Red Tops Wilderness Character Unit Submission A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Red Tops Wilderness Character Submission Submitted by the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance August 19, 2016 Red Tops Wilderness Character Unit Submission A. Red Tops Wilderness Character Unit Boundary Maps and GIS Data The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance (SUWA) submits this new information regarding the wilderness characteristics of the Red Tops wilderness character unit (Red Tops unit or unit), including a detailed map (Attachment A) to assist the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) in meeting its mandates under the Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA), 43 U.S.C. §§ 1711 - 1712, the Wilderness Act of 1964, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1131 et seq., and BLM Manual 6310 – Conducting Wilderness Characteristics Inventory on BLM Lands (Public) (March 15, 2012) (BLM Manual 6310). The attached narrative description, map (Attachment A), photographs (Attachments B and C), and analysis provides BLM with significant new information regarding the size, naturalness, outstanding opportunities for solitude or primitive recreation and supplemental values present within the unit. B. BLM’s Duty Under Manual 6310 to Act on the Significant New Information Presented in this Submission BLM’s wilderness character inventory for the Red Tops unit, as submitted, must comply with BLM Manual 6310 and Appendices A – D, which superseded all previous agency guidance on this topic. See BLM Manual 6310.01; id. § 6310.06(B)(4)(a) (stating that “in order to complete the inventory, District or Field Managers must document wilderness characteristics inventories according to attached Appendices A – D”) (emphasis added). BLM guidance specifically states, [r]egardless of past inventory, the BLM must maintain and update as necessary, its inventory of wilderness resources on public lands. In some circumstances conditions relating to wilderness may have changed over time, and an area that was once determined to lack wilderness characteristics may now possess them. BLM Manual 6310.06(A). 1 Red Tops Wilderness Character Submission Submitted by the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance August 19, 2016 Based on BLM’s most recent wilderness inventories, it appears that the Red Tops unit, as submitted here, has never been inventoried for wilderness characteristics under the procedures contained in BLM Manual 6310 and Appendices A – D. See Attachment A. BLM guidance and the new information contained in this wilderness characteristics submission affirm that BLM must conduct an on-the-ground wilderness characteristics inventory that adheres to the boundaries and descriptions contained herein. See 43 U.S.C. § 1711(a) (requiring that BLM keep its inventories current to reflect changes in conditions and to identify new and emerging resources and other values); BLM Manual 6310.06(A). Additionally, BLM must base its wilderness characteristics inventory on the terms, procedures and definitions contained in Manual 6310, regardless of past inventories. C. Detailed Narrative – Red Tops Wilderness Character Unit 1. Area Description The Red Tops wilderness character unit is an area where the Earth and its community of life are untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain. See 16 U.S.C. § 1131(c). The unit is located in central Millard County, Utah, approximately sixty miles from the Utah-Nevada border. It is part of the Great Basin geologic formation. The Red Tops unit is bounded by Steamboat Pass Road (3c Rd) to the south, Red Canyon to the east, Utah Highway 6 to the north, and Ibex Well Road to the west. The unit provides outstanding views of the Cricket Mountains, Sevier Lake, the House Range, Tule Valley, the Barn Hills, and some of the West Desert’s most brilliant Basin and Range landscapes uninhibited by human interference. See Attachment C. The overall impression created is one of a wild and rugged geologic region that has captured the hearts and minds of adventurers and explorers for hundreds of years. Id. 2. 2 Red Tops Wilderness Character Submission Submitted by the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance August 19, 2016 Substantially noticeable human-made features and impacts have been excluded from the unit and are used to form the unit boundary. BLM cannot disqualify the unit for lack of naturalness or outstanding opportunities for primitive and unconfined types of recreation based on these or other excluded impacts. See BLM Manual 6310.06(C)(2)(b)(iii) (stating that “human impacts outside the area will not . be considered in assessing naturalness of the area.”). Similarly, human impacts outside of the unit boundary can only be considered in regards to their affect on opportunities for solitude if they are “pervasive and omnipresent.” Id. § 6310.06(C)(2)(c)(i)(1) (emphasis added). 