Teragan Division Transit Project Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MEMORANDUM DATE: July 31, 2019 TO: Marianne Zarkin (MZLA) FROM: Todd Prager, RCA #597, ISA Board Certified Master Arborist RE: Updated Tree Plan for the Division Transit Project, Gresham Summary This report provides updated recommendations for meeting the applicable tree preservation, removal, mitigation, and protection requirements in Section 9.1000 (Tree Regulations) of the Gresham Code for the Division Transit Project. Background The Division Transit Project is a transportation infrastructure improvement project that extends from SE 11th Avenue and Division Street in Portland to the Cleveland Avenue MAX Station in Gresham. While I assessed 398 total trees within the project corridor, 229 of the trees are within the City of Portland and 169 are within the City of Gresham. The purpose of this report is to provide updated recommendations for meeting the applicable tree preservation, removal, mitigation, and protection requirements in Section 9.1000 (Tree Regulations) of the Gresham Code based on revisions to the project since my January 8, 2019 report. Tree Assessment In October and December, 2018, I assessed the trees along the Division Transit Project corridor. I also completed additional assessments until June 2019 to review revisions to the project. The project consists of transportation infrastructure improvements and extends from SE 11th Avenue and Division Street in Portland to the Cleveland Avenue MAX Station in Gresham. I assessed 398 trees along the project corridor. Of the 398 trees, 229 are within the City of Portland and 169 are within the City of Gresham. This report addresses the 169 trees within the City of Gresham portion of the project. A separate report is provided for the trees in the City of Portland. Teragan & Associates, Inc. 3145 Westview Circle Lake Oswego, OR 97034 Phone: 971.295.4835 Fax: 503.697.1976 Email: [email protected] Website: teragan.com Tree Plan for Division Transit Project, Gresham July 31, 2019 Marianne Zarkin, MZLA Page 2 of 26 Attachment 1 is the complete inventory data for the 169 City of Gresham trees and includes the species (common and scientific names), DBH, health condition, structural condition, whether the tree is a nuisance species, pertinent comments, treatment (remove or retain), whether arborist oversight is required during construction, mitigation required, whether the trees are on private property, and tree type (regulated tree, street tree, landscape tree, parking lot tree, etc.). The tree numbers in the inventory in Attachment 1 correspond to the tree numbers shown on the site plans by MZLA in Attachment 2. Tree Preservation, Removal, and Mitigation Of the 169 trees along the project corridor, 133 will be retained and 36 will be removed. Of the 36 removed trees, 32 are "protected" trees according to Section 9.1012 (Required, Regulated and Significant Tree Types) of the Gresham Code. The remaining 4 trees are not protected because they are either a dead stump (tree 101) or less than 8-inch DBH on private property and not landscape or parking lot trees (trees 144, 147, and 148). Note that shrub species (e.g. photinia) are not regulated as trees. The individual trees to be removed are listed in the tree inventory in Attachment 1. Table 1 is a summary of the proposed protected tree removals: Table 1: Summary of Proposed Protected Tree Removals Tree Type # to be Removed # to be Mitigated Comments Part of an approved Landscape Trees 1 1 landscape plan on private property In Cleveland MAX Parking Lot Trees 13 13 Station parking lot Street Trees 12 12 In public ROW No more than 3 trees Regulated Trees 6 6 per property Total 32 32 As shown in Table 1, 32 protected trees are proposed for removal. The proposed removals include 1 landscape tree, 13 parking lot trees, 12 street trees, and 6 regulated trees (over 8-inch DBH) on private property. All of the trees proposed for removal are less than 24-inch DBH. Note that tree 160 is now included in the list of trees to be retained and protected. Note that no more than 3 regulated trees will be removed per property. Therefore, these removals are exempt according to Sections 9.1021 and 9.1031 of the Gresham Code. Since all 32 trees are less than 24-inch DBH, they will be replaced with 32 trees in accordance with Sections 9.1025 and 9.1035 of the Gresham Code. The landscape plan by MZLA includes the mitigation tree sizes, species, and locations. Teragan & Associates, Inc. 3145 Westview Circle Lake Oswego, OR 97034 Phone: 971.295.4835 Fax: 503.697.1976 Email: [email protected] Website: teragan.com Tree Plan for Division Transit Project, Gresham July 31, 2019 Marianne Zarkin, MZLA Page 3 of 26 Tree Protection During Development (9.1022 and 9.1032) The standard tree protection zone