Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore, Submerged Cultural Resources Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
C. PATRICK lABADIE B&WScans cr" 2- [Oa 2.CX) • PICTURED ROCKS NATIONAL LAKESHORE • • :D-31 • SUBMERGED CULTURAL RESOURCES STUDY PICTURED ROCKS NATIONAL LAKESHORE • by C. Patrick Labadie Southwest Cultural Resources Center Professional Papers No. 22 Santa Fe, New Mexico 1989 • iii ON MlCROf\lM e • Submerged Cultural Resources Unit Southwest Cultural Resources Center Southwest Region National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior • iv • PUBLISHED REPORTS OF THE SOUTHWEST CULTURAL RESOURCES CENTER 1. Larry E. Murphy, Editor. Submerged Cultural Resources Survey: Portions of Point Reyes National Seashore and Point Reyes-Farallon Islands National Marine Sanctuary. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit, 1984. 2. Toni Carrell. Submerged Cultural Resources Inventory: Portions of Point Reyes National Seashore and Point Reyes-Farallon Islands National Marine Sanctuary. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit. 1984 3. Edwin C. Bearss. Resource Study: Lyndon B. Johnson and the Hill Country, 1937-1 963. Division of Conservation, 1984. 4. Edwin C. Bearss. Historic Structures Report: Texas White House. Division of Conservation, 1986. 5. Barbara Holmes. Historic Resource Study of the Barataria Unit of Jean lafitte • National Historical Park. Division of History, 1986 . 6. Steven M. Burke and Marlys Bush-Thurber. Southwest Region Headquarters Building, Santa Fe, New Mexico: A Historic Structure Report. Division of Conservation, 1985. 7. Toni Carrell. Submerged Cultural Resources Site Report: NOQUEBAY, Apostle Islands National Lakeshore. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit. 1985. 8. Daniel J. Lenihan, Editor. Submerged Cultural Resources Study: Isle Royale National Park. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit, 1987. 9. J. Richard Ambler. Assessment: Navajo National Monument. Division of Anthropology, 1985. 10. John S. Speaker, Joanna Chase, Carol Poplin, Herschel Franks, R. Christopher Goodwin. Archeological Assessment: Barataria Unit. Jean Lafitte National Historical Park. Division of Anthropology, 1986. 11. James E. lvey, Marlys Bush-Thurber, James T. Escobedo Jr., Tom Ireland. The Missions of San Antonio: A Historic Structures Report and AdministratiVe History. Divisions of Conservation and History, 1987. 12. Roger E. Coleman. The Arkansas Post Story. Division of History, 1987. 13. Toni Carrell, Editor. Submerged Cultural Resources Site Report: Charles H. Spencer Mining Operation and Paddle Wheel Steamboat Glen Canyon • National Recreation Area. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit. 1987. v 14. Hal Rothman. The Bandelier National Monument: An Administrative History. Division of History, 1988. 15. James E. lvey. In the Mist of A Loneliness. Division of History, 1988. • 16. Richard W. S e IIa rs and MeI ody Webb. The History of Historic in Service- 1947 1980. Santa Fe, 1988. 17. Laura S. Harrison and Beverley Spears, Historic Structures Report Chinle Trading Post Thunderbird Ranch and Custodian's Residence. Division of History, 1988. 18. James P. Delgado and Stephen A. Haller. Submerged Cultural Resources Assessment: Golden Gate National Recreation Area, Gulf of the Farallones National Marine Sanctuary and Point Reyes National Seashore, 1989. 19. Judith K. Fabry. Guadalupe Mountains National Park: An Administrative History. Division of History, 1988. 20. Peter J. McKenna and Scott E. Travis. Archeological Investigations at Thunderbird Lodge. Division of Anthropology, 1989. 21. Peter J. McKenna and James E. Bradford. The T. J. Ruin, Gila Cliff Dwellings. Division of Anthropology, 1989. 22. C. Patrick Labadie. Submerged Cultural Resources Study: Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit, 1989. • 23. Daniel J. Lenihan, Editor. Submerged Cultural Resources Study: USS Arizona Memorial and Pearl Harbor National Historic Landmark. Submerged Cultural Resources Unit, 1989. • vi • SUBMERGED CULTURAL RESOURCES UNIT REPORT AND PUBLICATION SERIES The Submerged Cultural Resources Unit was established in 1980 to conduct research on submerged cultural resources throughout the National Park System with an emphasis on historic shipwrecks. One of the unit's primary responsibilities is to disseminate the results of research to National Park Service managers, as well as the professional community, in a form that meets resource management needs and adds to our understanding of the resource base. A report series has been initiated in order to fulfill this responsibility. The following are the categories of reports that comprise this series. Submerged Cultural Resources Assessment First line document that consists of a brief literature search, an overview of the maritime history and the known or potential underwater sites in the park, and preliminary recommendations for long-term management. It is designed to have application to GMP/DCP's and to become a source document for a park's Submerged Cultural Resources Management Plan. • Submerged Cultural Resources Survey Comprehensive examination of blocks of park lands for the purpose of locating and identifying as much of the