2. Wilderness Characteristics The Wilderness Act established our nation’s policy “to secure for the American people of present and future generations the benefits of an enduring resource of wilderness.” 16 U.S.C. § 1131(a). “Wilderness” is defined “as an area where the earth and its community of life are untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain.” Id. § 1131(c). To qualify as wilderness, an area must: (1) have at least five thousand acres of land in an unimpaired condition; (2) generally appear to have been “affected primarily by the forces of nature, with the imprint of man’s work substantially unnoticeable;” and (3) possess outstanding opportunities for solitude or a primitive and unconfined type of recreation. Id. An area may also contain “supplemental values” such as ecological, geological, or other features of scientific, educational, scenic, or historic value. See id; BLM Manual 6310.06(C)(2)(d). Supplemental values are not required in order for an area to be identified as possessing wilderness characteristics, but the presence of supplemental values should be documented where they exist. As discussed below, the Red Tops unit easily satisfies the three wilderness requirements and also contains supplemental values. 3 Red Tops Wilderness Character Submission Submitted by the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance August 19, 2016 a. Size The Red Tops unit meets the size requirement for lands with wilderness characteristics. Under BLM Manual 6310, one way for lands to meet the size requirement for lands with wilderness characteristics is where the land contains “[r]oadless areas with over 5,000 acres of contiguous BLM lands.” BLM Manual 6310(C)(2)(a)(1). The BLM Manual adopted language in defining “roadless” as “the absence of roads that have been improved and maintained by mechanical means to insure relatively regular and continuous use. A way maintained solely by the passage of vehicles does not constitute a road.” Natural features, “ways,” and manageability issues considerations do not factor into the boundary determination equation. In locating new wilderness character unit boundaries, Manual 6310 requires that BLM utilize the physical edge of substantially noticeable human-caused impacts. See BLM Manual 6310.06(C)(3). Here, the unit boundaries are composed of bladed or otherwise substantially noticeable maintained roads. The Red Tops unit contains approximately 27,912 acres of contiguous federal public land, thereby exceeding the minimum 5,000-acre requirement. The presence of state lands within the unit does not affect or diminish the wilderness characteristics present on BLM-managed lands. b. Naturalness The Red Tops unit clearly contains naturalness when viewed through the lens of BLM Manual 6310. According to the Manual, at all times, BLM must apply the “average visitor” standard to determine whether the unit contains “apparent naturalness.” See id. at 6310.06(C)(2)(b)(ii)(1). This means that when BLM is evaluating whether an area contains apparent naturalness, the agency cannot permit its expertise or particularized knowledge to cloud its judgment, but rather must view the unit as someone “who is not familiar with the biological composition of natural ecosystems versus human-affected ecosystems” would see it. See id. § 4 Red Tops Wilderness Character Submission Submitted by the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance August 19, 2016 6310,06(C)(2)(b)(ii)(1)(b). Additionally, trails, historic properties, archaeological resources, fencing and stock ponds are specifically listed examples of human-made features that can be considered substantially unnoticeable and not defeat a finding of naturalness. See id. § 6310.06(C)(2)(b)(i)(1). BLM is instructed to use caution “in assessing the effect of relatively minor human impacts on naturalness” and to “[a]void an overly strict approach to assessing naturalness.” See id. § 6310.06(C)(2)(b)(ii)(2). To the average visitor, the Red Tops unit appears to have been affected primarily by the forces of nature, with the imprint of man’s work substantially unnoticeable. See Attachment C; 16 U.S.C. § 1131(a). This is the only requirement needed to satisfy the naturalness criteria. See BLM Manual 6310.06(C)(2)(b). It is a stark, beautiful landscape full of unique rock formations created by both sedimentary processes and ancient volcanism. The sagebrush hills and rocky slopes and outcrops are especially dramatic in changing weather, when clouds that can threaten either rain or snow cast great shadows across the stark landscape, which appears natural and unaffected by man. This area and its native vegetation provides habitat for many desert and range animals including pronghorn, mule deer, elk, mountain lions, coyotes, birds of prey, reptiles, jackrabbits, and other small mammals. Importantly, SUWA has specifically tailored this