed: 17 October 2018). Heggelund, G. (2017) Environment and resettlement politics in China: the Three Gorges Project. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351939775 (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Hermwille, L. (2016) ‘Climate change as a transformation challenge. A new climate policy paradigm?’, ingentaconnect.com, 25(1), pp. 19–28. Available at:
43 https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/oekom/gaia/2016/00000025/00000 001/art00007 (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Jackson, R. and Sørensen, G. (2016) Introduction to international relations: theories and approaches. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=- HLNCgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=International+Relations+Woodro w+Wilson+to+seat+in+1919+happened,+&ots=eaUULXTkQA&sig=909N6 JGhev1w79iWJ-EB5EpbxUU (Accessed: 10 October 2018). Jameson, F. and Miyoshi, M. (1998) The cultures of globalization. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=fsQOE03q4I0C&oi=fnd&p g=PR9&dq=Jameson+and+Miyoshi+(1998)&ots=ms7IBOZI6k&sig=p1tha CWWe6_EGyBui2xLxgrOmRE (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Johnson, T. (2009) Extending Environmental Governance: China’s Environmental State and Civil Society. Available at: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/40053869.pdf (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Kaplinsky, R., Terheggen, A. and Tijaja, J. (2011) ‘China as a final market: The Gabon timber and Thai cassava value chains’, Elsevier, 39(7), pp. 1170–90. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X10002512 (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Kern, F. and Rogge, K. (2016) ‘The pace of governed energy transitions: agency, international dynamics and the global Paris agreement accelerating decarbonisation processes?’, Elsevier, pp. 13–17. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629616301992 (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Khan, M. I. and Chang, Y.-C. (2018) ‘Environmental Challenges and Current Practices in China—A Thorough Analysis’, MDPI. Available at: file:///Users/soumyodeepakar/Downloads/sustainability-10-02547.pdf (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Kopnina, H. (2016) ‘Challenging economic development: the case study of teaching alternative cultural values in business education’, Journal of Integrative Environmental Sciences, 13(1), pp. 67–84. doi: 10.1080/1943815X.2016.1150300. Krause, J. and Renwick, N. (2016) Identities in international relations. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=2yC_DAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd
44
&pg=PR7&dq=globalization+is+encouraging+the+resurgence+of+patriotis m&ots=6nPHL0PwPM&sig=-kse3qjBGQghwddPh7ZvdWPUadY (Accessed: 22 October 2018). Kutting, G. (2000) ‘Distinguishing between institutional and environmental effectiveness in international environmental agreements: the case of the Mediterranean Action Plan’, gmu.edu, 5(1), pp. 15–34. Available at: http://www.gmu.edu/academic/ijps/vol5_1/kutting.htm (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Lauren, D. L.-P. et al. (2016) ‘Reform and Regulation: China’s Environmental Policy’. Available at: file:///Users/soumyodeepakar/Downloads/Ufü_Reform and Regulation.pdf (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Ledford, J. and Gast, D. (2018) Single case research methodology: Applications in special education and behavioural sciences. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351366861 (Accessed: 24 October 2018). Lemos, M. et al. (2016) ‘Linking development to climate adaptation: Leveraging generic and specific capacities to reduce vulnerability to drought in NE Brazil’, Elsevier, pp. 170–179. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959378016300607 (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Levi, P. G. and Cullen, J. M. (2018) ‘Mapping Global Flows of Chemicals: From Fossil Fuel Feedstocks to Chemical Products’, Environmental Science & Technology, 52(4), pp. 1725–1734. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.7b04573. Lewis, J. I. (2014) ‘The Rise of Renewable Energy Protectionism: Emerging Trade Conflicts and Implications for Low Carbon Development’, Global Environmental Politics, 14(4), pp. 10–35. doi: 10.1162/GLEP_a_00255. Lewis, S. (2015) ‘Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Approaches’, Health Promotion Practice, 16(4), pp. 473–475. doi: 10.1177/1524839915580941. LI, X. (2006) ‘ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS IN CHINA: PROBLEMS, POLICIES, AND GLOBAL IMPLICATIONS’, International Social Science Review. Pi Gamma Mu, International Honor Society in Social Sciences, pp. 43–57. doi: 10.2307/41887258. Liefferink, D. (1996) Environment and the nation-state: the Netherlands, the EU and acid rain. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=PRroAAAAIAAJ&oi=fnd
45
&pg=PR8&dq=Liefferink,+1996&ots=SxH2r6_Go5&sig=goV_Dv_idJZLn V-WJoADe9zTkO4 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Linklater, A. (1998) The transformation of political community: ethical foundations of the post-Westphalian era. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=0Ifc90o7kDgC&oi=fnd&p g=PA1&dq=Linklater,+1998&ots=Y7hurCt6zY&sig=_jlys652ekabdy8vwR xEDCPHhDE (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Litfin, K. (1998) The greening of sovereignty in world politics. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=JqDvCb4bxi4C&oi=fnd&p g=PR9&dq=Litfin+(1998)+&ots=_irA0svyog&sig=2JTcNR7yFs3maKiIYv U_YNeitJI (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Magilvy, J. K. and Thomas, E. (2009) ‘A First Qualitative Project: Qualitative Descriptive Design for Novice Researchers’, Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing, 14(4), pp. 298–300. doi: 10.1111/j.1744- 6155.2009.00212.x. Maguire, D. and Rasmussen, L. (1998) Ethics for a small planet: New horizons on population, consumption, and ecology. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=05B4cvkf_8AC&oi=fnd& pg=PR7&dq=Maguire+and+Rasmussen+(1998)&ots=b1qHavMala&sig=vL yWG1SuNGMzz3hyjNkPGeraKVE (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Mochizuki, M. and Ollapally, D. (2016) Energy Security in Asia and Eurasia. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=MCslDwAAQBAJ&oi=fn d&pg=PP1&dq=Asia+representing+the+biggest+portion+as+of+in+2005+( 48%25+of+aggregate+tonnage,+contrasted+with+Europe%27s+13%25)&ot s=LEo8VaPaS7&sig=TLykfXiwtqgPCABZrKlsYp52NhE (Accessed: 22 October 2018). Mol, A. P. J. and Carter, N. T. (2006) ‘China’s environmental governance in transition’, Environmental Politics, 15(2), pp. 149–170. doi: 10.1080/09644010600562765. Morgan, D. L. (2007) ‘Paradigms Lost and Pragmatism Regained’, Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 1(1), pp. 48–76. doi: 10.1177/2345678906292462. Ray, R. et al. (2015) ‘China in Latin America: lessons for south-south cooperation and sustainable development’. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=Qb41DgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd &pg=PA3&dq=sustainable+development+and+environment+in+China&ots
46
=UBzn6sNPJ_&sig=t1sEzkdDj51gJnzTfZ8PKlfrkP8 (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Renner, M. and Patterson, W. (1997) Fighting for survival: Environmental decline, social conflict, and the new age of insecurity. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=VYRzg4xaGk0C&oi=fnd &pg=PA7&dq=Renner,+1997+earth+is+contributing+factor&ots=q2gNq4T xc-&sig=I21enexgdVTlIKuhY_ZLtqEQ1NY (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Rønnfeldt, C. F. (1997) ‘Three Generations of Environment and Security Research’, Journal of Peace Research, 34(4), pp. 473–482. doi: 10.1177/0022343397034004009. Rosenbaum, W. (2016) Environmental politics and policy. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=r1O0DAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd &pg=PP1&dq=environment+policy+making+in+China&ots=7k9hghlsO9&s ig=txu6EHb3yqsBBjrlOmgZ8VWrG1I (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Schaeffer, R. and Dickinson, T. (2003) Understanding globalization: The social consequences of political, economic, and environmental change. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=bSTqbu7dWSYC&oi=fnd &pg=PR11&dq=Schaeffer+1997+globalization&ots=LdB0Yuili3&sig=bY w8XQHxqwwOM21KDSXT-St9QX0 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Schmidt, B. (2016) Political Discourse of Anarchy, The: A Disciplinary History of International Relations. Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=0c9_peiLbZEC&oi=fnd&p g=PR9&dq=origin+of+international+relations&ots=Rpfvk7hoz4&sig=4oW uIRp1sNH9NijHZQlCA6ZFHHk (Accessed: 10 October 2018). Sheppard, S. (2012) Visualizing climate change: a guide to visual communication of climate change and developing local solutions. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781136529009 (Accessed: 22 October 2018). Sun, Y. (2016) ‘The Changing Role of China in Global Environmental Governance’, Rising Powers Quarterly, 1(1), pp. 43–53. Available at: http://risingpowersproject.com/quarterly/changing-role-china-global- environmental-governance/ (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Tan, Y., Xu, H. and Zhang, X. (2016) ‘Sustainable urbanization in China: A comprehensive literature review’, Elsevier, pp. 80–95. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264275116300622 (Accessed: 16 October 2018).
47
Tang, Q. (2015) ‘The Role of Carbon Accounting in Corporate Carbon Management Systems: a Holistic Approach’. Available at: http://www.massey.ac.nz/massey/fms/Colleges/College of Business/School of Accountancy/Documents/Seminars/Auckland/2015/The Role of Carbon Accounting and Corporate Carbon Management Systems.pdf (Accessed: 7 April 2018). Thomas, C. (1992) The environment in international relations. Available at: https://www.osti.gov/etdeweb/biblio/7268574 (Accessed: 15 October 2018). Thompson, P. (2017) Peace and war: a theory of international relations. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781351500418 (Accessed: 10 October 2018). Tietenberg, T. and Lewis, L. (2016) Environmental and natural resource economics. Available at: https://content.taylorfrancis.com/books/download?dac=C2015-0-78850- 4&isbn=9781315523965&format=googlePreviewPdf (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Vogler, J. (2003) ‘Taking Institutions Seriously: How Regime Analysis can be Relevant to Multilevel Environmental Governance’, Global Environmental Politics, 3(2), pp. 25–39. doi: 10.1162/152638003322068191. Wiersema, M. F. and Bowen, H. P. (2009) ‘The use of limited dependent variable techniques in strategy research: issues and methods’, Strategic Management Journal, 30(6), pp. 679–692. doi: 10.1002/smj.758. Yi, H. and Liu, Y. (2015) ‘Green economy in China: Regional variations and policy drivers’, Elsevier, pp. 11–19. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095937801400199X (Accessed: 16 October 2018). Young, A. (1998) ‘Growth without Scale Effects’, Journal of Political Economy, 106(1), pp. 41–63. doi: 10.1086/250002. Zhang, X. et al. (2016) ‘Carbon emissions in China: How far can new efforts bend the curve?’, Elsevier, pp. 388–395. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140988315003503 (Accessed: 20 October 2018). Zhang, Z. (2010) ‘Copenhagen and beyond: reflections on China’s stance and responses’. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1668438 (Accessed: 20 October 2018).
48
Zhang, Z. (2016) ‘The U.S. Proposed Carbon Tariffs, WTO Scrutiny and China’s Responses’, in Legal Issues on Climate Change and International Trade Law. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 67–92. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-29322-6_3.
49