Management Plan 2006
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FORTY MILE, FORT CUDAHY AND FORT CONSTANTINE HISTORIC SITE MANAGEMENT PLAN 2006 SUBMITTED TO: SUBMITTED BY: TR’ONDËK HWËCH’IN JUDY CAMPBELL, ECOGISTICS Jody Beaumont, Heritage Officer CONSULTING Box 599, Dawson City, YT Y0B 1G0 EILEEN FLETCHER, ARCHITECT GOVERNMENT OF YUKON Mr. Douglas Olynyk T. J. HAMMER, HAMMERSTONE Heritage Resources Unit ARCHAEOLOGICAL CONSULTING P.O. Box 2703, Whitehorse, YT Y1A 2C6 FORTY MILE, FORT CUDAHY and FORT CONSTANTINE HISTORIC SITE MANAGEMENT PLAN We, the undersigned , accept this Plan as a framework for cooperative management of Forty Mile, Fort Cudahy and Fort Constantine Historic Site. _______________________________________ ____________________ Chief Date Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Hän Nation _______________________________________ ____________________ Minister of Tourism and Culture Date Yukon Government TABLE OF CONTENTS Note: The Executive Summary for this report is contained in a separate volume. 1.0 BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 The Planning Context ................................................................................................... 3 2.0 HERITAGE RESOURCES ............................................................................................ 15 2.1 Identification of Risks................................................................................................. 16 2.2 Archaeological Resources .......................................................................................... 21 2.3 Buildings and Structures............................................................................................. 25 2.4 Artifacts and Artifact Clusters.................................................................................... 31 2.5 Natural Resources....................................................................................................... 33 2.6 Resources on Mission Island ...................................................................................... 34 2.7 Resources at Fort Constantine .................................................................................... 34 2.8 Resources at Fort Cudahy........................................................................................... 35 2.9 The Cemetery.............................................................................................................. 35 2.10 Documentary and Other Resources .......................................................................... 35 3.0 CONSERVATION .......................................................................................................... 37 3.1 Conservation Approaches........................................................................................... 37 3.2 Levels of Intervention................................................................................................. 42 3.3 Prerequisites For Human Safety And Community Interests....................................... 44 3.4 Phase 1A: Basic Protection Of Cultural Values ......................................................... 45 3.5 Phase 1B: Enhanced Protection Of Cultural Values.................................................. 49 3.6 Phase 2: Conservation For Increased Visitation........................................................ 53 4.0 SITE DEVELOPMENT AND VISITOR USE ............................................................... 57 4.1 Range Of Possible Uses.............................................................................................. 57 4.2 Prerequisites For Community Safety And Community Interests ............................... 60 4.3 Phase 1: Protection Of Cultural Values..................................................................... 60 4.4 Phase 2: Development For Increased Visitation........................................................ 64 4.5 Fort Cudahy And Fort Constantine............................................................................. 68 4.6 Long Term Possibilities.............................................................................................. 68 5.0 INFORMATION, EDUCATION AND INTERPRETATION ....................................... 69 5.1 Interpretive Considerations......................................................................................... 69 5.2 Themes And Stories.................................................................................................... 75 5.3 Development Phases................................................................................................... 88 5.4 The Cemetery.............................................................................................................. 93 5.5 Mission Island............................................................................................................. 93 5.6 Fort Cudahy And Fort Constantine............................................................................. 94 5.7 Directions For Future Research.................................................................................. 94 6.0 MARKETING................................................................................................................. 97 6.1 Estimation Of Short And Long Term Demand........................................................... 97 6.2 Marketing Activities ................................................................................................... 98 6.0 IMPLEMENTATION................................................................................................... 101 7.1 Management Structure.............................................................................................. 101 7.2 Capital And Operating Costs .................................................................................... 102 7.3 Impacts, Benefits And Opportunities For Development........................................... 114 APPENDIX 1: HISTORIC SUMMARY (Under Separate Cover) APPENDIX 2: BIBLIOGRAPHY...................................................................................... 119 FOREWORD This Management Plan represents the best efforts of the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in and Yukon Governments to meet the requirements, intent and spirit of the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Final Agreement and the Umbrella Final Agreement. It is meant to provide sound guidance for the cooperative management of the cultural and natural resources at Forty Mile, Fort Cudahy and Fort Constantine Historic Site. This is a comprehensive document but not without limitations and is not written in stone. Though it sets us on course it must be treated as a dynamic work in progress, open to improvement as we discover new opportunities and gain greater experience along the path of its implementation. The plan respects the principles described in the Final Agreement: – protection, conservation and interpretation of Heritage Resources at the site. – recognition and protection of the traditional and current use by the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in. – encouragement of and public awareness of and appreciation for the natural and cultural resources at the site. and – provision of reasonable opportunity to the public to visit and appreciate the site Nothing in this Management Plan will, or is intended to abrogate the rights guaranteed under the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Final Agreement (Self Government Agreement) or impair the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in inherent right to practice traditional pursuits. As long as the intent and good will of both governments that went into the development of this plan remains in mind during its implementation, Forty Mile, Fort Cudahy and Fort Constantine Historic Site will survive and flourish to exemplify and honour our precious heritage. A heritage to be shared, respected and cared for by all Yukoners. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Forty Mile, Fort Cudahy and Fort Constantine Historic Site Steering Committee would like to thank the many people who have taken time to read and comment on the work while in progress or to attend public forums and provide their feedback. The Management Plan reflects the care and understanding that Yukon residents have for their special places. Steering Committee Members A six member Steering Committee consisting of 3 members from the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in and 3 members from the Government of Yukon guided the planning process: Doug Olynyk, Heritage Resources Unit, Peggy Kormendy, Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Tourism & Culture Georgette McLeod, Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Ruth Gotthardt, Heritage Resources Unit, Tourism & Culture Irene Nagano, Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Afan Jones, Parks Branch, Environment Jody Beaumont, Heritage Officer, Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in and Bruce Barrett, Heritage Resources Unit, Government of Yukon, have also provided support to the Committee and the consultants. BACKGROUND 1.0 BACKGROUND 1.1 INTRODUCTION This Management Plan was commissioned by the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in First Nation in partnership with the Yukon Government on behalf of the Forty Mile, Fort Cudahy and Fort Constantine Historic Site Steering Committee. The Steering Committee consists of three members of the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in and three members of the Yukon Government. The plan is a requirement under Section 3 of Schedule A of Chapter 13 of the Tr’ondëk Hwëch’in Final Agreement. It is also the first step in the conservation of the heritage resources at Forty Mile, Fort Cudahy and Fort Constantine. In this document the shortened term ‘Forty Mile’ or ‘Forty Mile