submerged cultural resources base as possible. A comprehensive literature search would most likely be a part of the Phase I report but, in some cases, may be postponed until Phase IL Phase I -- Reconnaissance of target areas with remote sensing and visual survey techniques to establish location of any archeological sites or anomalous features that may suggest the presence of archeological sites. Phase II -- Evaluation of archeological sites or anomalous features derived from remote sensing instruments to confirm their nature and, if possible, their significance. This may involve exploratory removal of overburden. Submerged Cultural Resources Study A document that discusses, in detail, all known underwater archeological sites in a given park. This may involve test excavations. The intended audience is managerial and professional, not the general public. • vii Submerged Cultural Resources Site Report Exhaustive documentation of one archeological site which may involve a partial or • complete site excavation. The intended audience is primarily professional and incidentally managerial. Although the document may be useful to a park's interpretive specialists because of its information content. it would probably not be suitable for general distribution to park visitors. Submerged Cultural Resources Special Report Series These may be in published or photocopy format. Included are special commentaries, papers on methodological or technical issues pertinent to underwater archeology, or any miscellaneous report that does not appropriately fit into one of the other categories. Daniel J. Lenihan • • viii • TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES xi FOREWORD XV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS xvii I. INTRODUCTION Project Rationale 1 Previous Research 2 Project Goals 3 Research Methodology 3 II. MARITIME HISTORICAL CONTEXT 5 Fur and Fishing 5 Copper and Iron Ore 7 Soo Locks 11 Grain and Flour 13 Gogebic, Vermillion and Missabe Iron Ranges 15 Lumber Trade 15 20th-Century Patterns, Summary 16 • Ill. DEVELOPMENT OF COMMERCIAL SHIPS ON LAKE SUPERIOR 17 Sailing Craft 17 The Canals 21 Propellers, Sidewheelers and Package Freight 22 Steam Barges, Consort System 25 Bulk Freighters 26 IV. SHIPWRECKS 31 Introduction 31 Analysis 31 Murray Bay: Schooner BERMUDA 35 East Channel: Bulk Freighter SMITH MOORE 43 Trout Point: Bulk Freighter MANHATIAN 48 Trout Point: Steambarge HERMAN H. HETILER 51 Sand Point (West): Schooner MARY M. SCOTT 54 Sand Point (East): Unidentified Schooner 60 Miner's Castle Area: Steambarge MICHAEL GROH 62 Schooner-barge ELMA 67 Mosquito Beach: Schooner GEORGE 70 Chapel Beach: Schooner WABASH 75 Spray Falls: Steamboat SUPERIOR 79 Twelve Mile Beach: Freighter KIOWA 85 Hurricane River: Bulk Freighter MARY JARECKI 95 Au Sable Point Area: Schooner ONEIDA CHIEF 105 • Bulk Freighter SITKA 108 ix Bulk Freighter GALE STAPLES 121 Propeller UNION 132 Log Slide: Steamer SOUTH SHORE 138 Grand Marais: Schooners GALATEA and NIRVANA 143 Steambarge H.E. RUNNELS 146 • Schooner SAVELAND 149 Propeller MANHATTAN 153 Steamer HUNTER 158 Chronology of Accidents 161 V. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 175 Overview 175 Retrospective 175 Management Recommendations 176 Law Enforcement 177 Interpretation 179 Further Research Needs 185 Relative Significance 188 BIBLIOGRAPHY 193 APPENDIX 227 • • X • LIST OF FIGURES 2.1. Grand Island Harbor, May 1867 6 2.2. Marquette in 1859 6 2.3. Iron ore carried in schooners and steamers 8 2.4. CITY OF TRAVERSE, at Munising 1870s 8 2.5. Comparison of iron ore to total freight 1855-1919 9 2.6. State Locks at Sault Ste. Marie circa 1860s 12 2.7. Indians fishing at Sault Ste. Marie 12 2.8. Fleets at Soo Locks 1880s 14 2.9. Lumber steamers and barges at Grand Marais 14 3.1. Merchant schooners circa 1837 18 3.2. An 1870s typical schooner 18 3.3. Steambarge with pilot house aft 24 3.4. Lumber hooker built after 1880 24 3.5. Early bulk freighters averaged about 200 feet 27 3.6. 500-foot steel bulk carriers 27 4. 1. Analysis of causes for shipping accidents 34 4.2. Analysis of vessel-types involved in accidents 34 4.3. BERMUDA deck arrangement 37 4.4. The canal schooner OLIVER MITCHELL 39 • 4.5. The canal schooner BERMUDA deck 39 4.6. Munising Channel wreck site locations 41 4.7. The SMITH MOORE deck arrangement 45 4.8. Silhouette of the SMITH MOORE 47 4.9. The SMITH MOORE's two-cylinder engine 47 4. 10. Original silhouette of the MANHATTAN 50 4.11. The MANHATTAN owned by Gilchrist 50 4.12. Original profile of the WALTER VAIL 52 4. 13. The HERMAN H. HETTLER 52 4.14. The HETTLER during 1913 rebuilding 53 4.15. A modernized HETTLER 53 4.16. The MARY M. SCOTT site plan 58 4.17. The MARY M. SCOTT rudder 59 4.18. The MARY M. SCOTT forward of the centerboard trunk 59 4. 19. Outline of the "Sand Point East" schooner 61 4.20. The MICHAEL GROH engine bed 65 4.21. Steambarge with its tow of barges 66 4.22. The old steamer PASSAIC towing the ELMA 69 4.23. Site plan of the GEORGE 72 4.24. The schooner GEORGE transverse section 73 4.25. The ANNIE M. PETERSON at Green Bay in 1873 74 4.26. Heavy 6-inch bilge ceiling on the GEORGE 74 4.27. The tug SAMSON 77 4.28. Spray Fails, the SUPERIOR wreck site 83 4.29. Keelsons and frames from the SUPERIOR 83 4.30.