in the City of Gresham Code encompasses a radius around a tree that is equivalent to one foot per inch of DBH. For example, a tree with a 24-inch DBH would have a 24-foot tree protection zone radius. However, the City of Gresham allows an alternative tree protection zone if it is developed by a certified arborist. A typical alternative minimum tree protection zone utilized by our firm encompasses a radius around a tree of .5 feet per inch of DBH. For example, a tree with a 24-inch DBH would have a 12-foot minimum tree protection zone radius. It is a typical minimum setback used in the arboriculture industry as long as overall root zone impacts are limited.1 Note that this minimum setback is permitted by the City of Portland code and will be used for the portion of this project in the Portland city limits. Since this project is along a transportation corridor and most of the trees are adjacent to streets, curbs, and sidewalks, meeting the City of Gresham standard tree protection zone radius of one foot per inch of DBH is not practicable. Therefore, the alternative minimum tree protection zone radius of .5 feet per inch of DBH will be used to protect the trees in the Gresham portion of this project. The following tree protection measures will be required to adequately protect the trees to be retained: Tree Protection Fencing: Tree protection fencing shall be installed in the locations shown in Attachment 2 for the trees that are adjacent to proposed construction. For future drawings, include the total tree protection zones2 and critical root zones3 of the retained trees so we can evaluate locations where additional protection fencing may be needed. Demolition: Any demolition of pavement or other improvements within the critical root zones shall occur under project arborist supervision. Heavy equipment shall be positioned outside the critical root zones and care shall be taken not to disturb the existing soil surface within the critical root zones during demolition activities. This will be particularly important for trees 6 through 48 at the Cleveland MAX Station. Excavation: Excavation within the critical root zones of trees to be retained shall occur under project arborist supervision as follows: o Carefully excavate adjacent to the trees by pulling shallow layers of soil away from the trees with the project arborist probing the soil in between layer removal to identify roots greater than 2-inches in diameter. If roots greater than 2-inches in diameter are encountered 1 Costello, L.R., and K.S. Jones. 2003. Reducing Infrastructure Damage by Tree Roots: A Compendium of Strategies. Cohasset, CA: Western Chapter of the International Society of Arboriculture. 2 Total tree protection zone per the City of Gresham is defined as a radius around a tree to be retained of 1 foot per inch of DBH. 3 Critical root zone is defined by our firm as a radius around a tree to be retained of .5 feet per inch of DBH. Teragan & Associates, Inc. 3145 Westview Circle Lake Oswego, OR 97034 Phone: 971.295.4835 Fax: 503.697.1976 Email: [email protected] Website: teragan.com Tree Plan for Division Transit Project, Gresham July 31, 2019 Marianne Zarkin, MZLA Page 4 of 26 during excavation, they shall be hand excavated and retained in placed until the full extent of structural roots can be determined. o If the project arborist determines that certain roots are not critical to tree health and/or stability, they may be approved for removal with sharp pruning equipment. o If the roots are critical to tree health and/or stability, the improvements may need to be modified to retain the critical roots if possible and approved by the project team. o If modifying the improvements is not feasible, additional trees may need to be removed. Repaving: When repaving occurs within the tree protection zones where existing pavement was removed, reuse or carefully replace the existing base rock materials under project arborist supervision without excavating below the existing native soil grade. This will be particularly important for trees 6 through 48 at the Cleveland MAX Station. Stump Removal: The stumps of trees to be removed from within the critical root zones of retained trees will need to be carefully ground out or have their structural roots cut before pulling with an excavator to protect the root systems of the trees to be retained. Protect Tree Crowns: Care will need to be taken to not contact or otherwise damage the crowns or branches of retained trees that extend outside of the tree protection zones. Crown Pruning: Clearance pruning may be required for the trees directly adjacent to construction. All pruning shall be completed by a qualified tree service with an ISA Certified Arborist on site. All pruning shall be in accordance with ANSI A300 pruning standards and Z133.1 safety standards.